I suspect that there is more to this than you know as well jwmc. I would highly recommend STD tests for both of you, just to be safe.
As to her equating her physical affairs (which is what they were, even if it were "just kissing" as she said) with your pornography problem, IMO those two things do not equate, however, I also think the issue is irrelevant as far as her infidelity is concerned.
Just because you cheated (which I don't know enough to say that I would agree that you did or did not engage in emotional infidelity) does not excuse her DEFINITE infidelity. It is true the that BS gets to set the definition of infidelity, but I suspect that her throwing the porn issue in your face is really just a symptom of typical WS behavior, blaming the BS for the state of the M and the A itself. Its a very common tactic of WS, to rewrite the marital history and blame the BS for thier infidelity.
Your previous porn problem certainly complicates things, but I think it is possible that she is simply using it to make you feel irrational and deflect responsibility from her own actions. Its a very effective tactic.
What do you think? How was the M before her As? How was it before your porn issues? How was it after your porn issues?
As to the antidepressant question: I have no idea. I personally think one should refrain from medication unless absolutely necessary, but that is a personal belief and lifestyle choice of mine and has nothing to do with what you or your W should choose. Basically, it is HER choice, not yours, and there's no way anyone here could tell you anything definitive about that from what you write here. Have her see a Dr. or a psychiatrist. They'll certainly tell her she should take something, if for no other reason than becuase its what they tend to do!
Last edited by Tyk; 12/30/07 12:47 PM.