I see your pain from the 8 month affair and raise you 22 more months.
I raise your bid of empty years to 17 years.
Dead why the poker analogy?
Because I have held the same cards that life dealt me that it dealt you:
Our Story:
http://www.marriagebuilders.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=31;t=009539Let me give you some very serious things to consider.
Sexual avoidance often is a sign of some serious sex abuse and even rape issues. They maybe known by the avoider or they may be suppressed in their memory or a some combination of both.
It seems like a contradiction that she was rather sexual while courting but withdrew almost instantly once married.
You see in reality it makes a tremendous amoount of sense. While dating she was in control...how? She could go home she could not go out she could even say no while dating.
IF she was abused as I suspect then control is what was taken from her by her abuser. And she gained much of that back while dating you.
But once married she could not go home. She could not see you on a given day. And she felt pressured to comply to her wifely sexual obligations.
My wife said she felt "trapped" once we married even though she knew I would never hurt her.
I asked her what she thought she would gain by having an affair and she said she thought she could be in control. She could say no I won't meet you. She could go home rather than have to rely on her high school sweetheart for a ride home the very person who had just abused her.
My therapist and most books on abuse say sooner or later a rape/abuse victim will act out in some capacity to try and take back the control stolen from them in their earlier years.
As to sex with the OM. If indeed abused then I say there is a 50/50 chance it was worst with him. Do not assume that going back says other wise.
Understand an abused woman has been conditioned to associate sex with abuse. Indeed if the abuse is long enough and extensive enough then abuse and sex blur into one and the same. For an abused woman the associate sex with
1) Secrecy
2) Shame
3) Sense of danger
4) Guilt
5) Sense of low self worth
6) Forbidden
There are more but see how common those feelings would also be for a woman having an affair.
This is going to hurt but if your wife was abused then she actually NEEDED those ingredients in order to be sexual.
You were safe. You did not represent any of the above.
My wife said she self pleasured for years not wanting to associate me with being abused.
My therapist said her rejections were actually the highest compliment someone tortured as her could give a man.
If for some odd reason your wife did actually enjoy the sex its because of her distorted sense of what sexuality should be. She needed to feel all those negatives feelings in order to have sex.
Odds are she went back as you put not for the sex but much like an battered woman goes back to the one that beat them.....the battered woman does not "enjoy" being beaten but it is familar and since she is so broken familar is better than the unknown.
I see two things that suggest just your wife has strong issues for avoiding a close healthy intimate sexual relationship.
1) The obvious in that she avoids sex with the one she says she loves.
2) Her weight issues. They don't have to be real she simply has to believe it is an issue. Lots of overweight women use being overweight as a means to avoid dealing with sex.
She could have numerous other childhood issues but for now I would strongly suggest you look into the possibility that she was sexually abused.
I would also be interested in knowing about the other man. Was he serial cheater? Was he controlling? So on. There are many male sexual predators who have an iniate ability to indentify sexual abused women. The see the signs of low self esteem then they go digging for more signs.
I am willing to be the OM pursued very aggressively after first playing to be a friend. And I am willing to be your wife disclosed the fact you two were struggling sexually to him before they actually slept together. And if she can remember in her mind I bet she will say he started going from friend to hitting on her shortly after she started talking to him extensively about your sexual problems.
My belief that the OM was a sexual predator is simple...most normal men would not pursue a sexual relationship with someone telling them they don't like sex and they are struggling with their husbands sexually.
But for a predator that is like a calling card.