TLB,<BR>You are in a tough spot.<P>In some ways an EA is even more of a fantasy land than a PA...the possibilities are endless and there is so little reality. This OM can be anything she dreams he can be, or anything he told her he is.<P>And since she admits to kissing, the PA was on the verge of beginning. Teenagers hardly stop at kissing.<P>So, what can you do? It sounds like you're trying the right things, Plan A, reading books, meeting her needs. I also suggest reading THE FIVE LOVE LANGUAGES by Chapman. I was able to identify that my H & I don't show love at all the same way, or receive it the same way.<P>With the counseling, I recommend going by yourself, if she won't go. She has complaints about you? Show her you are willing to change (even if you feel like you've already shown that). I went for quite awhile without my H, it helped me deal with the anger, frustration & betrayal. Then, he later joined me, and for awhile, went without me. He expressed curiousity for what I would be doing in counseling, or hearing from a counselor. And, it will help you set acceptable boundaries, even as you do Plan A.<P>We didn't use the Harleys from this site, but I've seen remarkable things from people who have.<P>Give Plan A some more time. If she isn't seeing the OM, her withdrawal should be on the wane after 5 months, and your efforts being noticed. If she is in some kind of contact, it will be very difficult to get through to her.<P>------------------<BR>Lor<BR>"A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger."<BR>(Proverbs 15:1).