Marriage Builders
Posted By: hbd Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 08:49 PM

My H and I POJA'd a threesome. We went out this weekend and picked up another guy (well, I picked up another guy) and we brought him back to our place. This was a fantasy of both of ours for quite some time.

Now, I feel guilty, even though my H was there and enjoyed himself. Should I feel guilty?
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 08:58 PM
POJA is not some magic pixy dust that makes everything moral or healthy. You can POJA the destruction of your marriage.

POJAing infidelity does not make infidelity moral or healthy. This is a major blow to your marriage, even if the two of you enjoyed it.

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:00 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
POJA is not some magic pixy dust that makes everything moral or healthy. You can POJA the destruction of your marriage.

POJAing infidelity does not make infidelity moral or healthy. This is a major blow to your marriage, even if the two of you enjoyed it.

Ok. What can we do to fix it at this point?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:02 PM
I'm regretting it so much. frown

I love my husband and I don't want to lose him or ruin my marriage. I feel horrible. Please help. frown
Originally Posted by hbd
I'm regretting it so much. frown

I love my husband and I don't want to lose him or ruin my marriage. I feel horrible. Please help. frown

Start with some radical honesty...tell your husband what you said here....you regret it and you feel horrible about it. And then vow to yourself and him and God you will never. repeat that.

Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:18 PM
Originally Posted by SmilingWoman
Originally Posted by hbd
I'm regretting it so much. frown

I love my husband and I don't want to lose him or ruin my marriage. I feel horrible. Please help. frown

Start with some radical honesty...tell your husband what you said here....you regret it and you feel horrible about it. And then vow to yourself and him and God you will never. repeat that.

Back up that vow with some Extraordinary Precautions (EPs). You need to ensure that this will never happen again. Both of you need to ensure that.

Get "Surviving an Affair." Read it.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:29 PM
Originally Posted by SmilingWoman
Originally Posted by hbd
I'm regretting it so much. frown

I love my husband and I don't want to lose him or ruin my marriage. I feel horrible. Please help. frown

Start with some radical honesty...tell your husband what you said here....you regret it and you feel horrible about it. And then vow to yourself and him and God you will never. repeat that.


Thanks. Yes, I already told my H that I regret it and feel guilty. He says I shouldn't because he wanted it just as much as me. He doesn't get it.

I have vowed to never do it again. I just worry that my H does not feel badly about it. He thought it was great and he didn't even do anything wrong...just watched mostly. How can I get him to understand that this was bad for our marriage?
Originally Posted by hbd
My H and I POJA'd a threesome. We went out this weekend and picked up another guy (well, I picked up another guy) and we brought him back to our place. This was a fantasy of both of ours for quite some time.
?

The purpose of the POJA is to make your marriage better, not WORSE. IT is not intended to faciliate destructive, disgusting marriage wrecking behavior. If you want to find out how destructive adultery is, and particularly swinging, just read about the wrecked lives in this forum and in the radio archives. There have been many radio segments over the years about what a DISASTER swinging is.

Is the next step for your H to commit adultery too? Does he get to pick up a woman to even the score?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:30 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Originally Posted by SmilingWoman
Originally Posted by hbd
I'm regretting it so much. frown

I love my husband and I don't want to lose him or ruin my marriage. I feel horrible. Please help. frown

Start with some radical honesty...tell your husband what you said here....you regret it and you feel horrible about it. And then vow to yourself and him and God you will never. repeat that.

Back up that vow with some Extraordinary Precautions (EPs). You need to ensure that this will never happen again. Both of you need to ensure that.

Get "Surviving an Affair." Read it.

This was an affair?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:33 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by hbd
My H and I POJA'd a threesome. We went out this weekend and picked up another guy (well, I picked up another guy) and we brought him back to our place. This was a fantasy of both of ours for quite some time.
?

The purpose of the POJA is to make your marriage better, not WORSE. IT is not intended to faciliate destructive, disgusting marriage wrecking behavior. If you want to find out how destructive adultery is, and particularly swinging, just read about the wrecked lives in this forum and in the radio archives. There have been many radio segments over the years about what a DISASTER swinging is.

Is the next step for your H to commit adultery too? Does he get to pick up a woman to even the score?

NO! We had already agreed that he could not be with another woman because I could not handle that. He wanted to see me with someone else. That was the fantasy. And this will be it, no more swinging. I can't take it. The problem is that my H doesn't feel it is bad because he agreed to it.
So it was his idea?

How did you honestly feel about that beforehand?

I get the impression that his 'no big deal' reaction to this is making you feel a bit uneasy. Did you want him to feel jealous?

Is this behaviour of his new or has be always been into the idea of sharing you out like that?

Personally, it worries me. My h used to be very protective of me and would go mad if men even spoke to me inappropriately. When he was wayward though, he stopped this, even made very odd jokes about me having sex with his friends!

I just think its a disrespectful attitude. THATS what bothers you. Because you 'couldnt handle' seeing him with someone else. However he has no problem seing you do it. It would bug me too.
Originally Posted by hbd
My H and I POJA'd a threesome. We went out this weekend and picked up another guy (well, I picked up another guy) and we brought him back to our place. This was a fantasy of both of ours for quite some time.

Now, I feel guilty, even though my H was there and enjoyed himself. Should I feel guilty?

First thing - if you and your H agreed to it, then by definition it's not infidelity / cheating. It's extra-marital sex.

Secondly, are you sure that the emotion you're experiencing is guilt? Or is it regret?
While it wasnt dishonest, letting someone else meet your needs IS the fast track to an affair. In this case, admiration? SF?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:48 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
So it was his idea?

How did you honestly feel about that beforehand?

I get the impression that his 'no big deal' reaction to this is making you feel a bit uneasy. Did you want him to feel jealous?

Is this behaviour of his new or has be always been into the idea of sharing you out like that?

Personally, it worries me. My h used to be very protective of me and would go mad if men even spoke to me inappropriately. When he was wayward though, he stopped this, even made very odd jokes about me having sex with his friends!

I just think its a disrespectful attitude. THATS what bothers you. Because you 'couldnt handle' seeing him with someone else. However he has no problem seing you do it. It would bug me too.

You are absolutely right. It makes me sad that he isn't jealous. I think I thought that he wouldn't actually go through with it. I don't know. This was just a huge mistake. I'm scared of what is going to happen to our marriage. I'm worried that we are going to fall apart now. frown.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:49 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
While it wasnt dishonest, letting someone else meet your needs IS the fast track to an affair. In this case, admiration? SF?

Yes, admiration for sure. frown
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:49 PM
Originally Posted by ManInMotion
Originally Posted by hbd
My H and I POJA'd a threesome. We went out this weekend and picked up another guy (well, I picked up another guy) and we brought him back to our place. This was a fantasy of both of ours for quite some time.

Now, I feel guilty, even though my H was there and enjoyed himself. Should I feel guilty?

First thing - if you and your H agreed to it, then by definition it's not infidelity / cheating. It's extra-marital sex.

Secondly, are you sure that the emotion you're experiencing is guilt? Or is it regret?

I'm not sure. I just feel bad.
Originally Posted by hbd
I think I thought that he wouldn't actually go through with it.

POJA requires that you don't do something unless you both ENTHUSIASTICALLY AGREE to do it. I'm getting the impression here that engaging in extra-marital sex was not something you were very enthusiastic about, and you had to be "convinced" by your H. Is that correct?
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:54 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
This was an affair?


Dr. Harley puts one-night-stands on the affair continuum (pg 21-26 of Surviving an Affair). He calls it an emotionless affair.

"... whether an affair is one-night-stand, years of intimate friendship, or anything in between, the way to end the affair and restore a marriage is essentially the same. So even though my examples throughout this book relate to the affairs of soul mates, the methods I suggest for ending an affair and restoring the marriage can be applied to all affairs." (pg 26)

Call it an affair, or not. Adultery. Infidelity. Fact is, you were unfaithful. Dr. Harley's methods will help restore your marriage. Read his books.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:55 PM
Originally Posted by ManInMotion
Originally Posted by hbd
I think I thought that he wouldn't actually go through with it.

POJA requires that you don't do something unless you both ENTHUSIASTICALLY AGREE to do it. I'm getting the impression here that engaging in extra-marital sex was not something you were very enthusiastic about, and you had to be "convinced" by your H. Is that correct?

No, I wanted to do it at the time. I thought it would be fun (and it was), but I didn't think about how I would feel afterwards. I guess I thought my H would be more aprehensive. If he had said one word about not wanting to do it, I wouldn't have gone through with it...but he didn't. At the time, I was glad..but, now I'm sad.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 09:56 PM
What a mess.
Originally Posted by Prisca
Fact is, you were unfaithful.

No she wasn't. Unfaithfulness requires practicing some level of dishonesty to get one's needs met outside of one's M, and there was no such dishonesty here.

I suspect that POJA (in the true meaning of the term) was not really followed here, and hbd now truly regrets that she engaged in extra-marital sex because her H wanted her to, and it really wasn't something that she wanted to do.
Keep your eyes open and on him. It could be he is trying to assuage his own guilt or get a threesome with a woman going. I would snoop for inappropriate behaviour on his part without telling him - check his phone, pockets, the works.

Do this even if you think 'impossible'. I think its fair to say his boundaries are lax, so you could maybe nip his flirting or something in the bud, even if hes not having an affair yet.

Hopefully not though. Could you both be just drifting apart a bit? How are you at meeting needs and spending UA time with each other?

I would definitely listen to the vets about installing the EPs.

Tell your h you didnt enjoy the threesome, tell him it was a wake up call for you, that you want to feel 'close and connected' to him like you used to (did you?). Tell him you want him and no one else. This will speak to his admiration need hopefully and give you an insight into what he wants.

Big him up, puff up the old ego, and see how he reacts..

Btw, what HAPPENED to make you do this? You clearly didnt want to - just wanted his attention. Is it fair to say he's been neglecting you a bit?

I dont think your solution was an MB approved plan!
Let's say we both ENTHUSIASTICALLY AGREE to smoke 5 packs a day of Marlboro cigarettes. Does that somehow magically negate the effects of smoking? No, it does not.

It is the same with swinging. Swinging is adultery, and it does not matter if they both ENTHUSASTICALLY AGREE to act like pigs, it does not negate the damage done to the marriage. Adultery is DESTRUCTIVE. "honesty" does not negate that, enthusiastic agreement does not negate that. NOTHING negates the damage done to the marriage by committing adultery.

POJA is not intended to be used on activities/behaviors that are destructive to the marriage. That DEFEATS the purpose of the POJA.
Posted By: Scotland Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 10:03 PM
Just an FYI, so there will be no more question about this,
Quote
Adultery-Voluntary sexual intercourse between a married person and a person who is not his or her spouse

So this was most definitely adultery. Now that that is out of the way, it was adultery that was POJA'd, a you say, but now you regret it?

hbd, how did you come to find this site, and how long have you been reading here? Have you used any of the other MB principles on your marriage? How long have you been following MB?
Posted By: reading Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 10:04 PM
I would suspect your H is into internet porn.
Something has deadened his sense of right/wrong.

Internet porn will sure do that.

If that is the case, yet another level of distance exists.

Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by indiegirl
While it wasnt dishonest, letting someone else meet your needs IS the fast track to an affair. In this case, admiration? SF?

Yes, admiration for sure. frown


We cant be strong without acknowledging our weaknesses, hbd, so well done for recognising one NOW at least.

You badly need a man's admiration at the moment, you were vulnerable to agreeing to have an affair. It doesnt really matter that your h egged you on, you knew it was an affair but you thought it would make you feel better in the short term.

Every cheating spouse on here has done the same thing - short term ego fix without thinking of the long term implications for their marriage.

I say this because you need to recognise you need the EPs as much as your 'lets have a threesome' husband.

If a guy starts flirting ith you at work, seems besotted with you - would that attention be hard to resist for you right now? I think it would
Originally Posted by Scotland
Just an FYI, so there will be no more question about this,
Quote
Adultery-Voluntary sexual intercourse between a married person and a person who is not his or her spouse

So this was most definitely adultery.


I'm not going to argue that definition of adultery, but what's being described here is certainly not cheating, an affair (of any sort) or unfaithfulness - all of which require one spouse resorting to dishonesty to get their needs met outside of their M.
Btw, admiration is one of my weaknesses, so I dont let men admire me.

If they say something too intimate I have a special 'almost frown' that stops it happening again.
What she has described here is adultery, plain and simple - it's not even up for debate:

a�dul�ter�y   /əˈdʌltəri/ Show Spelled
[uh-duhl-tuh-ree] Show IPA

�noun, plural -ter�ies.
voluntary sexual intercourse between a married person and someone other than his or her lawful spouse.
Originally Posted by reading
I would suspect your H is into internet porn.

...or he's involved in an A. A real one.

And yes, she was unfaithful:

un�faith�ful   /ʌnˈfeɪθfəl/ Show Spelled
[uhn-feyth-fuhl] Show IPA

�adjective
1.not faithful; false to duty, obligation, or promises; faithless; disloyal.
2.not sexually faithful to a spouse or lover.
3.not accurate or complete; inexact: an unfaithful translation
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
What she has described here is adultery, plain and simple - it's not even up for debate:

...but it is not CHEATING. It is NOT an AFFAIR. It is NOT UNFAITHFULNESS. It is NOT INFIDELITY.

It is quite possible to have adultery without cheating (as has happened here), just like it is to have cheating without adultery (emotional affair).

If you examine the MB links to the right of every message, you'll see that they refer to INFIDELITY, not ADULTERY. Perhaps that's because the good doctor recognizes the subtle but very important difference as well.
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
And yes, she was unfaithful:

un�faith�ful   /ʌnˈfeɪθfəl/ Show Spelled
[uhn-feyth-fuhl] Show IPA

�adjective
1.not faithful; false to duty, obligation, or promises; faithless; disloyal.
2.not sexually faithful to a spouse or lover.
3.not accurate or complete; inexact: an unfaithful translation

I disagree - you are misapplying the meaning of "faithful".


Posted By: Scotland Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 10:29 PM
Infidelity harms a marriage, adultery harms a marriage, and THIS has harmed THIS marriage.

Are we seriously going to go round and round and "argue" over if this was an affair or not? Some of us believe that it WAS. I believe that is was an affair WITH consent, but it still HARMED, can we agree to THAT at least?

hbd, how did you come to find out about MB? How long have you been using MB principles in your marriage, and what principles have you been using?

I also DON'T agree that this was a case of POJA, as described by MB. HERE As ML has already suggested.
Originally Posted by Scotland
Infidelity harms a marriage, adultery harms a marriage, and THIS has harmed THIS marriage.

However, the reasons WHY the M is harmed are different. Affairs involve some level of dishonesty on the part of one spouse, in order to get their needs met outside of the M. Was any of that involved here?

What has happened here is that in the M, one spouse has apparently had a need met by the other, at the expense of the other.

I think that something a bit more than using the usual MB A-busting techniques needs to be involved here. I would start by trying to find out why her H was so enthusiastic, before AND after, about indulging in the threesome.

Has he asked for any more, BTW?



Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 10:40 PM
Originally Posted by ManInMotion
Originally Posted by Prisca
Fact is, you were unfaithful.

No she wasn't. Unfaithfulness requires practicing some level of dishonesty to get one's needs met outside of one's M, and there was no such dishonesty here.

Yes, she was. Faithfulness means not getting your EN met outside of the marriage. She was unfaithful when she violated her marriage vows and had sex with another man.

Adultery (aka "being unfaithful") does not require dishonesty. Dr. Harley says so on his radio show.

When you are even simply navigating around this site, you learn that adultery causes problems with marriage.

If you have to even ASK if having a 3some is bad for your marriage, then there is a serious problem within your marriage period. It means that if you both agreed to this that neither of you place much emphasis on fidelity or trust or viewing the solemnity of your wedding vows in the first place.

I don't care WHAT you call the 3 way, it's plain cheating. We're not going to get into the 'type' or whatnot, (i.e. is what a former President and his intern did cheating?) It's PLAIN WRONG. Like you both taking a bottle of booze and drinking it together and then getting behind the wheel of a car. Both that, and your behavior with the other man or woman is simply WRONG and unethical, immoral, etc.

I don't even really think this needs to be discussed. It's kinda imho self-explanatory that this stuff is BAD for marriage period.
Posted By: Scotland Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 10:46 PM
Mim, but hbd WAS DISHONEST. She was obviously not as ENTHUSIASTIC about this as she led on to her H. She is now upset because she feels like he should have been jealous, but I don't believe that she told him that was the reaction she wanted in the first place.

There most definitely WAS dishonesty here, on BOTH of their parts, as well as some manipulation on BOTH their parts. There are probably other reasons that this marriage got to this point, as there are in ALL of the marriages who wind up here after an AFFAIR.

I've saved this post on my Notable Posts thread .... because this topic always seems to pop back up.
I think this is the best explanation of what is wrong with "open marriage" that I've read on this site.


Originally Posted by Originally written by Star*Fish
Marriage is a closed contract. When you open it....the contract has been broken. There are some people who argue that the contract is about "honesty" rather than "exclusivity", but opening a marriage invariable dilutes it's value as a covenant and opens it to RISK. Promiscuity waters down honor and marriage vows until they mean NOTHING.

I truly believe that there is a sanctity in the exclusive (emotional AND sexual) union of TWO people that provides the strongest bond, the most opportunity for depth and growth, the most stable environment for children, families and communities. It weakens us as a society when marriage models are flawed or fail.

If you "want it all"....don't get married or have children. I could care less if people want a hundred sex partners....but don't marry....and don't bring innocent children into the nightmare you're creating for yourself and bring them into the risk and drama that open marriage INVITES into your life.

Every time you add another person, another couple, fuzzy boundaries and wishful thinking....you increase RISK exponentially.

You think marriage with two people is hard??? Lord in Heaven....just start adding sex partners if you want a crash course for self destruct, shame and pain.

Can it be done successfully? Some say yes....but *I* don't believe it...I say....it's just another fantasy like the rest of affairs. I was hippie, and we grocked like the rest of the "Strangers in a Strange Land". What a delusion. This stuff was tried and failed. The only thing that differentiates swinging from affairs is the *honesty*.....and most of the time....that breaks down anyway!! It starts out honest until real feelings get in the way.....and they always get in the way, because we're WIRED that way.

But even if it didn't. Let's say two people agree to share their bodies but not their emotions and do it all above board....this is not a recipe for marriage...it's a recipe for tragedy, shame, denial and divorce. The essential problem with swinging is that it takes energy away from the primary relationship with spouse, family and children. It waters it down. It strains it. It undermines the intimacy.

It's next to impossible to share something as intimate as sex, and not develope affair-style biochemistry that acts on the marriage like ANY OTHER AFFAIR. You're kidding yourself if you think your biochemistry won't betray you.

I've spoken to many many people in this situation....and sadly....the results are as predictable as any other kind of affair. Somebody wants it....somebody gets talked into it. There is an agreement. It goes okay for a while....sometimes even a good long while. Then someone crosses the line....they start to hide their emotional involvement with one of their sex partners, or they get that "in love" biochemistry and there's no difference at all in the script....bla bla bla.

I honestly can't understand why people who want an open marriage, get married at all. Polyamory, open marriages, swinging....they are finally nothing but a selfish illusion that eventually blows up and creates shame and the destruction of families....JUST LIKE ANY OTHER kind of infidelity.

I've done extensive research on this subject. I have found absolutely NO evidence whatsoever that these models are sustainable long enough to raise children. In fact, the only research available says quite the opposite. The only place you get a real rosy picture of this lifestyle....is on the sites that promote it! Duh

It's a trap, a Brigadoon,....an insidious cancer like any other adultery that promises Utopia and delivers drama and heartbreak. There are probably a few die hard swingers who follow through....but for the majority of us....don't try this at home!! There are people who try to jump the Grand Canyon on a motorcycle....but that doesn't mean it's a good idea.

I agree with people who say that humans are probably not naturally monogamous. No siree....it takes strength of character to avoid temptation. It takes pain and forgiveness to move past the pitfalls and failures. But to me, that's precisely what makes marriage so special and unique...that we can rise above our primal roots and make a commitment that transcends even nature. That we care enough about one person to be MORE than our sexual yearnings for change. How cool is that?
Originally Posted by ManInMotion
Originally Posted by Scotland
Infidelity harms a marriage, adultery harms a marriage, and THIS has harmed THIS marriage.

However, the reasons WHY the M is harmed are different. Affairs involve some level of dishonesty on the part of one spouse, in order to get their needs met outside of the M. Was any of that involved here?

What has happened here is that in the M, one spouse has apparently had a need met by the other, at the expense of the other.

I think that something a bit more than using the usual MB A-busting techniques needs to be involved here. I would start by trying to find out why her H was so enthusiastic, before AND after, about indulging in the threesome.

Has he asked for any more, BTW?


I think you're right about digging for the reasons beneath and putting the focus on him. He is probably the more dishonest one and I would hesitate to call him a BS.

However hbd does need to examine her own boundaries and weaknesses too. I appreciate she hasnt been overtly dishonest with her h, but she was ok with getting her needs met elsewhere.

She has been brutally honest with us here (and with herself) and that will allow us to help her avoid more adultery on either part.
Originally Posted by Prisca
Adultery (aka "being unfaithful") does not require dishonesty. Dr. Harley says so on his radio show.

I agree with the good doctor that adultery does not require dishonesty. In fact, this thread involves just such a case.

What I will disagree with though is that adultery automatically means unfaithfulness is involved.

In any case, I've TJ'd this thread just a bit too much over this issue, so this is my last post on the subject.
Originally Posted by ManInMotion
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
And yes, she was unfaithful:

un�faith�ful   /ʌnˈfeɪθfəl/ Show Spelled
[uhn-feyth-fuhl] Show IPA

�adjective
1.not faithful; false to duty, obligation, or promises; faithless; disloyal.
2.not sexually faithful to a spouse or lover.
3.not accurate or complete; inexact: an unfaithful translation

I disagree - you are misapplying the meaning of "faithful".


Your disagreement is with the dictionary, not me. Anyone can plainly see from the definition that they were "false to duty, obligation, or promises" and "not sexually faithful to a spouse or lover..." UNFAITHFUL..




Welcome to Marriage builders hbd. Sorry you are here. HOwever .. this is the right place to be for you to get some sound advice on what to do in your situation.

Heres what I would do ..

1. Tell your hubby that what you did was a mistake and that you are no longer comfortable doing ANYTHING like that again.

2. Set up some keylogger on your PC www.desktopshark.com, VAR in the car etc and snoop on your hubby to see if he may be thinking of using this against you to further his agenda or justify any sort of infedelity he may have already done. If you start snooping DO NOT CONFRONT HIM OR SHOW HIM THIS SITE! Just bring the info here for the vets to help you sort out and read up on Plan A and of course all the concepts here so you can begin to learn how to make your marriage a happy one!

I think arguing about the politics and antics of adultery/infidelity is not very helpful to this poster. The OP was honest enough to voice her opinion and admit to her fault in this situation and is now looking to heal from her mistake. LEts keep doing that ... and not scare her away!

MrNiceGuy
Originally Posted by indiegirl
I think you're right about digging for the reasons beneath and putting the focus on him. He is probably the more dishonest one and I would hesitate to call him a BS.

I wouldn't call him a "BS" at all. In what way has he been "betrayed" here?

The only way I can see any "betrayal" being involved is if hbd had other reasons for actually engaging in the threesome to meet a need of hers that she kept secret from her H.

And as for her H, as he's apparently quite happy with the outcome, my suggestion would be for her to do a bit of "snooping", to find out if there's anything that her H might be keeping from her. It's quite possible that a porn habit (or worse) is involved. There's also the possibility that he's simply had a secret and unshared fantasy about threesomes.

IMO though, the very first step here is that hbd needs to let her H know that she sincerely regrets doing what she did, she regrets agreeing to it in the first place, and it's something that will never happen again.

Posted By: Gamma Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 11:06 PM
hbd,

While H does not see it as cheating now, there is a good chance H will see it as so in the future. My indirect experience here, from friends who told me about their threesomes, is that it leads to future problems no matter how cool everyone thinks they are.

I somehow had the sense to ignore threesomes offered to me, and after reading here on MB I am more glad I dodged that bullet.

God Bless
Gamma
Originally Posted by Gamma
I somehow had the sense to ignore threesomes offered to me, and after reading here on MB I am more glad I dodged that bullet.

Gamma, I think if my FWW had at any time offered me a "threesome" (before or after she became a WW), I'd have likely started asking her some pretty serious questions!

HBD, what when through your mind when your H first raised the subject? Was he the first to raise it?
Posted By: Gamma Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 11:20 PM
MIM

Gamma, I think if my FWW had at any time offered me a "threesome" (before or after she became a WW), I'd have likely started asking her some pretty serious questions!

Just to clear this up my W never indicated she wanted any threesomes, except of the social kind when we took OM2 out to lunch and did recreational activities with him.

The threesomes were offered to me by other women.

God Bless
Gamma
Posted By: ryanv Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 11:22 PM
hbd,

I'm sorry to see you here, truly I am and so is everyone here. We are in this forum because we have been in affair situations before. Some of us the beleaguered spouse (bs) and some of us the (ws) wayward spouse, and each is a different situation but the causes, effects, and solutions all follow patterns. Truth is you can call what happened in the 3-way whatever you want in the end it does not matter. You are here to seek help so I don't think a label is important. What I do feel is important is that you confront your husband with "radical honesty" and tell him EXACTLY how you feel. His reaction will speak volumes to the concerns of others on this site. Most likely he is having an affair (a) whether emotional or physical. I can say this from experience as my wife tried to get me to look outside the marriage while she was having an emotional affair so she would feel less guilty. I did not take the bait, but before I realized what was going on the physical affair started. Each situation is different yes, but if I would have found this site in time I could have stopped further damage to my marriage and begun to rebuild before the foundation was all but destroyed. I care for you and your marriage and I'm sure so does everyone else here. God Bless and good luck, and please don't hesitate to ask for advice. There are many people here who can help, some have posted in this thread who helped kick me in the butt to get my plan in order (Melody Lane being one).

