Marriage Builders
Posted By: Monc My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/06/09 09:35 PM
AUGUST, DECEMBER,JANUARY AND FEBRUARY ARE THE KEY PORTIONS IF YOUR IMPATIENT TO UNDERSTAND THE WHOLE PICTURE.

My wife is having an affair with another man and is trying to justify to herself why we should not be married.

The below information will have inaccuracies, but the general information is as close to accurate as can be.

Summary of her reaction to leaving the other man:
First time, she said she’d have to go through that depression again which made her want to kill herself. That made me back off at the time because I love her, and don’t want her to hurt herself.

The second time I asked she was more bolstered and said no she wouldn’t.

The third time she said she would never leave him.

The fourth she told me it wasn’t him she was leaving me for, it was because she was leaving me.


In one of our conversations she broke down and said, "Please don't tell my family, don't take them away from me." So her family knowing is a big deal and it's an action that I'm slowly coming to realize maybe my only choice but also at the cost of her because she'll hate me.


MISCILANEOUS INFORMATION CONCERNING TIME USAGE OR LOSS BETWEEN US: I began Mid-shifts(7pm-7am in the morning.) July 1st. I was on it from July 1st to Jan 1st. I would sleep at 7am to 3am and later often since I’m able to go for 9-10 hours if not woken.

Throughout the whole summer my wife told me that while I was sleeping she would wander around town bored out of her mind. She exclaimed how she would try and wake me and I wouldn’t get up from bed. Except I must argue that many times I’d get up at 12pm or other times for pre-scheduled events together sacrificing some sleep. I will admit some times I did stay up past 7am to around 9am before going to bed.[/b]

I have been through so much as you'd expect.

I have known about the attraction my wife has had to the other man for years, but trusted my wife to not do anything wrong with him. This last year we've had a hard time.

This all begins from June-July.

[b](June)
In June on my first month off of teaching school for her summer I spent the whole month building my new computer. I was very proud of the accomplishment because it’s not easy to do but WW had no appreciation for my devotion to the effort. She saw it as me ignoring her COMPLETELY. And in some ways I admit I did for it. The thing that didn’t occur to me was how bored she must have been downstairs with 24 hours a day to herself. At the time she was spending her time writing a “novella”. Which made it seem like she was enjoying herself none the less because for all my efforts I couldn’t get her away from writing that thing.

In July-September I did an English class.

What she failes to realize is that she blames me for ignoring her, but she has gone and done Playhouse shows that consume her entire evenings for months at a time and I only loved her the more for her devotion to something she loved. I spent that kind of time building a machine at expert precision capabilities and she had no love for the effort.

(JULY) Then my wife and the other man got in a fight where my wife was lied to by him several times about other girls he was dating and she was mad that he kept concealing the fact that there were other girls he was dating. To me I was a bit confused why it mattered but only saw that it was the "lying" that was upsetting her and not for the RED FLAG clue that she had something going on with him. I thought she was mad that he was just not telling her about his life when she’d ask.

Mid July) We went to a family gathering in Johnson City where I was working on an advanced English writing course. During the event I spent much of my time hanging with the family and on the last day was forced to sit down and finish my essay paper. Simply because a family event converged with school does not mean I didn’t spent time with the family. No gaming books or gaming in my head just family and school so I see no fault in this.

(AUGUST 10-14) At one point in August the other man was leaving to a place hours away for good. My wife asked if she could kiss him good bye. Being me, I trusted her and eventually conceded that a lip-to-lip good bye kiss would be fine. Then later she confessed the kiss became a deep affectionate kiss and I was stunned. (She said that the kiss was when she felt that she was in love with the other man.) She said nothing else happened though so I let it go. I had posted on another forum elsewhere and many folks suggested "affair" yet I trusted her a great deal that I figured the kiss had to be all it that happened. And after some personal turmoil I let it go. Inside of this date we both went on a min-vacation because we both felt that we should spend some together time. And I now recall that it was enjoyable but she wasn’t all there. She seemed distracted.

(FACTS: She slept with him multiple times in August and maybe before. She told me the kiss was first then a few days later they slept together. Later I pieced together based on the number of times she admitted that they were sleeping together more than that and that the KISS did not precipitate the affair like she let me believe. She let me blame myself for letting her kiss him.


(August 15) Then the other man finally left for his distant location in the middle of August which was the same week of the kiss. This was the end of their friendship because they had some HUGE fight and they were not talking anymore and I was a bit happy about this personally because that kiss bothered the [censored] out of me.

When the other man left it was under bad terms later. Apparently he slept with my wife and also had someone else on the side. So he was double-timing her. I don't understand why she is still wanting to be with him. This was an actual break up between them up till DECEMBER when he came back and apologized.

(August Thanksgiving) I spent the whole weekend with the family and enjoying myself. I brought no gaming books had no gaming in mind and was actually talking to family and spending time enjoying their company. To the detriment of my grade on that Essay paper I only spent an evening working on it. I even talked to Fran and others about the concepts I was learning in class, although everyone was more interested in the A&M game.

(August-October) Was hell. And me on midshift) We talked mildly about how we both knew our relationship was hurting and I couldn't figure out why because my wife wasn't talking to me and she was often very sad that the other man had left which I presumed was because they were best friends. In many ways I spent time with her and was still on mid shift. Almost all mornings she’d get up for work and I’d make her breakfast before going to bed myself because I wanted to show her I loved her and cared for her. I would OFTEN go to bed on my weekends at night with her so we could sleep together and get up together in the day even though it wrecked my sleep schedule. As my normal time for sleep was 7am. Sometimes I would stay up through my sleep time so that in the evening we’d be able to sleep together. Other times I would keep a normal schedule on my weekends so as to keep my normal work/sleep cycle. She took offense to this sometimes because she’d hint at “sex” by asking if I’d come to bed. My response would be that I can’t, I have to stay up, I’m on mids. Not once did she tell me it was innuendo for come down stairs to make love to me. She’d get PISSED and storm downstairs. This happened several times and she wouldn’t explain why she was so mad. She expected me to read her mind. The irony was that she blames me playing computer games. I’m so sorry that I didn’t understand. Each of those times I was playing with long distance friends who I barely spoke to and several times with her family of her own.

From Mid October to Mid December I did a Computer course and an Algebra course which consumed a massive chunk of time. The Computer course was busy work that I’d get done when at work and the Algebra I’d work on at home. I passed the Computer course but failed Algebra.

(OCTOBER 15th to Nov) I had been doing my two Courses. A Computer class that was busy work and the Algebra course. The course’s were demanding on me for many reasons. Having been homeschooled the California education system had a loophole that let me pass High School without having done any pre-algebra type coursework. So Intermediate Algebra was an entirely new concepts and having to relearn mathematical methods I’d not used in seven years. I from week two had fallen behind a week the whole way through and was struggling to catch up every week till the end. If my wife would recall how much I bitched about math and how stressed, crying, angry, and frustrated I was at the course. That just as I understood a concept the damn class pushed me to use it with another one I barely understood until eventually everything was mashed together and I couldn’t figure out how to break the numbers apart. This ate into my entire life and free time. In the Computer course I had even let several assignments fail knowing I could still get an “A” to give me more time at the Algebra course.

(November) She hit me with a doozy that she was falling out of love with me. I was shocked. For a moment I almost agreed that I was too but realized quickly it was simply that my work schedule kept us from spending quality time together and the school work on top of that. Unfortunately I had just started a new term of Mids for three months and nobody would trade shifts with me. So I redoubled my efforts to spend time with her. I came up with dates and places to go and movies and dinner as often as we could muster. I even came up with going to the MET opera, Phantom of the Opera(her idea), and if I recall Rent. The problem was that just as I tried to start spending more time with her she started a semi-professional playhouse production. My weekends were Friday night-Sunday night. The only night we had off together was Sundays. The production she started also used up Friday and Saturday for rehearsal. So I was SOL at spending time with her even more so now. Sundays we’d spend time but she was always so tired she just wanted to rest and our nightlife went to [censored] and it didn’t help that I was absorbed in my Algebra work almost every Sunday and even had to take leave time several times to hold off heading into work those evenings trying to complete coursework. I was used to her being unavailable in the past when she did playhouse productions so just let her be and did my own thing as well. We just had a very unfortunate last three months of 2008.

(December) This is about when the other man came into the picture again I believe. They had begun to apologies and make up as friends, so I thought. My wife asked if it was ok for them to mend their friendship and confusedly I said exactly, “I suppose so,” because I recalled the overly passionate kiss. Yet I trusted her and so let them start talking again. She was still doing the playhouse productions all through December. Then middle of December she told me that she HAD fallen out of love with me. I was shocked. I was hurt and afraid. I was desperate to recover. I was desperate for my next shift rotation to begin so I could be back on Days on Jan 1st and we could work on our relationship.

Then I came to a conclusion at the end of December as pieces fell into place in my head that this falling out of love coincided with the return of the other man. That she and the other man were in love and when I asked her she reluctantly said she probably was. I was stunned. I had to ask and she didn't tell me. She said she didn’t know how it happened and that it just did. We had a conversation where she promised that no matter what I could ask a question and she would tell me the truth. When I’ve asked for the truth she in the future beyond this point has obscured facts let me think I was at fault, or that an action determined certain events. She has consistently left me to determine the facts out of what she’s told me. I have no idea how true anything she has said is because of this.

(January) Now knowing they had affections I told her that they could not be together alone. She reluctantly agreed. I didn’t realize that there was reluctance until later. Immediately she broke that promise and drove him home one night, but she told me. And I said NEVER AGAIN. She again broke that promise when his car broke down and he had to get to his college several hours away. When she got home utterly late I asked what happened and she first lied to me about her whereabouts. Then came clean and told me that she drove the other man all the way to his college two hours away. I asked how long a drive it was and she said two hours. Both ways is 4 hours and this was at night so no traffic. The total trip time was 5 hours and 30 minutes. I caught the discrepancy when I asked what time they left town. She said 8pm. I asked how long to get there. 2 hours. She stayed at his place for an hour and a half longer than necessary. She arrived home at 1:30am. I decided to trust her and let it be. She still claims nothing happened. I am unsure due to all the lies now.

I then woke up one evening at 1am to hear her on the phone with him and saying his name and saying "I love you so very much." And then they talked about e-mails and an upcoming weekend that they'll get to see each other. Which was in Houston on the 23rd. I listened through our bedroom door for thirty minutes as they flirted and talked about an e-mail which at that point my wife’s voice dropped to a near whisper saying, “I won’t mention the contents, but you’ll like it.” She eventually hung up, I quickly went and got back into bed and five minutes later came out of the bedroom to use the restroom and got some water. She asked if I had woken her and I said, no, why? And she said no reason at all just that she was still up grading papers. (Previously in the evening I had even tried to devise a way to help her do faster in fact, but only one person can log into the database at a time she said. This is only mentioned to show that I try to support her as much as I can.)

This led to me going from concerned to afraid. I then for the first time in my life broke my trust of privacy to her and looked at her e-mails. What I discovered shocked and tore me apart. I couldn’t read them clearly through all the tears and crying. They were loving, and talking about dirty thoughts and such. I then constantly told her that she can’t be alone with him. Under ALL terms not alone. Then I tried to ask her not to go. She got mad at me for that because money had been paid to go. She probably was apprehensive about my actions and concerns but didn’t show it.

I spent the whole week up to the convention in a severe panic. I couldn’t sleep and was a nervous wreck because the e-mails talked about being loving and how much they loved each other. I couldn’t confront My wife because I knew she’d see the violation of her privacy as a criminal thing…but here I was confronting the possibility of infidelity.

Then she left for the Houston convention.

She got her own hotel.

His room was at the convention center.

I then still in a panic went day to day scared out of my mind. I then reread all the e-mails and was able to not cry. I then saw the most criminal line ever,”…us singing next to each other together in bed.”

I called her immediately and asked her point blank, "did you sleep with the other man. She paused for a while and said,”Yes.” When I asked the obvious question,”Why?” She said “Why else does someone sleep with another?” She wanted to hang up then and I wanted to talk. I called back three times and she finally started yelling and crying for me to leave her alone. I found out later that the other man spent the whole night holding her while she cried.

(KEEP IN MIND THAT I HAD TO DISCOVER THE AFFAIR): She told me that she didn’t tell me about it in August because she didn’t want me to tell her to stop. And against our pre-marital agreement concerning always telling about potential or actual affairs, she did not tell me after the fact either. She claims to have not told me to protect me, later she professed that that she didn’t tell me to protect herself.

When she got home I had bought flowers for her. I wanted her to know I still love her.

She claims nothing happened at Houston (Or ever since August). I do know they were alone together in a car trip. And that in the same car trip was when I called. I do know they spent that night together. I don’t know if sexual activity occurred that weekend but she claims nothing had happened. In any event, she has been having an emotional affair with him since the middle of December up to this point.

Since then they’ve been talking constantly and phoning, text messaging, e-mailing, and using Facebook to communicate.

My wife has refused to sever contact with him. She say’s if she were to pick she would pick him over me.

We started counseling which she initiated, but she is not taking it seriously so far. The counselors said sever contact with the other man and she didn’t. She resents him now for that.

The same week I discovered the cheating the 23rd-25th of January I moved out of the house to a friend’s at HER request(I chose to go because I wanted to be able to find her easily). She said either of us could move out but she wanted a separation. This coincided with my discovery of her affair. (Distance in my mind, so she could continue it without me hovering to interfere.)She claimed I was hovering. And DAMN RIGHT I WAS! SHE"S MY WIFE WHO I LOVE!

The very first counseling meeting (Her and him alone) the counselor told her that she had to leave the other man. Since then she has hated him and doesn’t like him. She went to three sessions on her own. And still has maintained contact with the other man.

(February)
My wife wouldn’t leave the other man but she tried to compromise that she’d talk to him less. I had a hard time believing this because I had moved out and obviously couldn’t monitor her.
We’ve gone to two counselor sessions together only.

On our first meeting at the counselor I had asked “Have you kept to the agreement to reduce communication?” She said,”Yes.” I then asked, “Do you have any plans in the year to see or meet with the other man?” She again said,”No”. I asked again if she was being honest,” She said,”Yes she was being honest!” And got angry at me. I then asked if I could see her e-mail and she resisted at first and then she let me…although she claims I forced her. I then asked if I could read them and she got mad that I was pushing. When we got home and she logged into her e-mail, what I saw was my wife e-mailing the other man every day except one day in a ten day span and obviously not keeping to the compromise.

At that point I was enraged although I hadn’t yelled at her. It was internal. Why was she lying to me and not being honest? At the counselor's even! (KEEP IN MIND IN RED ABOVE THAT SHE SAID SHE WOULD ALWAYS TELL ME THE TRUTH.)

Because she was lying to me I had a need to know what she was saying to him. As she turned away from her computer for a minute I quickly forwarded one of the e-mails to myself. And this e-mail showed that she was meeting him in 17 days which I found out from her was San Marcos(Feb 27th)AGAIN she lied to me! That night she called and asked if I had forwarded one of her e-mails. Being honest I answered right away,”Yes.” Her next words were,”I want a divorce.”
If you notice all of her reasons for divorce are absolutely SHALLOW.

That weekend Feb 7th she went to see her sister Claire who she told everything apparently. My wife had also made a giant box “care package” for the other man of food and who knows what else(found out the picture of them was in it too). Just as she was leaving the apartment while I was there and not at my current residence with my friend, my wife said, ”She just wants us to be friends.” I lost it at that point. I was feeling every painful emotion possible. The whole night I packed my things in the house I didn’t sleep, I didn’t eat, I left letters all over exclaiming how mean to me she is being. I almost collected all the jewelry I ever gave her but put it all back when I realized at that moment I was being vindictive.

I then went to get a picture of her and the other man in her dresser drawer. I really had no idea what I was going to do with it, but it wasn’t there. Instead I found a comparison sheet of ME VS the other man. On the paper it talked about “numerous” sexual encounters with the other man, which did not coincide with her story that she claims. She claimed the kiss premeditated the sexual encounter several days later. She claims I assumed only one time. She told me herself that there was only one time by telling me that the kiss happened first, sex, and then the other man left town. This set me into an even greater rage. Especially that the comparisons were things she could talk to me about and we could work out in counseling.

I was at the apartment driving back and forth between residences moving stuff till around 9am. On my last trip I passed our bank and thought about how people warned me the other spouse can go crazy and take all the money. So I went into the bank to make a checking account for myself just in case. Then my emotions carried me further. I became crushed with fear and took all but $800 from the bank account and moved it to my new checking account. My rational was that I was protecting myself from my wife. Who had been doing nothing but lying to me and cheating on me.

I thought I was being rational considering that I never would have expected her to cheat and lie to me. Then I called her and told her what I did. And as she screamed how I was stealing from her I realized that I was sinking to her level. I was becoming this other person who was not thinking about the consequences of ones actions. I immediately turned around and put all our money back into the bank.

Since then she has held that over my head as being a greater crime than her infidelity.

Then I returned to the apartment and cleaned up all my pissed and angry messages (which I wrote and put around the apartment), cleaned the house and made the bed. I then started taking the wedding candle and pictures to take home with me…then realized I’d already had moved more of my stuff out of the house than I knew what to do with. So I left them on the kitchen table and realizing she wanted a divorce decided to light our wedding candle and leave my wedding ring on a picture of us on that wonderful day.

She did not appreciate the melodrama when she got home to find a burning candle and my ring. I also admitted to the messages everywhere and such and she has decided that “she doesn’t feel safe” around me even though I’ve never struck her. I’ve expressed profanity a few times.

We went to dinner one evening of Feb 22nd. We talked and I tried to admit to my wife I’m glad that this mess had occurred because it has changed me in great ways and shown me how much I love her. Her retort was very cruel. That she learned how little she loved me and that she was happy she did it because she found that out. Rather than what I would have wanted which would be,"I realized how much we need to work to improve our marriage."

Since then I’ve yelled at her several times to leave the other man and she exclaims that she won’t. And that if I make her leave him she will “resent” me. She doesn’t even realize that what she is doing is making me resent her. She has used my love for her to protect herself over and over. By saying she wants a divorce it’s made me tiptoe. She doesn’t want her family to know that she is having an affair. She acting entirely on emotion and not even realizing how she is acting. I feel that my wife is not acting out of rational feelings that I am an inadequate husband but that she is infatuated with another man and trying to create reasons to justify her actions.

Our second Counselor meeting I somehow ended up being the one begging for ONE MORE CHANCE. Because of the BANKING INCIDENT. It wasn’t even defined as to what that one more chance was.

And now I don’t know why I was the one begging. I’m the one that was cheated on and has been given half truths and lied to outright in other cases. My feelings are that she is doing the counseling only to show a pretense of effort at fixing our problems for her image. The reason I believe this is because of all the lies and obfuscation of the truth she has provided. If she were honestly working to fix our marriage she would separate herself from the other man and look to make our love stronger.

I recently called two family members and told them everything because they were our marriage sponsors. I felt that they could introduce some wisdom into our marriage issues. I then told my wife I had talked to them and she felt I went over her head. That I’m not allowed to talk to family without consulting her. She has taken this as reason to revoke my ONE MORE CHANCE. And is asking for a Final Divorce.

I feel that she is trying to hide this and at the same time create a case to blame me in her mind. I feel that my only next step is to bring her to her parents and sit down and make her admit the infidelity outloud.


Expose to everybody
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/06/09 09:59 PM
Even if it angers her and causes her to hate me?
Your marriage can survive her anger. IT CAN NOT SURVIVE AN AFFAIR. EXPOSE.

Do not underestimate this.

I will repeat it.

Your marriage can survive her anger. IT. CAN. NOT. SURVIVE. AN. AFFAIR. EXPOSE.

Some veteran MBers will be here soon. TAKE ALL THEIR ADVICE.
Posted By: Gack1 Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/06/09 10:14 PM
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Even if it angers her and causes her to hate me?
YES!!
Quote
Even if it angers her and causes her to hate me?

OK, big news flash here Moncouer, all of the above quote is already true.

So what it it you actually want here? Are you trying to R your M or are you patiently using Plan Hope, where you "hope" she will change her mind and love you again? That ain't going to work, I promise you.

Have you read Dr Harley's Q&A portion of this web site? Please read and inform yourself.

Do you have any idea what marital boundaries are or even look like? You WW asked your permission to have an A and you said yes, because you loved her and trusted her not to really do it.

??????????????????????????

Moncouer, you are about as lost as an easter egg in August.

Could you call the Harley's for counseling, cause without a giant wakeup call, I'm afraid you don't have a clue. Sorry to be so blunt, but your thread borders on ridiculous.

All Blessings,
Jerry

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/06/09 11:15 PM
So what it it you actually want here? Are you trying to R your M or are you patiently using Plan Hope, where you "hope" she will change her mind and love you again? That ain't going to work, I promise you.

I don't know what "R" is? Ruin? NO I"M NOT TRYING TO ruin it, I'm trying to save it. I was trying to do counseling I don't know how to deal with this. Your reply acts like I should know what the [censored] I'm doing...why do you think I'm here?

WHAT WILL WORK THEN?

Have you read Dr Harley's Q&A portion of this web site? Please read and inform yourself.

I've read them and tried them...but she just keeps going further and further away. She won't work with me at all outside of counseling. Sometimes she talks to me but she only finds reason to get angry when I confront her failings.


Do you have any idea what marital boundaries are or even look like? You WW asked your permission to have an A and you said yes, because you loved her and trusted her not to really do it.

I was torn over letting her kiss him to begin with, and should have gone with my gut and told her no. It didn't matter though, she already [censored] him before the kiss. She just asked to try and absolve guilt.



Moncouer, you are about as lost as an easter egg in August.

YEs, yes, I [censored] am.

Could you call the Harley's for counseling, cause without a giant wakeup call, I'm afraid you don't have a clue. Sorry to be so blunt, but your thread borders on ridiculous.

What wakeup and I needing?

All Blessings,
Jerry

[/quote]
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/06/09 11:20 PM
What number?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/06/09 11:24 PM
This site talks about being patient and trying to show her your love and your telling me I'm messing up in trying to be patient? WHAT?

I DON"T KNOW WHAT TO DO!
You need to be patient but you do not need to be a doormat. Work Plan A as best you can and work to kill the A too.

Can someone post the carrot and stick of Plan A?
Originally Posted by Moncouer
I was torn over letting her kiss him to begin with, and should have gone with my gut and told her no. It didn't matter though, she already [censored] him before the kiss. She just asked to try and absolve guilt.


You let her kiss an OM?
Do NOT shield or protect her from any of the guilt she should feel. There are plenty of other people who will do that.
Why in the he77 would you let your wife kiss another man? WAKE UP
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 02:01 AM
*Sigh* I'm ME. That's all I can say.

But your hyper-focusing. She already DID the deed before asking me. So it doesn't really matter that I did other than to show my personality.

What is plan A exactly?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 02:30 AM
I just talked to her father. He's not going to say anything against my wifes actions. He said he would be staying out of it. He said I can talk to him though anytime.

How does exposure work if the family won't help?

I'm more afraid of destroying the relationship by exposure... Everyone around me I've told about the idea thinks it'll only make things worse.

She is already declaring divorce on me.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 03:42 AM
How does a marriage survive divorce in Texas if she is angry?

I'm afraid she'll divorce...she is already claiming she will after finding out I told one pair of family.
Originally Posted by Moncouer
How does a marriage survive divorce in Texas if she is angry?

I'm afraid she'll divorce...she is already claiming she will after finding out I told one pair of family.

Where in Texas are you? Anywhere near Houston? If she intends to file you need to file first. Then you can delay, delay, delay!!

I filed in 2007. I'm not divorced YET!! LOL!! I asked my attorney to delay. Well, did he EVER!!

But anyway, if you are near Houston, let me know. You need the best representation you can get and he is IT!

Charlotte
Originally Posted by Moncouer
How does a marriage survive divorce in Texas if she is angry?

I'm afraid she'll divorce...she is already claiming she will after finding out I told one pair of family.

Mon,

You are falling into a classic pattern that is followed by many BHes on this board. You lack balls and live in fear of upsetting your cheating wife.

Guess what? The men who succeed here are the ones who grow a pair and ACT regardless of how badly it upsets the WW.

Hope will get you nowhere. Action will.

So that means you expose to EVERYONE. Friends, family and OM's family.

Will it tick her off? Yes. Big time.

But the affair will continue if you don't.

And I can't believe you would allow her to disrespect you as she has with LETTING her kiss another man. Absolutely incredible.

So it's time to stop living in fear, grow a pair, and follow plans that work. Doing nothing and being afraid don't work. AT ALL.

I've never seen it work.

That being said:

If you're young and have no kids with this woman, then cut your losses.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 04:25 AM
We have no kids, but I love this woman. She is so much to me.

My first everything.

What is my next step after exposure?

You guys say expose, but I see nothing in the Q&A about this process.

Any examples of what a good exposure letter or thing to say is? How much information and such? How to deliver it?
A massive plan A.

What you do is this:

Your WW: I can't believe you told everyone about my relationship with XX! We're through.

You: I'm sorry you're mad, would you like a potato chip? (Whoever said that, sorry, I don't remember.)
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 04:40 AM
Exposure seems like a love buster to me?
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Exposure seems like a love buster to me?

No. It's not.

And look at it this way, you have ALREADY lost her. So do what needs to be done. Expose the affair to everyone.

It DOES help. And you get support from places you would never expect.

Charlotte
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 04:51 AM
Where should I expose too?
EVeryone!

Her work (she may be using company time to affair with. I mean if you had an affair you would try to use the work phone which your spouse couldn't keep up with), her family.

ANYONE who can influence her!

One woman's affair ended the second her parents were exposed to. They talked to her and BAM it was done.
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Where should I expose too?

Work, family, close friends...anyone who can be a positive influence for you.

You don't have to go as far as your mail carrier or your vet but you will sure want to once you get started. I almost did. Well, I did to the vet's assistant and she told the vet, but we know them well, LOL.

Charlotte

P.S.) Don't warn your WW that you are going to expose, either. This would give her an opportunity to paint you as looney tunes. That's what WS & OW did with OWH. But I got evidence that he couldn't deny so it was over for their lies.
When I told OMW, my WW texted me the next day and said that she thought she might love me again but she was wrong.

Here is what I have noticed:

Exposure makes them mad for a bit but then it's over.

The longer the A lasts, the truly madder they seem to get at you.


expose, expose, expose


Just tell her family what I told my WW family, you wanted them to know the truth so they could give good advice and guidance. Tell them you knew if they got bad information they would give bad advice.
You have to stop being Mr. Needy. She has cheated on you. Had sex with another man. You have tried to love her back. That never works while a spouse is in the fog. You have to pull away emotionally. You have to look after yourself. You have to regain your confidence. Right now she has zero respect for you. Why? Because after each time you took her back. You sent her the message that what she was doing was OK. Read the first part of your post. And how each subsequent betrayal, she was less and less convicted about. You convinced her that you wouldn't leave her when she cheats. How could she "not" continue cheating with a free pass. You should have kicked her a$$ out then. She should have had to work to earn your love and trust. But because you didn't require that of her. You convinced her that your love was not valuable enough. How could she think anything different? My advice is to start divorce proceedings. When she sees you starting them she will either balk at going through with it or she will want to go through with it. One or the other. But I will tell you that the way you are handling it now. She will eventually leave you. Because your love will be of no value. If you weren't willing to hold your love dear. Why would she?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 05:50 AM
The affair is now long distance.

It was physical for a time and now he's two hours away.

Why isn't there a sticky on Exposure to make this easier?
Just tell everybody about it. Pretty simple. Friends, family, yours, hers OM's.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:12 AM
She is also begging me to divorce her...to leave her.
That makes it your fault an not hers in her mind. My WW keeps telling me to go out with other women.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:21 AM
What do I do about that? She's been resolved to divorce me for a while...

She has been acting like I made her cheat.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:23 AM
She also claims that she feels trapped in our marriage...
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:33 AM
I want her to stay but just can't seem to figure out how. Everyone tells me that this Exposure thing will just make it worse... I'm scared to try it.
If she wanted a D that bad, she would have filed already.

Actions speak louder than words.
Originally Posted by Moncouer
What do I do about that? She's been resolved to divorce me for a while...

She has been acting like I made her cheat.

Yeah? She's using real or imagine failings to justify her affair. This is how it works in these cases.

You just don't pay attention to it because you know better.

Charlotte
Originally Posted by Moncouer
I want her to stay but just can't seem to figure out how. Everyone tells me that this Exposure thing will just make it worse... I'm scared to try it.



Who is everyone?
Originally Posted by Moncouer
She also claims that she feels trapped in our marriage...

More from the WS Handbook.

Originally Posted by Moncouer
I want her to stay but just can't seem to figure out how. Everyone tells me that this Exposure thing will just make it worse... I'm scared to try it.

Who the hell is EVERYONE? HER?

Exposure is like turning over a rock and letting the sunshine kill the mold growing beneath it--you shine this light into their affair to hasten its demise.

What the hell do you have to lose? YOU HAVE ALREADY LOST HER!!

If you want a snowball's chance in hell at changing that then you need to take action and stop whining about it!!!
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:45 AM
So should I tell the ENTIRE family? Close, relatives, extended?

And go on facebook and post to all of them as well?
skeptical
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:46 AM
People I've told so far about this idea is everyone.

Seems...counter productive. Although I am warming ot it.
Originally Posted by Pepperband
skeptical

rotflmao
She is gone and not coming back unless the A is over. Period.

What does that mean? End the A as soon as possible. Nothing else matters. If exposure makes her not come back, then she wouldnt come back anyways. If everybody knows about the A, it makes her catch flak for it and makes it harder for her to keep it up.
Originally Posted by Moncouer
People I've told so far about this idea is everyone.

Seems...counter productive. Although I am warming ot it.

Yes, you are right. It does seem counter-intuitive. That confused me at first as well. But it WORKS. And you will feel a LOT better and stronger when you get off your [censored] and take ACTION!!!

Charlotte
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:57 AM
I'm trying here ok mate?

I'm here. I'm trying to accept this idea.


What should this exposure letter look like? I'm full of anxiety and can barely think straight and have done so many stupid things so far from it that I'm scared of doing yet another.

What should the delivery method be?

How DEEP should I go? Cause Facebook literally exposes the entire family extended and all.
Dont do this in a letter, do it in person or on the phone.
Originally Posted by Moncouer
I'm trying here ok mate?

I'm here. I'm trying to accept this idea.


What should this exposure letter look like? I'm full of anxiety and can barely think straight and have done so many stupid things so far from it that I'm scared of doing yet another.

What should the delivery method be?

How DEEP should I go? Cause Facebook literally exposes the entire family extended and all.

There are some here who have exposed via facebook & myspace, etc.

If I were you I would use that for "secondary" exposure...for the main people you want to do it in person or on the phone. But for cousins, etc., you can use facebook, etc. JMO.

Charlotte
DUDE!!!! Affairs thrieve in secrecy. Expose to EVERYONE! I will make their relationship VERY uncomfortable.

You said that she apparently told her sister. I can assure you, she doesn't know the whole story. The majority of people have a moral compass and will realize that this relationship is wrong and won't be very excepting of it.

What about this OM. Does he have a wife or a girlfriend. I'm sure he has parents. I'm pretty sure his mother wouldn't approve.

If they work for the same company or (I believe, school system) They definately wouldn't approve for fear of a lawsuit.

This next statement is going to sound mean but YOU HAVE TO STOP BEING A DOORMAT! Stand up for yourself! Stand up for your marriage!
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:06 AM
I'll need to steal her phone to get the super list of numbers.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:09 AM
I had to work my [censored] off on google maps traveling down certain roads floor level to find the restaurant the OM owns. So I am taking this seriously at the same time I'm skeptical. So just keep the constructive aid coming and I'll be capable enough to carry out this act.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:10 AM
I should name the OM to everyone too right?
Posted By: SIHW Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:11 AM
Monty.....ok bro...imagine if you will (that sounds so twilight zone....but thats been your life lately right?) little wifey is sneaking around tip toeing planning to do evil....planning to suck the life from your marriage. WW is a VAMPIRE.

Ok you got that part...ok...next part...

Now you are the GREAT VAN HELSING....what is the one thing that destroys the evil that is vampires....LIGHT....light is the representative of all that is good.....thats why vampires hate it so and choose to sneak and live in the dark. They are souls damned and hiding away from the rest of the world. That is why they sleep during the day while mortals are awake.

YOU are the bringer of light back to your world (MARRIAGE)....by allowing her family to see the light (exposure...no pun intended) you bring whats good and right to thier lives.....most times they will also allow there light to hit the vampire quickening it's demise.

Your wife is dating a college kid with no attainable future at the moment. IF you value your marriage...you will expose it and allow those who love and care for your wife....to sort of add to the intervention...she is an addict right now (most vampires are...you know needing blood to survive thing).

If she values what they will think so much....it is sure to have an affect on her and on the life of the affair....I mean what do you have to loose....you don't fight you loose her....you do fight you still have the possibility of getting your wife back.

The vets here all have alot of collected experience. I highly suggest you listen to them.....if we could all write a script about what WS's would say next...trust me hun....her next line would read straight from it....everything she has said is like a broken record for all WS'S we have all heard and read the same things on other peoples threads numerous times....trust me yours is not that unique.

stay strong...gather your evidence...and present it to her family....you may have allies there yet willing to help you fight...you never know until you try.
THERE YA GO! And remember. THIS ISN'T YOUR FAULT! You can except 50% of the problems in your marriage. She is 100% at fault for the affair. You had nothing to do with that! Be strong!
Posted By: tnsr Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:18 AM
Originally Posted by Moncouer
So should I tell the ENTIRE family? Close, relatives, extended?

And go on facebook and post to all of them as well?

Yes. Tell everyone who knows her and can positively influence her to stop her immoral and wayward behavior. Don't tell her first. Don't even hint. Just DO IT.
If you think that people here don't know what their talking about. Check this out. When you start exposing to everyone, your wife will be EXTREMELY angry. Then (here's what she'll probably say, "At one time I was considering working things out with you, but now you've blown it!" It's a typical response from the WS script.
Posted By: tnsr Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:21 AM
Originally Posted by Moncouer
I should name the OM to everyone too right?

Not only name him, but directly call his wife (if married), his children, his parents, his wife's parents, his workplace, his co-workers, his boss, etc. Anything to shine the light on the A and make it supremely uncomfortable for him to continue.

Fight.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:24 AM
The two people who do know that pissed her off already for having been told are going to see me this weekend. Tomorrow in fact. I think I'll gather my evidence sit down with them and go through it so that anyone who doesn't believe can be shown easily what this is.

Keep the advice coming.

AND THANK YOU FOR THE SUPER RESPONSE TO ME. I AM IN A PANIC AND NEED INSTANT ACTION.
My WW likes to also say I am showing her no respect and I am pushing her farther away from me.

She didnt lose her love for you and get into an A, she got into an A and lost her love for you.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:25 AM
Originally Posted by Crossbar
If you think that people here don't know what their talking about. Check this out. When you start exposing to everyone, your wife will be EXTREMELY angry. Then (here's what she'll probably say, "At one time I was considering working things out with you, but now you've blown it!" It's a typical response from the WS script.

She said that when I told the two other family.
Originally Posted by Moncouer
The two people who do know that pissed her off already for having been told are going to see me this weekend. Tomorrow in fact. I think I'll gather my evidence sit down with them and go through it so that anyone who doesn't believe can be shown easily what this is.

Keep the advice coming.

AND THANK YOU FOR THE SUPER RESPONSE TO ME. I AM IN A PANIC AND NEED INSTANT ACTION.

GOOD! DAMMIT!!

And we will! You can count on that! We don't want to see you run into the ground and all twisted into a pretzel by your WS!!

Charlotte
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:28 AM
Now. After the exposure. How do I work plan A? How do I show her that I really love her? We are separated right now and soon getting different places to stay apartment wise.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:30 AM
I mean... How do I act towards her? I already know about the "So, you want a potato chip?" Thing, but what do I do in steps.
Just be nice, do things for her. Meet EN's but avoid any and all LB's.
Well, there you go! Listen to the vets when they chime in here. They'll be able to predict what she going to say or do with scary accurracy! Take care of yourself first and foremost!
The Carrot and the Stick of Plan A

The carrot of Plan A


Meeting your wandering spouse's emotional needs.

Making "home" a warm and inviting place to be.

Placing emphasis on what has worked in the marriage.

Showing consistent self improvement in areas where previously lacking.

Stop lovebusting behaviors.

Communicating with a calm reassuring voice and relaxed body language, even in the center of a verbal storm created by the infidel.

Becoming the person any reasonable spouse would want to come home to.

Remaining open to the possibility of recovery.

Offering forgiveness and understanding.



The stick of Plan A


Exposing adultery where it matters most. Exposure that takes the form of a swift and sudden unexpected tsunami of truth.

Not appologizing for exposure or speaking the truth in a kind yet direct way.

Directly communicating the hurt and devastation that the affair has caused.

Not accepting blame for the infidel's choice to become adulterous.

Let the consequences of adultery and infidelity fall freely upon the heads of the adulterous.

Establishing boundaries that disallow the affair to effect children of the marriage, financal security of the marriage, and otherwise ruin innocent bystanders.

Standing up to infidelity as a beast that must be slayed for the good of the family.


Exposure is your strongest weapon against the A. Use it, and use it wisely. Do not tell her that you are going to do it, just do it. Expect more anger. Your M can survive her anger, but it cannot survive if she remains a WS.

Start a good plan A. If you can call the Harleys for advice. Read Surviving an Affair. You will learn the dynamics of affairs. They are all pretty much the same. The WS use the same script.

Your WS will try to rewrite history and put you in a bad light. She is trying to justify her actions to herself. She is probably addicted to the feelings of the A, not the OM. He could be anyone.

She has weaknesses that she did not protect. It is a slippery slope.

Keep coming here. Read, read, read.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

And now,

I'm going to bed. I'll check up on you tomorrow, Pod'nah.

Charlotte
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:59 AM
Thanks Charlotte, good night for you. I'm still going to be up patrolling and questioning.

Hell, as I've asked, if anyone has a letter head example of what I probably should create as a script to tell people in person and in letter form, that would help my progress immensely. I'm already building a names list and such.
It all depends on who you are telling. If it's her parents, tell them how much you love her and want to try to make the M work but that she is having an A. To her family it will probably help you look better too as she is probably making them think you are a monster.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 08:34 AM
How much detail about the affair do I provide? Do I tell that it was both physical and emotional?

Should I ask her one last time to end the affair? But no ultimatum.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 08:46 AM
Also, after exposure, how do you get the to let you work on plan A? What if they are distant, what do you do to get them to let you show them your best side?

One other thing I'm wondering. Should I schmooze up to her big time in PLan A style before launching exposure? To try and show a better side? As right now she really just doesn't like me.
moncouer

Starting another post is not going to help you. Best to keep your story in one place.

WW's all say that they would of stayed until you exposed. They all get angry at exposure. It shows everyone that they are a cheatin hoe.

Exposure checklist

WW's parents, her siblings, being she is young her g parents, WW anunts and uncles, her close friends, if they met at work then expose there, OMW, OM parents, OM g parents.
Mon,

You should understand that while we don't know your wife, we know your WW. We've seen her here a lot. She comes in all shapes and sizes and races, but her behavior is nearly identical in every single case.

Sometimes the WW wakes up right away and starts to work things out with her H.

Other times she takes a while to do it.

And other times she's lost already and will not come back at all.

The actions in dealing with her are the same regardless of the outcome that will happen.

And she ALWAYS says the same stuff:

"I love you but I'm not in love with you."
"I don't know you."
"I feel trapped."
"Don't you want me to be happy?"
"OM is the love of my life. He's my soulmate."

Upon exposure:

"You ruined his life!"
"You're ruining my life!"
"I hate you!"
"You just ruined any chance we had at saving this. I was going to give you a chance before but you just destroyed that!"
"You're just doing this to be vindictive!"
"You violated my privacy!" (More on this later)

And it goes on and on. We've seen your WW here many, many times and the behavior is ALWAYS the same.

Now there are two types of betrayed husbands. There's those that live in fear of their wives and those that don't and take action and do something. The ones that succeed are the latter. The ones that don't are the former.

Fear and hope and love will get you nowhere.

Crying and whining will get you nowhere.

One big thing to do is to start acting like she's already lost. Almost like this poor lost child that you feel warmth towards, but who will be gone soon.

So you start to carry on with your life. Plan A isn't Plan Whine or Plan Doormat.

It's treating her well, like you would a house guest, but NOT allowing yourself to be treated badly or get beaten up by her on an emotional level. It means calmly looking at her when she rants and raves and acting normal in the face of madness.

When she rants and raves, you simply respond with "I'm doing everything I can to save our marriage."

That's it. No more explanation needed.

Here's the 180, which is a great guide on what to do. These aren't hard and fast rules, but are a great guide to help those that are lost on how to behave.

180 is a list of behaviors from Michelle Wiener Davis, the author of Divorce Busting, that will help your spouse to see you moving forward as a healthy person. I would highly suggest that any new BS begin these behaviors as soon as possible. I am convinced that if I had implemented them, I would still be married. In retrospect, I did everything besides 180. I looked pathetic. No one wants to be perceived as pathetic. 180 makes you look strong. Strong is attractive. (Making it)

So here's the list:

Don't pursue reason, chase, beg, plead or implore.

No frequent phone calls.

Don't point out "good points" in marriage.

Don't follow her/him around the house.

Don't encourage or initiate discussion about the future.

Don't ask for help from the family members of your WS.

Don't ask for reassurances.

Don't buy or give gifts.

Don't schedule dates together.

Don't keep saying, "I Love You!" Because if you have a brain in your head, he/she is at this particular moment, not very loveable.

Do more then act as if you are moving on with your life; begin moving on with your life!

Be cheerful, strong, outgoing and independent.

Don't sit around waiting on your spouse - get busy, do things, go out with friends, enjoy old hobbies, find new ones! But stay busy!

When home with your spouse, (if you usually start the conversation) be scarce or short on words. Don't push any issue?
No matter how much you want to!

If you're in the habit of asking your spouse his/her whereabouts, ASK NOTHING. Seem totally uninterested.
Your partner needs to believe that you have awakened to the fact that "they (the WS)" are serious concerning their assertions as to the future (or lack thee of) of your marriage. Thus, you are you are moving on with your life? with out them!

Don't be nasty, angry or even cold - Just pull yourself back.

Don't always be so available? for anything! Your spouse will notice. More important, he/she will notice that you're missing.

No matter what you are feeling TODAY, only show your spouse happiness and contentment? Make yourself be someone they would want to be around. Not a moody, needy, pathetic individual but a self assured individual secure in the knowledge that they have value.

All questions about the marriage should be put on hold, until your spouse wants to talk about it (which may not be for quite a while). Initiate no such conversation!

Do not allow yourself to lose your temper. No yelling, screaming or name calling EVER. No show of temper! Be cool, act cool; be in control of the only thing you can control? YOURSELF!

Don't be overly enthusiastic.

Do not argue when they tell you how they feel (it only makes their feelings stronger). In fact, refuse to argue at all!
Be patient and learn to not only listen carefully to what your spouse is really saying to you? HEAR what it is that they are saying! Listen and then listen some more!

Learn to back off, keep your mouth shut and walk away when you want to speak out, no matter what the provocation. No one ever got themselves into trouble by just not saying anything.

Take care of you. Exercise, sleep, laugh & focus on all the other parts of your life that are not in turmoil.

