Rebuilding a relationship without WS's support? - 09/11/10 05:33 AM
I guess that might be a confusing title. But that's basically where I am. I guess some background is needed...(this is going to get long, probably- I have never had anyone I could talk to about this)
I'm 26, my WH just turned 29. We've been married 8 years and have 2 children (ages 7 & 5). We dated in high school and started talking about marriage when I turned 18. The plan was that WH would go into the Air Force & I would go to college first. But, I got pregnant, and we bumped up the timeline- a lot!
I always knew that marriage wasn't all lovey-dovey, sunshine and roses, but these past 8 years have been a constant struggle. Every time something comes up, we fight, I beg for counseling, WH refuses (he used to say he'd rather get a divorce than see a therapist- he's mellowed in the last few years- now he just insists we don't need it). After he refuses, we have a week or two of talking about our issues and concerns, we agree that we both need to change- and I end up making all the changes.
To my knowledge, WH has never had a PA- but I can't be sure. He swears that he never has and, therefor, has never cheated on me. What he has done, though, that I feel is hurting out marriage...
Adult Dating Sites: He started creating profiles for himself on adult sites after we had been married for a year or two. When I first confronted him about it, he said "well, I knew you didn't want me to look at porn, this is different" I would tell him how wrong I felt it was- and how trying to meet other women, even just for "erotic emails" was a violation of trust. He would delete the account, and in a few months open a new one.
His excuses were
1) I wasn't sexual enough & neglecting him- which I agreed was an issue. I have/had a lot of self esteem issues, mostly related to my weight at that time, and I didn't like being touched. I have made a real effort and with that, and losing 50lbs- I feel more confident and don't see how SF is really an issue (he agrees now)
2) I spent too much time at the gym/with my weight loss friends-- so I scaled back my workouts to only be done when he was working, and cut myself off from the only friends I had at the time
3) He now feels unattractive because I have lost weigh & he hasn't- and wants to be reassured that people still want him-- I don't know what I can possibly change about myself to combat this!? I can't force him to eat right and exercise- and I have never made negative statements about his current weight. Our sex life hasn't changed, so what is he expecting from me???
He swears he hasn't joined one of those sites in 2 years- but he created 2 new accounts in July (with an email address he didn't know I new about) and several last year as well.
Short Lived EA with ex-girlfriend: When WH got out of the Air Force we moved back to our home town. It took longer than anticipated for him to find a job, but I got one rather quickly. This left him with a lot of time on his hands and, for a month or two, he spent that time emailing, calling, and going to visit his ex girlfriend. He swears he only saw her once, at lunch (in a public place) and nothing happened but 2 old friends catching up. I wanted to believe him, but he sent her emails telling her he was dreaming about her nightly, and wishing for what could have been between them.
I was hurt, but I made excuses for him. I know that not having a job really hurt him, and I assumed that part of this reconnection was just longing for an easier time in his past- where he didn't have to worry about how he could make ends meet or support his family. He swore he would stop talking to her (and to my knowledge has) and that we would get counseling when we moved into our own place (that happened over a year ago- still no counseling)
Ongoing EA with old "friends with benefits"- this is the one I struggle with the most. WH swears again that she is "just a friend" but he keeps all communication with her a secret from me. When I bring it up, he says it means nothing and "I'll stop talking to her if you make me"
What is bothering me and concerning me is that, in the last year he has called her every month when he goes out of town without me (guard duty) He IMs her, but usually ends the conversation with "wife is in the room, have to go" (he's not always so bright- usually just minimizes the screen and walks away
Lately, I've noticed that he texts her whenever he has a day off- and then suddenly has a mysterious reason for why he can't stick around the house that day. Like last weekend. We were sending the kids to stay with my parents for the weekend so we could go out of town, just the two of us. Thursday night he sends her a text asking what she is doing Friday- and then tells me he has to go to our hometown a few hours earlier than me to "look at some trucks" Luckily- I guess, my car died Friday morning- so he had to take the kids to school and ended up staying in town helping me fix it (I swear I didn't sabotage my car! )
Monday we got in a fight about her again- and he agreed to NC- sort of. He deleted her from his facebook, myspace, and xbox accounts. I asked him about the phone and he swore he didn't have her number. I reminded him that I had her facebook too- and she has her cell number posted. It just happens to be saved in his phone under his boss's name. He looked at me weird, didn't say anything- and didn't delete the number. This last week he's been acting like everything is perfectly fine, like he's oblivious to the fact that I still want him to cut off ALL contact.
So, my big question- what am I supposed to do here? I know that it takes 2 to cause problems in a marriage but I have tried and tried to change over the years. I have read every marriage book I can come across trying to make things better. I've tried talking to him- which usually ends in a nasty fight- and I've tried just trying to accept that I am apparently flawed in someway and incapable of meeting all of my husbands needs. Neither option is really ideal.
I can't force him to change, he has to WANT too, but he has no desire to. I have thought of moving out so many times- but I just cannot afford to do it. I'm trying to find a better job, something with a salary and benefits that will help make ends meet on my own- but without a college education my choices are slim. Without being able to put my foot down and move out- and without being able to get marriage counseling- what options are left??
