I knew they stopped SF and were having serious problems in their marriage.
Ok so they weren't having SF.
When he needed to give in to make her happy again
Wait, WAIT! You just said they weren't having SF...but
But they WERE having SF.
However you two constructed a nice little lie to make his 'cheating' on you ok...
The lie:
I knew he didn't want to but was only trying to make things livable at home, so I accepted it as part of our situation that we'd created.
but the kernal of truth is there:
...only trying to make things livable at home...
Why would he bother trying to make things livable at home. If you were so wonderful, and things were truly so terrible at home, why did he stay? Why did he not ride off into the sunset with some he 'cared so much about'?
Because he cared about his wife too. SF with her was an intimate connection with her.
I promise you there was an emotional component as well. She was his WIFE, they share a history and a life together.
He 'cheated' on you.
He kept you around because he had the best thing possible: two women FALLING over themselves to meet ALL of his needs. He just made sure to throw them each a bone every so often to keep them around.
Why WOULDN'T he maintain this system? It's great for HIM.
You keep finding excuse after excuse for him - to prove that he really cares about you, that there was something special here.
He didn't.
And that brings me to your next lie - you keep repeating to yourself so you can not feel the pain of how TRULY you were USED.
I didn't see it as cheating because he wasn't doing it for himself. He didn't want to, but he did it out of guilt.
Doesn't matter WHY he did it. Human beings don't do something they don't want to do. He WANTED to have SF with her. Regardless of his reasons it was a choice he made. He 'cared' about you, but not enough to actually be FAITHFUL. All he cared about was himself - and so why would he reject sex with his WIFE?
He made the choice. He unzipped his pants, got into bed with her. Touched her, caressed her, made love to her, reached fulfillment with her. With his WIFE, the person he vowed to share his life with.
He cheated on you.
Think about that.
Let it sit.
This amazing man who was so wonderful, used and manipulated TWO women, emotionally toyed with them, so he could get his needs met and all the sex he wanted.
There was nothing in his acts that spoke of love for EITHER of you. In those moments, it was about HIM and what HE needs.
I was living with someone a while back - it was a rocky relationship. I went to study abroad for a summer and a male friend also was part of our group. Partying in a club one night I made a pass at him. He turned me down. We were friends and liked each other's company - but rather than get an easy lay, he cared enough about me and my relationship to say no - he got some from an unattached girl he was kinda into.
Your OM didn't care about you, or your relationship.
He said the right words to get what he wanted: his needs met.
Yeah, I can see how f**ked up that looks. Yet I was so deep in it that it looked and felt normal.
Affairs set up a false sense of intimacy. They are "safer" for those who fear intimacy, because any rejection can be viewed as a result of the situation rather than an affront to personal vulnerabilities.
It is actually in the most valued relationships that a person with a fear of intimacy has trouble being vulnerable and expressing needs.
You missed this the first time.
Read it.
Read it again.
What you are doing here is blaming the 'situation'. OM and you were truly 'intimate' it isn't his FAULT the R didn't work - it was the 'situation'. Bull -
Think about why it is you chose to have your most intimate relationship in this kind of situation - with an unavailable man....
This way, if it doesn't work out - it was circumstances beyond your control. It's not because you have a lousy picker, or because you have poor, weak boundaries... The affair is an easy out - keeps you from looking at what is broken inside of you, so that you can FIX it.
Affairs are fantasies built on lies... Ask yourself why it is that THAT is the place where you sought intimacy.
Every time you defend OM, you only make it clearer that you fear TRUE intimacy. Thats why you refuse to connect with your husband - thats why you wont give him the tools that will give him a chance.