Marriage Builders
Posted By: MrAlias Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 03:06 PM
It's been about 20 months since I've posted on this site. I took a look around and noticed some of the veterans are still around. I hope everyone is doing well.

It's been a rough few months for me. I have a few stresses that have been making life a little disappointing. Work has been hectic and I've been working a ton of hours. I continue to struggle staying in shape due to poor eating habits and am so wiped because of working so much I don't have the energy to do much about it.

Life with my wife continues to be more of the same. Little to no sex. All kinds of reasons why and not all of them are her fault (pneumonia, bruised ribs, other ailments). The end line though is that for the last couple years even though we've had long, serious discussions about it ... not much changes.

I decided it was time to come back because I'm getting so depressed about these things that I'm struggling. It's come to the point now where I've lost interest in my wife. Sex with her is unappealing ... or better yet feels painful. I'd rather just avoid it entirely then deal with the ups and downs of hoping things are going to change and possibly get better.

I told her last August I was concerned and that I was hurting because of the lack of sexual activity and that mostly I felt hurt because there's been no acknowledgement of the infrequency. Like the big white elephant she'll avoid even discussing it and that's what hurts even though I've told her its what hurts me most.

She's done well providing other forms of affection ... but evidentally for me its the sex and the lack of acknowledgement that is the most important. She obviously heard me wrong back in August and although other attempts at communication have taken place ... well nothing's changing.

Anyways I've got my head screwed on backwards. I'm upset with most everything about her and really don't feel in love with her anymore. I fear what we all know comes from this and I don't want to go there. So far I've avoided those situations. For the first time that I can ever remember in my marriage to her I turned her down when she offered last night. It's been about 3 months since we last had sex and I just am not interested ... mind you I'm interested in sex but just not with her.

I really want to have a good marriage and I want my kids to have a good family. So I'm not ready to give up but I also find myself just not caring enough or am afraid of more hurt that I'm not doing anything about it. Even worse is I spend my time being negative and depressed about my life.

I feel bad and I know most of my problem is I'm feeling sorry for myself. But it seems to be far easier than trying to make this marriage work. Now that I've lost interest in her I can only see things getting worse instead of better.

I figured I'd stop back in at MB so all the good people here could help me find some motivation ... I guess.

I feel I've lost my way.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 03:45 PM
Hi MrAlias! If you have tried and tried to implement this program on your own to no avail, I would try using the professional services at Marriage Builders. Many of us have gone to the weekend or used the counseling services with great results. For my marriage, I only got so far doing it on my own. We went to the MB weekend in 2007 and it made a huge difference.

I can see right off that the problem in your marriage is that your wife and you are not in love. I don't know how strictly you have implemented this program, but I do know that if you cut corners on crucial things like UA time and the POJA, that you are spinning your wheels. For example, Dr Harley says his program doesn't even work if you don't spend at least 15 hours of TRUE UA time per week. In your case it needs to be 25 to 30 just to create romantic love and 15 to maintain.

It's sad to see that you have been here for years and are still in the same predicament. But I am not surprised. There are others who have used this forum - for years - to discuss specific conflicts rather than implement this program. They are in the same boat as when they arrived.

This Harley quote came to mind when I read your post:

Originally Posted by Dr Harley
"First I fix the relationship, and nine times out of ten, sexual problems disappear, with or without unresolved childhood experiences. I spend very little time fixing sexual problems these days because most couples I counsel don't have sexual problems after they have learned to follow the Policy of Joint Agreement. " here

Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 03:58 PM
Hi Melody, nice to hear from you again.

I'm one of those unfortunates who has been unsuccessful getting my spouse on board or interested in attending a MB weekend.

We did go to individual and couples counseling about 5 years ago. Things improved some from a relationship standpoint and many of those things we improved still exist today.

My hours worked are certainly problematic to my ability to follow the guidelines. It hurts that she has a hobby (horses) that take her away for me and the family as well. We do spend time together but most of that time is attending our kid's sporting activities ... which right now takes up a LOT of time.

I think I'm tired of trying to push for what I need. I told her as much last August. Informed her I was losing interest and that if I stopped asking for sex she may want to be concerned. I haven't asked for sex since that August day.

She goes on with life like nothing's wrong. So even if I ask her to take the reigns she's not motivated enough to do so.

I suspect I will soon have to tell her the whole truth of where I'm at. I just hate those conversations because in the end all of our problems are my fault or unavoidable.

I just don't seem to have the strength like I used to.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 05:10 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Hi Melody, nice to hear from you again.

I'm one of those unfortunates who has been unsuccessful getting my spouse on board or interested in attending a MB weekend.

We did go to individual and couples counseling about 5 years ago. Things improved some from a relationship standpoint and many of those things we improved still exist today.

MrAlias, this is why I am recommending counseling with Marriage Builders. Traditional marriage counseling is so destructive to marriages that I am not surprised that it did nothing to resolve your basic problem, which is a lack of romantic love. MC usually even counsels couples together which causes further erosion of love. Marriage counseling has a failure rate of 84% and marriage counselors have a higher divorce rate than the general population. They don't have the slightest idea how to save marriage. They probably addressed "communication" and did nothing to address the lack of love, which misses the point. A couple can learn to be great communicators and they still end up divorced if they are not in love.

The Harleys are completely and dramatically different. They focus on restoring the romantic love to your marriage, which fixes the sex problem. Communication is important, but it is much easier to communicate when you are in love. You didn't have trouble communicating when you were dating and in love.

Quote
She goes on with life like nothing's wrong. So even if I ask her to take the reigns she's not motivated enough to do so.

That is why I am suggesting getting counseling with Steve Harley. Let him be the motivator. He doesn't counsel couples together anyway so you don't need her participation intially. He would tell you what to say to bring her on. It is in her best interest to have a romantic marriage but if she doesn't believe that is even possible she will have no motivation to try. If she speaks to Steve, he can show her a plan that would achieve that.

Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 05:13 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
My hours worked are certainly problematic to my ability to follow the guidelines. It hurts that she has a hobby (horses) that take her away for me and the family as well. We do spend time together but most of that time is attending our kid's sporting activities ... which right now takes up a LOT of time.

This is part of the basic problem. The marriage is your last priority, so naturally it suffers. It doesn't have to be this way, MrAlias. This program really does work if you use it. But in order to work, it has to be used in its entirety. It might seem like hard work, but its really not. It is hard work to have a bad marriage. Being in love is not hard work.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 05:50 PM
Thanks for the advice Melody.

The counselor we saw was very helpful and she definitely was a proponent of the MB concepts and the 5 love languages.

What was interesting was when my wife and I were doing counseling the counselor would actually tell my wife what her role in the marriage was. She would talk to her about how she could make a difference in our marriage. And my wife would come home from those sessions and initiate.

As far as "being in love isn't hard work" ... I guess I would disagree. It is very hard to continually put yourself out there only to be hurt. To try to speak to my wife about my pain and only have it turned around on me like it's all my fault is very difficult. It makes it very hard to tell her how I truly feel. It is far easier to simply tell myself I'm going to ride it out without sex and keep the family together until their on their own. I have been telling myself now for a couple of months I'm riding it out without sex and keep the family together until the kids are on their own.

When I last posted here things weren't horrible. Manageable. I thought we were making progress. But eventually things went back to normal ... with one major difference. Once I stopped asking for sex since August every 2 to 3 months she initiates. So things are different in that respect. I always had to ask before. I know she loves me and I know she's trying but she continually tries when its far too late and I'm already back to feeling upset and disgruntled.

She asks if there's anything she can do to help me ... she knows I'm not happy. I don't even have the strength to tell her the infrequent sessions aren't enough for me. And I'm actually hurt that I have to say, yet again, the same thing I've been saying for over a dozen or so years. "Uh Hello!?!".

I'm going to fix what I know I can fix. I'm going to try to get a hold of this project at work so I'm less stressed and hopefully work less and I'm going to try to get back into shape so I feel better about myself.

Ugh ... I feel like a stubborn little brat here but I'm just so fed up with it all. I used to be able to tolerate that she was a bit of a hoarder but now I've become intolerant of that. And I no longer am concerned that she's needed to go out and find work because I'm tired of not being able to have the things I want out of life.

What does a person do when they literally believe they've just had enough and if the marriage is going to be saved its up to her to save it?
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 06:03 PM
She asks if there's anything she can do to help me ... she knows I'm not happy.

You tell her yes, she can give you a HJ every other day. And have regular lovemaking sessions with you once weekly. I would be specific on this.

And I no longer am concerned that she's needed to go out and find work because I'm tired of not being able to have the things I want out of life.

What is wrong with a woman working? I am working and my husband is out of work. Do you think I feel happy when I am working in the home office and he is in the family room watching TV? I had to put my foot down nicely and POJA this Friday.

I wrote in a notebook and showed it to him:" Do you think it is fair that I have to work while you watch TV?" He wrote:"No it is not fair" and "What do you need me to do to help you today?"

I then asked him to help me "today" and every day thereafter for the next 10 years! He has helped me every day since then.

About the sex, he wants less sex than I do. But is willing to meet my needs. So we vary the way we handle the sex problem, we have POJA'D that one. Either we have sex once weekly "no matter what" or I ask him to pleasure me whenever I want, every day if I want it...and he does not refuse.

What does a person do when they literally believe they've just had enough and if the marriage is going to be saved its up to her to save it?

If you have not POJA'd the sex issues and other issues, then you have not done enough to save the marriage..yet. If you are afraid to confront her due to her "silent treatment" or "yelling" or making you afraid she will be angry or leave you, then you are too chicken to bravely save your marriage.

You married a very manipulative,, selfish woman. That said, if you are brave enough you can be assertive and get your needs filled, learn to ALWAYS POJA things and quit letting her have WHAT SHE WANTS and NOT HAVE WHAT YOU WANT AND NEED in the marriage.

Why can she manipulate you for more kids, pets, horses, etc and she did not even have to work or care for all of these??? Are you nutz, friend?

Who would let thier wife steamroll over them and push for more and more stuff. You have relaxed your boundaries so far back that now you will have to be brave to reclaim all that lost ground and assert yourself so that she begins to have a smidgen of respect for you.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 06:12 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Thanks for the advice Melody.

The counselor we saw was very helpful and she definitely was a proponent of the MB concepts and the 5 love languages.

But the Five Love Languages does not have a plan to fall in love. This is why I am suggesting you try someone who is MB certified and knows this program and knows how to save marriages. I would use this program, MrAlias. Many of us have used this program and it has changed our marriages.

Go find the members on this board who are in love and happy. Ask them "how did you do it?" They will all tell you the same thing: they actually used this program. Don't ask those who are in bad marriages, MrAlias, they cannot help you.

Dr Harley has said that most couples that show up for his weekend program have one reluctant partner. His job is to motivate that spouse to engage. That is why I am suggesting you use Steve Harley to help you motivate your wife. Right now she has no motivation whatsoever becuase she sees no personal benefit and doesn't even believe she can be in love with you. Steve might be able to change that thinking.

