I am single, never wanted to marry and still don't
So do you have Autonomy and Intimacy issues? Is it safer to be with a married man so you don't have to confront and deal with your fears of being intimate? Both of you have a safety factor that helps you not get too close...this little detail called "marriage". Neither of you have to get too close, be too vulnerable, put it all on the line, because you have the built in "distancer" of his marriage.
Instead of individually working on autotomy and intimacy issues, you take the easy way out and have an affair. The problem then becomes outside the two of you...not a need for deep, painful, individual work. If you want to be single don't hide behind someone's marital status. Stand up as a single woman, date single men or don't date, and make clear your desire to remain single.
We broke contact almost two years ago, sorta, following a dday where she was told all the details by someone her husband and I had trusted
We broke contact...sorta. Sorta doesn't classify as "doing". People in denial often tell themselves and others half-truths so as to not look so bad. Own and speak the truth, the whole truth! Otherwise, just stand up, speak up, and say........ "This is what I did. It's none of your business. You're not my judge. I don't want to change my behaviors and I'm not going to. What happens between the WS and the BS isn't my problem. This is about me and my wants and needs."
By the way, it's too bad that someone you trusted had the nerve to tell the BS about your relationship. You and the WS can betray the trust of the marriage, but how dare someone else violate your trust!
I urged him to step up and do the right thing
What did it matter to you? It wasn't your business to tell him what to do related to his marriage. Again, if you were really worried about "right" behavior, you would have stepped out. Did telling him to do the right thing, somehow absolve you from your choice to continue wrong behavior?
I believe her to be a wonderful woman who just couldn't meet all his needs for whatever reaso
Ok, so the BS spouse couldn't meet all his needs. Having an affair is one way to deal with this concern. What about them having an "open marriage", where it was acknowledged and agreed upon openly/honestly? How about the WS hitting some counseling a whole lot earlier since he clearly recognized that he didn't intend to divorce his wife? 16 years is a long time to live with such inconsistency between values and behaviors. Uh.....how about divorce? If you don't want to honor your marital vows, and your partner wants you to, than step up to the plate and do the honorable thing. She can either learn to meet the WS's needs or choose to step out.
We began talking again 2 months ago
We have talked 1-2 a week for the past 6 weeks to "catch up"........6 Weeks later he is insisting we can be "Just Friends".
So "catching up" has gone on 6 plus weeks. Just like "I'm going to stop the calls soon."? And if you know that it's not possible to be "Just Friends", why are you being dishonest with him...by your actions....and continuing to have contact as a friend?
This is something we had always done for each other and he just felt he had to offer the support. He did not offer to become involved again. We both admitted that the thing we missed most was our weekly phone calls. We have talked 1-2 a week for the past 6 weeks to "catch up".
Ok, he didn't offer to become involved again. So what the heck happened? How did you go from that position...to ongoing contact? Just like with alcoholics..there's a few details missing, e.g. "A" + ?????? = "C". Alcoholic: "Well, I started to have cravings for a drink and the next thing I knew I was sitting at a bar drinking a beer." Several choices and steps had to have occurred to get from one point to the other. It didn't just happen.
Another question. You said you were dating someone. Why are you finding the need to get your support from the WS? Can't your current guy meet all your needs? I'd like to encourage you to go to the man in your life to share your joys, sorrows, concerns, etc.
He discussed an issue with me and I gave him a womans view and encouraged him to address it DIRECTLY with his wife. I reminded him she had a right to check up on him and that he needed to provide her with whatever reassurance she needs. He even half joked that he wished I could do their marriage counseling. I reminded him of the ethics of my profession and that marriage counseling is not my forte. I have sent him several articles on emotional affairs in an attempt to break through his denial that talking to me is OK. I will not let the "phone friendship" continue for long.
How kind of you to direct the WS's morals and correct behaviors! It's none of your business! If it doesn't bother him, why should you care? If you really cared about the BS, you wouldn't continue to stay in the situation..regardless of the WS's desires, behaviors, etc.
Again, what you did and what you said were two very different things. You directed him to talk about his concerns with his wife, but this was after you already gave him a woman's viewpoint. You took the psychological edge off just enough to provide some relief. This would lower his motivation to change his behaviors.
I have pointed out that not telling her makes it an emotional affair? Again my intention is not to create trouble but I feel she has a right to know he has a "friend" so she can confront him about why he is not talking to her and building their relationship.
Again, why do you care how the BS feels? You wouldn't continue to contribute to a painful behavior if you were really concerned. No...you're not the married person, and you didn't initiate contact...but you continue it. That's fine, but don't try and sit on the fence expressing concerns for the BS at the same time.
He even half joked that he wished I could do their marriage counseling. I reminded him of the ethics of my profession and that marriage counseling is not my forte. I have sent him several articles on emotional affairs in an attempt to break through his denial that talking to me is OK. I will not let the "phone friendship" continue for long.
I am a therapist, which I strongly suspect you are, too. Would you like me to send you some articles on intimacy-autonomy issues, denial, cognitive dissonance, ethics, radical honesty, the impact of adultry on a family, assertiveness, etc. We in the profession tend to be highly effective in deluding ourselves that we couldn't possibly make choices and do things that would knowingly hurt others. So, if we do, the next best thing is to at least be "fair" to the other person and let them know what is going on. Then one can wash their hands of the whole mess.
I think one reason you're concerned about what you should do ...why you came here...is because you are confused about the discrepancies in your morals and behaviors. Have you ever been in individual counseling? If not, I would strongly suggest it. If so, maybe it's time for a refresher. I gained the most professionally when I set my ego down and went in for individual counseling.
I have no personal investment in your behaviors or values. The fact that I have been a BS, is not your fault. You didn't participate in my marital problems. I do challenge you, however, to OWN your opinions, ethics, morals, behaviors, choices, etc. If no one else agrees with you, so what? Cognitive dissonance can do real harm to one's psyche.
You're on a challenging journey. Please, get some professional guidance for yourself.