Okay, so she is willing to go talk to the counselor/pastor. That's a good sign.
I'm getting the strong impression here that she WANTS to rebuild your marriage, but is just finding it difficult to do so on your terms.
If I were you, I would change my terms. Starting with:
Reading everything you can from this website regarding Recovering from an affair.
I would stop telling her that what you did before you were married shouldn't matter. While she did choose to marry you after infidelity, she's obviously rethinking her ability to overcome that, given your terms.
You caused a very big wound with those choices and if marriage to her is what you want, those wounds will need to be properly healed before she is able to run.
Take responsibility for your infidelity.
Taking responsibility doesn't mean simply saying, "I did it and I'm responsible for it". Taking responsibility means, you made the mess, you clean it up and you don't expect someonen else to shoulder that burden.
You destroyed her trust. You destroyed her feelings of safety. Clean it up. It isn't fair to expect her to sit there and wonder where you are. It also isn't fair to get angry with her for asking you where you are or have been.
If you want to take responsibility for rebuilding trust, provide that information to her ahead of time. Be an open book. Give her COMPLETE access to your life...all passwords, access to cell phone records, etc. If you're not doing anything wrong, information about your whereabouts can't hurt you. In fact, it can only HELP you. If she knows where you are and what you're doing and you can verify that to her, then there's no doubt in her mind. If there is no doubt in her mind, then slowly she will begin to trust you.
Yes I had a problem with temptation, and yes after this life changing experience I know i will never put myself in those situations anymore, and will never do that cause I have all I need and want in front of me.
We all have a problem with temptation.
If your terms are simply, "I've learned my lesson", that's not gonna be enough.
You're asking her to put blind faith in someone who has already betrayed her.
Even if you believe at this moment that you have everything you want right in front of you and you don't have doubts...it's naive to think that you will never again have doubts about your marriage or about her. You've already shown her how you handle things when you have doubts.
What about a plan that STILL protects your marriage, even when you have doubts or things aren't going perfectly between the two of you?
What are some foolproof ways that you can protect your marriage from infidelity, even when things aren't going perfectly?