Quote
As far as "being in love isn't hard work" ... I guess I would disagree. It is very hard to continually put yourself out there only to be hurt.

If you are in love, you are not being hurt when you put yourself out there, though. I am in love and it is not hard work. What you are experiencing is very hard.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 06:18 PM
p.s. MrAlias, when you have been on this forum posting for 8 years to no avail and have been unable to improve the quality of your marriage on your own, I would suggest it is time to hire a professional.[one with a successful track record]

Posters on this board are not a substitute for professional help.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 06:18 PM
Good to see you Bubbles. It's been a long time.

There isn't a whole lot of POJA in my marriage. She's not on board with the principles of this site. However she is willing to discuss and work on the marriage.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 06:23 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Good to see you Bubbles. It's been a long time.
There isn't a whole lot of POJA in my marriage. She's not on board with the principles of this site. However she is willing to discuss and work on the marriage.

POJA is almost impossible when you are not in love. I would take her willingness to work on the marriage and use this program, MrAlias. Don't start with POJA, start with falling in love. <----------------that is the problem.

My H was not on board with Marriage Builders either until he heard Dr Harley speak. Hearing Dr Harley frame his program in a way that benefited him, motivated him to get involved in the program.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 06:23 PM
Thanks Melody,

You are probably right. I have to ask myself if I want this marriage to work and if it is then I need to be more proactive in healing it. Coming here has helped some but still hasn't gotten me over the hump.

I just don't think I'm in love with her enough to even care if it's saved. I'm just way too frustrated with where I've ended up.

I would suspect she'll catch on here pretty quick ... heck I'm sure she knows already but she's just avoiding the inevitable. Maybe then she'll be ready to get on board and talk with someone.
Posted By: HerPapaBear Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 06:23 PM
Hi Mr. Alias

I agree with Melody that the coaching center would be a great benefit to you and your marriage.

I HIGHLY recommend that you call and schedule an appointment.

Ask your wife if she will join you for a few sessions, if she won't..... schedule them for yourself. You'll find some great answers to the problem you still face today!

Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 06:28 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I just don't think I'm in love with her enough to even care if it's saved. I'm just way too frustrated with where I've ended up.

And that is the point. We KNOW you are not in love. She is not in love either. The solution is to fall in love again.

Quote
Coming here has helped some but still hasn't gotten me over the hump.

Unforunately, coming here has not resolved your marriage problems. And that is understandable, because I think the veterans on this board historically spent alot of time discussing conflicts instead of implementing this program in its entirety. They used the forum for conflict resolution rather than creating romantic love.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 06:32 PM
MrAlias, for example, did you know this program does not work unless you spend 25-30 hours of undivided attention meeting the top 4 intimate emotional needs?

So all the counseling in the world would not overcome that lack.

Dr Harley refuses to even counsel a couple that won't commit to at least 15 hours of UA a week because he says "my program won't work without it."
Posted By: Viscountess Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 06:34 PM
I'm an avid horsewoman - many, many, many (Dare I say most?) horsewomen put their horse's first over their husbands. I don't know if this might be your issue. I was devoutly single when I rode professionally, got injured very badly, started dating my husband, and found I didn't have the singlemindness necessary to make it as a pro after I was married.

There's a reason why most successful, competitive horsewomen are single or divorced. It's the culture of our industry.

FWIW, I have two older horses and ride for pleasure now - I sometimes teach and sometimes feel an itch for a competition horse, but it's not worth the sacrifices to my marriage.
Posted By: gg615 Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/17/11 10:09 PM
Hi MrAlias,
Have you read Harley's thee part articles on when to call it quits? Have you tried Plan B? Your wife has been neglectful over a long period of time and it make take a more extreme measure on your part to get her to take action. I sense you really don't have it in your heart to try. Indifference is a bad place to be in any marriage.

When To Call It Quits
http://www.marriagebuilders.com/graphic/mbi8111_quit.html

Gg
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/18/11 01:04 PM
MrA, it's great to see you back; I'm sorry it's under this circumstance. Look at the bright side, you guys have your health, 3 beautiful kids, a beautiful home, work you enjoy. I'd say you two hit the jackpot smile You just have one hurdle left, a small hurdle that folks resolve every day. You're not starting from scratch; you have a lot of success to build on.

Yes, the kids' sports can get consuming. How about after this season is over, ask each kid to pick a favorite, and then figure out how to make it easier. Maybe your kids can carpool with other kids. Maybe it's something they can do as part of an afterschool program, and they can be done by 5. What do you see as the low-hanging fruit you can eliminate to make the week more fun and less stressful?

I have some great friends who were hoarders, and have had great success with freecycle.org. Folks will gladly come to your house at a time of your convenience and pick up your extra stuff, and then if you ever need it again, you can post to someone else trying to give away that thing. Or maybe your kids would have fun selling the extra stuff on ebay, who knows?

But like ML said, resolving the day-to-day stuff doesn't get you where you want to be. What do you all like to do for fun together? How about scheduling an hour or two a day this week?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/18/11 02:28 PM
Hello New,

Thanks for the feedback. I appreciate it.

I do try to look on the bright side. Trouble is when the negative items pile up sometimes it gets to be too much. Normally I can overlook the negative stuff but at times I feel overwhelmed.

Know this, I do not enjoy my job. Good news is there is a light at the end of the tunnel. The special project I'm working on comes to a close end of March and maybe then I'll get back to some semblance of normal work hours. I'm tired of working long days. Last week there were two days where I started at 6:30am and didn't get to bed until 4am ... the next day. To make matters worse I'm managing the project and we are WAY behind. So it's strikes a nerve for my pride and comfort level of retaining my position. It's quite stressful.

My beautiful home has become an eye sore to me. There is no room in the house that isn't cluttered. I've tried to stay on top of it because it's what I've wanted but working so many hours its too difficult. And now I'm so stressed when I do have a moment I simply need to veg. Don't get me wrong it isn't a hoarding nightmare but it's certainly unpleasant to see stuff lying about everywhere. I think our bedroom is the worst.

My wife has started a new part time job and has a lead on another. Bookkeeping work. If she gets this 2nd job she'll quit doing the parttime home daycare and then we're having a firesale this spring.

It is hard though. What she deems important or sentimental I consider to be trivial and could be tossed. I try to respect her judgement. When things are going OK with us then it's easier to do. When they're not then I'm afraid I become disgruntled and probably a bit petty. But I'm unhappy and to some extent feel I have a right to be upset.

As far as the sports ... well each boy is wrestling ... that's it. But it gets to be time consuming. I don't want to miss it though because its new to me and the family and I seem to be enjoying it. My 7th grader is trying it for the first time and seems to be doing OK. At any rate ... I can't ask them to pick a sport cuz they're only doing 1 sport at a time.

What do her and I like to do together? Not a lot. My wife and I like to golf together. We don't do it a lot but we do go several times. Can't golf in 4 feet of snow though. We like to go to dinner (going out Saturday) and movies. We also enjoy attending the kid's events together. My best friend and his family are there at wrestling and we've also made lots of new friends. Great people. So that's a good thing in my life right now.

Meanwhile I keep myself busy trying to finish off our basement. Maybe that can become my place of escape from the clutter ... we'll see.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/18/11 06:19 PM
Originally Posted by gg615
Hi MrAlias,
Have you read Harley's thee part articles on when to call it quits? Have you tried Plan B? Your wife has been neglectful over a long period of time and it make take a more extreme measure on your part to get her to take action. I sense you really don't have it in your heart to try. Indifference is a bad place to be in any marriage. When To Call It Quits
http://www.marriagebuilders.com/graphic/mbi8111_quit.html

Gg

Agreed. But then then my usually passive side says just the opposite. I hate the arguments or disagreements and how I inevitably feel worse coming out of our discussions. She sees things her way and me trying to convince her otherwise does no good. Why she'll twist it enough where it appears I'm not allowed to feel hurt.

She can be quite stubborn, not nasty, but just downright stubborn when she's cornered about her comfort zone. She'll tell you to your face "When someone backs me into a corner I dig in my heels". Some things are just too scary for her. She will do the same even in the face of a professional.

I've been told here she's done well to manipulate me, intentional or not. I've learned through prior experience the end result of our conversations and I come away knowing she doesn't see things the way I see them. And for me to keep pushing seems outlandish.

"I'm trying".

She is trying ... she has changed some. At the end of the day though the frequency is about the same as it always has which is unacceptable.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/18/11 06:22 PM
Originally Posted by HopefulNC
I'm an avid horsewoman - many, many, many (Dare I say most?) horsewomen put their horse's first over their husbands. I don't know if this might be your issue. I was devoutly single when I rode professionally, got injured very badly, started dating my husband, and found I didn't have the singlemindness necessary to make it as a pro after I was married.

There's a reason why most successful, competitive horsewomen are single or divorced. It's the culture of our industry.

FWIW, I have two older horses and ride for pleasure now - I sometimes teach and sometimes feel an itch for a competition horse, but it's not worth the sacrifices to my marriage.

My wife has quarter horses for pleasure. She visits them at her sister's farm during intermittent weekends. It probably averages to be slightly more than 50% of all Sundays. It's her hobby, they trail ride, and she feels she needs to get away.

Funny how the woman that wanted to have 6 kids and was angry I wouldn't give her 6 now needs ample time to get away from them and the home. I found this site when she was pressuring me to have more kids and I was opposed to the idea.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/18/11 06:35 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
MrAlias, for example, did you know this program does not work unless you spend 25-30 hours of undivided attention meeting the top 4 intimate emotional needs?

So all the counseling in the world would not overcome that lack.

Dr Harley refuses to even counsel a couple that won't commit to at least 15 hours of UA a week because he says "my program won't work without it."

I guess I have no right to come her and complain. I've long given up on many of the concepts of this site. I wasn't willing to take this to the next level which would have probably been some form of Plan B. Instead I've done the martyr thing with the caveat that I get to complain about my situation. Maybe that's my Plan B. I certainly have distanced myself from her. I rarely approach her for hugs ... she's been trying to approach me more with them. It's what I asked her to do years ago. Too little too late ... I don't know. Sometimes I don't even know what right.

It's the age old question: Do I feel justified in going to extreme measures in trying to change our lives just because I'm unhappy with the frequency?

Bubbles will call me a coward. Maybe I am. Then again maybe I fear splitting up the family. If I push too much ....
Mr. Alias,

All I have to say to you is " BUT THEN... .

I think it is time you retired this saying OK?

The MB coaching is a lot cheaper than a divorce.

Getting some anti-anxiety pills is a lot cheaper than a divorce and watching you kids as they see their family torn apart.

I don't know much about your W, but I do know she is not a mindreader and neither are you. TALK to the woman. Tell what you need and when you need it, don't make her guess and don't be mealymouthed about it.

You don't love her because you don't act loving toward her. Love is NOT A FEELING, it is an action. Take an active role, and that probably means seeing a professional that understands this sort of thing, and that would be the Harleys.

Mr.Alias, you are not close to done, but your job, your attitude, your failure to read her mind, her failure to read yours is getting in the way. Address the affects the job has had on you, your body, your mind. Start there.