Be strong, confident and learn to speak softly.

Know that if you can do this 180, your smallest CONSISTENT action will be noticed far more than any words you can say or write.

Do not be openly desperate or needy even when you are hurting more than ever and are feeling totally desperate and needy.
Do not focus on yourself when communicating with your spouse. It's not always about you! More to the point, at present they just don't care!

Do not believe any of what you hear them say and less than 50% of what you see. Your spouse will speak in absolute negatives and do so in the most strident tones imaginable. Try to remember that they are also hurting and afraid. Try to remember that they know what they are doing is wrong and so they will say anything they can to justify their behavior.

Do not give up no matter how dark it is or how bad you feel. It "ain't over till it's over!"

Do not backslide from your hard earned changes. Remain consistent! It is the consistency of action and attitude that delivers the message.

When expressing your dissatisfaction with the actions of the wayward party, never be judgmental, critical or express moral outrage. Always explain that your dissatisfaction is due to the pain that the acts being committed are causing you as a person.

This is the kind of behavior that will cause you to be a much more attractive and mysterious individual. Further it SHOWS that you are NOT afraid to move on with your life. Still more important, it will burst their positive little bubble; the one in which they believe that they can always come back to you in case things don't work out with the OM/OW."
One more thought:

You're young. That youth is your enemy right now. You haven't had the life experience to understand and know that not only is your wife's behavior beyond intollerable, she is, in fact, replaceable in every respect.

You also don't have the life experience to know that your view of her is clouded by your emotions for her. You love her and think she's all that while you have friend and family that think, "Boy, Mon could do so much better."

I've been throught the ringer a bit and I'm not much older than you (10 years). BUT.....I've learned a ton in those ten years.

What you're doing right now is no way to live.

You're young and are wasting your youth on a woman that simply isn't worth it.

You have no children with her. It's really about the only incentive she would have had to try to work something out with you, if it was going to happen at all.

What incentive does she have to return to you?

She doesn't love you. That's pretty clear.

She has no children with you.

She has no respect for you or your feelings. She doesn't respect her vows, her God, or the institution of marriage.

You think she's worth saving. Give yourself a few years away from her and you'll think, "My God, what did I ever see in her?"

Rightn now you should be talking to a lawyer and preparing to crucify her in court and take EVERYTHING.

Then, once that is done, you can walk away still in your twenties and with tons of great women out in the world.

Believe me, they're out there and they're awesome.

BUT...You want to try to save things. That's fine. We'll help you.

But understand that you're better than this and deserve to be treated better than this and she is disposable.

NO ONE is worth living this way. The second you accept this fact, the better you will do with either her or some future woman.
I just re-read your first post.

The only thing you have ever done which shows you have balls and brains that function somewhere inside all that fear you live with was the fact that you separated your finances.

Now what should you do?

Isolate her financially. She wants to cheat, then she can get her cheating a$$ a job, but you will not support her affair.

That means you cancel all joint credit cards, bank accounts, and cell phones.

You cutoff her cell phone if you pay for it.

Take the car back if it's in your name.

Believe me, it's counterintuitive, but this is stuff you should be doing because it is how she deserves to be treated right now as your wife.

She doesn't deserve to be treated like a wife you love because she's not acting like the wife you love.

Also, you should expose to OM's family and parents.

What state does he live in? You should be filing an Alienation of Affection lawsuit where you sue him for having an affair with your wife.

Start making his life miserable, to include calling him and telling him to stay the hell away from her.

Exposure extends to him and his work and his family and friends.

Let them put pressure on him to leave a married woman alone.

And don't be surprised if he has other girlfriends. Contact her if he does.

Exposure lets things out in the open to put an end to the affair.

And you must demand no contact for life from your WW.

Final warning for you to think about:

Your WW may already be lost forever. This may never be salvageable.

But I can guarantee you that you will regret not taking action if and when you heal from all of this.

Exposure works. Acting like a man works. Releasing your fear of her works.

What you're doind and have done does not.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 04:33 PM
Excellent help.

Now, what should the message be that I give to family? Rough draft. Should I mention the physical affair as well as mental affair? What details could be added?

Dear loved one,

I want to implore you for strength and prayers for both "wifes name" and mines marriage. I care and love for her. I humbly inform you so that you may pray for us and offer any guidance in wisdom that you may wish to offer.

I do not say this to hurt nor harm. “Wife’s name” my wife and mine's marriage has been affected by an affair. There is another man "named" who has been allowed into our lives in ways that should only be present in the holy matrimony and sanctity of marriage.

Plainly, “wife’s name” has allowed an emotional and physical involvement with another man to occur in our lives which has brought great pain on our marriage. She has been unable to end this affair on her own and at mine and our counselor’s direction.

Please keep your prayers with us in this time as we work to strengthen our marriage and work on the love that we have for one another,

Sincerely,

"Me"


Who do you need to still expose on the check list?

And as Baron said time to cut her off financially.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 04:43 PM
I have no means to cut her off financially. She is employed. And that would seem vindictive I believe.
No, it is not vindictive, it is letting her finance her affair HERSELF.

Why should YOU have to pay for her affair?!

You want to know what happens when you let your WW run all over you? Someone get pom in here!!

Originally Posted by Moncouer
I have no means to cut her off financially. She is employed. And that would seem vindictive I believe.
skeptical

Originally Posted by Moncouer
I have no means to cut her off financially. She is employed. And that would seem vindictive I believe.

This is what you don't get. She's an enemy right now. It is not vindictive to protect your finances.

She wants to act single, then by all means, let her support herself.

Do you not understand? She wants to act single. So treat her that way.

Ex husbands don't voluntarily support their ex wives.

You have no obligation to her if she acts that way.

It blows my mind how betrayed husbands have a woman that f***s another man and is concerned about 1. ticking her off and 2. appearing vindictive.

No, isolating her financially is not vindictive. It's smart.

But don't listen to a man who was literally robbed by his wife for doing EXCATLY what you're doing.

YOU are different and special from all the hundreds of other men who come here with the exact same story.

So go ahead and keep trusting her with your finances and keep funding her affair if that's the approach you think that works.

In my three years here, I've never seen it happen.

And yes, you're like dozens and dozens of other men who think the same way and then get burned.

What I say may sound harsh. But I'm trying to wake you up. Your finances are in peril.

Pi$$sing her off should be the least of your worries. Securing your finances and rights as a father should be number one.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 04:54 PM
Were you asking about if I could think of any others or if anyone else had any more ideas?


Exposure checklist

WW's parents - One already knows, he seemed to be sheltering the mother from the truth.
Her siblings - One supposedly knows, but the depth of the truth is uncertain.
g parents - She loves her grandmother, hates her grandfather.
WW anunts and uncles - Two already know, soon this will include them all.
close friends - Will have to get her phone and prepair a call list.
OMW - Unknown if other woman
OM parents - have mothers phone now
OM g parents - Will ask OM mother to spread the same letter.

IS THERE A WAY TO DOWNLOAD A PHONES LIST OF NUMBERS QUICKLY?

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 04:56 PM
baron_richtofen,

Well I have no means to financially cut her off. Everything car, phone and such are in her name.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 04:57 PM
Originally Posted by Pepperband
Originally Posted by Moncouer
I have no means to cut her off financially. She is employed. And that would seem vindictive I believe.
skeptical

Skeptical about what? That I don't have means to cut her off? Or just vindictive?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 05:02 PM
I need advice on the exact wording of the message now. Delivery seems important if I want people to understand that it's not a vindictive/hateful motion.
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Skeptical about what?

YOU ! skeptical



Quote
That I don't have means to cut her off?

Then, this is your answer.

But why did you write.....



Quote
vindictive

Posters on pro adultery boards call the betrayed spouses "vindictive" when they try to protect their assets. skeptical
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 05:05 PM
Some of these replies seem CUT and PASTE. Makes them hard to...translate into my issues. ^_^ But hey, your helping so woot!


I've said We are almost immediately and now living apart in separate domains. How do I provide plan A after exposure if we are not living together?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 05:06 PM
Pepperband,

Ah I see your point.
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Pepperband,

Ah I see your point.

When a newbie "BS" posts (word for word) right out of the pro adultery script ... I become skeptical skeptical skeptical
Originally Posted by Moncouer
I need advice on the exact wording of the message now. Delivery seems important if I want people to understand that it's not a vindictive/hateful motion.

Factual business-like language.

Try writing it that way.

Let's see what you come up with.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 05:41 PM
To whom it may concern,

Recent events have brought to light that "my wife" committed adultery in our marriage with another man "named" and that this adultery has impacted our marriages stability and health. It has been an arduous time for the both of us where great pain has been caused by the presence of the adultery in our lives.

Have been implored by our councilor and myself to cease being an adulterer yet she has not given way.

I inform you so that this fact may be brought to your loving attentions and that you may take action as you deem appropriate in aiding or praying for our strength and successful recovery of our familial bonds in marriage.



Arbitrary closing,

-Me
affected by infidelity?

Don't you mean SHE COMMITTED ADULTERY?

Infidelity is not the common cold.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 05:51 PM
To whom it may concern,

Recent events have brought to light that "my wife" has betrayed our marriage's trust by committing adultery with another man "named" and that this adultery has impacted our marriages stability and health dramatically. It has been an arduous time for the both of us where unnecessary suffering and great upheaval has been caused by the presence of this adultery in our lives.

Having been implored by our councilor and myself for her to cease, "my wife" has yet to end her adulterous affair. "My wife" has strongly resisted in not proceeding with total discontinued contact with the other man "name."

I inform you so that this fact may be brought to your loving attentions and that you may take action as you deem appropriate in aiding or praying for our strength and the successful recovery of our familial bonds in marriage.

Many may feel that this is an unusual step in the healing process, but I assure you that there is no malice nor vindictive effort in it's delivery and that it is directed by the guidance of a marriage counseling body. Adultery thrives in secrecy and as long as it may remains hidden there is no stopping it. So as many of you were there to celebrate our coming together on our wedding day I request of you now to share in this time of recovery with us.

I have nothing but love, respect, and care for my wife. If you feel a need to discuss this with me or validate my claims, I am available in every way.

With the greatest respect,

-The Husband
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:11 PM
That seems good to me?
Personally, I wouldn't send a letter to family and friends...I would call them up and say:

WW is committing adultery with OM. I love WW very much and want to save our marriage. Anything you could do to help me towards that goal would be greatly appreciated. Do you have any advice for me? (People typically like being asked for advice)

I understand that you are distraught, Mancouer, but I really think you are making this more complicated than it has to be...Simple phone calls stating the facts and asking for help and advice will suffice...

Hint: you WANT people to confront your wife about her behavior...you are not bestowing a secret upon them that you want them to keep...make that known: ie: Could you please talk to WW and try and help her see the folly of her current choices?

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:22 PM
The letter is for secondary family.

I'm going to call directly to close family.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:23 PM
Yea, the letter is getting to verbose I think.
Originally Posted by Moncouer
The letter is for secondary family.

I'm going to call directly to close family.

Okay...Personally I would make the letter more concise...

When will you be making these phone calls?

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:25 PM
It's just I know delivery is so important. I'm over focusing on it maybe.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:25 PM
Once I have all the numbers I need.
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Yea, the letter is getting to verbose I think.

Yes, I concur...

WW is committing adultery with OM. I love WW and want very much to save our marriage. Anything you can do to help towards that goal would be greatly appreciated.

Straight to the point is best, imo...

Mancouer, my affair ended the very day that my mom called OM and let him have it...She and Mr. W conspired together on what was to be said...(My mom knew OM since our childhoods - it worked best that she make the call)...My point is, don't underestimate the pressure on OM's side of the fence...Those exposure targets are VERY POWERFUL indeed...

Mrs. W
Originally Posted by Moncouer
It's just I know delivery is so important. I'm over focusing on it maybe.

This isn't stand-up comedy...Delivery counts less than the cold hard facts here...To the point...No hemming and hawing...

What more needs to be said?

1. WW is committing adultery with OM.

2. I love WW very much and want to save our marriage.

3. Anything you can do to help us save our marriage would be greatly appreciated.

No need to go around your elbow to get to your heiney...KWIM?

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:33 PM
To whom it may concern,

It has come to my attention that "my wife" has betrayed our marriage's trust by committing adultery with another man "named" and that this adultery has impacted our marriages stability and health dramatically.

Having been implored by our councilor and myself for her to cease the adultery, "my wife" has yet to end her affair. "My wife" has strongly resisted in not proceeding with total discontinued contact with the other man "name."

I inform you so that this fact may be brought to your loving attentions and that you may take action to show my wife the folly in her way and to pray for our strength and the successful recovery of our familial bonds in marriage.

I have nothing but love, respect, and care for my wife. I want our marriage to continue and for us to be loving in it. And I am prepared to put all my effort into this marriages recovery.

With the greatest respect,

-The Husband
Moncouer...

May I make a suggestion? How about you do the immediate family and OM's family FIRST and see if that does the trick? When you say "secondary family", are you meaning people like Aunt Sally and Uncle Fred who WW only sees once a year at Christmas? I'm not saying that they wouldn't make good exposure targets in the second round of exposure, but why not see if the main targets get this taken care of first?

Call OM's mama & daddy TODAY...I think sitting here spinning your wheels on endless letters that are TOO LONG is a waste of your time...

What do you think?

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:54 PM
Hehe, she sent me a Facebook flair (like a pin-button) with "Peace, Love, Wine" on it.

I have no idea what that was suppose to mean.

That bolsters me now. To know that this might actually work if she is still "poking" to see if I'm receptive to her since I accepted the flair piece.

Maybe that is what I'll do. I'll tell the immediate family. And not tell her that I will expand the pressure if she does not relent.
Agree with MrsW, just pick up the phone and start talking. There is no need to overcomplicate this and get bogged down in analysis paralysis.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:56 PM
I think I'm going to do her the favor and wait until after her spring break. Since it is suppose to be a time of fun for her.

I know...I know. I'm weak but there is so much stress for her I'm not sure if ruining her first trip to New York (w/out me to boot) is what I should do.

Or then again...it'll really put the weight on her because she'll be out of town and unable to physically confront me.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 06:57 PM
Wanting to wait... That's me delaying isn't it?
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Maybe that is what I'll do. I'll tell the immediate family. And not tell her that I will expand the pressure if she does not relent.

Of course you don't tell her your battleplans! Forewarned is forearmed!

There is no "maybe" to this Mancouer...You either WILL or you WON'T...Which is it? You need to get started TODAY...The courage is in the doing...You can't wait around for some magical feeling to overtake you...You must ACT...

Mrs. W
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Wanting to wait... That's me delaying isn't it?

YES!

Waiting til after Spring Break, so she can have "fun" all while your marriage is being DESTROYED??? faint

Knock it off, man-up and get this done, Mancouer...double time...

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:10 PM
Oh, we haven't addressed one thing.

Do I just let her make her decisions based on what you've told me?

I don't ask her to leave the other man, I simply inform family, sit, and wait, while improving myself?
Originally Posted by Moncouer
I think I'm going to do her the favor and wait until after her spring break. Since it is suppose to be a time of fun for her.

I know...I know. I'm weak but there is so much stress for her I'm not sure if ruining her first trip to New York (w/out me to boot) is what I should do.

Or then again...it'll really put the weight on her because she'll be out of town and unable to physically confront me.

Good grief Moncouer!

My guess is that OM is going to be in New York too...

[sarcasm]Maybe you should just offer to buy them theatre tickets and pay for a nice dinner out afterwards...[/sarcasm]

OR, you could man-up and expose now and possibly prevent that!

Not to mention, who cares if she physically confronts you?????? Exposure is supposed to tick her off...It's not a tea party! crazy

C'mon...MAN-UP...Git 'er done!!!

Mrs. W
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Oh, we haven't addressed one thing.

Do I just let her make her decisions based on what you've told me?

I don't ask her to leave the other man, I simply inform family, sit, and wait, while improving myself?

I'm not sure I understand your question, but you certainly do NOT inform her that you are going to expose...

But, yes...that's right, expose while simultaneously becoming the best husband you can be...

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:19 PM
Another thought. I tell the immediate family. What signs am I looking for that I shouldn't soon go and expand the exposure?

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 07:20 PM
Originally Posted by MrsWondering
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Oh, we haven't addressed one thing.

Do I just let her make her decisions based on what you've told me?

I don't ask her to leave the other man, I simply inform family, sit, and wait, while improving myself?

I'm not sure I understand your question, but you certainly do NOT inform her that you are going to expose...

But, yes...that's right, expose while simultaneously becoming the best husband you can be...

Mrs. W

Again, being the best husband I can be is hard when we are "separated". I'm still not sure how I'm going to pull that off.

The question clarified: I was asking, do I just let her react and not say anything about leaving the other man? Just let her decide what to do?
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Oh, we haven't addressed one thing.

Do I just let her make her decisions based on what you've told me?

I don't ask her to leave the other man, I simply inform family, sit, and wait, while improving myself?

Righto. Expose the affair, mancouer. The sooner the better.
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Oh, we haven't addressed one thing.

Do I just let her make her decisions based on what you've told me?

I don't ask her to leave the other man, I simply inform family, sit, and wait, while improving myself?

Righto. Expose the affair, mancouer. The sooner the better.

Yes! Don't delay! Do it TODAY!

Did you get ANY sleep?

Charlotte
Originally Posted by Moncouer
Another thought. I tell the immediate family. What signs am I looking for that I shouldn't soon go and expand the exposure?

Moncouer,

One day at a time...Let's get the first round of exposure done and see what happens...Come back here and report...Battle plans will expand then, okay?

Plan A is demonstrating a WILLINGNESS to meet the needs of the WS should they return to the marriage - make yourself inviting and appealing...Even if you were living with her she wouldn't be receptive to you meeting her needs right now...Plan A is about making yourself into a husband that any woman would be proud to be married to, got it? Be confident, go out and live...Buy new clothes, new cologne, get a tan, start working out...

Mrs. W

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 08:16 PM
As I've said two family members know...an Aunt and uncle.

Is that good enough for now in terms of exposure?

As a start? This was this week before I started talking to you guys about this in depth.

The aunt and uncle are advising that it's a bad idea to do this. And I respect them a great deal. 31 years married.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 08:26 PM
THey keep telling me to wait the course of this out...and obviously that's what I've been doing and it's not working.


I'm going over to their house to talk to them in an hour and i'll make my decision after that. If they can't provide me ANY method that sounds better than this I'll go ahead with exposure.

Because this all makes sense. She is getting to eat her cake and have it too with me standing on the side while she has her long distance affair.
Originally Posted by Moncouer
As I've said two family members know...an Aunt and uncle.

Is that good enough for now in terms of exposure?

As a start? This was this week before I started talking to you guys about this in depth.

The aunt and uncle are advising that it's a bad idea to do this. And I respect them a great deal. 31 years married.

What is their reasoning on this?

That it will make your WS angry?

That it will cause a rift between WS and other family members?

Have they ever experienced infidelity?

I'm sure it sounds counter-intuitive to them because it seems that way.

Are they on your side of the family?

Charlotte
Quote
Because this all makes sense. She is getting to eat her cake and have it too with me standing on the side while she has her long distance affair.

EXACTLY!!

If you are very close to them, why don't you direct them here and let them read the articles on this site? Let them watch the Infidelity video that's on the home page.

Charlotte
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/07/09 09:04 PM
Yea, I'm going to show them this.
Expose today. Their only reasoning would be that it would piss her off. So what. Never care about pissing off an enemy of your M. Right now the biggest enemy is your W.

"WW's parents - One already knows, he seemed to be sheltering the mother from the truth."

You then tell the mom directly.

"Her siblings - One supposedly knows, but the depth of the truth is uncertain."

Why don't they all know everything?

"g parents - She loves her grandmother, hates her grandfather."

And the gas is $2 a gallon, who cares who she hates, loves, did you tell them? Your unbelieveable.

"WW anunts and uncles - Two already know, soon this will include them all."

Good.

"close friends - Will have to get her phone and prepair a call list."

Good.

"OMW - Unknown if other woman"

Not other woman, OM's wife.

"OM parents - have mothers phone now"

So you want a medal, use it.

"OM g parents - Will ask OM mother to spread the same letter."

Pointless.




Delay exposing.

Great idea giving the OM another week to bang your WW.
The longer you delay, the more he deposits in her LB$$ and vice versa
Moncouer...

PLEASE call OM's parents...grandparents...OM himself...Blow this thing up on his side of the fence...Make your WW far too much trouble for him...Let him know that you are fighting for your marriage and will NOT back down...Ask his parents and grandparents to keep their son/grandson away from your wife...Let them know that their son/grandson is an interloper in your marriage!!!

PLEASE DO THIS TODAY!!!

You will feel GREAT relief when you start taking ACTION...

And YES, both of her parents should also know...

I'm sure you have great respect for Aunt and Uncle, but the advice they are giving you is NOT sound for your situation...Please listen to the voices of experience here...

Mrs. W
Moncouer...

Think about this:

If you let his parents and grandparents know, then he can't introduce your wife to them as his girlfriend...Do you see that? He won't even be able to say that you guys are in the process of divorce, and that you are okay with what they are doing...You ruin any plans of them normalizing their "relationship" to his family and instead reveal it to be what it really is...A SLEAZY AFFAIR: ADULTERY...

Moncouer, TRUTH is the solution to adultery...Exposure is doing nothing but exposing the TRUTH...It is WRONG to commit adultery, it is NOT wrong to expose adultery...

Mrs. W
Finally for now, in case you haven't noticed my signature yet, I am a FWW myself...I am telling you from THAT side of the fence, how to ruin this affair...In essence, I am giving you "insider information"...Please use it...

Mrs. W
Gee, this has really been a snap getting all this info to you Moncouer. skeptical dontknow

And rest assured your WW's funfilled trip to New York includes meeting her OM there. You can mortgage the house on it.

C'mon Mancouer, for every point blank suggestion, you come back with 15 or more questions.

How about more action and less thought. People here are not trying to steer you wrong. we've been there, done that. We've all walked this road in front of you, KWIM?

All Blessings,
Jerry
Moncouer...

You wanted information from Dr. Harley regarding exposure...From the private section of this forum (for those that have attended a Marriage Builders Weekend Seminar), here is some of what he has to say...

Originally Posted by Dr. Harley
I'm in the process of rewriting "Surviving an Affair" to add information about plan B. Some of the main points are as follows:

Whether in plan A or B, the world should know about your husband's affair. All of your relatives, your friends, your children, and the licensing board for your husband's lover. In some states a licensing board will revoke a license if a counselor is having an affair with a married person, client or not. This is because it's well known that affairs hurt families, especially children. And counselors know better than to have an affair.

The reason for the wide exposure is not to hurt the unfaithful spouse, but rather to end the fantasy. Your husband's secret second life made his affair possible, and the more you can to to make it public, the easier it is for him to see the damage he's doing. Keeping it secret does damage, but few know about it. Making it public helps everyone, including the unfaithful spouse and lover, see the affair for what it really is.
Plan B, avoiding all contact with your husband until he agrees to never see or talk to his lover is not designed to bring him back to you. It's designed to protect your emotions just in case he will eventually return. If you try to win him back over a long period of time (Plan A), the effect would not only risk a nervous breakdown, but it would also cause you to lose your love for him. So the purpose of plan B is to protect your mental health regardless of the outcome, and also protect your feeling toward your husband in case his affair ends earlier than you would think.

Truth is, your husband's life will soon become chaotic, and he will begin to see what life without you will feel like. It will put pressure on his affair. Very few of these relationships ever make it to marriage (5%), and few of them turn into successful marriages (30%). In other words, the chances of your husband being happy with this woman is less than 2%. His real happiness lies in a relationship with you, but right now he can't see that possibility.

The reason that you couldn't make your marriage work these past four years has been because he's been having an affair all this time. And the reason his affair has not died a natural death by now is that it's been kept secret. Once his affair has been made public, there's a pretty good chance that it will die a natural death fairly soon (within 2 years). And once the affair dies, and your husband is out of the fog, there's a good chance that your marriage will recover.

We'll do our best to help you through this crisis, whether your marriage recovers or not.

Originally Posted by Dr. Harley
When I first started recommending openness about an affair, I wasn't sure what would happen. But I did it because I knew it was the right thing to do. Now I know that for most couples it marks the beginning of recovery.

link

Mrs. W
Listen to Baron - he's 100% right! Each time I too felt "cannot be" advice given to me here turned out to be perfect!

Your WW will take you for a ride of your life. I know. I've been on this ride since over 3 months now!
Moncouer,

I hate to tell you this, but it's the reality:

You've lost your wife. She's gone. You have no children or "family" for her to want to come back.

You appear to be in a very very small number of BHes that I've seen on these forums that get drug along by their cheating wives for YEARS. The BH hangs on and "hopes" and is Mr. Nice Guy, afriad to move to Plan B or do anything that upsets WW, such as Plan B and actually filing for divorce while WW goes on to OM#2, 3, and 4.

The BEST way to act right now is as if she's lost forever with one exception: Make sure you expose to the universe that the marriage is ending because she's cheating.

Pis$ing her off should be the least of your worries right now. Your wife is dead and has been replaced by an alien that looks like her and simply wants to hurt you.
Well?
He was up all night. Probably will be on later tonight or in the morning.


Maybe he is just busy exposing.
HOLY CHRISTMAS!!!! WAIT TILL SPRING BREAK! So, you can spoil her fun. Dude, don't you think she's had enough fun? It's time to knock her back into reality! EXPOSE!! You've made excuse after excuse. It's apparent you don't like confrontation. What have you got to lose. You need to make that relationship as uncomfortable as possible. There's a very go chance that this guy will bolt thinking " This just isn't worth the aggrevation." And he'll through your wife under the bus. IT'S NEVER GONNA HAPPEN IF YOU JUST SIT BY AND WATCH!
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/08/09 10:19 PM
See...they are making me feel that if I tell everyone it'll only leave her permanently shamed in the family...that everyone will always look at her as the adulterer.

They are telling me that since she's willing to talk to a very good counselor to wait.

I've already told a couple people and she knows.

I'm skeptical because some of you who say do it have only 60 something posts and just me talking about this I've come close to that as well.

Your talking about my life here and badgering me in some cases.

I get that this is to help but I've done enough dumb things due to irrational pressures on my own.

I JUST found this concept. So...with a little respect. Allow me to gestate and do something that I THOUGHT about longer than a day or so.

So far my worst mistakes have all happened from "reacting." Let me have a moment and think about "acting".

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/08/09 10:22 PM
They think I want to do this out of vengeance, they understand she is in a fantasy world but don't believe that this is the right course.
Moncouer,
If you have found a better peer group than MB, as in "they", then by all means, follow the impetus of "they" and good luck to you in your future.

I'm quite sure "they" have not been a clinical phycologist for over 35 years dealing with addictions and their coresponding predictable behavior. But if you wise family and friends know better, with zero experience, Good Luck to you my friend.

This will most certainaly be the last time I waste my energy on one who know better.


All Blessings,
Jerry
Originally Posted by Moncouer
See...they are making me feel that if I tell everyone it'll only leave her permanently shamed in the family...that everyone will always look at her as the adulterer.

This is what I thought they'd say.

Quote
They are telling me that since she's willing to talk to a very good counselor to wait.

Yeah, she might be willing to go to a counselor, but why? If she's already dead-set on divorce her only goal may be to "let you down easy." And appease her own guilt.

Quote
I've already told a couple people and she knows.

Good. If she is so much in love, what is there to be ashamed of?

Quote
I'm skeptical because some of you who say do it have only 60 something posts and just me talking about this I've come close to that as well.

Hey!! I resent that!! rant2 I have WAAAAAAY more than 60 posts!! grumble

But seriously, no one wants to see you go through what a lot of us went through. I suffered for months carrying their ugly little secret around. And WHY? It was THEIR secret, not mine!! I was at the VERY end of my tether when I finally exposed. No one here wants to see you go through that same thing because you are trying to reach out to someone who is NOT HEARING you because they are so focused on themselves and their lover.

Quote
Your talking about my life here and badgering me in some cases.

You're right. Please see paragraph above, ditto that here. I am sorry if you feel badgered. We are worried about you, that is all.

Quote
I get that this is to help but I've done enough dumb things due to irrational pressures on my own.

I JUST found this concept. So...with a little respect. Allow me to gestate and do something that I THOUGHT about longer than a day or so.

So far my worst mistakes have all happened from "reacting." Let me have a moment and think about "acting".

Okay, stick around and read and get some more advice. I know we are a bunch of faceless strangers to you but we really do care. That's why everyone gets so wild-eyed when they see someone being taken advantage of.

Quote
They think I want to do this out of vengeance, they understand she is in a fantasy world but don't believe that this is the right course.


Vengeance has nothing to do with it. And I'm sure they are questioning why a bunch of strangers want to help, too. There are people out there that really care about others. I felt all alone, family or not. When I came here it really turned my life around for the better. And thanks a million to everyone here who helped with that!!!

Charlotte
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/08/09 10:55 PM
Originally Posted by HeartInPain
Me: 42
WW: 41
Married: 16 years
Known each other: 21 years
S12 D10.5
A Started: Nov 8, 2008
First Discovery: Dec 26th ("Just a Friend" excuse)
Big D-day: Jan 10th (Recorded evidence of full-blown A)
WW Moved out: Feb 1st, 2009.
Plan B started: Feb 13th, 2009.
D Papers served on me by WW: Feb 17th, 2009.
Plan B currently blown, A continues!
WW moved back into home: Feb 23rd, 2009.


Are you doing this right now too? And your wife is back home? Affair done?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/08/09 10:56 PM
Where is the acronyms page? I can't find it so my family that are involved can understand what you guys are saying sometimes.
Posted By: tnsr Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/08/09 11:00 PM
Moncouer - don't believe the folks here, then. But do go to the Coaching Center page and make an appt with the Harley's for counseling and hear it from the horse's mouth. Also, please go to your nearest bookstore or Amazon and pick up a copy of Surviving An Affair.

Good luck.

Originally Posted by Moncouer
See...they are making me feel that if I tell everyone it'll only leave her permanently shamed in the family...that everyone will always look at her as the adulterer.

I see, and it would be your exposing the truth about her actions that would cause this, not her actual actions, huh? But I can speak from the "Scarlett Letter" side of the fence, and I can tell you that I don't wear one around people that know me that know about my affair...Wanna know why? Because I am a RECOVERED Former WW...My actions and my words match with not being a WW anymore and those people that know respect me very much for changing...Moncouer, we are advising you on how to give your wife an impetus for change...

Originally Posted by Moncouer
They are telling me that since she's willing to talk to a very good counselor to wait.

I could agree to this ONLY IF the counselor was Steve Harley...I have seen him advise to wait on exposure until after HE had spoken with the wayward himself...However, he will advise you to expose if he sees that your WW is simply trying to play you...I would NOT advise you to do this with any other counselor though...Most counselors know NOTHING about the dynamics of infidelity...Did you know for instance that marriage counselors have an 84% failure rate in saving marriages? Pretty scary stat, eh?

Are you willing to give Steve Harley a call Moncouer?

Originally Posted by Moncouer
I've already told a couple people and she knows.

Have those people that you've exposed to spoken to your WW about her affair?

Originally Posted by Moncouer
I'm skeptical because some of you who say do it have only 60 something posts and just me talking about this I've come close to that as well.

Well, I've got a few more posts than that under my belt and a recovered marriage to boot...

Did you read Dr. Harley's words that I posted to you Moncouer? He surely has more than a few measely posts to his name on the subject of infidelity...

Originally Posted by Moncouer
Your talking about my life here and badgering me in some cases.

I apologize if you feel badgered...People here only want to help you...We are hoping that you will learn from our experiences...

Originally Posted by Moncouer
I get that this is to help but I've done enough dumb things due to irrational pressures on my own.

I JUST found this concept. So...with a little respect. Allow me to gestate and do something that I THOUGHT about longer than a day or so.

So far my worst mistakes have all happened from "reacting." Let me have a moment and think about "acting".

The problem is though that time is not on your side here...I see a lot of conflict avoidance and fear, Moncouer...Neither of those things will help your circumstances...

Question: What would "they" have against exposing on OM's side of the fence?

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/08/09 11:52 PM
(Much of the below is my argument to my family who I have told about this.)

I am not desperate. I am not disillusion. I'm rational and wise. I am not angry. I am not crying. I am not hateful.


I am concerned for her. I am loving. I am thinking of her. I've only sworn at her ever in my life under one condition, each time she refused to stop the affair.



I do know the other man's mother would castrate him for his current actions. The other mans mother had apparently said often that he'd try and hit on my wife and they'd cheat. Seriously. And look where I am for not listening to HIS mother?

I think in such a case, they might be more on board with THAT.

Although my wife would feel I'm unjustly attacking the other man only.

Which would mean my wife's family would have to say they were on board...

Which would mean her family would have to express they know and are supporting me. Which means they would have to support the method of exposure.

What is frustrating is my wayward wife's father won't support this. I know he won't because it means that his wife would have to learn of my wife's actions. So...because of that I am forced to watch my wife walk away from me, because I can't disrespect him. It would be like telling my own parents that I don't care about their opinion's...or hurting them on purpose. ...BUT some hard and painful pills need swallowing! One child's affair is nothing to the death and destruction in the world. My father-in-law can't shield his wife from that and it's way worse than her daughter's adultery.

I have to stand here...and not act because if I go forward his wife will eventually learn because for this to work it'll have to start with family, extended, and close friends. To save my marriage from my wife's affair I'll have to piss off my father in law if I were to do this.


Exposure is exactly what I feel needs to happen. This is an affair...she created this. I did not. I did not MAKE her sleep with another man. There are consequences and one of them is unavoidably....that she will have to accept shame. And then be humbled for it. As it stands, she will not be humbled when the crime is not exposed.

For some reason everyone thinks that her actions will always mark her... They won't. I'll make sure of it. They can't mark her because I love her and if the person who does the exposing wants to love the betrayer how can the family choose but to not love her still? It's all about supporting an addict away from their addiction.

Just because she is an adult "grown up" doesn't mean she should be absolved of feeling shame or being hurt for her chosen actions.

I am not attacking her or seeking revenge. It is purely as you say shining light on a fungus and if this is so bad that it shouldn't be "revealed" for the permanent damage she is doing, what is my "family" expect of me to do when she is the one who is slowly creating a fantasy that I'm the wrong doer. And in this fantasy walking away.

I love her. I'm still loving her. I'm doing everything in my power to restore my marriage and restore her to reality. If I wanted to hurt her there are vile things that come to mind. We are adults who know things about one another that if I were to tell, would hurt her. I don't because I love her.[b] I WOULDN'T ever do anything that was meant to hurt her...I mean to heal.


This is all about fixing...a surgeon must cut open a patient before they can remove the ailment. This is exactly the same case.



[/b]
Monc...

If you expose the affair and end up recovering your marriage, your wife will view you as a HERO for saving her from herself...for saving your marriage...Count on it...Sure, she will be mad at first, but as you've been told, your marriage CAN survive your wife's anger, it CANNOT survive her ongoing affair...

Call the OM's mother and expose...

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 12:19 AM
Are you willing to give Steve Harley a call Moncouer?

How do I go about this? The cost is like...300 bucks.

And how do I get her to talk to him? Would I be there or just her?

Because each session would be expensive.
Originally Posted by Monc
Are you willing to give Steve Harley a call Moncouer?

How do I go about this? The cost is like...300 bucks.

And how do I get her to talk to him? Would I be there or just her?

Because each session would be expensive.

Sessions are $195 each...They do have discounted packages...I believe that is 5 sessions at a cost of $175 each...I KNOW it sounds expensive, but it is much cheaper than divorce AND you are getting THE experts on the topic...The Harleys are far different from typical marriage counselors and can get more done in ONE session than your average counselor could do in 5...and that would be if you had a GOOD counselor...After calling Steve, you will have a PLAN...That is what you desperately need Monc...A plan tailor made for YOU...

Usually a great way to get your wife to participate is to tell her that this counselor needs her input in order to help you...Then Steve will typically split up the call...he will talk to you for half of it and your wife for the other half...a brilliant approach...

Here is the link to the coaching center~~~> MB Coaching Center All the info about how to set it up is there...

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 12:50 AM
Can these sessions be billed to health insurance?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 12:51 AM
I love the website so I have a hard time not agreeing. I'm willing to put five sessions in and see where we go.

Now...would I be exposing first or session's then expose? How does that work?

Basically with sessions, what is the order of business?
Monc,

I honestly can't help you on the health insurance question...I simply do not know the answer to that...If I were you I'd call the MB offices first thing in the morning and ask them...I'm gonna take a guess and say that they will happily provide you with a receipt that you can then submit to your insurance company...

Because of your reticience regarding exposure, IF you will call and make your appointment first thing in the morning, then I'd say you can wait and talk to Steve...Let him advise you on that...As I told you earlier, he will be able to tailor a plan especially for you based upon your situation...Because he is the professional he can tweak the MB advice for you and your situation - Something that no one here posting to you is qualified to do...

Mrs. W
I'm assuming that my 60 posts are the ones you are referring to.

I've been on this board for 3 years.

I've posted over 2000 times about myself or to others.

I'm here under a different name because my exww has tried to use my posts against me.

So I may sound harsh, but it's because 2x4s are intended to wake you up since you have nothing but fear for this cheating adulterous woman that has zero respect for you because you allow her to disrespect you in a horrible way.

Seriously, how could you possibly have agreed to let her kiss another man is beyond me.

But that's not relevant anymore. It happened.

Now exposure must happen and it appears you're on the path to do that, but it MUST happen.

And your WW will be ticked. She will say all the things we predicted.

And again:

Your wife is gone. There's nothing to entice her to come back since you have no children with her or family to restore.

Act with this reality in mind and you will move forward fairly quickly. Might even entice her to return when she sees that you're moving on with your life.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 02:29 AM
So I should schedule an appointment with my wife involved to see from there?

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 02:31 AM
2x4's?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 03:10 AM
Originally Posted by shinethrough
Gee, this has really been a snap getting all this info to you Moncouer. skeptical dontknow

And rest assured your WW's funfilled trip to New York includes meeting her OM there. You can mortgage the house on it.

C'mon Mancouer, for every point blank suggestion, you come back with 15 or more questions.

How about more action and less thought. People here are not trying to steer you wrong. we've been there, done that. We've all walked this road in front of you, KWIM?

All Blessings,
Jerry

Not meeting there I'm pretty damn sure. It's here Alumni college event.

I'm certain of that due to evidence.
Originally Posted by Monc
So I should schedule an appointment with my wife involved to see from there?

Monc...

If I were you, I'd let my first appointment with Steve be for just you...That will help you get all your ducks in a row and he will give you line by line what to say to your wife to get her engaged in counseling with him...

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 05:56 AM
Submitted for an appointment.

I still am going to need her fathers acceptance. It took me everything just to tell him what his daughter is doing to me. Asking him to let me follow through with exposure and support me in it is tough.

I mistakenly told him that he wouldn't have to do anything with the exposure...but I feel bad now because I lied without knowing it. For it to work people need to be critical of my Wayward wife's actions here.

If I don't get his acceptance this will be hard because I will need him to tell her she is wrong when she "attacks" me for exposing her.

From the beginning I've felt that my wife was addicted...based on her words and actions and justification. I found "love addiction" and then thought about exposing her via family like an intervention. Friends around me were skeptical...socially we don't accept that kind of action in "romantic" involvements of people.

So...why is it looked down on when one party is asking for it? I'm telling my family I need them to join me in an intervention and they balk and feel that it's not the right course.

If she was on heroin they'd do it in a heartbeat, but since she's addicted to an "emotional" attachment that is unhealthy for OUR marriage they feel that they shouldn't get involved.


It takes a village to raise a child... That encompasses all periods of that child's life.

I'm so distraught that they don't trust my assessment even as they agree that she's being bat-shiet-crazy.

My family that are involved tell me to wait, it won't last... but they don't realize that for it to not last will mean that I'll be divorced before she figures out her mistake and loses me.

And loses herself.

Affairs aren't free will...they are lost reason. Why is it so hard for others to see that?

EDIT: They don't think they shouldn't get involved... They just don't trust the way I'm wanting them to get involved.
Posted By: iam Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 12:51 PM
Monc,

I very easily came to the conclusion after your 16 pages of posts that you lack the testicular fortitude to do anything about your wife's infidelity. That's too bad.

You've now broken your wedding vows by not doing everything in your power to protect your wife. Actually, you did that when you LET YOUR WIFE KISS OM!!! Did you enjoy that in some perverse way?

Don't you see the sickness in that?

I hope you're a troll because you're not a husband.

Sorry, I don't sugar coat things.
And I'm guessing she didn't show enthusiasm for that high tech computer you built because she knew it was only to support your gaming addiction which further distracted you from your marriage.
Sounds like you are easily manipulated by your wife.

She can get you to do almost ANYTHING by threatening divorce, threatening she won't love you, or that she will leave you.

Wow, just wow...she won't leave you because she can push you around and get you to do almost anything she wants...

So how do you take back control of you life and your M?

You say you have read things on here...other than the forums, read Dr. Harley's advice and articles.

People who don't know about the Harley's will give you advice counter to MB advice, and that is to be expected. Before you take their advice ask if they have lived through infidelity though. The rules change when you actually live through it.

Truth is not the enemy of you M, it's the enemy of the A. The A is the enemy of your M. So do you want to stop the A or stop your M? The choice is yours.

If you want to stop your M then don't expose, do whatever your W wants you to, agree to letting her maintain the R with the OM. Believe whatever she tells you, do not check up on her, and keep it secret. Oh yeah, blame yourself but don't do anything about changing yourself or your role in the M. You do this and you will be D by the end of the year...

You want your M? Then you have to end the A. The tried and true methods of ending the A is with Plan A...letting the truth of the A out...telling/exposing to anyone that cares. Don't tell them what to do, to apply pressure, let them make up their own minds of what to do... You are not the insipid, no-nothing H waiting at home for her to get a clue, you are knowledgeable, and not sitting around. You will also make this a M she will want to return to. You make yourself look like prime rib and the OM like chopped liver. You fawn on her all the EN's she needs (and if you don't know what EN's are, you need to do some more reading here my man...)

No one can do this for you, got to do it on your own.

Is your M worth it? Only you can tell.

Is your love for her greater than your fear of losing her?
"him to let me follow through with exposure"

You need your FIL permission?

What not get your mom's permission?
Monc,

I was just like you in my situation. I was paralyzed by fear. I was afraid of my WW the same way you are. All she needed to do was tell me, "That's it! We're going to divorce and it's going to be ugly and there's no chance for us to be together again!"

I would then surrender.

I didn't realize how pathetic I was until I had time and space and years on MB seeing other men behave in the same way.

So my advice to you comes from the perspective of completely understanding the fear you feel.

Here's the thing: Who cares what her father thinks? Seriously, who cares?

You can't count on support from her family. Blood is thicker than mud and you must assume they will take her side.

There's another realization that comes with age and that is that you can't control a single thing others choose to do. All you can do is inform them and make a suggestion, but other than that, they're on their own.

You need to move forward with your plans regardless of whether or not you have the support of her family. You simply tell them of the affair. How they handle that information is completely out of your control.

Sure, it would be great to have them support you, but that's not a guarantee.

So you tell him and move forward. You tell everyone, and move forward regardless.

You can't control what they do with the info. Some will help you. Others won't. But exposure still has to happen.

And you should be looking into whether or not you can sue the other man for Alienation of Affection.

