Welcome to the
Marriage Builders® Discussion Forum

This is a community where people come in search of marriage related support, answers, or encouragement. Also, information about the Marriage Builders principles can be found in the books available for sale in the Marriage Builders® Bookstore.
If you would like to join our guidance forum, please read the Announcement Forum for instructions, rules, & guidelines.
The members of this community are peers and not professionals. Professional coaching is available by clicking on the link titled Coaching Center at the top of this page.
We trust that you will find the Marriage Builders® Discussion Forum to be a helpful resource for you. We look forward to your participation.
Once you have reviewed all the FAQ, tech support and announcement information, if you still have problems that are not addressed, please e-mail the administrators at mbrestored@gmail.com
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 204
M
marykat Offline OP
Member
OP Offline
Member
M
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 204
I'm moving over from the recovery page. It certainly no longer applies to me and wh. To make it short, I've (not him) been trying to recover my marriage since Nov. He has promised NC since then but always fell short.

Today he finally told me he doesn't want to quit talking with her. He doesn't see her as we live in Europe and she's in CA. They talk.

We talked openly this morning. He's unhappy too. He says he feels trapped and stuck in a situation that he can't free himself from. He wants us both or maybe he justs needs to be alone for a while.

Here's where it gets tricky. He's military. We live in Europe. We have 2 children. D (15) and S (13). Last week my DD did something I never in a million years anticipated. She has been depressed over leaving her boyfriend in the States. We moved here last Nov. He is not someone that My H and I approve of her dating. Her best friend here moved away this summer. She misses the USA. She's still angry with her dad regarding his A and our initial separation last summer. H had planned to D me and marry OW. She took a lot of pills and ended up in the hospital. I'm having a B*&^ of a time finding an English speaking therapist for her.

H thinks we need to stay together for the sake of the kids. He says he doesn't know what he wants. He doesn't want me to move back to US. He hasn't given up on us.

He told me this morning that he doesn't want to quit talking to ow. I know he's not happy. He says he wants to do the right thing. He wants us to stay together for the children. If we separate, it will be my decision.

Options

1. Leave him and move back to states. This means it's over because once the military moves me back to US that's it. He has 2 more years on our assignment here.

2. Stay here with him and try to put on the happy face for kids until next summer. Renters will be out of our home in FL. I can move back into our house. We'll have been married 20 years at that time which means I'll have full medical benefits for the rest of my life. Gives kids a little more time with their Dad. Maybe this is better for daughter at this time. She needs stability from 2 parents even though I think she would be ahppy to move back to US. Gives me a chance to complete an school that should help me get a job.

3. Plan B - get H to move out into own apartment and stay here until next summer. Told H this might be an idea. He is concerned about trauma to kids with this option. Doesn't want them to know we're having problems.

4. Modified Plan b - H stays here in our apartment. Different bedroom. I try to ignore him and endure until next summer.

I feel so stuck. Those of you who have followed my problems along, I would so appreciate advice. As well from anyone else.

Help

Marykat

Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 5,575
N
Member
Offline
Member
N
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 5,575
i havent followed the whole story---but i vote for option 2. it puts YOU in a better place with medical and job training. two things you are definately gonna need

Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 1,508
S
Member
Offline
Member
S
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 1,508
IMO stay there until have 20 years in,

1. That is an important survival issue (unless you are independently wealthy)...also I think affects retirement down the road.

2. Since they can only talk negotiate (if possible) frequency and length of calls, and let you know content (if willing)..maybe tape them. Ditto access to all voicemails/emails...BUT you must be absolutely safe, no comments at all, and assure him you won't harass him about the conversation no matter what transpires. This keeps you in the loop, and actuially the sharing (although difficult) automatically brings you closer together...rather than apart as would complaining.

3. Do a plan A/B combo....some distancing, seperate bedrooms (no intimacy unless NC). But meet other EN's and NO LB's. Who knows what may happen in a year. By knowing about contact (if he will agree) and doing an honest plan A, you have the best shot at getting him off the fence....he will know the clock is ticking, you don't need any ultimatums...just that you (both) will give this a year, and reevaluate then...rather than continuous conflict.

4. Focus on kids, gradually make them aware of your relationship problems, honesty is best policy....but that you BOTH are there for them, they need to be a part of this...it is a family issue that affects them too....and you can't hide it anyways.

5. Work on yourself alot, make it a point to focus on your growth too (independent of H or kids).

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 204
M
marykat Offline OP
Member
OP Offline
Member
M
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 204
For anyone who's interested I've explained my situation in previous thread's that can be found by clicking on my name.

I've been trying the Plan a/b, but without separate bedrooms and leaving out the SF. That was the one good thing we had going. He was very happy in that area with me.

He's always hid any contact. I've had to discover it on my own. Now I guess he's admitted he has no intentions of ending it with her. I don't know if I can keep it up. Maybe it would be different knowing that he intends to talk with her. He has to travel back to the States often. I'd always suspect he's seeing her.

How do I protect my heart? How do I live here for 11 months with the man I love knowing he wants someone else or at the very least isn't committed to me? How do I go out on a "date" with him just for a drink knowing he's thinking of her and is anxious to get home to call her.

What kind of an example am I setting for my children? "Doormat of the year"

I wish I could do the 180. That's been my goal lately. I can't seem to do it without anger. I'm certainly no fun to be around. I need an attitude adjustment.

Marykat

Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 1,326
H
Member
Offline
Member
H
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 1,326
marykat,

I am so sorry. This must be so difficult for you and your family. But maybe there is some relief that it is out in the open? I can offer very little help in this matter, except support for you and the kids. My kids are D, 16 and son,12. You found the right board in GQII. There are many here that can help you.

You might also search out Cerri on JFO. She is a MC and offers help on MB. Look up all threads by Cerri and JL, who also offers very solid advice on MB. This is a huge dilemma for you but there are many here that can give you the advice and tools that you need to get through this. Your kids are old enough to sense that things aren't right, and it will effect them.