Again good luck and I will pray for strength and wisdom for you
Posted By: Bryanp Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/25/11 11:42 PM
If you did not use protection then you will need to get tested for STD's. Picking up a stranger is crazy.
Originally Posted by hbd
No, I wanted to do it at the time. I thought it would be fun (and it was), but I didn't think about how I would feel afterwards. I guess I thought my H would be more aprehensive. If he had said one word about not wanting to do it, I wouldn't have gone through with it...but he didn't. At the time, I was glad..but, now I'm sad.


emphasis mine

The highlighted words are concerning. As evidenced by your WH's suggestion and your enthusiastic agreement to this, your marriage has been in trouble for awhile.

Is this the first time for the threesome? Have you or your WH been with anyone else outside of your marriage before this incident? It seems like you both had/have what we call around here a "wayward mentality".

As to your original question, I guess a threesome could be POJA'd but so could robbing a bank. Does that mean it is good for your marriage? How does it establish intimacy between the two of you? It doesn't. It encourages a destructive life style.

How long have you been married? Is this the first marriage for both of you? Are there any children? Who is the OM?


Posted By: BCboy Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 01:55 AM
hbd
I would also caution you not to POJA:
1) Leaping off a cliff
2) Driving into a brick wall
3) Sky Diving without a parachute etc....

I would suggest you spend some time getting acquainted with a moral compass. The intent of morals is to provide us with guidance so we will not hurt ourselves emotionally and spiritually. Just like you have learned not to drive the wrong way on the freeway you need to learn not to drive the wrong way in your relationship by getting emotionally or physically intimate with someone other than your husband. Your marriage needs repair and that can be found in Surviving an Affair.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 03:00 PM
Wow. Thank you for all of the suggestions and advice. I will try to answer all questions asked by starting from the beginning.

My h and I have been together for 17 years. We have two young kids. We have always been very "open-minded" sexually. I must admit that I cheated on my h before we were married ( in college), but never cheated once I took my marriage vows (until this incident). My h also cheated on me last year. That is when I became aware of this site. I even posted here for a while. That thread is now burried. After my h's affair, we read hnhn, saa, and lb. We found dr Harley's advice very helpful and did it all. We became so close and open and honest that we shared all sexual fantasies and found that we both fantasized about a threesome.

At the time, we also thought that a threesome would help with some lingering issues we had with my h's affair - his guilt and my need to feel like less of a victim. We talked about it for months and decided that it could work for us to set aside the affair once and for all.

I had a long honest talk with my h last night and I do feel better now. I told him about my guilt and he admitted that he did feel jealous. We both agreed that it was a mistake that will not be repeated.

Originally Posted by hbd
My h also cheated on me last year. That is when I became aware of this site. I even posted here for a while.

Posting on the forum is not enough. Did you ever READ the BASIC CONCEPTS?

Work the MB program.
Purchase the online program together.

*** LINK ***
Your marriage needs something more solid for both of you to grasp.

To imagine that your H's guilt would be assuaged by watching you "do" another man is insane. To imagine that your feelings of victimization would be assuaged by having your H watch you "do" another man is insane.

Your M can thrive after this with hard work and dedication and a MB PLAN !!!!,

However, ONLY getting forum opinions to repair what you have damaged ..... also insane. crazy

Take care.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 03:30 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
My h and I have been together for 17 years. We have two young kids. We have always been very "open-minded" sexually. I must admit that I cheated on my h before we were married ( in college), but never cheated once I took my marriage vows (until this incident). My h also cheated on me last year. That is when I became aware of this site. I even posted here for a while.

What was your original posting name?

Quote
That thread is now burried. After my h's affair, we read hnhn, saa, and lb. We found dr Harley's advice very helpful and did it all.
Where in all those books did you read Dr. Harley recommend going outside your marriage for SF? I don't believe you did it all. You and your husband have very, very poor boundaries.

Quote
At the time, we also thought that a threesome would help with some lingering issues we had with my h's affair - his guilt and my need to feel like less of a victim. We talked about it for months and decided that it could work for us to set aside the affair once and for all.
How? You were going to set aside his affair by having sex with another man? Sounds like a great excuse, to me.

Quote
I had a long honest talk with my h last night and I do feel better now. I told him about my guilt and he admitted that he did feel jealous. We both agreed that it was a mistake that will not be repeated.

What are you doing to ensure that it will not be repeated? If you've really read SAA, HNHN and LB, you should have some idea as to what to do.
Originally Posted by Prisca
Where in all those books did you read Dr. Harley recommend going outside your marriage for SF?

Ummmmmmm
Lemme tink think
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 03:41 PM
Oh yes, peperband, I read the basic concepts many times. In addition we read hnhn, saa, and lb. We put all into place...20 hrs ua time, o&h, meeting needs, etc. It was through total o&h that we found out we both fantasized about a threesome. We just shouldn't have gone through with it.

Originally Posted by hbd
Oh yes, peperband, I read the basic concepts many times. In addition we read hnhn, saa, and lb. We put all into place...20 hrs ua time, o&h, meeting needs, etc. It was through total o&h that we found out we both fantasized about a threesome. We just shouldn't have gone through with it.

I fantasize about being an opera diva.
You might try for loftier goals.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 03:51 PM
My posting name was hurtagainbydavid. I no longer want to use that name or thread though because my h was reading my thread.

We both read hnhn together and did everything suggested into place. I read saa and lb alone. I think I will also make my h read saa with me though because obviously we are both totally messed up. At least we r messed up together though. I would love to council with dr Harley, but we r seriously broke.

Please tell me what is "fun" about giving away your body to another man while your DH watches. That is grotesque beyond belief.
Posted By: markos Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 04:08 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
I would love to council with dr Harley, but we r seriously broke.

You know, you can give him a call for free on his radio show.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 04:10 PM
What about EPs? How did you do everything if you didn't have EPs in place?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 04:14 PM
Originally Posted by markos
Originally Posted by hbd
I would love to council with dr Harley, but we r seriously broke.

You know, you can give him a call for free on his radio show.

I already knowwhat he will say.. We need to put ep's in place, meet needs, be o&h, etc.

I think I'm just too messed up for anyone or anything to help me. frown
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 04:17 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
What about EPs? How did you do everything if you didn't have EPs in place?

I guess i was so focused on my h's ep's that I didn't put any of my own in place. I feel horrible. Just want to crawl into a hole and never come back out.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 04:27 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
I think I'm just too messed up for anyone or anything to help me. frown

With that kind of attitude, yes you are.

Ready to stop the pity party and get to work?
Posted By: schtoop Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 04:37 PM
I hate to be the bad guy here, but...

Quote
My h also cheated on me last year. That is when I became aware of this site. I even posted here for a while. That thread is now burried. After my h's affair, we read hnhn, saa, and lb. We found dr Harley's advice very helpful and did it all. We became so close and open and honest that we shared all sexual fantasies and found that we both fantasized about a threesome.

At the time, we also thought that a threesome would help with some lingering issues we had with my h's affair - his guilt and my need to feel like less of a victim. We talked about it for months and decided that it could work for us to set aside the affair once and for all.


It sounds to me like you husband is still of a wayward mind set and the you have been worked and persuaded into giving the OK to go outside the marriage for SF (you first, then he would be allowed to follow as things progressed).

You say you POJA'd the threesome. Are you sure it was mutual and enthusiastic, or was it discussed and encouraged until you wore down?

The key here is that your husband convinced you that this was a good way to finally put HIS affair behind him. Think about how warped and twisted that logic is!

I believe your husband still has the wayward mindset and gets excitement from SF outside the marriage, even if it starts with you, but better if it ends with him getting some too.

You said that you had a long talk with your husband last night and agreed to never do it again. If everything I said is wrong, perhaps he'll realize how hurt you are, drop the idea, and never mention it again.

If he starts bringing it up in the next weeks, months, or year and asks "was it really that bad? Didn't you enjoy it on some level?"

If you hear that you will know that I am right.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 04:52 PM
She is of a wayward mindset, too. Unless he held a gun to her head, no one forced her to do this. And if she had followed the program and had EPs in place, she never would have done it even if he was twisting her arm. She wanted to, and she did.

She needs to take responsibility for her own actions.
Posted By: reading Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 04:55 PM
If you read the books and followed the program, did you not get the major part of the whole program being
that you do not spend time in intimacy (i.e. sex) with someone outside of the marriage.
that you steer clear of potential trouble with other people (i.e. threesome)

Was that not noticed, noted?

It is a MAJOR part of the marriage builder program!
I like to go back to the genesis of a thread and revisit the original questions asked.


There were 2.
Quote
1. Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? (Thread title)
2. Should I feel guilty? (first post of thread)

It is quite common that the original questions are rhetorical. More of a statement, an expression of a state of mind, than an actual question.

It is also interesting what questions are not asked.


"What steps can we/I take to prevent this from ever happening again?"
"Exactly where did we/I go wrong?"
"How can this damage be repaired?"



Originally Posted by hbd
I feel horrible. Just want to crawl into a hole and never come back out.

I'm sure this is true.
Now what?
Are there answers to be found in that "hole"?

Going into a hole and sulking would be so easy.
That takes no effort whatsoever.

Now what?
Ask some different questions.
Put on your "big girl panties" and fix this.
No one is impressed with your self bashing.
WH: Okay, sorry I had an affair. Tell you what, why don't you bang some dude and then we'll be even.

HBD: I don't know.

WH: Come on... I'll even join in to make sure no funny business takes place.

HBD: Oh, well in that case, sure!


Originally Posted by hbd
No, I wanted to do it at the time. I thought it would be fun (and it was), but I didn't think about how I would feel afterwards. I guess I thought my H would be more aprehensive. If he had said one word about not wanting to do it, I wouldn't have gone through with it...but he didn't. At the time, I was glad..but, now I'm sad.

Why is the part I put in red germane to the discussion?

Why did you feel the need to say that?


That just leads me to believe that you are not the least bit sad, remorseful, guilt ridden or anything else about what you did.

That little part would be said with a smile.

committed
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 06:57 PM
Originally Posted by schtoop
You say you POJA'd the threesome. Are you sure it was mutual and enthusiastic, or was it discussed and encouraged until you wore down?

No, I wanted to do it for the reasons I've already stated. Also, I could feel my H slowly drifting away from me again (showing very little interest in me and the family) and I desperately wanted him to see that I am desirable and any man would want me.

Also, I wanted my H to feel a little bit of the Pain I felt after his A. I don't know why, but this was also important to me at the time.

These are idiotic thoughts, I know, but that's what I was thinking when I agreed to it.

I know my H wanted to do it to justify his A somewhat. I knew that going into it.

My arm wasn't twisted at all...I'm just plain twisted.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 06:59 PM
Originally Posted by committedandlovi
Originally Posted by hbd
No, I wanted to do it at the time. I thought it would be fun (and it was), but I didn't think about how I would feel afterwards. I guess I thought my H would be more aprehensive. If he had said one word about not wanting to do it, I wouldn't have gone through with it...but he didn't. At the time, I was glad..but, now I'm sad.

Why is the part I put in red germane to the discussion?

Why did you feel the need to say that?


That just leads me to believe that you are not the least bit sad, remorseful, guilt ridden or anything else about what you did.

That little part would be said with a smile.

committed

It was fun AT THE TIME. I enjoyed it AT THE TIME. Believe me, no one is more disgusted by that than me.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 07:06 PM
Originally Posted by Pepperband
Put on your "big girl panties" and fix this.
No one is impressed with your self bashing.

Sometimes a relationship is beyond fixing. Don't you think?

I'm not saying that we are going to get a divorce, far from it. In fact, we are closer now than we ever have been. The conversations we have had post threesome have been so deep, so personal, so emotional for both of us that I know we can overcome anything. I can't explain it. I just know that we will never ever have a normal marriage, but we will be together forever. Two twisted peas in a pod.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 07:12 PM
Quote
ometimes a relationship is beyond fixing. Don't you think?

I just know that we will never ever have a normal marriage, but we will be together forever. Two twisted peas in a pod.
The pity party feels great, doesn't it.

Turns my stomach to listen to it, actually.

You're not the first BS to become a wayward. You haven't done anything unique. There's nothing special here that makes you any more twisted than any other wayward.

When are you going to buckle down and get to work?
Been reading your hurtagainbydavid thread.

This just isnt going to work unless you are prepared to do the hard work. Because the things that do work are hard.

You wanted to believe what your wh said to you following his affair was the truth - because it was easier to believe that ignorance is bliss, than to snoop, expose and set firm boundaries. Easier but did it work?

You wanted to believe you could regain his love for you with the jealousy you hoped to generate from this revenge affair (because thats what it was). Again, easier. However you found out the hard way that a man just is not jealous over a woman he has no romantic love for.

Then there is the issue of your poor boundaries. You have said you were so focused on your h's EPs you did not put any in place of your own. This is just lazy. Someone who has had an affair before their marriage and read up on Dr H's policies knows better where poor boundaries will land you. You knew, but it's EASIER to get your admiration fix (and a need for jealousy is also that) from an OP than from your husband

You may have to let him go entirely if he refuses to change his wayward mindset. Very difficult that. Will you do it or search for an easier option?

On top of all that, you don't want to call Dr H in case he tells you to do some hard things that you dont want to do.

Did you come here for people to tell you not to feel guilty? Do you ant us to tell you that because your h has now told you that he DID feel jealous that he must now be telling the truth?

Like he did before?

Are you prepared to do the hard work, yes or no?

Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by Pepperband
Put on your "big girl panties" and fix this.
No one is impressed with your self bashing.

Sometimes a relationship is beyond fixing. Don't you think?
I'm not saying that we are going to get a divorce, far from it. In fact, we are closer now than we ever have been. The conversations we have had post threesome have been so deep, so personal, so emotional for both of us that I know we can overcome anything. I can't explain it. I just know that we will never ever have a normal marriage, but we will be together forever. Two twisted peas in a pod.


Wow what a great excuse to be lazy.
Originally Posted by hbd
I just know that we will never ever have a normal marriage, but we will be together forever. Two twisted peas in a pod.

OK.
Bye
Right hbd, your pity fest has just lost you the advice of one of the wisest people on here. Are you up to doing something about your situation or not?
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 07:19 PM
Quote
On top of all that, you don't want to call Dr H in case he tells you to do some hard things that you dont want to do.
Bingo.
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by Pepperband
Put on your "big girl panties" and fix this.
No one is impressed with your self bashing.

Sometimes a relationship is beyond fixing. Don't you

Yes, I do. And a marriage where my husband thought so little of me that he would even consider watching me commit adultery would be over. Because I would know that such a man did not love me and suffered from a deep, depraved soul sickness. And to think you believed such depravity would make him love you MORE.

I think the basic problem is that he does not love you, but you don't even know what love is. If you you did, you would know that any man would tolerate this does not love and cherish you. Because you don't understand that any man who would wh*re his wife out like that doesn't love her at all.

You have confused love with depravity.
I am just wondering what you get out of this relationship? A man who has affairs and thinks so little of his wife that he will wh*re her out to some loser; where is the payoff? What could you possibly get out of such a relationship?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 07:46 PM
Indiegirl - You are right. This was a revenge affair. I hadn't thought of it that way, but you are right. I take full responsibility for this. I was lazy and used my h's affair as an excuse. It will not happen again. I will put EP's in place. I am not ready to let him go though. I can't live without him. frown

Prisca and Pepperband - You seriously think this marriage can be fixed? How?
hbd Pep is gone.

If you want to keep the rest, you have a lot of proving of yourself to do because you have been ignoring good advice and telling yourself whatever you want to believe.

I think your situation is actually beyond my help and that you need the best vets you can get AND YOU NEED DR HARLEY.

Good luck.

Youll need it.
I don't believe it was a revenge affair at all. It was you trying to buy the love of a very wayward man. But the fact that he allowed it to happen just proves he has no love and no regard for you.
Btw, anyone can live without a wayward and you may need to accept this very difficult prospect. That doesnt mean you cant do everything you can to see if it can be saved first.

Im bowing out now. Bye.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 07:59 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
I don't believe it was a revenge affair at all. It was you trying to buy the love of a very wayward man. But the fact that he allowed it to happen just proves he has no love and no regard for you.

Yes. That too. So what do I do now?
What is your opinion of a person who would love you more if you sacrificed your principles and all semblance of decency?
Posted By: reading Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 08:14 PM
Just chiming in to say

yes

you CAN live without him.

You could. You choose to continue in a relationship but don't confuse that with having to be in one with him.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 08:20 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
Yes. That too. So what do I do now?

Call Dr. Harley on his radio show. Do whatever he tells you to do.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 08:39 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
Indiegirl - I will put EP's in place.

What EPs? Don't be vague.

In order to make it, you are going to have to have a complete and utter lifestyle change. You are going to have to do whatever it takes to protect your marriage at all costs. Your husband will have to do the same.

NO emotional needs get met outside of the marriage. NONE. Not even with your spouse at your side.

Absolutely NO 3rd party in your sexual relationship. Not a real life man or woman, or online. Your sex life is CLOSED to the outside world. The porn you and your husband watch together has probably contributed to these fantasies. The porn has got to go. It is not healthy for your marriage.

Your husband must agree to change your way of life as well. And protect it.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/26/11 08:49 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Originally Posted by hbd
Indiegirl - I will put EP's in place.

What EPs? Don't be vague.

In order to make it, you are going to have to have a complete and utter lifestyle change. You are going to have to do whatever it takes to protect your marriage at all costs. Your husband will have to do the same.

NO emotional needs get met outside of the marriage. NONE. Not even with your spouse at your side.

Absolutely NO 3rd party in your sexual relationship. Not a real life man or woman, or online. Your sex life is CLOSED to the outside world. The porn you and your husband watch together has probably contributed to these fantasies. The porn has got to go. It is not healthy for your marriage.

Your husband must agree to change your way of life as well. And protect it.

Thanks Prisca.

My EP's will be:

Avoid conversations with men.
No going to bars (alone or with my H).
Meet all H's needs and tell him how to meet mine.
Be o&h with H and myself.

We have an agreement that we cannot watch porn unless we are together. I have been watching my H's inet usage and he has kept his word on that. I will talk to him about stopping all porn usage, even when we are together. You are right about it not being good...it has desensitized me/us.
posted to you before ***EDIT***. you already have issues in your relationship. you are going to bring porn into it, not to mention a 3 some.. i am not a prude but wtf you are already playing with fire.

get some confidence. look at who you are and your character and get out., or dont stand for this behavior wtf were you thinking on this one- sorry

learn who you are... set your life on who you want to be not doing things to please others, wake up, i understand fantasys but come on are you just going to throw more on your plate, do you thrive on the drama.

do you have children i forgot?

you had alot of supporters and many that gave you very amazing advice and what happened?

just my thoughts, no vet just a bit angry with a wasted opportunity. sorry.

would you like to see my EP's???? break them and i am out. sorry so harsh but i have standards not that if not upheld..i am out. we are in agreement on that!

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/27/11 04:27 PM
Originally Posted by chickadee1
posted to you before ***EDIT***. you already have issues in your relationship. you are going to bring porn into it, not to mention a 3 some.. i am not a prude but wtf you are already playing with fire.

get some confidence. look at who you are and your character and get out., or dont stand for this behavior wtf were you thinking on this one- sorry

learn who you are... set your life on who you want to be not doing things to please others, wake up, i understand fantasys but come on are you just going to throw more on your plate, do you thrive on the drama.

do you have children i forgot?

you had alot of supporters and many that gave you very amazing advice and what happened?

just my thoughts, no vet just a bit angry with a wasted opportunity. sorry.

would you like to see my EP's???? break them and i am out. sorry so harsh but i have standards not that if not upheld..i am out. we are in agreement on that!

I know. I've truly made a mess of things, haven't I? Believe me, no one is more disgusted with this situation than me.

I had another long talk with my H last night and he agreed to all of my terms, including no porn. He says he'll do anything to see me happy.

We will work through this. We have been through much worse and always work things out, so this won't be any different. We will just have to work together to get to where we need to be.

We have two young daughters, age 8 and 5.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/27/11 09:08 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Originally Posted by hbd
Yes. That too. So what do I do now?

Call Dr. Harley on his radio show. Do whatever he tells you to do.

Ok, I just sent dr Harley an email. They are supposed to send me an email with a time to call the show. smile

I have another question though...so, not going out to bars is now one of our ep's, but my h has an employee "boat ride" scheduled through work that will have alcohol offered. I can't go because it's employees only. Its only three hours long and he said he would come right home after, but i feel it doesnt comply with our ep's. I told him I do not want him to go and he reluctantly agreed not to, but he's upset about it. Did i make the right choice by not letting him go? If not, how should I have handled it differently? In other words, how do you poja a specific event?

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/27/11 09:41 PM
Also, I've reread this thread and a lot of people say they think my h has a "wayward mentality." Does this mean that although he may not be in an active physical affair, he may be in an emotional affair or something like that? How can I get him to stop having a wayward mentality?
Why don't you read this - Herpapabear's thread about EPs

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/27/11 09:54 PM
Originally Posted by Mr_Recon6mo
Why don't you read this - Herpapabear's thread about EPs

Perfect, thanks!

So, from what I can tell on that thread, poja does not apply to EP's because they are just compensation. correct? I did the right thing then...I just need to figure out a way to get my h to see it that way.suggestions?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/27/11 09:58 PM
I just found out today that my department is officially closing and I will be laid off, so it could be that he is just upset and stressed about that too.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/27/11 10:11 PM
H just called to apologize. Says he doesn't even want to go on the boat ride, he was upset because his co-workers were giving him crap about being to "whipped" to go. He says they are teasing him for not being a team player. Whatever.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/27/11 10:15 PM
Wayward mentality = thinking like a wayward. May not be in an active affair, but is probably vulnerable to one.

Thinking like a wayward is not something you can make him stop doing. He will have to put forth the effort and actively change himself by following this program.

He'd better be pretty eager to follow his EPs to the letter. I'd be worried if he's already showing upsetness at having to keep them.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/27/11 10:17 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
H just called to apologize. Says he doesn't even want to go on the boat ride, he was upset because his co-workers were giving him crap about being to "whipped" to go. He says they are teasing him for not being a team player. Whatever.

He can tell them that his wife is prettier and more important than they'll ever be. So stuff it.
Originally Posted by hbd
H just called to apologize. Says he doesn't even want to go on the boat ride, he was upset because his co-workers were giving him crap about being to "whipped" to go. He says they are teasing him for not being a team player. Whatever.

fyi, they were teasing him about being "whipped" because he used you as the reason he wasn't going. He told them you wouldn't let him and threw you under the bus. A better way to handle it would have been to man up and take responsibility for his own choices. "Sorry I have changed my mind and won't be going." He didn't have to play the "wife won't let me" card.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/27/11 10:54 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by hbd
H just called to apologize. Says he doesn't even want to go on the boat ride, he was upset because his co-workers were giving him crap about being to "whipped" to go. He says they are teasing him for not being a team player. Whatever.

fyi, they were teasing him about being "whipped" because he used you as the reason he wasn't going. He told them you wouldn't let him and threw you under the bus. A better way to handle it would have been to man up and take responsibility for his own choices. "Sorry I have changed my mind and won't be going." He didn't have to play the "wife won't let me" card.

I think they heard him talking to me about it on the phone. He works in a small open office and people close to him can hear. I can even hear them making rude comments in the background sometimes. He works with a bunch of male [censored]. Im sure that contributes to his wayward mindset. It's better than him working with a bunch of women though I think.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/27/11 11:00 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
I think they heard him talking to me about it on the phone. He works in a small open office and people close to him can hear. I can even hear them making rude comments in the background sometimes. He works with a bunch of male [censored]. Im sure that contributes to his wayward mindset. It's better than him working with a bunch of women though I think.

All the more reason not to go to company events like the boatride without you.

From now on, your marriage comes first. Get a babysitter and go on a date that night instead.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/27/11 11:02 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
From now on, your marriage comes first. Get a babysitter and go on a date that night instead.

Great idea! Thanks.
Quote
No, I wanted to do it for the reasons I've already stated. Also, I could feel my H slowly drifting away from me again (showing very little interest in me and the family) and I desperately wanted him to see that I am desirable and any man would want me.

Also, I wanted my H to feel a little bit of the Pain I felt after his A. I don't know why, but this was also important to me at the time.


IMHO, in paragraph one above, hbd tells us that her marriage never really recovered from her husband's affair. The two of them did not make it through that first mess.

Then, in paragraph two, she tells us the real reason for this threesome - which is....

revenge.


What this threesome amounts to is a revenge affair, performed directly in front of the spouse, with the spouse somehow participating. Maybe the "BS" in this case has a need for the WW to do this, so he can feel like they can "move on" now?


Are the two of them "even"?


This wayward husband probably believes that they are. He set it up perfectly, didn't he?




SB
This couple needs more professional help than I think the boards might be able to offer...
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/28/11 12:00 AM
Originally Posted by schoolbus
This couple needs more professional help than I think the boards might be able to offer...

She has contacted Dr. Harley via his radio show, and will be calling in soon.
A. He cheated.

B. He thought, "Okay, you sleep w someone and we'll be even."

C. She was scared.

D. He convinced her it was safe as long as he was there. cool

E. She agreed.

F. Husband thinks they are even.

G. She feels guilty and confused.

H. Were the kids in the house while this was going on??? Did you get a babysitter? Leave the kids at Mom's? "Hey, Mom. Want to take the kids for the night while we go have a threesome?" Doubt mom would have agreed to that. There's definitely a lot of lying going on here. naughty

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/28/11 02:15 PM
Originally Posted by TryingEverything
Were the kids in the house while this was going on??? Did you get a babysitter? Leave the kids at Mom's? "Hey, Mom. Want to take the kids for the night while we go have a threesome?" Doubt mom would have agreed to that. There's definitely a lot of lying going on here. :naughty

The kids were camping with the grandparents, something that had been planned for months. We werent even staying at home, we went to a concert and were staying at a nearby hotel. We went out to the bars after the concert. We did not actually go out that night expecting to find someone that would come home with us. It was something we found fun to talk about, but didn't actually think it would happen. We both had way too much to drink and let things go too far (not that it's an excuse but it contributed to our lack of judgement). We would NEVER do something like that with kids in the house or even do that in our own house.