Hang in there man.

JL
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/20/11 03:58 AM
She asks if there's anything she can do to help me ... she knows I'm not happy.

You tell her yes, she can give you a HJ every other day. And have regular lovemaking sessions with you once weekly. I would be specific on this.

And I no longer am concerned that she's needed to go out and find work because I'm tired of not being able to have the things I want out of life.

What is wrong with a woman working? NOTHING!

And about the sex, my H wants less sex than I do. But he knows this fact about himself and is willing to meet my needs. So we vary the way we handle the sex problem, we have POJA'D that one. Either we have sex once weekly "no matter what" or I ask him to pleasure me whenever I want, every day if I want it...and he does not refuse.

What does a person do when they literally believe they've just had enough and if the marriage is going to be saved its up to her to save it?

If you have not POJA'd the sex issues and other issues, then you have not done enough to save the marriage..yet. If you are afraid to confront her due to her "silent treatment" or "yelling" or making you afraid she will be angry or leave you, then you are too chicken to bravely save your marriage.

You have relaxed your boundaries so far back that now you will have to be brave to reclaim all that lost ground and assert yourself so that she begins to have a smidgen of respect for you.


Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/20/11 04:02 AM
Alias,

Have you asked your wife for the once weekly scheduled sex? Have you demonstrated that you are different than her and you want more sex than she does but THAT IS OK because she can fulfil that need for you in other ways like helping you out every other day with touching, kissing and her hands. Then, together with the once weekly scheduled sex, you will become pretty happy and content and other things she does will not bother you as much.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/20/11 06:22 PM
Originally Posted by Just Learning
Mr. Alias,

I don't know much about your W, but I do know she is not a mindreader and neither are you. TALK to the woman. Tell what you need and when you need it, don't make her guess and don't be mealymouthed about it.

Please I've been around that mulberry bush far too many times. I've given up doing that over and over again!!!! It's easier to give up then to continual be denied after asking over and over and over and over again. She knows what I need and I've laid it out there what my expectations are. Those expectations have been communicated to her knowingly as an acceptable compromise. Once a week when she can. 3 times a month. It takes all of about 2, 2.5 hours a month to keep me happy. She knows this. It's no secret.

I also informed her last fall that all my attempts to woe her and be the husband I need to be have made nearly no impact on the frequency. If there's an excuse to not have sex she's used it. I've done what I can to eliminate those excuses but when she says no its no. I told her back then it was up to her, that I wasn't asking for it anymore. That it is too frustrating, too painful to do it for so many years. She's initiated 3 or 4 times since August. I've asked about the same even though I said I was done doing that.

Since this work project has kicked in its only made matters worse because I'm there much less and the UA time has decreased. Understandably. I don't care. I've done my time. I've done the work. I told her exactly that last fall. It seems to have fallen on deaf albeit concerned ears. Nothing has changed in the area most concerning and disheartening to me.

Anyways I told her yesterday morning that I'm sorry but I've given up ... given up being the husband that I need to be to make her happy only to be denied what I need to be happy.

She apologized and asked if we could start fresh. I told her I would try to muster the strength to try yet again one more time but the frequency has to change immediately or I'd lose hope real fast. I actually started prior to talking to her yesterday. Started doing the things I was doing before.

JL, of course I haven't been acting loving towards her because loving her hurts too much. It has netted me plenty of negative results. I suspect she's saying the same thing right now.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/20/11 06:39 PM
Bubbles it isn't that my wife is cruel. At least not in the respect that she gives me the silent treatment or yells. She's been good about being level headed about all of this. I know your opinion of her and somethings you are close in your assessment but there are somethings about her that you may not know.

I don't want a hand job and I can assure you that isn't something she's interested in doing. Yes I've asked for exactly what I've wanted and she informs me she's trying.

There are always excuses and reasons why it doesn't happen. Most of those reasons are things I have no control over. If she says she's tired she's tired.

My wife respects me and thanks me continually for the hard work I do to maintain a roof over our heads. There is nothing wrong with her working and I'd prefer to live a life where she did work so we could afford to do more of the things we all enjoy. She's interested in staying home and doing volunteer work. However she's now doing a part-time bookkeeping job and she's really getting into it so I suspect she may be changing her stance on that.

I told her I'm tired of being broke and I wish I made more money but I've just about hit my cap on what I can make. I'm in IT and I'm on the cusp of a 6 figure salary.

I think it's great you've been able to POJA with your H. I've tried all that I think I can do to change the dynamic of our sex lives. The negotiating/brain storming ends up with her staying she'll try harder. Little to no avail so far.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/20/11 07:07 PM
"I don't want a hand job and I can assure you that isn't something she's interested in doing."

Let me say this carefully. With a woman who does not like sex, like your wife, and you cannot add this to your sexual arsenal for variety, then this is 70% of your problems.

1. This shows that you are too inflexible and static in your views of sex
2. She is not flexible in learning new things about sex
3. If you limit your sex to intercourse only, you have to be careful with birth control and it is a real hassle then when she does not feel like this kind of sex.
4. I am assuming that oral sex is completely out of the question also.


If neither one of you is interested in any kind of sexual variety, and limit things to missionary, then you are so extremely limited. No wonder you are having problems.

Let me ask some other questions:

Since very few woman orgasm by intercourse alone, does she orgasm?
Does she orgasm each and every time?
Will she let you perform oral on her?
Will she allow manual stimulation for herself?

If she is not orgasming and will not allow oral or manual to help her have sexual pleasure you got real insolvable problems here buddy. No wonder she does not want much sex if she is just an unfeeling receptacle. No wonder she submitted to sex only for procreative needs and nothing more. This explains a lot.
Bubbles raises a valid point. There a certainly a portion - we can argue how large or small - of women who are not willing to permit themselves to enjoy sex. Whether because they have been taught that sex is evil and wrong and they feel bad about themselves if they enjoy it. Or they fear that if they permit themselves to enjoy it they will not be able to resist and they will lose control of themselves. Or for whatever reason.

I have perceived the statement "women will desire sex frequently when (i) they are in love with their partner and (ii) they can rely on enjoying the experience" to imply that it is always the man's fault if the woman is not enjoying the experience. That may often be the case. Certainly there are plenty of selfish or ignorant or unskilled males. But it is not always the case.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/20/11 07:29 PM

If I were you Mr Alias, I would do 300 hours of research on this subject both to enlighten yourself and to find solutions. If you are not willing to put in this time (like I did to solve our "infrequent sex" issues) then you do not want a good marriage enough. Sure you want a good fulfilling marriage, I believe this. But you simply do not want to do what it takes to get there.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/20/11 10:48 PM
Originally Posted by Bubbles4U
"I don't want a hand job and I can assure you that isn't something she's interested in doing."

Let me say this carefully. With a woman who does not like sex, like your wife, and you cannot add this to your sexual arsenal for variety, then this is 70% of your problems.

1. This shows that you are too inflexible and static in your views of sex
2. She is not flexible in learning new things about sex
3. If you limit your sex to intercourse only, you have to be careful with birth control and it is a real hassle then when she does not feel like this kind of sex.
4. I am assuming that oral sex is completely out of the question also.


If neither one of you is interested in any kind of sexual variety, and limit things to missionary, then you are so extremely limited. No wonder you are having problems.

Let me ask some other questions:

Since very few woman orgasm by intercourse alone, does she orgasm?
Does she orgasm each and every time?
Will she let you perform oral on her?
Will she allow manual stimulation for herself?

If she is not orgasming and will not allow oral or manual to help her have sexual pleasure you got real insolvable problems here buddy. No wonder she does not want much sex if she is just an unfeeling receptacle. No wonder she submitted to sex only for procreative needs and nothing more. This explains a lot.

Sorry,

Let me clarify. I am not interested in getting just a HJ and we've talked about it she'd rather not just give me a HJ.

My wife and I do have foreplay before sexual intercourse. This typically means we use our hands to stimulate each other all over. This includes HJs.
I typically try to have her orgasm first and sometimes we try to time it so we do at the same time.
She doesn't always want to have an orgasm and so that means we jump to intercourse until I'm done.
There's been times in the past where I've initiated oral on her but she's never given me oral. She generally doesn't like the concept of oral but hasn't always stopped me when I've started. She prefers it if I don't kiss her after I've given her oral. (mild case of OCB which stems from her stupid brother sexually assaulting her when she's was young).

The sex is usually pretty darn good. Normally she's on top ... I last longer that way ... but we switch once in awhile.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/21/11 12:11 AM
I am happy that your wife can enjoy sex. In this case, it will not be as hard as I thought to increase the sexual frequency. You will still have to deal with her basic personality, which to me, seems selfish and stubborn.

Perhaps she will care enough for you that she will realize that you need once weekly sex and come thru for you instead of refusing.

Another thing we have done is if my H refuses sex for the once weekly sex sessions, due to one or more reasons, then we have made a backup plan to have sex immediately the very next day.

For example, it is Saturday night. My husband is really tired and I really dont care for sex either that night. So we agree to postpone it until Sunday. Then on Sunday we do have the sex we missed for that Saturday.

After you and the wife have agreed on once weekly sex, she does not and should not change the rules by cancelling all the time for months at a time. You need to get this "rule" corrected and immediatly try for the "very next day"> Otherwise the once weekly thing will not be effective.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/21/11 01:53 PM
MrAlias, I would implore you to focus on using this program instead of getting distracted with conflict resolution. This is not a conflict resolution program even though you wouldn't know that from some of the posts here.

Your highest priority should be to restore the love in your marriage, not get distracted with sexual frequency. Fix the love in the marriage and the sex problem will fix itself. This is not a conflict resolution program.

Originally Posted by Dr Harley
Restoring Love versus Resolving Conflicts

Before I discuss with you some of the details of a well-conceived plan to resolve conflicts and restore your love for each other, I will focus attention on the highest priority of such a plan -- restoring love.

I know of no marriage, including my own, that is free of conflict. That's because every couple is made up of two distinctly different people, with different experiences, interests and emotional predispositions. Regardless of the compatibility a couple creates in marriage, a husband and wife will always have somewhat different perspectives, and those differences will create conflict. Conflicts over money, careers, in-laws, sex, child rearing, and a host of other common marital issues are part of the experience of being married.

Some couples feel that if they could only rid themselves of certain conflicts, they would be happy together. But I've discovered that marriages can be terrific in spite of conflicts, even when some of them are never fully resolved. The difference between couples who live in marital bliss and those who regret ever having met each other is not found in whether or not they are free of conflict -- it's found in whether or not they are in love with each other.

How to Create Your Own Plan to Resolve Conflicts and Restore Love to Your Marriage

Posted By: Telly Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/21/11 04:53 PM
Hi MA!!!

Nice to "see" you, I've wondered about you. I'm sorry that things are in such a bad place.

Having your top EN neglected for so long would certainly explain why you feel in withdrawel. And I know you've tried very hard to meet your wife's EN's consistently and over time in the past.

