GM. Thank you for coming and posting. Now, though, pardon me, but:

Let me see if I understand your post.
1) DWG needs you to be "in love" with her. I think that translates into her needing to feel like she is
the woman for you. Do you agree?
2) It is impossible for you to feel "in love" with DWG, not in any way equivalent to feeling "in love" w/ your last OW. You are actively comparing your
feeeelings now for DWG to your OW? In other words, you are comparing DWG to your OW. I know you said you think of the OW with nothing but unpleasant thoughts, but you preceded that statement with mentioning your rosy thinking about that time...
3) You're special because of the uniquely destructive nature of your longstanding
modus operandi of adultery, is that correct?
GM, Mark made a very good point to you. You are
well past D-day, you have had the forum and
the Harleys to hold your hand and coach you through this.
And you are saying that you can't feel "in love" with your wife who has given your lying, adulterous butt a second chance because YOU feel bad about what you did?GM, you should know better by now:
get over yourself.
This is not about you. This is about healing your victim. How do any of the above attitudes help that?
Listen, I understand the misery, the guilt, the paralyzing depression. It bites, sure. But it
pales in comparison to what our BSs are feeling, and, lest we forget:
they never signed on for this. We did. To that end, it is our responsibility, as the WS, to heal them as best we can.
Your attitude is doing just the opposite. So guess what that means? You need to drop it and try something new.
****
I'm taking a break for now. I will try formulating something helpful. Maybe nicer people will be along in the meantime and handle this more capably than I.
I am appalled, GM. And, no, this is no excuse for you to start wallowing in any sort of "poor me" pity party.