Your summary of the situation is way too simple. There were a lot of factors that contributed to this mess, including my own fascination with being with two men at once. I know all of you think it's disgusting, but I have to be honest about how I truly feel. It's not easy to admit, in fact it's very embarrassing. But, I'm not going to just allow everyone to shift the blame to my h. We share the blame for this mess equally.

If there was lying with regard to the threesome, it was me lying to myself. I thought that I would be ok with it because it was something we shared together, but I did not think about the guilt I would feel for committing adultery. That is on me and I take full responsibility and I'm working to fix the things that led to this mess.
Ok, I said I wouldnt post on this thread again, but feel compelled to.

I have noticed your honesty about yourself hbd, you seem to take all the 2x4s unflinchingly, which is a good sign. You seem also to have woken up to the fact that you 'were lying to yourself'. This is fantastic - and you must stop doing it. Lying to oneself is the most dangerous lie of all.

What does seem to escape your notice is that the favourite lies you tell to yourself are about your husband and his truthfulness and regard for you.

Time and time again on here I have heard you express baffling faith in your h.

"we will work it out" "he says"

So what if he says something? He has lied to you consistently. You're not stupid either. You choose to believe him because you can't face the possibility of having to Plan B him - or leave him for good if it comes to that.

His addiction to porn made you unhappy so you asked him to stop.
he agreed, but lied.

Realising that you would rather do anything than set firm boundaries you made the curious deal with him to watch porn together. This would have required lying to yourself about that your marriage is just your sole responsibility and not his.

I have the curious feeling that this deal re porn didnt give you the 'togetherness' you were craving. Probably at this point you lied to yourself some more and told yourself that you would just have to go that 'extra mile' for him. As long as that extra mile did not involve telling him he would lose you if he continued to behave this way.

I am assuming he had the affair at some point here....
(add the amount of lies he told you about that yourself, here)

Then he told you that rather than face his feelings of guilt and shame honestly, like a man, he would rather sweep them under the rug by having you even the score with a threesome.

You knew (because I can tell you aren't stupid) that he was pimping you out to save his own conscience.

Yes you had your own ideas that you are ashamed of but honestly, read the above sentence again.

You knew you were okay with this bizarre proposition because you were clean out of ideas of ways to get him to show love for you, without going to Plan B or kicking him out.

You knew that a man who was willing to watch you with another, had practically no feelings of love for you and did not respect you. However you lied to yourself that it was possible to make him jealous.

You may be able to wrench him out of waywardness. It will proabably involve doing everything that Dr Harley tells you to on the radio to the letter.

I am just afraid that if Dr H tells you to plan b him, you won't be willing to do something that difficult.

I dont know whether you fear making him angry or just dont want the pain of being without him, but you have done some crazy things to avoid plan b.

You do share the blame for this mess equally. But once you stop lying to yourself about your h's truthfulness and his ability to care for you, your side of the street will be a lot cleaner.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/28/11 08:14 PM
Indiegirl - did you read my whole "betrayed again" thread?

Your comments are giving me the impression that you stopped reading half way through the thread and missed the part where my h has done everything I have asked of him... He stands by no contact with OW (I confirm this with snooping), wrote NC letter, gave me access to all of his email and phone information, schedules ua time with me, meets all my needs, reads relationship books with me, goes to a counselor to discuss his issues, wrote a recovery plan and is sticking to it, set boundaries for himself, and is completely open and honest with me.

If he does break no contact with OW, I am prepared to move on to plan b. Dont worry, I am keeping a close eye on him (I just don't want to discuss my techniques on here as my h may read them).

As far as the porn is concerned... I Like porn. I enjoy watching It with him. In fact some of the stuff I like to watch is even more kinky than the stuff he likes. I asked him
not to watch it by himself because I wanted us to share it together. He doesnt watch it by himself anymore (I know this for fact by snooping - not sure where you got the idea he lied about that) and he has agreed to stop watching it together.

My h did lie in the beginning (as ALL waywards do), but there is no indication he is lying anymore (believe me, I have looked). Aside from the threesome, he has been working very hard to earn my forgiveness. There is no reason to plan b him when he is following the recovery plan.



Originally Posted by hbd
Your comments are giving me the impression that you stopped reading half way through the thread and missed the part where my h has done everything I have asked of him... He stands by no contact with OW (I confirm this with snooping), wrote NC letter, gave me access to all of his email and phone information, schedules ua time with me, meets all my needs, reads relationship books with me, goes to a counselor to discuss his issues, wrote a recovery plan and is sticking to it, set boundaries for himself, and is completely open and honest with me.


Which is all great stuff. And your other thread reflects that.

This thread however talks about him wanting to dodge repsonsibility for the affair by using a threesome. And you wanting to let him.

That is a massive alarm bell that he is in a wayward frame of mind. This would mean you cant take anything he says on faith.

I have alreay said Dr H needs to give the advice here,

Just glad to hear you ARE keeping a close eye on him, cause I wasnt hearing that.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/28/11 10:02 PM
I should also add that we both lied to each other about watching porn before we started being o&h. We were both too embarrassed to admit to each other the kind of kinky stuff we like (porn, bdsm, anal, etc.). As a result, we were both watching porn behind each others backs and lying about it (yes, I did - embarrassing to admit, but true). It was only after being completely o&h that we realized we liked the same stuff and were actually watching the same type of kinky porn seperately. That is when we determined that we would only watch porn together. It was an eye opener for us and made us realize how important o&h really is in our relationship.

I said all of this in my email to Dr. Harley. Just waiting to hear back from him on when to call the show.

prisca - do you still think I'm no more twisted than other waywards?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/28/11 10:13 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
That is a massive alarm bell that he is in a wayward frame of mind.

Yes, I do think he still has a wayward state of mind. I'm hoping that following the recovery plan will change that. Only time will tell. Hoping for the best and some great advice from dr Harley.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/28/11 10:36 PM
Quote
prisca - do you still think I'm no more twisted than other waywards?
I'm supposed to think you're more twisted because you looked at porn? Hardly.

Stop comparing yourself to other waywards. It's not going to solve anything for you. You've got enough to worry about without dwelling on whether you're worse or better than other waywards.

Let us know when you hear back from the Harleys.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/29/11 04:46 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
[quote]I'm supposed to think you're more twisted because you looked at porn? Hardly.

Well, that, and the fact that I like bdsm, anal, and sleeping with two men at once.

Originally Posted by Prisca
Let us know when you hear back from the Harleys.

I haven't heard back from them, but I will let you know as soon as I do!!!

Does anyone know how long it usually takes to get a response from them? The website says within one day, but I haven't heard anything.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/29/11 05:13 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
[quote=Prisca]
Quote
I'm supposed to think you're more twisted because you looked at porn? Hardly.
Well, that, and the fact that I like bdsm, anal, and sleeping with two men at once.

This is a new form of a pity party that you're trying to throw -- get everybody else to tell you how sick and twisted you are, and then you can feel bad about yourself.

I will not waste any more time analyzing how sick and twisted you are, nor will I compare you to other waywards. Non of this is beneficial to you, or any one else here.

Get back to working on your marriage, ok?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 07/29/11 05:23 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Originally Posted by hbd
[quote=Prisca]
Quote
I'm supposed to think you're more twisted because you looked at porn? Hardly.
Well, that, and the fact that I like bdsm, anal, and sleeping with two men at once.

This is a new form of a pity party that you're trying to throw -- get everybody else to tell you how sick and twisted you are, and then you can feel bad about yourself.

I will not waste any more time analyzing how sick and twisted you are, nor will I compare you to other waywards. Non of this is beneficial to you, or any one else here.

Get back to working on your marriage, ok?

Will do. Thanks! smile

I'm getting anxious and nervous about talking on the radio. How many people listen to the show? I have stage fright!
I have analyzed how sick and twisted you are, if it makes any difference to you.


I've seen worse, if it makes you feel better.


SB
Personally, I think you can leave out your fetishes and unuseful information.

We're not interested in hearing about it.

I just simply think it's too much information, and something I don't care to read about.
Posted By: Neak Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 02:40 AM
Yep, fetishes or the lack thereof do not change the underlying mindset both of you have that led to this mess.

Just a typical, entitled, wayward mindset. That's the place to start, not the irrelevant details.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 12:57 PM
Originally Posted by schoolbus
I have analyzed how sick and twisted you are, if it makes any difference to you.


I've seen worse, if it makes you feel better.


SB

Schoolbus, thanks for taking the time to analyze my situation. It does make me feel a little better, thanks.

I must say that your story is one of the most inspiring on this Forum IMO. You have been through so much crap, and even made your own mistakes (ONS), yet you have come out stronger somehow. So, if anyone can help me, I think it would be you. Do you have any suggestions for me that haven't already been given? I want to fix this and come out stronger in the end, like you.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 12:59 PM
Originally Posted by peachyisback
Personally, I think you can leave out your fetishes and unuseful information.

We're not interested in hearing about it.

I just simply think it's too much information, and something I don't care to read about.


I certainly didn't intend to offend anyone. I really just want to figure this all out. I thought it would be best to give all information, but I guess you don't need to know everything. I wish I could go back and delete some of my posts now.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 01:15 PM
Originally Posted by Neak
Yep, fetishes or the lack thereof do not change the underlying mindset both of you have that led to this mess.

Just a typical, entitled, wayward mindset. That's the place to start, not the irrelevant details.

You are right, it's the "entitlement" feeling that I have a problem with. I did feel entitled to have the 3some. I felt like, well, since he had affairs with two women, I should be able to have sex with someone too.

I know it's wrong. I know it's wayward thinking. At the same time, I still feel entitled after being so betrayed. This is absolutely what I need to change.
Are you legally married?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 01:40 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Are you legally married?

Yep, almost 11 years. That didn't stop him though.

Ugh, I feel so much resentment and anger. Sometimes I feel fine, other times I'm overwhelmed with resentment. It's the worst feeling to resent the person you love more than anything.

I wish the Harleys would get back to me. I'm going crazy.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 01:52 PM
An old friend of mine was here visiting and I told her everything. She sees nothing wrong with the 3some. In fact, she suggested that we have another 3some to make things even (since H slept with 2 women, she thinks I should get to sleep with 2 men). This is the type of mentality non-MBers have. I'm so glad I found Marriage Builders. If I hadn't I would probably be listening to her crappy advice and making things worse.

While she was here, I made the mistake of showing her OM's pictures on Facebook (he's not a complete stranger, I know who he is). I'm not facebook friends with him, but his photo albums are viewable. I didn't contact him or friend him, just looked. Now, I can't get the images out of my mind. Trying to redirect the thoughts.


Well of course, you shouldn't have looked. Don't you know better after posting here for some time?

If his albums are public, does that mean that you don't need your own Facebook account to view them?

Block Facebook as a site from your PC, if so. Never go there again.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 01:59 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Well of course, you shouldn't have looked. Don't you know better after posting here for some time?

If his albums are public, does that mean that you don't need your own Facebook account to view them?

Block Facebook as a site from your PC, if so. Never go there again.

I know. SO STUPID. I thought that since I want to work things out with my H that the pictures wouldn't affect me. Duh

I will block him on Facebook. It's the same thing I did with OW's page and I can't see her picture anymore either. Thanks.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 02:02 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
If his albums are public, does that mean that you don't need your own Facebook account to view them?

I have to be logged into facebook to see the albums. They can't be seen just by Googling his name. But, he does have a myspace account that is viewable from public. How do I block a website like myspace from coming up on google?
Posted By: markos Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 02:48 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
I wish the Harleys would get back to me. I'm going crazy.

If you haven't heard anything within a couple of days after contacting them, it is possible they didn't get your original message or that your email is blocking their response. Have you checked your spam folder, if you have one?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 02:51 PM
Originally Posted by markos
Originally Posted by hbd
I wish the Harleys would get back to me. I'm going crazy.

If you haven't heard anything within a couple of days after contacting them, it is possible they didn't get your original message or that your email is blocking their response. Have you checked your spam folder, if you have one?

I've checked my spam folder, still nothing. I'll resend. Thanks.
Posted By: markos Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 03:10 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
An old friend of mine was here visiting and I told her everything. She sees nothing wrong with the 3some. In fact, she suggested that we have another 3some to make things even (since H slept with 2 women, she thinks I should get to sleep with 2 men). This is the type of mentality non-MBers have.

A lot of people believe having sex with someone you are not married to is wrong, even without Marriage Builders.

A lot of people believe having sex with more than one person at the same time is wrong, even without Marriage Builders.

I really think you need to consider picking some new friends.
Posted By: Neak Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 03:14 PM
Hopefully they will see it and get back to you soon. You would really benefit from their help.

It sounds like you need some new friends...
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 03:22 PM
Originally Posted by markos
A lot of people believe having sex with someone you are not married to is wrong, even without Marriage Builders.

A lot of people believe having sex with more than one person at the same time is wrong, even without Marriage Builders.

I really think you need to consider picking some new friends.

Agreed. Almost all of my friends are either cheating, being cheated on, or are in the process of getting a divorce as the result of an affair.
Posted By: Neak Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 03:33 PM
faint You may just need to move to a whole new place with nicer people.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 03:41 PM
I don't think it's the area. I live in a nice suburb. Most of my good friends live at least 2 hours away anyway.

My best friend, who I've known for 25 years, actually just got cheated on by her H. We are working through all of this together. I told her about the 3some and she was shocked and disappointed. She thinks it was because we were drunk, which is why we added no drinking at bars to our list of EPs. I don't know what I would do without her.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 03:43 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
I don't think it's the area. I live in a nice suburb. Most of my good friends live at least 2 hours away anyway.

My best friend, who I've known for 25 years, actually just got cheated on by her H. We are working through all of this together. I told her about the 3some and she was shocked and disappointed. She thinks it was because we were drunk, which is why we added no drinking at bars to our list of EPs. I don't know what I would do without her.

If my H breaks NC and I have to go to plan B, I might move closer to her. She lives 3 hours away, near my parents.
Posted By: Krazy71 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 03:51 PM
I think a woman could find out a whole lot about her man prior to marriage: Bat your eyelashes at him and ask him if he'd like to have a three-way with you and another woman. If he says yes, dump him and never look back.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 07:18 PM
I heard back from Dr Harley. He didn't invite me to call the show (which is fine with me because I have stage fright about being on the radio). I've posted my email to him and his response below.

Here is the email I sent him:

"My husband and I have been together for 17 years, married almost 11. I'm 36 and he is 37. We have two beautiful daughters, age 5 and 8.

We have had a very turbulent relationship. I cheated on my husband with several one night stands before we were married and my husband had two affairs during our marriage (once before we had kids and then again last year). After the last affair, I found the Marriage Builders website and we read His Needs, Her needs together. I also read Surviving an Affair. After which, we put all of your suggestions in place.

We set up extraordinary precautions (no sharing personal information with opposite sex without partner by your side, no going out drinking w/o partner, etc.). We have undivided attention time 20 hours a week and family time 15 hrs week. We completed the needs questionnaire and work hard to meet each other's most important needs. We use the policy of joint agreement. Finally, and most importantly to us, we are very open and honest about everything (my #1 need).

It was through being COMPLETELY open and honest about sex that we both found that we like the same kind of ...ummm...kinky things. We also found that we both fantasized about a threesome with another man (I wanted to be with two men at once and he wanted that too). After several months of discussing this, we finally went ahead and did it.

I have felt some shame as a result of the threesome (it was adultery, after all), BUT at the same time, I feel closer with my husband because we shared it together. We enjoyed it together.

All of that being said, my questions are:

Could the fact that we weren't being open and honest about our interest in porn and kink be what caused us both to stray in the first place (our sf needs weren't being met the way we like them met)? You say that porn and thresomes are bad for marriage, but can it work if we are both enthusiastic, POJA, and do it together? If not, can you please tell us what we should do when porn and thresomes are the things that make SF enjoyable for both of us? Wouldn't we become bored and start looking elsewhere if we weren't meeting each other's SF needs the way we both enjoy having those needs met?"

Dr. Harley's response:

"I encourage sexual exclusivity in marriage for a whole host of reasons. In your case, I would avoid a threesome because so many of the couples I�ve counseled that did that became addicted to it, and it ruined their marriage. As it turns out, normal sex between a husband and wife doesn�t ever have to be boring unless there are alternatives outside of the marriage. So whenever you have sex, do it with each other and you�ll be fine. Don�t even self-stimulate unless you are doing it together.

Best wishes,
Willard F. Harley, Jr."


Posted By: schtoop Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 07:43 PM
Wow,

15 pages of beating up HBD, her husband, and their choices.

Tons of advice from putting in extraordinary precautions to going to plan B.

And the Good Doctor says simply "Don't do it".
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 07:48 PM
Originally Posted by schtoop
Wow,

15 pages of beating up HBD, her husband, and their choices.

Tons of advice from putting in extraordinary precautions to going to plan B.

And the Good Doctor says simply "Don't do it".

I know, right!!?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 07:50 PM
He cc'd Joyce, maybe she will have more to say. IDK
What I think he's saying there makes sense to me. Personally, if my h NEEDED an extra boost to be interested (be it someone else or props or porn) I would start to feel less connected to him. I know it would hurt his feelings if I told him that he alone wasnt going to be enough for forever.

I got the impression from your thread that the threesome was just 'for fun' but you are saying here that just the two of you, no porn, no games would get boring - really? Thats quite the put down you are giving each other.

My reading of Dr H is that sex only becomes boring when couples dont feel connected in other ways, so it spills into the bedroom

He has written an article about sex exclusivity and porn (here's the link http://www.marriagebuilders.com/graphic/mbi5050a_qa.html)

Of course this article is different to your sitch because the porn use annoys the wife, however there are some pars I think relate to your situation

The longer he would avoid the pornographic videos and any other sexual material, and limit all of his sexual options to having sex with you, the more your sexual relationship would return to the way it was when you were first married.

But it won't be easy for him to give up his tapes or whatever else he uses for sexual release. Over the years, his methods of self-arousal have probably become very sophisticated and work extremely well -- much better, in fact, than his sex with you.

Sex should be exclusively reserved for the marital relationship for quite a few reasons. For one thing, sex is one of the easiest ways to deposit love units in marriage. To waste it's pleasure apart from each other is to miss an opportunity to build romantic love.


Even though the threesome was your fantasy too, you did feel jealous that HE wasnt more jealous. Thats because you want to be everything to him, and why shouldn't you be?

You have used the word 'desensitized' to describe your reaction to porn, DrH is saying to become resensitised, focus on each other.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 08:21 PM
Thanks, Indiegirl.

Yeah, I do get bored doing the same things over and over again with my H. I need to spice things up. It's just the way I am. It doesn't mean I'm not connected with my H. In fact, I feel it means that I'm more connected because some of the things I like are very embarrasing...these are things that I would only share with someone that I'm connected with.

I was disappointed that he wasn't more jealous, but we have talked that through and he says he was actually jealous. So, I'm feeling better about that now.

We will definitely focus more on each other and cool it on the other stuff.

Thanks for your comments. smile
hbd,

One answer I can offer you is that jealousy stems from people wanting to be "number one" in the life of the person they love. An interesting concept, when you consider your idea that it is acceptable, even desirable, for three people to be in a triagulated relationship. What happens in the course of these types of relationships (not EVERY one, but most typically) is that one of the three people ultimately feels that he/she is second in line - and not "number one".

Let's face it - nobody wants to be the second one on the list when it comes to being loved. Or being pleasured. It is kind of natural for us to want to be first. Threesomes don't work long because of this feature of human beings.


When we look at marriages, we spend lots of time building that primary relationship. Then, when we bring a third into it, that threatens that "me first" position of the spouse. Of course! Because what else is the spouse to think? He/she is being replaced, or the potential is there. It just opens the door to the next step - which is affair behavior.


Your guilt is understandable. You did nothing to even the score. My analysis was correct, and your friend hit the nail on the head as well - which was to point out to you that you were (in her eyes) still "not even" with your husband in terms of sleeping around. You were still one affair short!

Gee. Now that we understand that this really does have some aspects of a revenge affair, we can look a little more closely at what it is.


Part kink. Part revenge. Part...what? I would say plain old wayward behavior, that is what I see.



I would say that your marriage is in trouble because there is a lack of honesty, period. There is a facade here that needs to come down before this marriage will ever reach any depth.

When you act a part for too long, there comes a time when you just want to be yourself. That's when the house of cards just falls.


SB
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/01/11 09:47 PM
Originally Posted by schoolbus
When you act a part for too long, there comes a time when you just want to be yourself. That's when the house of cards just falls.

Can you explain this a little more? You think I'm acting a part, or my H is?
I think you are. And that your revenge affair speaks to this. You carried out what you "wanted" to be a fantasy.

Turns out this was the fantasy of the role you played, and the guilt is telling you this. The guilt is not for the "affair". It is for the self-betrayal.


SB
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 07:31 PM
Originally Posted by schoolbus
I think you are. And that your revenge affair speaks to this. You carried out what you "wanted" to be a fantasy.

Turns out this was the fantasy of the role you played, and the guilt is telling you this. The guilt is not for the "affair". It is for the self-betrayal.


SB

I thought about your comments all night. It's an interesting concept (that I'm playing a part), but it's not true in my case. I have never been more honest with myself, my H, or the people on this message board for that matter.

If I was "playing a part" at all, it was before I found out about the A. Before the A, I never told my H about what SF I liked because I thought it would make him feel like he wasn't enough (as Indiegirl said it would make her or her H feel). As a result, I pretended to enjoy basic SF, which in turn caused me not to be interested in sex and I rarely climaxed. We then grew apart because SF is his #1 need.

Now that we are being O&H, we are having sex daily and it is good because I am being honest with my H and myself about what I like.

Also, revenge was a very small part of why the threesome happened. The threesome happened because of the following:

1. I had a fantasy of being with two men at once (80% of the cause).
2. I felt entitled to do it because of my H's affairs (10% of cause).
3. I wanted my H to see how desirable I am to other men (5% of cause).
4. I was curious to see if my H would get jealous or be hurt (4% of cause).
5. I was drunk (1% of cause).

I did feel guilty after, but I truly feel that was because I felt bad about committing adultery (a sin in the eyes of God) and I was worried about how it would affect our marriage.

Thanks for your comments though SB, they really made me think and examine myself and my situation. I appreciate you taking the time to offer your comments and answer my questions.

I told my H about the email I sent to Dr Harley and I showed him Dr. Harley's response. My H was very accepting of Dr. Harley's advice. We are putting EPs in place to make sure a threesome doesn't happen again.
Self-betrayal: when you commit an act which goes against that which you know is the right thing to do, despite that inner warning to the self that you are doing the wrong thing; including therein the betrayal of the conscience as well as the betrayal of the option to do the right thing for ANOTHER person


you in fact betrayed yourself



The role you played in this cannot be denied. You stepped into the role of a fantasy


acted it out

in spite of inner warnings that this might lead to poor outcomes



you ignored those inner warnings


you now pay the price


guilt being one of them.




It is the same with any act that goes against what we believe is "right" deep within ourselves. What I am talking about is NOT "right" in the sense of society, but "right" in our most inner, own self. Somewhere within you, there was a betrayal.


Read "Leadership and Self-Deception: Getting out of the box" by The Arbinger Institute.


It can lead you to understand when you betray yourself, which leads you to betray others around you.

It would also be good for hubby.


Can help with those EPs - and explains what I am talking about.


You need insight into those moments when you initially make decisions, to understand exactly how you are losing those chances. Why you are counting beans, looking for "being even" with your man, when you cannot be "even". Why there is not a need to be "even"...

And why you don't need to look for it.

SB
Every wayward plays a part, hbd.

The affair is 'friendship' 'fun' 'fantasy' or they just being someone's KISA - or spicing things up.

They play let's pretend I'm not damaging my marriage or selling out my values. They pretend it is not about betraying something priceless just to get a few needs met.

The negative act has a positive mask slapped on it, so the wayward can enjoy the moment without feeling guilty

The guilt comes later, because those masks don't hold up long.

You have owned your guilty feelings now but the radical honesty has to come before the act. To become a former wayward, you have to say to yourself 'at what point - and how - did I allow myself to lie to myself about the true meaning here?'

That will help you avoid doing it again.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 08:41 PM
Quote
Agreed. Almost all of my friends are either cheating, being cheated on, or are in the process of getting a divorce as the result of an affair.
Bad company corrupts good morals.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 08:41 PM
Originally Posted by schoolbus
Read "Leadership and Self-Deception: Getting out of the box" by The Arbinger Institute.


It can lead you to understand when you betray yourself, which leads you to betray others around you. SB

Will do SB! Thanks!

Now onto other issues...

H has to go to a regional meeting for work in a few months for 4 days. I've asked him not to go, but he says it's expected of him. I can't go because we can't afford it and we don't have anyone to watch the kids. How should I handle situations like this that go against our EPs, but we don't have a choice?
The lies to the self actually HELP you betray yourself


and helped you betray your husband.


You told yourself that it was okay to have this affair because your husband was a part of it (hmmmm, it wasn't okay, tho, because otherwise, why would there be guilt?).

You told yourself that it was okay to have this affair because your husband had an affair, so things would be somewhat more "even" (it turns out this isn't the case tho, because somehow things really are not even, they are worse inside your heart).

You told yourself, and still do, that your husband is truly okay with the 3-some, but somehow he has jealous feelings (so how can both of these be true......the two feelings are in direct conflict).


When we begin to "justify" a behavior, we must look at the behavior itself. Behavior that appears to require a justification often is NOT something we ought to be doing. If we find ourselves looking for reasons why it is "okay" to go ahead and do something

red flag it

because there is likely a form of self-betrayal going on.