Unfortunately, I think you've never been able to successfully POJA this issue--and it has led to the steady decline of your feelings, to the point where now you don't want to spend time with her (and vice versa).

ML wrote this:

Originally Posted by MelodyLane
MrAlias, I would implore you to focus on using this program instead of getting distracted with conflict resolution. This is not a conflict resolution program even though you wouldn't know that from some of the posts here.

Your highest priority should be to restore the love in your marriage, not get distracted with sexual frequency. Fix the love in the marriage and the sex problem will fix itself. This is not a conflict resolution program.

And yet, resolving conflict so that both people are happy (POJA) is foundational to the success of this program, and to how people ultimately feel loved. In fact, I would argue that learning how to resolve conflicts in a way that makes both people happy is the purpose of this website. The success of Dr. H's program depends on spending time together (UA PLUS resolving conflict well (POJA).

But please don't take my word for it--take Dr. Harley's!!!

From the article you linked:
Quote
The purpose of the Marriage Builders&#65454; web site is to help you to create and implement a plan to resolve your conflicts in a way that will restore and sustain your love for each other.

Quote
I also offer a Forum where you can discuss your situation with others who are [b]creating plans that resolve conflicts and restore love to their marriages.

The difference is that Harley doesn't JUST focus on resolving conflicts, as if that is a panacea... but that doing so is supposed to be part of the process of restoring love. Which is why conflicts are dealt with by POJA.

There should be nothing wrong with helping people to "resolve conflicts" as long as it is done in such a way to restore love, and as long as it's part of a plan where other things are also being done.

Quote
I found myself rejecting many popular approaches to conflict resolution because they tend to sacrifice a couple's love for each other. The way I now encourage couples to resolve their conflicts is to only use procedures that will also build their love.

Posted By: Telly Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/21/11 05:23 PM
In case this didn't come through, MA--I am so very sad for you that things continue to be hard. I really am.

My H and I are oftentimes doing MUCH BETTER, but there are still times when it is very hard for me that he is not very physical (sexually or even affectionately).

He is more attracted to me now that I look about what I did when we got married, and undoubtedly will be even MORE when I am the size I was before I met him... but I believe (and so does he) that he will never have the kind of interest in sex that I do.

He has low drive. Feeling more or less in love with me does not change that fact. He doesn't even feel motivated to have sex with me just to please me when he is really happy with me. Despite medicine to keep his testosterone levels high, he just doesn't have very much interest... He feels it is too much work, and he is too tired afterwards. When he does feel interested, it seems to have very very little to do with me.

I've been reading a lot about Low Drive/High drive spouses. So has he. It's helped some.

The reality is that some of us simply have to learn how to live in situations where one spouse (no matter how happy they are) are not interested in very much sex, or that of a great quality.

But by all means, before you arrive at the conclusion that this is the case in your situation, you should talk to Dr. H. He may be able to help you.

((((MyAlias!))))
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/21/11 06:05 PM
Originally Posted by Telly
And yet, resolving conflict so that both people are happy (POJA) is foundational to the success of this program, and to how people ultimately feel loved. In fact, I would argue that learning how to resolve conflicts in a way that makes both people happy is the purpose of this website. The success of Dr. H's program depends on spending time together (UA PLUS resolving conflict well (POJA).

But please don't take my word for it--take Dr. Harley's!!!

Telly, I agree we should take Dr Harley's word for it!! But you don't understand Marriage Builders if you believe that "POJA is the foundation of the program and how people feel loved." I assure you it is not. All the POJA in the world will not create romantic love. Conflict resolution does NOT create romantic love. Let's see what he says:

Originally Posted by Dr Harley
Before I discuss with you some of the details of a well-conceived plan to resolve conflicts and restore your love for each other, I will focus attention on the highest priority of such a plan -- restoring love.

See? The main purpose of Marriage Builders is to FALL IN LOVE, not resolve conflicts. You can be the best conflict resolver in the world, but it won't make you fall in love. It won't make you happy. It will just mean you are good at resolving conflict. And still end up divorced because you are not in love.

And again:
Quote
The difference between couples who live in marital bliss and those who regret ever having met each other is not found in whether or not they are free of conflict -- it's found in whether or not they are in love with each other.

So see, its not about resolving conflict, it's about falling in love - one of the most hidden secrets on this forum! Focusing on conflicts is a distraction from creating romantic love in one's marriage. As you can see, MrAlias is not in love.

And what is shocking is that he has been coming here for EIGHT YEARS and does not even have the slightest idea that this is the goal of MB. crazy [I guess they didn't cover that in the most widely recommended book on this forum, Dances with Anger]

What I see on this forum, Telly, are many posters who have been coming here for YEARS making endless posts about specific conflicts without ever focusing on the goal of Marriage Builders, which is to create romantic love. They think this is the conflict resolution forum. We can see the result with MRAlias and many others.

So no, the solution is not to come here and make more longwinded posts about a specific conflict, but to use this program properly so he and his wife can fall in love.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/21/11 06:21 PM
Telly, Dr Harley addresses this again in one of his newsletters. When the goal is conflict resolution, it distracts from the goal of creating romantic love.

Originally Posted by Dr Harley
The difference between my approach to saving marriages, and the approach of most other therapists, is that I focus on building romantic love (being "in love") between spouses, rather than simply focusing on conflict resolution. As it turns out, I also address conflict resolution, but I do it in a way that builds love between spouses.

Since most marital therapists fail to address the romantic love issue when they try to help couples, their approach to conflict resolution usually fails to build love, and as a result, the couples divorce, even after "resolving" some of their conflicts. here

And this is exactly what historically has happened on this forum: veteran posters fail to address the romantic love when they try help new posters so their approach to conflict resolution fails to build love. Here again, he makes it clear that the main focus should be on falling in love, not on conflict resoltion. So when a poster like MrAlias is not in love, the focus should be on creating romantic love, not getting lost in conflict resolution. That is a distraction from this program.


Originally Posted by Dr Harley
Some couples feel that if they could only rid themselves of certain conflicts, they would be happy together. But I've discovered that marriages can be terrific in spite of conflicts, even when some of them are never fully resolved. The difference between couples who live in marital bliss and those who regret ever having met each other is not found in whether or not they are free of conflict -- it's found in whether or not they are in love with each other. here

This is a very clear theme in all of his writings that seems to have been historically overlooked by most of the folks on this forum. The result is many posters who have been coming here for YEARS and their problems today are the same as their problems when they arrived. That is a tragedy.
Posted By: rprynne Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/21/11 06:41 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
So no, the solution is not to come here and make more longwinded posts about a specific conflict, but to use this program properly so he and his wife can fall in love.

Mrs. A doesn't appear to want to fall in love. She appears content to do just enough to keep Mr. A from leaving.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/21/11 06:52 PM
Originally Posted by rprynne
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
So no, the solution is not to come here and make more longwinded posts about a specific conflict, but to use this program properly so he and his wife can fall in love.

Mrs. A doesn't appear to want to fall in love. She appears content to do just enough to keep Mr. A from leaving.

How would we know this if no one has ever asked her?
Mr. A needs to decide what he wants. If he wants a happy marriage, then ML is correct. He should apply the MB system to attempt to rebuild the romantic love in his marriage. This means he should Plan A for a limited period of time. To show his wife he can meet her needs and avoid love busters. Then, if she does not respond positively, he should Plan B. To show that he is not willing to remain in an unhappy marriage where his needs are not being met.

On the other hand, he may want to remain married more than he wants that marriage to be happy. In that case, after he does Plan A for a limited period of time, he will have trouble continuing to follow MB. Because MB would counsel him to do Plan B. And even Dr. Harley admits that Plan B usually leads to divorce.

Dr. Harley suggests Plan B because his experience shows that 80% of unhappy marriages end in divorce eventually. So doing Plan B rarely changes the outcome. It just hastens reaching the same result.

Some of us do not want to hasten the result. Some of us want to remain married more than we want to be happy. Dr. Harley might well question why someone would want to remain UNhappily married. But there are those of us who do.

Mr. A needs to decide what he wants more.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 02:10 PM
Originally Posted by holdingontoit
Some of us do not want to hasten the result. Some of us want to remain married more than we want to be happy. Dr. Harley might well question why someone would want to remain UNhappily married. But there are those of us who do.

Mr. A needs to decide what he wants more.

That begs the question: why would such a person come on a marriage building website? If I don't want to alleviate my toothache, wouldn't I just stay home rather than hanging out in the dentist's waiting room spreading doom and gloom? "hey, folks, you can be like me too!! Miserable and depressed!"

Quote
Mr. A needs to decide what he wants. If he wants a happy marriage, then ML is correct. He should apply the MB system to attempt to rebuild the romantic love in his marriage. This means he should Plan A for a limited period of time. To show his wife he can meet her needs and avoid love busters. Then, if she does not respond positively, he should Plan B.

I am going to suggest that it is going to take much more than that. He has been here for YEARS, after all. When do-it-yourself doesn't work, it might be time to hire a professional. The basic issue in his marriage is one of motivation and that is something the Harley's are very good at.
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 02:39 PM
Oh man, I just mentioned the dance of Anger on markos' thread and came over and read this. I think we all agree on a lot more than what we disagree on. I 100% agree with the goal of restoring the love in the marriage, and I think it's easier, possible again, and more fun when folks stop the obvious LBs.

MrA, what are you doing differently since you've been back here? Any fun plans for the weekend? C'mon and show us how it's done smile
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 02:48 PM
Originally Posted by NewEveryDay
I think we all agree on a lot more than what we disagree on. I 100% agree with the goal of restoring the love in the marriage, and I think it's easier, possible again, and more fun when folks stop the obvious LBs.

I agree! smile Hence Dr Harley's program for eliminating lovebusters.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 02:49 PM
That begs the question: why would such a person come on a marriage building website? If I don't want to alleviate my toothache, wouldn't I just stay home rather than hanging out in the dentist's waiting room spreading doom and gloom? "hey, folks, you can be like me too!! Miserable and depressed!"

Hey Melody, this is very negative and unwelcoming. Things are not black or white in life, there are many varient shades of grey. Why should Mr Alias NOT come here to try and get help? He clearly wants to help his marriage, why are you being so militant and unwelcoming here? Aren't "AVERAGE PEOPLE" welcome on this MB board anymore?


I am going to suggest that it is going to take much more than that. He has been for for YEARS, after all. When do-it-yourself doesn't work, it might be time to hire a professional. The basic issue in his marriage is one of motivation and that is something the Harley's are very good at.

Melody, thanks for this, we agree that Harley's ideas are good ones. And this is his site for which you can push the counseling which is good I am sure. But you are starting to sound so negative yourself that you are turning people away from this site. Whatever you are going thru yourself you might want to back off on these folks trying to get some help or at least vent a little so as to have a little clearer view of thier marriages. MB helped me and I never had to go to the counseling though I purchased and read at least 3 of his books.




Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 03:08 PM
Originally Posted by Bubbles4U
[
Hey Melody, this is very negative and unwelcoming. Things are not black or white in life, there are many varient shades of grey. Why should Mr Alias NOT come here to try and get help? He clearly wants to help his marriage, why are you being so militant and unwelcoming here? Aren't "AVERAGE PEOPLE" welcome on this MB board anymore?