The worst thing you can do, and something which you will kick yourself later for, is to respond to her with fear.

You'll shake your head in shame when you look back at this time period and see the indecisiveness or flat out pathetic behavior (crying, begging, cowering, fear) that you're going through.

It's normal, but you must fight it. Fight it for your dignity as a man and to have her respect you, because Plan Doormat never works on these boards.
Originally Posted by Monc
They think I want to do this out of vengeance, they understand she is in a fantasy world but don't believe that this is the right course.
they are wrong. They don't have the experience to know. They haven't seen it work. They aren't studying the psychology of the issue and know that shining light on an affair shows it for all its slimy disgusting mess so that the two are ashamed of themselves. They don't realize that having all their family and friends and coworkers look at them with disgust will seriously make them stop in their tracks and reassess if this affair is really worth it.

And your WW is playing you, telling you not to tell. When she says that, just say 'I'm not the one who is cheating and lying. You don't tell me what to do any more.'

Grow some self-respect, man!
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 08:12 PM
Your right, i've constantly responded with fear.

Every time I've cowered.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 08:12 PM
And how do I respond to statements of I'm divorcing you? Just ignore it?

You call their bluff and start to talk about what it will take...

My suggestion, you say...

"That is not what I want, but if that is what you want, what is the first step? Do you have a place to stay?" (Do not move out first...) "Have you contacted a lawyer or should we use a mediator?"

There is a HUGE difference between threatening D and actually going through it. Either way, you have no choice if she has really thought about this and started to work on this.

There is a line that is crossed when a couple begins the process. I am willing to bet she has not crossed that line. She has probably fantasized about it...most unhappy spouses have, but have not done anything about it...

But if she has already crossed the line into divorceland, better to get that out in the open now. Know with what and whom you are working with...are you working with a manipulator, or is she serious...

Threatening D is your Kryptonite...she can get anything she wants at the threat of D...and what kind of marriage is that? One where she can throw the divorce trump anytime she feels she is not getting her way...

Reminds me if my daughter when she was five and I wouldn't let her have her toy back...she said, "I'm not going to be your best friend..."

Truly, do not fear you are pushing her into D by simply calling her bluff. You may have helped push her into D by your selfish and neglectful actions but not by exposure and fighting for your M. You are just preventing her from doing what she wants, and what she wants right now is harmful to your M.

So, once again may I suggest you read the articles on the website...not just the forums, but Harley's articles. You will find your answers...
http://www.marriagebuilders.com/graphic/mbi5060_qa.html
Originally Posted by Monc
And how do I respond to statements of I'm divorcing you? Just ignore it?

Stick to this mantra: "I don't talk divorce, that is what lawyers are for. I only talk marriage. Wanna go out to eat?" (or some other question that changes the subject)...

Did you hear from the MB offices today regarding your first appointment, Monc?

Also agree with the others who have said you don't answer to your FIL...Didn't he give his daughter to you on your wedding day? She is YOUR WIFE...Your FIL has no say in your marriage, Monc...NONE...

Mrs. W
Don't think she hasn't talked to a lawyer. Mine did so and blindsided me with legal stuff in a way that had me unprepared.

I went along because, like you, I cowered. Even the threat of consulting a lawyer would send her into fits that had me cowering because I wasn't following her way of doing things.

The response to her threat is what has been suggested, with one corrolary, "I don't talk divorce, I talk marriage, but know this: if it goes down the path of divorce don't expect it to be friendly or nice. I will be merciless and will look to crucify you for adultery and marital misconduct and will sue the OM for Alienation of Affection while I'm at it. So your choice on which path we take. Reconciliation will be a lot less bloody."
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 09:02 PM
I thought I shouldn't threaten her? That sounds like it.

An ultimatum?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 09:04 PM
yea I heard from them...but it's next Sunday at 7am.
Originally Posted by Monc
I thought I shouldn't threaten her? That sounds like it.

An ultimatum?
No. Basic honest discussion of what you will do if cornered. That is called NOT being a doormat.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 10:27 PM
If she threatens divorce couldn't I also say I'll divorce for adultery?


Just talked to her on the phone...she's constantly screaming at me to let her go. And is threatening divorce. Also that if I talk to any more of her family she'll divorce me.

Seems like fear monger eh?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 10:27 PM
I think she's scared her fantasy is about to be destroyed.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 10:29 PM
A friend who I asked for a number from of the OTHER MANS mom's restaurant ratted on me...was why I just had a discussion.

Told her it was just to certify a claim that his mother already knew... Which I believe is not true.

She seemed distraught.
Originally Posted by Monc
I think she's scared her fantasy is about to be destroyed.

Yes, of course she is...She is a crack addict who doesn't want to lose her crack pipe...Take away the crack pipe, Monc...EXPOSE...

As far as the response goes to her threats of divorce, I personally would hide behind your attorney...get a bulldog and let him go to town...Anytime she brings up divorce, repeat the mantra: "I don't talk divorce, my attorney does that. I only talk marriage." Let the attorney be the bad guy...

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 10:34 PM
She just yelled at me she doesn't want me...and that it has nothing to do with him.

Yea, she said that...and I said I don't talk divorce, I talk marriage. And she yelled at me to let her go and hung up.

Then tried to bargon with me. That she'd stop talking to the other man until we were divorced in 61 days.

I didn't agree. She was pissed.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 10:36 PM
I'm going to expose. Finality in that statement. Starting with close family.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 11:02 PM
It's no use...

Everyone I've called tells me to stop and that it won't work out.

Everyone thinks I'm being vindictive and then starts asking questions and agree I must be hurting but that this isn't the way.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 11:12 PM
This can't work...it is just hurting everyone I tell.
No, the Affair hurt everyone you are telling.
Monc...

As I've told you repeatedly, blow this up on OM's side of the fence!!! TODAY!

Also, please believe me that exposure does work...it isn't always instant, but it does work...Rest assured it WILL put pressure on the affair...It WILL change the dynamics of it FOREVER...It messes up the fantasy...injects it with a dose of reality...Affairs thrive in secrecy and crumble in the light of day...

Mrs. W

Quote
This can't work...it is just hurting everyone I tell.
Is there an equal sign here that I am missing?

How is it hurting other people for you to tell them the truth?

Who have you told so far?

Why is the fact that other people are as shocked over it as you were initially a sign that it isn't going to work?

What do you think the word "work" means in this context? What do you think exposure is supposed to do that it isn't doing or going to do?

Mark
She now knows you are exposing. Get everyone exposed ASAP tonight so that she can't spin the story.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 11:40 PM
My FIL is telling me that It'll only cause the family to hate me...

You have to realize I don't have a family on my side. I don't.

So the idea of losing them and my wife... Overwhelming.

I understand that it's the affair that is the hurt but I'm the messenger and everyone kills that person.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 11:42 PM
My FIL is acting in denial as it puts "if" she is having this affair in front of everything he say's to me.

If the one person I thought who'd be on my side isn't.

How are her siblings going to act.

I sent the FIL an e-mail that proves her actions but he still say's "if".

I trust in this...but I don't want them to hate me. WHAT THE [censored]! Why can't this be more clear to others.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 11:44 PM
To do this I have to accept the possibility of losing my wife and losing my family.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 11:45 PM
I told the mom and she did the same thing...said stop.
Monc...Your FIL is gaslighting you...You are gonna have to man-up and handle this...You CAN do it...Stop letting her adultery control you...Take charge and do what is necessary...If your wife were lying on the floor of a crack house right now would you go get her? Or would you listen to your FIL when he told you that it would embarrass the family for them to know she was there so you should just leave her?

Monc...ACT, don't REACT...

Mrs. W
I have a different take on this.

My husband's family is on the East coast (we're on the West) and he doesn't have a very close connection with them. So when I was having my affairs, he went to my family for support. It drove a wedge between my family and I that still has not been removed. The relationship I have with them is now very distant and "casual". That being said, they have stronger connection with my husband.

It can go the other way as well.

Do you think that their responses are their way of saying that they don't want to get involved?
Originally Posted by Monc
To do this I have to accept the possibility of losing my wife and losing my family.

Monc what you don't seem to get is that you have already lost them...Exposure is your best chance of getting your wife back...Now toughen up son...You can do this...

Call OM's Mom...Right now...

Mrs. W
Originally Posted by MutedSparkle
I have a different take on this.

My husband's family is on the East coast (we're on the West) and he doesn't have a very close connection with them. So when I was having my affairs, he went to my family for support. It drove a wedge between my family and I that still has not been removed. The relationship I have with them is now very distant and "casual". That being said, they have stronger connection with my husband.

It can go the other way as well.

Do you think that their responses are their way of saying that they don't want to get involved?

Sparky...

It was YOUR BEHAVIOR that drove that wedge, NOT your husband telling them the truth...You get that, right?

Mrs. W
Originally Posted by Monc
To do this I have to accept the possibility of losing my wife and losing my family.

And what's the alternative?...having a WW that boinks other men but comes home to you every night...at least until she doesn't ever come home? :twobyfour: Grow a pair already. Sheesh.
Originally Posted by MrsWondering
Originally Posted by MutedSparkle
I have a different take on this.

My husband's family is on the East coast (we're on the West) and he doesn't have a very close connection with them. So when I was having my affairs, he went to my family for support. It drove a wedge between my family and I that still has not been removed. The relationship I have with them is now very distant and "casual". That being said, they have stronger connection with my husband.

It can go the other way as well.

Do you think that their responses are their way of saying that they don't want to get involved?

Sparky...

It was YOUR BEHAVIOR that drove that wedge, NOT your husband telling them the truth...You get that, right?

Mrs. W

We were both involved with other people at the time, to be honest.

I completely understand that my behavior was the reason for the wedge. What I find difficult to understand is that she invited my H and the xMOW over to her house for my brother's wedding reception.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/09/09 11:54 PM
They were telling me that if I go through with this I'll lose them... And they again told me to wait it out.

[censored] why am I so easily swayed away from my course!
Originally Posted by MutedSparkle
Originally Posted by MrsWondering
Originally Posted by MutedSparkle
I have a different take on this.

My husband's family is on the East coast (we're on the West) and he doesn't have a very close connection with them. So when I was having my affairs, he went to my family for support. It drove a wedge between my family and I that still has not been removed. The relationship I have with them is now very distant and "casual". That being said, they have stronger connection with my husband.

It can go the other way as well.

Do you think that their responses are their way of saying that they don't want to get involved?

Sparky...

It was YOUR BEHAVIOR that drove that wedge, NOT your husband telling them the truth...You get that, right?

Mrs. W

We were both involved with other people at the time, to be honest.

I completely understand that my behavior was the reason for the wedge. What I find difficult to understand is that she invited my H and the xMOW over to her house for my brother's wedding reception.

Well I can't speak for why your mother would do something that is so morally wrong...That's a real shame...

I just want to make it clear that TRUTH is the solution to adultery...It is wrong to commit adultery, it is NOT wrong to expose it...Any consequences are NOT a result of the truth getting out, but of the adultery itself...

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 12:01 AM
I want ONE of you to link somewhere on this site where it talks about revealing to everyone around the wayward wife.


I can't find it. I find about revealing the affair itself but nothing about total exposure.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 12:04 AM
And I [censored] promised him I wouldn't continue... [censored]!

I just realized I said I promise I won't continue.
Originally Posted by Monc
They were telling me that if I go through with this I'll lose them... And they again told me to wait it out.

[censored] why am I so easily swayed away from my course!

All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.

If you lose them over telling the TRUTH, then they weren't worth having in your life, Monc...

When will you be calling OM's mother?

Mrs. W

Originally Posted by MutedSparkle
I have a different take on this.

My husband's family is on the East coast (we're on the West) and he doesn't have a very close connection with them. So when I was having my affairs, he went to my family for support. It drove a wedge between my family and I that still has not been removed. The relationship I have with them is now very distant and "casual". That being said, they have stronger connection with my husband.

I would just point out that this is a consequence of your affair. If there is a wedge, it is due to YOUR ACTIONS, not his. If he has exposed that you were singing too loud in church, there would be no wedge. If my sister had an affair, her AFFAIR would drive a wedge between us because I don't consort with adulterers. Now, if she changed and repented, I might befriend her again, but she would have to work to remove that wedge.

In fact, my sister is a druggie and THAT has driven a wedge between us. I told her when she is ready to straighten out, I will be there to help but I don't associate with druggies, sister or not. So please, lets not blame the TELLING of the truth, when it was the SUBJECT of the truth that drove the wedge.

Monc, please listen to Dr. Harley and other posters who are in recovered marriages. Your FIL is more concerned about protecting his DD from the consequences of her affair than he is in helping you save your marriage. He does not know how to save marriages.

Exposure is bound to make some angry. Mostly those who are corrupt themselves. But folks who know right from wrong will stand on the side of your marriage and will not throw you under the bus for exposure.

Exposure is simply the most powerful tool you have at your disposal. It is like chemotherapy to cancer, REGARDLESS of whether the foggy minded and those with an agenda object.

Do what is right and stop listening to the chatterers and the naysayers who don't have a CLUE what they are talking about.

Man up and do it because it is RIGHT, and ignore your FIL. Tell him "thank you, Sir, but I choose to follow the advice of a PSYCHOLOGIST who knows how to save marriages. I know you love your DD and want to protect her from conflict, but I also love her and intend on doing what is right for my marriage. I hope you will support me in that endeavor."

Dr. Willard Harley, clinical psychologist and author of Surviving an Affair:

"I'm in the process of rewriting "Surviving an Affair" to add information about plan B. Some of the main points are as follows:

Whether in plan A or B, the world should know about your husband's affair. All of your relatives, your friends, your children, and the licensing board for your husband's lover. In some states a licensing board will revoke a license if a counselor is having an affair with a married person, client or not. This is because it's well known that affairs hurt families, especially children. And counselors know better than to have an affair.

The reason for the wide exposure is not to hurt the unfaithful spouse, but rather to end the fantasy. Your husband's secret second life made his affair possible, and the more you can to to make it public, the easier it is for him to see the damage he's doing. Keeping it secret does damage, but few know about it. Making it public helps everyone, including the unfaithful spouse and lover, see the affair for what it really is.

<snip unrelated>

When I first started recommending openness about an affair, I wasn't sure what would happen. But I did it because I knew it was the right thing to do. Now I know that for most couples it marks the beginning of recovery."
Originally Posted by Monc
I want ONE of you to link somewhere on this site where it talks about revealing to everyone around the wayward wife.


I can't find it. I find about revealing the affair itself but nothing about total exposure.

HUH? I posted Dr. Harley's very own words to you in this thread Monc...In GIANT LETTERS I might add...Did you read it?

Mrs. W
:crosseyedcrazy:
Originally Posted by Monc
And I [censored] promised him I wouldn't continue... [censored]!

I just realized I said I promise I won't continue.

That was a bad promise...The only thing worse than making a bad promise is keeping a bad promise...

Mrs. W
Originally Posted by Monc
I want ONE of you to link somewhere on this site where it talks about revealing to everyone around the wayward wife.


I can't find it. I find about revealing the affair itself but nothing about total exposure.

Re: Where do I go from here? [Re: hockeymom]
Dr. Harley Dr. Harley
#2160600 - 11/18/08 05:46 PM


Registered: 11/16/00
Posts: 2221


"I'm in the process of rewriting "Surviving an Affair" to add information about plan B. Some of the main points are as follows:

Whether in plan A or B, the world should know about your husband's affair. All of your relatives, your friends, your children, and the licensing board for your husband's lover. In some states a licensing board will revoke a license if a counselor is having an affair with a married person, client or not. This is because it's well known that affairs hurt families, especially children. And counselors know better than to have an affair.

The reason for the wide exposure is not to hurt the unfaithful spouse, but rather to end the fantasy. Your husband's secret second life made his affair possible, and the more you can to to make it public, the easier it is for him to see the damage he's doing. Keeping it secret does damage, but few know about it. Making it public helps everyone, including the unfaithful spouse and lover, see the affair for what it really is.

<snip unrelated>
When I first started recommending openness about an affair, I wasn't sure what would happen. But I did it because I knew it was the right thing to do. Now I know that for most couples it marks the beginning of recovery."

http://www.marriagebuilde...umber=2160385#Post2160385 here

another:

"While most affairs die a natural death in less than two years, there are some that take much longer to die. That's one of the primary reasons that my first rule in surviving an affair is to never see or talk to the lover again -- even if the affair seems to have died a natural death. An affair can rekindle after it seems to be over. And to guarantee complete separation between the unfaithful spouse and the lover, extraordinary precautions must be taken, such as providing radical accountability and transparency. In many cases, I've encouraged couples I've counseled to change jobs or even move to another state to help create permanent separation.

Another suggestion I make to a couple struggling to restore their marriage after one of them had an affair is to make the affair public. Everyone should know what happened -- children, relatives, friends, and especially the children and spouse of the lover -- so that the affair is exposed to the light of day. What often makes affairs appealing is that it is done in secret. Most affairs become very unappealing once everyone knows about it.

So whether an affair is a one night stand, or has been going on for years, the basic rule for ending them are the same -- extraordinary precautions to guarantee permanent separation. But I will admit that the precautions used for long-term affairs are usually more extraordinary than those used for short-term affairs. I've helped many spouses overcome affairs that have lasted over ten years, but none of them have been easy. "

Best wishes
Willard F. Harley, Jr. here
Originally Posted by Monc
And I [censored] promised him I wouldn't continue... [censored]!

I just realized I said I promise I won't continue.

The only thing WORSE than making a bad promise, is KEEPING a bad promise. Monc, your FIL is only trying to protect his DD's reputation. You are trying to save your marriage. If you lose sight of that in your approval seeking, you will LOSE your marriage. The goal here is save your marriage, not to appease your FIL. Keep in mind that Dr Harley knows how to save marriages - YOUR FIL DOES NOT.

Dr. Harley says this about exposure:

"When I first started recommending openness about an affair, I wasn't sure what would happen. But I did it because I knew it was the right thing to do. Now I know that for most couples it marks the beginning of recovery"
Originally Posted by Monc
They were telling me that if I go through with this I'll lose them... And they again told me to wait it out.

[censored] why am I so easily swayed away from my course!

Waiting it out means that it gets deeper entrenched, you riskher getting pregnant or an STD and you lose your love for her and make it harder to overcome in R.
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MutedSparkle
I have a different take on this.

My husband's family is on the East coast (we're on the West) and he doesn't have a very close connection with them. So when I was having my affairs, he went to my family for support. It drove a wedge between my family and I that still has not been removed. The relationship I have with them is now very distant and "casual". That being said, they have stronger connection with my husband.

I would just point out that this is a consequence of your affair. If there is a wedge, it is due to YOUR ACTIONS, not his. If he has exposed that you were singing too loud in church, there would be no wedge. If my sister had an affair, her AFFAIR would drive a wedge between us because I don't consort with adulterers. Now, if she changed and repented, I might befriend her again, but she would have to work to remove that wedge.

Agreed. How does that explain her welcoming my H and his MOW (at the time) into her home for my brother's wedding reception?
Originally Posted by MutedSparkle
Agreed. How does that explain her welcoming my H and his MOW (at the time) into her home for my brother's wedding reception?

MS, I have no idea what this has to do with the subject at hand. My goal here is to help this young man. Please help us stay on that track. This thread is about HIM and his problems.
so Monc, I gotto ask you, How's "plan Monc" working out for you??

You've been given countless hours of how to do Dr. Harley's plan the right way, and yet, you continue to find objection after objection as to why you should not do it.

Have you studied these methods for over 35 years? Do you have your PHD in physchology? Have you ever saved someone else's M?
Have you figured out the difference between your left hand and your right hand?

Yet YOU KNOW that following this plan will destroy your M! You have as much capacity to save your M as do your WW's doting FIL and MIL. It is OBVIOUS that is where she got the selfish, self entitled perspective that she was entitled to have an A behind your back in the first place. That and your surrender to her impish and childish will. I'm sure her parents did the same. That is why you should stop, and protect their DD from the guilt and shame she so rightfully deserves.

Couple of the best here have wasted their time and breath on you, you cannot change your fear. A marriage is often won back by a warrior, because your M is under assault. It will NEVER be won back by a dreamer and an appeaser.

ETA: What would your next step be if you weren't afraid?

Good Luck with YOUR plan,
All Blessings,
Jerry
Originally Posted by Monc
I want ONE of you to link somewhere on this site where it talks about revealing to everyone around the wayward wife.


I can't find it. I find about revealing the affair itself but nothing about total exposure.
There's this for a start. From Q&A More later.

But I am one of the very few that advocate the revelation of affairs at all costs, even when the wayward spouse has no feelings of guilt or depression to overcome. I believe that honesty is so essential to the success of marriage, that hiding past infidelity makes a marriage dishonest, preventing emotional closeness and intimacy.

It isn't honesty that causes the pain, it's the affair. Honesty is simply revealing truth to the victim. Those who advocate dishonesty regarding infidelity assume that the truth will cause such irreparable harm, that it's in the best interest of a victimized spouse to go through life with the illusion of fidelity.

It's patronizing to think that a spouse cannot bear to hear the truth. Anyone who assumes that their spouse cannot handle truth is being incredibly disrespectful, manipulative and in the final analysis, dangerous. How little you must think of your spouse when you try to protect him or her from the truth.

It's not only patronizing, but it's also false to assume that your spouse cannot bear to hear the truth. Illusions do not make us happy, they cause us to wander through life, bumping into barriers that are invisible to us because of the illusion that is created. Truth, on the other hand, reveals those barriers, and sheds light on them so that we can see well enough to overcome them. The unsuspecting spouse of an unfaithful husband or wife wonders why their marriage is not more fulfilling and more intimate. Knowledge of an affair would make it clear why all efforts have failed.

After revealing an affair, your spouse will no longer trust you. But lack of trust does not ruin a marriage, it's the lack of care and protection that ruins marriages. Your spouse should not trust you, and the sooner your spouse realizes it, the better.
Monc,

I understand to an extent. My exww's parents didn't want to hear what I had to say or see the proof that I had for them.

Nevertheless, exposure had to be done.

Now, that being said, you've been warned that you can't count on their support and that they will stick by their daughter over you because you're not family.

Sorry, you're not.

You're not blood. Only in America do we have this "mom" and "dad" thing for inlaws.

Not so in other parts of the world. It's understood that the MIL and FIL are "her" family and/or "his" family.

Monc, againg, you have to understand that this is not easy and that her parent's attitude towards you is irrelevant. You have inlaws that don't care or will side with their daughter. They are enablers. It's not surprising that she married an enabler considering your fear at upsetting a woman who is openly screwing another man and you're afraid of telling others she's doing so.

They don't want to hear the truth. Well your attitude should be, "Look, you can stick your head in the sand or hear the truth. Your daughter is having an affair and destroying her marriage and forsaking your vows. You can either side with her or do the right thing and encourage her to do the right thing."

Done, end of conversation.

Who gives a rat's a$$ about them at this point when they are enabling your wife's affair?

Wake up!

Now, expose to OM's family. THAT has a higher chance of ending things.

Exposure works.

You have women on here who are former waywards that are telling you what to do. You have men who have been in your shoes telling you what they wish they had done when they look back and you are repeating the mistakes they made. Guess where most of us are that didn't take a hard stand?

Divorced, separated from our kids, and in financial straights because the exww royally hosed us because we let them.

That's you and that's the path you're on.

The second you realize that life will be fine and even better without this cheating woman in your life, the better you'll be. Indifference to all of this is the best gift you could ever achieve.

Ironically, THAT is when she'll likely wake up.
One more thought:

I had a counselor who encouraged me to play along with her for a time and that this was some weird game for her and that likely come back if I played along and did as she asked.

Doing that got me nothing but divorced and broke and unemployed. I basically gave her all she wanted and asked for and allowed myself to be hosed.

And they are not your family. They simply aren't. You had your own parents. THAT is your family.

These people are showing their true colors. YOu're disposable to them over their cheating daughter.
Originally Posted by Monc
To do this I have to accept the possibility of losing my wife and losing my family.
If you don't stop the affair, you HAVE lost your family.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 04:01 AM
Originally Posted by baron_richtofen
One more thought:

I had a counselor who encouraged me to play along with her for a time and that this was some weird game for her and that likely come back if I played along and did as she asked.

Doing that got me nothing but divorced and broke and unemployed. I basically gave her all she wanted and asked for and allowed myself to be hosed.

And they are not your family. They simply aren't. You had your own parents. THAT is your family.

These people are showing their true colors. YOu're disposable to them over their cheating daughter.

It was more that they didn't want to see me ostracized for attempting something they thought was completely absurd.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 04:01 AM
It's over, she want's a divorce.

Over the two family I did tell her about.

Why do the most faithful people always get screwed? I still love her and am...kind of just sad at the moment. I should be crying.
My WW told me the same thing when I exposed to OMW. Here it is 3 1/2 months since then and she still hasnt filed.

If she does file, delay it.
Originally Posted by Monc
It's over, she want's a divorce.

Do you understand that pretty much every wayward says that at one time or another? That is not the exception, but rather the rule...Your situation is NOT unique in the least...

If you want a chance at saving the marriage then expose...Call OM's mother and anybody else on his side of things...

As others have pointed out, you are very young with no children...You may be best off cutting bait at this point, but that is entirely up to you...

What do you hope to gain by being here on the MB board if you aren't going to follow the advice you are given Monc?

Mrs. W
By the way, all waywards say they want a divorce after any exposure...it's in the script...she is following it to the letter...If you want to kill the affair keep exposing...

Mrs. W
Quote
It's over, she want's a divorce.
Let me see...
She's been lying to you for quite a while now. She denied actually having an affair and said that exposure would mean the end of your marriage so you believe her...

Monc, my wife told me she wanted a divorce. She told me there was no way she would give up OM. She told me she hadn't loved me in 20 years, in fact she never really loved me. She told me she married me for the wrong reasons, that she married me too young, before she knew who she was, who I was, what love was...

It's part of the script, man. EVERY wayward says those things..If you give them enough time, they'll say all of them.

Oh, and exposure?

"I was thinking of giving us a second chance, but not now."
"I thought about trying to work this out but you blew any chance of that."
"I could never trust you ever again after what you've done." rotflmao I always laugh at this one...The cheater can't trust the cheated any more...
When they become wayward, they get a membership card and a book of idiotic things to say. It's part of the package. Just ignore it...

But now the 64 thousand dollar question...

What do YOU want?

Mark

PS We've been married almost 36 years, BTW. D-day was almost 3 years ago and my wife just came and kissed me goodnight while I was typing all of that...

Silly waywards...

Aint it the truth.

My WW told me the day after I told OMW that "I thought I would grow my love back for you and I have decided I wont". She also talked about how could I do this to her. If I really wanted her back I wouldnt have done this. She cant trust me.


The point is Monc, she will get over it. If she doesnt...that isnt what done it anyways. She's just using any excuse to play the victim role and to frighten you.
Monc, why don't you spend some time reading some of the other threads here, from their beginning, to see how EVERY OTHER BETRAYED SPOUSE has gone through the exact same thing you're going through - all the 'how could you do this' and 'you've ruined everything' and 'that's it I'm through'...

They ALL say the exact same thing. If we had had time, we could have printed it all here for you so you'd be prepared for it, BEFORE she said it to you.
You know, Cat has a good idea. In fact for a long time I wondered if I just got it faster than most guys but I've come to the conclusion that most guys don't read here very much. They want a short cut and there aren't any.

When I got here I read hundreds of threads, some going back 5 or 6 years. I read Longhorn's stuff and Bob Pure's thread before I ever even registered. I read WAT and Graycloud and Larry...My first post came after I had read SAA and was working on HNHN...

I learned reverse babble from Orchid and learned to focus from Swords. I learned to have some fun with this stuff from Pep and Mel.

Read what others have learned, Monc. No point in having to reinvent the wheel.

When I got here I felt my situation was totally unique. NO one could have ever been through what I was going through...

It took me all of three minutes to read the flash script running at the side of the page and a couple of threads to understand..."ILYBINILWY" "Too much has happened" "I need space" "I can't change the way I feel" "I don't feel that way about you."

These things all run right down the side of this very page as I type this. I heard every word. When I saw them I knew that either affairs are all alike or someone had bugged my vacation cabin.

You don't need insight, man. You don't need special revelations from God. You don't even need something special or magical. You need a PLAN that you can execute...

Unless YOU are done and then you just need a good lawyer to protect your rights and assets.

Mark
AMEN Mark!

Monc, breathe and read and listen to all the advice. You are getting the best here.

If you have not and are able make an appointment with Steve Harley. I think I saw where you were going to do that? He will get you on a plan and you will feel more grounded and able to cope. He has helped me keep my sanity. For you, please. Take in everything here, they have all been there and know what works.

I will keep reading and rooting for you.
Posted By: iam Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 12:31 PM
26 with no kids and a lying unfaithful wife just a few years into the marriage?

Why stay married? There's actually good faithful women out there.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 12:45 PM
Well I'm going to tell her who knows.

Three cousins of hers and her parents.

And let her sit on that.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 12:45 PM
I have nothing further to lose.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 12:46 PM
And going to call the OM mother.
Originally Posted by Monc
I have nothing further to lose.

You don't have to tell her anything.

If you're going to use Exposure as a tool to kill the A, use it properly.

You are NOT using it properly at the moment.


1. DO NOT TELL YOUR WW OF YOUR EXPOSURE PLANS. Let her find out on her own who knows and doesn't know.

2. EXPOSE TO ALL PERSONS YOU BELIEVE CAN HELP TO END THE A. The objective is to shine the cold light of reality on the A. You are NOT doing that by limiting the exposure to only a few persons, then telling your WW about that afterwards.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 12:53 PM
The OM just stonewalled me. TOld me to never call there again.

Said I should talk to my wife...lol

My wife even told me the OM's mom wouldn't want to hear anything let alone talk to me.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 12:56 PM
Nobody I've told has been willing to "HELP".
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 12:57 PM
Even her friends don't care and ratted on me...


This is just done.

My wife keeps claiming it's me she's leaving and not for him. Lol

Originally Posted by Monc
The OM just stonewalled me. TOld me to never call there again.

Said I should talk to my wife...lol

My wife even told me the OM's mom wouldn't want to hear anything let alone talk to me.

So, did you ask to speak to the OM's mom?

If you didn't get through, continue trying.

If you still can't get through, pay her a visit.

Ignore the fog-babble from your W.


Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 12:59 PM
No the OM's mother stonewalled me. I talked to her. She said I don't want to talk to you, talk to your wife.
Originally Posted by Monc
Even her friends don't care and ratted on me...

What do you mean by that?


Originally Posted by Monc
This is just done.

So, file for D, and get that WW out of your life as quickly as possible. What's the saying - the best way to get revenge on someone who steals your W is to let him keep her? wink

What is it that you actually want, Monc? What's your end goal?

Originally Posted by Monc
No the OM's mother stonewalled me. I talked to her. She said I don't want to talk to you, talk to your wife.

Monc, people react in different and sometimes unexpected ways when they're told about something that is particularly upsetting to them. The point now is that she KNOWS, and she will view her son's actions in a different light. The same goes for the other people you've told.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:06 PM
Well nobodies actively helped.

And I won't file for divorce.

So my wife said she would when she has "time" since she is so busy.

I don't know who else to tell that can exert pressure.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:06 PM
They've advised me but not confronted her.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:07 PM
The theory of this seems sound, but people's reactions are...resistant. Like I'm the adulterer.

And the OM's mom knows who I am but acted like she didn't.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:11 PM
So I shouldn't tell her that her parents knows even if they are not helping? I thought I was suppose to tell her afterward about who talked too.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:12 PM
Originally Posted by ManInMotion
Originally Posted by Monc
Even her friends don't care and ratted on me...

What do you mean by that?


Originally Posted by Monc
This is just done.

So, file for D, and get that WW out of your life as quickly as possible. What's the saying - the best way to get revenge on someone who steals your W is to let him keep her? wink

What is it that you actually want, Monc? What's your end goal?

Get back the woman I married.

Some of her friends who I told, went to her and said "I was revealing" the affair when I called asking about the OM's moms work place.
Posted By: iam Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:14 PM
Originally Posted by Monc
Get back the woman I married.

You've got her.

At 26 you ought to re-think your poor choice while you're still young.
"It's over, she want's a divorce"

It's over because you will not fight for her. You refuse to man up and not let fear control you. You start to expose then you stop finishing exposure.

As been stated before you need to expose. So WW gets mad and bangs the OM. Oh wait she is already doing that. She wants to leave you for OM. Oh wait she was already doing that.

Expose the hell out of her. At least if she does not come back everyone will know that she is a cheater.
Monc,

What makes this woman so special that you are willing to tolerate this kind of abuse from her? What is it about her that is so fantastic that you're willing to put up with cheating when you have no kids with her.

Seriously, would you ever be comfortable having kids with this woman after what she's done to you?

You're hanging on to this scum of a woman because you don't know any better. You can do better than a cheater and you deserve better than this.

The second you accept this, the better you will be. What makes you think you deserve this treatment?

You want scraps of affection from her, her family, and others.

Is your self esteem that low?

NO WOMAN is worth being treated this way.

Contact a lawyer and ask about an Alienation of Affection lawsuit against OM and file for divorce on the grounds of adultery.

Trust me when I tell you that the women out here are fabulous and that once you understand this that you will never tolerate an ounce of drama from a cheater with no morals who isn't worth a word out of your mouth or one tear on your part.

Taking that kind of attitude with her will make her respect you more, but you won't care since her opinion of you doesn't matter anymore than that of the local hooker working the corner down the street.

Sounds harsh, but that's the reality.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:19 PM
You know what... I think my WW already spun her story to everyone a month ago. That is why everyone is against me. I just read stuff where she is telling family that she thinks she married to young.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:20 PM
She believes this effort is trying to destroy every bit of happiness she's building...she's already vilifying me to everyone.
Originally Posted by Monc
So I shouldn't tell her that her parents knows even if they are not helping? I thought I was suppose to tell her afterward about who talked too.

What's the point - so she can have more time to "spin" her story properly before talking to them?

Originally Posted by Monc
You know what... I think my WW already spun her story to everyone a month ago.

Did you expect anything else?

That's why Exposure needs to be done as early as possible, to as wide an audience as possible, before the waywards have time and opportunity to give their own "spin".

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:24 PM
Doesn't help me now.

Lets see what kind of flack the OM mother gives him.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:24 PM
She's telling everyone that she's been giving ME chances when she cheated. Wow.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:33 PM
So how do you manage the WW when they are acting like you are ruining all their happiness?

That [censored] storm keeps paralyzing me.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:39 PM
The New York trip is off and she didn't tell me. And is going to use the money to still go.

She IS planning on taking the OM with her I think.

She's being vile...wtf am I wanting this for?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:51 PM
My WW is getting a restraining order on me now for calling the OM mother.
Posted By: iam Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:53 PM
Originally Posted by Monc
My WW is getting a restraining order on me now for calling the OM mother.

Are you really that gullible?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:54 PM
I can't see her succeeding. I've made no threats. I know, I'm not being gullible, but she does do what she say's she's going to do.
Posted By: iam Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:55 PM
Originally Posted by Monc
but she does do what she say's she's going to do.

Like her wedding vows?!?! crazy
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 01:56 PM
Good point.
Monc, have you exposed on Facebook yet? Why not?

I thought I'd go back and bring up some of the stuff that's gone on your thread, since you seem to have no fortitude. OM works at his mom's restaurant, right? If I were you, I'd be at that restaurant, telling the customers and the workers what OM is doing with your wife. I'd be posting ads in their local paper saying call me and ask me about this restaurant's owner's son. I'd be talking to him in public about scr&wing your wife! I'd be making his life miserable so he'll leave her alone. I'd be moving BACK into your own home and making HER leave.

Actually, at your age, I'd kick her to the curb and find a woman who deserves you, who doesn't lie, cheat, and make you out to be a jerk.

*sigh*

Anyway, here is some of your earlier (3 days ago, and you're already 'done') stuff:
That weekend Feb 7th she went to see her sister Claire who she told everything apparently.
Obviously not.
I immediately turned around and put all our money back into the bank.
Since then she has held that over my head as being a greater crime than her infidelity.
GO BACK AND CLOSE OUT THE ACCOUNTS! BEFORE SHE MOVES THE MONEY TO HER OWN ACCOUNT! This is NOT your wife, it’s a WW! An alien!
I've read them and tried them...but she just keeps going further and further away. She won't work with me at all outside of counseling. Sometimes she talks to me but she only finds reason to get angry when I confront her failings.
You haven’t read it all if you don’t know you that it does NO GOOD to talk to her until she has NO with other man and has been through withdrawal.
What is plan A exactly?
How can you say you’ve read everything if you don’t even know what Plan A is?
Everyone tells me that this Exposure thing will just make it worse...
Everyone who knows her and is afraid of her temper…NOT everyone who has had experience with affairs and has seen them dissipate when exposed.
People I've told so far about this idea is everyone.
You said this Saturday, and today you say you’ve told 3 cousins. Which is it? Have you told her best friend? Her other friends? Sisters? Brothers? Aunts? Uncles? Coworkers? Boss? His boss? His brothers and sisters?
How DEEP should I go? Cause Facebook literally exposes the entire family extended and all.
Most definitely do Facebook, then, if it tells everyone at once. You are saving her from herself by exposing. She is NOT herself right now. If you can get her away from OM, she can withdraw and return to her former self, the one you fell in love with.
I'll need to steal her phone to get the super list of numbers.
So get it.
I should name the OM to everyone too right?
H&ll yeah. Make sure he can’t do this to some other poor schlub’s wife!
Well I have no means to financially cut her off. Everything car, phone and such are in her name.
But you have access to your bank accounts. Do NOT let her withdraw from those accounts!
As I've said two family members know...an Aunt and uncle.
Is that good enough for now in terms of exposure?
Are you insane? No mother, father, sister, brother, best friend? What are you thinking?!
they are making me feel that if I tell everyone it'll only leave her permanently shamed in the family...that everyone will always look at her as the adulterer.
Now I KNOW you haven’t read everything here. When she leaves OM and goes through withdrawal, she learns shame and becomes repentant, and she asks her family for forgiveness and they forgive her and you have a better marriage than you had before.
I do know the other man's mother would castrate him for his current actions. The other mans mother had apparently said often that he'd try and hit on my wife and they'd cheat. Seriously. And look where I am for not listening to HIS mother?
Then TELL HER! And keep telling her so she'll tell her son to leave your wife alone!
What is frustrating is my wayward wife's father won't support this. I know he won't because it means that his wife would have to learn of my wife's actions. So...because of that I am forced to watch my wife walk away from me, because I can't disrespect him.
Bullchit! So you will GIVE UP your marriage just so you don’t disrespect your FIL? Do you think he will respect you? No!
Not meeting there I'm pretty damn sure. It's her Alumni college event.
I'm certain of that due to evidence.
And I’m certain he has already booked a room near hers so they can spend the evenings together when she leaves the event.
Told her it was just to certify a claim that his mother already knew... Which I believe is not true.
She seemed distraught.
Because she’s been lying to you. His mother does NOT know. Have you called her yet? Why not? She should be the ABSOLUTE FIRST person you call, as you said earlier.
I told the mom and she did the same thing...said stop.
They are why your wife feels entitled to scr&w other men – they have taught her entitlement – everything is for poor sweet daughter. Ugh! Ignore them and call HIS MOM again!
I want ONE of you to link somewhere on this site where it talks about revealing to everyone around the wayward wife.
I can't find it. I find about revealing the affair itself but nothing about total exposure.
Go back and read the first 5 pages of your thread. We already posted that information. You ignored it.
Originally Posted by Monc
My WW is getting a restraining order on me now for calling the OM mother.

rotflmao
Have you frozen your bank accounts yet?

Have you moved back into your own home?

Have you inconvenienced her A in any other way?

Then you SHOULD just walk away, if you're not willing to fight for this marriage.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 02:08 PM
Sorry, I'm on xanax so my memory is [censored] for short term.
Frankly, I agree with catperson and baron. Can you imagine having children with this woman and going through this with 3 little children in tow? Cut your losses and get out while the getting is good. You said yourself she doesn't change her mind and is intent on divorce. Why not take her at her word and just move on?
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Frankly, I agree with catperson and baron. Can you imagine having children with this woman and going through this with 3 little children in tow? Cut your losses and get out while the getting is good. You said yourself she doesn't change her mind and is intent on divorce. Why not take her at her word and just move on?
And I would bet you $100 that the first time you DO say 'fine, I'll see you in court,' she'll whip her head around so fast and beg you to stop you won't even see it. She needs to respect you to love you, and she obviously doesn't. Her parents taught her to feel entitled to use people, so the only ones she'll not use are those she respects - those who stand up to her.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 02:25 PM
Because she's also being crazy? And lying, and cheating? Something she doesn't normally do.
Originally Posted by Mark1952
Quote
It's over, she want's a divorce.

Monc, my wife told me she wanted a divorce. She told me there was no way she would give up OM. She told me she hadn't loved me in 20 years, in fact she never really loved me. She told me she married me for the wrong reasons, that she married me too young, before she knew who she was, who I was, what love was...



Silly waywards...

You heard this all too? LOL

Almost word for word from my wifes mouth.
Monc,

At this point there is only one phone call you need to make...

Call a lawyer and get rid of this woman while the gettin' is good.

Mark
Originally Posted by Monc
Because she's also being crazy? And lying, and cheating? Something she doesn't normally do.

But you told us that she said she was DONE and that she means everything she says, remember?
Originally Posted by Monc
Because she's also being crazy? And lying, and cheating? Something she doesn't normally do.

Or it is exactly what she normally does and is who she really is.

It took falling out of love with my exww to see her for who she really was: a drama queen who has no self esteem and who uses medical conditions to draw attention to herself and/or creates the medical drama to draw sympathy and get attention.

I didn't see her that way till I fell out of love with her yet everyone of my friends and family saw that long before I did.

I would give anything to have seen her this way when I was your age and could have bailed on her without having to go through the financial and emotional loss I suffered at her hands years later when she cheated on me with 3 kids in the picture.

You have the opportunity to dump the cheating woman now and start anew with someone who deserves it. NO WOMAN is worth this. NONE.

And waywards threaten legal action without knowing a single thing about the law. You can't make a restraining order or file harassment charges because you make a phone call to someone else about something they don't exactly like.

Call her bluff and tell her to give it her best shot and waste the court's time.

Seriously, you need to start acting like you're 10 foot tall and bullet proof and are sure about what you're doing.

Originally Posted by Monc
"It's over, she want's a divorce"

"...I'm not being gullible, but she does do what she say's she's going to do. "
Posted By: Gack1 Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 03:11 PM
Originally Posted by Monc
My WW is getting a restraining order on me now for calling the OM mother.
Sure she is rotflmao

My freind you are absolutly all over the map.
Stop listining to what she, or her supporters say. Start looking at what she is actually doing.

And CALM DOWN!!

Many of those supporters will abandone here after they see more of her actions come to light.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 06:38 PM
My WW's e-mail:

Quote
"Please stop doing that, then. You're invading the privacy of my friends now, and that is completely reprehensible. The jilted husband bit is getting old and tired, and you don't get to wave the Victim flag anymore. This is harassment. And if I have to, I will get the police involved. Be careful, now you're bringing down the wrath of his family, too."

After she found out I called her guys Mother. Supposedly I deserve to be scared.

Also, doesn't that seem almost polite?

And should I respond?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 06:45 PM
By what method could this turn into a case of harassment in TX?

