Welcome to the
Marriage Builders® Discussion Forum

This is a community where people come in search of marriage related support, answers, or encouragement. Also, information about the Marriage Builders principles can be found in the books available for sale in the Marriage Builders® Bookstore.
If you would like to join our guidance forum, please read the Announcement Forum for instructions, rules, & guidelines.
The members of this community are peers and not professionals. Professional coaching is available by clicking on the link titled Coaching Center at the top of this page.
We trust that you will find the Marriage Builders® Discussion Forum to be a helpful resource for you. We look forward to your participation.
Once you have reviewed all the FAQ, tech support and announcement information, if you still have problems that are not addressed, please e-mail the administrators at mbrestored@gmail.com
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
#1828337 02/21/07 09:19 AM
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 9,015
F
Member
Member
F Offline
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 9,015
Quote
Okay, so what if your FWS weren't 2 fall off the fidelity wagon by having another A (even specifically saying so), but insisted after 5 years since d-day, that they don't want 2 be married in the sense we talk about here, and that they want 2 be able 2 have friends of the opposite sex, even if that friend is their former A partner?

Like mine said 2night.

Oh, and some time ago she put a pic2re on her bulletin board that was taken around when the A started 16 or so years ago, that shows several coworkers standing outside their field lab - including, you guessed it, Rat Meat.

I saw this pic2re maybe a few weeks ago. It may or may not have been there for a while before I noticed it.

See, my problem is that, even without infidelity looming again, we still haven't really recovered our marriage. (How can we, if she insists she doesn't want a marriage?)

And 2 make matters "worse", I don't want it either.

I'm worn out. I'm not angry, though I do have 2 be careful and not raise my voice because she wanted 2 talk - I just don't see anything productive 2 talk about.

I had thought, over the past few months or so, of asking her if she would be willing 2 participate in coaching with the Harleys if I paid for it. I haven't ac2ally asked that 2uestion, but I'm pretty sure she wouldn't want 2. And I long ago realized that coaching or doing anything 2 unilaterally save a marriage that the FWS still insists she doesn't want after 5 years since d-day, is just a waste of time and money.

-ol' 2long

2Long, you posted the above on Pep's thread, and I didn't want to TJ that thread just to speak directly with you, hence this thread.


"I had thought, over the past few months or so, of asking her if she would be willing 2 participate in coaching with the Harleys if I paid for it. I haven't ac2ally asked that 2uestion, but I'm pretty sure she wouldn't want 2."

As a proponent of "MB ways" to recover and rebuild marriages without any "outside" intervention, may I ask you if you really do believe that the "MB ways" really do work if they are followed?

It would appear that "I'm pretty sure she wouldn't want 2" is a bit of, maybe a big bit of, a Disrespectful Judgment concerning your wife.

Now, it may actually BE the response, but if we assume that she does want to remain married to you even if she is saying those "WS-like" things about friends, especially RM, and if you really would like to move on to Recovered instead of remaining in the perpetual limbo of "recovery," don't you think that it makes plain sense to ASK the question and actually get a response?

For me, the "breaking point" would be any contact with the OM at all. That is a "Boundary Issue" with me and the consequences attached to a violation of that Boundary are dependent upon the "willfulness," if you will, of that contact. The "friendship line" was irretrievably crossed and cannot be reestablished anymore than you can put a smashed china cup back together again, no matter how much you "wish" you could.

A FWS who does not recognize that is in self-denial. A FWS who recognizes the hurt that the former "bad decision" caused in his/her spouse AND then seeks to justify continued contact with the co-conspirator is a FWS who does NOT understand or accept the concept of Fidelity in a marriage and sacrifice for the spouse. A "Spouse" is NOT single and everything they do must, voluntarily, be considered in the light of "is it good for my spouse and the marriage and not just my own wants and desires?"

If you are "comfortable" with a spouse who wants to put her needs ahead of yours, especially when the OBJECT is to interact with the person who "raped" you against your will, then you have to accept the "doormat" role.

THAT does not sound like the 2Long that vigorously engaged me on many issues and I'm not even married to you.

2Long, I have long said, and you know it, that CHANGE most often is the result of a CRISIS. A "crisis" is precipitated by loving confrontation when those Boundary issues are violated and when the person whose Boundary has been violated has the cajones to "just say 'no'" and says so. You cannot force a change in anyone, but no one can, or will, change unless they come to see the destructiveness of their behavior and that the behavior "is not who they want to be."


"insisted after 5 years since d-day, that they don't want 2 be married in the sense we talk about here, and that they want 2 be able 2 have friends of the opposite sex, even if that friend is their former A partner?

Like mine said 2night."


If you'll forgive me for a moment, this sounds like a paleontologist constructing a "missing link" out of a pig's tooth. It's all in THEIR interpretation of the "data."

You look at the same "data" and you see a completely different interpretation that says, "yep, it's a tooth, but I have no where it came from or what it belonged to."

You look around for other "parts" and you discover the entire carcass of the Wooly Mammoth with a missing tooth that matches the tooth that was found. You conclude, reasonably, that the tooth came from the Mammoth and that the paleontologist's interpretation that it came from an 'ancient missing link of a Man' was incorrect, and was based on the paleotologist's "bias" in favor of "finding" things to support her preconceived belief.

Her preconceived belief in this instance is that her past "bias" has no bearing on her "interpretations" of today. Wooly Mammoth is still there and is still a Wooly Mammoth. Rat Meat is still there and is still Rat Meat.