I agree that MrAlias wants help to save his marriage, otherwise he wouldn't be here! Which is why I asked hold why he would imagine any person would not. That is not "militant" and "unwelcoming." It is a valid question to hold's comment.

Quote
Melody, thanks for this, we agree that Harley's ideas are good ones. And this is his site for which you can push the counseling which is good I am sure. But you are starting to sound so negative yourself that you are turning people away from this site. Whatever you are going thru yourself you might want to back off on these folks trying to get some help or at least vent a little so as to have a little clearer view of thier marriages. MB helped me and I never had to go to the counseling though I purchased and read at least 3 of his books.

Bubbles, I am starting to see a very bad pattern with you. I don't think you want people to get better. You want their marriages to stay sick and crippled. Those of us here with recovered marriages used many Marriage Builders resources, such as the books, counseling services, weekend programs, etc. So doesn't it only stand to reason that we would tell someone whose marriage has not improved in EIGHT YEARS how WE did it? Isn't that what they are here for? To find out how to have a great marriage?

So, why in the world would you call it "negative" when I recommend counseling to a board member who has been here for EIGHT YEARS and still has a bad marriage? crazy Why do you condemn board members for recommending books that saved their own marriages and accuse them of trying to "sell books?" Wouldn't it be MEAN to not refer newcomers to the very services that saved our own marriages?

I can only conclude that you don't want people to get better on a board that is freely provided by Dr Harley for that very purpose. And I think that is mean... and very "negative."

Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 03:13 PM
p.s. I can't seem to remember a time when you chastised a poster for recommending the book Dances with Anger [for "selling books"], so why is your only issue with recommending Marriage Builders resources?

Can you point to a single post where you ever chastised a poster for recommending that book?

Or is it ONLY Marriage Builders books that you take issue with?

Isn't it because you don't want people to get help here? You would rather they listen to your own "expertise."
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 03:36 PM
I want people to get better and have happy marriages.
I love the Harley books. I have never ever said a single thing bad about them. I have not read "Dance of Anger" so I know nothing about it, are you reccomending I read it or something?

Why do you think I do not like the Harley books? I LOVE them. Are you nutz?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 03:43 PM
Originally Posted by Bubbles4U
I want people to get better and have happy marriages.

I don't believe that you want people to get better when you call me "negative" for telling a man who has been here for EIGHT YEARS that he needs to try the counseling. You clearly have another agenda. [maybe handjobs? sick ]

But you didn't answer my question. I want to know why it would be "negative" to tell a man whose marriage is in trouble that he should try the counseling services here. Can you answer that?

Some of your objections lead me to believe that you are under the impression that posting on this board is a substitute for professional help only because it is free. Let me disabuse you of that notion. Chatting on a forum is no substitute for professional help. You and I are unqualified to save marriages. Our best thinking screwed up our marriages. That is why I continually refer to Dr Harley. He is the professional, not me, not you. But I don't think you realize that.

You have a lot of nerve to come on Dr Harley's board as a guest and chastise board members who recommend his services. That is very disrespectful.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 03:50 PM
I love the Harley books and love the fact he is counseling people and helping them. I have never and would never think of chastising him. I chastise you a little maybe for unwittingly "turning people off" of his counseling services by your militant attitudes. Harley is great and so are the books, etc.

If you make this board seem unwelcoming, like with MA when you accused him of not wanting to save his marriage and then chastised him for being here 8 years without signing up for the counseling,, then who will want the counseling?
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 03:52 PM
"Chatting on a forum is no substitute for professional help. You and I are unqualified to save marriages."

I agree with you 100% on this fact!
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 03:55 PM
Originally Posted by Bubbles4U
I love the Harley books and love the fact he is counseling people and helping them. I have never and would never think of chastising him. I chastise you a little maybe for unwittengly "turning people off" of his counseling services by your militant attitudes. Harley is great and so are the books, etc.

Well, Bubbles, your approach turns me [and many others] off immensely, so I guess we are even. grin My goal is not to turn you on, though, but to help people have what I have: a great marriage. If you are "turned off" by that, it is your problem, not mine. smile

I would question the agenda of anyone who is "turned off" when we recommend the same services that saved our own marriages. We would be remiss if we didn't. I don't give a rip about the opinion of such people.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 03:58 PM
OK. I hear ya.
Originally Posted by Bubbles4U
I love the Harley books and love the fact he is counseling people and helping them. I have never and would never think of chastising him. I chastise you a little maybe for unwittingly "turning people off" of his counseling services by your militant attitudes. Harley is great and so are the books, etc.

If you make this board seem unwelcoming, like with MA when you accused him of not wanting to save his marriage and then chastised him for being here 8 years without signing up for the counseling,, then who will want the counseling?
Bubbles, I went back and re-read this thread and can find no post where MelodyLane is chastising Mr.A about not getting MB counseling. She is strongly urging that he avail himself of this counseling because it works.

Mr. A's wife is not in love with him. And YOU'RE telling him to direct her to give him hand jobs? doh2 That's going to help her to fall in love with him how??
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:02 PM
Again, I am not a professional. I hear ya. But it is good I probed at the problem by asking that since he answered me and now we know more about the problems and the fact it is not all because she does not enjoy sex. Narrowing down a problem is not usually such a bad thing.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:06 PM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
Mr. A's wife is not in love with him. And YOU'RE telling him to direct her to give him hand jobs? doh2 That's going to help her to fall in love with him how??

This is why it is obvious to me that Bubbles doesn't want people to get better. She has her own agenda that has nothing to do with Marriage Builders. She gives ridiculous "advice" ["hand jobs"] that has nothing to do with Marriage Builders and then attacks board members for suggesting legitimate MB resources. crazy
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:10 PM
attacks board members for suggesting legitimate MB resources

Totally untrue.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:11 PM
I am a human being. Yet I do not feel welcome here though I use the Harley books, tapes and have followed the advice in my own marriage.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:14 PM
Originally Posted by Bubbles4U
attacks board members for suggesting legitimate MB resources

Totally untrue.

Yes, you do.

And I am still awaiting your answer to my question that I have asked three times. I want to know why it would be "negative" to tell a man whose marriage is in trouble [for EIGHT YEARS] that he should try the counseling services here.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:14 PM
If I do not feel welcome here because some (possibly errant) words of advice I gave are attacked and clearly I am not allowed to give ANY advice, then more so of other posters. They will not feel welcome here either. You dont see Mr Alias coming back to post anytime soon. Just my observations...
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:15 PM
Originally Posted by Bubbles4U
I am a human being. Yet I do not feel welcome here though I use the Harley books, tapes and have followed the advice in my own marriage.

Yet you would deny that same thing to others.... crazy What kind of person does that? The books helped you but you chastise board members for recommending those same books?
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:16 PM
That begs the question: why would such a person come on a marriage building website? If I don't want to alleviate my toothache, wouldn't I just stay home rather than hanging out in the dentist's waiting room spreading doom and gloom? "hey, folks, you can be like me too!! Miserable and depressed!"

This is just so bad it set me off. There are other ways to invite a person to take advantage of some (great) counseling than this.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:19 PM
Where do I chastise members for reccomending Harley's books??? You keep saying that but it is totally untrue. Why do you continue to lie, Melody?

Let me think back....oh was that when I asked if you were employed by the Harleys or something, is that what you are referring to? If so, I was not insuLting thier very great books, I was just wondering about your employment since you are on here 24/7. In no way at no time did I not believe in the Harley books or concepts. tHEY HAVE HELPED TENS OF THOUSANDS OF FOLKS.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:20 PM
THERE IS NOTHING BAD TO SAY ABOUT HARLEY'S BOOKS AND TAPES. I LOVE, SO FAR, ALL OF THEM THAT I OWN AND HAVE READ.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:22 PM
Originally Posted by Bubbles4U
If I do not feel welcome here because some (possibly errant) words of advice I gave are attacked and clearly I am not allowed to give ANY advice, then more so of other posters. They will not feel welcome here either. You dont see Mr Alias coming back to post anytime soon. Just my observations...

Do you imagine that fellow board members feel "welcome" by you when you beat them up for recommending MB resources? Why is it ok for you to beat up people for recommending Marriage Builders on Marriage Builders?

You have been here longer than me. Do you think that makes me feel "welcome" when you do that? Do you think other board members feel free to recommend these resources when you do that?


Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:23 PM
Yet you would deny that same thing to others

Melody, there is no way I would deny the books and tapes and counseling to others. They are so good, why would i ever deny people these????????
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:24 PM
Why is it ok for you to beat up people for recommending Marriage Builders on Marriage Builders?

Had I ever done this, It would NOT be OK. I do not, however, ever do this NOR HAVE I EVER DONE THIS!.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:24 PM
Originally Posted by Bubbles4U
Yet you would deny that same thing to others

Melody, there is no way I would deny the books and tapes and counseling to others. They are so good, why would i ever deny people these????????

I ask the same question.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:25 PM
WHHHHHAAAAAATTTTTT????
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:26 PM
What are you trying to say here?
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:27 PM
I dont deny the people the books
I dont deny that the counseling is great
I dont beat up people for reccomending Marriage Builder products.
Posted By: Bubbles4U Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:29 PM
OYYYYYYE!!!!
Posted By: JustUss Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 04:49 PM
DONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

stop
Originally Posted by Bubbles4U
If I do not feel welcome here because some (possibly errant) words of advice I gave are attacked and clearly I am not allowed to give ANY advice, then more so of other posters. They will not feel welcome here either. You dont see Mr Alias coming back to post anytime soon. Just my observations...
I'd be outta here too, if someone kept hounding me to have my wife (who doesn't love me, btw) perform explicit sex acts on me in order to fall in love with me. crazy
Sorry, JustUss, I posted before I saw your post.
Posted By: JustUss Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/11 09:25 PM
Please, lets get back to helping this member with constructive advice using MarriageBuilders Concepts & Principles!

Thank you!!!!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/24/11 03:03 PM
To be quite honest I know I am in love with my wife. I truly think I'm just to the point where the one conflict in our R is causing me pain and thus I feel myself withdrawing ... worse I see myself doing the kind of BS like DJ'ing her instead of working the program.

Saying things to her like I've given up are probably just one way of making attempts to shake things up ... to do something differently because everything else, while its made my marriage a more solid marriage, still has yet to resolve comfortably the one conflict that appears to cause me the most difficulty in being married to her.

I do know I'm tired of the pain, the rejection and the lonely feeling those things bring. I'm tired of being depressed. Tired of thinking of the heaping pile of negatives in my life. Try as I can to be positive I'm wore down to the point where I'm extremely sensitive to all negative things that happen.

This weekend my wife and I spent the weekend together. We went to my son's wrestling meet on Friday (I had to work long on Thursday and had 2 hours of sleep). Saturday we cleaned the house together ... something we hadn't done in months. Saturday night we went out with friends and had a nice time... no fun afterwards as there were kids sleeping over out our place and I needed to try to catch up on sleep. Then yesterday we went clothes shopping for me before we watched our beloved Packers put it to the Bears.