Originally Posted by Monc
My WW's e-mail:

Quote
"Please stop doing that, then. You're invading the privacy of my friends now, and that is completely reprehensible. The jilted husband bit is getting old and tired, and you don't get to wave the Victim flag anymore. This is harassment. And if I have to, I will get the police involved. Be careful, now you're bringing down the wrath of his family, too."

After she found out I called her guys Mother. Supposedly I deserve to be scared.

Also, doesn't that seem almost polite?

Here is what you reply:

W, the man you are having an affair with invaded the privacy of MY marriage. I will not tolerate that offense without responding. I have responded by informing his mother, your family, and our friends of THE TRUTH. Why do you have a problem with me speaking about the truth? Please, I would love to hear why you have a problem with me talking about your actions, if there is nothing wrong with your actions. I'm waiting to hear your answer.

I can wave any flag I want to, as long as you are married to me and having sex with ANOTHER MAN!

You want to call the police? Please go right ahead. Here is their number (XXX-XXXX). I would love to hear what they think when I tell them I am responding to your infidelity.

And you can tell your affair partner that his family is welcome to address me any time they like, and I will be happy to talk to them about how their son, brother, cousin, or nephew is scr&wing the wife of another man.

Have a nice day.

PS: I will be returning to our home tonight. If you try to prevent me, I WILL be bringing the police.

Love,
H
Originally Posted by Monc
By what method could this turn into a case of harassment in TX?
It can't. They are blowing smoke because you have them scared, now.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 07:20 PM
Catperson,

I liked that. I sent it to her.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 07:37 PM
Should I threaten to expand my "exposure"? Or just continue on?

I'm feeling liberated now... Once we divorce I'm not going to have the family anyway. I won't want to see "THEM" standing together ever...it'll just make me sick.

And why would I want a family that protects an affair? Granted...some have been helpful, but not in the way I need.
Posted By: Tabby1 Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 07:46 PM
Don't threaten. Just do it. Threatening will simply inform her, and she'll use that information to counter- expose (i.e. make up some story about what a raving lunatic you are so when you expose, that's exactly what you sound like). In fact, she is already informed that you are exposing so do what you need to do quickly. It's the only chance you really have to make a difference.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 08:18 PM
Her friends list encompasses EVERYONE in her life... That would be a big explosion...
Posted By: Tabby1 Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 08:21 PM
Where do you think the term "nuclear exposure" comes from? Explode away!
Originally Posted by catperson
Originally Posted by Monc
My WW's e-mail:

Quote
"Please stop doing that, then. You're invading the privacy of my friends now, and that is completely reprehensible. The jilted husband bit is getting old and tired, and you don't get to wave the Victim flag anymore. This is harassment. And if I have to, I will get the police involved. Be careful, now you're bringing down the wrath of his family, too."

After she found out I called her guys Mother. Supposedly I deserve to be scared.

Also, doesn't that seem almost polite?

Here is what you reply:

W, the man you are having an affair with invaded the privacy of MY marriage. I will not tolerate that offense without responding. I have responded by informing his mother, your family, and our friends of THE TRUTH. Why do you have a problem with me speaking about the truth? Please, I would love to hear why you have a problem with me talking about your actions, if there is nothing wrong with your actions. I'm waiting to hear your answer.

I can wave any flag I want to, as long as you are married to me and having sex with ANOTHER MAN!

You want to call the police? Please go right ahead. Here is their number (XXX-XXXX). I would love to hear what they think when I tell them I am responding to your infidelity.

And you can tell your affair partner that his family is welcome to address me any time they like, and I will be happy to talk to them about how their son, brother, cousin, or nephew is scr&wing the wife of another man.

Have a nice day.

PS: I will be returning to our home tonight. If you try to prevent me, I WILL be bringing the police.

Love,
H

Game..Set... and Match.

Nice one.
Originally Posted by Monc
Once we divorce I'm not going to have the family anyway.

So is plan D and/or FU in motion now?
She is making threatening noises because exposure is WORKING. It's causing PROBLEMS over in affair-land. You are not doing anything illegal as long as you are polite and do not continue to expose to a person if THAT person has asked you to stop. (This does not mean your WW asking you to stop.)

I live in Texas and adultery is still on the books, even though it's no longer used as grounds in a divorce. You can still CLAIM it in a divorce petition as it relates to property division and custody.

I just found out it can also be a separate cause of action in a civil suit!

Here's an article about suing your spouse for adultery in Texas (not divorce)

(BTW, this is NEWS to me and I've been in the legal field in Texas for years!) hurray
Posted By: MacNut Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 08:35 PM
Monc,
drop the exposure bomb, soon as you can. Even if it doesn't save your marriage, at least the family will KNOW the divorce is not exclusively (or even mostly) your fault, but hers.
None whatesover from what you have told us. Unless you threatened her or called her repeatedly after she asked you to stop, this isn't harrassment. Sounds like someone is just pissed off because you made them look bad, which is somewhat the point.

It also isn't defamation, which is a term that is used all too loosely, and it sounds like you may hear it soon. If it's true, it's not defamatory - remember that.

-Edit: sorry I guess I wasn't on the last page like I thought.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 08:42 PM
A reply to one of my e-mails:

Quote
No. and no. and NO.

I want a divorce.

I want to be free.

I want you to let me go.

How is that vague?


A therapist, whom I respect very much once told me this:

When considering a divorce, a lot of times it just doesn't happen because one person is willing to hold on to the marriage for better or for worse and even though the other person says they are done they'll usually continue on. If the other party isn't fully "in it to win it though" their sword will come back out and it will start all over again. This sometimes even results in the opposite person wanting to leave the marriage, and maybe now the other one wants to keep it going, creating a circle of bad behaviour in the marriage that may never correct itself.

There's only two ways to break the circle. Someone has to put down their sword, or you both decide to go your seperate ways.

In my opinion Monc, I'm having a hard time determining exactly what it is you are wanting to do. If you wish to persue the marraige, then persue (cautiously) - but if you are wanting to walk away, it seems like the writing is right there on the wall.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/10/09 10:18 PM
I want the marriage.

She had an affair and now thinks I'm not "IT" because she feels more strongly about the other guy now.
Monc,

Beware that there is a part of a BH mind which says, "I will win her back and then get rid of the cheating bit**ch on my terms."

It's a battle that really isn't worth fighting.

You're pursuing a cheating and lying woman. Why? You haven't answered that question. You say this isn't normally her. But it is. This IS who she is. She is showing you her true colors. She's a cheater who puts no value on vows or marriage or family.

If she wants a divorce, then why doesn't she file?

And move back into your house/apartment. You have as much a right to be there as she does and you'll be making a statement that you're not going to make things easy or will be going down without a fight.

And I'd confront OM. I like the idea of going to his restaurant when he's working and announcing to everyone that he's doing your wife.

Embarrass him. Humiliate him. Regardless of whether or not you keep her. Do it.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/11/09 12:13 AM
The OM is hours away and I know not his where abouts.

Or I'd have probably kicked his [censored] by now just in frustration.


Why do I want her back? Because those vows and promises mattered to me. Even if she's broken them.

I'm a unique case. She was my first everything.

I've got a great deal of emotions tied up in her.

Letting that go...I'm trying to fight.

Though you are right about some things. She IS this person but I see that now and I want to be the one to help her be better than this.

That is what being her husband is to me... It's hard but I can only fight for her even when she doesn't want me.

Before this she wasn't a lying cheating woman.

I promised 60 years to her...

As to filing(said last night she would since I won't): She claims she was going to give me a year to work this out but now she's going to file when she has time. The year was to fence-sit and see who she wanted. If I'd please her but at the same time she was indulging in the other guy...so basically stringing me along without realizing it.

She reminds me of my ex-fiance. I started dating him in high school; he was 3 years older than me. He was a manipulator. At one point, he said to me "I don't think you're mature enough for me. I'm going to give you 6 months. If you're not grown up enough by then, I'll just have to leave you and find someone else." Of course, I begged him not to leave me, to give me one more chance. It was the most humiliating moment of my life and I've hated myself ever since; it was so traumatic that I remember it exactly, like it was yesterday.

Don't do that to yourself.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/11/09 01:31 AM
After calling the OM mother. The mother threatened to cut him off financially for his college.

My WW called me telling me that she would do anything I wanted down to sex slave if I would never call his mother again...that she'd not talk to him for five years to protect him.

I told her I didn't want her to be my slave, I wanted my wife.

She said she'd do anything and any list could be written except divorce was absolute...

She said I had finally broken her.

She said she'd go to her family and tell them how much of a "whore" she was.

What the hell?

She's an amazing actor by the way. Although I try to believe her at all times.

The OM who I being a emotional/intellectual person myself, am sympathizing with him. I don't want to destroy his future career. Is Exposure basically coercion or is it meant to just break their fantasy down?
Quote
is it meant to just break their fantasy down?

That's its primary use...

Fantasies don't like daylight...

Or truth...

Or reality...

All of which exposure brings to the fight.

She's going to want to negotiate some way to keep OM in the loop. The only thing you can live with is total unconditional surrender. Nothing less will stand a chance of real recovery.

Hold out for "Whatever it takes for as long as it takes." The "I'll do anything if...(if you don't interfere with my affair)" line is still quite a ways off from what you need from her to know she is ready to work with you at recovery. And you certainly don't want to trade for anything you might get from her for a divorce unless YOU are ready to divorce her and want to just take everything in the process. In that case just write everything down for her and have her sign it over to you.

She's willing right now to do ALMOST anything to get you to stop interfering with her fantasy. You now have to wait for her to end the fantasy and be ready to give you whatever you need to stay married to her if you want to recover your marriage. Raise THAT bar as high as you can dream...Do NOT settle for the sake of peace...

Oh, and the divorce thingy?

All WWs say that when exposure happens. "I was gonna work this out with you but NOW you've blown any chance you might have had." or "I was thinking about trying to work on our marriage but after what you did I could never forgive you..." (as if what they did was not wrong and therefor requires no forgiveness) or "There's no way I could ever trust you again..." (I really like that one. The WW can't trust her BH because he fought for her instead of letting her ruin his life and hers as well.)

Ignore all of it, Monc. It's all just the babbling of an insane person.

Mark
Originally Posted by Monc
I'm a unique case. She was my first everything.

I've got a great deal of emotions tied up in her.

This shows why you want to fight so badly. Trust me, she's disposeable. You just don't know any better. You've been driving a Pinto this whole time. There's lots of Mercedes and Ferraris out in the world. You don't know any better because you've been with just a Pinto this whole time.

Originally Posted by Monc
Though you are right about some things. She IS this person but I see that now and I want to be the one to help her be better than this.

This is where you're very mistaken. YOU can't do a darn thing to change her. Not one single thing. SHE can change her.

Originally Posted by Monc
Before this she wasn't a lying cheating woman.

She was. You just didn't know it. Now OM is in the picture. He'll get cheated on too. And then the next guy. She'll likely marry several times.

Originally Posted by Monc
As to filing(said last night she would since I won't): She claims she was going to give me a year to work this out but now she's going to file when she has time. The year was to fence-sit and see who she wanted. If I'd please her but at the same time she was indulging in the other guy...so basically stringing me along without realizing it.

So lawyer up and be absolutely merciless. Leave her with nothing.

You don't understand that you're in a way and will be fleeced if you don't prepare.

And what she said to you is pretty standard wayward garbage.

Keep exposing. Move back into your apartment or wherever you lived before with her. It's your home as well. Force her to get papers. If she leaves, then file for abandonment.

Seriously, you don't know better. It's mainly your age. There's a wonderful world of women who you could start with a clean slate and who have morals and who won't cheat.

Believe me, if she came back you'd always wonder about her. You won't love her the same way she did before unless she really, really changed and that's no guarantee. Many a BS on these boards can't get past the cheating.

They go through predictable stages in recovery. First it's the elation of the return. Resentment and anger kick in afterwards when reality hits. Even SH says that the biggest threat to a marriage in recovery is the BS.

It's happening to Krazy on this board, who is 3 years into recovery and just can't get past the cheating.

And she broke her vows and gave you one of the few biblically justifiable excuses to divorce.
Monc, I for one give up.
I can't fathom at this point why you haven't done the same.

When do you say enought=!!! And move on?

Why not wipe the slate clean and start again. Admit that you made a horrible choice for a W and leave it at that?

All Blessings,
Jerry

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/11/09 02:55 AM
Mark:

Quote
She's willing right now to do ALMOST anything to get you to stop interfering with her fantasy. You now have to wait for her to end the fantasy and be ready to give you whatever you need to stay married to her if you want to recover your marriage. Raise THAT bar as high as you can dream...Do NOT settle for the sake of peace...

So your saying I have to wait for her to beg to stay in the marriage? And raise the bar she has to obtain to appease me?


Shine, you give good advice and berate often. You're useful and fracking annoying.

Why I don't wipe the slate? As I joked with a friend...I'd have to learn how to date like a 16 year old but only be 26. Seriously though. I. Made. A. Promise. To. Her. That is who I am.

Others, not naming is not thanking you too.

Baron, I've loved your advice entirely all the way through.

I'm just...I love my pinto, what can I say? See...if I can recover this I'm fairly sure I can prevent a cheating again because this site will prepare me with important tools I wish I had at the beginning. And if she does, well I know what to do right away to stomp it into the dirt again.

Marriage should also require "TRUE" marriage counseling. Not that [censored] they gave us about compatibility. They need to teach how to change with each other like this site does.

Not blaming myself(skeptical):She wanted more excitement in her life but I was boring, a computer geek. I could have gone dancing once in a while or do something crazy and I think she'd have been good.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/11/09 02:57 AM
But what do I do with this "Desperation" from her?

She will bring it up again and I can only dodge so many times. I don't know what to answer her with.

Because right now it looks like she's "anchoring" into him.
Quote
So your saying I have to wait for her to beg to stay in the marriage? And raise the bar she has to obtain to appease me?
I'm saying that right now she isn't worth wasting time on and if she does decide she wants to return to you you need to get a marriage out of it that is above reproach, beyond suspicion and she needs to become your dream spouse.

Minimum: counseling with a pro marriage counselor, better still Steve or Jennifer, a MB weekend, an agreement to follow all MB concepts for the rest of your lives together and maybe a post-nup agreement that says that if she ever cheats again you get every marital asset and she gets 50% of the bills as a minimum.

She won't likely ever agree to such things, but that has to be your starting point. If you begin at perfect and negotiate from there you might get something of value in the end. If you settle for her crawling back to you because she is out of options and let her treat you like second best, you will just be biding time until the next OM comes along to make her panties damp...

What I'm suggesting to you is that if I were you I would follow JL's advice anyway and find someone real, committed and faithful. Baring that, only accept forever faithful from your WW.

You will know when she is remorseful and repentant. She won't have to say it because it will be her actions that show it to be true. If she says "I'm sorry but..."(Fill in the blank with anything other than "I'm a cheating lying sl^t and not worth spit") and the remorse is only for getting caught. Broken people act broken. Any remaining self serving actions (or language) mean they aren't broken, just sorry they got caught.

Too many BHs take their WW back just because she agrees to come home. They sulk and cry over OM, withhold sex, whine about their lot in life and spend their time making their husbands wish they had let them go.

Aim at the moon and you might not hit it. Aim at a hole in the ground, you'll hit it every time (unless you're using a putter) :RollieEyes: , but it will never shine like the moon...

Don't accept a mud hole for fear of never reaching the moon...

OH, in case you need reminding, none of this applies now. You don't tell her that while she is still running away. Considering your lack of following advice so far I thought I might need to add that... skeptical

Mark

Let me see if I understand this, she'll do anything you want just as long as you keep quite until she's able to divorce you? Nope, sorry!

Sounds like you hit a nerve with OM mother. She's going to cut him off finically? The dude is probably ready to bail thinking that this isn't worth it. Or he told his mom that he ended it and their keeping their relationship DEEP underground from her. If you get wind that he's still seeing her and you tell Mom, not only is her "little boy" still sleeping with a married woman she was also lied to. She's try to keep you quite.

Most of the people you've talked to state that they don't want to be involved. Well, people are curious by nature. Their gonna ask her what's going on. She probably spun up this evil image of you and now they're seeing a different side of the story. AND they can SEE that she seeing someone else. Who's more believable now?
The advice I give you is based on the very hard lessons I've learned at 36. I was an idiot when it came to women when I was growing up, but the worst was in my 20s. I fell madly in love with all the wrong kind of women. I had "White Knight Syndrome" and saw myself as the romantic Knight in Shining armor with a need to save the damsels in distress. The first really serious girlfriend I had was hung up on an ex of hers who was in jail and (unbeknownst to me) was trying to quit drugs cold turkey. I had no idea.

I at least had the presence of mind to let her go.

The next woman I met was seeing me and another guy at the same time. I didn't know. She went on to marry the other guy. I was MADLY in love with this woman and thought she was "The One".

She later contacted me after marrying this other guy and we had an emotional affair for a while afterwards. I was still in love with her when she contacted me and her unhappiness was something I hung on to and I had restored hope that she would leave this man and go with who she was originally intended to be with. I seen now how wrong it was for us to talk, but my romantic notions overrode everything else at that time.

The next woman I got serious with was really attractive, but a mental case. She was bipolar. She was very exciting and I wanted to marry her. I'm soooooo glad I didn't. She's on her fourth husband right now and is in her early 30s and about to split from the fourth.

Then came my now exww. She seemed normal at first. She was young, though, which in hindsight was probably our greatest problem. I am 7 years older than her and was well past the need to go to clubs and dancing, etc. She has a very strong need for attention and really needs a man who will be at her side all the time because she has anxiety attacks on a regular basis and it is very normal for her to suffer from one massive medical scare a year which usually turns out to be not as serious as originally thought. When we were married she thought she had skin cancer, breast cancer, IBS, Krohn's Disease, and dozens of anxiety attacks. All of them were taken seriously by me and they were nerve wracking each time, but a sense of "Cry Wolf" started creeping in.

She cheated on me when I was deployed for war and went out with 5 guys in the two weeks before I came home.

My "sins" as a husband sound similar to yours. Wasn't romantic enough. Didn't like to go dancing. Let my mom express her opinion too much.

The faults are easy for her to focus on. She overlooks the times I gave up flights and the career sacrifices I made to be at her side during all her medical scares. And there is absolutely no way she can say I wasn't an involved father. I helped in every aspect of taking care of the kids and would often stay with them and watch them while she "ran errands".

I had my moments when she was sick where I would ask myself, "Why did I marry someone who can't handle stress or is so sick all the time?"

But I'd always remind myself of "For better or for worse".

I too wanted to forgive her infidelity and restore our marriage nor did I see my alleged sins as a husband as things that couldn't be addressed, but the reality is that I wasn't the one that was broken. She was and still is and still has that "woe is me" victim mentality.

I've already heard the stories of the guy she's with who does the same exact stuff I use to do. I've heard how he helps her out of bed and down the stairs because of her latest ailment (back pain from a car accident that her boyfriend was in as well).

I was even told by people who know them both that he's a good guy, but they feel sorry for him and think she'll leave him before he leaves her.

All I care about is that he treats the kids well, which is good.

In the course of my healing I've learned hard lessons about women and see very clearly now that I settled in every single relationship I was in. I didn't seek women who were mature and sought women who had emotional voids. I felt good about filling the emotional voids for them and patted myself on the back for it and for "being a good guy".

What I've learned is that settling is not an option. I've learned that women in their 30s are awesome to date because most of the ones I've met are mature. I've learned that if you end it with one, you can easily find someone else after some time.

And the best thing that has happened to me in my personal life is that I've met a woman who is emotionally stable and who supports herself completely and puts zero pressure on me about anything. We're both nerds and revel in our nerdness. She watches Battlestar Galactica and has discussions with me about who she thinks is a Cylon and where the plots are headed.

She is my lobster. smile

But I suffered a lot of heartache to find her.

So what I'm saying to you in my advice comes from a long history of dating the wrong kind of women. Your wife is just that kind. She married young, which is a very common thing to find in wayward wives on these boards. So she wants to find what's out there and what she thinks she's missing out on. You're lucky you have no kids with her. What you're likely to learn is that there's better and more compatible women for you out in the world, but you're stuck loving your Pinto.

This isn't to minimize the pain you feel. It's very real. It hurts worse than anything short of the death of a child. But you WILL get past it and will be grateful you're not with her anymore. Trust me on that.

I was just as madly in love with my "lost love" when I was 26. Crazy mad in love with romantic notions. Never thought I'd love like that again. The truth is that I haven't loved like that again, but that's because I'm older now and see that romantic notions can cover up reality. So instead of images of rainbows and butterflies flying with bunnies playing on grassy fields while holding hands, I focus more on important stuff like "what do I have in common with her?" and "does she support herself" and "is she a drama queen or not"?

She was your first everything. I get that. I completely understand the intesity of that emotion.

But I can say, with near certainty, that you'll be glad to have let her go and will see her, after some time, for who she really is once you've had time to heal.

You have nothing to lose by going to a Plan B after you're done exposing. Nothing to lose at all since you're on the path to divorce right now as it is. There's no more powerful a motivator as the fact that there is nothing left to lose. The fact is that she is lost. You have nothing to lose by following the advice you're given here which seems counter-intuitive, but you won't regret having done it when you look back.

You will look back and be glad you exposed and did it properly, regardless of her return. You should be talking to a lawyer right now about an Alienation of Affection lawsuit to bring against OM and possibly a Civil Suit for damages caused by adultery (heard about this being possible in Texas).

Cliches have truth to them, and there is no more truth than "there's plenty of fish in the sea".

So let this one go. Heal. Then go find your lobster.
Posted By: Tabby1 Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/11/09 12:51 PM
Monc, you can clearly see exposure is having an effect. It IS working. Her reaction to it is evidence that you have hit the target and caused damage to her fantasy. Awesome! But there's more work to do here.

She's still looking for a way to keep the OM without destroying everything else in her life. If you cave in now, she's just going to take her A even further underground. It's not so much waiting for her to beg to come back. It's more about showing her what her choices are, and allowing HER to make them. Through exposure and plan A, the better choice will clearly be the M. But be forewarned, waywards don't often make the better choice. Either way, it MUST be her choice or she will never be fully committed to the M - she'll always be looking for a way to keep the OM (this one or another one) around only this time she'll be craftier and better at keeping info away from you.
Originally Posted by Monc
After calling the OM mother. The mother threatened to cut him off financially for his college.

The Exposure Bomb seems to be working. See how the response had changed after the exposure has had some time to sink in? I suggest that it would have been even more effective if done earlier.


Originally Posted by Monc
Is Exposure basically coercion or is it meant to just break their fantasy down?

It's a means to end the fantasy.

BTW - you are NOT responsible for the consequences suffered by the OM! It was his choice to engage in an A with your WW that led to this situation and the possible damage to his career.

Also, you should get into the habit of recording those conversations with your WW. Start a journal about your interactions as well. And protect your finances. Remember, while she is in wayward mode, your WW is an ENEMY to your M, and WILL take steps to destroy the M, and YOU, if she thinks it's to her benefit.

Worth repeating and committing to memory:
Quote
BTW - you are NOT responsible for the consequences suffered by the OM! It was his choice to engage in an A with your WW that led to this situation and the possible damage to his career.

Everyone, can you give him a list of demands he needs to put in effect? For starters, you need to MOVE BACK INTO YOUR HOME!

TODAY!

You have GOT to get that control back.

What do you do with this desperation? You work on the other part of Plan A, the part where you fix what was wrong with the M.

What part did you play in the demise of the M?

You've only hinted at some things. Does she have reasonable complaints about you? Work on fixing those...

Make yourself worthy of winning her back...
Originally Posted by StillHereMakingIt
What do you do with this desperation? You work on the other part of Plan A, the part where you fix what was wrong with the M.

What part did you play in the demise of the M?

You've only hinted at some things. Does she have reasonable complaints about you? Work on fixing those...

Make yourself worthy of winning her back...
Monc, this is very important. If you get back together, she has to see a reason to stay. You may have been half of the problem.

(but that doesn't mean you let her have a pass on not being transparent about her actions and working NC)
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/11/09 03:36 PM
Baron,

I'm starting to see that. She's taking steps now to completely cut me off socially so that I can't communicate wit her. She just removed me from Facebook and Myspace as well as my brother and his wife.

All through the one "withdrawal" period where they first broke up she never told me what happened and so was dead inside. She said when he came back she came alive again. She just won't here me when I said that sounds like an addiction.

Catperson, I've said the apartment is being let go and we are both moving into our own places.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/11/09 03:50 PM
Here response to everything is like this is a romance novel...and I'm the bad guy who won't let her go.
You're about to have Plan B imposed on you.

My friend, it's time to move away from the denial and accept that this is truly over.

Shield yourself from her abuse, expose to the last remaining folks, get yourself a good lawyer. File first on the ground of adultery and martial misconduct.

Be ruthless.

Go quiet in the meantime and start carrying on with your life.

Monc,

Those of us who have fought so hard to save our marriage whether we succeeded or not tend to be passionate about not giving up because we ourselves often wanted to do just that. For anyone who was ready to throw in the towel and then wound up in a recovered marriage or at least in a marriage in recovery, it is very hard to advise someone to just cut his or her losses and move on...

And yet that is what I advise you do...

You are still floundering, grasping at anything you can think of and looking for that magic bullet that will right the world that has suddenly turned upside down. This is the EASY part...Recovery is where it gets hard...

As a wise adviser around here is fond of saying, let's look at the data...

* You are both pretty young
* You have no children together
* You can identify issues with the relationship from the beginning
* You pretty much admit that your main reason for wanting to save this marriage is to avoid failure (vows meant something special to you etc)
* Your marriage isn't that entrenched because it is still pretty new
* You have little in the way of assets that need to be divided and even less that she seems to want from you in a settlement


And these are the positive things you have going for you... :MrEEk:

Not every marriage can be saved and more importantly not every marriage should be saved.

Are you 100% certain that you can move beyond this and build a great marriage with this woman?

Do you have a plan (a specific set of things you can do, in sequence no matter what she says, does or does not do) to save your marriage?

Do you know what you will need from her in order to feel like you have a marriage and not just a relationship that is on the verge of collapse?

Do you think that you would be able to have a family with her and know that your children will be taken care of whether or not you are there at all times?

I'm not asking if you think she can change in the person you want, but if you want to live the rest of your life with who she is...

Mark
Originally Posted by baron_richtofen
You're about to have Plan B imposed on you.

My friend, it's time to move away from the denial and accept that this is truly over.

Shield yourself from her abuse, expose to the last remaining folks, get yourself a good lawyer. File first on the ground of adultery and martial misconduct.

Be ruthless.

Go quiet in the meantime and start carrying on with your life.

Yeah, and email me to let me know where you are in Texas. You need my attorney since your wife is the way she is right now. He will take excellent care of you. I just hope you are in one of the "right" counties.

Take care,

Charlotte
I think he's up north, Charlotte. He mentioned San Marcos, and a 'trip' to Houston.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/11/09 07:30 PM
I know your intentions are meant well Baron.

I know part of this is due to my vows...but it's that from this site I know what and how to figure out what we both need.

Unfortunately she laughed at me when I told her I wanted to meet her emotional needs.

This danger and fear of ruining the other mans life through talking to his mother again, is a reaction.

I just don't know how to proceed with it. If I give her a list of things that I want so that I don't call the OM's mother again, that would be a form of blackmail correct? She's trying to create a case to call blackmail on me because she knows I'm also desperate in my own way.

She also thinks I'm being vindictive by calling her...and she knows me. She knows vindictive is not my nature.

This almost seems like a chance to bargain with her...to get her to the discussion table because since I found out about the affair she's not been at the table.

At least... I missed my opportunty to bring her to the table before because I didn't know what to do or how to proceed such as this site directs.

I was too needy after discovery. I was clingy and everything that looked weak.


I have a lawyer in hand for advice. Thanks.

Quote
Unfortunately she laughed at me when I told her I wanted to meet her emotional needs.

OK, so this is your very lame excuse for not fulfilling her EN's?

Sorry for this, but if my H gave up so easily and made such flimsy excuses for not acting in ways that would try to make me happy, we would not be married any longer.

You can try harder...
Quote
Unfortunately she laughed at me when I told her I wanted to meet her emotional needs.
So?

Which of you has their full mental faculties at this time? Are you going to let a fog-filled alien dictate your relationship?

Quit being a wimp.

She will NEVER respect or WANT you if you continue giving in every time she gets petulant, whines, glares, or yells. She will HATE you for being such a spineless schlub. Any woman would. It is in our DNA to need our man to be strong. DNA.

Look at how fast she turned around as soon as you showed a backbone. Now it has retreated back into your nether regions. So she has reverted back to hating you.

I really don't think you are spending very much time thinking; merely feeling. Which does you absolutely.no.good. So let's get some things straight.


  • You do NOT try to reason with a WW. There is no human in that brain - only a fog-wrapped alien addict bent on maintaining access to the drug of OM in any way possible.
  • You DO NOT give her a list of things you want SO THAT YOU DON'T CALL OM'S MOM. You give her a list of things that would make you CONSIDER letting her stay in your life. Got it? You couldn't care less what happens to OM and/or his mom. You DO care that your own wife is schtupping another man while married to you. Outrageous! is what you should be feeling right now, not concerned if OM gets his funding cut off. He is an ant, an amoeba, a cell; beneath you in every shape and form.
  • You are NOT desperate. You are NOT blackmailing anyone. You ARE telling her what it takes for you to be willing to FORGIVE her. Got it?
  • Who gives a flip if she thinks you are being vindictive? YOU sure don't. You don't even care what she thinks at this point because she has betrayed you, the ultimate betrayal, and you are trying REALLY REALLY hard not to HATE her at this point. Thus the list of things that she will have to do, if she has any intention of DESERVING your forgiveness. Got it?
  • You do NOT bargain with a crack heroin alien addict. You DICTATE RULES for continued dialogue with you. You will remain in contact with OM's mother for as long as your alien wife remains in contact with OM. PERIOD. Got it?


Answer this. Did your WW NOT turn tables and start working WITH you the minute she realized you had grown a spine and started running the show? Did you not get the result you wanted when you followed our advice? In record time, may I add?

Then KEEP listening to us, follow our advice, and man up! Act like a man, not a woman. Demand her respect or kick her a$$ out on the curb. Period. There is no in-between.

And if you choose any in-between....you get the hell you deserve with her.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/11/09 08:59 PM
What? I was trying to introduce the concept to her... Geez assume much?

To talk about what she wanted.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/11/09 09:01 PM
Liked that last post cat.
There is talk and there is action...

If all you are going to do is talk about it...

then laughing is all you will hear.

What have you done to fulfill her EN's up till now?
Monk,

What do you know about OM? The reason I ask is I fear that you don't, at this point, really know what your WW's top EN's are.
But, rest assured, your WW's OM does know. I suspect you are a good man who has been missing the mark for years because you don't really know your WW enough.

You wouldn't be the first or last spouse to do so. That's why A's are so prevelant in M's. Aproaches 55% of all M's. That is a pretty depressing thouht, but it would seem to be true. For the record, I have been M'd 39 years. That's 13 years before you were born. Both of my sons are at least 10 years older than you.
But if I thought that an A would strike my M while we we professing vows to each other, I would have never said "I DO", but rather "HECK NO."

Things can and often do go sour in a M, But it is not an excuse for an A. Excuses are a33holes, everybody's got one.

Having said the above, I question if there is a chance for this M to recover? If your WW would return to the M, what would you do? Would you put her in a glass cage and guard her like the crown jewels? Isn't she responsible to guard you and your M in the same mannor and fashion as you? Ask yourself truly, under the current state of mind that she is in, is she ever going to be capable of doing that in a way that you can be happy and confident of that?

I just wonder sometimes, at such a young age, why you can't see that this decision to marry, may have been a horrible mistake. Im my case, we had been M'd and raised a family for nearly 32 years. We both had a huge stake and investment in our lives dedicated to each other. Doesn't decrease the pain, but, makes R a more plausible solution and desire.

From Dr Harley:
Quote
Why do I encourage an apology when the Takers are adamantly opposed to offering them? Because an apology is really in order (they did, in fact, hurt each other), and it also helps settle down the Takers, as long as they both apologize. S.C.'s wife knows that she did the wrong thing when she had an affair. It's her defensive Taker that will not let her apologize. But if she could let her defenses down for one moment and honesty express her Giver's regret for what she had done, it would give S.C. some encouragement.

So Monk, there needs to be something here that Dr David Carder qoutes in his book entitiled "Torn Assunder," called "Godly Sorrow" on the part of the betrayer. Without it, there will never be R. Does this sound even remotely close to what your WW is offering you.

I'm just saying..........
Your choice, in spite of what your wounded heart is telling you......

I do wish you all the best.

All Blessings,
Jerry
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 12:34 AM
Shinethrough, how old were you on marriage day?

Quote
Having said the above, I question if there is a chance for this M to recover? If your WW would return to the M, what would you do? Would you put her in a glass cage and guard her like the crown jewels? Isn't she responsible to guard you and your M in the same manner and fashion as you? Ask yourself truly, under the current state of mind that she is in, is she ever going to be capable of doing that in a way that you can be happy and confident of that?


I wouldn't put her in a glass cage. I'd talk to her and she'd talk to me and we would learn how to stand back to back guarding each others flanks.

We BOTH failed to guard our marriage properly. We both failed at that. We both saw the signs but looked away. Our fairy tale couldn't be disturbed or else... So we both looked away.

And we are paying the price for our own fantasy.
Quote
Shinethrough, how old were you on marriage day?


We were two twenty year old kids that no one, including our parents, gave a snowballs chance in he)) that we could ever survive beyound 3 to 5 years.

Our M has since outlived our parents and continues, in spite of trauma beyond description over her betrayal. so you see, I am not an unbeliever. But it has not come without a cost. Guess I would have been outa here a long time ago if it didn't. grin

Just wondering if you, at such a young age, are going to be able to bear the cost of this betrayal. It will take the rest of your lifetime, in ways that you cannot yet conceive. I'm too old to worry about it. crazy Perhaps that insulates me in many ways.

I do truly hope you find your answers, Monc, really I do.

All blessings,
Jerry

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 01:12 AM
Quote
What do you know about OM? The reason I ask is I fear that you don't, at this point, really know what your WW's top EN's are.
But, rest assured, your WW's OM does know. I suspect you are a good man who has been missing the mark for years because you don't really know your WW enough.

I know that he is dominant. He is charming and charismatic. He is not tender. He is intelligent. He is physically fit. He is confidant. He is self assured. He does what he wants. He is taller than my wife. He shares theater with her. He also learned singing from her. They talk a great deal about the same topics. Music and theater...but that is it(nothing broader). I am/was beginning to come around to talking to her about those things...but she cut me out before I really got to fill that EN.

I know that he gives her full attention...I used to. I know he talks to her endlessly...I used to. Theirs is on the same subject all the time. I know that my WW is fantasizing about a future with the OM. I know that she did so with me.

The WW and the OM are identical really in many ways. Personality and interests. I hear that is a bombshell waiting to explode from my counselor. *shrug*

When they talk it's often about themselves and what they are doing. I didn't ever communicate much about what I was doing to her.

So Communication is definitely a big one for her...identifying is important as well. I saw that and before things went to hell and I lost it over the OM still being in the picture, we were working towards covering that EN actually.

The sad part was that the OM left the picture at one point leaving my WW in withdrawal. While all my efforts were not being put into her Love Bank. I didn't know this...and then the OM came back and nothing could go in anymore as well.

Although I've been the one working to fulfill her's right now...mostly because I realize that she is out there on a tether and needs to see me fulfilling them. I am aware that at some point my Taker will want in return...but my taker is not demanding on others as much as...antisocial. I just like to be alone sometimes, which I could achieve when she's busy and just realize that when she's home I should be giving.

The EN's he might fulfill are opposites of what I provide.

I've been pretty poor about meeting her EN's and now I get it.

I wish she would have filled out that EN worksheet. It upset me that I couldn't get her too. Would have helped a [censored] load. Her response was that if I didn't know her that well by now, we shouldn't be married then. This was...Early January.Since the OM came back she's been belligerent for the most part.





Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 01:20 AM
Originally Posted by shinethrough
Just wondering if you, at such a young age, are going to be able to bear the cost of this betrayal. It will take the rest of your lifetime, in ways that you cannot yet conceive. I'm too old to worry about it. crazy Perhaps that insulates me in many ways.

I do truly hope you find your answers, Monc, really I do.

All blessings,
Jerry

You have wisdom to insulate you.

I've got nothing but a whole lot of nothing below me. Except you guys.

FYI: I'm thinking some things through right now. Trying to figure out how to keep my brain from freezing when I try to talk to my WW next about the OM's mother and what I expect.
Monc, you need to do this from a position of ANGER! Aren't you mad at being betrayed? You should be!

YOU are the victim here. NOT her. GET that through your head, ok? You have GOT to be mad! Indignant. Skeptical. Irritated.

Any time you talk to her, you need to do it from a position of amazement that she would do this to you, ok?
Quote
Trying to figure out how to keep my brain from freezing when I try to talk to my WW next about the OM's mother and what I expect.

OM's mother, as harsh as she may be, is not going to save your M. It may well break up the A, which is a critical first step, but in will not reconsile your M.

Monc, as much as you have floundered here, your M stand a chance. But you have got to see the true reality that is a very slim chance at best. In Plan A you have got to work on yourself and improving who you are. That way, if your M doesn't survive, you will still have become a better and more attractive person, to someone who does know how to protect against their own weakness, and has much better boundaries than does your WW.

It's the 45% of those who don't cheat, that we fail to talk about!

Get busy making yourself a better person, you cannot order your WW to stop seeing OM. That is her choice to make. But you can morph yourself into something, I believe, your WW will kick her [censored] for ever leaving. faint

God Bless,
Jerry
Quote
Trying to figure out how to keep my brain from freezing when I try to talk to my WW next about the OM's mother and what I expect.

Monc,

I see two things that are working against you right now, well more than two, but two that YOU have control over...

First is the fact that you seem to have this notion that you and your wife were MEANT to be together, that you were put together by some mystical force or kismet or providence...

But the feeling of "love" is merely a response to stimulus caused by having our ENs met. You and your wife fell in love because you met each others ENs and in so doing began to foster in each other a feeling of well being and satisfaction or "happiness" that once established was present just by being together. Not romatic at all is it?

But that is how your wife fell in love with OM as well. The thing is she let it happen and did not protect your marriage or herself from his meeting those ENs, maybe because she hadn't had them met by you in quite a while but maybe just because she didn't know any better. And NOW she feels like it was something magical, kismet, providence that brought THEM together.

The second thing I see here is that you insist that if you could just reason with her, explain to her the right way that what she is doing is wrong, because your were MEANT TO BE, after all, that everything would work out for the better and things would become like they should be.

I have no idea how much you have read here on this site, but almost any thread started by a betrayed husband takes the same course most of the time. The begging and pleading and whining is followed by attempts to educate the wayward wife into doing what is right.

Eventually some guys understand that to fix what's wrong with your marriage you have to actually have a marriage and in order to have one you have to either save the one you have or get a new one with somebody else. Those that never reach that point divorce, whine about it and seldom come back here for updates since they feel that MB let them down because we couldn't help them save their marriages.

I have news for you...NOBODY here can save your marriage. You MIGHT be able to save it, but you have to know how to do it and the best way to learn that is to read more than just the answers to the questions you can dream up.

1) You can't fix anything right now as it applies to your WW
2) You have to fight the affair, not OM, not your WW, the AFFAIR.
3) WW and OM will not help you in any way, shape or form.
4) You need to have a plan of action, not a bunch of things to do as you get around to them, or things to try one at a time till you hit the magic button (there is NO magic button) but a unified, one step after another, bonafide PLAN.
5) You need to KNOW what your wife's top 3 or 4 ENs are. You can guess; you can try different things; you can identify what your own top ENs are and try to translate them into hers, but the only thing that will work is to actually identify her ENs so that YOU can start meeting them.
6) You need to stop trying to scare her, coerce her or shame her into returning to you. You also need to stop trying to educate her, teach her and pressure her into coming home.
7) You need to look deep inside yourself and identify those things that you know are love busters. (Not as hard as you might think considering the list and description of just about every one known is on this site (there are basically 6 of them) and once you have identified your own love busters you must rid yourself of them completely and totally.
8) You need to stop trying to fix her and work on improving yourself so that YOU are a better choice than OM. If every interaction with you is stressful, results in an argument or causes her to feel unhappy, she will prefer OM who makes her feel good over you.
9) You need to commit to meeting her ENs while killing love buster even though she will not respond the way you would like. It will be your own expectations that will result in your demise. You will lose hope when she doesn't react the way you WANT her to and not be able to continue the fight.
10) You need to pull the rope tight, get a grip and hang on if you expect to make the whistle. Bull riders only need to go 8 seconds. You're going to need to go at least 3 or 4 months getting NOTHING from her in return.

And THAT is just the basics of Plan A from the carrot side of the equation.

On the stick side you need to do everything you can do to put pressure on the affair...NOT on her but on the affair itself. Exposure is for THAT purpose only. It is not a bargaining chip, a negotiating tool or a threat to be wielded when you aren't getting your way the way she threatens divorce when you are interfering with her affair.

You need to protect your finances and ensure that you do not inadvertently fund the affair in any way. If she wants to live alone, let her live alone, but you do not pay her rent. You don't pay for her car, her gas, her lunch or her medical expenses as long as she continues the affair. You stand in the way of her destroying the marriage in any legal way you can without actually physically restraining her.

You keep this up for the 3 to 4 months I explained above and then evaluate whether or not you can go another 2 or 3. Then you get to think about Plan B. And in Plan B you have to move on as if you will have to be without her while not actually ending the marriage, closing the door, but not nailing it shut while offering her a way to come home.

Then, after a couple of years, you decide if you need to divorce or just live as a eunuch the rest of your life.

Saving your marriage will be the hardest thing you have ever done in your entire life. And if you win and get her back, you get to try what is even harder and that is recovery. But don't try to recover before you save it or you won't have anything to recover. Save it, then fix it. If you try to fix it in order to save if there will be nothing left to fix.



Get a PLAN and execute it step by step. Right now you're responding to whatever she does or says. Start ACTING instead of reacting if you want to save your marriage.

And just so you know, you stand little chance if you do it all just right. If you do it the way you've been going, you might as well quit while you're still alive.

Your own romantic notions stand in the way of you understanding what you need to do to save your marriage. Love ain't magic and there is no magic to fix this. Pull your hat low, your rope tight and hang on. This ride will be the toughest of your life.

Cowboy up!

Mark
Quote
Her response was that if I didn't know her that well by now, we shouldn't be married then.

She has a point...just because she will not fill out the EN questionnaire is not an excuse to not fulfill her EN's.

You have a good idea of some important ones, you have hinted at them already. You have been truthful about not being good at fulfilling them...now are you getting over that and working to fulfill them now?

What are they? Only she can say for sure, but think back about her complaints, the things she had said or complained to you about that you were not willing to do in the past, and work hard at doing those things.

These changes are not for the short term , for the duration of Plan A, but for the life of your M. Concentrate on showing distinct changes to fulfill her EN's.

And do NOT give up on fulfilling her EN's because you are getting nothing in return...that's what she is waiting for, to see if your changes are permanent or just a manipulation to get her back...to win. And she will test you at every turn. To see if you are trustworthy, to see if your changes are permanent.

You make these changes in yourself to be a good partner even if you don't stay with her. You make these changes in yourself for YOU, and...heaven forbid...for your next relationship.