Read the book......I swear.....life-changer.


SB
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 09:14 PM
How to Block a Website on Your Computer
Originally Posted by hbd
[quote=schoolbus]
H has to go to a regional meeting for work in a few months for 4 days. I've asked him not to go, but he says it's expected of him. I can't go because we can't afford it and we don't have anyone to watch the kids. How should I handle situations like this that go against our EPs, but we don't have a choice?


Has he told his boss in no uncertain terms that he cannot go because he had an affair and it would mean the end of his marriage?

What would be the consequences of his not going? Fired? Or just disappointed boss?

I think the vets on here will tell you the loss of a job is nothing compared to the loss of a marriage.

Do you even believe him? While it is possible he is still in an actively wayward mindset you should only trust what you can verify independently.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 09:22 PM
Quote
H has to go to a regional meeting for work in a few months for 4 days. I've asked him not to go, but he says it's expected of him. I can't go because we can't afford it and we don't have anyone to watch the kids. How should I handle situations like this that go against our EPs, but we don't have a choice?

I've highlighted the problem in red. He says. It's not that he doesn't have a choice, but he will not stand up and say "No, I will not go without my wife."

He's not on board with this program.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 09:33 PM
It's just expected for his position. People in his position don't just not go. This would be a first, so I don't know what the outcome would be.

I just lost my job though. We would be totally screwed if he lost his.

He has not told his boss about the A. I think he should though...or maybe I should?

Yes, I believe him. He forwarded the invite and itinerary. I would also ask for copies of tickets, receipts, etc. He already knows that.

The last time he had a business meeting was just after we started Marriage Builders. It went fine until he didn't answer his phone one evening. Then I freaked. It was the worst night since d-day.

Just the thought of him going to this thing triggers me and makes me feel bad. I'm trying to get him to find a way to let me go along. He said he would try. If I can't go along, do I tell his boss about the A or give my H an ultimatum? What do you think?
Great work with getting the invite and itinerary etc...

His side of why he must go/you cant sounds very weak to be honest

'Im expected to' - or what?

'I'll try' - TRY????!!!

Tell him you expect to either go along or for him to refuse to go. Even if it means losing his job. Reiterate that his going will be a very bad trigger for you and it is unacceptable. That your recovery will be damaged.

Your h is supposed to be a repentant former wayward who would do anything to avoid triggering you or hurting your feelings again.

If he gets wishy washy and refuses to be pinned, I would see that as a big redflag
In that circumstance I would let him go but would secretly put a GPS in the car and get a PI to check him out while he's away too.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 09:45 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
H has to go to a regional meeting for work in a few months for 4 days. I've asked him not to go, but he says it's expected of him. I can't go because we can't afford it and we don't have anyone to watch the kids. How should I handle situations like this that go against our EPs, but we don't have a choice?

I've highlighted the problem in red. He says. It's not that he doesn't have a choice, but he will not stand up and say "No, I will not go without my wife."

He's not on board with this program.

I just got this email from my H: "Technically I don�t think you can go with, but maybe that�s what we�ll have to do."

What do you think? Is he on board? If not, what do I do now?
Please keep in mind that the recent threesome has helped him erase quite a bit of guilt. (If SHE can do it etc..) The guilt helps keep him on track. I would not be ok with this trip at all.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 09:46 PM
Quote
I just lost my job though. We would be totally screwed if he lost his.
You'll be even more screwed if he won't protect your marriage.
He can get another job. He can't get another you.

Quote
Just the thought of him going to this thing triggers me and makes me feel bad. I'm trying to get him to find a way to let me go along. He said he would try.

He'd better do more than try. He'd better DO.
This is non-negotiable.
You don't negotiate EPs.

I've traveled with my husband on business trips. You share a hotel room. You split meals. It doesn't cost that much more than him going alone.

You either both go, or both stay. If he insists on going alone, then he's not willing to protect your marriage and he's gone.
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
H has to go to a regional meeting for work in a few months for 4 days. I've asked him not to go, but he says it's expected of him. I can't go because we can't afford it and we don't have anyone to watch the kids. How should I handle situations like this that go against our EPs, but we don't have a choice?

I've highlighted the problem in red. He says. It's not that he doesn't have a choice, but he will not stand up and say "No, I will not go without my wife."

He's not on board with this program.

I just got this email from my H: "Technically I don’t think you can go with, but maybe that’s what we’ll have to do."

What do you think? Is he on board? If not, what do I do now?


Maybe isnt good enough. He needs to declare hes going with you or not at all - to you and his boss.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 09:50 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
His side of why he must go/you cant sounds very weak to be honest

'Im expected to' - or what?

It's expected for his position. All managers go to the regional managers meeting. I work (or worked) at the same company, so I know how what's expected. People don't just "not go" unless there is a very good reason. My H would have to tell his boss and his boss's boss why he can't go and they would have to decide if the reason is good enough. That's why I'm thinking if they don't let him bring me along, he's going to have to tell them about his A.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 09:54 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
You either both go, or both stay. If he insists on going alone, then he's not willing to protect your marriage and he's gone.

Gulp. Ok, got it. I'll send him this via email and let you know. Fingers crossed.
Be brave. You wont compromise your standards or your marriage.
Porn. Must. Go.

You are both exhibiting symptoms of extended and elevated use of hyper-stimulating erotica;


Quote
How can porn cause sexual performance trouble?

The cause appears to be physiological, not psychological, given that such diverse men change only one variable (porn use), yet report a similar recovery pattern. For these men, anxiety is secondary.

Recent behavioral addiction research suggests that the loss of libido and performance occur because heavy users are numbing their brain's normal response to pleasure. Years of overriding the natural limits of libido with intense stimulation desensitize the user's response to a neurochemical called dopamine.

Dopamine is behind motivation, "wanting" and all addictions. It drives the search for rewards. We get little spurts of it every time we bump into anything potentially rewarding, novel, surprising, or even anxiety-producing.

Animal models have established that both sexual desire and erections arise from dopamine signals. Normally, dopamine-producing nerve cells in the reward circuitry activate the sexual (libido) centers of the hypothalamus, which in turn activate the erection centers in the spinal cord, which send nerve impulses to the genitalia. A steady stream of nerve impulses, which release nitric oxide into the penis and its blood vessels, maintain an erection.

Nitric oxide in turn stimulates the blood vessel dilator cGMP, the on/off switch for engorgement and erection. The more cGMP is available the more durable the erection. So, the pathway from the brain to an erection is:


Don't let the focus on erection fool you, the physiology is not that different;

Quote
The relevance of recent addiction brain science

In the last decade or so, addiction researchers have discovered that too much dopamine stimulation has a paradoxical effect. The brain decreases its ability to respond to dopamine signals (desensitization). This occurs with all addictions, both chemical and natural. In some porn users, the response to dopamine is dropping so low that they can't achieve an erection without constant hits of dopamine via the Internet.

Erotic words, pictures and videos have been around a long while, but the Internet makes possible a never-ending stream of dopamine spikes. Today's users can force its release by watching porn in multiple windows, searching endlessly, fast-forwarding to the bits they find hottest, switching to live sex chat, viewing constant novelty, firing up their mirror neurons with video action and cam-2-cam, or escalating to extreme genres and anxiety-producing material. It's all free, easy to access, available within seconds, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Overstimulation of the reward circuitry in the brain is a very real possibility today.

Many men don't realize their brain's sensitivity is declining toward normal sex because Internet erotica delivers endless dopamine hits�making erection and climax possible where normal encounters would not. When they try to have actual intercourse and cannot, they understandably panic.

The brain changes causing porn-induced erectile dysfunction arise from actual physical addiction processes (among them, numbing of the pleasure response of the brain). Quitting can therefore be quite challenging. In addition to an alarming temporary drop in libido, some men experience withdrawal symptoms: insomnia, irritability, panic, despair, concentration problems, and even flu-like symptoms. Finding a good counselor who understands addiction, and why today's porn has different effects from viewing a Playboy magazine, can be very helpful.

The brain needs a chance to "reboot," that is, return to normal dopamine sensitivity. This can take a couple of months. For a science teacher's explanation of the science behind porn-related erectile dysfunction, see this video presentation: Erectile Dysfunction and Porn.

Most men are astonished to learn that pornography use can be a source of sexual performance problems. Instead, many are becoming convinced that ED at twenty-something is normal. They are amazed that heavy porn use can affect them adversely, that no one told them it could affect them, and that humans have actually masturbated without porn. There is almost total ignorance about the significance for porn users of the recent discoveries of addiction science.


I would quit side-stepping and dancing around the fact that you have both formed a habit that has become destructive to one of only 4 intimate emotional needs. A need that, when met, creates romantic love.

I agree HHH, I think it desensitises women too, makes them unable to climax as easily if theyre used to being bombarded with fantasies/images and it become an excessive habit.

Its easy enough to go back to enjoying the simple things though! Which are really the best. In just the same way that a little black dress is better than head to toe whistles, bells ribons and colors.

Hbd has already agreed to cool it though and give each other more one on one focus...
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 10:33 PM
Ok, here is the email I sent my H:

You remember watching that video about affairs on the computer? Dr. Harley said that in order for our marriage to recover, you needed to give me "just compensation." Part of "just compensation" was ending the affair and all contact with your affair partner. But, I was also supposed to establish "Extraordinary Precautions" that you would need to meet in order to compensate me for the pain caused and to make me feel safe staying with you. Although we discussed those precautions, I don't think I ever gave them to you in writing and you need a reminder, so here they are:

1. Protect me and my feelings above all else.
2. Absolutely no contact with your affair partner.
3. Make all phone, email, and texting information available to me.
4. No sharing personal information with females unless I am by your side.
5. No one-on-one meetings with anyone of the opposite sex.
6. No going out drinking with friends if females will be present.
7. No overnight stays away from me.
8. Use the policy of joint agreement (POJA) as a basis for all decisions.
9. Be open and honest with me at all times.
10. Commit to at least 15 hours of undivided attention with me to meet each other�s emotional needs every week
11. Anytime you think, �I don�t want you to know about��.�, call me immediately and tell me.
12. Continually work on our relationship with discussions and relationship books.
13. Avoid porn and self stimulation

These precautions are not negotiable as they are supposed to be compensation for the pain that has been caused by your affairs and to protect me from more pain.

As you can see, overnight stays without me would go against the precautions, so you cannot go on the trip without me. Either we both go, or both stay. In my opinion, if you go alone, then you are not willing to protect me. The "just compensation" needed to fix the damage of the affair would not be fulfilled and our marriage will not survive.

So are you on board with our marriage recovery program or not?

If so, you will need to do whatever is necessary to comply with the extraordinary precautions, including telling your boss about your affairs.

I love you. I hope you choose me and our marriage. Please print this and bring it home, so you have the list whenever you need it.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/02/11 10:34 PM
Yes, we are going to cool it on the porn. Thanks for the info HHH.
Good letter to hubby.


The book recommendation I made will help you see when the justifications begin, and point you in the right direction for shining a light on the behaviors of self-betrayals.


When I read this book, it really helped me understand a great deal about human behavior

mostly my own smile


Seriously, it is written so that you can really capture that moment when you begin down that wrong path. It stops you dead in your tracks - you actually SEE that snap-moment when that bad decision actually begins to be made.

And you can actually STOP yourself before you start.


I have been able to lose over 50 pounds using this book, and nothing more. It is NOT a weight-loss book.

I have been able to stop worrying. It is not a stop-worry book.


I have been able to improve my driving. It has nothing to do with driving whatsoever.


I still need to stop cussing......sheesh.


I have actually nearly stopped all DJs. I stopped blurting out what I "felt" I just "had to say".


Talk about an improvement in self-control. Because I can SEE that moment.

Now, if only I could get OTHER PEOPLE to see their own moments. smile



SB
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 01:21 AM
H still hasn't responded to my email. I called him at work to ask why and he says he's too busy right now. I said, "you can't take three minutes to read the email and commit either way?" He said, "well, I wanted to read it and think things through." I said "either you are in or out." He said "whatever."
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 01:22 AM
Now what?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 03:06 PM
So H called me last night on his way home all pissed off that I was making demands and yelling at him while he was at work. He says they are so busy and everyone is working overtime and his wife is emailing and calling and making all kinds of demands. He says it was inconsiderate of me to try and discuss our relationship stuff while he was at work. He was a total ahole.

Then when he got home, he saw that I was crying and he immediately changed his tone. We talked all night about what we were going to do. He says he can see things from my perspective and he wants to comply with my EPs. He says he is going to talk to his boss today. He is going to tell him about the A and that he cannot go on the trip.

I asked him why he was so mad before and he said, "Let's say you are walking across the street concentrating on your phone or something and someone runs up to you and pushes you to the ground. At first, you get angry and yell at the person for pushing you. But, then you notice that there was a bus coming down the street that would have hit you if the person hadn't pushed you to the ground. So, you become grateful and thank them instead."

Anyway, I'm really nervous about what is going to happen today. My H could lose his job for having an affair in the workplace and for not being able to complete the duties his job requires.

By the end of the day, we could both be jobless and broke with two kids to support.



Even if he "has" to go on this trip, there is no reason why you can't go, too. You are an adult woman and can go anywhere you want to go. The idea that the company says wives can't go is wrong; all it means is that the company won't PAY for a spouse to go.

Yes, you'll have to pay for your expenses, but since he will be in a hotel room, it shouldn't cost anything extra for you to stay in the same room. If he's driving, it shouldn't cost anything extra for you to ride with him. If he's flying, yes, you will have to pay for your ticket. Yes, you will have to pay for your meals. Yes, you will have to arrange care for your children. However, that will all be much cheaper than a divorce!

Since this event appears to be coming up in a few months, cut back on your expenses and start putting aside money for your share of the trip.

Since you're short on funds, you can amuse yourself while he's in business meetings. You can go sightseeing, take books with you to read, take knitting/crochet work with you, etc.

You and your H can enjoy each other during his down-time. If a company doesn't care if a man spends time with skanks during his down-time, then it darned sure shouldn't care if a man spends his downtime with his wife!
Originally Posted by hbd
Anyway, I'm really nervous about what is going to happen today. My H could lose his job for having an affair in the workplace and for not being able to complete the duties his job requires.

hbd, you probably addressed this earlier, but he doesn't still work with the OW, does he?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 04:25 PM
Originally Posted by Lady_Clueless
Even if he "has" to go on this trip, there is no reason why you can't go, too. You are an adult woman and can go anywhere you want to go. The idea that the company says wives can't go is wrong; all it means is that the company won't PAY for a spouse to go.

Yes, you'll have to pay for your expenses, but since he will be in a hotel room, it shouldn't cost anything extra for you to stay in the same room. If he's driving, it shouldn't cost anything extra for you to ride with him. If he's flying, yes, you will have to pay for your ticket. Yes, you will have to pay for your meals. Yes, you will have to arrange care for your children. However, that will all be much cheaper than a divorce!

Since this event appears to be coming up in a few months, cut back on your expenses and start putting aside money for your share of the trip.

Since you're short on funds, you can amuse yourself while he's in business meetings. You can go sightseeing, take books with you to read, take knitting/crochet work with you, etc.

You and your H can enjoy each other during his down-time. If a company doesn't care if a man spends time with skanks during his down-time, then it darned sure shouldn't care if a man spends his downtime with his wife!

This is supposed to be a "team building" event. Spouses are not allowed. All team members are to stay together "on-site." All activities, meals, everything is to be done together as a "team." They will even have shared rooms. Team members are not allowed to stay "off-site" either. Managers that live just miles from the event are not even allowed to stay at home.

If I do go, I would have to pay for the plane ticket, another hotel room, and sneak around the whole time trying not to be seen. I think the best choice in this situation is for him to simply not go.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 04:28 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
hbd, you probably addressed this earlier, but he doesn't still work with the OW, does he?

No, he works in a totally different department now. They work in totally different buildings with no chance of seeing each other or coming in contact in any way.

He would get fired as a result of his affair with her if his boss knew. I told my H to tell his boss about the affair, but not tell him it was someone at work. That should keep him from getting fired.
Quote
Anyway, I'm really nervous about what is going to happen today. My H could lose his job for having an affair in the workplace and for not being able to complete the duties his job requires.


Unfortunately those are the consequences of his actions. Cannot save someone from those....and very well shouldn't in all reality.

Quote
By the end of the day, we could both be jobless and broke with two kids to support.


Again, unfortunate but that is what happens.

I would suggest actively searching for another job. His sins are gonna find him out...eventually.

committed
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 04:34 PM
Quote
This is supposed to be a "team building" event. Spouses are not allowed. All team members are to stay together "on-site." All activities, meals, everything is to be done together as a "team." They will even have shared rooms. Team members are not allowed to stay "off-site" either. Managers that live just miles from the event are not even allowed to stay at home.
With these kinds of company events, it sounds like getting fired may be the best thing that could happen for you ...
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 04:36 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
This is supposed to be a "team building" event. Spouses are not allowed. All team members are to stay together "on-site." All activities, meals, everything is to be done together as a "team." They will even have shared rooms. Team members are not allowed to stay "off-site" either. Managers that live just miles from the event are not even allowed to stay at home.
With these kinds of company events, it sounds like getting fired may be the best thing that could happen for you ...

Agreed. He would never find anything comperable though right now and I'm going to have a very hard time finding a job in my field right now too.
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
This is supposed to be a "team building" event. Spouses are not allowed. All team members are to stay together "on-site." All activities, meals, everything is to be done together as a "team." They will even have shared rooms. Team members are not allowed to stay "off-site" either. Managers that live just miles from the event are not even allowed to stay at home.
With these kinds of company events, it sounds like getting fired may be the best thing that could happen for you ...

Agreed. He would never find anything comperable though right now and I'm going to have a very hard time finding a job in my field right now too.

Is he looking? If they work at the same company how will he avoid seeing her? And if she works there, he could easily see her at work by going to her building or vice versa.
Quote
This is supposed to be a "team building" event. Spouses are not allowed. All team members are to stay together "on-site." All activities, meals, everything is to be done together as a "team." They will even have shared rooms. Team members are not allowed to stay "off-site" either. Managers that live just miles from the event are not even allowed to stay at home.


Ohmigosh, those are terrible functions. I went through the Ropes courses myself at my last company and they are such a set up for affairs. It is just amazing this is still going on. You know how our first course was kicked off? GROUP HUGS!
Posted By: Scotland Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 05:17 PM
If his A happened at the workplace why didn't YOU tell them that it happened?

And, why would you show your WH that it is OKAY to lie?

Personally, I would send the exposure to his workplace myself.

Seriously, how do you KNOW that he doesn't ever see OW? Would there ever be a chance that they read an email the other has sent? Maybe even be in on a conference call together?

What you are doing here is allowing your WH to skirt around his consequences.

I still see a lot ot wayward behaviour from him, and now I see why, he is still a wayward, and will continue to be so until his actions have real consequences.

Are you even certain that this affair didn't just go further underground?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 05:19 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
This is supposed to be a "team building" event. Spouses are not allowed. All team members are to stay together "on-site." All activities, meals, everything is to be done together as a "team." They will even have shared rooms. Team members are not allowed to stay "off-site" either. Managers that live just miles from the event are not even allowed to stay at home.
With these kinds of company events, it sounds like getting fired may be the best thing that could happen for you ...

Agreed. He would never find anything comperable though right now and I'm going to have a very hard time finding a job in my field right now too.

Is he looking? If they work at the same company how will he avoid seeing her? And if she works there, he could easily see her at work by going to her building or vice versa.

Her building is 10 miles away from his...totally different departments (she's in mortgage collections, he's in auto loan underwriting). They have no chance of seeing each other or having any contact at all unless they contact each other on purpose.
Just thinking out loud here. I hope your H's discussion with his boss will get him out of this, but that would not have worked at my old company. It was not optional. And if a person did refuse, they would have viewed as someone who was not willing to grow with the company. Our participation was part and parcel of our performance appraisals.


The other glaring problem I see that a) his company environment leads to affairs and b) the company trips are an opportunity to hook up with the OW.

How do you know the OW works in another building and has not been included on these company trips? My point is that if your H wanted to continue his affair at work he would just lie about all this. This might be why you have an uneasy feeling about his truthfulness.
Posted By: Scotland Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 05:22 PM
Quote
This might be why you have an uneasy feeling about his truthfulness.

And the fact that she encourages him to be deceitful when he needs to be to protect himself.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 05:27 PM
Originally Posted by Scotland
If his A happened at the workplace why didn't YOU tell them that it happened?

And, why would you show your WH that it is OKAY to lie?

Personally, I would send the exposure to his workplace myself.

Seriously, how do you KNOW that he doesn't ever see OW? Would there ever be a chance that they read an email the other has sent? Maybe even be in on a conference call together?

What you are doing here is allowing your WH to skirt around his consequences.

I still see a lot ot wayward behaviour from him, and now I see why, he is still a wayward, and will continue to be so until his actions have real consequences.

Are you even certain that this affair didn't just go further underground?

I didn't tell his workplace because he had already moved to a different department, so there was no need.

I didn't tell him to lie, I suggested that he not mention that the affair happened at work.

I work at the same company (Investments) and I never see either of them (she's in mortgage collections and he's in auto loan underwriting). This is a HUGE company. Each department is like a company in itself. There is no chance that they would ever see each other's emails or be on conference calls together.

I've been snooping a lot and found nothing to show that he is still in contact with her. I'm very on top of snooping. Don't worry. I even have access to his work email box. The only way he could be contacting her is on a pay phone at a gas station or something like that.
Originally Posted by hbd
[

Her building is 10 miles away from his...totally different departments (she's in mortgage collections, he's in auto loan underwriting). They have no chance of seeing each other or having any contact at all unless they contact each other on purpose.

WEll, we have facilities that are anywhere from 25 miles to 300 miles away and I see many of those coworkers at various meetings. Or they could just be attending a meeting at my building and I see them in the hallway. I work for a large company [250,000 employees] and I see people from different facilities, from different departments all the time. I get emails every day that include hundreds or thousands of employees in different locations.

I am not trying to scare you, but have you taken all these factors into consideration?

If your H's company has a no fraternization policy that would cause him to lose his job if they found out about the affair, why wait until they do find out? It has been my experience with workplace affairs that everyone usually knows and it eventually comes out.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 05:28 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Quote
This is supposed to be a "team building" event. Spouses are not allowed. All team members are to stay together "on-site." All activities, meals, everything is to be done together as a "team." They will even have shared rooms. Team members are not allowed to stay "off-site" either. Managers that live just miles from the event are not even allowed to stay at home.


Ohmigosh, those are terrible functions. I went through the Ropes courses myself at my last company and they are such a set up for affairs. It is just amazing this is still going on. You know how our first course was kicked off? GROUP HUGS!

Exactly why he shouldn't go even if I go along!
Posted By: Scotland Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 05:30 PM
hbd, you are trying to split hairs here. You DID tell your WH to LIE. You told him to omit a very important detail. With your recent answer, I am OUT.

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 05:33 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by hbd
[

Her building is 10 miles away from his...totally different departments (she's in mortgage collections, he's in auto loan underwriting). They have no chance of seeing each other or having any contact at all unless they contact each other on purpose.

WEll, we have facilities that are anywhere from 25 miles to 300 miles away and I see many of those coworkers at various meetings. Or they could just be attending a meeting at my building and I see them in the hallway. I work for a large company [250,000 employees] and I see people from different facilities, from different departments all the time. I get emails every day that include hundreds or thousands of employees in different locations.

I am not trying to scare you, but have you taken all these factors into consideration?

If your H's company has a no fraternization policy that would cause him to lose his job if they found out about the affair, why wait until they do find out? It has been my experience with workplace affairs that everyone usually knows and it eventually comes out.

I would be worried if they were in the same group, but she in the mortgage group and he's in the auto group. There's no chance of any contact. EVER.

Believe me, I've thought about this and the only reason I'm okay with this situation is because I worked at the same company in a different group and never come into contact with people from other groups.

Don't worry, the only possible contact they would have is if they contacted each other on purpose...and I would find out about that.
Posted By: markos Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 05:41 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by hbd
[

Her building is 10 miles away from his...totally different departments (she's in mortgage collections, he's in auto loan underwriting). They have no chance of seeing each other or having any contact at all unless they contact each other on purpose.

WEll, we have facilities that are anywhere from 25 miles to 300 miles away and I see many of those coworkers at various meetings. Or they could just be attending a meeting at my building and I see them in the hallway. I work for a large company [250,000 employees] and I see people from different facilities, from different departments all the time. I get emails every day that include hundreds or thousands of employees in different locations.

I am not trying to scare you, but have you taken all these factors into consideration?

If your H's company has a no fraternization policy that would cause him to lose his job if they found out about the affair, why wait until they do find out? It has been my experience with workplace affairs that everyone usually knows and it eventually comes out.

Every day when I type names into my email program on my company computer, names are suggested to me to "auto-complete" what I am typing. This reminds me of people I know of by name only, people I've known who are not in this area, etc. Sometimes I even send to these people by accident. This is at a relatively small company.

If I had had an affair with one of them I would potentially be triggered to remember her every time I sent an email as part of my job.
Originally Posted by hbd
[
I would be worried if they were in the same group, but she in the mortgage group and he's in the auto group. There's no chance of any contact. EVER.

How do you know she wasn't invited to this team building trip?
I ask because there were 800 people attending my first, of many, Ropes courses. They were from different locations and departments across the nation.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 05:46 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Just thinking out loud here. I hope your H's discussion with his boss will get him out of this, but that would not have worked at my old company. It was not optional. And if a person did refuse, they would have viewed as someone who was not willing to grow with the company. Our participation was part and parcel of our performance appraisals.


The other glaring problem I see that a) his company environment leads to affairs and b) the company trips are an opportunity to hook up with the OW.

How do you know the OW works in another building and has not been included on these company trips? My point is that if your H wanted to continue his affair at work he would just lie about all this. This might be why you have an uneasy feeling about his truthfulness.