Yesterday while we were shopping I needed to pick up some items from the drug store. One item in particular I know I wanted to get was protection so if we decided to have some intimacy I would need. So we're in the store and I let her know I need that item and she seems genuinely disinterested and informs me she's out of commission anyways. Sensitive me said never mind and we left the store without buying anything. Stupid as it may seem I felt hurt. Its not her fault she's out of commission but her hangups about sex seem to create a distance between us that I don't like. It makes the sex seem like its a chore for her and a task that's my problem to deal with. There just isn't that loving connection at times with it comes to the sex. It may just may be me being hyper sensitive.

Once we got home I knew I had acted hurt. So I hugged her and told her I was sorry and felt depressed because I was really looking forward to being together. She was concerned too, said she was sorry too and that we just missed it by a day. So goes the story of my life. So here I am waiting yet again.

Nearly all other parts of our marriage are better due to the help this site has provided. My wife and I are more open and honest with each other than we've ever been. If anything I still have some areas I need to keep working on that. I suspect she could too. But it's 100 times better than it was 8 years ago.

She still hugs me a lot and asks me if I'm OK a lot. She thinks of me often and tries to do Acts of Service and buy me items she knows I'll need.

She has initiated more in the last year than she ever has even though I told her that's what she'd have to do cuz I wasn't going to ask anymore. I just can't stand that there are times where I have to wait 10-12 weeks at times. I think right now its been 14 weeks. She had pneumonia and had a lot of chest pain for quite a few weeks. She's been better for about 6 weeks now.

I don't know why it feels like work having to do what it takes to create romantic love in our R. It's almost as if I feel like I have to do so much to get so little that it's not worth it. Instead of seeing it as "That's what a person does when there in love" I almost see it as if it's torture, an unfair requirement, a prerequisite to sex. I'm sure it's due to the poor return on the investment that's turned me sour on doing those things.

Hey Telly!!!! Very nice to hear from you again. It's nice to see old friends still hanging out. Ones that know the history.

I must say to everyone that I accept all feedback. To pretend there's one cut and dry method of restoring love in the marriage is probably foolish. Each couple is different and depending on the personalities and issues within the marriage the path to the restoration is going to be slightly different for everyone.

I have always respected Bubbles feedback ... she's found something that has made her marriage better and when the largest issue in the marriage is a conflict in sex I appreciate all she has to offer. And she knows I will pick and chose what I feel will work best for me even though she knows that isn't how she'd want me to go about resovling that conflict. That doesn't mean she or anyone should change what they feel they need to communicate what they feel is the best way to a better marriage.
I am told that Jennifer in particular is skilled at convincing wives that SF is a legitimate need within marriage. If your marriage is fairly good and open in other areas, then I would urge you to give the Harleys a shot at helping you overcome your LBs and helping your wife address her reluctance to be an enthusiastic sex partner.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/24/11 11:49 PM
Originally Posted by holdingontoit
I am told that Jennifer in particular is skilled at convincing wives that SF is a legitimate need within marriage. If your marriage is fairly good and open in other areas, then I would urge you to give the Harleys a shot at helping you overcome your LBs and helping your wife address her reluctance to be an enthusiastic sex partner.

Thanks for the feedback Hold.

Really, what if my wife's lack of need meeting stem from something other than a romantic love for me? Is Jennifer qualified to deal with areas outside of simple MB principals and concepts? You see my fear? My wife knows what it takes to have a great marriage, she knows that SF is a legitimate need for me and states she's trying. But when the rubber meets the road that's where she fails.

My wife has been to 4 different counselors. Unfortunately the last one we both saw who helped the most is no longer available. She was a trained professional in counseling and worked with my wife using the Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) procedure. This counselor helped with Mrs. A's OCD. She also did a great job of explaining the simple underpinnings of theories like MB which seemed to help albeit temporarily with the meeting of needs. This was helpful to me because my wife has always stated she doesn't need to follow a PLAN to improve our marriage. She said its common sense things and she doesn't need someone telling her what to do. Her response is a direct response to me trying to entice her into using the MB concepts. NOPE!

Please don't take offense Hold but I unlike you know that I could be with someone else. I'm sorry you don't see your worth and opportunity there. I know that someone else could probably make me very happy. But I also know that that isn't where I want to be if it means I have to split up the family. I realize 10 years is a long time to hold on to a marriage that's making me miserable and that's probably how long it will take before the kids are out on their own. It's probably a sentence I'm willing to endure for the sake of the kids. They are precious to me and my wife. Family is precious to me. I'm pretty sure you and I think a like in that respect.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/25/11 12:24 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
To be quite honest I know I am in love with my wife. I truly think I'm just to the point where the one conflict in our R is causing me pain and thus I feel myself withdrawing ... worse I see myself doing the kind of BS like DJ'ing her instead of working the program.

Saying things to her like I've given up are probably just one way of making attempts to shake things up ... to do something differently because everything else, while its made my marriage a more solid marriage, still has yet to resolve comfortably the one conflict that appears to cause me the most difficulty in being married to her.

I do know I'm tired of the pain, the rejection and the lonely feeling those things bring. I'm tired of being depressed. Tired of thinking of the heaping pile of negatives in my life. Try as I can to be positive I'm wore down to the point where I'm extremely sensitive to all negative things that happen.

I must say to everyone that I accept all feedback. To pretend there's one cut and dry method of restoring love in the marriage is probably foolish. Each couple is different and depending on the personalities and issues within the marriage the path to the restoration is going to be slightly different for everyone.

MA, there is one cut and dry method of restoring the love in a marriage that I know of. I don't know of any others. Do you? My husband and I are in love so I know this program works. Those of us who have used this program are in passionate, romantic marriages. We are not despressed and lonely. So while there might be other ways to fall in love, I think you have to admit that you don't know of one. And while Bubbles wants to be helpful, her personal opinion is no substitute for the tried and true principles of Marriage Builders.

So, you are in love with your wife. The issue is that she is not in love and does not meet your emotional needs. That is why I suggested using this program. I hope you decide to use it like many of us did. It transformed our marriages.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/25/11 12:33 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[quReally, what if my wife's lack of need meeting stem from something other than a romantic love for me? Is Jennifer qualified to deal with areas outside of simple MB principals and concepts? You see my fear? My wife knows what it takes to have a great marriage, she knows that SF is a legitimate need for me and states she's trying. But when the rubber meets the road that's where she fails.

MA, I don't believe that your wife's unwillingness to meet your needs stems from anything other than her lack of romantic love. If she were in love, she would have no problem making love to you, I suspect. Like Dr Harley says, he solves the other problems in the marriage [problem=not being in love] and the sex problem solves itself. As long as your wife tries to meet your needs out of a sense of obligation rather than from a real feeling of passionate love, she will always fail. Women need 2 things in order to be willing to have sex: an emotional attachment and the prospect of enjoyment. Once that is present, the sex problem dissolves.

I suspect if Dr Chalmers [who is a licensed psychologist, btw] gave your wife the test to measure romantic love, that she would fail the test.[and yes, they do test this - and keep testing until it is restored] That would be her starting point. And if she is not in love, Dr Chalmers would teach you both how to attain it.
Yup, this is truth.

Why NOT try this, nothing else seems to be working.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/25/11 05:24 PM
Originally Posted by princessmeggy
Yup, this is truth.

Why NOT try this, nothing else seems to be working.

Well before I try this I'd better due my part of getting back on the program. We go in there now and all my issues will be my fault because I haven't been doing the things necessary to create romantic love. Trouble is I just don't feel it right now. I am actually at a point in my life where I have to go through the motions until I get back to that feeling.
Posted By: MrWondering Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/25/11 05:35 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by princessmeggy
Yup, this is truth.

Why NOT try this, nothing else seems to be working.

Well before I try this I'd better due my part of getting back on the program. We go in there now and all my issues will be my fault because I haven't been doing the things necessary to create romantic love. Trouble is I just don't feel it right now. I am actually at a point in my life where I have to go through the motions until I get back to that feeling.

Well then...maybe this will be the first time you and your wife enter a program as equals...wherein both of you (instead of just her) will be expected to/asked to "go through the motions" until you both get back that "feeling".

Both of you will have to take a leap of faith.

I don't know...just a thought. The difference MAY matter. I don't typically post in these situations but I wish you luck.

Mr. W
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Well before I try this I'd better due my part of getting back on the program. We go in there now and all my issues will be my fault because I haven't been doing the things necessary to create romantic love. Trouble is I just don't feel it right now. I am actually at a point in my life where I have to go through the motions until I get back to that feeling.

I disagree. Don't wait to call the Harleys until you feel you are doing a good job of avoiding LBs and meeting ENs. Accept that you can't (won't) do that without their help. It is like the First Step in 12 step programs. Accept that you are powerless to fix this yourself, and accept the Harleys help.

Or to put it differently, don't have in the back of your mind that you want to head into MC as the "good" spouse. That you are the one implementing MB, and your spouse is the one that needs to get with the program. That is a huge DJ. Better to go in saying "unless my needs get met, I can't be enthusiastic about meeting her ENs, please help motivate both of us to do what we need to do to regain our romantic love for one another."

And suppress the "I could find someone else" thoughts unless you are prepared to Plan B and Plan D. The other person is only relevant after you divorce. For now, you are comparing your wife's reality to a fantasy hypothetical woman who lives only inside your imagination. If you aren't leaving (at least for now), banish the ghost.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/26/11 12:25 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Well before I try this I'd better due my part of getting back on the program. We go in there now and all my issues will be my fault because I haven't been doing the things necessary to create romantic love. Trouble is I just don't feel it right now. I am actually at a point in my life where I have to go through the motions until I get back to that feeling.

You should both start this together, rather than apart. You will both be going through the motions to get back that feeling. It will be easier for you to meet her needs if she meeting yours, and vice versa. But I think the most important thing is to have a plan that includes you BOTH.

Finding someone else will not resolve this problem either. If you don't know to create and maintain the romantic in this marriage, you won't in another marriage. Might as well just learn how to do it where you are at.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/26/11 12:05 PM
Thanks Hold and ML.

I'll see what I can do about asking my wife about the counseling. The money isn't there so I doubt she'll be up for it. And I don't dare throw the D word around to her to justify it because I doubt I'm getting one anytime soon.

I'll banish the ghost.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/26/11 01:00 PM
mrAlias, they won't counsel you together anyway so you don't need her there to do it. What Steve or Jennifer will do is tell you what to say to persuade her to get on the phone alone with them. But they will counsel you alone.

Good luck!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/26/11 03:28 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
mrAlias, they won't counsel you together anyway so you don't need her there to do it. What Steve or Jennifer will do is tell you what to say to persuade her to get on the phone alone with them. But they will counsel you alone.

Good luck!

So in other words they will counsel me to get back on board with the MB principles and concepts but also help me get my wife to counsel with them.