Hopefully you can change enough and longlasting to show her there is a better M in the future with you.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 03:38 PM
Honesty is important to her, but this entire plan of action pisses off that portion of her.

She thinks I'm being sneaky and vindictive. She understands that I've never been vindictive but her counter is that she was never a "wh0re s1ut" either. (which I say I've never called her.)

How do I continue exposure without hitting that EN so damn hard?

I can do everything else but exposure hits one of her greatest EN's trust and honesty.

She tells me she hates me for "hurting" her love by calling the OM's mother.

I told her I understand he's a kid that is just in love and I'm not trying to hurt him...should I have said that?

I tried to explain to her my actions in calling the OM's mother. She did argue that she was not like an addict. That it was "love" and not addiction.

Do I avoid talking about our relationship altogether? It seems to only anger her more. She wants control and she feels I have the ability to embarass her.

She see's me calling family and friends and trying to shame her, you say don't try and shame her but she see's exposure as that exact action.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 03:44 PM
One of her EN's is listening to her. Irony is she wants me to listen to her telling me that she doesn't want me.

She won't talk to me about anything normal. So I can't meet the EN of communication.

She won't go out and do anything with me either.


So plan A is falling apart on me.
Quote
I tried to explain to her my actions in calling the OM's mother. She did argue that she was not like an addict. That it was "love" and not addiction.

Do I avoid talking about our relationship altogether? It seems to only anger her more. She wants control and she feels I have the ability to embarass her.

The ONLY thing you should be saying in your defense is "I will do whatever is necessary to save my marriage."

Trying to explain your reasoning to a WS is wasted breath. Don't be telling her about aliens, wanting to meet her EN, etc., just do it.

No relationship talk! She brings it up, you say, "Hmmm. How 'bout them Cowboys?" "Want a cookie dear?" If she insists, you say, "I don't discuss divorce. If you insist, let's let the lawyers deal with it. What's your favorite ice cream?"
Quote
So plan A is falling apart on me.

The only excuse for Plan A to fall apart is if you give up.

Do not try to educate her, do not try to talk to her about what you are doing, or your relationship...just DO IT!

What other EN's can you fulfill that she will let you.

You seem to make excuses and give up too easy.

If I were her, the message I would receive from that is that you don't care about her enough to get over your own victimhood...

Offer to take her out...to a movie, cuddle, buy her flowers, rub her neck...

Yep, darn-tootin if she gets angry and thinks you are manipulating her, because you are unless you are determined to keep doing these things until you don't have arms or breath to do them. So she doesn't trust you...who's fault is that?

Make yourself trustworthy and continue to fulfill her EN and DON'T GIVE UP!

You do give up and you have proven you are not worthy to be in this M...
Sorry to be so tough, but if you REALLY want to be M, you are going to work at it...

Read "Buyers, Renter's, Freeloader's"...you are a Renter, at best...
Originally Posted by Monc
Honesty is important to her, but this entire plan of action pisses off that portion of her.

Then why did she lie for so long?

She thinks I'm being sneaky and vindictive. She understands that I've never been vindictive but her counter is that she was never a "wh0re s1ut" either. (which I say I've never called her.)

It's an accurate description of how she feels about herself before her justification process which was based on making YOU the bad guy.

How do I continue exposure without hitting that EN so damn hard?

You don't. You expose because it is the best tool you have in a very limited tool-box.

I can do everything else but exposure hits one of her greatest EN's trust and honesty.

No, it hits her squarely in the fantasy portion that she is in some kind of magical relationship and not engaged in adultery.

She tells me she hates me for "hurting" her love by calling the OM's mother.

Didn't she say she hated you any way? You're not hurting her love, merely her secret.

I told her I understand he's a kid that is just in love and I'm not trying to hurt him...should I have said that?

I tried to explain to her my actions in calling the OM's mother. She did argue that she was not like an addict. That it was "love" and not addiction.

Why do you insist on negotiating, arguing and attempting to educate her? You do what YOU need to do and let her react to you instead of the other way around.

Do I avoid talking about our relationship altogether? It seems to only anger her more. She wants control and she feels I have the ability to embarass her.

Working on the relationship is part of recovery, not a part of saving the marriage. Save your marriage if you can, fix it if you get the chance but fixing the relationship is not going to work until there is no affair and she has completed withdrawal from her addiction, which is what she is involved in BTW whterh she believes it or not. That is why she is so mad that you are interfering. If OM is not an addiction then she should be able to give him up easily because it is the right thing to do. This is plain old fog-babble- Blah, blah, blah...

She see's me calling family and friends and trying to shame her, you say don't try and shame her but she see's exposure as that exact action.
She sees it as you trying to take away the source of her addiction. She's trying to make you the bad guy so that she doesn't have to admit she is doing something wrong.

Meet her ENs as much as she allows.
Kill all Love Busters in your own actions.
Expect nothing from her till the affair is dead and she is ready to commit to recovery.
Pressure the affair. You can't pressure her into returning home but you can put pressure on the affaair itself. Stop trying to change HER and start working on changing YOU. You are the only one you can control. Change YOUR actions and stop reacting to what she does so much...
Posted By: iam Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 04:00 PM
You're 26...GTF out of the 'marriage'.

Do you want look over your shoulder for the next 50 years?
I would agree that you can't educate your ww, but I would answer a little different.

"It's not love. It's an affair and a fantasy and I will do whatever it takes to end it and save my marriage. Want a cookie?"

Keep saying it over and over and call it what it is: An affair and adultery.
Posted By: Gack1 Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 04:20 PM
Originally Posted by Monc
She thinks I'm being sneaky and vindictive.
Of course she does, your hurting the fantasy of the affair!!

Originally Posted by Monc
How do I continue exposure without hitting that EN so damn hard?
Exposure is NOT being disshonest!!

Originally Posted by Monc
I can do everything else but exposure hits one of her greatest EN's trust and honesty.
No, it does not!!
She is twisting it to seem that way so you will stop hurting her affair. If you stop hurting it, you are enabling it!!


Originally Posted by Monc
She tells me she hates me for "hurting" her love by calling the OM's mother.
Wrong!!
She is mad at you becouse you are hurting her affair, DO NOT STOP EXPOSING!!!!

Call his mother again!!!!

DO IT NOW!!!






Let me try an analagy for you.

You ever see the movie "The Terminator"?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Terminator

There is a point where Reese is trying to explain to Sara Connar that the T-800/101 is completly single minded.

Kyle Reese: Listen, and understand. That terminator is out there. It can't be bargained with. It can't be reasoned with. It doesn't feel pity, or remorse, or fear. And it absolutely will not stop, ever, until you are dead.

Untill her affair is DESTROYED, this is how you MUST consider your WW!!!

You can Not reason with her about the affair!

You can not bargain with her about the affair!

She will not feal pitty untill the affair is destroyed!

She will not feal remorse untill the affair is over!

And she absolutly will not stop untill the affair is destroyed.

Do everything you can to make her affair crumble, it will enfuriate her, but she will get over it. Eventually they all do, one way or the other.




Posted By: Tabby1 Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 04:25 PM
Originally Posted by Monc
Honesty is important to her, but this entire plan of action pisses off that portion of her.

She thinks I'm being sneaky and vindictive. She understands that I've never been vindictive but her counter is that she was never a "wh0re s1ut" either. (which I say I've never called her.)

How do I continue exposure without hitting that EN so damn hard?

Letting her face the consequences of her actions is not an LB. You aren't "hitting an EN". SHE was the one who chose to have the affair. SHE is the one who percieves that everyone thinks she's a w--sl--. They don't think she is because you TOLD them she had an affair. They think she is because she DID have an affair.

If you have cancer and I'm your doctor and tell you, is it my fault you have cancer?


Quote
I can do everything else but exposure hits one of her greatest EN's trust and honesty.
She says honesty is important to her. Telling the truth is honest behavior. You are telling the truth - you are being honest.

Don't bother explaining that to her, she's using wayward illogic at the moment.
Quote
She tells me she hates me for "hurting" her love by calling the OM's mother.
And she's not hurting you by breaking the very promises she made to you? How's that for trust and honesty? You don't give a rat's a$$ about POSOM anyway.

Quote
I told her I understand he's a kid that is just in love and I'm not trying to hurt him...should I have said that?
I assumed he was an adult but if he's old enough to have seen a PG movie, he's old enough to understand he shouldn't be messing around with another guy's wife. I wouldn't waste a moment's effort defending anything you do that might have reprocussions on him.

Quote
I tried to explain to her my actions in calling the OM's mother. She did argue that she was not like an addict. That it was "love" and not addiction.
Why are you trying to educate her? She's incapable of rational thought.

Quote
Do I avoid talking about our relationship altogether? It seems to only anger her more. She wants control and she feels I have the ability to embarass her.

She see's me calling family and friends and trying to shame her, you say don't try and shame her but she see's exposure as that exact action.
Exposure isn't what shamed her. HER ACTIONS are what shamed her. Make this distinction. When she accuses you of this - remind her - HER CHOICES are what is shamefull here. Truth is NEVER shameful.
Monc, how many times do we have to say this:

Who gives a flip what she thinks right now? She IS NOT HERSELF! Quit talking to the alien! DO NOT TALK RELATIONSHIP! Do not even talk affair. Talk integrity. There is no way she can get around that one.

You wouldn't be telling OM's mom ANYTHING if she weren't scr&wing another man! You wouldn't be telling her family ANYTHING if she were faithful to you!

Don't you see what she is doing? She is twisting you around her finger like a string. A wimpy, limp string.

STOP IT! STAND UP FOR YOURSELF AND GET MAD!

Oh, and this:
Quote
I can do everything else but exposure hits one of her greatest EN's trust and honesty.
TELLING ABOUT THE AFFAIR IS BEING HONEST. Lying about cheating your H is NOT being honest. Got it?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 05:42 PM
From Terminator:
"John Connor: About what you said before - about not being able to trust me.
Cameron Phillips: Yes?
John Connor: I don't have to prove anything to anyone. Anyone - including you!"

I remember something about "Do you trust me?" as one of the movie lines.

Thanks for the inspiration.

I have an appointment now, submitted. I need to get this [censored] rolling. Done be a coward. [censored] it. I'll lose my family either way.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 05:48 PM
Wow...


I just got hit by a profound feeling. Like...zen cleansed.

I'm in the game again. I'm in the chase.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 05:49 PM
No anxiety. No matter what. And no xanax since Monday?

Nerves are calmed for now. She's not my wife, she's an alien.

She'll see warfare I'll see guardianship.

I'm calling her father tonight and telling him that if he believes in my love and my vows he will not challenge my choice and trust in my love.

I do not need to prove anything to anyone because I know what is in my heart and what I'm doing.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 05:53 PM
I'm hungry...I think I'll go get something to eat now.

I'm going to pick up the book today on my way home...[censored] getting read tonight! And hit up the place I'm moving into to check it out... Already out of the house blows. I'd have a better chance at this. Although I'd been out long before I grew my balls back.

Monc, if you don't mind answering what's your field of work?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 06:26 PM
BTW: I'm angry at her.

To anyone who say's this is vengeance or vindictive and who I care to explain my actions too.

I will tell them that is an act of the weak.

I'm am being just and truthful. Justice takes strength and I stand for it.

All others will have to trust in me.



Former Air Force. Integrity First, Service before self, Excellent in all we do.

You can say cheesy, but it'll define my effort.



Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 06:30 PM
Computer Technician/Sys admin.
Former airforce is the past. What do you do now?
Originally Posted by Monc
Computer Technician/Sys admin.

Got it.
Originally Posted by Monc
No anxiety. No matter what. And no xanax since Monday?
Is that safe? Are you going to have a huge mood swing? Not smart, if so.

Quote
I'm calling her father tonight and telling him that if he believes in my love and my vows he will not challenge my choice and trust in my love.

I do not need to prove anything to anyone because I know what is in my heart and what I'm doing.
Just remember that each time you get pumped up here, and then you talk to HER, you come back her with your tail between your legs. Make sure you're aware of that the next time you talk to her, ok? So it doesn't happen again. The mad needs to happen when you're with HER.

Have you talked to her mom yet? Why not? You could be asking her to help you.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 07:46 PM
Both her mom and dad talked me down...I had to go over the dad to talk to mom and he was pissed. I love him but I had too try and see if mom would help.

I love my wife more than them. So I'll risk losing them to letting her walk away because as it stands...their policy to wait is not working.

My last spurt of courage...I talked to OM's mom.

I'm not backing down anymore.


It's like watching the TV and not liking the channel and not changing it. You get the same crap show unless you get up off your [censored].
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 08:23 PM
It's a lower end dosage I believe.

I'm taking it again now actually as a precaution. I need to keep calm and not have a panic attack and stop my forward motion no matter how slow or painful.

As far as mood, it doesn't affect that too much. It can make me forgetful and slower thinking, which is a downside to talking to my wife. She's quick on the wit but I'm going to just hold onto anger and not cower.

I'm realizing that there is nothing wrong with anger. I love my wife, I hate the affair.
Go Monc, go!
Go Monc, go!

dance2 Keep on this plan of action!
Originally Posted by iam
You're 26...GTF out of the 'marriage'.

Do you want look over your shoulder for the next 50 years?

I'm afraid I have the same reaction... You are young, no kids, she is a cheater - not a promising start. I would seriously consider cutting my losses, and finding someone who understands how funny it is for a cheater to have honesty as a top EN.

AGG
Monc,

Former AF here as well. Tanker pilot grounded by the emotional he77 his wife dumped on him when returning home from deployment.

Don't worry about being cheesy. Tell yourself whatever you need to do to hold yourself up. I use to talk to myself in the mirror to psyche myself up.

I would also tell myself to "be Mr. Spock" to help me control my emotions.

Do what you need to. This is a crazy time.

Stay strong. Glad to see you're growing a pair.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/12/09 09:06 PM
baron, can I have your e-mail?
Send your request to the mods by clicking on "notify" below and they will send you my email. Tell them to use my email from my "other" username.
Quote
I'm realizing that there is nothing wrong with anger. I love my wife, I hate the affair.
Yay Monc! Yes!

If you really want her, this is the only way to get her back. And either way, you're gaining self-respect. A lot of women are going to find that very sexy.
Monc,

Navy guy here following your situation. I couldnt agree more with the Baron.

Like you I think I wanted to fix the situation and my WW. Why couldn't she see reality?

Do you play golf? If you do, you know you have to hit down on the ball to make it go up. You let the clubhead do the work.

Same thing here, and just as tough. When you beg or ask for her love and affection and consideration the opposite happens. When you stand firm for yourself and what's right like a rock you respect yourself and gain her respect as well.

You are apparently figuring it out, and I commend you. It will be tough to maintain this frame of mind though if you are like me. I allowed myself for a long time to let my actions and feelings be controlled by her reactions to my actions, and would try to make adjustments rather than continue on the path that was best for me, regardless of her reactions.

Stay on this path of strength. No matter what the ultimate outcome, you will be far better off.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/13/09 05:45 PM
Sickwithworry,

How did it fair for you?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/13/09 08:08 PM
Originally Posted by shinethrough
Monk,

What do you know about OM? The reason I ask is I fear that you don't, at this point, really know what your WW's top EN's are.
But, rest assured, your WW's OM does know. I suspect you are a good man who has been missing the mark for years because you don't really know your WW enough.

You wouldn't be the first or last spouse to do so. That's why A's are so prevelant in M's. Aproaches 55% of all M's. That is a pretty depressing thouht, but it would seem to be true. For the record, I have been M'd 39 years. That's 13 years before you were born. Both of my sons are at least 10 years older than you.
But if I thought that an A would strike my M while we we professing vows to each other, I would have never said "I DO", but rather "HECK NO."

Things can and often do go sour in a M, But it is not an excuse for an A. Excuses are a33holes, everybody's got one.

Having said the above, I question if there is a chance for this M to recover? If your WW would return to the M, what would you do? Would you put her in a glass cage and guard her like the crown jewels? Isn't she responsible to guard you and your M in the same mannor and fashion as you? Ask yourself truly, under the current state of mind that she is in, is she ever going to be capable of doing that in a way that you can be happy and confident of that?

I just wonder sometimes, at such a young age, why you can't see that this decision to marry, may have been a horrible mistake. Im my case, we had been M'd and raised a family for nearly 32 years. We both had a huge stake and investment in our lives dedicated to each other. Doesn't decrease the pain, but, makes R a more plausible solution and desire.

From Dr Harley:
Quote
Why do I encourage an apology when the Takers are adamantly opposed to offering them? Because an apology is really in order (they did, in fact, hurt each other), and it also helps settle down the Takers, as long as they both apologize. S.C.'s wife knows that she did the wrong thing when she had an affair. It's her defensive Taker that will not let her apologize. But if she could let her defenses down for one moment and honesty express her Giver's regret for what she had done, it would give S.C. some encouragement.

So Monk, there needs to be something here that Dr David Carder qoutes in his book entitiled "Torn Assunder," called "Godly Sorrow" on the part of the betrayer. Without it, there will never be R. Does this sound even remotely close to what your WW is offering you.

I'm just saying..........
Your choice, in spite of what your wounded heart is telling you......

I do wish you all the best.

All Blessings,
Jerry

No...she isn't offering any apologies for the affair. Zero. She is glad she did it because she supposedly found out how little she really loved me.

I talked with my mom, who I've not talked to since the day I learned of this affair. For some reason I hadn't. She agreed that for such a woman to betray me so badly I probably shouldn't put myself through trying to save it. She'd have divorced immediately.

That exposure, if it would give me closure, should happen then. Whether it is vengeance, justice, or telling the truth she shouldn't get away with this without hurting.

And if I don't expect to see her every again or her family after we divorce I shouldn't concern myself with that worry anyhow.

Busy trying to find an appartment to stay at so exposure got it's own excuse for being put off last night.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/13/09 10:15 PM
Talked to her about that I'm doing everything I can to save this marriage and her first thought was that I was going to call the OM's mother again and she started crying.

Finally some responsibility is creeping in. She said she'll talk after she comes back to SA from Houston. I asked her what she felt when she learned that I called the OM's mother and she paused...along time. First time in a while she was speachless. I don't know what she was feeling but she definetly reacts to this.

She also feels that I'm trying to destroy her life and cause her pain. As I express that what she is doing to me is hurting me a lot she argued that I shouldn't put it on her family too.

Problem. I'm not suppose to threaten her but this seems like my only way to get her to stop moving forward with D.

What I'm going to do is get the Her needs, His needs book and give it to her and say read it.

Exposure to her family will just drive a wedge between our marriage right now. I've not been able to meet enough EN's for her to have a reason to come back once she gets over her anger.


----
Just for you naysayers, I was just about to hit send on my exposure letter. She called and we talked and I told her "I am donig everything I can to save our marriage." And she immediately thought I was talking about telling the OM's mother again.

She is scared [censored] and thinks I'm out to destroy the OM's life and as some of you express that I should have no pitty for him, that is NOT a part of my nature and in this, I must stall on going against my nature.

I told her flat out though that I will not promise not to call the OM's mother ever. And she was desperately pleading that I don't drag him down too.

Originally Posted by Monc
I must stall on going against my nature.

If it's one thing I've learnt from hanging out on the forums here is that "nature" typically leads us VERY WRONG when it comes to breaking up As and restoring Ms.

Remember this: when it comes to breaking ups As, APPEASEMENT NEVER WORKS.

What you are choosing to do is likely going to cause this damage to your M to go on much longer before the M ends.

Monc,

You're failing to see that exposure is doing exactly what it is intended to do. It is supposed to end the affair.

She cries a little to you and you cave.

She's upset because it's working.

Don't let up. NO, it isn't going to drive a bigger wedge between you guys. How much bigger a wedge can you have when she's openly and unapologetically doing another man?

Carry on with exposure. If she gets upset, you simply repeat what you're doing and that you're "Doing everything you can to end her affair and save your marriage."

Her emotional reaction shows that what you're doing is working.

Don't let up.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/13/09 10:35 PM
I was telling her how every time I'm angry she has been out of town or distant from me. That she has no idea what this is putting me through and I'm tired of talking about the R when we could be spending time together constructively fixing things...yet divorce is the way she see's the fix and she also thinks the affair is over since they aren't screwing. Yet, they talk about a future together and such.

She has no clue.

I do. Trying to negotiate a chance to fill some EN's before exposure.

Exposure right now would devistate my chances. I spoke with my mom who is quite a wise lady and she is for exposure but said that at this point it'd simply be punishment.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/13/09 10:36 PM
Her parents have stayed out of hit...she even saw them the last couple days and they obviously said nothing to her.

Monc,

You've got mail...
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/13/09 10:38 PM
The problem is my wife is arguing that she just doesn't want to be with me... And is planning to move further away from the OM actually. This is secret intel I've gathered.

So...they are having the long distance affair and she doesn't see it that way. She see's an affair as physical. And she see's me simply attacking her with "exposure" rather than forcing a wedge in the affair because the OM is not physically present.
Posted By: SIHW Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/13/09 10:49 PM
Ok monc...as a FWW (yes at one time I was) I am gonna say this to you. Fair warning it's gonna be harsh.

If I set my mind frame to that of a WW....I SEE EASY BAIT. I see you wern't a man and would not do anything to fight for me. OM is such a more tempting package.

So until I can get rid of you. I'm gonna get what ever I can from you. And if you tick me off I can tell everyone what a nut job you are since they are my family and will believe me over you.

As long as I get what I want (fulfillment from OM) I am gonna do every under handed thing I can no matter what to secure my future and fantasies.

But your now telling everything to my family and I am gonna throw a tantrum because it is not what I want and you just won't accept defeat.
Now OM is thinking I am more trouble than it's worth because of what you did. But you'll roll over again I can still fix this if I am persistent. For now You've stopped and won't follow through I know you won't. Your a wimp have been for years.....you don't have it in you.

So monc are you gonna let the story take a turn in her favor and let her do damage control?

Honestly Monc if she gets even nuttier....cut your losses. I know it's hard...but some spouses never turn back. My XH had a revenge affair. He is married to his OW now.

Moving on is hard but it can be done. I was your age when it happened to me....now I am with a man I deeply love who loves my son and considers him his son as well. We are due to get married next year. Life after divorce is possible.

An ending is just the start of a new beginng....remember that.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/13/09 11:25 PM
What do I do with threats from her that if I do this I'll never have a chance with her?

Oh wait...she is already saying I don't.

Posted By: MacNut Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/14/09 12:07 AM
Originally Posted by Monc
What do I do with threats from her that if I do this I'll never have a chance with her?

Oh wait...she is already saying I don't.

EXACTLY!!! So WHAT exactly do you have to lose by continuing to expose? She keeps saying you're driving a "wedge" between you and her by continuing to expose, but there's ALREADY a wedge between you two big enough to make another Grand Canyon thanks to HER actions!

Keep exposing-like I said a few pages back, even if it doesn't ultimately help save your M, it will let everyone else know WHY your M really ended.
Originally Posted by Monc
What do I do with threats from her that if I do this I'll never have a chance with her?

Oh wait...she is already saying I don't.
Oh my freakin' G!

Monc, have you read ANYTHING here?!

Do you trust MB or not?

How many places have you read that the WW is going to say "If you do this you'll never have a chance with me?"

Did we NOT tell you she would say this exact thing?

Why did we say that?

Because every WW says the exact same thing!

AND THEN THEY STOP THE AFFAIR!

Because you made it no more fun.
Quote
Exposure right now would devistate my chances. I spoke with my mom who is quite a wise lady and she is for exposure but said that at this point it'd simply be punishment.

I'm sure your mother is a very wise woman, but how many marriages has she helped recover from an affair?

Dr. Harley has saved thousands. And he recommends exposure until the A has ended.

This is NOT about punishment or revenge.

It is about killing the AFFAIR!

Look Monc, when you called OM's mother and she told her son that she would cut him off if he continued to commit adultery w/ your W, I guarantee you that he told her he would end it immediately.

He then followed it up by telling your WW that IT WAS OVER!!

She begged and pleaded w/ him not to end things and promised him that she would control you.

He has probably reluctantly agreed to keep the A going as long as she keeps you under control.

If you call his mother again, I guarantee you that he will cut things off completely w/ your WW.

THIS IS WHY SHE IS SO FRIGHTENED ABOUT YOU CALLING OM'S MOM AGAIN.

Once the A is over you will have a chance to recover your M.

Your M can survive her anger, but not an on-going affair.



Quote
So...they are having the long distance affair and she doesn't see it that way. She see's an affair as physical. And she see's me simply attacking her with "exposure" rather than forcing a wedge in the affair because the OM is not physically present.

Yes, we know your WW doesn't get it. We know that she doesn't understand what you are really doing here.

We know that she isn't seeing your love for her or getting your true motivations.

We know. We know.

She is EXACTLY like every other wayward.

EXACTLY.

If you're waiting for her to see the truth here before you act, you might as well file for D right now.

She will not see the truth until she establishes NC and gets through w/drawals.

STOP EXPECTING HER TO UNDERSTAND.

And finish this A off by another dose of exposure.

Here's Mr. W's Do's and Don't list...


DOs

1. Act Happy
2. Get a life (new activities, etc.)
3. repeat over and over..."I will make it"
4. Actively LISTEN....keep conversations at "to the point...small talk" ...don't blow it up beyond the waywards current comfort zone
5. Tend to Agree (Thank you for your truthfulness, It seems that way, you have a point)
6. Expand your social relationships (Being especially aware of your own vulnerability and keeping sharing and time with opposite sex relationships to an absolute minimum)
7. Get sexy (gym, new clothes, etc)
8. Focus on your strengths and Positives...don't put yourself down verbally or constantly go over what you did wrong
9. Accept Uncertainty (Do your best today and let God take care of tommorrow)

DON'Ts

1. Repeatedly say "I love you"
2. Ask questions that don't have answers yet
3. Criticize, complain, whine or nag
4. Say, "I've changed"....allow the wayward spouse to simply judge your actions
5. Argue, Reason or Plead
6. Don't get family or friends overly involved in recovery (notice I said "in recovery", EXPOSURE to bust up an active affair IS ESSENTIAL and EXPOSURE to the OP's spouse is an absolute MUST)
7. Act helpless or depressed
8. Discuss morality, invoke God or Dr. Laura type babble
9. Suggest marital counseling (must be the waywards idea)
10. Tell them continually "we need to work on the relationship"
11. GIVE UP

And Pep's Carrot and Stick plan A...

The carrot of Plan A

Meeting your wandering spouse's emotional needs.

Making "home" a warm and inviting place to be.

Placing emphasis on what has worked in the marriage.

Showing consistent self improvement in areas where previously lacking.

Stop lovebusting behaviors.

Communicating with a calm reassuring voice and relaxed body language, even in the center of a verbal storm created by the infidel.

Becoming the person any reasonable spouse would want to come home to.

Remaining open to the possibility of recovery.

Offering forgiveness and understanding.


The stick of Plan A

Exposing adultery where it matters most. Exposure that takes the form of a swift and sudden unexpected tsunami of truth.

Not apologizing for exposure or speaking the truth in a kind yet direct way.

Directly communicating the hurt and devastation that the affair has caused.

Not accepting blame for the infidel's choice to become adulterous.

Let the consequences of adultery and infidelity fall freely upon the heads of the adulterous.

Establishing boundaries that disallow the affair to effect children of the marriage, financal security of the marriage, and otherwise ruin innocent bystanders.

Standing up to infidelity as a beast that must be slayed for the good of the family.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Plan A is both a *carrot* and a *stick

Thank you Marsh,

Monc,

What Marsh said?

Ditto!

And ditto to Cat, too...

Mark
Monc,

Breathe. you remind me so much of myself it is nearly as painful to read your words as it was today when i re-read mine from months ago when these wise people were telling me to man up, use your anger, and stop worrying about her reactions but rather stand up for what is right.

Dude, I was right where you are a few months ago. I listened to these people...but...i didn't trust enough to act quickly enough!

You have got to stop worrying about her reactions. Kick some a$$. Be angry. Think about what you would advise a good friend who was going through the same thing you are going through.

You would tell him to NOT BE AFRAID!

Right now, i am sorry, i honestly tell you:

You would be better off to do as you are told by people with far more experience and quit thinking on your own. For people on this board who have seen this thousands of times is like a doctor prescribing an antibiotic to someone that is coughing up green junk from their lungs.

It is that predictible. Just do it!
Quote
She is scared [censored] and thinks I'm out to destroy the OM's life

She is lying to you.

If she cared about OM's mother cutting him off/"destroying his life", she'd end the affair.

What she is "scared [censored]" about is that her affair/drug will be taken away from her.

SHE is the one who is willing to risk OM's future to get her fix.

OM is the one who is willing to risk his own future to continue this A.

All you are doing is letting his mom know what's going on.

Why should you keep their secret for them?

Do you owe OM anything?

Hasn't he taken enough from you?

WHY WOULD YOU WANT TO ALLOW THIS AFFAIR TO GO ON FOR ONE MINUTE LONGER?










Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/14/09 03:08 AM
BTW: The only phone calls my wife doesn't scream at me and hang up on are the ones where we talk about the OM and calling his mom again. She politely asks are we done?

So, she said she would support him if I called his mom again. I'd love to see that... SHe'd get to feel my pain.

Having supported a woman with a college degree for four years and then get left for someone else less bitchy than she is.


She also tried to claim that he doesn't demand her to choose anything or to divorce me. That i"m the one demanding she not see him....what the [censored]?
Originally Posted by Monc
BTW: The only phone calls my wife doesn't scream at me and hang up on are the ones where we talk about the OM and calling his mom again. She politely asks are we done?

So, she said she would support him if I called his mom again. I'd love to see that... SHe'd get to feel my pain.

Having supported a woman with a college degree for four years and then get left for someone else less bitchy than she is.
Well, DUH! That's because she's taking your cue on this one, she's scared to death you're going to ruin her affair! This is the one thing she has to kiss up to you on, because...

it's the only thing you have shown any backbone about.

Man up!
Monc,

The very thing that increases your chances of saving your marriage is the very thing you're most afraid of doing.

Call the mom again and let her know that the affair is ongoing.

You are killing the affair and she's losing it.

Let her lose it.

She will one day look back and understand that you were fighting for her.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/14/09 04:08 AM
<-- Ever the gentleman.

I'm going to call the OM and tell him "last chance". Give him the option to back down.


Monc,

Dude! Get a handle on this ASAP...

A plan is something you can do no matter what she does. You don't guage what you do by what she does, you do what you have to do and ignore what she does.

It isn't what she says or does that dashes your hopes, but what you expect her to do or say.

I have to get up in about 5 1/2 hours and have a crappy cold, so listen to what the rest of these guys are telling you.

Mark
Posted By: tnsr Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/14/09 06:14 AM
Originally Posted by Monc
<-- Ever the gentleman.

I'm going to call the OM and tell him "last chance". Give him the option to back down.

2x4 out.

You're not being a gentleman. You're being an idiot. As others have told you, cowboy up and expose. The OM is scum and you shouldn't waste a second thinking about his well being. He's a liar with no respect for you, your WW or the institution of marriage.

EXPOSE to the world now. Stop this conflict avoidance!!!! You are doing everything you can to lose your WW's respect, not to mention making it harder to recover your M assuming that is your goal.

Personally, I'd expose then D her. You're young and deserve better.


Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/14/09 04:20 PM
Seriously, what is "2x4 out"?
Posted By: tnsr Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/14/09 04:34 PM
Originally Posted by Monc
Seriously, what is "2x4 out"?

Good morning. 2x4 - whacking you up side the head with a 2x4 to knock some sense into you... wink

Monc,

Get any sleep last night?

You don't need to call OM about anything. You don't want to call him regarding exposure at all.

But if you want to contact him, do it quickly and with a specific message in mind. That message needs to be that you love your wife and you are willing to do whatever it takes to save your marriage. Then ask if he is as willing to fight for YOUR wife as you are. Tell him to leave your wife alone...

Then hang the he77 up! Do NOT debate, threaten, call him names or in any other way try to engage him. He is not your friend, has no rights in your marriage and is NOT an innocent bystander in this affair.

Exposure is NOT a negotiating tool. It is a weapon, the most effective one a BS has in his/her cache of weapons (can't believe the PC filter stops the word used to describe a selection of weapons! sigh). It creates stress and tension in the affair. It causes conflict between the affair partners. It brings the light of day into focus in the midst of the darkness of secrecy where affairs live and thrive.

If you think about all the silly old vampire movies and TV shows, there was one thing all the vampires feared most of all and that was being hit by the one thing that would surely kill them, sunlight. So they skulked about in the dead of night, avoiding any possibility of seeing daylight since it would kill them instantly if they were exposed to it. Of course everybody always looked for that magic bullet, silver bullet or right kind of stake to drive through their hearts and lived in fear that the vampires would get them.

Truth is like daylight to an affair. It is deadly to an affair because it is the one thing that the affair cannot tolerate, since an affair can only exist in secrecy. And everybody (95% in the latest surveys) believe an affair is wrong so when they find out someone they know is having one, they are suddenly faced with the reality that the person they care about is something they themselves detest.

When you expose an affair to those who care about the infidel, you are making those people uncomfortable. They don't like being told that their loved one is doing something so detestable. Their belief system is being challenged...

But they still know the truth and it is the truth that will destroy the affair in the long run, whether the infidel returns to the marriage or not, it is still certain death to the affair. This is because when it is no longer a secret, it can't be called by any name other than an affair. It is no longer a friendship, a relationship or a person you care about but a cheating, adulterous, unfaithful action.

Vampires feed at night because they can't survive in daylight. Affairs thrive and live in secrecy because they can't survive illuminated by reality and truth.

As a BS you have very little chance of recovering your marriage. Even if you do everything right and get another chance to work at it, you might never be able to get your marriage to a place where you and your WS can both be happy with it. You have very few weapons to use against the enemy, which is the affair (not your WS, not OM/OW) but the one thing you do have is the sunlight of exposure and truth.

Mark
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/14/09 07:57 PM
I've already done everything the wrong way...

Monc

Still crying like a little girl. Man up and follow the advice you have been given.
Monc,

Have heart. No one has said this will be easy. You will make mistakes. We all did. We all made big ones.

But we're talking to you from the perspective of having already made those mistakes.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/15/09 05:04 AM
Will be sending out an exposure letter pending how my WW reacts to my current pair of people wanting to talk to her. Monday Night most likely.

I want to do it sooner, but they are on board and understand that I must do what I must do if she does not tell them the truth.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/15/09 05:05 AM
My WW is telling everyone I'm being crazy, acting like a stalker, and making threats if she doesn't work things out with me.

Oddly, I found she is telling friends this. Not relatives much.
This is pretty standard. That's why it's important to expose to everyone right up front and let them know ahead of time that she's cheating so they hear both sides of things, but you have your evidence to show the truth.

She's going to continue to do and say crazy stuff. Nothing should surprise you. You've been forewarned here that she's going to get nuttier and nuttier because you're making her life difficult and the affair difficult.

If anyone asks you, you simply stick to the story, "My wife is having an affair and I'm doing what I need to do to save my marriage and end her affair. Your support would be appreciated."
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/15/09 05:59 AM
BTW: It's a [censored] to focus on life while trying to save my marriage from a psycho.

Friends are pissed at my lack of apartment hunting and damn xanax is making me half arsed. Told them barely enough information and now not only am I dealing with my wife but the generous friends are biting my heels now as well for omission...which I agree with them was lying. I didn't tell the entire story as I should have. The irony is I was trying to not just wave them off and say that I did nothing at all...and telling them I did anything upset them.

This same issue is a pain when trying to talk to my wife. I just can't get my information straight.
Posted By: tnsr Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/15/09 06:50 AM
Originally Posted by Monc
BTW: It's a [censored] to focus on life while trying to save my marriage from a psycho.

Friends are pissed at my lack of apartment hunting and damn xanax is making me half arsed. Told them barely enough information and now not only am I dealing with my wife but the generous friends are biting my heels now as well for omission...which I agree with them was lying. I didn't tell the entire story as I should have. The irony is I was trying to not just wave them off and say that I did nothing at all...and telling them I did anything upset them.

This same issue is a pain when trying to talk to my wife. I just can't get my information straight.

Tell everyone to whom you expose the entire, unvarnished truth. Same with your wife. If you always stick to the facts you'll never have to worry about keeping your information straight.
warning the OM is NOT being a gentleman its being ... frankly ... foolish.

WHY??? because of something like this maybe ??????

OM to Mum - Mum that crazy H of my EX girlfriend... because mum I really didn't know she was married until he rang you.... rang me again and told me to leave her alone... but I have already mum after you told me to.... that guy is CRAZY he's a nut case... I did the right thing mum like you told me too ... mum you are so wise I nearly messed up big time mum ... but you saved me ... etc etc ... mum I even heard he abuses her ... pee in mums pocket a bit more ..."

Mum to OM - "Ok dear as long as you have learned. Don't worry I'll protect you from that nut case."

Mum to you - YOU ARE A NUT CASE.. NEVER RING HERE AGAIN OR ELSE I'll HAVE THE POLICE ONTO YOU - ABUSER!!!

That's the sort of phone conversation that you will get after warning him.

Monc I am a FWW and this how the real world works in this crap. Your WW REALLY believes all her lies. So does OM.
Your wife only lies when she speaks. Yet you hang onto every word she utters. I understand your desperation to have your WIFE back but you need to ignore her madness while she is a ww... I was a mad woman as well while a ww. AND a fantastic liar.

You really need to follow the advice you have been given... your M is already all but down the tubes anyway... AVOIDANCE of conflict = divorce on your WW terms.

You're a good avoider. Its a habit your ww has trained you in since you both got engaged and REINFORCED from your wedding day.
YOU need to change as much as she does.

START NOW... FOLLOW THE ADVICE YOU ARE BEING GIVEN BY THOSE WHO HAVE BEEN THERE DONE THAT.!!!
You keep finding new ways to be a weasel. Weaseling your way out of exposing, pending this or that.
Monc,

How did things go this morning with your appointment?

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/16/09 08:13 PM
Missed the appointment time. So I'm begging them to refund the late fee but I have one for tomorrow morning 6am again.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/16/09 08:36 PM
She wants to meet up and talk our separation today but I'm going to tell her no thanks. I'm not interested in talking about that today.

I'm going to draft a Plan B letter and have it in my back pocket and if she doesn't remotely give me the impression that a long distance Plan A will still be workable, I'm handing her the letter.

I've decided that I'm telling her that many different people know about the affair and that includes her parents. Just her knowing her parents know will be massive.

Them knowing matters more than anything, but they didn't confront her.


From what I've seen you've not done much in the way of showing her your M would be better if she returned. You move to Plan B now, you are dooming yourself to Plan D...perhaps what you want.

You show her consistent action you can fulfill her EN's, show her a better H, THEN move to Plan B, you run a better chance of her return.

And you have to SHOW her, not Tell her....
Monc,

Get ready!

Hang on!

Here it comes!


:twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour:

Quote
I've decided that I'm telling her that many different people know about the affair and that includes her parents

WTF?

Exposure is not a negotiating tool. It is not something that you toss out as a way of trying to force her to change er mind,

Whay would she want to stay married to you, Monc? That is what you have yet to get. You have to be able to offer her something BETTER than OM or being alone. You do that by:

(All together now)

1) Meet her ENs as much as she allows
2) Avoid Love Busters
3) Have no expectations when it comes to the way she will react at any given moment in time.

# 1 deposits into her Love Bank
# 2 prevents unnecessary withdrawals from her Love Bank
# 3 protects you from having your hopes destroyed when she doesn't react the way you expect her to.

You really have very little time to get this concept down. You can't fix her or the affair and you can't fix the marriage right now. All you can fix is YOU. So work on YOU. Make YOU the best YOU that YOU can be. Make Monc the man of her dreams, the one she can't live without.

I hear the argument already, so spare me...

I didn't tell you to make her understand anything or to get her to react the way you want her to or to get her to stop telling you she hates you...

I said to fix YOU and make YOU a better YOU!

You're running out of time here my friend! Quit feeling sorry for yourself and start fighting for your marriage and your wife or just let her go.

Just so you know, if you went to Plan B today, she would have no good memories to make her consider coming back when the affair is dead, which it will be eventually. You're still trying to get her to come home on your terms and she is not willing to make any concessions right now. But if you SHOW her that you can be the man of her dreams, she MIGHT be willing to consider staying.

:twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: (My arm is getting tired. Somebody help me out here...) :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour:
I'm going to quote the Joker and show what a nerd I am.

What happened? Did your b@lls drop off? Man up and follow the plan if you want your wife to come back to you.

Plan A does not mean

Pleasing
Loco
Adulterer
No matter what

A.

Plan A is, condensed, comprised of two things:

1. Show your WS what he or she will miss when/if you go to Plan B. Fulfill ENs, etc.
2. Expose like h311.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/21/09 04:08 AM
Sad thing mark...

It's taken me months to realize I need to fix me... And work on me. And just endure that the affair would continue and that it wouldn't just END immediately.

The fact that there was someone else in her heart destroyed me and drove me crazy. And now I've beaten the [censored] out of my chances because she won't even talk to me without yelling.

I am essentially moved out now, my own apartment, and her telling me she wants to file in a week's time.

She fed me some lines about being afraid that I'd hurt myself, or let my job go to [censored], or do something crazy.

I didn't say it, but I was just stumped. I couldn't speak and could only glare and fume as she wanted to quite talking I was thinking, why do you care?! If you really don't love me why do you care what divorcing me will do?!

And talking to my friends I'm realizing just how selfish she has been our whole marriage. I went along with ALL of her past times. Movies, opera's, shows, plays, etc. I rarely forced my tastes or wants. The only want I ever exercised was playing video games a great deal which I often asked her to join me in, but she only put up a token effort in all the five years we've been dating/engaged/married.

And now she calls me a child constantly and belittles me and says crap about my computer being my mistress... She had an affair because she was threatened by a machine? How low can your self esteem be? This is all stuff I'm thinking but can't say to her because I've already LB'ed my [censored] into the ground yelling over and over about the affair at her.

And not getting to meet any EN's at all pretty much ensured her Lovebank just plummeted.

I really don't know how to talk to her. She is just certain she is done with me and doesn't want me.

I feel I may be addicted to video gaming in terms of managing my time and lifestyle. So having told her this belief(which she reinforces by saying I spent all my time on my computer), I made an effort to show her my desire to change for the better.

So went over to her place. I came up to "her" apartment door to talk to her and she was crying on the phone talking to her friend. I tried to give her my video card to smash as a token and a letter to read but she just wouldn't do it. As much as I wanted her to get something from it, I think she didn't want to do it because it would be a "commitment" towards me. Something to repair this. She yelled at me and told me that if I wanted to deal with my "addiction" I should do it myself and not put the responsibility on her. And that I should grow a pair and do it myself.

She is just utterly angry. And thinks I want her to do everything for me. Hell, she even went so far to say that she has to get a divorce because I won't do it.


Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/21/09 04:18 AM
I am glad I exposed to her father and mother and the OM's mother.
I wish I had just gone balls out and told both her brothers too. I was just so broken and her mother begging me not to keep going just stopped my rush.

Oh yea, she just found out that her parents know and told me that drained all the last bits of love she had for me.

But...then as we're leaving a divorce discussion which I failed to avoid she told me she just wants to be friends, maybe not right away. I seem to walk into them all and just start talking it with her. I'm so eager to please her it's sad. Anyway, Mark told me on the phone "babble" and I was like...damn it!

We'll see. It's scary because my wife is someone who tends to do what she say's she will.