Just out of curiosity, what does you WH expect you to do? Just get out of the way when he wants to talk or go visit the OW? Maybe he can offer some suggestions as to how to deal with adolescent children whose father is committing adultary with another woman? It is helpful when those creating these horrible problems for their family have some solutiions as to how everyone does not suffer the obvious consequenses.

Hugs to you marykat. Please keep posting at MB and let us know how you are doinging. Keep asking questions, there are many here with intellegent effective answers. God Bless you.

Heavens

Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 1,078
I
Member
Offline
Member
I
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 1,078
Dear Marykat:

somehow I missed your story up to now. I am so sorry for this dilemma that you are in.

I think you have to work on yourself first. Maybe when you find an English speaking therapist for your daughter you could ask about IC for yourself. You need to find out what you want. Do you want to tolerate the continued contact and enable your H's cake-eating behavior? Would you be able to plan B until NC is established?

I see that you are in a more difficult situation being in a foreign country and the OW is far away. Nevertheless NC is very important.

IMHO plan A is not going to work because you don't set boundaries and yes - turn into a doormat. It sounds like your H still loves you so maybe he has to realize what he is risking to loose. Plan B sounds like a good option. It also prevents you from LB'ing and from getting hurt.

Have him move to a different apartment. Talk openly with your kids.

You sound like a strong woman with an excellent sense for analyzing the situation.

I wish you strength to find the way that is right for you.

All the best

Joined: May 2002
Posts: 9,015
F
Member
Offline
Member
F
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 9,015
marykat - I am sorry to hear what you are having to endure. It is time for some "tough love" and and end to the cakewalking that your husband desires because he can't seem to deal with reality.

</font><blockquote><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><hr /><font size="2" face="Verdana, Arial">He told me this morning that he doesn't want to quit talking to ow. I know he's not happy. He says he wants to do the right thing. He wants us to stay together for the children. If we separate, it will be my decision. </font><hr /></blockquote><font size="2" face="Verdana, Arial">Forgive me for being so blunt, but I could care less about what he "wants". He cannot have it both ways. That is reality. It's called a choice.

He says he wants to do the right thing. He wants us to stay together for the children. If we separate, it will be my decision.

He is trying to avoid a decision and make you out to be the "bad guy" for making the decision regarding your marriage. I'm sorry, but in this respect he is being a mouse, not a man.

He has no idea what the "right thing" is, or at the most generous he does know what the "right thing" is but he refuses to do it.

I was afraid that this would happen following his "visit" with her when he was in California. He is afraid of withdrawal and so to avoid it he "gives in" to his "need" to talk to her. It is obvious that he will not make the hard decision without some external pressure and motivation.

His idea of the right thing is confused. He wants us to stay together for the children is an indication that he knows that what he is doing is wrong and destructive to both the marriage and to the children. You cannot allow him to use the children against you to "justify" his continuing to live in sin and violate the marriage covenant.

Let me put it this way. Suppose that he liked the Bin Laden terrorist organization and found them "easy" to talk to. Suppose there were things about the US Military that he didn't like or that didn't "meet his needs". Suppose that every time he talked to, or met with the BL organization he "felt good and understood" whereas in fulfilling his military duties he felt some needs were not being met and that he was just going through the motions of loyal service to his country. Suppose that he wanted to stay in the military for the "good of the other servicemen and women" in his unit even though he had sensitive, "classified" information at his disposal that he could, or did, talk about with his BL friends.

Now, consider yourself to be his commanding officer. YOU are aware of his relationship with the BL organization, either through discovery or because he told you about it "pleading his dilemna in wanting to keep both relationships". As his commanding officer, who's best interest is served in allowing him to continue the relationship? Who's best interest is served in demanding an immediate end to his relationship with the BL organization? If he will not stop the relationship on his own, will you allow his "sin" and "confused decision making process" and "faulty justification reasons" to cause long-term harm to your entire command and the people YOU are responsible for? Would you "arrest him" and put him in forced "no contact"? Would you seek the aid of others to "unbrainwash" him?

Obviously, his commanding officer would not tolerate such a situation. He would be arrested and most likely dishonorably discharged and possibly jailed for "treason", certainly for "fraternization with the enemy". But in your husband's twisted idea of what is "right" he wants you to condone his actions and be the "bad guy" if you don't agree with him.

marykat, this is not easy. He is torn and being controlled by his emotions, not what is right and what is wrong. He wants to manipulate you because YOU have an understanding of what is right and wrong and he wants YOU to feel guilty if you move to protect yourself and your children from his blatant sin. He says he wants to be married, but his actions reveal the lie to what he says.

Yes, I understand fully about the 20 years and medical benefits. There is nothing that says you have to divorce. But there is also nothing that says you have to be a doormat and allow him to continue in his blatant sin. Married means NO ONE comes between husband and wife for any reason. Married means forsaking ALL others whether we "feel like it" or not. If it were me it would boil down to "choose this day whom you will serve". When faced with a similar situation, my response was "pack up and move out today". Not because I stopped loving, but because the sin and ALL of it's ramifications must be exposed and must be felt. So long as you allow him to "have it both ways" he escapes having to confront the reality of his choices.

Yes, it could well end in divorce. I don't know his spiritual status is so he may well decide that his "feelings" are his sole guide to right and wrong. But the issue must be "forced" in my humble opinion if you are to have a realistic chance at recovering your marriage. You don't have that now and you won't as long as the OW is anywhere in the picture.

Yes, there will undoubtedly be more pain, anger, and heartache for the children. They won't understand. But you must be there to support them and to show them that there ARE "right and wrong" standards in marriage. You teach them that there ARE consequences to sinful actions, some of which affect the innocent, but that standing up for what is right is what "adults" do.