I suspect my wife will say no no matter what I or anyone says. She doesn't need anyone telling her what, if any, plan she needs to follow. She needs me to do this or that and jump up and down on one leg and solve world peace and these other things outside of our control get in the way and ...

ugggghhhhh. I dread the conversation. I dread spending yet more money only to have things put back on me. I like being accountable ... I like being a man of character. However I don't like taking all the blame or bearing the burden of it all.

Seriously I've tried all of the convos where I try to convince her we're not in love enough and that I want things to be better. She just tells me she's sorry it's not good enough and she'll try harder.

ahk. I'm sorry I'm so resistant to your suggestions. I know they are the right suggestions. I'm just having a hard time justifying carrying them out them based on past experience, coupled with freetime and financial constraints. I'd rather just crawl in a hole and pray things work out ... and if they don't. Ah well. frown
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/27/11 02:17 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Seriously I've tried all of the convos where I try to convince her we're not in love enough and that I want things to be better. She just tells me she's sorry it's not good enough and she'll try harder.

That is not what I am suggesting at all. I am suggesting you let Steve or Jennifer Harley do the selling, instead of you. What you have done is not effective. I am saying you should try something completely and dramatically different this time. If they could sell her on the merits of having a great marriage, then you could do the work yourself with the help of we forum members who have successfully used the program.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/27/11 01:12 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Seriously I've tried all of the convos where I try to convince her we're not in love enough and that I want things to be better. She just tells me she's sorry it's not good enough and she'll try harder.

That is not what I am suggesting at all. I am suggesting you let Steve or Jennifer Harley do the selling, instead of you. What you have done is not effective. I am saying you should try something completely and dramatically different this time. If they could sell her on the merits of having a great marriage, then you could do the work yourself with the help of we forum members who have successfully used the program.

And what I'm saying is she will refuse to talk with them. She will just tell me she's sorry it's not good enough and that she'll try harder. I dread the part where I'm going to have to try to convince her it's important enough to me that we should try. She'll look at me like I'm some kind of alien or idiot. Mostly she'll use the all too valid reason .... we can't afford that.

Posted By: KaylaAndy Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/27/11 01:20 PM
Sadly, I think you will find more pain in withdrawal and having your marriage decline further than you will in stepping into the conflict with your wife and dealing with this issue in a much more open and honest manner.

I've found that when I'm stretched to the limit on my patience, and I start lovebusting it gets worse.

It can always get worse.

So do the hard thing. Have it out. Lay it on the line. And get help. If that means a few months without buying lunches - instead packing it with you, I think you'll find the payoff worth it.

You can always find the money for what you value most - even on a shoestring budget.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/27/11 01:37 PM
Thanks KA,

I realize withdrawing is painful ... I've been living it for over 6 months now. It sucks.

As far as finding the money? It'll go on a card which already has way too large of a balance or I'll use part of this year's bonus to pay for it which would have gone to pay down that balance or I'll forego the physical therapy I need to help with my tendonitis and plantar fasciitis so I can use my flex spending acct. None of these look like great options to me. So I'm finding I have to balance my unhappiness alongside the health of our financial situation. Better to be a martyr then be broke. I'm hoping my wife starts to get more hours in this new job she's working and I also hope she persues another job where our neighbor works. She's put in a good word for my wife and I think the job could be her's when it opens up.

Quote
You can always find the money for what you value most - even on a shoestring budget.


Yes and I'm kind of at the point where I'm questioning just what it is I value most. Sounds kind of dramatic I know but while I've been in withdrawal all kinds of notions and ideas have floated around in my head.
Posted By: KaylaAndy Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/27/11 01:42 PM
As you're weighing things in the balance, consider the pain you're avoiding will hurt worse than you can imagine.

As you step back into the conflict and get open and honest with her, the two of you can come up with ideas to come up with the money together rather than you play martyr.

Of course, if you are getting something out of the martyr pity party, by all means continue. It's kind of a warped and twisted way to meet an emotional need for significance, isn't it?

It's a lovebuster when someone plays that card in my world and I quickly want to separate from the person doing it.

Maybe your wife is different. But it's a passive aggressive way of manipulating her. It's more likely to backfire and make things worse.

But it's your life, your world. Whatever trips your trigger.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/27/11 02:17 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
And what I'm saying is she will refuse to talk with them. She will just tell me she's sorry it's not good enough and that she'll try harder. I dread the part where I'm going to have to try to convince her it's important enough to me that we should try. She'll look at me like I'm some kind of alien or idiot. Mostly she'll use the all too valid reason .... we can't afford that.

MA, I am not asking you to try to persuade her yourself, but to let Steve or Jennifer tell you what to say to get her involved. I know Steve is very good at providing talking points that are effective in getting the reluctant spouse on the phone and then selling her on the merits of having a great marriage.

We already know you have tried to persuade her and have failed. That is why I am suggesting trying something different. You have been here for 8 years with no improvement. Try something different!!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/27/11 02:25 PM
Originally Posted by KaylaAndy
But it's a passive aggressive way of manipulating her. It's more likely to backfire and make things worse.

Oh trust me I've consider my motivations for doing what I've been doing. I'm I trying to manipulate her or protect myself from further aggravation and heartbreak? Maybe both. At the end of the day it is probably and ineffective form of a Plan B. And maybe that's where I failed ... I didn't plan. Truth is when August rolled around last year I had had enough and had already withdrawn from her. I only spoke to her about what's important and rarely had intimate conversations with her. I had stopped doing all the great things I was doing for her up to that point. It was too painful to get nothing in return. I started to focus on what I wanted and was less concerned about what she wanted. So was I being passive-aggressive??? No I think I had started down the path of where I knew I wasn't going to spend the rest of my life with her. I was planning for the day the kids were out of the house.

Once down that path she has/had every option to do what she wanted to either end the R or seek to improve it. She chose neither from what I can gather. I told her then, finally, in August that I had withdrawn and that I felt we were slipping apart. That her inability to meet my needs or even ACKNOWLEDGE the lack of meeting my needs on a regular basis was hurting me too much and I was done trying to get what I needed from it.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/27/11 02:26 PM
Thanks Melody,

I am giving your suggestions serious consideration.
To buttress KA's comment, Mrs. Hold announced today that she does not feel emotionally safe with me, so sex is off the table. I understand why. But think about it. That means she feels even less inclined toward sex than she has the last 18 years. And it means we have an even higher mountain to climb to get back together. So if you think your going into withdrawal can't make it worse, you are wrong. Your wife can become even more averse to sex than she is now.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/27/11 04:21 PM
Originally Posted by holdingontoit
To buttress KA's comment, Mrs. Hold announced today that she does not feel emotionally safe with me, so sex is off the table. I understand why. But think about it. That means she feels even less inclined toward sex than she has the last 18 years. And it means we have an even higher mountain to climb to get back together. So if you think your going into withdrawal can't make it worse, you are wrong. Your wife can become even more averse to sex than she is now.

At that point I didn't care if it made it worse. I wasn't planning on having sex with her anymore. I even turned her down a couple of weeks ago for the 1st time ever. I was done. I felt alone and depressed but had a plan to ride it out in withdrawal until I was prepared to leave. Roommates until the end. Then I came here evidentally because being in withdrawal and feeling alone isn't really where I want to be.

I've since changed my tune and am doing the things I need to to not make matters worse. Question is whether or not I trust my wife that this "start fresh" comment she made is her speaking the truth ... that things will be different. Either way I have to decide if taking this marriage back to counseling is the right thing to do.
Posted By: EasyE Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/29/11 12:21 AM
Hi Mr. Alias (and Hold, and all),
I haven't been on this site in ages, but look in from time to time. I have been in a fantastic "marriage" to a wonderful woman for quite a few years now. I use quotes because it is a marriage of our own creation, with trusts and powers of attorney, not with state license. She is ten years my junior, and she is amazing, sexy, giving, hard working, and the best friend I've ever had. I only say this as a matter of catching up with my friends here, not as a point of discussion.

I had to write because my previous marriage, the one that brought me here, was a lot like yours, in a way, and probably a lot worse. Some may remember.

What I wanted to say is that your wife will never change. She is who she is, and you have to make the decision to accept her or make a move in another direction. It really ends up being that simple.

In my previous marriage, I got really twisted up about the lack of sex, her constant unlimited spending, and the awful feeling of loneliness I had when I was with her. She would be kind and loving to everyone, while ignoring me(in my view). My ex was/is very beautiful, and she gave herself to those in need. But she never saw my needs. I was the walking wallet.

I was angry every day. Just like you, I couldn't believe she didn't see what she was doing to me. All the while, she was content with the status quo.

Looking back on it, I realize that all of that anger, resentment, and snivelling over sex got me nowhere. I was spinning my wheels. Our relationship was in a stalemate. I felt like a child, even though I'm a great guy with a great career.

The divorce was the hardest, most excruciating thing I've ever gone through.
It made me stronger, though, and really opened my eyes to how much power a woman has in a marriage. This ain't the fifties anymore.

I guess I just really feel for guys like us who have been in this situation. We do the right thing, and we ask for little, but so many times we are taken for granted. It really blows.

Mr.Alias, I would put the hopes of a wild sex life on the back burner right now. You need to heal, and get back to your confident old self. I know it's hard when you are basically living a monk's life, but there are ways. I, myself, have non-MarriageBuilder-approved philosophies about what guys like you and Hold should do, but that's just me.

The point is, you have to step back and take and get to a state of mind where you can be yourself again. Your wife definitely will not submit favorably to a snivelling, whining guy who is constantly at her to get him off. I only say this because that's probably how she sees it. She does not at all understand.

Get on top of your career (I'm a software engineer, too.) Get working out on a constant basis. Lose some weight and get looking as good as you can. This is not for your wife, but for you. Also, working out does wonders for your moods.

Get out of the house more. She's got her horse thing, so you do whatever makes you happy. Get a little more assertive in your role around the house. Don't be a whining malcontent. Women hate that.

Allow yourself to enjoy looks from other women. This is not illegal, and it gives you a nice little boost. Think about them when you have "self time". And have lots of self time!! Don't worry if your wife knows or not. This is all about you.

By the middle of this summer you could be a carefree, in-shape stud with a damn good career. Your wife will notice this, for one. It's kind of a indirect Plan A.

And one other thing, never feel like things will never get better. You can have whatever you want. It may not be an easy path to get there, but it is still true.

My rotten ex-marriage is all in the past now. That was my path. And I am smashingly, uncompromisingly, ecstatically, happy now. Every day is better than the previous one. We're in love still, even after almost eight years of being together.

I hope you pick yourself up and get to work on yourself. It could be a really good summer for you!

I'm happy to hear that your live-in arrangement is working so beautifully for you.
Originally Posted by EasyE
Hi Mr. Alias (and Hold, and all),
I haven't been on this site in ages, but look in from time to time. I have been in a fantastic "marriage" to a wonderful woman for quite a few years now. I use quotes because it is a marriage of our own creation, with trusts and powers of attorney, not with state license. She is ten years my junior, and she is amazing, sexy, giving, hard working, and the best friend I've ever had. I only say this as a matter of catching up with my friends here, not as a point of discussion.