The trip is not optional, he will definitely be seen as someone that is not willing to grow with the company. If he doesn't get fired today, he will at the very least get written up or seen as a worthless employee and get poor evaluations.

I often look ow up on the company employee directory. She still works in collections in a building 10 miles from his. Totally different group. She is actually closer to where I work and I never see her. There is no possible way she would be included in anything his group does.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 05:48 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by hbd
[
I would be worried if they were in the same group, but she in the mortgage group and he's in the auto group. There's no chance of any contact. EVER.

How do you know she wasn't invited to this team building trip?

It is for managers in the auto loan group. She is a lowly collector for mortgage. No chance.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 06:03 PM
Originally Posted by Scotland
Personally, I would send the exposure to his workplace myself.

Okay, if he doesn't tell his boss about the A today, I will send his boss an email myself.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 06:30 PM
Originally Posted by markos
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by hbd
[

Her building is 10 miles away from his...totally different departments (she's in mortgage collections, he's in auto loan underwriting). They have no chance of seeing each other or having any contact at all unless they contact each other on purpose.

WEll, we have facilities that are anywhere from 25 miles to 300 miles away and I see many of those coworkers at various meetings. Or they could just be attending a meeting at my building and I see them in the hallway. I work for a large company [250,000 employees] and I see people from different facilities, from different departments all the time. I get emails every day that include hundreds or thousands of employees in different locations.

I am not trying to scare you, but have you taken all these factors into consideration?

If your H's company has a no fraternization policy that would cause him to lose his job if they found out about the affair, why wait until they do find out? It has been my experience with workplace affairs that everyone usually knows and it eventually comes out.

Every day when I type names into my email program on my company computer, names are suggested to me to "auto-complete" what I am typing. This reminds me of people I know of by name only, people I've known who are not in this area, etc. Sometimes I even send to these people by accident. This is at a relatively small company.

If I had had an affair with one of them I would potentially be triggered to remember her every time I sent an email as part of my job.

That is possible and we have talked extensively about triggers. He says he has trained his brain to redirect his thoughts to me and my pain when he is triggered with thoughts of her.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 06:45 PM
I should also say that I also know my H and OW haven't been in contact because I have been keeping close tabs on her as well.

I know where she has been and when. I'm not going to say how I know this because it might be illegal and it's highly unethical, but I know that she hasn't been anywhere near my H's work.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 06:57 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
I should also say that I also know my H and OW haven't been in contact because I have been keeping close tabs on her as well.

I know where she has been and when. I'm not going to say how I know this because it might be illegal and it's highly unelical, but I know that she hasn't been anywhere near my H's work.

If it turns out he has to go on the trip to Denver, I'll also know if she is near him there. Again, I'm not going to say how I will know, but I will know with 100% accuracy.
Quote
I work at the same company (Investments) and I never see either of them (she's in mortgage collections and he's in auto loan underwriting).


I thought you said that you lost your job?

See...it is things like this that make me question the authenticity of the poster.

I suffer from "Dust Kitty" syndrome.

committed
Quote
Believe me, I've thought about this and the only reason I'm okay with this situation is because I worked at the same company in a different group and never come into contact with people from other groups.


Wait...a few posts later and you are back to not working.

And...No...I don't believe you.

Therefore....bowing out and moving on.

committed
Same here. If you're going to lie, at least do it consistently.
I, too, wondered about the working vs not working issue, but didn'twant to split hairs.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 07:48 PM
I've been given a 90 day "working notice." My last day is October 14th.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 07:50 PM
Surely your husband can find another job by October 14.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 07:50 PM

Huh?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 07:50 PM
Why would I lie on this forum? I'm here for help. Lying would defeat the whole purpose of being here.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 07:51 PM
Sorry -- "I just lost my job" on page 17. ?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 07:52 PM
Originally Posted by Surfer88
Huh?

lol. My whole department is being closed. We were all given 90 days notice. 150 people.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 07:58 PM
Originally Posted by Surfer88
Sorry -- "I just lost my job" on page 17. ?

I have lost my job. I get to work until October 14th, but I have still been laid off.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 08:00 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Surely your husband can find another job by October 14.

Maybe.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 08:02 PM
HBD,

This may be the case, but the page 17 statement isn't 100% true, is it? Splitting hairs? Nope, and here's why.

You stated this while explaining the financial impact your H's losing his job would have on you both. "You would be screwed". Not the whole truth is it? The whole truth is that you've got 90-days on payroll, so the true calamity isn't as great as you stated, correct?

Big deal around here, as you are finding out.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 08:05 PM
Originally Posted by Surfer88
HBD,

This may be the case, but the page 17 statement isn't 100% true, is it? Splitting hairs? Nope, and here's why.

You stated this while explaining the financial impact your H's losing his job would have on you both. "You would be screwed". Not the whole truth is it? The whole truth is that you've got 90-days on payroll, so the true calamity isn't as great as you stated, correct?

Big deal around here, as you are finding out.

It's still a calamity. Oct 14th will come quick. If neither of us are employed, we ARE screwed.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 08:11 PM
Well if you must know all of the exact details of the layoff, my whole department was given a 30 day "pre-notice" towards the end of July. On August 25, we will get a 60 day "notice." Of that 60 days, we will work 50 and not work for 10. So, I work until October 14th and get paid until the end of October.

Honestly, didn't think anyone would care to know all of the exact details of my layoff situation. The fact is, I have been laid off. As a result, I AM still screwed if my H is fired. We are barely making ends meet with both of our incomes as it is.

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 08:58 PM
First, I'm told you don't need irrelevant details (see page 13). Then, I don't give the irrelevant details and summarize something and I'm told that I'm lying.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 09:17 PM
You make it sound like if your husband gets fired today, all is lost.

Yet, if you're getting paid till the end of October, then you're not going to be out on the street tomorrow if your husband is fired today.

I don't think you were lying. But I do think you like the drama.

Your husband CAN get a job by the end of October, if he's not picky. He may not like the job, but he can put food on the table.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 09:18 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
We are barely making ends meet with both of our incomes as it is.

It also sounds like you're not living within your means.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 09:21 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
Well if you must know all of the exact details of the layoff, my whole department was given a 30 day "pre-notice" towards the end of July. On August 25, we will get a 60 day "notice." Of that 60 days, we will work 50 and not work for 10. So, I work until October 14th and get paid until the end of October.

Honestly, didn't think anyone would care to know all of the exact details of my layoff situation. The fact is, I have been laid off. As a result, I AM still screwed if my H is fired. We are barely making ends meet with both of our incomes as it is.

Also, I only work part time, so my paycheck is only a third of our total income. As a reuslt, my H being fired would be a much bigger impact. Not sure if you need that detail, but I wouldn't want to leave anything out and be called a liar.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 09:23 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
You make it sound like if your husband gets fired today, all is lost.

Yet, if you're getting paid till the end of October, then you're not going to be out on the street tomorrow if your husband is fired today.

I don't think you were lying. But I do think you like the drama.

Your husband CAN get a job by the end of October, if he's not picky. He may not like the job, but he can put food on the table.

Thanks Prisca. He can look. Jobs aren't easy to come by these days though.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 09:35 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Originally Posted by hbd
We are barely making ends meet with both of our incomes as it is.

It also sounds like you're not living within your means.

Yes, I have had a huge problem with spending since D-day (mostly me). For a while, I just went out and spent money to make myself feel better. At the time, I figured, well, we both have good jobs, we can afford this.

My H also scheduled a trip to Disneyworld a few months ago as a show of his commitment to the family. We put several thousand dollars down at the time. We could cancel and try to get that money back, but the kids would be devastated. That would be an option if he loses his job though, I guess.

Anyway, since I found out about being laid off, I have been working on my spending and we have established a budget. I guess it's too little too late though.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 09:52 PM
It's easy from the outside looking in to think, "What's the big deal?" But, from my perspective, the idea that both of us could be jobless is extremely scary.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 10:04 PM
Also, if he is fired, he won't be eligible for unemployment.

At least I'll get some unemployment. I will also get some severance from my employer. It won't be much though because I only work part time. I'm figuring that with severance and unemployment, we would be able to cover about a fifth of our expenses if my H is fired and can't find another job.

My boss is trying to find out from HR if I switch to working full time before the "notice" period starts if I could get the full time severance...which would be a HUGE difference.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 10:11 PM
I don't think any body is thinking "What's the big deal?"
Markos and I have been in tight financial situations -- feeding a family of 6 on $64 a week. One of those 6 people was an infant with a liver condition who required very expensive formula ($20 a can, 2-3 cans a week).

I understand being scared.

But you're still being over-dramatic. You're not going to be out on the street tomorrow. You're not going to starve. You'll probably have to cut way back on your expenses, and eat beans and rice for awhile. You may have to sell some things. But you will survive.

Your husband will find a job. You have a whole country to look in. And he's not bound to his particular field.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 10:24 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
I don't think any body is thinking "What's the big deal?"
Markos and I have been in tight financial situations -- feeding a family of 6 on $64 a week. One of those 6 people was an infant with a liver condition who required very expensive formula ($20 a can, 2-3 cans a week).

I understand being scared.

But you're still being over-dramatic. You're not going to be out on the street tomorrow. You're not going to starve. You'll probably have to cut way back on your expenses, and eat beans and rice for awhile. You may have to sell some things. But you will survive.

Your husband will find a job. You have a whole country to look in. And he's not bound to his particular field.

Thanks Prisca.

Yes, we will survive. There is no doubt about that and I'm sorry if I gave the impression that we would be out on the street or something.

We have had a really good standard of living. Nice home, nice cars, the best foods, etc. I guess I'm just feeling that it's not fair that the kids and I could lose all of this because of my H's stupid mistakes. It makes me feel so resentful and angry and sad for myself and my kids. If he just hadn't had an affair, we would be fine and wouldn't have to change our standard of living at all! It's just so unfair!

Another pity party, I know.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 10:43 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
If he just hadn't had an affair, we would be fine and wouldn't have to change our standard of living at all! It's just so unfair!

I just went back and reread this...you are right. I am a drama queen. lol
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 11:31 PM
Ugh! H didn't talk to his boss today. Says he was too busy. He did send his boss an email requesting to talk about the trip when he had a chance, and his boss replied stating they could meet tomorrow morning at 8:30. H forwarded the email to me.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 11:47 PM
And I'm too busy for cancer. Anywhoo...wrote this earlier.

You are in great hands with Prisca and many others. One thing amongst many that I've learned here at MBs is that, whether you are a WH, WW, BS, or none of the above but seeking counsel, there is little room for drama. Think about this: how often do you use or think words like

always
ruined
never
constantly
can't




You get the point. What MB will help you do is see a) where you are, and, b) how to get where you want to be regardless of the destination, provided that destination is a healthy one (meaning not continuing an A, etc.) You're already finding out by way of firehose that issues in your M are not limited to an A or any other behaviors in the M department, but the net cast is much bigger. Sound like bad news? No! Just the opposite, in fact.

An A or mutual indiscretions are inexcusable actions, yet fix-able symptoms.

You saw Prisca's (and others) response to the job situation. It's not that you �lied�, OK? Think about how YOU posted your situation, Ms. Drama. See? The reality is that the world will not crash around you, you will not fall into financial ruins, and you will not die. What you will be potentially is strapped for awhile. That's the reality from someone who financially ruined herself twice, never to do again.

Why �never to do again�? I have personal financial boundaries, and have for 8 years now. I tell every person I know without shame that I only pay cash now as I almost lost my house because of my poor money management and excessive credit card debt and living beyond my means in the past. (EXPOSURE!) In other words, I set up my own financial EPs for ME. I have people still to this day that call me on it...confusing a debit card with a credit card. Always a good laugh. I set up my own accountability measurement.

See the common message and strategy? This website is called MarriageBuilders, not �how to overcome an affair builders�. Overcoming affairs is only one aspect of the concepts here, but the concepts are consistent.

Keep posting, stick with it, and good luck.

Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/03/11 11:52 PM
And, if that doesn't happen? Or, he doesn't expose? Then what will you do?
hbd,

Sorry to hear about the job situation. FWIW, I don't consider what you posted as lying. Overreaction and panic, but not lying. A natural state, considering the situation you are facing, and the economic situation the world faces as well.


So, the advice I have for you is this: when you face a crisis or emergency, the best thing a person can do is


HAVE A PLAN.


As with MB, you have a plan in place to address the marital crisis. So it should go with the job crisis you face.


Anticipate perhaps that hubby may also face changing jobs, because if the affair happens to be exposed at work - and let's face it, someone ELSE might do this for you in the workplace (you might not be able to control this!). So, have a plan for that possibility, however remote you might think it is.


Sit down with him, talk about this, and discuss how the two of you will approach it. AS A TEAM. Because you are a team right now.


SB
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 02:24 AM
Quote
Ugh! H didn't talk to his boss today. Says he was too busy.
I'm not really surprised. I expected it, actually.

Quote
And I'm too busy for cancer.
QFT

What's your plan?
HBD,

I just have an idea for you. Why not start your own little company with your H and be your own employers. That will give you most needed time together and that is an excellent opportunity for true team building.

Think of what is your profession, what are your skills and what are your other interests/hobbies. With your H's you have plenty on the table. This double package might give you many ideas what your future company might sell.

In our country, starting your own business is real easy and not expensive at all.

Me and my H knew that our job situation would change in Aug-Sept this year and we really didn't want to continue as employees anymore. It took 2 months to brainstorm ideas, discuss and read things through and have our first agreements. You have that time at hand, too.



Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 03:45 PM
H disclosed everything about the A to his boss this morning! smile

His boss actually already knew because OW complained to HR about me harassing her via Facebook (when I exposed, I sent FB messages to her brother and some of her friends). HR looked into the situation by reviewing my H's emails. Since they found no continuing contact with OW, and he was no longer working with her, the issue was dropped. They didn't even tell my H or me that OW complained. They only told my H's boss. I'm guessing his boss was supposed to talk to him about it, but his boss never brought it up.

There is still a chance my H might get fired because his boss will need to confirm the affair to HR. I'm hoping HR will see that my H is trying to turn things around. Maybe he will just get a slap on wrist. We could use everyone's prayers about this.

Anyway, H's boss is ok with me going along on the trip. In fact, he said that I can go to any "employees only event" as well. He told my H to contact the travel management department to get me included in trip travel plans and that he would approve it. We just have to pay the difference.

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 03:52 PM
Originally Posted by Surfer88
And I'm too busy for cancer. Anywhoo...wrote this earlier.

You are in great hands with Prisca and many others. One thing amongst many that I've learned here at MBs is that, whether you are a WH, WW, BS, or none of the above but seeking counsel, there is little room for drama. Think about this: how often do you use or think words like

always
ruined
never
constantly
can't




You get the point. What MB will help you do is see a) where you are, and, b) how to get where you want to be regardless of the destination, provided that destination is a healthy one (meaning not continuing an A, etc.) You're already finding out by way of firehose that issues in your M are not limited to an A or any other behaviors in the M department, but the net cast is much bigger. Sound like bad news? No! Just the opposite, in fact.

An A or mutual indiscretions are inexcusable actions, yet fix-able symptoms.

You saw Prisca's (and others) response to the job situation. It's not that you �lied�, OK? Think about how YOU posted your situation, Ms. Drama. See? The reality is that the world will not crash around you, you will not fall into financial ruins, and you will not die. What you will be potentially is strapped for awhile. That's the reality from someone who financially ruined herself twice, never to do again.

Why �never to do again�? I have personal financial boundaries, and have for 8 years now. I tell every person I know without shame that I only pay cash now as I almost lost my house because of my poor money management and excessive credit card debt and living beyond my means in the past. (EXPOSURE!) In other words, I set up my own financial EPs for ME. I have people still to this day that call me on it...confusing a debit card with a credit card. Always a good laugh. I set up my own accountability measurement.

See the common message and strategy? This website is called MarriageBuilders, not �how to overcome an affair builders�. Overcoming affairs is only one aspect of the concepts here, but the concepts are consistent.

Keep posting, stick with it, and good luck.

Thanks Surfer!

Honestly, I never realized I was such a drama queen until I went back and reread some of my posts. lol

I have always had an anxiety problem and that might be causing some of my overreaction. I think I need to get back on my anxiety meds until this storm passes. I took one this morning and feel much better.

I don't mind the firehose. Although at first I get defensive, in the end it helps me see things that I wouldn't have seen otherwise. Does that make sense?

I will definitely keep posting. This site has been a miracle for our marriage and myself. Thanks!
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 04:03 PM
Originally Posted by schoolbus
hbd,

Sorry to hear about the job situation. FWIW, I don't consider what you posted as lying. Overreaction and panic, but not lying. A natural state, considering the situation you are facing, and the economic situation the world faces as well.


So, the advice I have for you is this: when you face a crisis or emergency, the best thing a person can do is


HAVE A PLAN.


As with MB, you have a plan in place to address the marital crisis. So it should go with the job crisis you face.


Anticipate perhaps that hubby may also face changing jobs, because if the affair happens to be exposed at work - and let's face it, someone ELSE might do this for you in the workplace (you might not be able to control this!). So, have a plan for that possibility, however remote you might think it is.


Sit down with him, talk about this, and discuss how the two of you will approach it. AS A TEAM. Because you are a team right now.


SB

Thanks SB!

Our plan right now is for me to try and get the full time severance through my work. My boss is working on that for me now. From what we can tell, if I switch back to full time before 8/22, then I can get the full time severance payment. That would be a difference of about $17,000 for someone that has been with the company for at least 10 years and I've been there 11.

If that doesn't work out, and my H does lose his job (which doesn't appear that likely now) our plan is to just cut expenses and spending. We may have to sell our house as a last resort. We are lucky enough to have some equity in our home that could cover us for a while.

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 04:07 PM
Originally Posted by Mrs_Recon6mo
HBD,

I just have an idea for you. Why not start your own little company with your H and be your own employers. That will give you most needed time together and that is an excellent opportunity for true team building.

Think of what is your profession, what are your skills and what are your other interests/hobbies. With your H's you have plenty on the table. This double package might give you many ideas what your future company might sell.

In our country, starting your own business is real easy and not expensive at all.

Me and my H knew that our job situation would change in Aug-Sept this year and we really didn't want to continue as employees anymore. It took 2 months to brainstorm ideas, discuss and read things through and have our first agreements. You have that time at hand, too.

Thanks Mrs. Recon!

I like that idea! Especially if I can get the full time severance through my work. I can use that money towards my business.

I'm thinking about starting a freelance editing business. My current job is an investments principal (series 9/10 licensed). I review and sign off on broker written correspondence with clients (in the investment industry, all written correspondence with the public must be reviewed and approved), so editing wouldn't be that much of a stretch. What do you all think?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 08:38 PM
I just realized...OW was trying to get ME and my H fired when she went to HR.

First, she tried to steal my life. Then, when that didn't work out, she tried to sabotage my life instead. What kind of person does that? Unbelievable. I can't believe my H found her remotely appealing.
Posted By: Neak Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 08:51 PM
If your husband doesn't find a job soon enough, consider moving to an area that is in a boom.

Williston, ND is one example. Because of the oil field, there are jobs everywhere, both in the oil field itself, and in all the supporting industries. The big problem is finding housing, but if you can resolve that, the jobs are there.

That's just one example. The country still has plenty of places that are growing, and looking for people to work there.
Originally Posted by hbd
I asked him why he was so mad before and he said, "Let's say you are walking across the street concentrating on your phone or something and someone runs up to you and pushes you to the ground. At first, you get angry and yell at the person for pushing you. But, then you notice that there was a bus coming down the street that would have hit you if the person hadn't pushed you to the ground. So, you become grateful and thank them instead."


I love this analogy, think he's really starting to get it. That's all thanks to you setting healthy boundaries, insisting on protection and being honest about how much it means to you.

It helps me realise should I ever be in a position to do recovery with my h, that I will need to be tough.

Then the risky honesty with the boss and it tuns out he knew all along!!!

Honesty really is the best policy isn't it?

You both still have a long way to go but I think you deserve a little clap for putting great advice into practice. Keep it up..
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 09:28 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
I just realized...OW was trying to get ME and my H fired when she went to HR.

First, she tried to steal my life. Then, when that didn't work out, she tried to sabotage my life instead. What kind of person does that? Unbelievable. I can't believe my H found her remotely appealing.

She truly thinks she is entitled to sleep with my husband, but I'm not entitled to tell people about it. It's taking everything in me not to call her and tell her off.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 09:33 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
Originally Posted by hbd
I asked him why he was so mad before and he said, "Let's say you are walking across the street concentrating on your phone or something and someone runs up to you and pushes you to the ground. At first, you get angry and yell at the person for pushing you. But, then you notice that there was a bus coming down the street that would have hit you if the person hadn't pushed you to the ground. So, you become grateful and thank them instead."


I love this analogy, think he's really starting to get it. That's all thanks to you setting healthy boundaries, insisting on protection and being honest about how much it means to you.

It helps me realise should I ever be in a position to do recovery with my h, that I will need to be tough.

Then the risky honesty with the boss and it tuns out he knew all along!!!

Honesty really is the best policy isn't it?

You both still have a long way to go but I think you deserve a little clap for putting great advice into practice. Keep it up..

I know, I love that analogy too. It brought tears to my eyes when he said it.

I think his boss didn't believe OW or something because he never said anything to my H. But, when my H told him he had the affair, his boss said, "Was it OW?" My H says he just about died.

Thanks for the support Indiegirl.
My OW is the same, sometimes I roll around laughing thinking of how pathetic she is.

Calling her would take away your superiority and dignity. I get why you want to though.

Think of her evil little screwed up face when she was trying to get her revenge on you with HR. Pitiful.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 09:34 PM
Quote
You both still have a long way to go but I think you deserve a little clap for putting great advice into practice. Keep it up..
hurray
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 09:34 PM
Originally Posted by Neak
If your husband doesn't find a job soon enough, consider moving to an area that is in a boom.

Williston, ND is one example. Because of the oil field, there are jobs everywhere, both in the oil field itself, and in all the supporting industries. The big problem is finding housing, but if you can resolve that, the jobs are there.

That's just one example. The country still has plenty of places that are growing, and looking for people to work there.

Thanks Neak.

I'd hate to move because my kids love it here and they have tons of friends, but that's always an option if we can't find any jobs here.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/04/11 09:40 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
My OW is the same, sometimes I roll around laughing thinking of how pathetic she is.

Calling her would take away your superiority and dignity. I get why you want to though.

Think of her evil little screwed up face when she was trying to get her revenge on you with HR. Pitiful.

Thanks. She IS pitiful.

I love your tag line BTW!

"She may be after my life and my hairdo but she's still a tacky loser"
really, she is laugh
hbd,


One thing you need to remember about your affairs - both you and your hubby - is that the affairs are not about the affair partners, or about your spouses. The affairs really are about you, yourself.

Try not to focus too much on the OW in your recovery. I know it is hard to do that (been there, done that), but try anyway. The OW could have been anyone, from anywhere. She was not, and is not, special.


SB
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/06/11 08:28 PM
Good news! My boss was able to approve my switch to full time before the official layoff notice period begins. As a result, I should be eligible to receive the full time severance payment!

IMO I should receive the full time severance anyway because I worked full-time for six years (until my second daughter was born), and I had always planned to go back to full time when she started kindergarten (which she starts on 9/6). I'm just starting back a few weeks earlier than my original plan.

We have also been able to work out the specifics of my H's business trip. My MIL is coming to watch the kids and H's boss has approved our travel arrangements.

I'm lucky to have such a great MIL. She supports me so much and is always
checking up on H. She was so mad at him about the A because her first H (my H's Dad) cheated on her and married his OW.

Everything seems to be working out. Keeping my fingers crossed.
Sounds good, keep on track..
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/18/11 09:43 PM
Ugh!!

H's boat trip has been rescheduled due to bad weather, so we are going through the whole argument again.

He says he is expected to go because he's the manager and he doesn't want to cancel again. He doesn't understand what the big deal is because it's only three hours long and he will come right home after it's over. He says he'll wear a VAR so I know he's there and I can hear everything said. He also says he won't drink, so he feels that technically it's not going against our EPs.

I'm so frustrated. He still doesn't get it and I don't know how to get him to see things from my perspective. Maybe I'm overreacting. I don't know. Advice?

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/18/11 09:59 PM
I just sent this email to my H at work:

"I have to be honest, I'm still not happy about this. I tried to be happy about our compromise, but I'm honestly not and I need to be upfront with you about how I'm feeling.

Regardless of whether you use a recorder, I don't understand why it's so important for you to go on the boat trip. It looks optional according to the email and it can't possibly be that big of a deal. It really bothers me that avoiding disappointing your boss is somehow more important to you than protecting my feelings. It makes me feel that I'm always going to be #2 to your job.

That being said, I do see everything that you are doing to make our relationship better. Your love bank in my heart has grown so much as a result of your efforts that I cannot get enough of you! But, you should know that your need to make everyone else happy at my expense, and your lack of trying to understand my fear and pain, has taken HUGE love bank withdrawals out of my love bank for you. I think you should know this before all of the hard work you have done to fill my love bank is ruined. I'm not trying to threaten you or make demands, I just want you to know this before your love bank in my heart is empty."

He sent a reply saying "Thanks for being honest with me!" But, did not say he wouldn't go on the boat trip.
He has the list of EPs, he knows they're non negotiable. Presumably he's not comatose upstairs.

Just a short while back he was singing you all the right songs, showing commitment to paying you just compensation.
Because he saw you were serious.

However it appears what he was really thinking was: "give it a few weeks and she'll go back to being the 'old hbd' the one who can be convinced she is 'overreacting'.

Are you kidding me??!!

What happened to the whole 'It was like you were warning me that a bus was headed for me'. Yeah he didnt like you being firm at first with that one either did he?

If you dont have firm boundaries with this guy, he'll torpedo right through them all.

I see a big redflag

Keep your eyes on stalks, snoop extra hard and dont budge an inch on EPs. Dont give in to AOs either, he may be trying to provoke you into another stupid act to ease his guilt - just like he did with the threesome.