</font><blockquote><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><hr /><font size="2" face="Verdana, Arial">3. Plan B - get H to move out into own apartment and stay here until next summer. Told H this might be an idea. He is concerned about trauma to kids with this option. Doesn't want them to know we're having problems. </font><hr /></blockquote><font size="2" face="Verdana, Arial">This is the option that you presented that I would favor. Doesn't want them to know we're having problems is not true. "WE" are not having problems. HE IS the problem and his lack of honor is the problem. He wants to hide, you cannot allow him to use you and the kids to hide from making the only decision that is "right", forsaking the OW forever, enduring the withdrawal from the addiction, and honoring your marriage vows. He doesn't want pressure to have to make a decision. He really couldn't care less about the children or he would stop NOW. He WILL try to use them as a club to beat you into accepting his continuing sin. Or will you put in another 2 years, playing the "all is okay" game and move back to the States where she will be waiting for him?

This is emotionally tough no matter what you do. Choose the direction that offers the most protection and safeguards for you and the children. Each way has pain and negatives to overcome, but even though painful at times, standing up for what is "right" has the best long-term chance for recovery, married or not, and for your children as they grow into adulthood.

God bless you during this very difficult time.
(((((marykat)))))

Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 1,326
H
Member
Offline
Member
H
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 1,326
marykat,

FH just gave you an excellent, moral, Christian answer. I wonder if your WH is sitting on the fence, not able to move, wanting it all, suffering in guilt, shame and self-loathing because he cannot make the choice on his own? Maybe he is needing marykat to be the strong one and make the choice for you both, for the family, bc he can't or won't?

My FWH said that he was sloppy about a lot of things during his short EA/PA, bc, subconsciencely, he wanted me to find out about the sin and secrets and step in and stop him. He was too weak and confused to do it himself. OW was also very overbearing and demanding.

When I did find out, I rocked his world, our world. There was no way I would tolerate a "third" person anywhere near our M. So, I flew into action. When I forced him into decisions and threatened him with "exposure" to his children and his family, his attitude changed in a matter of hours. The light of day (or another light?) flooded in.

This doesn't work for everyone, its just that I don't share my stuff with anyone and, thank the Good Lord Almighty, it was the 2x4 my WH needed to wake him up out of the fog.

Excellent advice, FH. As I have said before, God bless you. When I read your answer the voice in my head was saying "why didn't I see that?" It is simple when you follow the right and only path, right? His path...

Heavens

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 204
M
marykat Offline OP
Member
OP Offline
Member
M
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 204
Heavens and Foreverhers

I've just returned home from my son's end of season baseball party and parent/son baseball game. My H is an avid ball player and my S is quite good. It was so dishearting to watch the game. How can he just turn his back on this family. How could he have let this ow tear us apart.

I'm so thankful for your replys. I'm going to get through tonight and hope for a better day tomorrow. I've got a lot of thinking to do. it'll be a long night.

Marykat

Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 1,326
H
Member
Offline
Member
H
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 1,326
Marykat,

((((((((marykat)))))))))),

Please pray about this. He might have the answer for you. It might take a while for you to know the right path, been when you know it, you will find it easy to follow, JMHO.

Be strong, MK. Hang in there. Go the distance. I might not be as bad as it seems right now. Keep your faith. Keep patience. Please, please take care of yourself.

Post here as much as you need. Vent, rage, cry, get it out. There are so many here with experience and wisdom to share with you. You are lucky to have MB. We all are.

I am gone from this Sat to next Sun. Fam to the beach. But I will try and sneak in from time to time. You are in great hands so I won't worry about you too much. OK, I will. <img border="0" title="" alt="[Smile]" src="images/icons/smile.gif" />

You are in my prayers.

Heavens

Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 777
J
Member
Offline
Member
J
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 777
MaryKat,

Wow what a decision. Although I did not have quite the decision to make three years ago I still had a life altering decision to make after my EX 2nd affair. We had worked so hard in recovery I had thought. I had plan A'd and I thought we were doing great. It just so happened that his Mid-life crisis was stronger than I was. Actually it was my 16 year old D and my 13 yr old son that said,"Mom, what Dad is doing isn't fair to you or to us we want him to leave." So he left and moved in with OW and her kids across town. I couldn't afford the house alone so we moved to a rental and that B*&^$%d moved into our home with her and her kids. For me it came a time when I couldn't be treated like that anymore. My kids saw that and I'm sure your daughter sees that too. She is crying out right now. I think she is very unhappy and just doesn't know how to deal with it. I think they need to be your first priority right now. Not him, health insurance ect but the kids. What do they want?? How do they feel? Don't underestimate their intelligence in this whole thing. You are not the bad person here but its you who has to make the hard decisions.

My advice to you would be at the least make him live apart. If you and the kids are unhappy in Germany than I say go back home where your support system is.

I'm sure the Army has rules of conduct for infedelity maybe they can help you continue with your health coverage.

I know how painful this is. The decisions you make now will impact the rest of your life in some way. Just remember that you are too good to be treated like this.

Try to find out information on mid-life crisis. Sounds to me like he is having one.

Jill

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 204
M
marykat Offline OP
Member
OP Offline
Member
M
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 204
Subdb

This is certainly the option that seem less painful at the moment. And you're right who knows what can happen in a year.

One thing that I've really been thinking about last night is the fact that I don't want to hand her my life on a platter. As a military wife, we've moved "a lot". I've been a stay at home mom, but I've learned how to throw a great party on no notice. I'm not anxious for a serious life-style change. I'm not afraid of going back to work. My kids are getting older and it's time for me to get out with the grownups again. My H has worked hard to support our family. We have a nice home, investments, we're at the point where we can finally enjoy our lives. I don't want to walk out and hand all that over to her.

However,

Right now H says he can't give up calling her. He says he will promise not to see her. ( Does this mean he had plans to see her?) There's no way he will tell me anything about their calls. (when, regarding conversations).

There's something that I don't understand. Our sex life was great, very frequent and always fulfilling for us both. However, he was never affectionate with me. I would sometimes get a quick peck on the lips goodbye. Cetainly no real kisses. He would hold my hand when we were walking. I can't remember the last time he came up on his own for a hug. So basically no affection, but he sure liked the sex part.

His A started sometime the end of 2001, early 2002. We're coming up on 2 years of his relationship with her. Maybe he will never give her up.