Some are saying I should file first for advantage. The first to strike the blow tends to be the last one standing they say.





Drop the games. Don't talk about it. And yeah, the games is an addiction which can be neglect of her from your part. Fix your marriage - quietly.

However she does need to learn to communicate her problems. And you do need to listen.

Why do you want to listen to her mother about stopping the spread of news. What qualification does she have? Do what you got to do?

Listen, you never talk to her about divorce - ever. You talk about rebuilding your marriage. Divorce is managed by your lawyer.
Your addiction to video games has been obvious since your first posts. I believe Dr. Harley says it is impossible to treat the affair until the addiction is addressed first. In this case, the addiction is yours. When your WW was yelling at you through the door, what she said was pretty true. Your addiction is your problem to deal with. There is no way to recover your M until you face this addiction.
Your trying to hand her the card is like the crack addict telling her to flush the bag down the toilet. She knows you can get more. How many alcoholics have sworn "this" was their last drink? I think you have two different dynamics at work here and you are only focused on one. I suspect the addiction did play a large part in the A. When you went on vacation with Ww, even when you weren't playing games, you were reading books about games. If the A hadn't come along, you would still be happily playing games (and probably still do to console yourself and help ease the pain).

Whether you have any hope of saving this M or, failing that, having a successful M in the future, all hinges on your dealing with your addiction.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/21/09 12:32 PM
I just moved into my new apartment and unpacked a lot of stuff yesterday. And felt calm...but desperate. This place could be where I end up alone.

The first time I've played just to console myself was actually last night, but again with friends and they suggested it first. After she first said she didn't love me I wiped every game off my computer except World of Warcraft. I didn't because at the time it just got billed(reoccurring.). And I've only logged five hours a week. That is 1/4 to 1/6th the time I'd log average in the past. I think it should be next on the chopping block. My WW told me that I shouldn't remove all of my gaming. That going cold turkey would be bad and that gaming is a part of me. I wonder if she said that for ulterior reasons?

I think it’s my last step. Destroying a video card is stupid and costs money, but discarding my games isn’t. And… In the back of my mind I just recalled thinking,” I can always use this destruction as an opportunity to upgrade.” Grabbing another bottle at the store after smashing the previous one on the WW’s doorstep to prove myself? Yup.

Damn… I was just thinking about how often I previously thought about gaming… Endlessly. Also looked up game addiction. It described me somewhat. I was often aloof because I was more interested in thinking about gaming. And now I can’t stop thinking about my WW and how much I want her back in my life. It hurts me that she tells me that it’s too late. That we’re done. I’m just scared to see divorce papers by next week. Especially for all I’ve worked to change.



20 to 30 hours per week is more free time than I have (take away work and sleep). Obviously you didn't have much extra to devote to WW. And she noticed. And when you weren't actually playing, you were reading about it or building computers to enable it or thinking and dreaming about it. Dr. Harley recommends 15.5 hrs/wk with the spouse. You ain't got it to give.

You need some serious counseling. You cannot have an addiction like this and expect to have a family. I suspect you are done for the moment. But how can you grow and learn from this?
I have heard that WoW is highly addictive as well. Interesting you couldn't let yourself wipe that one too. Just in case you need a late night fix you'll be all hooked up.

When WW said you were having an A with your computer, she was right. So you left the M long before she did.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/21/09 01:51 PM
Ouch... Piojitos.

Here I was learning to put the blaim on her and to stop blaiming myself and then that.

I did leave the marriage long before this affair. That's why she say's all five years of our relationship. Except... Every time I talked to her about gaming too much and reducing it she discouraged me. She said don't quite gaming... She never suggested I reduce how much I play or anything.

Just like now. I said I'm quiting and she again discouraged me from quiting.
If you learn about the dynamics of relationships and addiction, you'll find that she's an enabler for a reason - and she will carry that problem into her next relationship.

You have an opportunity to deal with your intimacy issues (addiction is typically a way to avoid having a real close relationship). Figure out who you are - independent of WoW (btw, I've personally seen that game destroy a young man all of 18 yrs old - ruin his opportunities for education and relationships and shamed him to his family - Asian boy - so ultimate dishonor there).

Find out who you really want to be as a man, as a husband, as a father, as a brother.... And then learn what it takes to be that person.

Conflict avoidance is a hallmark of what I've read on your thread - and you've placed responsibility for your addiction recovery on another addict and intimacy avoider.

Step into a conflict where you don't know the outcome - take a risk and do the right thing instead of trying to figure out the most painless way to yank the bandaid off.

It's gonna hurt, right? You can't stop that. You're going to hurt regardless of what happens. So get WoW off the machine now. Clean up. get a sponsor (not your wife) to hold you accountable to use the 20 to 30 hours you've normally spent gaming to do some good and make a difference!

Or get a second job and pay down some debt, build up some savings. But make that time productive!
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/21/09 02:32 PM
MMO(Massively-Multiplayer-Online) Gaming is addictive. Safe, achievement based rewards, with no real threat from failure.

Pretty addictive compaired to the damage failure causes in real life.

It's empty though. Utterly devoid of value other than entertainnment.

So, I moved out and took a Futon for my bed...and was thinking of going back and getting MY bed from before our wedding and putting that in my house. The reason is that she will only have a couch to sleep on at this point. And she'll be pissed.

Although I'm afraid of poking a tiger ready to divorce me. She said I had no balls. Well...when she wonders where the bed is I can reply,"I'm making OUR new home as wonderful as possible. If you would like the bed you can join me here in OUR new residence.

Wouldn't making my NEW home better for her be reason? And a way to show her some impact from her actions?

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/21/09 02:40 PM
How do I address her enabling?

I'm uncertain why she would enable me?
Her enabling is none of your business - just don't set her up to have to enable you anymore. You don't try to educate a wayward - rule#1 of recovery.

As far as the bed goes, do the right thing - not to poke a bees nest or something. You don't go picking fights. But you don't avoid conflict. If the bed was yours before the marriage and the OM hasn't been in it, then I'd go get it. But that's me.

Pick up a copy of the "big book" for Alcoholics Anonymous - replace the word "alcohol" with "gaming" and you'll get started on your recovery.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/21/09 03:04 PM
The OM was in it...but it's my damn bed. And I've had sex with her in it 99% of our marriage. The sentimental value far exceeds the burn.

I'm actually bothered by the possibility of MORE sex in my bed later on.

This(?) KaylayAndy: http://www.aa.org/bigbookonline/en_tableofcnt.cfm
Monc,

You can game in a healthy way. I use to do it much more than I do now. I don't go so far as to call it an addiction. It's a hobby that can be overdone as much as any hobby out there.

But you do have to have a conscious thought to the time you spend on it versus being with your wife. i was lucky and married a woman who enjoyed playing games with me. She and I use to play together and had good times doing so.

I also played whenever she was out running errands or shopping or sleeping.

I limited it to those times when she wasn't around and tried to play less when she was around.

I'm divorced and single now and play on my computer more than anything, but I have a girlfriend and am able to put the games away to spend time with her and I have a real balance in my life.

You have your work cutout for you because you're now living apart.

I hate to tell you, but there is zero reason for her to interact with you in any way. You have no children together. So there is nothing which encourages her to interact with you at all and no "family" to restore.

Monc, seriously, this is over. Time to act like it's over. Could it turn around before all your feelings for her are gone? Possibly, but not likely. She's doing another man and isn't living with you.

Finally, the bed thing is a pride thing. If she brought another man into it then it needs to be thrown out. I don't care how much sex you had with her in it.

It's like spending many hours preparing an awesome meal. Once it drops on the floor it's done. You don't pick it up to eat it because it's dirty now. Same with your marital bed. I couldn't lay in it knowing another man has been in there. It was a sacred place that she desecrated.

So start over and let this cheater go. It's over and you need to accept that. There is NOTHING to entice her to return.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/21/09 05:00 PM
Yea, actually I recall not being able to sleep in it because of that fact. I had gone to the couch but being distant from her overpowered that and I slept next to her anyway.

I think it would be the same feeling now only she wouldn't be present to overpower the sickening pain.

Baron, as I've been told. It's not over until it's over. I'm fighting as I've been fighting.

I'm not done until the Marriage License is no longer worth the ink that's written on it.
If you do get the bed back, which is not worth it in my opinion, just take and burn it.

The blessing in all this is you get to get away from that nasty selfish lying cheater BEFORE bringing children into her mess.

YAY! Be happy you are getting out of a lifetime of heartache. Now you have a chance at a good life, once you get over the destruction and bad feelings she has wrought upon you.
Originally Posted by Monc
I'm not done until the Marriage License is no longer worth the ink that's written on it.

Well, that happened the "SECOND" she slept with the OM.

Baron is giving it to you STRAIGHT ... whether you have the maturity to recognize "good" advice is yet to be determined.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/21/09 06:13 PM
It is sad that I am the one fighting hardest for us...when she claims to have been fighting the previous months between August and December... Such molarchy.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/21/09 06:16 PM
Seriously, I heard his advice. It is good advice. It prepairs me for the inevitable truth. Simply that I choose to have hope does not mean I'm foolish or lacking maturity.

Saying that it happened the second she slept with the OM would say that I should have divorced her on the spot instead of trying.

Which did you want of me? To try and have a backbone or be a whimp and give in to please my WW so she can have her affair easily and without conflict?
Originally Posted by Monc
MMO(Massively-Multiplayer-Online) Gaming is addictive. Safe, achievement based rewards, with no real threat from failure.

Pretty addictive compaired to the damage failure causes in real life.

It's empty though. Utterly devoid of value other than entertainnment.

So, I moved out and took a Futon for my bed...and was thinking of going back and getting MY bed from before our wedding and putting that in my house. The reason is that she will only have a couch to sleep on at this point. And she'll be pissed.

Although I'm afraid of poking a tiger ready to divorce me. She said I had no balls. Well...when she wonders where the bed is I can reply,"I'm making OUR new home as wonderful as possible. If you would like the bed you can join me here in OUR new residence.

Wouldn't making my NEW home better for her be reason? And a way to show her some impact from her actions?
I would most definitely do this! Anything you can do to keep showing her that it is her mistakes that are causing all the trouble, not you!

And the more you stand up to her, the more likely she is to want you.
Originally Posted by Monc
Saying that it happened the second she slept with the OM would say that I should have divorced her on the spot instead of trying.

Look ... you can twist mine (and others) words to justify whatever you wish ... I'm not going to waste much time on someone who only wants to use this forum to whine and commiserate, while ingoring the collective WISDOM of those who have MUCH more experience than you.

You have chosen to INGORE certain facts, but they are the FACTS nonetheless.

It takes TWO to get married, but only ONE to split up ... its not fair, and it sucks to be on your side of it ... but those are the FACTS.

Another FACT ... the SECOND she slept with the OM, she UNILATERALLY, BY HERSELF ... ended the M you had before. Your marriage license, vows, commitments, etc. became IMMEDIATELY WORTHLESS.

Now you can recover a M, "IF" BOTH parties are willing, but here's that FACT from above coming back to bite you ... she can end this M all on her own, and in effect, SHE HAS!!!

Now you can "man up" and move on with your life, or you can continue to humiliate yourself by hanging around as her doormat ... YOU MAKE THE CALL!!!
Monc,

Your feelings are normal and understandable. You just haven't had the life experiences to understand.

You need to treat her as if it's over, regardless of whether or not you're going to save it. You see, if you had kids I'd be advising you to go after her with every single legal weapon in the book and to prepare yourself for court to keep the kids from a cheating woman. But you don't have that, so all you have is your love for her, which I know is very real, and the hope that she regains her love for you.

She won't. Not with you guys living apart and not without any sort of incentive or her to return.

She has ZERO incentive to return. No kids to coordinate things over. No kids to lose in a custody fight, which does happen to women from time to time.

The second you start to behave as if you don't care if she returns or not is when she'll notice your behavior change.

But seriously, she's not worth a damn. In all seriousness.
There are tons of great women out there and not a single one of them, NOT ONE, is worth putting up with this kind of thing for.

I admit I don't know this whole story but I, funny enough, don't like to criticize this WW with such harsh words. She suffered (and allowed/enabled) years of emotional abuse.

For Monc's part, she is the perfect woman because she not only allowed his addiction - she encouraged it. So for Monc to give this up, he has to face the grim reality that another woman may not be so enabling. IMHO, Monc is not so afraid of giving up WW as he is afraid of the life-change he may have to face.

His WW was abused. If he physically beat her would you be so harsh toward her?

Now why was she so enabling? That makes me curious.
Posted By: SIHW Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/22/09 02:11 AM
Ok guys...lets remember the title of this site is marriage builders....not divorce builders....

Ok so monc is young....ok his wife is definatly on the short list designated for hell right now, yes his situation is BAD.

YES he could move on and find some thing better...there is life after divorce....I know many people who are living proof of this.

But I do give him credit for at least doing some exposure and making some waves in the affair....they may not have been the tsunami he really needed and would have gotten with full exposure but he did more than I have seen some people do coming to this site looking for no more than sympathy.

Some people before they will admit failure need to work a problem from every angle first to know it won't work.

I believe monc is one of these people. The fact he is still holding on to hope and giving this a go he is not ready to give up.

All advice is welcome....but lets do what this site is desinged for. Help monc with poistive guidance. He's not perfect none of us have/were during our processes.

Monc I am risking my own neck here...I expect you to follow the poistive advice givin to you here from now on. The goal is to build...right now you are building a road back home to your marriage for WW. Follow the advice and experience given to you by the vets.....also I think you should consult with Dr. Harley. He will give you the best advice of all.
My positive advice is to get Monc to treat his addiction. That has to be his first priority. He'll never save/have any marriage without treating this problem. Even Dr. Harley says that.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/22/09 04:03 AM
In terms of spending time with her. I can say, that I failed to do so 15 hours a week for the last six months because I was on Midnight shifts and doing 3 classes. The time she cheated was June when I was JUST building the computer she let me build.

She felt unwanted because of that but didn't say ***edit*** to me.

Not a word. Just typed in her online diary how sad she is in her "cave" all alone. And it was a private entry to boot. I couldn't see it without going one extra step in her diary account.

She has failed utterly to communicate with me folks. She won't even communicate now.
Guys,

This woman wasn't "abused" as you imply. He plays games. So did I. So do many men. Unless it's an round the clock thing, it's normal. Playing WoW doesn't make you an addict.

It's also an excuse by the WW.

And this website isn't a "save marriage at any cost" type of site.

We can blow sunshine up Monc's a$$ all night about how there's hope if he follows the plans, etc, when the reality is that his wife is lost. She's gone. Done. Nothing to bring her back.

There's other forms of advice other than, "Yes, hold out hope that this cheating woman you have no kids with will come to her senses and return."

Sorry. I don't see the point of forgiving a cheater when there are no kids. There's nothing to save.

Better to get a clean slate with someone else, especially when you're young.

If Monc get her back I'd bet my next 3 paychecks that he'll be back here seeking advice in a few years after they've had a few kids and she's freaked out about the responsibilities of parenthood.

You're right, this isn't a divorce sight. But there's no need to pee on his leg and tell him it's raining.

Coho and Zen are here and both committed to trying to save their marriages. That's one worth working on BECAUSE the WW is open to R and working on what led her down this path.

Monc's wife isn't.

The hard lesson I've learned in life is that women (and men) are replaceable.

The bullshyte factor is very low when you've been around the block a bit and there TONS of fish in the sea.
Originally Posted by baron
I don't see the point of forgiving a cheater when there are no kids. There's nothing to save.

Whoa Baron...Though I agree that it's less likely for this WW to return due to the no children factor, it is not impossible...And I do NOT agree with you that there is "no point in forgiving a cheater when there are no kids"...What if the WW did return? No point to forgiveness? I just don't buy it...I didn't "get it" and repent just because Mr. W and I have a daughter...

On another note, I agree that Monc has an addiction to gaming that must be dealt with, but that is no excuse for his wife to have an affair...The gaming issue is the part of the "state of the marriage" that Monc is responsible for...He is not responsible in any way for his wife having an affair though...

Originally Posted by baron
Coho and Zen are here and both committed to trying to save their marriages. That's one worth working on BECAUSE the WW is open to R and working on what led her down this path.

This is a threadjack, but I just HAVE to say it...You are willing to support an AFFAIRAGE over a legitimate marriage? You've GOT to be kidding me...It is blowing my mind to watch you do that here in this venue...Do you realize how utterly ticked and even destroyed you would be if that was YOUR exWW and her OM here trying to save their affair? Mr. W and I both feel sure that you haven't thought that one all the way through...

Mrs. W

Quote
This is a threadjack, but I just HAVE to say it...You are willing to support an AFFAIRAGE over a legitimate marriage? You've GOT to be kidding me...It is blowing my mind to watch you do that here in this venue...Do you realize how utterly ticked and even destroyed you would be if that was YOUR exWW and her OM here trying to save their affair? Mr. W and I both feel sure that you haven't thought that one all the way through...

YUP good to know.
Originally Posted by piojitos
My positive advice is to get Monc to treat his addiction. That has to be his first priority. He'll never save/have any marriage without treating this problem. Even Dr. Harley says that.

Nevertheless it's no excuse for an affair Pio
I don't remember saying it was an excuse for her to have an affair. Find that and highlight it for me because I've not found it yet.

All I am saying is that the addiction is a serious issue and I don't see how WW is going to want to come back to this marriage and keep the status quo.

Monc is going to have to seriously change his behavior in order to be able to maintain any type of LTR. Most women don't want to be ignored for hours or days on end. Or maybe Monc could find a woman who is also addicted to gaming and they could share the hobby. How healthy is that though?
Well, I see the "marriage at all costs" group is rallying its troops.

OK, I'll play along ... considering their youth, no kids, and the dysfunctionality on BOTH sides of this cluster ... just what are the reasons that make anyone think there is a snowballs chance of this becoming a healthy M?

Personally, I think the best possible outcome would be for both of them to D, learn from their mistakes and then start over fresh with new partners, without all of the baggage that will haunt this M forever more. But that's me ... and I'm open to other perspectives.

Also, I have some history to draw from ... I originally married way too young with a mismatched partner and grew apart as we matured to the point where we couldn't stand to be around each other. Not only does this happen ... in these cases, it should be EXPECTED, and from my understanding THIS IS MB philosophy straight form Dr. Harley ... young, short M, no kids, infidelity ... Plan D, learn and start over.
Posted By: SIHW Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/22/09 04:32 PM
Originally Posted by baron_richtofen
And this website isn't a "save marriage at any cost" type of site.

There's other forms of advice other than, "Yes, hold out hope that this cheating woman you have no kids with will come to her senses and return."


This was not my point....I did not tell him to "save the marriage at all cost"....I said Monc is at a place where HE still has hope....until he knows that he has tried everything and no angle or road will work....he won't be able to give up.
It is something HE needs to work out before he has a sense of finality....this is why I suggested he consult Dr. Harley...a trained professional who could advise him better than us....most people listen to trained profesionals than regular people.


Quote
Sorry. I don't see the point of forgiving a cheater when there are no kids. There's nothing to save.

Coho and Zen are here and both committed to trying to save their marriages. That's one worth working on BECAUSE the WW is open to R and working on what led her down this path.

Monc's wife isn't.

SURE because all WS's want to save there marriage....I mean come on....This case is no different than most others.....and it's not the worst I have seen...I seen ones way worse on this site.

Truth is....this site has changed from the old days....Plan B here sometimes is jumped to way too early in some cases....if you go back and read the older threads you will notice...Plan B was reserved for EXTREME cases. There were also a higher number of recoveries than I see now. Now it seems Eh your young Just give up on the effort you have made and vows you made. So what if you love that person and still feel hope just give up. How exactly does that help this persons healing process. Weather the marriage survives or not a grieving process must be gone through...following things through is part of that.

I am not speaking for myself but also for other memebers who have noticed this....But no one wants to speak up because the angry mob with shovels, picks, and torches seems to arrive at anyone speaking there mind. I really could care less if people do not like what I am saying...but someone had to say it....and many members here know I am not one to keep my mouth shut and be bullied.

I think we all could learn something by going back and reading the threads of the older members like Orchid and lost in VA just to name a few. You might be surprised at the differance in today.
Quote
Also, I have some history to draw from ... I originally married way too young with a mismatched partner and grew apart as we matured to the point where we couldn't stand to be around each other. Not only does this happen ... in these cases, it should be EXPECTED, and from my understanding THIS IS MB philosophy straight form Dr. Harley ... young, short M, no kids, infidelity ... Plan D, learn and start over.

What exactly should be expected?

If you and your first wife "grew apart" MyRev it was not because you married too young but because you failed to build a mutually compatible marriage which is the aim of Marriage Builder's tools to build and maintain romantic love. Next thing you will be telling me you believe in soulmates.

In any case, you are right that Dr Harley pretty much says if you are not long married with no kids then you should divorce however he also says he doesn't really understand people wanting to recover their marriages after infidelity but that they invariably DO want to recover.
I agree Pio RE the addiction and what you say however his first priority has to be ending the affair.
you've gotta know when to hold em and know when to fold em...
At least, according to the great Johnny Cash.
Quote
At least, according to the great Johnny Cash
Uh...

I think that would be Kenny Rogers...

Cash recorded Bull Rider:

Quote
Well first you gotta want to get off,
Bad enough to want to get on in the first place

Mark
Mark - it's an "in" joke between Pio and I - he's just messing with my head - or rather he was TRYING to mess with my head.
Mrs. W,

Sorry, but I don't see any reason to even bother saving a marriage when there are no kids and the marriage is so young and the parties are young.

I also know that Zen and Coho are an affairage, yet, as Dr. Hareley himeself has said, it is a marriage that even he tries to save.

My exww doesn't have an OM. I never gave her the chance to have one since I agreed to a D so quickly.

Her bf did come along a few months later and they started dating and any and all hopes of saving our M ended there.

I think it's great you and Mr. W saved your marriage. I just fall on the other end of the spectrum after years on this board and my own life experiences.

I just don't see anyone as being worth my tears and time ESPECIALLY if there are no kids.

There's just no family to save, IMHO.

Monc is very young at 26. His WW has many many maturity issues.

I've been single for 3 years and have seen how awesome the women out there are and how I could do leagues better than what I settled for in my marriage.

Having seen that and experienced it I've realized that no person is worth the massive hassle of overcoming infidelity.

The only time I'd even consider it with anyone in the future is if there was a child in the equation AND she was a very very remorseful WW right off the bat.

Otherwise I'd kick her to the curb, but not after gathering massive evidence and lawyering up and not repeating the mistakes I made this go around.

My ultimate goal is to meet a woman who is willing to follow MB.

I've been on these boards for many years now and I've seen men like Monc hang on to a cheating wife for long periods of time, wasting their lives away in the hopes that the WW "wakes up".

I just don't see an unrepentant WW as worth a lick.

Originally Posted by baron_richtofen
I just don't see an unrepentant WW as worth a lick.

That's setting the bar pretty high. I bet many, if not most, recovered marriages began with an unrepentant WW. I think recovery statistics would be far lower it we went by your standard.
Originally Posted by baron_richtofen
Sorry, but I don't see any reason to even bother saving a marriage when there are no kids and the marriage is so young and the parties are young.

I also know that Zen and Coho are an affairage, yet, as Dr. Hareley himeself has said, it is a marriage that even he tries to save.

These sentences are kind of inconsistent. If Monc were to call Dr. Harley (or Steve and Jennifer) they would gladly help him too (and his chances of success are 100 times better than Zen and Coho since the good doctor is clear that he's had close to no success with counseling affairages whereas he's helped and saved countless kid-less marriages). If you'll help Zen and Coho because "Dr. Harley himself" would try...why wouldn't you apply the same standard to Monc's situation even though the odds are long as well?


Originally Posted by baron_richtofen
My exww doesn't have an OM. I never gave her the chance to have one since I agreed to a D so quickly.

The point is that IF your wife ran off with an OM and married him...you can be sure that Mrs. W and I wouldn't have helped you AND then helped them save thei affairage on MB. The point expands out to the many other people we have helped (or tried to help) on these boards, some still here and some now gone, that still struggle with ex-ws's married to their OP's, that are long awaiting the karma bus to come around full circle and smack their former WS's. Whether it's healthy to wish for that or not...many divorced betrayed's that visit these boards WANT the affair to end...WANT remorse...WANT an apology and, perhaps, mostly WANT their x's spouse (the OP) FAR and AWAY from their kids. If Zen or Coho were my neighbors IRL...I wouldn't hesitate to assist them as much as I could (though even the professional finds helping affairages fleeting, at best)...but I'd do so IN PRIVATE. I'd NEVER invite them here for help and betray those legitimate marriages that I tried to promote and protect with my years invested here. Just as I'd never send a rapist to a public recovery program for rape victims.

Originally Posted by baron_richtofen
I think it's great you and Mr. W saved your marriage. I just fall on the other end of the spectrum after years on this board and my own life experiences.

I just don't see anyone as being worth my tears and time ESPECIALLY if there are no kids.

There's just no family to save, IMHO.

My wife was worth it. Kid or not. I said so in the beginning and mean it to this day. I did not fight, nor save my marriage FOR my daughter. I did what I did for US/her. I am not a "save all marriages" guy/poster either (we've got to have a name for the "end all marriages crew"...maybe DAC's or Divorce at All Costs"...lol). Rather, I respect the process. Monc is processing. I don't think it's unhealthy for him to try to save his marriage. He's not damaging himself or his worth but undertaking a noble effort...even if it's likely a matyr's mission. If it works...great. If not...he'll come around to divorcing and doing what's likely/maybe best for him and moving on. He'll regret, like some of you guys seemingly do, the time he wasted TRYING...but there's really no sense crying over spilt milk. In the grand scheme it's not that much time "wasted". The end result is the same and you guys are better and stronger because of it. The process seasoned you. However, I think those that want to try and don't will likely have bigger regrets wondering "what if". Anyone with THAT regret can never get over it. They can never go back and get a do-over so instead they will spend years trying to convince themselves (and others) that booting their WS to the curb was the best decision they ever made. However late at night while they lay in bed alone (or with their current temporary conquest) they so often have to question whether they really handled their life properly. When you take shortcuts in life you'll never what opportunities you missed if you'd have just stayed on the highway. I don't know...it's all so convoluted...but I do know that each person has to figure this out on their own in their own time.

Originally Posted by baron_richtofen
Having seen that and experienced it I've realized that no person is worth the massive hassle of overcoming infidelity.

The only time I'd even consider it with anyone in the future is if there was a child in the equation AND she was a very very remorseful WW right off the bat.

My wifes remorse & repentence took months. She was still worth it. Monc's wife MAY be worth it to him. Please note...I'm not telling you NOT to post your opinion or that your opinion has no merit...rather I am attempting to balance your opinion out with another experience. IMO...I think we should let Monc figure this out and support him along the way with the techniques for "trying" provided by this website. We can also be there for him as emotional support if and when such attempts fail (as we were for you).

Mr. Wondering
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/23/09 06:16 AM
Well... I got her to make an appointment with Dr. Harley.

I had to trade my new home address so she can serve me papers for divorce. My address for an appointment.

She bit. So...hopefully it helps some how. If she had no intentions of trying remotely, why on earth would she make the appointment? As my letter to her was about having never sought real help in our marriage.

I'm actually confused a great deal because she still talks to me with a hard angry edge.

Anger means she is still emotionally invested in the relationship (whether for good or for bad). The opposite of love is indifference - not hate.
The opposite of Love is not indifference - it is Hate.

Think of indifference as a neutral point between the 2.

Opposite of positive feelings are negative feelings.
That logic works on Bohr's model of the atom and also in general electricity. How many peopl, after a few years, truly hate their ex-spouse? Most simply no longer care. Hate is part of the rationalization process to fall out of love. It is a systemic and systematic process of removing love.
I agree most no longer care. However the opposite of good or bad feelings is still bad or good feelings - neither of which is desirable - so the middle position indifference is what to strive for.
So then, by your logic, you're saying Monc's marriage is done and dusted?
Not at all Pio.
Originally Posted by Monc
Well... I got her to make an appointment with Dr. Harley.

I had to trade my new home address so she can serve me papers for divorce. My address for an appointment.

She bit. So...hopefully it helps some how. If she had no intentions of trying remotely, why on earth would she make the appointment? As my letter to her was about having never sought real help in our marriage.

I'm actually confused a great deal because she still talks to me with a hard angry edge.

What precludes her from canceling this appointment? You don't have many bargaining chips left.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/23/09 10:20 AM
I've not given her the address yet.

I don't know...I just hope she'll keep it?
Quote
Also, I have some history to draw from ... I originally married way too young with a mismatched partner and grew apart as we matured to the point where we couldn't stand to be around each other. Not only does this happen ... in these cases, it should be EXPECTED, and from my understanding THIS IS MB philosophy straight form Dr. Harley ... young, short M, no kids, infidelity ... Plan D, learn and start over.
This is something I say often. IMO, most people - in America's society anyway - have no business marrying before they are at least 25. They are not done changing yet. What they THINK they want at 21 will be vastly different from what they finally realize they want at 30. Best to not drag kids into such a relationship that, if not doomed to fail, is at least doomed to be not so great - and produce not so great kids.
Quote
This is something I say often. IMO, most people - in America's society anyway - have no business marrying before they are at least 25. They are not done changing yet. What they THINK they want at 21 will be vastly different from what they finally realize they want at 30. Best to not drag kids into such a relationship that, if not doomed to fail, is at least doomed to be not so great - and produce not so great kids.


Wow, I'm glad I didn't read something like this when I was newly married at 19. Our "doomed to fail" marriage produced four great kids who turned out to be wonderful adults.

I disagree that it's an age thing. Look how many people married very young way back when and STAYED married for years and years.
Age only applies to any of this because at middle 20s a person who is considering the hassle of trying to save and rebuild a marriage has time to start over with his/her life. Age has nothing to do with success of a marriage.

Growing up is not what causes marriages to fail but failing to grow up. Grown up people accept responsibility for the choices they have made.

It wasn't until the 20th century that people waited to get married until they were older than about 16. Men were typically in the military at about age 14 and had served their time by 17 or 18, assuming they survived till then. By 40 many were dead, that left a 20 year period in which to have a family and provided for their continuation once you were gone.

It is a 20th century notion that marriage is for the purpose of fulfillment. It isn't growing up that ends marriages; it's living independently. Marriages don't end because folks were too young when they met, they end because one or both did not provide extraordinary care for their partner. They sought personal fulfillment (they felt entitled) over provision for their spouse.

People fall out of love because they don't build compatibility by meeting each others EN and avoiding love busters. They end up resenting each other because they don't deal with conflict but seek to avoid it. If being older, wiser and knowing more about what to expect from marriage made a difference then second marriages should last longer than first marriages. They don't because the second ones end for the same reasons as the first and age is not what ends marriages.

Marriages end over selfishness, not maturity.

Mark
Can't edit so I'll add it here...

What makes for a stable, fulfilling and happy marriage is adapting to changes. Waiting till you are older does not mean people won't change, it really only means they will be more set in their independent ways and have to adapt even more.

The key to marital success is compatibility. Compatibility is not a condition you simply find yourself in, it is created by hard work. You aren't born compatible, you become compatible by adapting to each other and to changing conditions.

Mark
You will notice I said in America's society. That's because our treadmill is filled with the better car, the better condo, the pool, the private school, the $200 tennis shoes, the $600 video game...

And this is what today's youth is being brought up to honor, thanks to media, 300 channels on tv, and all their accompanying ads.

There was a story on NPR Friday about schools having to bring in athletes to primary schools, to teach kids how to get off their butts and play during recess, rather than just sitting around talking and listening to iPods. The officials said that recess is typically the only time each day that kids today ever get any physical activity any more.

More and more stories about 20-somethings in the workforce who expect to be promoted in a year, running the business in 5. They're so used to having everything handed to them that when reality hits them in the job, they just quit. So companies are having to come up with 'perks' to keep them from leaving, like having monthly 'praise' meetings to stroke their egos.

You seriously think these 20 year olds are ready to understand and commit to a marriage, babies, and sacrifice?

Most people posting here are at least in their 30s, if not 40s to 60s. Totally different mindset.
Originally Posted by catperson
And this is what today's youth is being brought up to honor, thanks to media, 300 channels on tv, and all their accompanying ads.


Not ALL of today's youth are being brought up like this. I personally know of a whole group of 19-20 somethings that have no such mindset. I do agree however, that they are probably the exception. These kids have been brought up right. They DON'T honor "things". They value relationships, their parents, others.

Media is not totally to blame. There is an "off" button on these things that parents are free to use. LOL

When I was at the juvenile detention center for my nephew's hearing, there were two mothers there discussing what they were going to do when their daughters were released.

Mom1: "Well, the Judge said the monitor her cell phone and Internet use. But I just can't do that to her. She would feel like she was living in a prison!"

Mom2: "Oh, I know what you mean. What do we do to make sure that they're not abusing their privileges? I can't be there 24/7! I have a life!"

Me: I have a suggestion.

Mom1: Yes?

Me: That computer? Unplug it and move it out of her room. The cell phone? Turn it off.

Mom1: Whaaattt??? She would be so angry with me....

Me: And you care because?..... You're her mom, not her buddy. Hello?? If you want the same things happening over and over again then just keep doing the same things you've been doing.

They just looked at me like I had two heads.

Daughter to Mom1 was released. Mom hands her her cell phone. Daughter is on the phone, laughing and giggling before they get out the door.

Mr.W, you're in a small small group on these boards who have actually saved their marriage and had an eventually repentant WW.

Would I have taken back my exww? If she had acted in time, yes. But those feelings are now totally gone and have been replaced with the realization that no woman, no matter how attractive, smart, etc, NONE, is worth the pain of recovery when there are no children involved. There are plenty of very awesome, attractive, smart, and moral women out there to replace her with.

Children in the equation changes things a bit. Now there is a family to fight for and save and the temporary insanity of one of the partners is worth trying to forgive and attempt the recovery.

But, as the thread I started before stated, what is the cost of having a WW return? It's years of suspicion, pain, rebuilding, and then what? Short of a massive change on her part, there is always that lingering doubt of, "will she do it again?"

Perhaps that is not a concern for you anymore, and that's great. But you see someone like Krazy and the idea of his wife with another man is simply one he can't get past.

If Zen and Coho didn't have 4 chidlren I'd be telling Zen to run in the other direction, apologize to the former BH, and count his blessings that there are no kids.

But, regardless of whether or not Zen and Coho are an affairage, they have 4 innocent victims of their original sin. So it would be great, for their children, if they can save their affairage.

That's not an endorsement of affairages. It's an endorsement of preserving a family for children or at least making the attempt.

Your WW had the capacity to learn. There's a chance both Zen and Coho could learn as well and straighten out. The fact that their marriage was born out of a heinous act doesn't mean that they can't change as individuals and see the light.

I don't buy into the MB poster's philosophy that affairages are something to seek pleasure in their destruction and dissolution.

Am I happy when affairages crash and burn? You bet. First one to laugh at the Karma bus. But I do feel for any kids caught in the drama. So my goal is that there is stability for the children and the hopes that the new affairage doesn't produce more innocent victims in the form of new children.

Zen and Coho have four such innocent victims. The only victim in Monc's case is Monc. It's tragic and it sucks, but Monc has the ability to say, "I deserve better and she's not worth my tears."

She's not. No woman is.

No cheating man is.

There's too many available and single wonderful women for him to get stuck on this cheater he married.

If she came back tomorrow and was remorseful and committed to changing and had the will to make it happen then that's a different story. But she shows no signs of this and I've seen men like Monc wait for years for the WW to return.

It's my opinion that doing so is a waste of youth and time.

Too many better women out there than to get hung up on this one.

But I will agree with you that it is a process. There would be something wrong with Monc if this was easy for him and he had no feelings over the loss of his wife.

But his wife is dead. The WW is what's left and a WW isn't worth a darn. Not worth a breath. Not worth a tear. Not worth a thought.

The second any woman ever sets foot in wayward territory with me is the second I will be emotionally dead to her. Will be tossed away like a dirty kleenex. It's a lesson I've learned through hard experience.

My challenge is to make sure I meet her EN's so she's not wayward at all. That's where my responsibility comes in.

But for Monc to be hung up on her is just not worth his youth or his time.

But he'll eventually realize this on his own.
One thing to consider in all of this is that when Monc first got here the advice he first received was to let his WW go and move on. He decided that to him his wife IS worth the fight and so that is where the advice has headed since those initial posts.

But as to whether or not his wife is worth fighting for and is really worth the effort is HIS decision to make. Once that decision has been made those wishing to help him can and should focus their attention on that goal. If he had decided to end the marriage and move on with life, then it would be pointless to continue to instruct him in the finer points of Plan A, since Plan A is designed to save a marriage from an active affair.

And that is what gets missed in the discussion of whether or not to use Plan A on an active cheater. Plan A is ONLTY for an active cheater. If the affair ends and the WS is instantly repentant, then there is no need for a Plan A, since recovery can begin and Plan A has NOTHING to do with recovery. Plan A is only for those who have decided to fight for their marriage in spite of an ongoing affair.

You are right, Baron, in saying that few marriages have recovered from an affair when the WS will not end the affair at once. Mr W IS the exception rather than the rule. That is not an indictment of Plan A but rather an indication of how difficult the process really is. It also points to the character of Mr W and his perseverance in the face of nearly overwhelming odds.

But filing for divorce and really just moving on with your life is a valid one and one that probably should be the one made many times if not in most cases; it does not lead to recovery from an affair and does NOT save the marriage. If the goal of the BS is to accomplish those things, then moving on can’t gain what they want.

Plan A doesn’t work most of the time, but because most affairs do in fact end within a couple of years Dr Harley recommends Plan B, which only marginally works at ending the affair and simply allows a healing and reconstruction of life for the BS to wait to see if the WS ever wakes up and desires to reconcile. At that point it is still up to the BS to decide if recovery is even possible. For most at that point I would think that it no longer is much of an option since so much garbage is present it would take years to sort through and recover from.

But Plan A is only for a BS who does not have a repentant WS. There is no need to Plan A a repentant WS. And as much as it would be my choice to just move on with my life if I was under 30, had no children and not much in marital assets, Monc has decided to fight for his marriage and his wife. Though even divorce does not mean the ultimate end of the relationship, just letting the divorce happen and finding someone else is not what he has chosen. He has chosen to fight and until he has exhausted that option he really can’t move on because until he knows that he has done all he can do there will forever be a lingering doubt in his mind as to what else he might have done to save what he feels is of enough value to fight for.

Plan A as it applies to the WS is only for those who do NOT repent at once and for the BS it only applies to those who choose to not just move on. If the WS repents, no Plan A is needed. If the BS decides to move on, no Plan A is needed.

Mark
Quick last TJ: PM, you and I are completely on the same side. That's how I raised my D18. She knows better. She includes us in activities with her friends. Her only rule, lol, is that we're not to go to the mall with her on a Friday night. That's embarrassing, apparently. wink

But we wrestle every day with all the kids she deals with whose parents just aren't interested in working that way with their kids. I see mothers of 1 year olds just turn the tv on and leave the room to go do their own thing. Her former best friend used our house (and our D18) to bring her boyfriend over to do the deed; when D18 called her out on it, she launched a smear campaign to ruin our daughter! One of D18's male gay friends had a nosebleed Saturday night and just left his coke can - WITH his blood-soaked kleenex on top of it - on my coffee table, for me to clean up! Her best friend got shipped off to live in Peru for a year with grandma when her mom had a baby with her new husband, so she wouldn't interfere. The first week of school D18 had a phone AND a camera stolen. The kids were warned not to go near a certain park this weekend, as it was going to be gang initiation, and any girl there would be 'targeted.'

And this is in the upscale school in our district, where the parents are supposed to be the involved ones. The stories from the 'poor' school are even worse.

And it's not about the kids, really - it's about the parents who have let raising their kids go, so they themselves can do what THEY want, leaving these kids to learn their rights and wrongs from society and media.

This kid with the nosebleed - he brought a movie to watch about two young white boys (about 18) who proceed to torture and murder a family, and then go on to the next family; this kid tells us that this movie is amazing! That he 'so gets it' - what these boys are trying to say, and he 'gets' why they don't see anything wrong with killing people if it's what they 'need' to do.

I later told D18 he's not allowed at our house without my permission any more. *sigh*

I'm not saying all kids are like that. I'm saying you're safer assuming they have some aspect of this in them or in their culture. Whether they climb out of it or avoid it altogether really depends on their parents. JMHO
You can't Plan A a woman that doesn't live with you. You can only Plan B her.

Otherwise, all you are is a doormat that she seeks out when she wants EN's met. I've seen it here.

The WW goes on dates with BH. BH gets his hopes up. WW gets her jollies with BH. BH sees signs things could be better.

All the while WW is with OM1, 2, and 3.

BH becomes a doormat.

If you don't want to divorce, then take the interim step of going to Plan B.

Nothing to lose by doing that and the calmness and separation can bring clarity of thought to the BH.

But I ultimately feel the realization will be the same at the end of the day. NO ONE is worth this.

Kids make it worth the effort.

To me a BH hanging on to the idea of a WW returning when there are no kids in the equation is the same as a beggar sitting next to a buffet table waiting for the meal he wants versus the awesome mean he could have if he just opened his eyes.

That buffet table (the awesome women out in the world) beckons but he's stuck waiting for the crappy meal he's had before.

Makes no sense.

But it is a process. All I want is for Monc to not be stuck waiting for this WW for years, like I've seen happen on these boards to several men.

It's a waste of life and youth.
Quote
You can't Plan A a woman that doesn't live with you.
Why is that? It can and has been done. Plan A is harder when a WS leaves, or worse yet, when a BS leaves right after D-day, but it isn't an impossibility. It just has to be done in bits and pieces when ever you get the chance. Trust me when I say that while the affair is going on it is no piece of cake to meet a WS's ENs and avoid love busters even in the same house.

Quote
You can only Plan B her
Shows complete lack of understanding what Plan B is. Plan B is a specific Plan, still focused on saving the marriage. It isn't just ignoring the WS. In order to actually DO Plan B requires establishing in writing the path home for the WS and letting her/him know what it will take for there to be any chance of reconciliation. It requires establishing a method of communication that does not entail directly speaking to the WS and making plans that can include the WS at some time in the future but are not dependent on what the WS eventually does.

Also, Plan B usually only does anything to hasten an end to an affair if a decent Plan A precedes it. Unless the BS has given the WS some reason to come back to the relationship, there isn't any reason to wait any longer and divorce is the most likely outcome.

Will the WS have another affair while in Plan A? Sometimes it happens that way, though not usually. When it does, it means not that Plan A was being a doormat but only that Plan A did not have the desired affect. At that point I would think everybody should go into Plan B. But again, Plan B needs to be planned out in advance so that it can be a help to the BS if nothing else.

A BH only becomes a doormat when Plan A becomes Plan appeasement and nothing is done to try to bring an end to the affair. If the WS jumps from AP1 to AP2 during the time set aside for Plan B it probably means that the marriage is pretty much done anyway since the end of the affair did not result in the WS seeking reconciliation. It can also mean that there was in fact some other reason the WS left other than just the affair. (food for thought for the BS, I'm sure)

Again, Plan A is only for cases where the affair continues and not for any other case. If either the BS or the WS leaves, that is not Plan B but only Plan Conflict Avoidance, which is NOT what Plan A or Plan B is all about.