Just be a great, reasonable wife - with good boundaries on what she expects in a husband.

What is he so guilty about I wonder. He may just have poor boundaries and likes it that way though.
non�ne�go�tia�ble (nnn-gsh-bl, -sh--)
adj.
1. Difficult or impossible to settle by arbitration, mediation, or mutual concession: a nonnegotiable demand.
2. Nonmarketable
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/18/11 10:16 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
He has the list of EPs, he knows they're non negotiable.

He says it isn't against our EPs because the EP that applies (No going out drinking with friends if females will be present) involves drinking...and since he is not going to be drinking, it's not against our EPs (which is technically true).

Maybe I should change the EP to "no going out with friends." I don't think I want that either though...I want us both to have friends and I usually go out with my friends at least once a month.
Originally Posted by hbd
Although we discussed those precautions, I don't think I ever gave them to you in writing and you need a reminder, so here they are:

1. Protect me and my feelings above all else.
2. Absolutely no contact with your affair partner.
3. Make all phone, email, and texting information available to me.
4. No sharing personal information with females unless I am by your side.
5. No one-on-one meetings with anyone of the opposite sex.
6. No going out drinking with friends if females will be present.
7. No overnight stays away from me.
8. Use the policy of joint agreement (POJA) as a basis for all decisions.
9. Be open and honest with me at all times.
10. Commit to at least 15 hours of undivided attention with me to meet each other’s emotional needs every week
11. Anytime you think, “I don’t want you to know about…….”, call me immediately and tell me.
12. Continually work on our relationship with discussions and relationship books.
13. Avoid porn and self stimulation


So he's trying to lawyer you, eh? Nice.

What about number one? and number 8?

If you arent enthuiastic the decision should not be made, even when something isnt an EP, which this is.

If he needs the EPs need to be nailed on tighter, do it. Change the EPS to cover what is specifically bothering you about the trip? Is it the alcohol? The fact that the buddies are chauvenist pigs?

Did they support the A by the way?

Regardless, their company and drinking is not a great combination for a wayward.

Its sort of like a gambler going to meet a bunch of jockeys with inside knowledge.. Its not technically the track but its just too close for comfort to what feeds the addiction..
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/18/11 10:39 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
So he's trying to lawyer you, eh? Nice.

What about number one? and number 8?

If you arent enthuiastic the decision should not be made, even when something isnt an EP, which this is.

If he needs the EPs need to be nailed on tighter, do it. Change the EPS to cover what is specifically bothering you about the trip? Is it the alcohol? The fact that the buddies are chauvenist pigs?

Did they support the A by the way?

Regardless, their company and drinking is not a great combination for a wayward.

Its sort of like a gambler going to meet a bunch of jockeys with inside knowledge.. Its not technically the track but its just too close for comfort to what feeds the addiction..

Yeah, #1 is the EP I'm trying to enforce. We did POJA about it the other night. The compromise was for him to wear a VAR.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/18/11 10:59 PM
POJA does not include compromises. If you settled on a compromise that you are not happy about, then POJA didn't happen. And, if you were initially happy about it, but are no longer enthusiastic, then the answer is to do nothing until the two of you renegotiate. NOT continue with the original plans regardless of your feelings.

You're not happy about him going, therefore he doesn't go. Period.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/18/11 11:00 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
If he needs the EPs need to be nailed on tighter, do it. Change the EPS to cover what is specifically bothering you about the trip? Is it the alcohol? The fact that the buddies are chauvenist pigs?

Did they support the A by the way?

I thought the trip bothered me because I wouldn't know what he is doing. But, we POJA'd the VAR, so I would know what he's doing and it's still bothering me...so now I think it's just that I feel like I'm #2 to his work. It makes me feel like I'm not important to him, which hurts my feelings. Does that make sense, or am I being selfish?

His boss is the only one at work that knows about the A. He doesn't support it and told my H if he pulled anything like that again he'd be out on is A$$.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/18/11 11:03 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
POJA does not include compromises. If you settled on a compromise that you are not happy about, then POJA didn't happen. And, if you were initially happy about it, but are no longer enthusiastic, then the answer is to do nothing until the two of you renegotiate. NOT continue with the original plans regardless of your feelings.

You're not happy about him going, therefore he doesn't go. Period.

That's exactly what happened. I was happy about the VAR idea, but now I'm having second thoughts.
Boat trip = fun

That is the simple equation of it all.


It does not matter that it has to do with "work". You can put lipstick on a pig, and it is still a pig. The boat makes it a little more fun, and people are more inclined to relax, which is the INTENT.

They say and do things they are less likely to say or do at an office.

Which means: boundaries are LESSENED.


Which is why you are nervous about the "work" boat trip.


It does not take a rocket scientist to figure this out.


He wants to go because he wants to be in the environment where those boundaries with co-workers are DOWN.




You do not want him there for that exact reason.


Yoda says:

No POJA for bad situation.



Schoolbus
Originally Posted by hbd
I thought the trip bothered me because I wouldn't know what he is doing. But, we POJA'd the VAR, so I would know what he's doing and it's still bothering me...so now I think it's just that I feel like I'm #2 to his work. It makes me feel like I'm not important to him, which hurts my feelings. Does that make sense, or am I being selfish?


You've already answered your own question by sending him the info about the love bank. It is never selfish to tell your other half when they are hurting you. It helps them. You can change your mind about what hurts you too, telling him you have is part of beng radically honest.

If you give your giver too free a reign, he will just totally squander the love in your h's account.

Thats the beauty of POJA. You dont have to argue out who is 'right' who is 'wrong' who is 'selfish' or 'unselfish' - you keep going right past those distractions like an arrow bound for mutual agreement.

Dr H says:

The Policy of Joint Agreement also avoids the worst advice of our Giver and Taker. In the state of Intimacy, we are encouraged by our Giver to sacrifice our own happiness so that the other person can be happy. In the state of Conflict, we are encouraged by our Taker to let our spouses sacrifice so that we can be happy. Neither of these are worthy objectives because in both cases someone gets hurt
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/19/11 02:53 PM
Thanks all.

H came home very appreciative of me, hugging and kissing and trying to make me happy again. I asked him if he told his workers he would go on the boat trip and he said he didn't tell them anything "yet." I think he wants us to negotiate about it more, but I don't see anything that would make me happy with him going.

At the same time, I'm worried that me not letting him go will cause him to be resentful towards me. Isn't the POJA decision supposed to be something we are BOTH happy with? I'm happy with him not going, but he will be unhappy. So it's still not POJA because he isn't enthusiastic. This is so frustrating.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/19/11 04:47 PM
Originally Posted by Dr. Harley
There are two kinds of resentment: (1) Resentment due to something one of you DID to the other that was hurtful, and (2) resentment due to something you DIDN'T do for yourself that you would have liked, but would have hurt your spouse. Your husband has the first kind of resentment because you had an affair three months into your marriage. What you did hurt him. You have the second kind of resentment because you now feel obligated to avoid seeing a friend who is a threat to your husband.

I think you would agree with me that the first kind of resentment is the worst, because your husband knows you deliberately hurt him. It's no wonder he's having trouble recovering from the experience. Your poor communication may be partly due to the fact that he is still trying to recover from the shock.

The second kind of resentment, the kind you are experiencing, may be uncomfortable, but life is full of instances where we need to control ourselves for the protection of others. In other words, I'm saying that whatever resentment you may feel about not being able to see your friend is nothing compared to the resentment you would feel if your husband had indulged in an affair.

Following the Policy of Joint Agreement When You're VERY Incompatible
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/19/11 05:31 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Originally Posted by Dr. Harley
There are two kinds of resentment: (1) Resentment due to something one of you DID to the other that was hurtful, and (2) resentment due to something you DIDN'T do for yourself that you would have liked, but would have hurt your spouse. Your husband has the first kind of resentment because you had an affair three months into your marriage. What you did hurt him. You have the second kind of resentment because you now feel obligated to avoid seeing a friend who is a threat to your husband.

I think you would agree with me that the first kind of resentment is the worst, because your husband knows you deliberately hurt him. It's no wonder he's having trouble recovering from the experience. Your poor communication may be partly due to the fact that he is still trying to recover from the shock.

The second kind of resentment, the kind you are experiencing, may be uncomfortable, but life is full of instances where we need to control ourselves for the protection of others. In other words, I'm saying that whatever resentment you may feel about not being able to see your friend is nothing compared to the resentment you would feel if your husband had indulged in an affair.

Following the Policy of Joint Agreement When You're VERY Incompatible

Thanks Prisca!!

I printed the link and will have my H read it.
hbd, have you read this thread of Extraordinary Precautions?

This kind of list protects both of you eventually and is not the subject of poja. Read this thread very carefully.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/19/11 09:10 PM
Originally Posted by Mr_Recon6mo
hbd, have you read this thread of Extraordinary Precautions?

This kind of list protects both of you eventually and is not the subject of poja. Read this thread very carefully.

Thanks! Yeah, I've read it a few times actually. To be honest, I found those long lists a little overwhelming, so I made my own list of EPs that are important for me (posted earlier in my thread). I think my main problem is myself. I don't want my h resenting me or feeling controlled, so I don't enforce the EPs. I guess I just need to be stronger...easier said than done, I guess.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 03:31 PM
H and I finally came to an enthusiastic agreement about the boat trip.

I really do want him to have friends at work, so I do want him to participate in work outings occasionally. He works 50 hours a week and I want him to have some friends there or he will be miserable. I just don't want any of those friends to be women.

So, I decided, that I want him to go on the boat trip, but he cannot drink or have any conversations with women. To confirm that he is upholding his side of the bargain, he will record the entire outing using a VAR. Also, he will need to make up the time spent away from me by taking me out to lunch a few times.

Our first lunch date is today. smile

How does that sound?


I would spend ALL my leisure time with my H and getting the most of it to work ourselves back to intimacy. I don't see you are doing that right now, I'm sorry.

Not enforcing EP's will backfire. Not practising POJA or use the twisted version of it will do you no good. Right now, you are focusing on bargaining - and as said earlier, this is not POJA. Think about it - if you need to bargain something, you are by default NOT happy about the situation.

And I would NEVER trust him to have ALL the outing on the tape.
Quote
I don't want my h resenting me or feeling controlled, so I don't enforce the EPs. I guess I just need to be stronger...easier said than done, I guess

I think you are taking the whole situation too lightly. Reread this EPs thread and especially the part where HPB discusses why EPs are necessary. You should never trust a WS.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 07:40 PM
Originally Posted by Mrs_Recon6mo
Quote
I don't want my h resenting me or feeling controlled, so I don't enforce the EPs. I guess I just need to be stronger...easier said than done, I guess

I think you are taking the whole situation too lightly. Reread this EPs thread and especially the part where HPB discusses why EPs are necessary. You should never trust a WS.

Thanks Mrs. Recon. I appreciate your concern. I definitely don't trust him, which is why using a VAR is a requirement of the outing(I'll keep track of timing and how much is recorded to be sure it's all on there).

I would also like to use this as an opportunity to see what is said at the outing. I can see how he behaves and how his co-workers behave. I feel like this will be an opportunity for me to know more about the people he works with and which ones are good for him to be friends with.

He currently spends all of his free time with me. We are getting 15 to 20 hours of UA time each week. I go out with my girlfriends monthly, but he hasn't been out without me since d-day. This outing would be his first in 7 months.
POJA doesnt mean - I'll 'put up' with something I am not enthusiastic about (boat trip) in exchange for something I want (lunches)

It means you both have to be enthusiastic about each and every single decision.

You arent happy about the boat trip - you've told him so twice. But you arent happy with having your arm twisted either and being guilted by him. So you cave and throw POJA out the window.

Entusiasm is the key word. If youre not enthusiastic, it doesnt happen, you keep coming up with alternatives.

no more tit for tat deals
Quote
I think my main problem is myself. I don't want my h resenting me or feeling controlled,


He has the exact same power in POJA that you do. You wouldnt go off on any boat trip that made him unhappy.
Originally Posted by hbd
he hasn't been out without me since d-day. This outing would be his first in 7 months.


WHAT?! He hasnt been out with you yet, but when he gets invited on a boat trip with a bunch of guys, he's acts like cinders not being able to go to the ball? ?

He has an amazing wife at home, who's all ready to go out and have some fun with him and he acts like he's getting the sort of deal orphans get at christmas.

I think you need to see a bit more effort from this one.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 07:50 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
POJA doesnt mean - I'll 'put up' with something I am not enthusiastic about (boat trip) in exchange for something I want (lunches)

It means you both have to be enthusiastic about each and every single decision.

You arent happy about the boat trip - you've told him so twice. But you arent happy with having your arm twisted either and being guilted by him. So you cave and throw POJA out the window.

Entusiasm is the key word. If youre not enthusiastic, it doesnt happen, you keep coming up with alternatives.

no more tit for tat deals

I do want him to go though. I want him to have friends. That is something that has always attracted me to him..the fact that he has always been popular and had a lot of friends. I really do want him to go and have fun, as long as he isn't drinking or talking to women.

The lunches were to make up for missed UA time...so we get our 15 to 20 hours in for the week.

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 07:51 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
Originally Posted by hbd
he hasn't been out without me since d-day. This outing would be his first in 7 months.


WHAT?! He hasnt been out with you yet, but when he gets invited on a boat trip with a bunch of guys, he's acts like cinders not being able to go to the ball? ?.

LOl. No, I meant he hasn't been out without me. We have a date night at least once a month.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 08:21 PM
Ok, so what I didn't post earlier was that when H came home on Friday night, he told me he didn't want me to feel like work is more important to him. So he decided not to go on the boat trip.

So, I got what I wanted (or what I thought I wanted), which was my H not going on boat trip. Yay! However, then I got to thinking, it wasn't the boat trip itself that was making me feel bad...it was that he was putting work ahead of me. Now that he wasn't puting work ahead of me, the boat trip didn't bother me as much.

So, then I said to myself, what exactly is it that bothers me about the boat trip? I thought about it and decided it's just that I don't want him drinking and talking to women. That's all. I have no problem with him hanging out with men and talking about sports and stuff. I actually want him to have friends. So, then I actually became unhappy about him NOT going on the boat trip.

The solution was for him to go and just use a VAR, so I know he's not drinking or talking to women. That way we are both happy.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 08:33 PM
I don't know, HBD, I've got bad feelings about this.

Are you each others FAVORITE recreational companions?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 08:36 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
I don't know, HBD, I've got bad feelings about this.

Are you each others FAVORITE recreational companions?

Yes. We have a great time together. Have SF almost daily. Snuggle every night. Show each other a lot of affection, etc...
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 08:39 PM
Also, H said he wanted me to go along on boat trip. I said I didn't want to go because I would be the only spouse there and would feel uncomfortable.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 08:44 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
I don't know, HBD, I've got bad feelings about this.

Are you each others FAVORITE recreational companions?

Now you are getting me nervous. What is giving you a bad feeling? Do you think he would try to meet OW or something? Cause I have my eye on both of them and would know if that happened.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 09:07 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
I don't know, HBD, I've got bad feelings about this.

Are you each others FAVORITE recreational companions?

I also didn't mention earlier, that we completed the EN questionaire and LB questionaire last week (we fill out the forms every few months to make sure we are on track for meeting needs - like a report card) There were a few LBs that I didn't do well on, but H said that I met all of his ENs. He put extremely satisfied for every one. I also gave him a good report.

Anyway, my point is that we are getting on great and this boat trip has been our only issue since the threesome.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 09:20 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by Prisca
I don't know, HBD, I've got bad feelings about this.

Are you each others FAVORITE recreational companions?

Yes. We have a great time together. Have SF almost daily. Snuggle every night. Show each other a lot of affection, etc...

What about Recreational Companionship?

What worries me is the concentration on having friends right now instead of being together and working on your marriage.

Your marriage just very recently took some hard blows.

Dr. Harley says there is no problem with independent recreational activities when:

* You and your spouse are following the Policy of Undivided Attention (POUA)
* The activity is not spent with members of opposite sex
* You are each others' favorite recreational companion
* The activity meets with enthusiastic agreement

When you can engage in the activity, but find yourself missing your spouse's company, THAT'S when you're ready for individual recreation. Is that where the two of you are?
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 09:22 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
Also, H said he wanted me to go along on boat trip. I said I didn't want to go because I would be the only spouse there and would feel uncomfortable.

Go!
Originally Posted by hbd
Also, H said he wanted me to go along on boat trip. I said I didn't want to go because I would be the only spouse there and would feel uncomfortable.

So what if you're the only spouse? I've gone to plenty of events with my husband's set team and been the only spouse to go. His team members are amazed when I show up mid week that I care enough about my husband to come to his companies events, even though I usually end up driving because they're mid week and held wherever the team is that week. His coworkers think we have an amazing marriage (I think we do to).

And, my DH comes to my company events, sometimes as the only spouse, and he's made a few guy friends out of some of my male coworkers and it's been good for us.

Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 09:28 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by Prisca
I don't know, HBD, I've got bad feelings about this.

Are you each others FAVORITE recreational companions?

Now you are getting me nervous. What is giving you a bad feeling? Do you think he would try to meet OW or something? Cause I have my eye on both of them and would know if that happened.


A lot of things give me a bad feeling about this

1. You very recently were reluctant about him going. You may have changed your mind, but the fact remains that you were at one point reluctant.
2. He threw a fit about that.
3. I don't believe you need to be having recreation separately right now. The danger is in setting up a situation where he compares the fun he has with his friends to the fun he has with you.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 09:30 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Originally Posted by hbd
Also, H said he wanted me to go along on boat trip. I said I didn't want to go because I would be the only spouse there and would feel uncomfortable.

Go!

I know I should go and H wants me to go. He said he could probably get the ok from his boss because his boss now knows about the A and how I feel about H going out without me.

It's just that the email invitation (which H forwarded to me) specifically says "Team Members only" and I know that other employees would want to bring their spouses too because there will be free food and beverages. I would just feel SO uncomfortable and embarassed. I would so much rather just have H use the VAR. It's just like me being there without the embarassment.
Posted By: markos Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 09:39 PM
It just really concerns me that he is going off for this during such a fragile stage of recovery. I think he needs to be taking better care of you by putting some things like this on hold, or by bringing you along. If his most fun times are not with you, it will cause a real danger for your marriage. Recreational Companionship is typically one of the most important needs for a husband, and as such, I think you should be more concerned about building the friendship between the two of you (which is on extremely thin ice) than getting him friends at work.

http://www.marriagebuilders.com/graphic/mbi5069_qa.html

I know you said that you are each other's favorite recreational companions at the moment, but it just seems like maybe there should be more of a track record of this. You guys may be in what is called "hysterical bonding" (do a search and read about it on the forum), which is great, but you need to start setting up the habits now to sustain your marriage for the long term.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/22/11 09:41 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
A lot of things give me a bad feeling about this

1. You very recently were reluctant about him going. You may have changed your mind, but the fact remains that you were at one point reluctant.
2. He threw a fit about that.
3. I don't believe you need to be having recreation separately right now. The danger is in setting up a situation where he compares the fun he has with his friends to the fun he has with you.

Ok, I'm going to think this through a little more. Thanks.
Originally Posted by HopefulNC
Originally Posted by hbd
Also, H said he wanted me to go along on boat trip. I said I didn't want to go because I would be the only spouse there and would feel uncomfortable.

So what if you're the only spouse? I've gone to plenty of events with my husband's set team and been the only spouse to go. His team members are amazed when I show up mid week that I care enough about my husband to come to his companies events, even though I usually end up driving because they're mid week and held wherever the team is that week. His coworkers think we have an amazing marriage (I think we do to).

And, my DH comes to my company events, sometimes as the only spouse, and he's made a few guy friends out of some of my male coworkers and it's been good for us.


Oh my god, go girl!

What a detail to leave out! Here was me thinking he was desperate to get away from you for a stupid boat ride.

I get why you would be embarassed, but you need to get over it. I think you are envisaging whispers and sniggers, but that prob isnt whats going to happen at all. You would prob find the reaction is more like the one to HNC and people think its great the effort you put in.

Also you say you want to know more about the people he works with. I just think you'll do a better job, if you go as you will understand more about his co-workers and life. Theres a lot that can be missed on a VAR, body language etc.

Maybe if it goes well the boss will want everyone's spouse there - you could be a pioneer!
Hi, I'm David ...as in the Hurt By David, David (hbd's husband). I really want my wife to go with me on the boat trip. I really don't like spending more time with my co workers then I need to and I really miss my wife when I don't get to spend time with her. Especially at the end of the week when that's the whole motivation to get through the work week. As a manager in my company it's strongly encouraged for me to participate in theses team events. That's a big reason why I wanted to tell my boss of my past so he would either understand why I wouldn't participate in theses events or why it was so important to be able to bring my wife along. I can understand why my wife doesn't want to go, I work with whiny people and they will complain. Although I don't care. My peers and manager get it, only the ones that report to me and other managers are like that.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 12:18 AM
Well, this is a no brainer unless not POJA. You go together. Where is the POJA hiccup?

HBD, why on earth would you want a VAR versus being with your husband?

I have been on hundreds of company trips with spouses that also attend...nothing odd about it. Pretty normal.

Kudos to you 22, to tell your boss. Just do that.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 12:26 AM
Huh?

What's to think through?
Hi 2time, welcome.
Originally Posted by 2time2timer
I really want my wife to go with me on the boat trip. I really don't like spending more time with my co workers then I need to and I really miss my wife when I don't get to spend time with her.... I can understand why my wife doesn't want to go, I work with whiny people and they will complain. Although I don't care. My peers and manager get it, only the ones that report to me and other managers are like that.


The Policy of Joint Agreement achieves two important objectives in marriage. First, it helps eliminate behavior that benefits one spouse at the expense of the other, and second, it helps create substitute behavior that benefits both spouses

You say here 2time in the first part that you want her with you (which is awesome). You also spell out some career benefits for you, but are you willing to give up the trip if she really doenst want to go?

I think there are some benefits for her in going and I have spelled those out for her. However if she feels at all apprehensive she needs to feel your support.

She is a bit anxious at the moment about making you resent her, and shouldnt be.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 01:12 AM
Hello David smile Welcome to Marriage Builders.

Please feel free to start a thread of your own. We discourage husbands and wives from posting on each others threads.

Glad to see you here.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 01:12 AM
Well, and I just made my own DJ's didn't I? smile

See how that works?

POJA without any DJ's takes practice!

I'm trying, too! See how it works?
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 01:56 AM
H is starting his own thread. Thanks
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 02:00 AM
Originally Posted by Surfer88
Huh?

What's to think through?

I'll just be uncomfortable. I'm picturing people giving me dirty looks and being unfriendly. I'd much rather just have h take a var.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 02:04 AM
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by Surfer88
Huh?

What's to think through?

I'll just be uncomfortable. I'm picturing people giving me dirty looks and being unfriendly. I'd much rather just have h take a var.

I'm more enthusiastic about him going with a var than I am about going along. Just being honest.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 03:44 AM
And, how long is that going to last?

Look...I was just going to site examples...deleted.

I'd much rather a lot of things.

You need to put your big girl pants on and get there with your head held high. Be nice, be charming, and if you're anything like my couple-friend...address head on. They are slightly crazy, though. smile


Not ready for that? OK. Go and be nice. You can't run, dollface. Dirty looks are very highschool...adults will test and test you, and eventually respect you both. You've gotta weather that storm if want to and then you'll earn it. And, you can. It'll take years. Got that?
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 03:51 AM
Huh again?

What grade are we in? C'mon. Unfriendly? Try being honest and see how friendly people are...no "dirty looks" toward a person who says "I f--ked up". Unless that is a lie, and people can smell a liar.

Be honest. Be nice. And, have no fear. Get your butt to this event.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 04:00 AM
I'd rather lose 10 pounds by eating alfredo pasta versus working out, too. Would be much less uncomfortable.
EPs prevent unnecessary discussions over boundaries every time the situation occurs. Once you have "no outings alone" in the EPs list, there wouldn't be any discussion about whether he should go alone, with VAR, without it or what you should do about it all together. There would only be 2 options - you go together or not at all. Him going alone would not be an option at all.

You have to start from somewhere - you cannot continue living as if there were no affairs, no other meltdowns in your life.

this has come up alot between us,,,, and is a poja constantly next month we have 4 of them. but on friday my H had an outing, i flipped back and for like you- and i know his collegues.

h sent a car service i drove 2 hours and went to the outing, i looked great and yes the other were jealous that their wives werent there.

his boss said to me are "you" behaving ( as a joke) i said of course then he said i guess i should as if h is.... ok a bit uncomfortable-

we took a hotel room and came home.

its part of the EP's.

yes i was annoyed that i had to change my life but that the way it is now.

go on the stupid boat trip, catch alot of fish and look like you are loving it. otherwise you will be pissed at him when he is home and pissed at yourself for not going.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 02:19 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
What about Recreational Companionship?

What worries me is the concentration on having friends right now instead of being together and working on your marriage.

Your marriage just very recently took some hard blows.

Dr. Harley says there is no problem with independent recreational activities when:

* You and your spouse are following the Policy of Undivided Attention (POUA)
* The activity is not spent with members of opposite sex
* You are each others' favorite recreational companion
* The activity meets with enthusiastic agreement

When you can engage in the activity, but find yourself missing your spouse's company, THAT'S when you're ready for individual recreation. Is that where the two of you are?

I don't think I answered this one yesterday.

We are each other's favorite recreational companions. We have been doing about 15 to 25 hours of UA time a week (depending on work schedules). About 50% of that time is spent on SF. The rest of the time is split between conversation, playing games, or cuddling while watching TV/movies. We also try to go out on a date once a month. Usually dinner and a movie or some sort of event (concert, party, casino, etc.).

I'm definitely at the point where I miss H's company when I go out without him. H says that too.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 02:21 PM
Originally Posted by Surfer88
And, how long is that going to last?

Look...I was just going to site examples...deleted.

I'd much rather a lot of things.