Last night I asked H if he remembered how miserable he was here without us. He was here from June to Nov last year before we arrived. Part of this time was spent with us being separated and his anticipation of our D and marrying ow. He whined and carried on about how unhappy he was alone. He said last night that ow would not join him here again. She came over last summer. She was in the process of moving her things here. She gave up her job, apartment, everything to come over with him. He asked her to leave 2 days after she got here. She's just moved back to CA with her family. After all he did to her I can't believe she still talks to him. I guess she's got it bad to.

FH

I'm still absorbing all that you said. It's all so true. There is healing in doing the right think. I know I would survive. In the end maybe the kids and I would be better off without his manipulative behavior.

I don't know if I can convince him to move out here. I can't move. I have no income at present to qualify for a lease.

I don't plan to do anything until I've spoken with my D's therapist. She has an appointment this weekend. After all that has happened with her, I certainly don't want to throw her over the edge again.

I can't imagine my S without his Dad. They're such buddies.

I've considered telling them that their Dad has continued his relationship with ow. I know they know there is tension between us right now, but they don't know why.

I think my H is on his last leg with his commander. I'm sure he wishes we were never assigned to his section. He knows a lot about ow from last year. He knows of D overdose. He has told H that anything else and we may be sent back to US. Not sure if me deciding to leave matters or if I ask H to move out if that will be the last straw.

Heavens

Have fun at the beach. I'm jealous. I could crash on the beach right now. Thank you, thank you for the support. What do you think of me telling the kids what's going on. My H's relationship with his family is a bit strained right now. I had their full support last summer over all this. He's felt hurt by their support of me. His F basically called him a coward. I haven't told them of his continued contact. don't think that would have much affect on H.

If his commander knew of his continued contact that wouldn't be pretty. I guess telling him would be a huge LB. Not to mention possibly affecting his status in military and thus retirement money and prospects for job in the civilian world.

This is some seriously thick fog for him to not see how he is screwing up.

Ice princess

you're right Plan A is the doormat plan for me. I've been trying it for 7/8 months and it hasn't changed anything.

Somewhere I read that Plan A is for getting the ws away from ow. PLan b is for when the ws is sitting on the fence. He's definately on the fense. I don't know if I have the guts for plan b.

Jillybean

I like your name. It makes me smile just to say it. You sure seem to have made it. I read another post of yours. Best wishes for your engagement. What happened to you is what I'm so afraid of. I guess it's the fear of the unknown. I've never actually lived on my own and been solely responsible for myself. Maybe I would like it.

The thought of raising 2 teenagers by myself scares the (*&^*^%$ out of me. Your story sounds to me what my life might be like after D. If H and ow were to marry I don't give them much hope. She has 2 young children. A crazy exH. My H loves our kids to death, but he doesn't have much patience with other kids. He's admitted he doesn't like and can barely tolerate her kids. I don't think they would last.

I'm not staying with him just for the medical insurance. I mean I certainly wouldn't D him today just 9 months short of our 20th anniversay. That's when full medical kicks in for former military spouces if you D. My H and could separate until then and D after that point. I know he would wait that long.

Of course he says he doesn't want me to leave at all. Why does life keep giving me this?

Thanks to all

Sincerely

Marykat <img border="0" title="" alt="[Confused]" src="images/icons/confused.gif" />

Joined: May 2002
Posts: 9,015
F
Member
Offline
Member
F
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 9,015
marykat - yes, I agree with you that the difficult decision is to know what to do and then to take the tough step of "doing it."

Only you can make that decision. Only you have all the facts at your disposal. Only you truly have an understanding of all the dymanics.

All that we can do is offer suggestions, but YOU have to decide what is applicable to you and what is not. Only YOU has to live with whatever your decision is.

You did mention several factors that are real concerns, such as your daughter's problem. That may even take some precedence in the process. One thing is certain though, she will continue to be affected by your husband's continuing infidelity. You have to decide at what point there is more potential damage to her from observing your tolerance or intolerance of your husband's blatant infidelity. Sometimes it's both the verbal and nonverbal communications that the children are exposed to that shape THEIR mental processes. (i.e., is the proper way to deal with sin to ignore it simply in an attempt to avoid pain caused by the sinner?)

With respect to your son...I know it tears at your heart, but please remind yourself that it is your husband, not you, who is responsible for any potential loss or rift in their relationship. Infidelity, unfortunately, strikes at many people and at the entire family. The consequences are the fault of the the infidel, not you. Yes, you may be left with the task of trying to teach your son "lessons" from the unfaithful actions of his father, but that, too, is part of parenting.

</font><blockquote><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><hr /><font size="2" face="Verdana, Arial">This is some seriously thick fog for him to not see how he is screwing up. </font><hr /></blockquote><font size="2" face="Verdana, Arial">Yes, and the problem with the fog is that the one caught in it usually can't see it. To them, all that they are doing is "normal" and "necessary". I suspect strongly that your husband is still talking to her because of guilt. He feels "responsible" for the problems in her life that have resulted from his actions and their affair. He thinks of himself as a "nice guy" and that it would be "selfish cruelty" to simply "dump" her.

Yet, the fog prevents him from seeing that he is doing all that to both you and your children. He knows that you have all the fears. He knows that his actions are, or would be, unacceptable to the children. He knows that you care about the children. He knows that you have "taken him back" and didn't "force" a decision on him.

But he also knows, as you have stated, that the military has no problem with enforcing rules. Yes, up to a point they will work with the person to try to help them get their life "straightened out", but there is a limit to that and a point at which the commanding officer will "cut his losses" for the good of the entire command.

The fog, again, fools your husband into thinking that the military rules are not for him because he "cares so much". This is false logic driven by his lying emotions. To him it seems real because he then gets to do what he has decided is "important". But everything about it rationalizes the pain and suffering for you and the children and denies that the military has rules that he cannot "bend to his warped thinking."

This is why confrontation is necessary sometimes. This is why the issue needs to be "forced" sometimes. There are consequences of his continuing actions that may well affect his future with your family and with the military. Such is the nature of infidelity and lying to oneself, which is what your husband is doing. The reality in infidelity is that SOMEONE always gets hurt, even devastatingly hurt. There is no situation where everyone gets away with no pain.