In other words, despite evolutionary bias', if you'll again pardon my analogy, a leopard really can't change it's spots and playing with fire WILL get someone burned eventually if they keep insisting on putting their hand INTO the fire pit, they will not "evolve" asbestos hands in this lifetime.

Isn't this a opportune time to actually confront, in love, just what it MEANS to be in a monogamous marriage?

Good luck.

Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 10,816
2
Member
Member
2 Offline
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 10,816
Quote
As a proponent of "MB ways" to recover and rebuild marriages without any "outside" intervention, may I ask you if you really do believe that the "MB ways" really do work if they are followed?

Yes, they certainly can. But they are "methods", not "principles", so they might not work in all si2ations. I'm not sure they'll work "completely" in mine, either. And I definitely don't agree with the Harley's views on unconditional love, but I do believe I understand their position.

Quote
It would appear that "I'm pretty sure she wouldn't want 2" is a bit of, maybe a big bit of, a Disrespectful Judgment concerning your wife.

Yes it was. I sent her the following email:

Quote
Mrs 2long:

If I were willing to pay for marriage coaching, would
you be interested in participating?

I really don't know all that many marriage coach
professionals, just 4. Here are the ones I know:

Steve Harley, M. S.
Jennifer Harley Chalmers, PhD

The Harleys are from Marriage Builders. I had one
session with Steve Harley in 2002.


They all do phone counseling.

I did my best not 2 sound condescending in my email. The bit about the degrees is in reference 2 my W's complaint from 3 years ago or so where she characterized marriage coaching as vastly inferior 2 counseling or therapy - in spite of the fact that our MC at Kaiser was a social worker, not a therapist. But that's also why I was DJtal in my initial post on Pep's thread.

I haven't gotten a reply yet. It's possible she's busy, but I don't think she starts her class until about now. I could have that wrong, as it's the first day of the quarter.

Quote
For me, the "breaking point" would be any contact with the OM at all. That is a "Boundary Issue" with me and the consequences attached to a violation of that Boundary are dependent upon the "willfulness," if you will, of that contact. The "friendship line" was irretrievably crossed and cannot be reestablished anymore than you can put a smashed china cup back together again, no matter how much you "wish" you could.

I believe that this is the case for me as well, but as Trix made me realize, I will see when I see. But if my W is ever 2 "sign up" 2 the notion of permanent NC, it's going 2 have 2 be someone other than me 2 point that out 2 her. I've tried many times and in many ways, all 2 no avail.

Quote
A FWS who does not recognize that is in self-denial. A FWS who recognizes the hurt that the former "bad decision" caused in his/her spouse AND then seeks to justify continued contact with the co-conspirator is a FWS who does NOT understand or accept the concept of Fidelity in a marriage and sacrifice for the spouse.

I know this and so do you, but my W's very description of her concept of marriage shows dramatically that she either doesn't know it, or refuses 2 accept it. I think I know what it is, but as above, I need someone else 2 point that out 2 her besides me. If it can be done at all.

Quote
A "Spouse" is NOT single and everything they do must, voluntarily, be considered in the light of "is it good for my spouse and the marriage and not just my own wants and desires?"

As above. True, but I'm not the one who can convince her of this fact.

Quote
If you are "comfortable" with a spouse who wants to put her needs ahead of yours, especially when the OBJECT is to interact with the person who "raped" you against your will, then you have to accept the "doormat" role.

THAT does not sound like the 2Long that vigorously engaged me on many issues and I'm not even married to you.

Thank GOD! <img src="/ubbt/images/graemlins/grin.gif" alt="" /> But you're right. That ain't what I ever signed up for.

Quote
2Long, I have long said, and you know it, that CHANGE most often is the result of a CRISIS. A "crisis" is precipitated by loving confrontation when those Boundary issues are violated and when the person whose Boundary has been violated has the cajones to "just say 'no'" and says so. You cannot force a change in anyone, but no one can, or will, change unless they come to see the destructiveness of their behavior and that the behavior "is not who they want to be."

All true. Hence the offer 2 pay for coaching.

Quote
"insisted after 5 years since d-day, that they don't want 2 be married in the sense we talk about here, and that they want 2 be able 2 have friends of the opposite sex, even if that friend is their former A partner?

Like mine said 2night."


If you'll forgive me for a moment... ...playing with fire WILL get someone burned eventually if they keep insisting on putting their hand INTO the fire pit, they will not "evolve" asbestos hands in this lifetime.

Well, that was rather circuitous, but I agree with your point. Hence the offer 2 pay for coaching.

Quote
Isn't this a opportune time to actually confront, in love, just what it MEANS to be in a monogamous marriage?

Good luck.


Perhaps. And thanks.

-ol' 2long


Moderated by  Fordude 

Link Copied to Clipboard
Forum Search
Who's Online Now
0 members (), 621 guests, and 85 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Newest Members
ameliamartin, Nicholas Jason, daisyden878, Oren Velasquez, Kerniol
71,999 Registered Users
Latest Posts
Annulment reconsideration help
by Oren Velasquez - 06/16/25 08:26 PM
Roller Coaster Ride
by happyheart - 06/10/25 04:10 PM
Following Ex-Wifes Nursing Schedule?
by risoy60576 - 05/24/25 09:12 AM
Advice pls
by Steven Round - 05/24/25 06:48 AM
Forum Statistics
Forums67
Topics133,623
Posts2,323,508
Members72,000
Most Online3,224
May 9th, 2025
Building Marriages That Last A Lifetime
Copyright © 2025, Marriage Builders, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Site Navigation
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 8.0.0