You need to put your big girl pants on and get there with your head held high. Be nice, be charming, and if you're anything like my couple-friend...address head on. They are slightly crazy, though. smile


Not ready for that? OK. Go and be nice. You can't run, dollface. Dirty looks are very highschool...adults will test and test you, and eventually respect you both. You've gotta weather that storm if want to and then you'll earn it. And, you can. It'll take years. Got that?

It's not POJA if I'm not enthusiastic though. I have to be honest about this or I will be resentul if I go and have an aweful time.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 02:36 PM
Originally Posted by Mrs_Recon6mo
EPs prevent unnecessary discussions over boundaries every time the situation occurs. Once you have "no outings alone" in the EPs list, there wouldn't be any discussion about whether he should go alone, with VAR, without it or what you should do about it all together. There would only be 2 options - you go together or not at all. Him going alone would not be an option at all.

You have to start from somewhere - you cannot continue living as if there were no affairs, no other meltdowns in your life.

I think "no outings with the opposite sex" is sufficient. I like the list of requirements from Dr. H (provided earlier by Prisca) for seperate outings. It appears that Dr. H thinks outings alone are ok if his list of requirements are met. I think we meet those requirements. We just need to do a better job of POJAing. Obvioiusly, we have issues with POJA...evidenced by the title of my thread. We will definitely work on POJA...probably for the rest of our lives.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 02:39 PM
Originally Posted by chickadee1
this has come up alot between us,,,, and is a poja constantly next month we have 4 of them. but on friday my H had an outing, i flipped back and for like you- and i know his collegues.

h sent a car service i drove 2 hours and went to the outing, i looked great and yes the other were jealous that their wives werent there.

his boss said to me are "you" behaving ( as a joke) i said of course then he said i guess i should as if h is.... ok a bit uncomfortable-

we took a hotel room and came home.

its part of the EP's.

yes i was annoyed that i had to change my life but that the way it is now.

go on the stupid boat trip, catch alot of fish and look like you are loving it. otherwise you will be pissed at him when he is home and pissed at yourself for not going.

Thanks Chicadee. Ok, lets say I go and have an aweful time. Hating every minute because H's colleagues give me a hard time. Won't I then be resentful? That's not POJA either.

I've basically come to the conclusion that there is no way to POJA this type of situation. Either I'm going to be unhappy that I have to go along or H is going to be unhappy he can't go. So frustrating.
Quote
Thanks Chicadee. Ok, lets say I go and have an aweful time. Hating every minute because H's colleagues give me a hard time. Won't I then be resentful? That's not POJA either.

I've basically come to the conclusion that there is no way to POJA this type of situation. Either I'm going to be unhappy that I have to go along or H is going to be unhappy he can't go. So frustrating.
Is there a way that you can adjust your mindset about this outing? There are business functions that I attend with my H when I'd prefer not to go. Actually, sometimes I'd prefer bamboo shoots under my nails rather than having to go! grin I can work up enthusiasm for the event by thinking:

It's one evening.

I'm going to attend with H and really support him because I'm so proud of him.

I'm going to pick one person I don't know very well and make sure they have a positive impression of me as the woman who is married to their colleague.

We can POJA to attend this event and then go to your favorite lunch spot, recreational place, wherever - fill in the blank next weekend.

I'm going to go to this event and practice my skills in gracefulness under adversity.

You get the picture - can you adjust the way you're looking at this event? I get the impression that you've decided you're going to be miserable and that's that.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 02:57 PM
Originally Posted by chickadee1
yes i was annoyed that i had to change my life but that the way it is now.

It's just not fair that we have to change so much when they are the ones that lied and cheated. I'm feeling the resentment build and this is what I was afraid of happening. I'm not even at the event yet.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 03:01 PM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
Quote
Thanks Chicadee. Ok, lets say I go and have an aweful time. Hating every minute because H's colleagues give me a hard time. Won't I then be resentful? That's not POJA either.

I've basically come to the conclusion that there is no way to POJA this type of situation. Either I'm going to be unhappy that I have to go along or H is going to be unhappy he can't go. So frustrating.
Is there a way that you can adjust your mindset about this outing? There are business functions that I attend with my H when I'd prefer not to go. Actually, sometimes I'd prefer bamboo shoots under my nails rather than having to go! grin I can work up enthusiasm for the event by thinking:

It's one evening.

I'm going to attend with H and really support him because I'm so proud of him.

I'm going to pick one person I don't know very well and make sure they have a positive impression of me as the woman who is married to their colleague.

We can POJA to attend this event and then go to your favorite lunch spot, recreational place, wherever - fill in the blank next weekend.

I'm going to go to this event and practice my skills in gracefulness under adversity.

You get the picture - can you adjust the way you're looking at this event? I get the impression that you've decided you're going to be miserable and that's that.

I would definitely go and have fun if it didn't specifically say on the invite "team members only." In fact, I've already gone to some events with H and had a great time. It's just that I wasn't invited to this particular event and H works with a bunch of whiny babies that will cry and complain about it. Seriously, they will.
Posted By: markos Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 03:26 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by chickadee1
yes i was annoyed that i had to change my life but that the way it is now.

It's just not fair that we have to change so much when they are the ones that lied and cheated. I'm feeling the resentment build and this is what I was afraid of happening. I'm not even at the event yet.

h,

Some of these changes are simply a way of life. Not spending the night apart, for example, is a good way for anyone to live a marriage. It's not a consequence of cheating, it's just a good boundary to have.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 03:30 PM
Quote
It's just not fair that we have to change so much when they are the ones that lied and cheated. I'm feeling the resentment build and this is what I was afraid of happening. I'm not even at the event yet.
Careful.

The changes you are making to your marriage are a GOOD thing, even if nobody had cheated.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 03:30 PM
I think I'm just going to have H not go. He says he's ok with not going (not particularly happy, but he's ok with it). Plus, it's a message to H's boss that if events are going to be for "team members only," then David won't be there.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 03:31 PM
Quote
It's just that I wasn't invited to this particular event
You've been invited by your husband.
Quote
I would definitely go and have fun if it didn't specifically say on the invite "team members only." In fact, I've already gone to some events with H and had a great time. It's just that I wasn't invited to this particular event and H works with a bunch of whiny babies that will cry and complain about it. Seriously, they will.
Looks like they're going to have to consider revising that policy, since it doesn't work for their married 'team members'. grin

Let the whiny babies whine. If your H wants to be there with you, that's all you need to know. If a superior of his says anything to your H, he can tell them that the two of you have a standing agreement concerning attending events together. Unless he's on Obama's secret staff, and they'll be planning the next take-down of a world despot, there's nothing work-related that will be happening that should require your exclusion. This is a boat ride.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 03:34 PM
Prisca and Markos - Thanks for the reminder. I have to remember that our marriage is getting better as a result of these changes. These are things we should have been doing anyway.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 03:37 PM
Did you read Markos' post, where he mentioned hysterical bonding? Did you read Dr. Harley's article that he linked to?

HBD, I think it's just too soon for the two of you to be going to separate recreational events. Your marriage took a severe blow very recently. It is fragile. I think you need to be concentrating on recovery and not on having friends and doing things with friends.

I believe when this subject first came up, I said either you both go, or neither of you goes. I still stand by that. You need to be together for recreational events.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 03:42 PM
Quote
I've basically come to the conclusion that there is no way to POJA this type of situation. Either I'm going to be unhappy that I have to go along or H is going to be unhappy he can't go. So frustrating.
Read about the 2 types of resentment, again.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 03:44 PM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
This is a boat ride.

I know. It's so ridiculous that we have to make such a big deal about such a small thing. crazy
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 04:02 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Did you read Markos' post, where he mentioned hysterical bonding? Did you read Dr. Harley's article that he linked to?

HBD, I think it's just too soon for the two of you to be going to separate recreational events. Your marriage took a severe blow very recently. It is fragile. I think you need to be concentrating on recovery and not on having friends and doing things with friends.

I believe when this subject first came up, I said either you both go, or neither of you goes. I still stand by that. You need to be together for recreational events.

Yes. I think we are just ending the histerical bonding phase, actually. It lasted from about February through a few weeks ago. We are now in more of a rebuilding phase (at least I am). So, I agree, that this is not a good time to spend time apart. I did read the thread and I get it.

That being said, unlike the woman that doesn't like her H going to fantasy football, I do support my H going to that event (hear me out). For example, My H has a fantasy football draft in two weeks. He does this every year. It's three hours, all guys at an old co-workers house, and he won't be drinking. He comes right home after because he has to work early the next morning. We did POJA this event weeks ago. I'm enthusiastic about him going. We usually talk about his team afterwards and I follow his games every week too. We are originally from Wisconsin (he's from Green Bay) and he tries to get Packer players on his team. It's fun for me too.

Anyway, my point is that I'm totally fine with this type of event because there won't be any drinking or women and I am supportive of the outcome because it's fun for both of us to follow the team he drafts. On the other hand, I am not ok with the boat trip because there are women there. I just need to draw a line saying no outings when women will be present. No negotiating.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 04:03 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
I've basically come to the conclusion that there is no way to POJA this type of situation. Either I'm going to be unhappy that I have to go along or H is going to be unhappy he can't go. So frustrating.
Read about the 2 types of resentment, again.

Right. So the best choice is for H not to go on boat trip.
Originally Posted by hbd
Right. So the best choice is for H not to go on boat trip.

hbd, FWIW, I used to work for a company that would have outings where the spouses were excluded. We did things like go to sporting events and trips to the city for dinner etc etc. No one was looked down upon for not going due to family responsibilities.

I can also tell you that things got very raunchy without the wives around.
Posted By: markos Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 04:24 PM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
Quote
I would definitely go and have fun if it didn't specifically say on the invite "team members only." In fact, I've already gone to some events with H and had a great time. It's just that I wasn't invited to this particular event and H works with a bunch of whiny babies that will cry and complain about it. Seriously, they will.
Looks like they're going to have to consider revising that policy, since it doesn't work for their married 'team members'. grin

Let the whiny babies whine. If your H wants to be there with you, that's all you need to know. If a superior of his says anything to your H, he can tell them that the two of you have a standing agreement concerning attending events together. Unless he's on Obama's secret staff, and they'll be planning the next take-down of a world despot, there's nothing work-related that will be happening that should require your exclusion. This is a boat ride.

I agree, and I'd take special delight in showing up to make them whine and talking in a classy way that made them realize how rude they were being.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 04:28 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
I've basically come to the conclusion that there is no way to POJA this type of situation. Either I'm going to be unhappy that I have to go along or H is going to be unhappy he can't go. So frustrating.
Read about the 2 types of resentment, again.

Right. So the best choice is for H not to go on boat trip.
Go on a mind-blowing date instead.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 04:36 PM
Originally Posted by markos
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
Quote
I would definitely go and have fun if it didn't specifically say on the invite "team members only." In fact, I've already gone to some events with H and had a great time. It's just that I wasn't invited to this particular event and H works with a bunch of whiny babies that will cry and complain about it. Seriously, they will.
Looks like they're going to have to consider revising that policy, since it doesn't work for their married 'team members'. grin

Let the whiny babies whine. If your H wants to be there with you, that's all you need to know. If a superior of his says anything to your H, he can tell them that the two of you have a standing agreement concerning attending events together. Unless he's on Obama's secret staff, and they'll be planning the next take-down of a world despot, there's nothing work-related that will be happening that should require your exclusion. This is a boat ride.

I agree, and I'd take special delight in showing up to make them whine and talking in a classy way that made them realize how rude they were being.

Ok, here are the options I just gave my H and I'm leaving it up to him to decide.

1. I can go along and try to put on a happy face
2. We don't go at all and we have a nice evening at home...have some wine, go in jacuzzi, light some candles, I give him a massage, etc.

I hope he picks the jacuzzi. wink
Quote
1. I can go along and try to put on a happy face
2. We don't go at all and we have a nice evening at home...have some wine, go in jacuzzi, light some candles, I give him a massage, etc.
Yeah, but look how you worded this, hbd. Number 1 is heavy with sacrifice on your part. I can hear the implication behind this: "I don't want to go and it's going to be a huge pain in my neck, but...sigh...I guess I'll go if that's what you really want..."

And then you're obviously selling him on Number 2. Geez, I think it's pretty obvious which choice you want him to he'd better pick.

I don't mean to criticize, but could you have worded these choices differently?

"Sweetie, here are our options. We could take the company boat trip, or we could stay at home and have a date night in the jacuzzi. What do you think?" Continue to POJA from there.

I get it, don't get me wrong: you don't want to go on the boat trip, and you don't want him to go, either. But that's not an enthusiastic decision you've both made. YOU'RE making it, and I fear that will lead to resentment on your H's part.
sorry you are having to go thru all of this.

i know i hate it also. I am going to print the last few pages for my h to read beacuse we have the samething coming up again, and it will be an issue for us forever. thats when he carried on, so no events alone.

but i may be reliving your thread on mine in a few weeks/days.

i hope all of the whiny employees get a choppy night and get sick, ooohh was that bad... as long as you arent on the boat. an outbreak of seasickness would give them thought to having the boat ride at all.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 04:53 PM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
I fear that will lead to resentment on your H's part.


Yes, but if he makes the right choice, I will make it worth his while...if you know what I mean. flirt
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 04:55 PM
Originally Posted by chickadee1
sorry you are having to go thru all of this.

i know i hate it also. I am going to print the last few pages for my h to read beacuse we have the samething coming up again, and it will be an issue for us forever. thats when he carried on, so no events alone.

but i may be reliving your thread on mine in a few weeks/days.

i hope all of the whiny employees get a choppy night and get sick, ooohh was that bad... as long as you arent on the boat. an outbreak of seasickness would give them thought to having the boat ride at all.

Oh, that's another thing. I get seasick. The last time I was on a small boat, I had nausea and vertigo for a whole day.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 04:59 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by chickadee1
sorry you are having to go thru all of this.

i know i hate it also. I am going to print the last few pages for my h to read beacuse we have the samething coming up again, and it will be an issue for us forever. thats when he carried on, so no events alone.

but i may be reliving your thread on mine in a few weeks/days.

i hope all of the whiny employees get a choppy night and get sick, ooohh was that bad... as long as you arent on the boat. an outbreak of seasickness would give them thought to having the boat ride at all.

Oh, that's another thing. I get seasick. The last time I was on a small boat, I had nausea and vertigo for a whole day.

Granted it was a small boat in choppy water, but it could happen on a larger boat if it's windy.
Posted By: kerala Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:04 PM
I know it's fun to diss the whiny employees and hbd's husband doesn't like them but...

No one likes to see a co-worker get special treatment. It's not really their problem that hbd's H committed adultery and it doesn't make it ok for the company to permit his spouse to attend while their own cannot. In a perverse way it looks like the H is being given special consideration for being a sleaze.

I also find it interesting that so many are encouraging hbd to attend. She doesn't appear enthusiastic about it, so really shouldn't that be the end of the story?
Posted By: markos Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:11 PM
It is always okay for spouses to attend company functions. Even when the company says no. smile Regardless of past infidelity or not.
Quote
I also find it interesting that so many are encouraging hbd to attend. She doesn't appear enthusiastic about it, so really shouldn't that be the end of the story?
But it's not simply a matter of hbd not wanting to go. She doesn't want her H to go, either. There is a POJA issue here.

Side note: Any company that creates socializing opportunities that exclude spouses is setting themselves up on a slippery slope toward possible future sexual harrassment issues. These non-spouse get-togethers stink all the way around.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:19 PM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
Quote
I also find it interesting that so many are encouraging hbd to attend. She doesn't appear enthusiastic about it, so really shouldn't that be the end of the story?
But it's not simply a matter of hbd not wanting to go. She doesn't want her H to go, either. There is a POJA issue here.

Side note: Any company that creates socializing opportunities that exclude spouses is setting themselves up on a slippery slope toward possible future sexual harrassment issues. These non-spouse get-togethers stink all the way around.

Which is why I think we should just not go. I am leaving the final choice up to H, but I think he should make a stand and say, "If you are going to plan non-spouse events, I simply won't be there."
Originally Posted by hbd
[quote=maritalbliss] [quote]Side note: Any company that creates socializing opportunities that exclude spouses is setting themselves up on a slippery slope toward possible future sexual harrassment issues. These non-spouse get-togethers stink all the way around.

i agree!
Originally Posted by hbd
Which is why I think we should just not go. I am leaving the final choice up to H, but I think he should make a stand and say, "If you are going to plan non-spouse events, I simply won't be there."

That's what you really want here isn't hbd? For your H to stand up for your marriage and do the right thing. To make you feel safe without having to POJA it.

I feel like I am missing something here. What about EPs?
Posted By: kerala Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:35 PM
Originally Posted by markos
It is always okay for spouses to attend company functions. Even when the company says no. smile Regardless of past infidelity or not.

These kinds of cutesy statements do not help people deal with actual problems. smile

Posted By: kerala Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:46 PM
Perhaps it is my line of work, but I find some of the statements above to reflect a very narrow range of work experience. The fact is that many work events include socializing opportunities - e.g., a retreat to discuss strategic planning, held outside of the office that includes some of kind of recreation, or a one-day conference in the same city. Very tough for a spouse to attend unless in a related field (as an academic I sometimes attend conferences with my husband. These events do not uniformly "stink" nor do they provide a slippery slope to sexual harrassment, at least no more so than is routinely encountered in any work place where people have individual offices and a modicum of control over their schedule (ie., without a supervisor monitoring their every move).

I know, I know, this is a boat ride for the dreaded "team building" (which I, personally, loathe) but I couldn't let some of the over-generalizations in this thread pass.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:46 PM
Originally Posted by kerala
Originally Posted by markos
It is always okay for spouses to attend company functions. Even when the company says no. smile Regardless of past infidelity or not.

These kinds of cutesy statements do not help people deal with actual problems. smile

Nothing "cutesy" about it, Kerala.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:48 PM
Originally Posted by pokerface
Originally Posted by hbd
Which is why I think we should just not go. I am leaving the final choice up to H, but I think he should make a stand and say, "If you are going to plan non-spouse events, I simply won't be there."

That's what you really want here isn't hbd? For your H to stand up for your marriage and do the right thing. To make you feel safe without having to POJA it.

I feel like I am missing something here. What about EPs?


The EPs I gave H (posted earlier in this thread) are:

1. Protect me and my feelings above all else.
2. Absolutely no contact with your affair partner.
3. Make all phone, email, and texting information available to me.
4. No sharing personal information with females unless I am by your side.
5. No one-on-one meetings with anyone of the opposite sex.
6. No going out drinking with friends if females will be present.
7. No overnight stays away from me.
8. Use the policy of joint agreement (POJA) as a basis for all decisions.
9. Be open and honest with me at all times.
10. Commit to at least 15 hours of undivided attention with me to meet each other�s emotional needs every week
11. Anytime you think, �I don�t want you to know about��.�, call me immediately and tell me.
12. Continually work on our relationship with discussions and relationship books.
13. Avoid porn and self stimulation

The EP that would apply to this boat trip is #6, but since he wouldn't be drinking it technically is ok with my EPs. So, we have to POJA it.

H decided to go and bring me along with him. The funny thing was when he told his co-worker (the guy taking RSVPs) he wanted to go and bring me along, the co-worker said it was just fine. In fact, another manager is bringing is wife. H said great, count us in! But, then the co-worker (guy taking RSVPs) came back to H and said now there isn't enough room on the boat for both of us. We waited too long to make the decision. faint
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:49 PM
There's a difference between working with members of the opposite sex and having recreation with them, Kerala.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:52 PM
Quote
H decided to go and bring me along with him. The funny thing was when he told his co-worker (the guy taking RSVPs) he wanted to go and bring me along, the co-worker said it was just fine. In fact, another manager is bringing is wife. H said great, count us in! But, the co-worker (guy taking RSVPs) said now there isn't enough room on the boat for both of us. We waited too long to make the decision.
Remember this next time! Maybe you won't dread it the next time so much with this knowledge.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:53 PM
And, since you know that you can't go now anyway, even if you wanted to, start planning for that MIND-BLOWING DATE! laugh Make it something that David will have NO regrets missing the boat ride for.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:57 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
H decided to go and bring me along with him. The funny thing was when he told his co-worker (the guy taking RSVPs) he wanted to go and bring me along, the co-worker said it was just fine. In fact, another manager is bringing is wife. H said great, count us in! But, the co-worker (guy taking RSVPs) said now there isn't enough room on the boat for both of us. We waited too long to make the decision.
Remember this next time! Maybe you won't dread it the next time so much with this knowledge.

What I think H will do going forward for other events is talk some of his other co-workers into brinking their spouses along. That way I'll know ahead of time who will be there and I won't worry about being the only one.
Originally Posted by hbd
The EPs I gave H (posted earlier in this thread) are:

1. Protect me and my feelings above all else.
2. Absolutely no contact with your affair partner.
3. Make all phone, email, and texting information available to me.
4. No sharing personal information with females unless I am by your side.
5. No one-on-one meetings with anyone of the opposite sex.
6. No going out drinking with friends if females will be present.
7. No overnight stays away from me.
8. Use the policy of joint agreement (POJA) as a basis for all decisions.
9. Be open and honest with me at all times.
10. Commit to at least 15 hours of undivided attention with me to meet each other�s emotional needs every week
11. Anytime you think, �I don�t want you to know about��.�, call me immediately and tell me.
12. Continually work on our relationship with discussions and relationship books.
13. Avoid porn and self stimulation

The EP that would apply to this boat trip is #6, but since he wouldn't be drinking it technically is ok with my EPs. So, we have to POJA it.

Maybe #6 needs to be re-visited since it is causing so much upheaval in your life and is not serving its intended purpose.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 06:58 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
And, since you know that you can't go now anyway, even if you wanted to, start planning for that MIND-BLOWING DATE! laugh Make it something that David will have NO regrets missing the boat ride for.

Oh, yes. I have a very special treat planned for him. flirt
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 07:00 PM
Originally Posted by pokerface
Originally Posted by hbd
The EPs I gave H (posted earlier in this thread) are:

1. Protect me and my feelings above all else.
2. Absolutely no contact with your affair partner.
3. Make all phone, email, and texting information available to me.
4. No sharing personal information with females unless I am by your side.
5. No one-on-one meetings with anyone of the opposite sex.
6. No going out drinking with friends if females will be present.
7. No overnight stays away from me.
8. Use the policy of joint agreement (POJA) as a basis for all decisions.
9. Be open and honest with me at all times.
10. Commit to at least 15 hours of undivided attention with me to meet each other�s emotional needs every week
11. Anytime you think, �I don�t want you to know about��.�, call me immediately and tell me.
12. Continually work on our relationship with discussions and relationship books.
13. Avoid porn and self stimulation

The EP that would apply to this boat trip is #6, but since he wouldn't be drinking it technically is ok with my EPs. So, we have to POJA it.

Maybe #6 needs to be re-visited since it is causing so much upheaval in your life and is not serving its intended purpose.

Yes. I'm going to change it to no going out without me if females will be present.
Quote
The fact is that many work events include socializing opportunities - e.g., a retreat to discuss strategic planning, held outside of the office that includes some of kind of recreation, or a one-day conference in the same city.
Yep. This is common, and I think it is mis-guided. Any company that has to include a social activity in their 'strategic planning' activity is missing the boat (sorry, hbd, I just had to say that grin ) If the point is to strategically plan, the planning doesn't have to be lopped in with socializing on a boat trip, or a golf outing, etc. Socializing activities that are built into work activities still present opportunities that could place an employer in lawsuit jeopardy when spouses are specifically excluded.
Originally Posted by hbd
Yes. I'm going to change it to no going out without me if females will be present.

That is wise. Good luck to you guys.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/23/11 07:16 PM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
Any company that has to include a social activity in their 'strategic planning' activity is missing the boat (sorry, hbd, I just had to say that grin )

rotflmao
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/24/11 02:15 PM
Our new EPs...I changed them to apply to both of us and tweaked a few too:

1. Protect our marriage and each other's feelings above all else.
2. Absolutely no contact with previous affair partners (including googling their name, looking them up on Facebook, etc).
3. Make all phone, email, internet history, and texting information available to each other.
4. No sharing personal information with the opposite sex unless we are together.
5. No going out separately if members of the opposite sex will be present.
7. No overnight stays away from each other.
8. Use the policy of joint agreement (POJA) as a basis for all decisions.
9. Be open and honest with each other at all times.
10. Anytime either of us thinks, �I don�t want you to know about��.�, call immediately and tell the other person.
11. Commit to at least 15 hours of undivided attention to meet each other�s emotional needs every week.
12. Continually work on our relationship with discussions and relationship books.
13. Avoid porn and self stimulation unless doing it together.


Posted By: kerala Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/25/11 08:59 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
There's a difference between working with members of the opposite sex and having recreation with them, Kerala.

Do you work outside the home, Prisca?
Posted By: CWMI Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/25/11 09:13 PM
Originally Posted by kerala
Originally Posted by Prisca
There's a difference between working with members of the opposite sex and having recreation with them, Kerala.

Do you work outside the home, Prisca?

That has nothing to do with anything.

Just because something is commonly done does NOT make it the right thing to do. Nor does it mean that someone should shut up and tolerate something they do not like in THEIR MARRIAGE.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/25/11 10:00 PM
CWMI! I was just looking for my post from last year on your thread...immediately thought of you.
Posted By: CWMI Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/25/11 10:12 PM
Yeah, this topic has my name all over it. Not the 3-some thing, the work thing, lol. Hbd, my thread "duped" has my long hard battle with just this, if you have a few days to read it. smile
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/25/11 10:18 PM
CWMI -- and...the first time I've ever seen you post on SAA forum!

Hot issue for me, too.

Sorry to TJ.
Posted By: markos Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/25/11 10:20 PM
Originally Posted by kerala
Originally Posted by Prisca
There's a difference between working with members of the opposite sex and having recreation with them, Kerala.

Do you work outside the home, Prisca?