I'm 26, my WH just turned 29. We've been married 8 years and have 2 children (ages 7 & 5). We dated in high school and started talking about marriage when I turned 18. The plan was that WH would go into the Air Force & I would go to college first. But, I got pregnant, and we bumped up the timeline- a lot!
I always knew that marriage wasn't all lovey-dovey, sunshine and roses, but these past 8 years have been a constant struggle. Every time something comes up, we fight, I beg for counseling, WH refuses (he used to say he'd rather get a divorce than see a therapist- he's mellowed in the last few years- now he just insists we don't need it). After he refuses, we have a week or two of talking about our issues and concerns, we agree that we both need to change- and I end up making all the changes.
To my knowledge, WH has never had a PA- but I can't be sure. He swears that he never has and, therefor, has never cheated on me. What he has done, though, that I feel is hurting out marriage...
Adult Dating Sites: He started creating profiles for himself on adult sites after we had been married for a year or two. When I first confronted him about it, he said "well, I knew you didn't want me to look at porn, this is different" I would tell him how wrong I felt it was- and how trying to meet other women, even just for "erotic emails" was a violation of trust. He would delete the account, and in a few months open a new one.
His excuses were
1) I wasn't sexual enough & neglecting him- which I agreed was an issue. I have/had a lot of self esteem issues, mostly related to my weight at that time, and I didn't like being touched. I have made a real effort and with that, and losing 50lbs- I feel more confident and don't see how SF is really an issue (he agrees now)
2) I spent too much time at the gym/with my weight loss friends-- so I scaled back my workouts to only be done when he was working, and cut myself off from the only friends I had at the time
3) He now feels unattractive because I have lost weigh & he hasn't- and wants to be reassured that people still want him-- I don't know what I can possibly change about myself to combat this!? I can't force him to eat right and exercise- and I have never made negative statements about his current weight. Our sex life hasn't changed, so what is he expecting from me???
He swears he hasn't joined one of those sites in 2 years- but he created 2 new accounts in July (with an email address he didn't know I new about) and several last year as well.
Short Lived EA with ex-girlfriend: When WH got out of the Air Force we moved back to our home town. It took longer than anticipated for him to find a job, but I got one rather quickly. This left him with a lot of time on his hands and, for a month or two, he spent that time emailing, calling, and going to visit his ex girlfriend. He swears he only saw her once, at lunch (in a public place) and nothing happened but 2 old friends catching up. I wanted to believe him, but he sent her emails telling her he was dreaming about her nightly, and wishing for what could have been between them.
I was hurt, but I made excuses for him. I know that not having a job really hurt him, and I assumed that part of this reconnection was just longing for an easier time in his past- where he didn't have to worry about how he could make ends meet or support his family. He swore he would stop talking to her (and to my knowledge has) and that we would get counseling when we moved into our own place (that happened over a year ago- still no counseling)
Ongoing EA with old "friends with benefits"- this is the one I struggle with the most. WH swears again that she is "just a friend" but he keeps all communication with her a secret from me. When I bring it up, he says it means nothing and "I'll stop talking to her if you make me"
What is bothering me and concerning me is that, in the last year he has called her every month when he goes out of town without me (guard duty) He IMs her, but usually ends the conversation with "wife is in the room, have to go" (he's not always so bright- usually just minimizes the screen and walks away
Lately, I've noticed that he texts her whenever he has a day off- and then suddenly has a mysterious reason for why he can't stick around the house that day. Like last weekend. We were sending the kids to stay with my parents for the weekend so we could go out of town, just the two of us. Thursday night he sends her a text asking what she is doing Friday- and then tells me he has to go to our hometown a few hours earlier than me to "look at some trucks" Luckily- I guess, my car died Friday morning- so he had to take the kids to school and ended up staying in town helping me fix it (I swear I didn't sabotage my car! )
Monday we got in a fight about her again- and he agreed to NC- sort of. He deleted her from his facebook, myspace, and xbox accounts. I asked him about the phone and he swore he didn't have her number. I reminded him that I had her facebook too- and she has her cell number posted. It just happens to be saved in his phone under his boss's name. He looked at me weird, didn't say anything- and didn't delete the number. This last week he's been acting like everything is perfectly fine, like he's oblivious to the fact that I still want him to cut off ALL contact.
So, my big question- what am I supposed to do here? I know that it takes 2 to cause problems in a marriage but I have tried and tried to change over the years. I have read every marriage book I can come across trying to make things better. I've tried talking to him- which usually ends in a nasty fight- and I've tried just trying to accept that I am apparently flawed in someway and incapable of meeting all of my husbands needs. Neither option is really ideal.
I can't force him to change, he has to WANT too, but he has no desire to. I have thought of moving out so many times- but I just cannot afford to do it. I'm trying to find a better job, something with a salary and benefits that will help make ends meet on my own- but without a college education my choices are slim. Without being able to put my foot down and move out- and without being able to get marriage counseling- what options are left??