Let me get a little gross for a moment. He has been, through his actions, crapping on the floor. The smell and the potential health hazards are there for your whole family. Given enough time it may even affect the military unit he is assigned to. Next to his "favorite" dumping place is the proper receptical for his "urges", the toilet. So he "compromises" and only dumps on the floor every other time (because it takes more work to lift the lid and sit down)and thinks that this is a viable solution. You can choose to accept and live with his compromise and tell the kids that you are being tolerant because he has a "problem that you trying to work through", or you can choose to simply inform him that the risks from his continued behavior are unacceptable and you will no longer allow yourself and others to be put at risk by his behavior. He has to choose. He either uses the toilet all the time, especially when he has urgent "urges" or he finds another place to leave it on the floor, in another house. But you will no longer "clean up his mess" for the good of the family. He is an adult. He needs to stop acting like a spoiled, fearful, self-centered child and DEAL with the consequences of his choices.

You have lived with the mess on the floor long enough. You HAVE given him all the understanding and forgiveness for his occasional bouts of diarrhea that exploded before before he could reach the toilet (like when you two are physcially separated by geographic distances). You HAVE helped him to clean up the mess, sometimes even dealing with it all by yourself as he runs away from the stench himself. Now, he is no longer a child in diapers. Now he has to take the responsibility of putting his "desire" in the proper recepticle instead of just dropping it wherever he "feels like it".

I hear your fears, and they are real. YOU have to decide WHEN enough is enough. You have to decide whether your marriage to him, the possible pension, the possible healthcare benefits, the possible damage to your children, etc., is sufficient reason to "endure" his continuing blatant infidelity. And continue it will if the boundary is not set. The fog will continue until the heat of the sun sheds enough light on it to start it lifing and to eventually dissipate the fog entirely. But even though the fog does lift, it may leave behind the multiple car crashes on the highway that will take additional time to clear away. Remember, that in this analogy, the sun doesn't care about the loss of the fog or that there are "messes to clean up". All it does is to provide the "light of day" that acts upon the fog, darkness, and painful crashes that resulted from the "cloud" deciding to rest on the surface instead of staying where it belonged, in the sky. The sunlight leaves the "clean up" to us, but it leaves a clear view of reality and the future cautions that must be taken to avoid further crashes when another inevitable future fog desends to confuse our decision making process.

Part of this process is laying out for your husband, if you choose to talk before simply acting, all of the losses that he will cause. Military career, pension, wife, children, family, .... the list goes on and on. Yes there will even be a loss that the OW suffers and that your husband will have to deal with (all of the things that make him "him" to himself, as well as the guilt, disgust, remorse, etc.). This is the "light of day" shining on his foggy brain. It won't lift instantly, but the light doesn't stop and the inevitable lifting will occur. Sometimes quickly and sometimes it takes a long time if the fog is thick and parts are hidden in mountain shadows, until the sun rises high enough in the sky to reach those stubborn fogbanks also.

The one place that you should turn in all of this is to the Scriptures. Turn these difficult decisions and potential problems over to God and ask for His help. Be true to God and let sin be dealt with, for the good of your family, your husband, the military, and even for the good of the OW. The timing of the "sunrise" in this instance is up to you. You can continue to keep running, keeping just ahead of sunrise, or you can reach a point where you realize you can't run forever and then stop and accept that sunrise will happen. Prepare for it, wait for it, be ready for the cleanup when daylight overtakes the fog.

God bless.

Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 1,508
S
Member
Offline
Member
S
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 1,508
I dunno marykat, having read some more and based on your confidence your 20 year benefits are not at risk (and does seem no matter what could delay any divorce 9 months), as well as your certainty H would not include you in the "loop" re ow, I am going to modify my suggestion. Also although I took a different (pragmatic) tack, I pretty much also agree with FH response. I am NOT a fan of enabling fence sitting...it is just that sometimes fence sitting is not really what is going on, real confusion is...but in your case it seems more likely classic fence sitting.

A couple more thoughts. If he is on the outs with this commander, he may (in part) want you to stay (etc. etc.) to avoid further military consequences, using you in other words. Re the sex, it is really really disturbing (to me) when a man uses a woman just for sex, no regular habit of affection, and other nurturing behaviour.... Oft times folks just write this off as oh well, that is just how males give and recieve love....nothing could be further from the truth, it is how males use women for their primal needs, and has nothing to do with love....males express higher order love exactly like females do, and when that nurturing/safe/buddy relationship isn't happening....neither is love. He can have sex with you for one simple reason....you make yourself available for his use, you may (if you do) feel good about it cause you think it means he wants you for being you, and also enjoy the hardwired benefits we all feel from sexual activity. This confuses women cause they think somehow committment is involved.....it isn't, not without other validateing committment actions...it is just sex, he could do it with anyone. However, when (if you do) stop, telling him it is not good for your well-being without a committed (exclusive) relationship, he will eventually get angry etc. cause of the enforced celibacy. This may be directed at (and blamed) on you. Stand your ground, this is a boundary issue, and a consequence issue....he will either respect that or he won't...if he won't he is not a safe marital partner, and you need to know that if you have any desire to spend the rest of your life with him....he may not be worthy, now is the time to find that out.

Re the kids and his "buddy" relationship. It is common for people in this circumstance to say such things, and wear blinders. It is hard for me to imagine he is much of a role model, and often the buddy stuff is really about the adult, and benefits them, is focused on them. Is he really tuned into your son, understands your son, meets his needs without worrying about His (H) own? Or is he really fundamentally using your son, and the relationship to feel good about himself?

If he was a good role model, he would not visit injury on his son by concealing the affair, he is instead treating him with disrespect, and injury (by introducing tension into the family without any explanation). It is one thing to find oneself in disharmony with ones spouse, with or without an affair...and quite another to try and conceal the disharmony. Teenagers are not kids, they are young adults, they need to know what the problems are, and how they are being resolved, this teaches them important skills, as well as reduces unwanted/unexpected (and unnecessary) side affects on their emotional/psychological well-being.