No, my wife does not work outside of our home at this time, but she would certainly be offended if I was engaging in recreation with women I work with, and for that reason, I do not do it.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/25/11 10:59 PM
Kerala,

I am offended by the implication that Prisca or Markos may not get the �real world� or are responding in �cutesie� terms.

There is NOTHING cutesie about establishing boundaries for after hours work events. I attend my own company trips and events, I sponsor customer events, and I also arrange and host after-hours events. Any event that I have a hand in always includes spouses or guests. And, any event that I am mandated to attend until 10:00 pm or later, I do as a part of my job, but I run..not walk...but, run as nothing business related happens after 10:00 pm.. Period.

I don't want to see what happens, nor do I want to participate in other idiot behavior. Does everyone behave badly? Gosh no. I posted to CWMI last year that we have a �club� of those that just disappear. Some of us go to our rooms, some go to spend the night/time with their husbands or wives, some of break off into different �safer� groups, but we all know who we are. Just like we all know who to avoid.

Any company that does not allow spouses to attend is not a company worth working for. Period. Mine does, and we charge for that which is fair to pay for food/drink/general headcount. NEVER do we do �team building� crap after hours or even during meetings. NEVER do we do �strategy� crap after hours. These are all code words for �save money� and �tax deduction�. I set these things up and have for over 20 years...I know.

Sure, to tell you boss that you're family is more important than a mandatory meeting until midnight might be awkward for about 10 seconds. ? But, not if you've got a newborn, or an ill family member, or a kid that needs help with homework via SKYP...or if YOU are sick...

Not one person is saying one cannot or should not attend a regular meeting. But, to imply that the �real� world has to include IB because it's expected for work reasons is insane. And, to imply that anyone not in your �real� world is misinformed is also ludicrous.

It's 2011, not the 50s.
Originally Posted by 2time2timer
Hi, I'm David ...as in the Hurt By David, David (hbd's husband). I really want my wife to go with me on the boat trip. I really don't like spending more time with my co workers then I need to and I really miss my wife when I don't get to spend time with her. Especially at the end of the week when that's the whole motivation to get through the work week. As a manager in my company it's strongly encouraged for me to participate in theses team events. That's a big reason why I wanted to tell my boss of my past so he would either understand why I wouldn't participate in theses events or why it was so important to be able to bring my wife along. I can understand why my wife doesn't want to go, I work with whiny people and they will complain. Although I don't care. My peers and manager get it, only the ones that report to me and other managers are like that.











You crack me up, David. I also hate whiny people. And somewhere in there, I "get" you.

I think what you mean about the whining is that you don't want to have to come back to work after one of these events and have to listen to the others griping about how "they" participated, and "YOU got out of it". People like this somehow expect an explanation from you, and while you can deal with their whining, you just do not want to have to deal with all of their discussion about your life and why you did not go.

I deal with this at work as well. I am definitely NOT a social events person. I do not "do" baby showers, wedding showers, and all that yadda-yadda stuff. Drives me batty. I also don't do the company parties, the dinners, the other stuff they just insist is important. When we travel to conferences, they all go out to these dinners and comedy clubs and all these places as a group. I stay and read in the peace and quiet of my hotel room, where I can Google the latest neuro text, or really delve into the linguistic whatever.....that's my idea of fun.

They used to laugh at me, but now that they have begun to "understand" that this is just who I am, they ultimately have accepted that this is the way things are with me. Take it or leave it, and I actually do not care if they whine.

Here is your new mantra for the workplace social routines:


"I practice indifference."


Schoolbus
Quote
Do you work outside the home, Prisca?
I don't want to speak for you, Prisca, but: Prisca doesn't need to work outside of the home to understand the danger of excluding spouses during a socializing event. Do any of us? crazy

Back in my younger, pre-married days, I attended a number of 'team-building' events. There was lip service paid to the team building, and then it was time to hang out and relax (read "drink too much and wonder the next day what you did that might embarrass you"). Whooo-boy, the stuff I saw. naughty

There is NO PLACE for socializing events that exclude spouses. It is disrespectful for an employer to even put together something like that, as well as potentially dangerous legally for their company.
Posted By: Tom2010 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/25/11 11:41 PM
Surfer88,

To my knowledge most Fortune 500 AND middle-size corporations now do not sponsor evening "employee" events w/o spouses or significant others, and they haven't for several years. A compnay I worked for back in the '80s sponsored some pretty lavish events - dinner and preferred seating at a major play in Chicago, private admission to the Monet exhibit at the Art Institute, late evening ride on someone's yacht out in Lake MI after a dinner - that sort of stuff. They made good profits then and wanted to reward and impress their employees. But, and a big but, pretty much everyone at the corporate headquarters knew everyone else, or were at least acquainted, and if someone who everyone knew was married showed up w/o their spouse, or tried to hit on someone even with their spouse there it became common knowledge and was frowned on. It was self regulatory. Even as recently as just a couple of years ago the mid-size company I worked for and still consult with sponsored a day outing at the Arlington Race Track. Fun yeah, I think I won about $20 even tho I had never been to a race track before, but again I didn't feel anyone went there to use this as an opportunity to hit on someone or allow themself to be hit on! So, it depends on the organization and more importantly the culture, as well as the people! The two companies I worked for were classy.

Tom
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/25/11 11:56 PM
"They used to laugh at me, but now that they have begun to "understand" that this is just who I am, they ultimately have accepted that this is the way things are with me. Take it or leave it, and I actually do not care if they whine."

Same here...I have to give my "speech" often about how I engergize alone (this is true)...now it's not an issue after years of ribbing about me being the party pooper. Truth is, some of us (girls) gather in our rooms and play cards until 3 a.m.

And, we have a blast!

Tom is right. Lots of employers are now very hip to the idea of including spouses - and the reason is clear: they see the affair issue in the workplace as dangerous! Lawsuits abound.

We just had a legal update at work, and the attorney presented a top-ten list for us.

Her number 2 on the list for lawsuits???? "Affairs with co-workers or spouses of co-workers".


I sat there and just smirked. Because I knew that my neighbor had just been demoted because of this exact issue, and so had her boss. They were co-workers, and also, the boss' wife works for the same company. The wife had enough of the rumors, filed a complaint against her own husband, and got him demoted. I guess she must have seen a website or something?

Oh. BTW, I also heard a rumor that affair is busted up. The OW is really mad at her former boss. LOL
Quote
Oh. BTW, I also heard a rumor that affair is busted up. The OW is really mad at her former boss.
DANG that employer for screwing up her affair! rotflmao
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 12:15 AM
Tom,

You are right, in theory. The fact is...events are held whether spouses are invited or not. The responsibility of who actually goes or doesn't is the employees' and the company can object or not.

OMG, you must be kidding! No disrespect, but in my world spouses are NEVER formally invited. N.e.v.e.r. They are not "uninvited", but it's up to the spouse to invite/include, and pay for (as it should be, in my opinion) them.

I actually think that your perception is just the opposite of today. Today, it is just too expensive to invite spouses. (great companies allow a cost to the employee to have their spouse attend.) And, self-regulation is a nice concept, but happens to those that only wish to do so, as it has been for the last 500 years? See my "club" post. Back in the 80s there was not so much litigation either. Companies are far too exposed to the suits idiots bring forth as a result of their own mistakes.

Ie: "I got drunk and slept with Joe. Now he is ignoring me. Lawsuit!"
Quote
OMG, you must be kidding! No disrespect, but in my world spouses are NEVER formally invited. N.e.v.e.r. They are not "uninvited", but it's up to the spouse to invite/include, and pay for (as it should be, in my opinion) them.
Smart employers avoid this issue by asking for RSVP's and tacking on an additional cost for the spouses. Easy.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 12:29 AM
SB,

I take 100 years to type 2 paragraphs.

You are all are right, but I can tell you that NO evolution in inviting spouses is happening or paid for based on family values. What's different is that it's not discouraged. Nor encouraged. Businesses do not know the path to take to avoid the lawsuits. Sorry for the reality.

I am IN the meetings. It's about litigation and warnings about public indiscretions and potential fallout.

So, what does that mean?

Nothing if one is going to allow any business, job or employer to dictate what is right for their marrige and family.

Back to EPS and POJA.


Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 12:35 AM
My point is, if a company tries to gaslight you, call them on it, or find a different job.
Posted By: Surfer88 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 12:37 AM
Exactly. Smart employers.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 01:21 AM
Originally Posted by CWMI
Yeah, this topic has my name all over it. Not the 3-some thing, the work thing, lol. Hbd, my thread "duped" has my long hard battle with just this, if you have a few days to read it. smile

Will do! Thanks.
Posted By: Tom2010 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 01:28 AM
Hi Surfer was intending to post something elsewhere but this seems a topic. The bottom line is that employers, at least those who I have been associated with don't hold employee events to be a playgound. There are probably some who don't care about the morals, but I have to feel most do.

And no, it isn't "too expensive" to invite spouses, at least for the firms that are successful. Look, another example from just my life is all, but even the owner of the hardware store where I worked only one day a week as a supervisor just a few years ago wanted to make that spouses were included in any kind of company event. Simple dinner at local pizza place but would have wondered it my wife wasn't there. Again, it goes to the culture.

Tom
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 01:49 AM
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by CWMI
Yeah, this topic has my name all over it. Not the 3-some thing, the work thing, lol. Hbd, my thread "duped" has my long hard battle with just this, if you have a few days to read it. smile

Will do! Thanks.

OMG ...80 pages? Um, can you summarize or just give me your advice? dontknow
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 01:56 AM
H told another co-worker about the affair yesterday. I was really surprised because not too long ago, he didn't want anyone to know. Now he's telling people when there is no need! Anyway, he says he wants people to know why he isn't on the boat trip and for people to know why he won't be going to any events without me.

Posted By: CWMI Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 01:58 AM
Complain about things you don't like, be firm and steady, don't compromise, spend lots of fun time together working on a common goal, don't be afraid of exposure, ask for what you want, do not settle for less. Ignore anyone who uses the phrase "real world", they are often morally wrong, very, very wrong.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 02:03 AM
Originally Posted by hbd
H told another co-worker about the affair yesterday. I was really surprised because not too long ago, he didn't want anyone to know. Now he's telling people when there is no need! Anyway, he says he wants people to know why he isn't on the boat trip and for people to know why he won't be going to any events without me.

The co-worker (a married man with 4 kids) said something like "oh, I can see how that could happen." David said he almost told him to read HNHN because obviously he needs to affair proof his marriage! It made me smile because he now sees how that mindset is dangerous. smile
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 02:04 AM
Quote
H told another co-worker about the affair yesterday. I was really surprised because not too long ago, he didn't want anyone to know. Now he's telling people when there is no need! Anyway, he says he wants people to know why he isn't on the boat trip and for people to know why he won't be going to any events without me.
This is a great step for him, hbd laugh
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 02:05 AM
Originally Posted by CWMI
Complain about things you don't like, be firm and steady, don't compromise, spend lots of fun time together working on a common goal, don't be afraid of exposure, ask for what you want, do not settle for less. Ignore anyone who uses the phrase "real world", they are often morally wrong, very, very wrong.

Thanks!!!
Originally Posted by hbd
H told another co-worker about the affair yesterday. I was really surprised because not too long ago, he didn't want anyone to know. Now he's telling people when there is no need! Anyway, he says he wants people to know why he isn't on the boat trip and for people to know why he won't be going to any events without me.
This is huge - good for him!
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 02:07 AM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
H told another co-worker about the affair yesterday. I was really surprised because not too long ago, he didn't want anyone to know. Now he's telling people when there is no need! Anyway, he says he wants people to know why he isn't on the boat trip and for people to know why he won't be going to any events without me.
This is a great step for him, hbd laugh

I know. I'm so pleased. The last bit of fog might finally be clearing? grin
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 02:43 AM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
Prisca doesn't need to work outside of the home to understand the danger of excluding spouses during a socializing event. Do any of us?
Tell me about it smile A few years ago, Markos' company decided that, in order to build morale, they were going to set up an office secret pal program. It "encouraged closer relationships."

I was hot the moment I heard about it. Our marriage was rocky. It wouldn't have been difficult at all for some woman to get all cozy with Markos, leave him notes and small gifts, fill him up with Admiration and sweet talk. It wouldn't have been difficult for him to have hidden all that from me. All with the permission of their employer.

Still makes me gag to think of it. What nerve to set up such a thing.

Markos didn't participate. laugh
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 02:45 AM
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
H told another co-worker about the affair yesterday. I was really surprised because not too long ago, he didn't want anyone to know. Now he's telling people when there is no need! Anyway, he says he wants people to know why he isn't on the boat trip and for people to know why he won't be going to any events without me.
This is a great step for him, hbd laugh

I know. I'm so pleased. The last bit of fog might finally be clearing? grin


hurray
Quote
Markos' company decided that, in order to build moral, they were going to set up an office secret pal program.
faint And these people get paid to come up with these big ideas. I have no words.

Caveat: Unless it was a male/male or female/female secret pal. Totally different. Totally acceptable in that case. Somehow I suspect the company wasn't that conscious.
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 02:57 AM
Quote
Caveat: Unless it was a male/male or female/female secret pal. Totally different. Totally acceptable in that case. Somehow I suspect the company wasn't that conscious.
No, they weren't frown
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 01:48 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by CWMI
Complain about things you don't like, be firm and steady, don't compromise, spend lots of fun time together working on a common goal, don't be afraid of exposure, ask for what you want, do not settle for less. Ignore anyone who uses the phrase "real world", they are often morally wrong, very, very wrong.

Thanks!!!

I will continue to be firm about my stance on the subject and not settle, but how do I do this without making DJs or demands?
Posted By: CWMI Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/26/11 04:42 PM
Originally Posted by hbd
I will continue to be firm about my stance on the subject and not settle, but how do I do this without making DJs or demands?

Well, I am certainly NOT the poster child for avoiding DJs or demands, lol. However, to be radically honest you need to express how you feel about things. If he continued to cause you resentment by not sticking to your extraordinary precautions, would you end up hating him or feeling indifferent toward him? If so, then that is what you say to him. "I want to be in love with you. When you do something that violates our extraordinary precautions, I feel resentful toward you. I'm afraid that eventually that resentment will build into hate/indifference." You avoid telling him what to do, but you give him the information he needs to make a choice. Then he is consciously CHOOSING whether he wants you to love him or not. Ideally, you both will agree to POJA decisions, and I think that's possible for you based on this boat thing.

But based on some of your other decisions, I think you need to be extra cautious to not POJA things that are bad for your marriage. No agreement on things like, "Hey, I think we should shoot each other in the head. How do you feel about that?" "Oh, honey, I think that's a great idea! Should we use pistols or shotguns?" "Hm, well my dad has a couple of .44's, we could probably borrow those. Would you like me to call him and ask?" "Oh sure! Does Saturday at 4pm sound like a good time to do this?" "Lemme check...yep, Saturday at 4 works for me." "Oh, I am so glad that our marriage is so good that we can make these kind of decisions together!" rofl. You know what I mean.

Quick and dirty tip to avoid DJs: validate his opinion even if you have a different one, and when you state your opinion, do so in a way that avoids negating his. Even better if you can state it in a way that gives admiration.

For instance, we had what could be called the Doughnut Fiasco. My H started a new job and announced he was going to bring in a bunch of doughnuts to, as he put it, "Get in with the service team." I didn't like this one bit, I felt like my H was constantly doing and doing for people in order to get them to like him, which I find incredibly unattractive, and it sets up, imo, a lopsided relationship where one is the giver (H) and the other is a taker (everyone else). The board had a BLAST with this conflict. Anyway, I ended up telling him that I thought it would be better to wait to do something like that (this was during his first week there) until after he got to know the service team because he was the type of person who could 'get in' with anyone based on his personality alone. He liked that and agreed to hold off on the doughnuts. The whole sordid tale is on one of my threads.

And you avoid demands just like that. "I think this, I would do this, If someone did that I would think that." If you approach conversations as a time to share information, you'll avoid demands. I think it was melody who said that asking someone to NOT do something is not a demand. A simple, "Please don't do that, that would hurt," should suffice in most instances.
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by hbd
H told another co-worker about the affair yesterday. I was really surprised because not too long ago, he didn't want anyone to know. Now he's telling people when there is no need! Anyway, he says he wants people to know why he isn't on the boat trip and for people to know why he won't be going to any events without me.

The co-worker (a married man with 4 kids) said something like "oh, I can see how that could happen." David said he almost told him to read HNHN because obviously he needs to affair proof his marriage! It made me smile because he now sees how that mindset is dangerous. smile


This is amazing hbd, well done you two...!
Posted By: Tom2010 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/27/11 01:55 AM
hbd,

Well a little confused. Posted here other night but now thinking this may be a comedy farce hypothetical deal. Or just that maybe I am too old now to keep up!..*s*

On the other hand maybe some of you would be good candidates to convince Michelle Bachmann that Paul Revere's ride had nothing to do with warning the French that the Germans were coming! He lived a few years earlier.....


Tom

Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/27/11 02:05 PM
Originally Posted by Tom2010
hbd,

Well a little confused. Posted here other night but now thinking this may be a comedy farce hypothetical deal. Or just that maybe I am too old now to keep up!..*s*

I assure you, this is not a farce or hypothetical. This is my life. I suppose some might consider my life to be a comedy, but I feel it's more of a tragedy.
Posted By: Tom2010 Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/28/11 01:53 AM
Now that you commented, I just want to assure you I don't view your current life situation as a comedy. Just was when I tuned in here it seemed like quite a off-track or levity comments. I think that might come from fact that your opening comments were entertaining an open marriage, not realizing what your wishing for, and then coming around to complain about it. If you're really serious about retrenching, which I hope you are, then I wish you well. Just keep in mind that whatever you two did has become a part of the history of your marriage.

Tom
Posted By: Prisca Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/28/11 02:02 AM
I think she's well aware of that. She and her husband are really beginning to make progress. He's starting to impress me, and I have no doubt that if they continue down the MB path that they're following, they're gonna end up alright smile

(tj: this is my 700th post ... that's a lot of talking for me! okay, end tj)
add t/j
Quote
(tj: this is my 700th post ... that's a lot of talking for me! okay, end tj)
Yay, Prisca! You da woman! hurray
end t/j smile
Originally Posted by Prisca
(tj: this is my 700th post ... that's a lot of talking for me! okay, end tj)

continuing TJ/ Awesome Prisca! Only 50,000+ more posts to catch Mel. I love reading your posts (and Markos' too). I think it's very cool when you guys tag team sometimes.

/continuing TJ
Posted By: CWMI Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/28/11 03:38 AM
Originally Posted by hbd
Originally Posted by Tom2010
hbd,

Well a little confused. Posted here other night but now thinking this may be a comedy farce hypothetical deal. Or just that maybe I am too old now to keep up!..*s*

I assure you, this is not a farce or hypothetical. This is my life. I suppose some might consider my life to be a comedy, but I feel it's more of a tragedy.

If you go by traditional thought, a comedy ends in marriage, and tragedy ends in death, so your life will most certainly be both. You can get out of marrying, but nobody gets out of dying!
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/28/11 03:46 PM
Originally Posted by CWMI
If you go by traditional thought, a comedy ends in marriage, and tragedy ends in death, so your life will most certainly be both. You can get out of marrying, but nobody gets out of dying!

LOL!! True. crazy
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/28/11 03:57 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
I think she's well aware of that. She and her husband are really beginning to make progress. He's starting to impress me, and I have no doubt that if they continue down the MB path that they're following, they're gonna end up alright smile

(tj: this is my 700th post ... that's a lot of talking for me! okay, end tj)

Thanks Prisca!!! I really appreciate your support.

Congrats on reaching 700 posts!
Originally Posted by Prisca
I think she's well aware of that. She and her husband are really beginning to make progress. He's starting to impress me, and I have no doubt that if they continue down the MB path that they're following, they're gonna end up alright smile

(tj: this is my 700th post ... that's a lot of talking for me! okay, end tj)


Im not a vet but have to agree as far as my experience allows me. Hbd has taken all the 2x4s on the chin, taken the advice given by the vets and is persistently working on the marriage. It seems they're doing much much better and putting whats good for the relationship first
Posted By: yaravy Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/29/11 05:05 AM
Oh wow well, finnally I find someone with kinda my problem here.

my husband's fantasy is the one u just did, however I never wanted this and so I told him I won't go for it, and so after lot of investigation I just ended here and reading the book his needs and her needs, now if you read it carefully it says that man are diferent than women, they think about sex more animal way, more like something that u need to have and need to be pleased they don't attach feelings like the way we do, in my brain as a woman am also worry because he told me that if I dont go for it he is ok, that he really doesn't need it, but he was just curious about it and it would be so great if i would, so in my head am always thinking that if he is gonna love me less for not doing it , or if he is going to cheat on me with someone who will.
Now the trick here is, Make your husband read the books so he can understand YOU and work out like if this was an infidelity wich techically speaking it was becuause you both brought someone else in the equation.

if u still feel bad and feel like your husband is going to ask for it again, then get professional help to fix it, sometimes there's only so much you two can do by your own, don't feel ashame to speak ur problem to a profesional, lots of ppl ends in this problem and mostly is the wife who ends feeling bad.
Posted By: yaravy Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/29/11 05:37 AM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
Originally Posted by ManInMotion
Originally Posted by Scotland
Infidelity harms a marriage, adultery harms a marriage, and THIS has harmed THIS marriage.

However, the reasons WHY the M is harmed are different. Affairs involve some level of dishonesty on the part of one spouse, in order to get their needs met outside of the M. Was any of that involved here?

What has happened here is that in the M, one spouse has apparently had a need met by the other, at the expense of the other.

I think that something a bit more than using the usual MB A-busting techniques needs to be involved here. I would start by trying to find out why her H was so enthusiastic, before AND after, about indulging in the threesome.

Has he asked for any more, BTW?


I think you're right about digging for the reasons beneath and putting the focus on him. He is probably the more dishonest one and I would hesitate to call him a BS.

However hbd does need to examine her own boundaries and weaknesses too. I appreciate she hasnt been overtly dishonest with her h, but she was ok with getting her needs met elsewhere.

She has been brutally honest with us here (and with herself) and that will allow us to help her avoid more adultery on either part.

Ok I think what happened here is that she was confused on her feelings and am gonna tell you why, my husband had the same fantasy, that's right, and I hate the idea.

Now this kinds of fantasies surely crosses lots of ppls mind women and man, however, when it did in my brain was because my husband wasn't affective and open and never gave me sex like I wanted i mean in the romantic way, that he would foreplay and seduce me at all, he just wanted me like a porn movie masturbate and be ready for him to stick me, so while doing sex I always fantasy on having a good romantic love with him, and sometimes i thought aobut another guy doing the things he wasn't doing, so there you go i was cheating on my husband in my head.

Now there part I think she was confused and thought she liked the 3 some was because there was a lack of affection from her husband and demonstration of care from him and she thought that by doing this he would open and show her affection the way she wanted and turned to be a failure. evidently she was looking for something totaly diferent than his husband. now did she enjoy it at the moment of course like any other animal that gets stimulated, we can't forget we are animals after all, however women's brain is diferent than man and she gets to see this with regreat and confusion while her husband doesn't because he had what he was looking for while she didn't.
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/29/11 12:50 PM
Originally Posted by indiegirl
Originally Posted by Prisca
I think she's well aware of that. She and her husband are really beginning to make progress. He's starting to impress me, and I have no doubt that if they continue down the MB path that they're following, they're gonna end up alright smile

(tj: this is my 700th post ... that's a lot of talking for me! okay, end tj)


Im not a vet but have to agree as far as my experience allows me. Hbd has taken all the 2x4s on the chin, taken the advice given by the vets and is persistently working on the marriage. It seems they're doing much much better and putting whats good for the relationship first

Thanks for your support Indie!!
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/29/11 01:03 PM
Originally Posted by yaravy
Oh wow well, finnally I find someone with kinda my problem here.

my husband's fantasy is the one u just did, however I never wanted this and so I told him I won't go for it, and so after lot of investigation I just ended here and reading the book his needs and her needs, now if you read it carefully it says that man are diferent than women, they think about sex more animal way, more like something that u need to have and need to be pleased they don't attach feelings like the way we do, in my brain as a woman am also worry because he told me that if I dont go for it he is ok, that he really doesn't need it, but he was just curious about it and it would be so great if i would, so in my head am always thinking that if he is gonna love me less for not doing it , or if he is going to cheat on me with someone who will.
Now the trick here is, Make your husband read the books so he can understand YOU and work out like if this was an infidelity wich techically speaking it was becuause you both brought someone else in the equation.

if u still feel bad and feel like your husband is going to ask for it again, then get professional help to fix it, sometimes there's only so much you two can do by your own, don't feel ashame to speak ur problem to a profesional, lots of ppl ends in this problem and mostly is the wife who ends feeling bad.

Hi Yaravy,

Thanks for your feedback.

I think my situation is a little different from yours though because I fantasized about being with two men. I have to be honest, it was a turn-on for me. I wasn't talked into doing anything I didn't want to do at the time.

It was only after I went through with the 3some that I realized it only made matters worse. The guilt over committing adultery was overwhelming for me.

My H and I have agreed that we will NOT be doing anything like that again!
Posted By: hbd Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 08/31/11 03:37 PM
Originally Posted by schoolbus
Read "Leadership and Self-Deception: Getting out of the box" by The Arbinger Institute.

It can lead you to understand when you betray yourself, which leads you to betray others around you.

It would also be good for hubby.


Can help with those EPs - and explains what I am talking about.

SB

Schoolbus,

I looked at this book and it appears to be associated with business decisions. Am I missing something?

While looking at this book, Amazon recommended "Bonds That Make Us Free - Healing Our Relationships, Coming To Ourselves," which apparently describes the same things as the book you recommended. Have you read that one?
Posted By: Tanam Re: Is a threesome cheating if it's POJA'd? - 09/01/11 09:33 AM
It's a brilliant book

what applies in business also applies in relationships. It's one that helped me and I also like their website.

Give it a go, it's a short but powerful read.
© Marriage Builders® Forums