Plan A is also not a time of working out issues surrounding recovery. That is for recovery, not Plan A. What makes Plan A hard is NOT working on dealing with trying to fix the marriage from the WS's side at all but merely fixing what the BS has under his/her control. That is after all what Plan A is supposed to be about. It gives the WS a reason to stay married to the BS and that is all it is supposed to do.

Your analogy of the buffet table sounds great, except that it does not describe what we're talking about. The decision to end a marriage and jump into a new relationship, or as your analogy suggests, sample all that might be available only becomes viable once the decision is made to end the marriage. Monc has decided that he wants his hamburger most of all and he is willing to wait and fight to get it. The fact that lobster might be there for the taking doesn't matter. Monc has to make the decision to give up on waiting for the burger. To do otherwise is nothing more than doing excactly what his WW is doing. It is going outside the marriage in order to get his ENs met and nothing more.

Once Monc decides to end his marriage, has divorced his wife and healed enough to enter into a new relationship, he can do it with clear conscience. Until that time, he is still married because he wants to be and while it might be easier to divorce her and look for something else, it is still up to him to decide when he is done waiting for his hamburger.

I understand the purpose of Plan B and what it requires. Plan B IS NOT a plan to save the marriage. It's to insulate the BS from the abuse of the WS, provide some peace to the BS, put the full burden of meeting the WS's emotional needs on the AP, and to conserve whatever remaining feelings the BS has for the WS OR (and this is the key part mentioned by SH) prepare the BS for divorce.

I'm not advising Monc to go out and get himself another woman. That will only put a bandaid on the gashing wound he has.

What I'm saying to him is that his life experience so far is one which makes him think his wife is the greatest thing ever. He loves her, obviously, and is grieving her loss.

Once he's done grieving, however, and is available again, he'll look up and see the rich variety available to him and how much he was settling for the chopped liver he's had all these years.

I understand it's a process and it takes time. I've been through it.

But what I've learned for myself after going throught he process is that NOT ONE SINGLE WOMAN is worth the effort and pain when there are no kids in the picture.

NONE.

Not when there are many other great ones to choose from that can provide a clean slate to start with.

And in a way, his very own wife can provide that provided that she changes as a woman into someone else. She has to become a different person in terms of her values, morals, and boundaries.

It's a transformation few WW'es ever make. Some that do do so before their husbands have called it quits and they can save their marriages, such as with Mortarman and Mr. W.

Yes, Monc wants to hang in there right now. I understand that desire. There's still hope in his heart that she will "wake up" and be remorseful.

My experience on these boards is that a WW with no kids has zero reason to interact with her BH. They go and sow their oats while the BH lives with his grief. On rare occasions they wake up, often years after hurting the BH and often after a D, and come back hoping for the BH to take them back.

Check out Lie2Me's thread to see this very thing in action. WW walked out nearly 6 years ago. He's hung in there.

But look at the cost. 6 years waiting for a WW to wake up. She's as messed up as ever, by his postings, and is manipulating him.

He still has residual feelings for her.

I didn't want a divorce. I wanted to save my marriage. Yet divorce came and was upon me and 3 years later I thank God I'm not married to an overgrown child that suffers from hysteriaonics and is a hypercondriac.

I've gone out and dated adult women with grown up ideas and who don't depend on anyone to support them. It's very, very refreshing and an experience that shows me that I ate chopped liver for years. That's something I would have only dealt with for my kids.

Monc doesn't have that. He's young and has his whole life ahead of him.

He can hang in there for a while and when to call it quits is his call. But my experience both on these boards and in life so far tells me that she's not worth it and he can do better.

That's something he'll have to realize on his own.

So we can go on and on about how he can Plan A her while she lives alone and keeps banging another man.

Frankly, I have more respect for him than to advise him to do that when he has absolutely no reason to tolerate that disrespect at all. ZERO.

He can tell me to shut up and not advise him anymore, but the last time I checked he seemed to value my inputs.

Monc, it's your call. You're getting boths sides of things here, but I'm not a "save your marriage at all costs" kind of man.

I've been divorced for 3 years and it sucked at first, but I'm content with my life now and have a great woman in my life. There IS life after divorce. And with no kids there's even more freedom to kick the ex to the curb, never deal with her again in any way, and wish her luck in her life while you carry on with yours.
One other thought which bears repeating since I've heard others share it:

Sometimes we want the wayward back simply to dump them on our terms. A part of me wanted that. It's often a subconscious thought and it's what led me to the thread I started about what happens after a WW returns.

There's a honeymoon period but the reality sinks in after a bit that the woman you wanted back so badly has desecrated your marriage by being with another man.
Is she chopped liver only because she's wayward?? I certainly do not think so as a FWW, I am anything but chopped liver.

Maybe he doesn't think she's chopped liver- and ultimately it's his decision to stay with her or not- chopped liver or not.

B_R,

Been on this site a long time. The statements about the rarity of recovery are not really well founded. Many folks have recovered and they leave. I still have contact with a few, but it has been over 10 years now since I first started reading here.

One can plan A with the spouse elsewhere and sometimes it works. As Marks said and even Harley says, plan A sometimes ends the affair, but most of the time it plants seeds for eventual recovery once the affair ends and most of them do.

Now whether someone wants to recover a marriage or not is clearly their choice and if there are no children involved this boils down to an easier decision because there are only two people involved, not many more.

What is not mentioned here often but is seen and has been seen by Mr. W, MyRev, and many others, is that affairs are traumatic and because they are, they are agents of changes. With patience and time one can determine if that change is going to allow the marriage to continue or end it. But, change happens and not all change is bad, it can even be useful.

People do change and often for the better when there are compelling reasons, they just need time to see the reasons. Doesn't mean every marriage makes it or should, it is just that time and patience coupled with the insights one finds on this sight often do lead to recovered marriages.

God Bless,

JL
Coach,

You earned your "F". You changed and learned from your mistake.

But you ended up ultimately divorced. That was your H's choice and one which came about because of the affair.

You have moved on with your life and he's moved on with his. Is your BH happy with his life now? Are you?

People grow and change. Monc's WW is unwilling to do either.

I personally think that most BHes want the WW back out of a desire to restore things, but the reality is that once the WW returns he's faced with the reality of the betrayal.

Can he forgive her years down the road? Sure.

But I see marital infidelity as an unforgiveable offense when no kids are in the picture. That's Monc's call to make, but my life experience at this point tells me that life is too short and there are too many women in the world to deal with this form of abuse.

And that is exactly what infidelity is. It's emotional abuse of the worst kind. If she smacked him around we'd tell him to bail and find someone who won't do that. But since it's infidelity we don't.

It's abuse nonetheless and he can do better and is young enough to not have to deal with the doubt he'll always have about her in the back of his mind.

She would need to dramatically change into someone she's not for them to have a chance.

She's unrepentant and is going to be lost until she "finds herself".

Finding herself is a process that will take years. You learned from your experience and feel bad for the pain you caused your ex and I commend you for earning that "F". If your BH was still single and you were still single then perhaps you could restore your marriage, but his ship has sailed and he's chosen the path to carry on with his life.

As a WW, you were once "chopped liver". As a FWW, you are filet mignon. But how long did it take you to wisen up about what you did? How long should your BH have waited for you to grow and mature?

Chalk me up in the category of men who will find infidelity unforgivable from here on out. Any future WW (God help me and hope that there isn't) will face a man who is much wiser than he was 3 years ago. I will crush any cheater in the courthouse and give no quarter and offer no forgiveness.

I may feel different years from now, but I see no reason why a young man with no kids should place his life on hold while his WW goes out and "finds herself" and gets scr3w3d by other men while he sits idly by and hopes she wakes up.

He deserves better.

All that said:

Monc, you still around?
Quote
Is she chopped liver only because she's wayward??

I don't think thats what barron said at all. In fact those are your words, not his.

The point as I read it, was that it is the BS' choice to continue in the M after such a abomination or not. And rightfully so. If it goes that route, the WS should learn to live with the fact, that it is just another consequence of their horrible choice to enter into an A in the first place.

There is no insulation from our choices, be they good or bad. We simply have to live with the consequence, like it or not.

All Blessings,
Jerry
Posted By: SIHW Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/24/09 05:37 PM
I think the point is all WS are not repentant in the beginning....it takes time to see if they will come around.....and yes the BS has to do some work on there own....to put those deposits in and see if the WW will come around....

I know in my time of insanity I said some harsh things to my xh....I told him I didn't regret what I did....but after he put for effort into us...and counseling and withdrawl.....I realized how bad I screwed up.

Little did I know BH started a revenge affair. That led to our divorce.

It's not an easy quick process. Maybe with counseling moncs wife would realize how bad she is damaging herself and her family.....it's different for different people.
Originally Posted by baron_richtofen
Coach,

You earned your "F". You changed and learned from your mistake.

But you ended up ultimately divorced. That was your H's choice and one which came about because of the affair.

Actually he wasn't the only one who decided not to recover- it was pretty mutual. I was still foggy although out of the affair and didn't know it.

Quote
You have moved on with your life and he's moved on with his. Is your BH happy with his life now? Are you?

I assume he's happy although I hear from stepmom sometimes different things that give me pause. I myself am extremely happy.





Quote
If your BH was still single and you were still single then perhaps you could restore your marriage, but his ship has sailed and he's chosen the path to carry on with his life.

I have no desire to restore that marriage- as bad as I feel for the things that I did- and I do feel bad that ship sailed a long time ago for me as well.

Quote
As a FWW, you are filet mignon. But how long did it take you to wisen up about what you did? How long should your BH have waited for you to grow and mature?

At least two years. That doesn't mean that it will take that long for anyone else to wise up- I was just particularly stubborn. I never said he should have waited at all for me.


Quote
He deserves better.
I agree but ultimately it's his decision to make.

I have a friend struggling in a similar situation yet I can see why she wants to stay with her H. He hasn't always been a wayward entitled [censored] and she still sees glimpses of what he was before- that is what keeps her hanging on. Perhaps that is what keeps Monc around too?

All that said:

Monc, you still around? [/quote]
Coach,

I understand where your friend is coming from.

The way I see it my wife died 3 years ago and I haven't seen her since. That's how it feels and has felt.

Things were once good with my wife and we were best friends.

But I've never seen that woman in 3 years. The one I've seen since is horrible to deal with and an entitled ex.

Like I told Lie2Me, in my ex's mind all would have been ok if I had simply done as she demanded, gone to live off in my own little place, given her a fat check each month, and seen the kids when it suited her.

She envisioned times when I'd come over, sit down with her new boyfriend, hold hands with them and sing Kumbaya while flower petals fell from the ceiling, the kids danced around us, and little bunnies pranced in the distance while rainbows filled the sky.

She envisioned divorce this way and will forever think that this is what would have happened and how I should have behaved.

She's entitled and that will never change.

Monc's wife is entitled. It has taken years and years for WWes to wake up and mature.

Life is too short and he deserves better than to sit around waiting.

Drowningman is a good example of a poor soul who forever waits for his WW to wakup. It's been years.

There's too much living to be done to be caught up.

You've moved on with your life and have a conscience over your mistakes. I've yet to hear a "I'm sorry for how I hurt you" going on 3 years now.

It's not going to come since she doesn't think she did anything wrong since "she had decided that the marriage was over" while I was deployed.

I may come off as salty and bitter, but I don't hold my ex's mistakes against women I date. Each new woman is a clean slate. If anything, the MB principles pay off in new relationships.

Lessons learned to carry with me into a future marriage. But if I follow MB to the best of my ability and still have a new WW? No mercy and no quarter given.

Monc needs to learn from this experience, pick up his self esteem so he understands he deserves loads better, and find a new woman that he can have a clean slate with.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/24/09 06:48 PM
Yea, I'm just trying not to moan and complain about my life right now. As most of what I want to say deserves to be in a blog somewhere talking about how pathetic my life is and that I should // my wrists or drive off the road and see what hitting a tree head on feels like. Although such an action is well outside my character.

It looks like my WW is scared now. She's afraid of being alone and bla, bla, bla. Though still thinks she married the wrong person.

It's sad that she can't see the best thing is me.

I'm going to my lawyer today to talk about filing...divorce for infidelity.

I think last night the rest of my hope dwindled away.

Talking to my mother, my wife is literally like my father. Selfish, unwilling to change, and a cheater. I think even if she were to come back she would be unable to admit wrong the way I will need her too.




Originally Posted by Just Learning
People do change and often for the better when there are compelling reasons, they just need time to see the reasons. Doesn't mean every marriage makes it or should, it is just that time and patience coupled with the insights one finds on this sight often do lead to recovered marriages.

Yes! Well said JL! smile Mr. W and I will NEVER EVER be grateful for the affair, but we ARE grateful for many of the lessons that we've learned in this process...That's kind of an odd feeling...

For me, the lesson that my mom had been trying for YEARS to teach me FINALLY sunk in...She never stopped repeating these words to me..."Times may change, but morals never do"...I get it now, and I'm very grateful...

Mrs. W
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/27/09 03:59 AM
So she filed for divorce and is "mailing" me the papers and wants me to sign them. If I don't in ten days she'll serve me papers.

I'm counter filing with "adultery" attached.

I'm strongly contemplating a last ditch exposure to EVERYONE I can possibly touch.

She's still an alien being and utterly devoid of reason. I'm just not sure what to do right now.


Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/27/09 04:01 AM
Her reasons for divorcing me are freaking lame. I don't love you anymore. And that I moved out of the house taking my belongings without telling her. And claiming I'm stalking her, etc.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/27/09 04:09 AM
And she acts like since it was August 08 that the fact that the affair is still ongoing and that they aren't sleeping together that it's ok... That divorcing me makes absolutely reasonable sense.
Quote
I'm strongly contemplating a last ditch exposure to EVERYONE I can possibly touch.
Do it! NOW! Before she goes to everyone and convinces them this is all your fault and you're a nutcase and she had to do it to get away from you.

They need the truth! Even if you've told them before, let them know what she's doing now. Even people who said they don't want to hear from you. They need to hear what she's doing and WHY!
Don't sign a thing and have her serve you.

You've been advised to expose from the start. We've spent a great deal of time trying to help you. There's those that tell you to run away from this woman and count your blessings. There's those telling you what you need to do to save your marriage if you're going to try to do so.

So far you've ignored the advice given by both sides or have half a$$ed implemented some of it.

Get a hold of yourself, pick a path, and follow it.

You shouldn't be months into this and still be contemplating exposure when that is the very first step you need to take.

Now do it or sign the papers and be done with her and carry on with your life!

OR

If you want to make things difficult, don't sign anything and force her to file legal papers and have you served.

Then, don't answer your door for anything since you can't be served if you can't be found.
Any updates?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 03/31/09 05:42 AM
Waiting for Wednesday for her appointment to talk with Dr. Harley.

I'm anxious for that... I'm not holding my breath that it'll change things though.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/01/09 10:27 PM
Update.

My wife talked to Dr Harley at 7am. She called and left a voice message on my phone at 1pm. She feels I don't understand her reasons for divorcing me and wants to clarify them and talk openly without expectations of reconciliation of our marriage. She seemed tentatively honest…I don’t trust her “honesty” though because she is very histrionic at times (Shallow expression of emotions and rapidely changing through them). Besides that, she's having an afair of course. Especially lately. I can’t trust her emotional output at all(She’s a performer musically and theatrically.) And because she knows how she is acting often herself(unconsciously at the least), she doesn’t trust my emotional outputs either. The thing is, she KNOWS I don’t lie. I express exactly how I’m feeling. I have no emotional control. Thus why I’d be a poor performer, but for me it makes conversing with her difficult. She just “babbles” on and plays on my reactions. Although being concerned for what she views my actions as is probably something you guys would tell me to stop doing.

She said to call her when I have time to come and talk with her and was very lenient about “when” giving me the option of choosing. Although I’m certain now that it’s code for “immediately” as she is assuming I’ll read her mind and jump in right away.

The problem for me is that I have a hard time resisting or seeing through her "babble” in person. She could have gotten the divorce papers that allege Adultery or Dr Harley could have gotten through to her. And last time she wanted to talk she pulled a switch-a-roo on me.

Talking to her is hard for me because I can't get off the fence of being angry and being in love with her. Her words easily lead me along because I'm middle brained. I'm emotional and logical...the problem is I'm a male. Which means unlike women who can think emotionally and "business" oriented at the same time, I have a hard time sticking to the "business" or the "emotional" sides which men can only do one of at any given time. I move back and forth in conversation. Especially those that deeply matter to me. I often start in the business end and move to emotional. The issue is staying on track with the business end because once I’m emotional I can’t think straight any more and am easily swayed, led or left to inaction.

I need some way to remind myself over and over to follow a specific plan of action while talking to her. As the "I talk marriage and not divorce." does not stick in my head. I start with it and slip into an emotionally pliable state. And afterwards I realize it and hate myself.


So that’s where I’m at. I’ve not called her back yet.


Give yourself a visual clue. How about a rubber band on your wrist. Safety pin a note on that rubber band that says 'look at the big picture' or 'can you live like this or not?' or 'she has lied to you 26 times'...whatever works to keep you reminded what you're really dealing with.
Have you done anything toward treating your addiction?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/02/09 01:14 PM
Talked to many friends and coworkers.

I’d agree that there was and is a mild/moderate addiction to gaming.

I was feeling desperate and over exaggerating the truth. I don't have an uncontrollable desire to play.

My issue was time management mostly. I'd go to work, do college work there and at home, and play games because my wife was often so busy I started adjusting to use my time for myself expecting she would say when she was available. Eventually I just kept playing even when she was available because she’d fill her time with her own things. (We both failed there.)

I DID have an unhealthy level of time spent gaming and thinking about it. I did think about it inappropriately though. In the midst of company or social gatherings I’d be thinking about some gaming thing and failing to be present. Sometimes I’d be asked what I was thinking and would honestly say and it would be about gaming when everyone is talking about broccoli.

A key problem is that I've realized my wife was an enabler and a poor communicator of her needs. This led to me playing games without recognizing there was a problem. She expected me to "notice" on my own. Which is something I'm willing to put effort into now.

Now that she's more than willing to emphasize my failings I'm listening and self correcting.

Right now I'm only gaming 5 hours a week. This weekend was the first time in two months that I spent most of the weekend gaming. Each day though I went out with my friends and spent several hours away from the computer socializing with them.

When/if my WW comes around I'll be using Harleys methods of determining how we spend time together to manage my gaming. If she doesn't want to have any part in it we'll find something else we both want to do together.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/02/09 03:16 PM
Talked to my wife some last night on the phone. She's annoyingly forceful when I tell her I don't want to talk and still talks.

She didn't like Dr Harleys idea of being happy in the first marriage. She interpreted it as a "MUST" be happy in the first marriage rather than wouldn't it be better? Although she quoted the “better” part so she heard him.

She even told him that she wanted a divorce so she could pursue the other relationship.

She had to [censored] for some reason that he talked to her for 80 minutes rather than only 30-45 minutes. Idiot. I was happy for the value when he gave me all that time.

She said she wants to end our marriage amicably and be friends. She's turning around again and going back to the lets be friends bit where the previous week she was in the "I won't want to be your friend because you told my parents about the adultery." I wonder if she got the divorce papers for adultery.

She also keeps assuming my position. Telling me that the only reason I don't want to divorce is that I don't want to have to look for someone else.

She wanted one of our wedding items, our unity candle because her Aunt said she should have it and not because she originally wanted it. I told her flat out "No, I'm not giving it to you." And her response turned crying, "Why can't she have any of the wedding stuff that was made for us? Do I think she doesn't care?" I told her that I would rather talk about that in person. Which was an indirect way of saying, "Yes, I don't think you care."

She also told me that she has my new apartment address and that when I updated my address with my bank it displayed it for her too. So now I’m pissed. She can more easily have papers served to me now.

I wish I knew if it was Dr Harley that has made her…discussion oriented. She’s still fogged though.

She ended the conversation talking to me about her dog and how much he's grown since I've been away. Talking all sweet and conversationally.
Quote
She also keeps assuming my position. Telling me that the only reason I don't want to divorce is that I don't want to have to look for someone else.


This comment takes the CAKE.... In other words, you're too lazy (or something) to look for a woman to replace your WIFE

rotflmao

Sorry, DJ here, she seems really dumb to me.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/02/09 06:28 PM
Yea, she's doing an outstanding job of demonstrating her intellect to me. Over and over. Cause, you know, she's amazing because she's looking for new people during our marriage!

Below is bitching and points just for the hell of talking about it.

To support her, she is a Choir teacher and a fine one at that.

It's just when it comes to us she's a poon. She is an outstanding oral speaker and accomplished in writing and literature but I'm starting to realize that she is one dimensional. She does music vocals very well but doesn’t do anything else a fraction as well. She can transcribe music but doesn’t exercise composition. She doesn’t “create” she just mimics music albeit very well. She wrote a book but when it got turned away she didn’t get back to the grindstone to make it publishable. She just lamented it’s failure and let it sit even though I gave her a full year of no work to put an effort into the novel. I asked to have time to work on my degree and not work and she denied me.

I won't boast that I'm amazing, but she carries that and her teaching a little too greatly. She thinks she is outstripping me in life because she is working on her Masters and teaching. Ironically, I've been working towards my bachelors for the last year with seven courses under my belt and working full time. All A's in my courses and only failed the most recent one being Algebra and completed a second course next to it at the same time with an A. I’ve also got 8-9 years of System Administration experience under my belt. She has 1 year of teaching and many, many, part time jobs that she holds up as some great accomplishment that proves her work ethic to be employed. All of them ever netted 14k at the highest any given year over three years. I netted 32k in my job and supported her and our lavish lifestyle of eating out and having fun.

And her reasons for not wanting our marriage are all arguable. Except she won't hear the arguments nor allow me to present them. She just fires twenty arguments at once and I have to select one and then we get into a round robin concerning that one point that isn’t even accurate. So I've learned to ignore the points as much as I want to argue them. Unfortunately she's of the crowd that if you don't speak up it must be true.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/02/09 10:19 PM
Son of a [censored] this woman is pissing me off now. She actually believes that everything I've done so far is "skulking."

Simply because I don't talk to her about what I'm doing. Talking to her family, moving out of my home, etc.

And she still believes that the affair is OLD news and doesn't have any impact on anything and thus does not count as reason for my actions!
Um, why should you move out? Why not her? she should be the one to move out if she hates you so much and wants SO BADLY to be the one to get away from the "skulker."
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/02/09 10:37 PM
So question. If she feels that I'm skulking and I want to expose wider, would it aid her perception if I told her before I did it?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/02/09 11:26 PM
We're living apart at the moment. Two different apartments now, but I'm still trying.

Originally Posted by Monc
She wanted one of our wedding items, our unity candle because her Aunt said she should have it

She wants the unity candle?

rotflmao and the aunt is backing her up? crazy


Quote
I want to expose wider, would it aid her perception if I told her before I did it?

No! But it would aid her ability to spin things into you being a raving lunatic who will stop at nothing to destroy her...

If you were going to use the most powerful weapon in your arsenal, why would you tell her before you fire it? It would be like calling the enemy to tell him you plan to launch an attack at 11:30 Tuesday morning. Or like a cop calling someone to tell them a week in advance that he will be there with a search warrant.

Exposure is not a threat, it is a gun. Only take it out if you intend to shoot it and don't warn them in advance. You don't threaten to expose; you expose or not. Yes it will make her mad. Yes she will call you all sorts of things. Yes it will bring the wrath of God down on your head...(at least it will seem like that.) Ignore what she says...

If exposure is still part of your plan, just do it all at once. You can't expose to one person and check to see if she changed her mind yet and then call the next one on your list if she hasn't. Exposure doesn't work like that. It is like when you first begin to learn to play a guitar. The first time you play you get blisters on your fingers. They hurt, you wait for them to heal and play again. You do it often enough and you begin to build up calluses and now playing no longer hurts your fingers and you don't get blisters any more.

If you expose, then wait for her to recover, then expose a little more and back off again, then try to expose again she gets used to it as well as coming up with her own plan to counter what you are doing. She will go to everyone before you get there and tell them that you have lost your mind and that is why she is leaving you...She'll add that OM has nothing to do with it...Just like she tries to make you believe. You bought into it at first and so will everyone else...

What did Steve say regarding further exposure?

Didn't he want you to write a letter to her? Did you get that done?

Have you been working on a real Plan B letter? (You can post it here for input and comments before you send it to her.)

Mark
Quote
So question. If she feels that I'm skulking and I want to expose wider, would it aid her perception if I told her before I did it?


After 33 pages into your thread you actually have the audacity to ask that Q when you have been advised to absoluteltly NOT warn about exposure, about 100 times, I would say, sure, go for it.

Go ahead with your plan Monc, because it's gotten you so far down the road to R so far.

And of corse your "still trying." Trying it YOUR way as opposed to the MB narrow path for Recovery.

How's that working for you?

I personally, give up.

Perhaps so should you, if your ears are closed.

All Blessings,
Jerry
DO NOT WARN HER
DO NOT WARN HER
DO NOT WARN HER
DO NOT WARN HER
DO NOT WARN HER
DO NOT WARN HER

You should absolutely, positively not....ever, under any of the planets, not even if she begged you to, WARN HER ABOUT IT!

When you have a big bomb that could wipe out your enemies, do you say "HEY I HAVE A BIG BOMB THAT'LL WIPE YOU OUT?"
Monc, GOOD GRIEF!
When are you going to grow a pair?

Stop worrying about what she thinks!

She has already chosen to screw another man!

Why should you give a crap what she thinks you're doing?!!!!!!

Stand up for yourself and stop looking like such a pansy.

Get on the phone - RIGHT NOW - and work your way down your entire list of family and friends and call them and tell them what she is STILL doing!

Jeez...
Grow a pair. I think I know where the old Pom went... :crosseyedcrazy:

YOU NEED TO STOP LETTING YOUR WIFE WALK ALL OVER YOU!
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/13/09 09:31 PM
I had talked to steve again this last Thursday myself.

He said that further exposure past parents in the case of having no children can create a feeling of irepairable damage to the social relationship. He also said that it is very easy for two people without children to part ways and never see each other again and that putting too much pressure from exposure can be bad.

He's told me to work the angle of "us" being happy and that is what I'm aiming for. I wish I had this last conversation last time we spoke because I'd have had better answers for my wife in our recent conversations.

My wife recently decided that she won't talk to me unless I sign the lopsided divorce papers... So I'm kinda laughing because I was about to do Plan B because she has resisted any efforts on my part to Plan A.

I'm still doing Plan B shortly just to set the tone from my perspective and as my last effort to Plan A a little. I'm going to write a love letter that accompanies the Plan B letter. I'm writing both and borrowing from another poster here and will post them for viewing soon enough.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/14/09 01:13 AM

From rod24773 letter which I thought was so great I'm borrowing it essentially verbatum.


WW, it is with a heavy heart that I write this letter to you. It is truly sad to see what has happened to us and to our marriage and our families. The decision I now make is out of a necessity to spare what I can of the love I have for you.

I have made many mistakes in the past and cannot change those mistakes or take them back. I failed to allow you a loud enough voice in the decisions concerning our marriage. I didn’t acknowledge your needs, seek them out, nor take them seriously enough at times. I failed to listen when I should. I being human do not fully understand all the things in our marriage that I failed in but am willing to learn and rectify them.

I am truly sorry for helping to create and sustain an environment that has made your affair possible and allowed it to continue. I too had a responsibility to meet your most important needs; and by lacking the right judgment, I did little to aid efforts in building and growing our love for each other. I lost sight of the importance of you as a wife. Now I know I am more than able to not just meet those needs, but to be lovingly enthusiastic in meeting them. I am willing to forgive mistakes you have made just as you should forgive those made by me.

I have had a most difficult time in the last 3 months. There has been pain and hurt in this time knowing you are with someone else. These times I have spent learning to mend my failings. The pain and hurt, even though causing me great anguish, has let me realize the inner strength I really possess. The dual nature of hurt and strength makes a conflict that now leads me to an inescapable conclusion. This conclusion, I will hold firm to, as I have learned my strength will only be in my resolve.

WW, this decision I make, I do not make lightly. It is not meant as a measure to punish you. It is simply meant as a way to no longer drain the love I have for you, even the kind of love I had for you during the time of this affair. The continued pain has become an unhealthy part of my learning to be the best possible husband to the one I love. As soon as you can fully, permanently, and unconditionally separate from OM and are willing to commit to measures to verify that separation, I am willing to do whatever it takes to start a full recovery of our marriage.

Until then, I will not be able to communicate with you. I will avoid seeing you or speaking to you. I will avoid all communications in any form. You can contact me through (Family Friend). I won't be able to accept any calls, texts, emails, or letters from you, but (Family Friend) will forward anything important to me.


I want US, not me alone and not you alone, but us to rebuild our marriage. We need to build a new lifestyle including everything that can be done to make us Both happy. I know it is possible for our marriage to flourish, and have no more separations in body or spirit. I want to be your best friend and a husband that any woman would be proud to have as a spouse.

WW, I want to grow old with you. When I said “I DO,” I made a promise in front of God, you, our families and friends for life. I want to be your husband, your friend, and your lover. I loved you more than life itself while we were together and I continue to do so as I write this. I want us together to someday watch our future children grow and flourish.

The path home is a simple one. When you are ready to choose to recover the marriage as one just leave OM, never contact him again, and call me to let me know your affair is over. I will be willing to discuss our future together as a whole and healthy family unit without judgment or anger.

Your loving spouse and best friend,



-Monc

One does not send a love letter with or include a love letter within a plan B letter.
Tear that up. Use this:


Dear Wife,
I can no longer bear to look at you without wanting to throw up. All I see is you with OM. So, to preserve any last feelings I have left for you, I am removing myself from your vicinity. I will no longer speak to you in any form. If you need to contact me, contact ABC (#: XXX), who will forward any pertinent information to me and back to you if necessary.

If you decide you want our marriage back, I'm willing to listen. But first you will have to agree to the following safety (of my heart) measures:
Never contact OM again and never strike up another friendship with another male without my consent.
Write a NC letter which I approve and send myself.
Provide me every password, URL, email, and any other form of electronics you use to contact the outside world; I will monitor this all at will to ensure you are not again cheating.
Never go anywhere without me or that I don't approve of, for the rest of our marriage.
Sign a post-nup agreement that states that if you stray again, you will forfeit any claim to any of our joint assets.
Attend therapy to my satisfaction.

Until you are willing to accept these demands, I will have no choice but to believe you are still lying to me, and I can have nothing to do with you. When you are ready to work on our marriage under these conditions, let ABC know.
Posted By: dh104 Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/14/09 06:12 PM
Originally Posted by TheRoad
One does not send a love letter with or include a love letter within a plan B letter.
If I'm not mistaken, I've seen it stated here many times that a Plan B letter SHOULD be a love letter outlining a path home for the wayward spouse.

See here...
http://forum.marriagebuilders.com/ubbt/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=2214852#Post2214852

Quote
a Plan B letter SHOULD be a love letter outlining a path home for the wayward spouse.
That would be the way Dr H would state it...
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/14/09 09:25 PM
Catperson,

Knowing your history I completely understand and feel much the same way at times. All of the stuff listed though goes with no contact. I may even expand on the letter to include the list of requirements.
Originally Posted by Monc
Catperson,

Knowing your history I completely understand and feel much the same way at times. All of the stuff listed though goes with no contact. I may even expand on the letter to include the list of requirements.
I don't get what you're saying.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 04/15/09 09:06 PM
I was refering to your letter version I should use. The "I can no longer bear to look at you without wanting to throw up."

When I read this during my last post it seemed much more angry compared to the one I borrowed from Rod.

That was what I was saying.

Monc,

Dr. Harley specifically states that a plan B letter should be a love letter, with a well defined path home once the affair ends. Rod's letter is well done, use it as your template.

God Bless,

JL
Originally Posted by Monc
I was refering to your letter version I should use. The "I can no longer bear to look at you without wanting to throw up."

When I read this during my last post it seemed much more angry compared to the one I borrowed from Rod.

That was what I was saying.
Oh. I was just trying to get you to remember your path. I didn't think you would actually use that letter. Just keep in mind that you have a right to be angry with her, so your letter isn't all kissing up. That's all.

fwiw, I think that other letter is way too long and sappy. She will never even finish reading it in her mindset. Maybe later. So I was trying to get you to stick closer to facts.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/01/09 03:53 AM
Our Three Year Anniversary was yesterday and today she sent me this. I'm really not sure if I'm looking for any thoughts. I talk to Mark1952 on the phone often enough to get an opinion on current events. I know she was at her brothers wedding a week ago and was thinking "how many people did i tell about her", and I know she is telling coworkers that I'm simply "trying" to prove her affair rather than it being true. I just figured I'd put this up. Mark1952 had said that the fact that she is even wondering who knows says my wife is still in there somewhere... *shrug* Sometimes it's hard to see anymore.

-------------

What do I have to do to be free of you, "my name"? What's it going to take?

You want my money? Here. Have all of it. I'll write you the ***edit*** check now. I'll pawn everything down to my underwear. I'll sell my car. I'll return every piece of jewelry you ever gave me, if you just let me go.

You want the wedding gifts? Fine. Keep them. I hope they make you happy. But let me go.

You want something else? My organs, my blood? I'll extract them now and hand them over. But let me go.

Because if you're going to insist on the whole "til death do us part" ***edit***, there are ways I can arrange that. Right now, I am ready to drive my car into a ***edit*** tree. I am ready to slash my wrists or swallow bleach or inhale the contents of a bathtub just to get free of you. Just so I don't have to be tied to you one more ***edit*** day. If you're going to insist that I live my entire life as your wife, then I will go ahead and end it, because I can't be your prisoner anymore.

I need to breathe. I need my own name back. I need to know if I can ever plan anything good for myself ever again without the shadow hanging over me of how much you will punish me for having something for myself without you. I need to know if I can do things like buy a bed for my own ***edit*** house without worrying that I'll need money to pay my ***edit*** lawyer to make you go. the ***edit***. away. I need to know that you are human enough to see that I am dying, tied to you like this. It is killing me. You are the worst thing that ever happened to me, and I cannot live like this. I need to know that you have a grasp on reality, that you realize that this is over. Please tell me you realize that if I am offering to kill myself just to get away from you, then you cannot possibly in good conscience believe that it is right to cling to me anymore, or insist that I am in any way obligated to try to pretend to be happy with you for your sake.

You cannot make me happy. YOU CANNOT MAKE ME HAPPY. I cannot make you happy. EVER AGAIN. All you can do is set me free. That's all you can or will ever be able to do for me, is set me free, and if you cared about me at all, if my life meant anything to you, you would do it. You would just sign the ***edit*** divorce papers and ***edit*** let me go. Rather than drive me insane, rather than watching me struggle so frantically to get away from you, rather than endlessly pursuing me and thinking that all you have to do is talk me into staying trapped with you, let me go. Let me live.

You cannot talk me into staying with you. You can't. And if there is nothing I can do to get away from you, I would rather take a bullet to the brain than stay your wife. If I have to spend the rest of my life tied to you and your delusional ideas of how our first marriage is more important than my freedom or sanity, then I will inhale a box of sleeping pills tomorrow. And yes, I will have spent the remainder of my life tied to you, just like you want. But at least it won't have to last as long.

Please let me go. I am begging you. I am begging for my life. My life is not yours. My soul is not yours. My heart is not yours. My body is not yours. And they will never willingly be yours ever again. Accept it. Let me go.

Please, let me go. Stop punishing me. Let me go.
Posted By: SIHW Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/01/09 04:06 AM
Simply tell her if you hear/read comments like this again you will immediatly call the police because she is threatening her life and welfare....and if she continues she will most likely be sent to a mental institution against her will for being 5150 (insane).
GOOD LORD.

I don't think I have EVER seen a wayward spouse this spoiled.

She is humiliating herself. Remember, everything she says is MANIPULATION. SHE IS TRYING TO CONTROL YOU FOR HER OWN BENEFIT.

Ok, this is NOT MB, but if I were you? I would take her text, send it back to her and say:


You want my money? Here. Have all of it. I'll write you the *edit* check now. I'll pawn everything down to my underwear. I'll sell my car. I'll return every piece of jewelry you ever gave me, if you just let me go.
OK. We will meet at XYZ and sign the papers. You will GIVE UP EVERYTHING YOU EVER OWNED IN THIS MARRIAGE.

You want the wedding gifts? Fine. Keep them. I hope they make you happy. But let me go.

You want something else? My organs, my blood? I'll extract them now and hand them over. But let me go.
Put it in writing; let me know.

Because if you're going to insist on the whole "til death do us part" *edit*, there are ways I can arrange that. Right now, I am ready to drive my car into a *edit* tree. I am ready to slash my wrists or swallow bleach or inhale the contents of a bathtub just to get free of you. Just so I don't have to be tied to you one more *edit* day. If you're going to insist that I live my entire life as your wife, then I will go ahead and end it, because I can't be your prisoner anymore.
Go ahead.

I need to breathe. I need my own name back. I need to know if I can ever plan anything good for myself ever again without the shadow hanging over me of how much you will punish me for having something for myself without you. I need to know if I can do things like buy a bed for my own *edit* house without worrying that I'll need money to pay my *edit* lawyer to make you go. the *edit*. away. I need to know that you are human enough to see that I am dying, tied to you like this. It is killing me. You are the worst thing that ever happened to me, and I cannot live like this. I need to know that you have a grasp on reality, that you realize that this is over. Please tell me you realize that if I am offering to kill myself just to get away from you, then you cannot possibly in good conscience believe that it is right to cling to me anymore, or insist that I am in any way obligated to try to pretend to be happy with you for your sake.
You are welcome to do whatever you want. I will continue, however, to inform EVERYONE WE KNOW what you did.


You cannot make me happy. YOU CANNOT MAKE ME HAPPY. I cannot make you happy. EVER AGAIN. All you can do is set me free. (to *edit* my OM) That's all you can or will ever be able to do for me, is set me free, and if you cared about me at all, if my life meant anything to you, you would do it. You would just sign the *edit* divorce papers and *edit* let me go. Rather than drive me insane, rather than watching me struggle so frantically to get away from you, rather than endlessly pursuing me and thinking that all you have to do is talk me into staying trapped with you, let me go. Let me live.

You cannot talk me into staying with you. You can't. And if there is nothing I can do to get away from you, I would rather take a bullet to the brain than stay your wife. If I have to spend the rest of my life tied to you and your delusional ideas of how our first marriage is more important than my freedom or sanity, then I will inhale a box of sleeping pills tomorrow. And yes, I will have spent the remainder of my life tied to you, just like you want. But at least it won't have to last as long.

Please let me go. I am begging you. I am begging for my life. My life is not yours. My soul is not yours. My heart is not yours. My body is not yours. And they will never willingly be yours ever again. Accept it. Let me go.
You are sick. You have been infected by an affair. It has infected your brain to the point that you think this endorphin-controlled feeling you have is reality. IT IS NOT. Some day, you will realize what you did to us, your marriage, your parents, your family, your children...all of us - just to get a 2-day fix of sex.

I feel sad for you.
You'd think your WW could write a letter without so many F-bombs!

Why is it angry people think they make your letter hit home more, but...
While I was reading her letter to you, I was reminded of an animal that has its leg stuck in a steel-jawed trap and will gnaw its leg off to escape the trap.

You should go to B soon.

Charlotte
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/01/09 06:08 AM
I wish you didn't use that analogy. She has already called herself "trapped in a bear" trap.
Sorry, it's what came to mind. You want me to erase it?

You need to be in B to protect yourself from these tirades.

Charlotte
I agree with Plan B. And my WH said the same thing "Just let me go." It's painful to hear these words. But hearing them helped me realize just how broken he is. And your WS seems very, very broken.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/01/09 09:02 AM
Haha, no Dancing_Machine it's fine. It was just a momentary...ah damn it.
If we're voting, I vote for...

PLAN B
Posted By: dh104 Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/01/09 02:48 PM
You were writing a Plan B letter a couple of weeks ago. What happened to it?
Originally Posted by Monc
Our Three Year Anniversary was yesterday and today she sent me this. I'm really not sure if I'm looking for any thoughts. I talk to Mark1952 on the phone often enough to get an opinion on current events. I know she was at her brothers wedding a week ago and was thinking "how many people did i tell about her", and I know she is telling coworkers that I'm simply "trying" to prove her affair rather than it being true. I just figured I'd put this up. Mark1952 had said that the fact that she is even wondering who knows says my wife is still in there somewhere... *shrug* Sometimes it's hard to see anymore.

-------------

What do I have to do to be free of you, "my name"? What's it going to take?

You want my money? Here. Have all of it. I'll write you the ***edit*** check now. I'll pawn everything down to my underwear. I'll sell my car. I'll return every piece of jewelry you ever gave me, if you just let me go.

You want the wedding gifts? Fine. Keep them. I hope they make you happy. But let me go.

You want something else? My organs, my blood? I'll extract them now and hand them over. But let me go.

Because if you're going to insist on the whole "til death do us part" ***edit***, there are ways I can arrange that. Right now, I am ready to drive my car into a ***edit*** tree. I am ready to slash my wrists or swallow bleach or inhale the contents of a bathtub just to get free of you. Just so I don't have to be tied to you one more ***edit*** day. If you're going to insist that I live my entire life as your wife, then I will go ahead and end it, because I can't be your prisoner anymore.

I need to breathe. I need my own name back. I need to know if I can ever plan anything good for myself ever again without the shadow hanging over me of how much you will punish me for having something for myself without you. I need to know if I can do things like buy a bed for my own ***edit*** house without worrying that I'll need money to pay my ***edit*** lawyer to make you go. the ***edit***. away. I need to know that you are human enough to see that I am dying, tied to you like this. It is killing me. You are the worst thing that ever happened to me, and I cannot live like this. I need to know that you have a grasp on reality, that you realize that this is over. Please tell me you realize that if I am offering to kill myself just to get away from you, then you cannot possibly in good conscience believe that it is right to cling to me anymore, or insist that I am in any way obligated to try to pretend to be happy with you for your sake.

You cannot make me happy. YOU CANNOT MAKE ME HAPPY. I cannot make you happy. EVER AGAIN. All you can do is set me free. That's all you can or will ever be able to do for me, is set me free, and if you cared about me at all, if my life meant anything to you, you would do it. You would just sign the ***edit*** divorce papers and ***edit*** let me go. Rather than drive me insane, rather than watching me struggle so frantically to get away from you, rather than endlessly pursuing me and thinking that all you have to do is talk me into staying trapped with you, let me go. Let me live.

You cannot talk me into staying with you. You can't. And if there is nothing I can do to get away from you, I would rather take a bullet to the brain than stay your wife. If I have to spend the rest of my life tied to you and your delusional ideas of how our first marriage is more important than my freedom or sanity, then I will inhale a box of sleeping pills tomorrow. And yes, I will have spent the remainder of my life tied to you, just like you want. But at least it won't have to last as long.

Please let me go. I am begging you. I am begging for my life. My life is not yours. My soul is not yours. My heart is not yours. My body is not yours. And they will never willingly be yours ever again. Accept it. Let me go.

Please, let me go. Stop punishing me. Let me go.

Seriously Folks ... exactly what is there here to recover???

This is a 3 year M between "twenty-somethings" with NO CHILDREN.

This W doesn't seem as much "wayward" as just fed up ... ALL SHE WANTS OUT OF THIS M ... IS OUT OF THIS M ... PERIOD!!!

This is not a fogged up babble ... this is pure HATRED for Monc and their M.

IMHO, the best advice for Monc is to simply sign the D papers and move on ... there's simply NOTHING left to R.
Sounds COMPLETELY 100% WAYWARD to me.