Your H needs to step up to the plate and be frank about his marital concerns, as well as his need to continue contact with the ow. By revealing this information the truth sets you all free, and a course of action can be arrived at that takes care of everyones needs. This should not be an assign "blame" lovebusting fest. For H or you you (and whatever contribution you have to the marital breakdown). It is not the end of the world as we know it for an adult to admit they have issues and concerns and confusion about life. If nothing else this would be a huge rolemodel benefit to the kids. They are old enough to understand that relationships are complex, and difficult (heck they know that from relating with their parents). They are also quite capable of understanding one parent cannot be a doormat to the other just for their sake, or some hope of "saving" something....teenagers have a keen sense of fairplay (just ask em <img border="0" title="" alt="[Wink]" src="images/icons/wink.gif" /> ). They will have no real problem in understanding different bedrooms, some emotional distancing etc.

This also relieves (and rightly so) the huge burden of keeping secret from them something you know they are entitled to understand. It also gives all kinds of opportunity to use this bad experience as a learning one for them, as they will be selecting mates soon, and this is an entree into the whole area of marriage, behaviour, temperament, how people fit and communicate, and what can happen if they don't do their pre-marital homework. It also gives an opportunity to fully discuss all the family dynamics they have also lived, that led to this point. All this is very very important....your H desire for secrecy is hugely self-serving, disturbing, and revealing of his character far more than having been in an affair.

You do not need his permission, this is one of those unilateral decisions a parent is allowed to make for their kids well-being. But if you do so, I would think it ALL through carefully, and present it without being about blame..."see what your dad did to us", that would be a reflection on YOU, and very unhelpful to all.

One resolution may be that dad needs to live somewhere else (a seperation), kids can understand that too. There are proper responses to all human circumstances. Continuing to live as if you are a functional married couple (decieveing the kids) is not one of them IMO. They need to be a part of what is not only a couple problem (they don't need to be privy to say....um the sexual details, or other personal stuff between you and H), but also a family problem (are we an exclusive unit or not dad, if you are vesting time/emotions/money in another person, that needs to be figured in). They have a right to voice opinions about this.

As for your H, he does not sound like good marriage material. He obviously has serious issues with committment, and duty, and may be just your garden variety narcissist, or BPD, who just really has no capacity for seeing other people, only himself, not unusual, and just means you have to be prepared for a life of imbalance, as you will never be safe, and the marriage will be about him. Asking the woman to alter her life, come to him, and then send her packing is breathtakingly selfish (not to mention the ow obviously needs a major overhaul to her reality filters, not realizing what a loser your H is....not that she isn't just as bad). Continuing to have sex with you while pursuing the ow is bad bad news. He doesn't even have the decency to be exclusive to someone, he just uses you both for his needs. His concern about the commander is revealing also....he is defying that authority (and committment) as well. Lastly using his son (by decieveing your son of information that would allow your son to act as he wants with his dad) is also "using". Basically he comes across as a self-serving user....your basic narcissist. Yep, he hated being alone, why wouldn't he, no one to use...no one to validate HIM.

Affairs are not plesant things, but they do have one very interesting unespected affect, everyone gets revealed for who they really are...the ws, the bs, and the op. The sad thing is, many people do not take advantage of this information, and thusly get no benefit from a life experience (more commonly known as the school of hardknocks), that comes at a very high price. Strange.

In any event my advice has changed.

1. Tell H the kids must be told, for their well-being, encourage him to work with you on an HONEST revelation...but that if he is not up to this, you will...assure him you will tell him first, so he can comment if he wants, but you will do it yourself if he is not up to it. When he uses anger/threats to try and manipulate you, be calm, tell him you understand that is upsetting, but the kids welfare comes first, and you hope someday he understands.

2. In conjunction with #1 (and kids input), he probably needs to move out unless he is willing to at least reveal all contact with ow, as well as content. He needs to tell you when they talk, and what they discuss. Then maybe could do the in-house thingy...under the concept he is temporarily emotionally disturbed, and some support is ok for awhile.

3. You need to look hard at his relationship with your children and be sure he actually is a safe parent, or whether he is using them for his own emotional well-being. This is how kids get messed up for life...when they have a seemingly "good" parent, but they are being "used". It is very very common. Abuse is not just about verbally trashing or neglecting your kids....it is about focus too, and whether you are using your kids for your own benefit...enjoying the camaraderie, vicarious living throgh them, all that stuff. Parenting is a leadership role, a mentoring role, it is absolutely not a buddy role...no one should be buddies with their kids. I realize buddy is a loosely used term, the relationship should be fun, but there should never be any doubt that mentoring is going on, teaching important moral/ethical/behavioural skills, and it sounds like yoour H is not doing that much.

4. I would definitely consider going back to states after a few months (if you see the need)...maybe not wait a year, more plan B focus. But in the meantime giving your kids a few months to understand and adjust to this seems useful. I don't think your H really comprehends (if he is even able to do so at all) his marriage is almost over. I think he is using the kids to also further his agenda (which includes keeping you around until he decides to replace you....yuck).

Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 1,326
H
Member
Offline
Member
H
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 1,326
marykat,
Read this link about plan A and plan B. Maybe it can help you sort things out.

http://www.marriagebuilders.com/graphic/mbi8113_ab.html

Still praying for you. Yes, come to the beach. Maybe you need a little break, go to some exotic place for the weekend just you or with the kids and think about your plan. Sweetie, you need a plan.

Heavens

Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 1,326
H
Member
Offline
Member
H
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 1,326
MK,
Leaving today. Please keep posting. I am going to post on recovery for tsc. She can help you.

