LoveMess<P>You and adam are both experiencing what I went through, and it is the same with everyone that ever had an affair..I think. <P>I dont believe any of what they are saying for a couple of reasons...<P>If it were truly over *so long ago*, they would have been out by now, and surely after you finding out about the A, they had a free ticket to leave if they truly wanted it. They are trying to absolve themselves of guilt and responsibility by having you tell them it is over. They are manipulating the situation, while still in the fog, so that they can feel free to pursue the OM/OW with your permission..after all, you asked them to leave, to move on, to quit. If you do that, they have permission and the guilt is gone.<P>Another factor of this living in the past....(I haven't felt anything in years, its been over for a long time, that is why I had the affair), is that they need a reason to rationalize the affair, and it usually contains blaming you, the BS. WS are masters at manipulating and rationalizing the A as being your fault. We would never have had the affair if we were happy at home, etc. <P>I don't think he is ready to go in as much as he is looking for reasons to stay. Those reasons have to come from within him and he needs to convince himself he is worthy of being loved again. He goes to her with everything right now because a) she is safe, b) she tells him what he wants/needs to hear and c)she validates everything he feels right now. But even with all that, he hasn't left. That says something for you, no matter what he may SAY! OW is very clever, as you stated. She tells him exactly what she knows he needs to hear. She is pushing the right buttons and pulling the right strings, but you are still in control, even if you dont feel like it. Keep loving him, talking to him, showing him how important he is. Ultimately, he will make a choice, but he has to come out of the fog before he does.<P>Keep the faith!!<P>Trueheart