This is the hang-up for me as well. I have read this story with this speech from several posters and in almost all situations an A was in the works. Or at least an EA. I confronted and she has denied it, as all WS would do.
As I’ve said in my previous post, if your W was not yet involved in an EA, she was most probably in a situation where she had started to develop “in love” feelings (infatuation) towards someone else. I suspect she was at least involved in an inappropriate friendship OR has secretly developed a ‘crush’ on someone (possibly the man she was flirting with or received the cell phone calls from). And if this was the case, it can help to explain the
”I love u but not in love with u” speech. It’s even possible that the ‘crush’ was one-sided and that the other person was not aware of how she felt. It's already clear from what you’ve posted that previously your W didn’t had strong boundaries in place with the opposite sex.
From experience I can tell you that to start having feelings of infatuation/attraction towards someone else (even if there is not yet any A) can make a person feel very confused and questioning one’s feelings for one’s own spouse. You can read more about it on
THIS POST (just click on the link). If you read my signature and the link in my signature line, you will see I was involved in an inappropriate friendship. During the friendship there was a lot of flirting and other inappropriate behavior involved, but at the time I didn’t view my behavior as betrayal towards my H. If your W was involved in a similar situation (inappropriate friendship or “crush” but not a full-blown EA yet) it’s possible that she didn’t view it as betrayal either. And because she doesn’t view this as *very serious*, she possibly doesn’t see the need to share this with you or she thinks she will unnecessarily hurt your feelings with this information.
I also have already confronted her about the flirting and boundaries and she agreed that it shouldn’t be happening at work or anywhere else and that she would make the effort to make sure it didn’t. We have read his needs her needs. I called her boss and had him address it as well with all employees with a threat of sexual harassment suit to make sure I was taken seriously. Then I confronted the suspected man and made it clear that I would not tolerate flirting or any personal communication. Then I made it known that all of this was initiated by me to everyone in the office.
An affair would be almost impossible as i know where she is almost all the time with no time not accounted for.(almost)
My gut still says something wasn’t right!
I agree with you that something wasn’t right and I think you can trust your gut on that. However, it sounds if your W
is aware of the boundary issue now and willing to put the necessary boundaries in place to safeguard herself and your M against the opposite sex in future. Maybe she has learned from her previous mistakes (flirting; inappropriate behavior etc.) and will not make the same wrong choices again. This is good. Maybe you can also print out the following thread and give it to your W to read as a reminder:
Emotional infidelity in the workplace She is making every effort to restore love in our relationship and says that she had lost herself and that was the problem. She is in counseling for that and says she feels better.
I don’t know if I need to move on and plunge trustingly ahead or not. Do I forgive and forget?
Onemoretime, I can’t answer that for you and I can understand why it’s difficult for you to put things in the past, but I can tell you this: Your W
does sound remorseful and it’s clear that she’s trying to make amends in the M. Also, the fact that she is in counseling and recognizes that
she was the problem and temporarily lost her way, is
very good signs. However, if you can’t make peace with the fact that you will probably never get the full truth from your W and if you can’t put things in the past and move forward without it, then probably you need to take this issue up with your W again and try to work/talk things out with the help of a Marriage Counselor. My question is, if your W wasn’t involved in an A but had developed a serious ‘crush’ on someone (which was most probably the case), do you want to know about it and do you think the knowledge of this will help you to move forward and forgive your W?