I just wanted to tell you, kinda quick. FWH and I were talking last night. He told me that what snapped him out of his fog was when I was going to make him talk to his children and tell them where he had been over the weekend (not on fishing trip but with OW). He said to look his son and tell him and see the devestation and the hurt in his eyes, he could not do it. He knew it would damage his innocence for life. I told him he would probably never want to play baseball again, the sport that they share, bc he would resent his dad so much. I told him that the 15 year old d would probably start taking drugs and sleeping around, cause that is what kids do when they are angry and their parents screw up things so bad that they destroy the safety and security of the family. I was going to make him do this. Whether I would have gone through it, I will never know. But the reality of what he was going to have to say to his children, to look them in the eye and tell them how much he had messed up, he could not do it. could not face them. It scared him into reality. The light of day. It can be powerful. JMHO.

I will be praying for you.

Heavens

Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 598
A
Member
Offline
Member
A
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 598
MK,
I am sorry, so very sorry that it has come to this. I feel for you, I feel like you are a real friend. I can sense the wonderful person you are through your posts. There are so many terrific people here, yet your posts have stood out for your dignity and loving manner.

I think you need some form of Plan B, whether it be he goes somewhere else to live or you go for a few months back to the states. Is there anywhere you could go? Your D could get good therapy during that time, you can separate yourself from your H and let him deal with the consequences of his actions.

A couple of things: this is HIS decision to mess up the M and risk separation. He is continuing contact with OW. I know whereof I speak as my H is still doing it. Phone only as well, but in your case I really believe they will see each other when he goes to the states. DO NOT take on the blame for separation.

You are changing/have changed the things you were responsible for in the state of your M. He and only he is responsible for the A. Very, very hard for them to see this and they are good guys so they don't want to do wrong, but they are being, as FH put it, mouses, not men. Need to grow up and handle emotional pain and sacrifice when it is for the right reason, moral, value.

What I want to offer you is for you, not any plan or specific action except that you MUST take care of yourself. Be your own best friend. If you believe in God or spirit, rely on that. God will never let you down, you are never alone. KNOW that lessons will be learned from this, even if only on your part and your kids'. Seek those lessons. One for me was that I was way too far from God and my spirituality. Praying, reading scripture, listening to Christian music, reading books by Christians; all have helped me find peace within myself. I am working on loving detachment from my H and letting go of a particular outcome. This is a result of a long journey, but one that I do not regret embarking upon. Wish I hadn't had to have this as my catalyst, but honestly, most days I find peace and balance, even if my H is still being unfaithful. I can only say that until I got glimpses of this kind of life, I was a wreck. I now try to wait and see what will happen, what H will do. I wonder instead of worry. We can take care of ourselves, MK, and we will be happy, married or not. This is not the path we chose, but we will stay strong.

Every time I discover contact between H and OW I reiterate again that it is not tolerable in a M, that it must not continue. Two weeks ago, H called OW (has always been the other way around) and he actually told me about it and apologized. In the past, I would have just accepted it and gone on. It was painful, but I realized finally that this is ALL him, his responsibility, his sickness, his hurt that make him act this way, NOT me or anything I have done or am doing. So I don't accept any blame when he tries to rationalize. He has until tomorrow to write the NC letter and has agreed to get into MC with me.

This is YOUR life, your journey, your path. In your heart you know what is the right thing for you to do, or it will become apparent if you can just be still, feel the presence of God or spirit within you. You will act lovingly and kindly, but also strongly if need be for your H's behavior is harmful to EVERYONE. He is so lost he just can't get that, maybe not now, maybe not ever. But don't allow him to drag you down with him.

I have regrets in how I have handled this stuff, I wish I had all the answers. I just know I am doing the best I can. I am being true to myself. I balance the needs of my lost H with my needs, the needs of the M and my D. My D is only 2, but I asked H if he felt that he would be comfortable explaining his behavior to our D when she can understand? Would he want her to stay M to a H that was doing the things he is doing to me?

One thing my IC told me--you need to stop crossing the line and doing H's work for him. I think that might apply to you too. Let him take the consequences of his actions. I don't think the kids should be in the dark forever, they likely have an idea anyway. He is doing this, NOT you. He can not be trusted at this point to not see her, so don't grant that trust and badly wound yourself in the process.

I know I am rambling. I wish I could just have you with me here for a cup of tea. I would share with you some of the books that have helped me, most recently "Surviving Betrayal" by Alice May, listen to you, cry with you and offer you hugs.

I live in Colorado in a resort type area, so if you want to come here for a vacation, bring the kids, get away for some perspective, I sincerely invite you to do so.

You are not alone. Keep posting.

Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 1,022
T
tsc Offline
Member
Offline
Member
T
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 1,022
Marykat--
I have been away for a while. I have just read everything. I am so sorry that it has come to this. You have a tough desition to make. I agree with so much of what has been offered already. Some of my thoughts are this::

1)You deserve much more than you are getting.

2) You should not divorce until you have 20 years in. Sad to even have to talk about that, but it is an issue.

3) I believe your husband loves you and your family; but he loves himself more. He has all the attention on himself and HIS issues. In other words, his head is so far up his own a$$, he can't see daylight. (sorry)

4) I think, if I were you, I would ask him to get his own apt. He should be responsible for talking to the kids, but you should be there. I would tell him he can see them every other weekend---at his place. Let him have a taste of what it will be like without you. No meals. No sex. No conversation about this day/life/needs. No you. Double bills for two households.

He needs a 2x6, marykat. My prayers are with you. (Talk to your DD counselor first.) I hope she is doing better.
God Bless your family.
tsc

Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 204
M
marykat Offline OP
Member
OP Offline
Member
M
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 204
UPDATE for all who have advised me

The last few days have been intense. As of Thursday morning I had withdrawn from H trying to decide what to do. Which option to take. I asked him to sleep in the other bedroom absolutely no physical contact, little to no conversation. I took off my wedding ring. (He really didn't like that). I went to lunch with him Friday. He was questioning whether we could get a "real marriage back. Could he really love me again. Would he ever be able to give her up. He had the infamous line. "I love you, but I'm not in love with you."

He hasn't been telling me he loves me much lately. I asked whether he ended his conversations with her with an "I love you." His response was "yes". Ouch.