It's manipulative drama ridden fog-babble that should be ignored.

Now there likely isn't much value in trying to save it (you're young and there are no children) but that's MONC's decision to TRY and even if he fails, which is likely, there is value in the effort. That he lived up to HIS VOWS and tried until the very end to "love, honor and cherish her" even in these "bad times".

This letter...email is NOT, in itself, the final word erasing all possibility of reconciliation. It's sole purpose is to attack any hope MONC may have (i.e.-manipulation). Her ACTIONS are what's erasing the possibility of reconciliation (not the words in an email) and thus, attack the affair, expose it, make it so horrible OM dumps her and then, just maybe, SHE will come back to reality.

Sorry if I missed something...haven't read this thread in a bit and don't know all that's going on.

Mr. Wondering

Hey why not give this woman a divorce!!!????

She really wants one!

Give her what she wants!!!!!
Good points and of course it's Monc's decision, ultimately. I still vote for him going into Plan B so he isn't bombarded with such vicious diatribe.

This line, though:

Quote
rather than endlessly pursuing me and thinking that all you have to do is talk me into staying trapped with you

She feels manipulated by him with Plan A. I believe he's mentioned that before, some months back.

Charlotte
I know I haven't been posting on your thread MONC but before I didn't have much to say. But after reading that letter I'd like to tell you that you deserve better than that, than her. Its hard to get past the pain that she has inflicted upon you, but you need to see that you are an incredible person. You need to see that she obviously didn't appreciate you for who you are. If she did she wouldn't be so hateful.

Did she send this as an email or written letter? Either way I would make sure there is one copy on file for your divorce just to show her way of thinking. And I would take the original or a printed version if its email and have yourself a barbecue. Take all the precautions of course, but burn the letter, it will release so much tension you won't even believe it.

I don't know if it would be worth it to try and save any thing with your marriage, but if you do divorce don't give her the divorce on her terms. She's the one that hurt you, don't give her exactly what she wants. I know she said she doesn't want anything in the divorce other than away from you, but that doesn't mean you have to do it on her terms. Start doing things for yourself. Be true to who you are!!
Dearest Monc;

If I write the most mean, hateful, disgusting letter to you, then you will:

1. Give me everything I want.
2. Leave me alone.
3. Stop Plan A'ing me.
4. Stop making me look at my betrayal in the face.

How has your most recent conversation with the OM Mother gone?

I would send her a copy of her letter, and state, that this is what her son has pushed your wife to do.

But, whatever.

LG
Hi Monc!

My BS is on this site (want2stay) and showed me the last couple pages of your thread. I don't know your whole sitch, and I've never posted to you, but I just wanted to chime in with some things that may help concerning the email from your wife.

First, I agree with many who have said that a short marriage with no children is the toughest type of recovery. When there are ties that bind (in a good way) other than just a marriage license, it gives the WS and the BS a little more to hang onto when things get this bad.

However, being a FWW myself, I can tell you that while I never wrote anything that blatantly vicious, that email is NOTHING BUT FOG BABBLE! Let's break it down...

The thing that stuck out like a sore thumb to me was the fact that since you DON'T have children and she obviously makes her own money, etc...she would be "free" of you like she swears she wants in a New York minute if she were 100% committed to being rid of you and moving on with her life. Seriously- WHY would she be begging and whining for you to "let her go" and blah blah blah? WHY wouldn't she just get a lawyer, file for divorce, and if need be (ie- you were really "stalking" her or harassing her) get a RO on you and MOVE ON already!

WHY? Because she IS NOT 100% committed to leaving you! Because she is writhing in her own self-inflicted misery! Because if you were a good husband and have done a good Plan A (and BTW- the fact that she feels "manipulated" by your Plan A MEANS IT'S WORKING!!!!!!) then she has no "good" reason for doing what she has done. Let me clarify that statement- there is never a GOOD reason for having an A, I'm just trying see things the way she probably does. She feels guilty and rages against that guilt by raging at you. You are the source of her turmoil in that she is looking for someone (other than herself) to blame for the mess and pain she has caused.

This is all very painful, and you have every right to be "done" at any time, but if you have done a good Plan A, then you MUST do a good Plan B before calling it quits. Plan A is agony, but Plan B is for YOU to heal, to find calm, to find things that make you happy and shut her our completely. I think, just from reading the last couple pages of your thread, that she may come to a completely different conclusion than her email suggests (provided you decide to take her back and work on the M at that point).

Honestly, if you have put the work and effort into Plan A, and then go straight to a D without at least trying Plan B for even a few weeks, then all that time spent suffering through Plan A was for nothing!! Plan B is necessary in most cases to snap the waywayd out of their nonsense, and yet most people either can't or won't do it, and when they do, they half-[censored] it by letting the WS get their little fixes here and there (phone calls, IMs, emails, etc) which renders Plan B worthless.

SO, my advice is to go dark and stay dark until she makes serious concessions or one of you decides to file for a D. Write a GREAT Plan B letter with Mark's help (he's awesome, isn't he!) and then POOF- go dark. Her email is total fogged-out BS (and I don't mean betrayed spouse!). If you get a chance, read the link in my sig line "Inside the Wayward Mind." Maybe that will help you understand her silly brain a little better so that you can brush off her ridiculous rants a little easier.

I wish you luck!
Thank you LaLa...

Just what was needed here.

resonance

great answer
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/04/09 04:37 AM
"I think, just from reading the last couple pages of your thread, that she may come to a completely different conclusion than her email suggests (provided you decide to take her back and work on the M at that point)"

What conclusion do you mean she would make?

She already filed for divorce. She wants me to sign the papers that she presented me. I filed back for Adultery. Dr. Harley said he applauds that because it shows her I will only be pushed out of this marriage.

LaLa, I've actually read your Inside the Mind once before, it's been a while. It was a good refresher. I generally just take what she says and ignore it. Mark actually explained how that works and figured I apparently do that on my own. Which is a good thing because most of the pain has gone right over my head.

She yells and thrashes wanting to know why I'm punishing her... Offers all her money and more but doesn't push the divorce she filed.


It sounds like you have a good plan going Monc. Stay strong and keep remembering that you deserve better. You are a strong guy, stay that way!!
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/04/09 11:04 PM
So that e-mail I posted above...on her blog the same day she posted essentially(not quoted),

"I didn't call him today and ask him over even though I wanted too. We probably would have just fought or had pitty sex, or both. I'm really proud of myself for not calling."

Yea. I know...wow.

six weeks ago she had posted about being sad that she is alone and that I would use the blog entry against her as a reason we should stay together.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/05/09 12:02 AM
Oh and to answer before, I'm working on my Plan-B letter now. Scheduling an appointment with Dr. Harley to have him advise me as it's been a month since I last spoke with him.

I posted someone elses before and was planning to give it to her before the 29th...but I guess I got cold feet. Even me talking to her right now is something and going dark is going to hurt.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/05/09 03:42 AM
Wow...this is one of the hardest things I've had to do so far... Trying to write a romantic letter and remembering all the wonderful times and trying to sort the best ones out is painful.
Quote
I posted someone elses before and was planning to give it to her before the 29th...but I guess I got cold feet. Even me talking to her right now is something and going dark is going to hurt.
Consider it tough love. If you ever want her back, she has to see the consequences.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/07/09 02:46 AM
So would a WS even if they don't express love towards you keep finding ways to attain negative contact? Now after weeks of silence she is harassing me for her half of the tax return.

Nm, I'm answering my own question. Of course she is...

The one thing I don't like is giving her money. She is trying to say it's a legal matter for me to give her the other half when there isn't a legal case right now. I don't want to give her the money because it'll just make her divorcing easier. At the same time it pisses her off if I don't...

I'm not sure what to do with the money to avoid giving it to her or helping her.

Actually this was her e-mail:
"I'm not sure if you've just been exceptionally preoccupied, but I have been trying to reach you for the past few days. if your phone is not working, please contact me through another method. We need to talk about the tax return, and when I can expect to get my half. It is your legal obligation to return it to me, so please don't play games and with hold it under some mistaken idea that you have a right to it."

So I'm now contimplating that legal matters aside, it wasn't her right to cheat on me and until she rectifies her actions towards dumping the other man, she won't be seeing anything she feels is her right.
Hey Monc. :wave:

I haven't made it through your entire thread and likely wont until the weekend but I just wanted you to know you have a new reader.
Put it in a one-year CD that neither of you can touch for 12 months. By then, you'll have rectified all your issues. Send her ONE email informing her you did so, and then refuse to read any of her emails. In fact, change your email address, and change your phone number.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/07/09 05:47 AM
Quote
Go ahead and play dead
I know that you can hear this
Go ahead and fake it
Why can't you turn and face me?
Why can't you turn and face me?
Why can't you turn and face me?
Why can't you turn and face me?
You ***edit*** disappoint me.

Passive aggressive ***edit***.


Just trying to get him on the phone. Just trying to talk to him, to find out if he has received my tax return in his bank account. Trying to find out when he's going to give it to me.

If he's going to give it to me.

My mother urges me not to do anything hasty, like, say, reporting him for tax fraud. Says wait, be patient, be mature, have dignity, don't play his games.

I asked her how long I have to wait and be mature while he steals from me and commits felonies. Because really, there has to be a limit somewhere. Perhaps a $3000 limit, I don't know. I know I did bad things, I know I'm the villain for leaving and the ***edit*** for giving up on a marriage. But come on. What's the time limit on my redemptive victim-hood?

End rant. I had a very, very good weekend, and there was a someone I met. A someone I can't really talk (or think) about as long as I'm wearing the wrong last name. So I'm once again ready for this to be over.

***edit***...this is from her diary two hours after the e-mail above.

She utterly does not understand passive aggressive...and she keeps calling me that. Grr.
Originally Posted by Monc
So would a WS even if they don't express love towards you keep finding ways to attain negative contact? Now after weeks of silence she is harassing me for her half of the tax return.

Nm, I'm answering my own question. Of course she is...

The one thing I don't like is giving her money. She is trying to say it's a legal matter for me to give her the other half when there isn't a legal case right now. I don't want to give her the money because it'll just make her divorcing easier. At the same time it pisses her off if I don't...

I'm not sure what to do with the money to avoid giving it to her or helping her.

Actually this was her e-mail:
"I'm not sure if you've just been exceptionally preoccupied, but I have been trying to reach you for the past few days. if your phone is not working, please contact me through another method. We need to talk about the tax return, and when I can expect to get my half. It is your legal obligation to return it to me, so please don't play games and with hold it under some mistaken idea that you have a right to it."

So I'm now contimplating that legal matters aside, it wasn't her right to cheat on me and until she rectifies her actions towards dumping the other man, she won't be seeing anything she feels is her right.

Mmmmmmm......it would be a good idea for you to discuss this with your attorney. It may need to be placed into a trust account until the estate is settled.

Her attorney WILL be asking for it, (you'd better believe it!!)--so don't do anything too hasty that might get you in trouble.

Just to be on the safe side.

Charlotte

P.S.) Yeah, and don't give it to her, either. (I know you won't, just adding for info.) That's something that definitely needs to be documented in case she comes back later and claims you didn't fork over her half.

You can tell her that as well--that it will have to go through the attorneys. That way she will be off your case about it. Maybe.
My quick research indicates that if she signed the joint return which indicated that the refund would be depoisited electronically into your bank account....she MAY be screwed, especially if you are in a community property state and no separation/divorce proceedings are underway.

I haven't read this all but this link may help:

http://www.nrglaw.net/downloads/whogetstaxrefund.pdf

Gotta run.

Mr. Wondering
MONC,

Just a question here that may or may not have anything to do with what eventually happens to the refund...

She expects half of the refund. Did she pay half of the taxes for the year? If she paid less than half, talk to your lawyer to see if you can get away with only giving her the same percentage that she paid. If she paid in more that you, then hold out for YOUR half.

A couple in our neighborhood went through a quiet yet nasty divorce a few years back. She quit her job and ran off to be with her boyfriend in another state. The boyfriend dumped her for another OW (surprise!) and she returned home and "tried to work things out." 3 months later she left to be with another OM and at the end of the year wanted HER half of the tax refund. It went to court and the judge asked her why she expected half of the refund of money her husband had paid the government since she hadn't actually paid any taxes that year because she wasn't working anywhere AND was not actively operating as his spouse but as a free-agent rather than his wife.

BTW, the neighbor got the house too and married a woman who divorced her husband because he was sleeping with her sister...
Ok...back.

Are you in a community property state?

Did she sign the joint return?

Did the return indicate the refund would be direct deposited into your individual bank accout or did you get (or are you holding a joint check)?

*If you are holding a joint check...not much you can do with it until she signs it.

Who paid in what to the IRS? If you PAID in more (earnings aren't relevant) than you are entitled to more of the refund regardless of anything else.

In the end, even if some of the money IS hers...doesn't mean you can't apply it to a marital obligation instead of handing her cash. Pay it all on a joint bill and be done with it. Send her an email indicating "I used our refund to pay xyz". Maybe she co-signed the mortgage or lease agreement on your home...use it directly for that as just because she's moved out doesn't mean she's not still liable for it. Pay rent in advance even. Since no divorce/separation proceedings are under way...the refund is "OUR" money...not yours and hers to be divided up.

Of course...get your attorney's advice on the matter as though I'm a tax attorney...I've only looked at this a few minutes.

Mr. W
Just got an email from a lurker on this subject:

She indicated that she took a joint refund check and ddposited into a remaining idle joint checking account and then immediately paid down a joint credit card debt with the money all without obtaining her spouses signature on the check or anything. Her attorney advised her that that was OK and nothing further came of it in the divorce proceedings that are now finalized.

Any joint obligation would be OK...even if she's just a co-signor on your auto loan or lease.

Just an idea.

Mr. Wondering
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/07/09 06:42 PM
She gave me the tax documents while we were separated. I filed for the taxes electronically and filled her signature in electronically. She is now lying and claiming that I signed for her against her will.

The money was put into my account. There are no joint resources that we need to have payed off. Although she did take my Target card and charged $600 to it without my knowing until I got a bill.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/07/09 06:44 PM
A refund results from an overpayment of income tax, either by withholding or by estimated tax payments for the year in question. The source of the overpayment determines ownership of the refund. U.S. v. Anthony, No. CIV 97-1772-PHX-SMM, 1999 W.L. 424884 (D. Ariz.1999). Under federal tax law, an overpayment by a married couple is owned by each spouse separately to the extent that he or she contributed to the overpayment. Rev. Rul. 74-611, 1974-2, C.B. 399. Each spouse has a separate interest in the family income as reported on a joint tax return and, consequently, a separate interest in any overpayment. Id.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/07/09 06:46 PM
Well...my lawyer says she has pushed for a court date now...no matter what.
Posted By: dh104 Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/07/09 06:51 PM
Quote
I had a very, very good weekend, and there was a someone I met. A someone I can't really talk (or think) about as long as I'm wearing the wrong last name. So I'm once again ready for this to be over.
So let me get this straight, besides the OM, she now has someone new that she's interested in?

Monc,

Please edit out any profanity from your wayward wife's blog before posting. The Harleys do not wish to have profanity used here on their board. Thank you in advance for respecting their wishes.



Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/07/09 09:18 PM
I'm very sorry Maverick. I saw that in my earlier e-mail...I guess I missed it again. I'm getting used to it from her that I glaze right over.

Wow, I assumed it was the same guy...she made a blog entry again two hours ago...new guy...second OM! @&#%!!!!!
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/07/09 09:26 PM
Her diary:
Quote
Came home, and was settling into bed that night when the phone rang. New Guy calling. What am I up to this weekend? Oh, I don't know. What would you like me to be doing this weekend?

So, life definitely did not suck yesterday. Matter of fact, I enjoyed the hell out of it. I may not be out of the tunnel, and the light may be tantalizing from so far away, but at least it's there. I can see it, and it's there.

Also, she got refunded for the New York trip that got canceled and is now, "planning on going with the new guy, he is supposedly from New York, but wait, that would be too quick so maybe with a friend only..."
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/07/09 10:04 PM
I look forward to my Harley appointment tomorrow.

...I wonder...if there IS a new guy could I figure out how to introduce him to OM#1 or tell OM#1 about it?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/07/09 10:18 PM
The court date was june but I just got my lawyer to set it for a jury hearing. Now it's going to be as far as September...and three times as expensive for me.
Originally Posted by Monc
I look forward to my Harley appointment tomorrow.

...I wonder...if there IS a new guy could I figure out how to introduce him to OM#1 or tell OM#1 about it?
Monc, I think that is an excellent idea!
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/08/09 02:04 AM
Mark came up with something I also considered...she is calling the same guy new to pretend to the world that this guy wasn't here before...
Either way, you owe it to OM to tell them what a landmine they are in for.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/08/09 06:43 AM
I don't think he's interested in understanding how *swear*'ed up, my wife is... He is 20 and has no idea what is normal...
Originally Posted by Monc
I wonder...if there IS a new guy could I figure out how to introduce him to OM#1 or tell OM#1 about it?

OM#1 probably wouldn't care that much. Probably saw your WW as another notch on the handle. The new OM on the other hand, might be interested in finding out what your WW really is like before finding himself in any sort of relationship with her.
Originally Posted by Monc
The court date was june but I just got my lawyer to set it for a jury hearing. Now it's going to be as far as September...and three times as expensive for me.

I gotta tell you ... this is FOOLISH!!!

Exactly WHAT are you trying to save here???

It appears to me that all you're doing is prolonging YOUR own agony, while wasting a bunch of money to do it.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/08/09 06:37 PM
That is something I am afraid of...am I fighting a truly lost battle?
Originally Posted by Monc
That is something I am afraid of...am I fighting a truly lost battle?

She has now moved on to a 20 year old????

I hate to ask, but now knowing this, are you still sure this is a battle you want to fight...and pay more for?

And I am sorry to say, but as to the 20 year old; I doubt he'll care about OM1. He prob insn't interested in a long-term committed realtionship anyway.
Originally Posted by Monc
That is something I am afraid of...am I fighting a truly lost battle?

IMHO ... YES!!!
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/08/09 08:17 PM
The OM1 is 20.

OM2 is probably just OM1 being redefined to the world.
Originally Posted by Monc
That is something I am afraid of...am I fighting a truly lost battle?
What exactly do you think you're fighting for? You're not taking her back, you have no assets, what the heck do you need a jury trial for?
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/08/09 09:11 PM
It was the only way to push the date for divorce back. The case for the jury trial is to prove adultery essentially besides that.
And what benefit does proving adultery give you?

A lot is going to be said about you too in front of that jury.

Yes IMO you have been fighting a losing battle for a very long time.

Divorce or no divorce - you are the one truly losing here.
Originally Posted by Monc
It was the only way to push the date for divorce back. The case for the jury trial is to prove adultery essentially besides that.

Your lawyer should be able to present a strong enough case to the judge to prove adultery.

Do you just want that to come out or there a lot of assets to be divided?

Was it your idea?

Charlotte
Monc,

I told you the other night that I didn't think that your wife would wake up and defog before the divorce was final no matter when that date is. I still stand by that opinion.

You aren't going to stop the divorce at this point by any legal means. You guys have almost nothing that needs to be distributed in a break-up.

Do I think that someday she will regret her actions and maybe even wish she could come back to you? Absolutely! The problem is that by then she may have married someone else already (OM1, 2, 3, 27, 49...whatever)

I know you want her and still love her and I know you are willing to wait for her to defog, but that should not be at the expense of being able to reach some sort of healing for yourself. You can just let her go, Monc and still wait to see if she wakes up within a year or so. Divorcing doesn't have to mean that you are not willing to take her back if she ever does become a rational member of society again. You stop waiting when you are done and not before, but I don't think you are going to win this battle and you might need to begin thinking about disengaging from the battle entirely if you want to survive to fight another day down the road.

If you fight this to the bitter end, spend weeks fighting in court over ending the marriage and waste thousands of dollars to do it, by the time the divorce is final you will hate her so much that you will never even consider taking her back. Now if THAT is your goal, to fall out of love with her completely so that you can start shopping for your next wife right away, then the way you are headed is probably the best route to take.

But if your goal is to remain in Plan B waiting mode for some period of time before moving on with your life and giving up on her, the way you are going about it probably won't accomplish that goal for you because by the time she does defog and seek reconciliation with you, you will have NOTHING left to give to the effort. THIS is the REASON for Plan B to begin with. It SAVES your love for her IN CASE she turns around.

You also should realize that the more difficult you make her life right now the more resentment you will have to overcome from her if the affair burns out and she starts to miss you. At this point you aren't going to stop the divorce, she has already ended her relationship with you as faar as she is concerned and given that you have no children together and no real marital assets, you can quickly and without a lot of further grief get to the end of the divorce and begin to let your own feelings recover.

I am NOT saying you have to give up. She is no longer fighting and is simply taking every punch you throw at this point but she refuses to "tap out." The best you can accomplish now is to continue to injure her some more. Let her last thoughts of you be that you let her go because you loved her rather than that you made her life hell in order to prove a point. Since she is unable to fight back at this point, just stop hitting her. Nobody is going to stop the fight, she isn't unconscious but will never surrender. Right now it is your pummeling that is keeping her pinned to the side of the cage that is keeping her from falling down. Let her fall...

Will she come back to you? Not any time soon.
You now have to save enough to fight on in case she does...

Who is OM1, 2, 3, 27 or 49 no longer matters...

The fight is no longer about saving your marriage. It is now about being declared the winner. Just walk away...

You did all that you could have done.

JMO


Yeah; it sucks...

Mark
I still don't understand what you are trying to 'win' in your side of the divorce, doing it the way you are. What is it? To stop the divorce? Make the jury tell her to take you back and stop screwing other guys? Give you money she doesn't have? I really don't understand what you're thinking.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/10/09 02:21 AM
It was my idea. I asked how the date could be put off. One was to ask for an extension, which gives a couple more weeks and that's it. The other was going to jury which extends it several more months out to wait for a date.

No real assets to be divided. Simply that I'm wanting to also create a situation of consequences for her actions too.
Quote
Simply that I'm wanting to also create a situation of consequences for her actions too.


Stop trying to control that which you cannot. Why not try pushing spaghetti? You'll get better results.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/10/09 12:28 PM
Thanks Mark. I keep coming back to reread your post to reaffirm the clarity it gives me. It's the hardest thing in the world to...let go when your heart is so firmly attached.
Monc, do me a favor. Go back to the beginning of your thread, and reread the things that you have told us she has done. Maybe that will give you the clarity to realize what she has done to you.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/10/09 10:13 PM
I did actually today.

Let me ask you this then. You went through this, you wanted to save your marriage too even though you were hurt right?

Actually, I didn't go through this. My H will not cheat.

But I know psychology and human nature. I know what happens when people are put in certain situations. When they have undergone XYZ in childhood, what they will do in adulthood. I offer that, only.

Bottom line is, if a person is a Taker, and never has to suffer consequences, they will spend their entire life hurting people, leaving them in their wake, if the Givers keep on giving without saying ENOUGH!

It is YOU who has to say enough. She has to see what she is losing. Laying out a divorce over months means nothing to her. Walking away from her with your head held high does.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/11/09 03:34 AM
"My H will not cheat."

Because you follow MB principles? I'm swallowing those words myself.

Catperson, was it you? Or are you just the lucky damn person to have found MB before it could happen?
Monc, I'm cutting my own throat by saying this, but I've spent the last 20 years wishing my H would give me a reason like that to leave him because I'm afraid I never really loved him, and I wished he would leave and find someone who did. I married him because I was 'supposed to' - part of my generation's belief that if you didn't get married you were defective.

And the marriage was dysfunctional enough, and I had such low self-worth, that I spent much of my 30-year marriage wishing I wasn't married and hating myself for not having the guts to tell him.

I have to tell you I didn't treat him that well. I've always been selfish, willing to let him do for me while I didn't want to do for him (but I did, for fear of his anger). But he stuck through it all. He (as far as I know) tells me everything - every woman who talks to him, hits on him, the hookers in China and Thailand who try to get him to use them...all of it.

Because he considers me his best (and only) friend, and that's what friends are for, right? Who else would he tell? He decided he wanted to marry me while I was still engaged to someone else, and he just decided to wait for me. That's the kind of relationship we have. He just never realized that I wasn't reciprocating, that I never talked, about anything (he filled up the time on his own, lol).

So, it's my instinct to say what I did.

Of course, I don't truly believe that 100%. I just think that, if he were going to do it, it would have been earlier, when I was just surviving the marriage and really not giving him anything he needed.

Now that I'm at MB, I've found the reasons I used to like him, and coming to the point where I feel like I can appreciate him and even want him. I'm working on that.

So that's my story. I'm sorry if it offended you. Or anyone else. I knew as soon as I said it, I probably shouldn't have. I even came back here to delete it if you hadn't read it. But since you have, I'll take my lumps for being so insensitive.

ETA: I keep thinking about this, and realizing how insensitive it sounds to all you BSs, and I never meant that. I only explained my situation to help Monc. But the way I've felt about my H is really just a sign of my depression and desperation: I wanted out so badly and hated myself so much for being too chicken to say so, that I wanted HIM to be the bad guy so I could live with myself. And our marriage was miserable enough that I literally daydreamed about being alone, no matter how it happened. I know I'll go to hell for thinking that, but it is what it is. frown
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/11/09 06:58 PM
It's honest, which for me is enough. You're learning to be a giver for someone who gives. There was actually no offense taken by me, although severe jelousy was present when I read it.

Thing is, I'm like your husband. My wife didn't tell me she was unhappy, and wouldn't spend the time with me the way I wanted and eventually I filled it for myself. Then she turned it around and thought "I" was choosing to not spend time with her when it became a habit for the both of us.

If there was no affair to prompt looking for MB, how did you ever come to find this resource?

lol, I used to post at another place, a TV place, and I used to moan and groan about my awful husband so much that someone there who posts here recommended I come here. I think they all got together and decided to do an intervention.

I learned here, that the worst thing I could do is NOT tell him what I felt. In fact, LA told me that I was actually being abusive to HIM by not telling him how I felt, by not giving him the information he needed to decide if he would change or not before it was too late, while all along I was safe and secure in calling HIM abusive. I had a longtime plan to leave him when D18 leaves for college. Now, I don't know. I see glimmers of the old guy I married sometimes now, since I have learned to be more honest. Now that he knows I may leave.

But it took me 1 1/2 years of coming here to get the courage to tell him. I still haven't told him everything, like the marriage of convenience part, don't know if I ever will. I have severe walls in place from childhood crap, and I think that would be more hurtful than all. Maybe someday I'll have enough faith in 'us' to be completely O&H; who knows?

Anyway, if I was paying more attention, I should have said 'I doubt my H will cheat' because who really knows? I didn't mean to sound smug or anything.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/11/09 07:23 PM
The Jury trial decision was taken out of my hands thankfully and sadly. She is willing to accept Adultery on the divorce decree.

There is no option to push the date back although it will save me money so I should be thankful.

Extension put the date to early July now.

How do you not collapse in the middle of this? I was calming my mind as time went on and now that there is a date set for court I'm a whirlwind of thinking about her. I miss her, want her. That little bit of love that is left desperately screams at me that I need her.

And my comfort…lately has strangely been my dog.

My terrier likes to lay at my back now for some reason and it always reminds me of my wife. My way of pushing that out of my mind is to turn over and wrap my arms around my dog and burry my face in her fur. My dog has become such the comfort I never thought she could be…that there is something, almost a someone, who ecstatically greets me at the door, wants my attention as I do things in the home, and relies on me to feed, walk, and play with her. It surprises me that when I look over at her and her tail starts wagging I find it amazingly cheering.

That when I go to bed she is so predictable in jumping up with me flopping into me ready for her before, we got to sleep total scratching…which is something my wife and I did together before.


And I hate movies now…I’m scared to watch anything anymore because everything seems to include a spouse in danger, an affair, a death…and they all trigger me.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/11/09 07:26 PM
hehe, Catperson your tone went from the previous "certain I know what I'm telling you" to "apologetically concerned."

Thanks.

From me...tell him the truth. My #1 EN is O&H.
Tell him I never really wanted to marry him? Wow, I don't know...
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/11/09 08:54 PM
Ok, are you glad "now" that you married him?

Is one of his top EN's O&H?

I'm glad for the daughter I have with him. I love him, as in I've been around him for so long that we are intertwined. I wish I hadn't married him, because I would have been a completely different person and had a totally different life.

I doubt he even thinks about that; 90% of our conversations are about him, his work, and what's wrong with the world (i.e. what it's doing to him); 9% is about D18; 1% is about how I fit into what they are doing. So he wouldn't even know what to be O&H about.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/11/09 10:23 PM
1.
Originally Posted by catperson
I have to tell you I didn't treat him that well. I've always been selfish, willing to let him do for me while I didn't want to do for him (but I did, for fear of his anger). But he stuck through it all. He (as far as I know) tells me everything - every woman who talks to him, hits on him, the hookers in China and Thailand who try to get him to use them...all of it.
2.
Originally Posted by catperson
I learned here, that the worst thing I could do is NOT tell him what I felt. In fact, LA told me that I was actually being abusive to HIM by not telling him how I felt, by not giving him the information he needed to decide if he would change or not before it was too late, while all along I was safe and secure in calling HIM abusive. I had a longtime plan to leave him when D18 leaves for college. Now, I don't know. I see glimmers of the old guy I married sometimes now, since I have learned to be more honest. Now that he knows I may leave.
3.
Originally Posted by catperson
I doubt he even thinks about that; 90% of our conversations are about him, his work, and what's wrong with the world (i.e. what it's doing to him); 9% is about D18; 1% is about how I fit into what they are doing. So he wouldn't even know what to be O&H about.

What are you doing now to not be selfish? Now something else to point out. You say you've always been selfish, and he's always been giving? In (1), not wanting to give while he gave, is selfish, but how was his giving leading to (2)? What change in (2) are you wanting from him before it's too late? And in (3) if 90% of the conversations are about him what are you doing to tell him that you'd like it if the conversations included you? And how is your perspective that conversation is selfishly bent on him when he is supposedly giving? And I'm talking in a giver/taker sense.

I sense strongly that you talk about MB in passing and haven't sat down to really put forth the scary work of finding out about each other and where you both stand in your marriage.

Am I right?

Full Disclosure. How else are you going to become happy together?
Well, it's a bit more complicated than I can answer in one post. Please feel free to read my thread in Emotional Needs for the whole schpiel. But I'll try to answer your questions.

1. What I meant is that he would always buy me stuff, take me out, always take care of me first in SF. But it was never what I asked for, and even if I said I wanted something (like hanging up curtains that have been sitting on the floor in the bathroom for almost 6 years), he would pretend I didn't even speak. A control issue. And if I didn't do what he wanted, he would make life miserable - pouting, shouting, yelling, passive aggressive, etc., so I learned to make sure we did things his way. After awhile, I just stopped talking, and asking for anything, and he never even noticed.

2. The change I would want from him? To ask me about myself - I can count on one hand the number of times he has asked me about me, my thoughts, my work. To listen to me and stop interrupting me when I DO try to talk, like he just did for the umpteenth time. To actually acknowledge that I've asked for help instead of looking me right in the face and walking away and doing something else (he is changing this somewhat, since I had 'the talk' and told him I couldn't handle it any more).

3. He calls me when he leaves work, and talks all the way home (an hour) about his job and how they're screwing him over. Then he gets home and talks more about it, or complains about D18, or complains about the neighborhood, or the Mexicans or the Blacks who are doing him in, or...you get the idea. When I say he is giving, he is a very hard worker, tries to buy me things (though he is $80,000 in debt), and he puts up with me not giving him back rubs when he gives me one (but that's only when he wants SF).

Talking? I have just now (a month ago) told him I'd been thinking about leaving, after 30 years of marriage and never saying a word. I've had too many near misses with wanting to choose suicide over doing the hard work. He knows, but is unwilling to talk about it. He went to therapy with me once for a few sessions until she told him she needed to see him alone and he cussed her out and refuses to speak about it. And there's a good chance that he is developing his mom's paranoid schizophrenic tendencies, so the negativity just gets worse and worse.

We're a long way away from being honest about this stuff.

But I'll keep working on it. And he has made some tiny...awarenesses, if not changes. So I am more hopeful than I have ever been that I can find a reason to stay.

I hope that made more sense.
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/13/09 07:22 AM
So now she is putting herself in compromising situations. She's visiting people who were interested in her in the past and staying the night with them.

Stayed the night in the same bed next to someone who just broke up with their girlfriend, tried to kiss her before they fell asleep and later in the evening woke her to being sexually assaulted in her sleep...spooned her, grabbed her breast under her shirt, masturbating and humping her from behind.

She freaked out and left, but seriously...

Then I find her and OM were not talking very well lately and this somehow brought them together again. She called him while she was shaking from the experience and driving home. IE: I think she made him jealous with the information.
Posted By: iam Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/13/09 09:55 AM
Originally Posted by Monc
So now she is putting herself in compromising situations. She's visiting people who were interested in her in the past and staying the night with them.

Stayed the night in the same bed next to someone who just broke up with their girlfriend, tried to kiss her before they fell asleep and later in the evening woke her to being sexually assaulted in her sleep...spooned her, grabbed her breast under her shirt, masturbating and humping her from behind.

She freaked out and left, but seriously...

Then I find her and OM were not talking very well lately and this somehow brought them together again. She called him while she was shaking from the experience and driving home. IE: I think she made him jealous with the information.

Seriously Monc....You should seek counseling to find out why you hate yourself.

That's the only explanation for what you are doing to yourself in this situation.
I agree. Do you get your self-worth from saving people or something? I can't fathom any other reason why you get kicks caring about her.

Now for some 2x4s: Monc, what are you doing staying steeped in all this crap - there is no longer any reason for you to be snooping. Stop reading this stuff, stop asking people about her, stop doing whatever you are doing! Every little tidbit of sluttiness you read makes you feel more and more like a puddle of poo under her feet!

STOP IT!
Monc,

What do you need to find that will make you let her go? Will it take an orgy with dozens of men? Will it take her using drugs and sleeping in the alley with the winos? Will finding out she is pregnant turn you off enough to stop following her every move looking for signs that she is starting to change her mind? Will learning that she has a life threatening STD from her exploits do the trick?

What need are you getting filled by reading all of this crap from her?

I told you recently that I didn't think there was any way to get her to come back before the divorce is final even if you delayed it several months. This is no longer just a flash in the pan "whoops; I let someone get too close." She has her mind set on the destruction of your marriage and nothing less will be sufficient.

This isn't even about what she thinks is wrong with you any more. This is now entirely what is broken inside of her. It isn't something YOU can fix. You can't stop her. You can't save her from herself. You can't catch her before she falls; she has already hurled herself from the mountaintop. If you truly still love her and want to try to build something new with her, just let her go, wait for the THUD when she hits bottom and be ready to clean up the mess when she hits. Right now that is the best you can do because she is already in free-fall.

The only thing you are accomplishing by continued snooping right now, wishing that you'll find some crack in her armor that you can exploit, seeking confirmation that the affair is burning out as you hope (unmet expectations) is that you are slowly torturing yourself into not loving her any more. If that is your goal, then keep reading. If you really think she might ever come back and want to reconcile, then stop killing your love over her antics and just go dark. Plan B letter or not, just ignore all of this or you will end up a basket case.

Mark
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/13/09 06:52 PM
So to follow this advice from my letter thread and here, my final steps are the letter, talking to her brothers and going Plan B THIS week. By Sunday I have to go Dark into Plan B.

Your right Mark...I realized it yesterday and lastnight that my love is being vaporized. I realized it again this morning when I dreamed about a cute girl who was amarous and who I was quiet ready to screw like a bunny until my alarm clock went off.

I've never had a dream like that since getting with my wife...

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/14/09 12:43 AM
So for the soap opera, my recent reply to my spouses demands for her half of the tax return. This is again a Steve directed thing...keep telling her how our marriage can be great. Let me know your thoughts I'm sending it later tonight or in the morning.

Quote
To my wife,

When we last talked you said that I promised your father I'd give you your half of the tax return and that it was the honorable thing, whether it was a legal issue didn’t matter. Why is it that you feel entitled to press me to do the honorable thing, like seeing my promises through when you yourself won’t hold to the honorable thing? You said once that adultery was not illegal but it certainly isn’t the honorable thing, is it? Telling me you want a divorce two weeks after I discover your secretly kept adulterous affair is not honorable is it? You also brought up that you know me, that in my heart I know what the honorable thing is and that I always do it. Why is it that you discard my selfless promises for a joyful marriage if you can so readily recognize what other honorable actions are?

Since Jan 23rd I have made many promises to you. Promises I have been acting on that are in keeping with ensuring we can have a happy marriage. Promises that I am pursuing right now that are changing the way I live. Promises you willingly discard. Promises you mistakenly throw into the garbage because of your own actions and selfish desires. I have pursued an honorable, joyful, and happy marriage for us since finding out Jan 23rd that you had slept with OM in our bed twelve nights in August of 2008. Even as your actions permitted me to drop my vows, I chose to keep to the sworn oath I made in front of your family, mine, and to you because I love you deeply enough to realize my faults that contributed to the affair and to correct them. I swore to love, honor, and cherish you all my life and I will keep that vow.

In keeping that vow I have found Marriage Builders and have followed it to be a better husband and person in my life whether you choose to see it or not.
There is a certified way for us to again be happy in this marriage. A way for us to communicate freely, a way for us to act in a loving way, and a way to repair our marriage and make it absolutely joyful!

The act of carrying out a great and joyful marriage is no different than practicing to play a guitar. Sometimes a person picks one up and learns on their own. Others get a teacher. With time comes great music and sometimes it goes out of tune and you have to retune it, other times a string breaks and you have to get a new string, and when the guitar is damaged you find a capable luthier to fix it. The only time one throws the guitar out is when it’s smashed.

You speak of honorable things and of the heart. You know in your own heart that we have taken no steps to retune, repair, or get a teacher for our marriage.
Dr. Harley is our marriage’s luthier and instructor/counselor. And the Marriage Builder methods is the strings and tool to retune our marriage. You’ve talked to him, you know how well he saw things. He can help us and our marriage be happy again. I am not dead and neither are you, this marriage can be repaired to be joyous again!

It can be joyous and amazingly happy. I would get on my knee’s and swear this too you since I never did when I proposed to you in California. That abiding by a year of effort we will be well on our way to happiness. There is no magic bullet and it will take effort from us. Dr. Harley and Marriage Builders are just the tools and guides.

I have heard every insult and complaint you have made about me. From the most minor to the most major. I have remembered them and none of them are below any sense of importance to me.

And nothing is below my ability to sacrifice to ensure we can have a joyous marriage together.

I want to give you a happier marriage and to live a joyful life with you.

I want to create amazing music with in a duet of hearts.

I love, honor, and cherish you my love,

-BS


P.S. Threatening me that “I” will lose you as a friend for not giving you your half of the taxes is shallow I must say when it is your actions that necessitate my withholding of the tax return until our divorce. It is not only my legal council to maintain all funds until the court date, but also that any funds I provide you while you are divorcing me for an adulterous affair will only aid the affair and I will not besmirch our marriage in such a way.
Monc, I don't have a problem with you wanting to give her a second chance, but please stop sucking up to her. It is NOT attractive! In fact, it's ugly to see a man kiss up so much.

To my wife,

When we last talked you said that I promised your father I'd give you your half of the tax return and that it was the honorable thing, whether it was a legal issue didn’t matter. Why is it that you feel entitled to press me to do the honorable thing, like seeing my promises through when you yourself won’t hold to the honorable thing? You said once that adultery was not illegal but it certainly isn’t the honorable thing, is it? Telling me you want a divorce two weeks after I discover your secretly kept adulterous affair is not honorable is it? You also brought up that you know me, that in my heart I know what the honorable thing is and that I always do it. Why is it that you discard my selfless promises for a joyful marriage if you can so readily recognize what other honorable actions are?

Since Jan 23rd I have made many promises to you. Promises I have been acting on that are in keeping with ensuring we can have a happy marriage. Promises that I am pursuing right now that are changing the way I live. Promises you willingly discard. Promises you mistakenly throw into the garbage because of your own actions and selfish desires. I have pursued an honorable, joyful, and happy marriage for us since finding out Jan 23rd that you had slept with OM in our bed twelve nights in August of 2008. Even as your actions permitted me to drop my vows, I chose to keep to the sworn oath I made in front of your family, mine, and to you because I love you deeply enough to realize my faults that contributed to the affair and to correct them. I swore to love, honor, and cherish you all my life and I will keep that vow.

In keeping that vow I have found Marriage Builders and have followed it to be a better husband and person in my life whether you choose to see it or not.
There is a certified way for us to again be happy in this marriage. A way for us to communicate freely, a way for us to act in a loving way, and a way to repair our marriage and make it absolutely joyful!

The act of carrying out a great and joyful marriage is no different than practicing to play a guitar. Sometimes a person picks one up and learns on their own. Others get a teacher. With time comes great music and sometimes it goes out of tune and you have to retune it, other times a string breaks and you have to get a new string, and when the guitar is damaged you find a capable luthier to fix it. The only time one throws the guitar out is when it’s smashed.

You speak of honorable things and of the heart. You know in your own heart that we have taken no steps to retune, repair, or get a teacher for our marriage.
Dr. Harley is our marriage’s luthier and instructor/counselor. And the Marriage Builder methods is the strings and tool to retune our marriage. You’ve talked to him, you know how well he saw things. He can help us and our marriage be happy again. I am not dead and neither are you, this marriage can be repaired to be joyous again!

It can be joyous and amazingly happy. I would get on my knee’s and swear this too you since I never did when I proposed to you in California. That abiding by a year of effort we will be well on our way to happiness. There is no magic bullet and it will take effort from us. Dr. Harley and Marriage Builders are just the tools and guides.

I have heard every insult and complaint you have made about me and I have made none about you, although you deserve it for what you have done to me. From the most minor to the most major. I have remembered them and none of them are below any sense of importance to me.

And nothing is below my ability to sacrifice to ensure we can have a joyous marriage together.

I want to give you a happier marriage and to live a joyful life with you.

I want to create amazing music with in a duet of hearts.

I love, honor, and cherish you my love,

-BS


P.S. Threatening me that “I” will lose you as a friend for not giving you your half of the taxes is shallow I must say when it is your actions that necessitate my withholding of the tax return until our divorce. It is not only my legal council to maintain all funds until the court date, but also that any funds I provide you while you are divorcing me for an adulterous affair will only aid the affair and I will not besmirch our marriage in such a way.
_________________________
Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/14/09 01:39 AM
Thank you Cat... I actually was thinking of editing...granted I DIDN'T so...

That is something I've been thinking about. The sucking up.

Nice guys finish last so they say.

Posted By: Monc Re: My WS won't leave the OM and is divorcing - 05/14/09 07:50 PM
Her response to the e-mail:

"You're pathetic. You're claiming you have a right to keep thousands of dollars of my money because I cheated on you back in August? Pathetic."
Quote
Her response to the e-mail:

But you knew that was going to be her response when you sent her the email, right? skeptical

Lots of time and effort went into getting the email just right and her only comment is that you are controlling and cheating her again... rant2

Waynerds! sigh
Get out now. She does not want the marriage anymore. Clearly. She wants any and all monies that she can get out of you and that is it.
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$


This is all she wants. From you. This is how much she cares for you: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour: :twobyfour:
So what do you really think, Bubbles?

crazy dance2
© Marriage Builders® Forums