I told him I was waiting to speak with therapist for our D and if she suggested it might not damage D too much, I wanted him to move into his own apartment. I was planning to start with plan b and remain here. He agreed that he would move if I wanted him to leave. I don't think he realized what it would involve. NC on my part.

I also told him (heavens this is for you) that based on agreement from therapist for D that either he or I was going to tell the kids the real reason Dad was moving out. No just the "we need some space routine". He was not pleased about that. He said so "You get to be the hurt one and I still look like the bad guy." I told him that was pretty much correct. The reason our marriage is in crisis is because of his a.

Sat morning, D and I want shopping. We had a nice day out, had lunch. H had said he was going over to work on his car, wash and wax. He has a really cute '67 MGB. Red and in perfect condition. (Are we talking midlife crisis here) He was going to workout at the gym. All this is located at his office where I know he talks to her on the phone. I really didn't care. If he wanted to talk with her, oh well.

D and I arrived home around 4 pm. I was so angry coming home. I was realizing what it was going to be like here until next summer. I felt so isolated. Sure I had the kids to take care of and do things with. But that's not like having adult interaction. I was going to be taking classes online. Whoop! I don't have many friends here. The language barrier is tough and the few girls I do things with are other military wives whose husbands work with my husband. What was I going to on a Friday night when my kids were out with their friends and I'm at home.

I really began to ask why am I considering staying here. If I moved back to FL I had friends and family there. Screw him.

He called about 30 minutes after I got home. He had the MG out and it was a beautiful, hot, sunny day. (Something to be cherished in Germany) He asked if I would go for a ride with him. He wanted to talk. Basically I launched. I told him I was in a dreadful mood and would't be good company. I told him I hated it here. I was leaving. He couldn't committ to me and was in love with ow. Screw him, I'm out. I'm ready to move one with my life. I told him that if our S hadn't had one of his friends over I was ready to tell the kids what was happening.

He asked for me to please come with him. He needed to tell me something. I said fine, but prepare for me being in a really *((&^$#@ mood.

He told me that he had spent the last little bit telling the ow that he was never going to talk with her again. He wanted to really work on our M.

Remember he told me that is what he did when he saw her back at the end of June when they were together for a week. Apparently he had never told her he was ending it with her. Just me. I guess I'll believe anything. He told me I could call her to verify what he said. He said she was really upset. (Secret deep down feeling, too bad, good, I hope she's miserable)

Have considered calling her but I really don't want to talk with her. He says he will give me copies of all phone records, email passwords. I can check whatever I want.

He says he needs help. Will I please help him. He said he can't do it on his own. Remember this is the man who has always said, We can do this on our own.

He actually agreed and we have an appointment for Monday with Penny. (Save your marriage central)

This is getting long and I'm tired of typing. That's basically it. I'm cautiously optomistic.

One question.

Who's used drugs and which one's seem best with fewer side effects? I really think he could use them. This will be very hard for him. He's not sleeping.

Anne

Wow. I've often thought how much I'd like to be able to have a real conversation rather than computer based. It takes so much time typing all this. It would be sooooo nice to talk with someone face to face. Someone who's been there. I certainly appreciate your response. I wish you the best and hope for you and your H.

I'll be back.

Marykat

Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 1,022
T
tsc Offline
Member
Offline
Member
T
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 1,022
Marykat--
So glad to get an update! Sounds like to me that we are all right. he does love you. He just has loved himself more lately. You withdrew
from him. He chased. It's classic. (Same thing happened here.) Problem is, when you begin to respond, he may withdraw from you again.
Be careful. No need to play games. But be smart. Don't give too much of yourself away. let him do some work. When my husband finally desided to act like a husband instead of a teenager; I told him all I could promise was that I would allow him to "try". That I would not make him leave....yet. I never gave him anything other than that. I was not cruel. I was receptive to whatever he did, and responded in kind. But I stopped being the one to "do" everything. I think it helped both of us. I got to "rest" from all the work. And he got to feel like he was making up for all he had done.

Be careful.

1)Ithinkseparate bedroms is ok. Tell the kids he is snoring.

2 Do NOT call OW! She is of no value to you or your husband. She may lie. She may tell you things you don't want to or need to hear. Don't call her.

3)DO get access to all of his phone/computer stuff. Block her anyway you can.

4) HAve him read about NO Contact letters. Make sure he understands that this is not a "goodbye" letter. It is a letter that said what he and "they" have done is selfish, and he is committed FULLY to his wife and children. No appologies to her. Just "do not contact me, and I shall not contact you". HAve HIM write it, you approve it, and he can mail it in your presence.

5) get counselling. For you, for him, for y'all, and for your family. Especially your daughter. She is crying for attention and help. Ask what the theropist thinks about filling her in on some of what is going on. She is almost grown. Maybe she would do better if she felt like she wasn'tbeing lied to, or protected. Like she was part of a "unit" that needed her support and help. I'm not sure, because I am no therepist. I just think because of her age, that you can not completely hide this. Plus, she knows the history about her father/OW.

6) WELLBUTRIN!!!! Very good for depression. AND it does not interfer with ones libido or sexual performance. I started taking it last fall. I stopped and I cried everyday. So, I'm back on. It really has very few side effects. No weight gain either! <img border="0" title="" alt="[Smile]" src="images/icons/smile.gif" />
I have heard that "Paxil" is another good one. But I do not know anything about that one.

Good luck to you, MK. Be smart. Be strong. Be firm in what you want and what you expect.

Take care of YOU. Take care of your sweet children. They deserve a father who will be a good role model. If Mr. MArykat proves to be worthy,......wonderful.
If not, then you know you gave him every chance to be a part of y'alls day to day life. It is his choice.

Keep posting. God Bless you.
tracey

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3

Moderated by  Fordude 

Link Copied to Clipboard
Forum Search
Who's Online Now
0 members (), 1,027 guests, and 52 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Newest Members
Mike69, petercgeelan, Zorya, Reyna98, Nofoguy
71,829 Registered Users
Building Marriages That Last A Lifetime
Copyright © 1995-2019, Marriage Builders®. All Rights Reserved.
Site Navigation
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5