I had to write because my previous marriage, the one that brought me here, was a lot like yours, in a way, and probably a lot worse. Some may remember.

What I wanted to say is that your wife will never change. She is who she is, and you have to make the decision to accept her or make a move in another direction. It really ends up being that simple.

In my previous marriage, I got really twisted up about the lack of sex, her constant unlimited spending, and the awful feeling of loneliness I had when I was with her. She would be kind and loving to everyone, while ignoring me(in my view). My ex was/is very beautiful, and she gave herself to those in need. But she never saw my needs. I was the walking wallet.

I was angry every day. Just like you, I couldn't believe she didn't see what she was doing to me. All the while, she was content with the status quo.

Looking back on it, I realize that all of that anger, resentment, and snivelling over sex got me nowhere. I was spinning my wheels. Our relationship was in a stalemate. I felt like a child, even though I'm a great guy with a great career.

The divorce was the hardest, most excruciating thing I've ever gone through.
It made me stronger, though, and really opened my eyes to how much power a woman has in a marriage. This ain't the fifties anymore.

I guess I just really feel for guys like us who have been in this situation. We do the right thing, and we ask for little, but so many times we are taken for granted. It really blows.

Mr.Alias, I would put the hopes of a wild sex life on the back burner right now. You need to heal, and get back to your confident old self. I know it's hard when you are basically living a monk's life, but there are ways. I, myself, have non-MarriageBuilder-approved philosophies about what guys like you and Hold should do, but that's just me.

The point is, you have to step back and take and get to a state of mind where you can be yourself again. Your wife definitely will not submit favorably to a snivelling, whining guy who is constantly at her to get him off. I only say this because that's probably how she sees it. She does not at all understand.

Get on top of your career (I'm a software engineer, too.) Get working out on a constant basis. Lose some weight and get looking as good as you can. This is not for your wife, but for you. Also, working out does wonders for your moods.

Get out of the house more. She's got her horse thing, so you do whatever makes you happy. Get a little more assertive in your role around the house. Don't be a whining malcontent. Women hate that.

Allow yourself to enjoy looks from other women. This is not illegal, and it gives you a nice little boost. Think about them when you have "self time". And have lots of self time!! Don't worry if your wife knows or not. This is all about you.

By the middle of this summer you could be a carefree, in-shape stud with a damn good career. Your wife will notice this, for one. It's kind of a indirect Plan A.

And one other thing, never feel like things will never get better. You can have whatever you want. It may not be an easy path to get there, but it is still true.

My rotten ex-marriage is all in the past now. That was my path. And I am smashingly, uncompromisingly, ecstatically, happy now. Every day is better than the previous one. We're in love still, even after almost eight years of being together.

I hope you pick yourself up and get to work on yourself. It could be a really good summer for you!

Spoken like a true renter. This "advice" sounds awful familiar and following it may help you if your goal is divorce.
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/29/11 01:32 PM
PM, if you read the When to Call It Quits newsletters, this is very close to what Ellen was advised to do, get her ducks in a row for Plan B.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/29/11 09:15 PM
Originally Posted by NewEveryDay
PM, if you read the When to Call It Quits newsletters, this is very close to what Ellen was advised to do, get her ducks in a row for Plan B.

How so?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/29/11 09:53 PM
Originally Posted by EasyE
What I wanted to say is that your wife will never change. She is who she is, and you have to make the decision to accept her or make a move in another direction. It really ends up being that simple.

EasyE, are you aware that Dr Harley turns around marriages like this all the time? Many of the men on this forum have never really used Marriage Builders, and as a result, are in the same position today as when they arrived. Some have used a little of this, a little of that, others have used non-certified Marriage Builders "coaches" [who couldn't pass certification] and because of their half measures, have availed nothing. Certainly, MB cannot force a spouse to participate against her will, but most couples that show up for the counseling or the weekend forum contain one reluctant spouse. The Harleys are often able to turn that around and motivate the reluctant spouse to participate in the marriage.

The presenting problem of lack of sexual fulfillment is not a tough issue at all. People who are in love don't have a problem meeting that need. All they have to do is actually use the program.

Quote
"First I fix the relationship, and nine times out of ten, sexual problems disappear, with or without unresolved childhood experiences. I spend very little time fixing sexual problems these days because most couples I counsel don't have sexual problems after they have learned to follow the Policy of Joint Agreement. "

here

In MrAlias's situation, he has never availed himself of the coaching or counseling services here so it is no surprise that he is in the same boat today as he was when he arrived. Some can use the free resources and books here to solve their marriage problems but when that doesn't work, they should rachet it up and get professional help.

I know so many bad marriages that were turned around on this website that it is TRAGIC to come over here and find so many who don't even know that it really works. They have given up without ever really trying. That is very sad..
ML, I have asked you politely to stop flogging me on other people's threads. I don't see why you feel the need to pound on me when I am among those suggesting MrA call the Harleys. Yet you persist. I am asking you once again to please stop.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/30/11 12:35 PM
Originally Posted by holdingontoit
ML, I have asked you politely to stop flogging me on other people's threads. I don't see why you feel the need to pound on me when I am among those suggesting MrA call the Harleys. Yet you persist. I am asking you once again to please stop.
"Flogging" you? "Pound on" you? Where has ML done this? Her post above did not mention you. Are you sure you're not "flogging" her?
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/30/11 12:52 PM
Originally Posted by EasyE
Allow yourself to enjoy looks from other women. This is not illegal, and it gives you a nice little boost. Think about them when you have "self time". And have lots of self time!! Don't worry if your wife knows or not. This is all about you.
EasyE, does your name describe your approach to marital sexual morality?

How dare you come to the site MarriageBuilders, which is dedicated to building affair-proof marriages, and where many betrayed spouses come in desperation for help, and tell someone to seek sexual thrills outside their marriage. And to describe this as being "a kind of indirect Plan A?" How dare you.

It is true that enjoying looks from other women "is not illegal". Certainly it will give most men "a nice little boost". But if you don't know, after having been on this site since 2006, and after reading the affair stories of people whose marriages have been crushed and reading Dr Harley's advice on extraordinary precautions....

If you don't know that allowing members of the opposite sex to give you "a nice little boost' because "this is all about you" is the start of wayward mentality, and that such mentality ends in the devastation of an affair...

If you don't know that your advice is tantamount to INCITEMENT to an affair, and that THIS should be illegal...

Then it's time somebody told you.

As a BW whose H allowed himself to enjoy the looks his future OW gave him, told himself that this was "not illegal" and decided that his affair was "all about him", and who went on to destroy the lives of me and our kids, I am horrified that you could be so cruel and downright stupid and lacking in foresight as to come here and post that.

You should be ashamed. I will go out on a limb and say that your views have no place on this site. Do not come here posting such filth ever again.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/30/11 03:07 PM
Originally Posted by holdingontoit
ML, I have asked you politely to stop flogging me on other people's threads. I don't see why you feel the need to pound on me when I am among those suggesting MrA call the Harleys. Yet you persist. I am asking you once again to please stop.

hold, why do you consider it flogging for me to point out the truth about why so many men on this board have not recovered their marriages? I am not trying to bust your balls, but it seems to me that is important information for others to know. If I were a man who is new to this forum, I would sure wonder why there are so many men on this board who have been here for YEARS and have not recovered their marriages.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/31/11 02:16 PM
While I know EasyE has plenty of counter-to-MB comments in his post there are plenty of points buried in his comments that ring true for me. His main point I'm taking away from his comments are ones concerning me getting myself back. This holds true because I've allowed myself to become quite depressed over my job, my health and physical conditioning and the frequency of intimacy in my marriage. He's asking that I take control of what I can. Those points are valid and I'm making efforts but it's difficult to do when I'm feeling the way I do.

I'm not interested in doing any of the things he suggests that, of course, are not MB recommended. I want my self esteem back but not at the expense of creating more damage to the marriage. No I have to either decide I want this marriage or move on. And as I've stated before I feel responsible to have my children grow up having their parents together. I've seen the ugly side of divorces and shared custody. NO THANKS.

Melody's points ring true for me. I understand that feeling of being in love and as such many of our marital problems seem to dissolve when I had that feeling. I would like that back ... but just as I am saying I'd like to try to get that back I'm afraid because I've felt enough dissapointment in the area of frequency that it's hard to stick my neck out yet again.

I am trying to move forward. I am contemplating ways I will bring up this subject to my wife. At a minimum I have to explain why I feel the need to seek further help even if its alone. I would like to do it in a way that gives her some comfort in joining.

As far as you being flogged Hold ... well I'm not sure how you feel you are somehow safeguarded from ridicule just because you ask. You've been at this site for I don't know how many years. I left for over 2 years and came back to read the same posts from you. Only now they're much worse. You've allowed yourself to become a "nothing". You feel you matter to no one and could never find someone who would appreciate you for you. That's bunk. You're a brilliant man who has a ton to offer and somewhere out there are people, not just women, who would find value in you as a person. And even if you don't believe that you should be able to find value in yourself. Co-dependency comes to mind. I believe that's the point that EasyE was trying to get across to us. I understand that point and am fortunuate enough to know I have a lot to offer and that I matter in this world.
Posted By: EasyE Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 01:11 AM
Look, I know what the Marriage Builders principles are, and I've been reading and participating on this forum for a long time.

My point is simply that even with counselling, even with Marriage Builders counselling, the stalemate that occurs when one spouse ignores the other's pleas for intimacy is a long, vicious one.

My suggestion was that since Mr. Alias is getting no response from his wife, (and yes, maybe she will change in a glacier-like timeframe), and he intends to stay in the marriage, he should pick himself up, take care of himself, work out, relieve himself, and get happy and confident so that maybe, just freaking maybe, his wife will respond to the happy, confident Mr. Alias.

And I disagree, there is NOTHING WRONG with enjoying the fact that a person of the opposite sex finds you attractive! If that were the case, my wife would be the worst person in the world, as she turns many heads.

Why even go out in public ever again?

Now I will admit that I stated that I have my own "hail mary" approach to quelling the desperation that arises in a sexless marriage, and that it is my opinion only. I have lived a forced celibacy, and it is an awful existence. Desperation takes hold on a daily basis.

Anyway, Mr. Alias, I hope you do hit the exercise regimen and get feeling good about yourself again. Get out of the rut of despair. It is a first step.

And sorry to cause a commotion on your thread.
E


Posted By: EasyE Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 01:22 AM
Oh, and one other thing Mr. Alias, The great thing about the exercise regimen is that it costs very little!

Pretty good bang for the buck!
Quote
Why even go out in public ever again?
I usually do it to get from one place to another.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 01:32 AM
Originally Posted by EasyE
My suggestion was that since Mr. Alias is getting no response from his wife, (and yes, maybe she will change in a glacier-like timeframe), and he intends to stay in the marriage, he should pick himself up, take care of himself, work out, relieve himself, and get happy and confident so that maybe, just freaking maybe, his wife will respond to the happy, confident Mr. Alias.

And I disagree, there is NOTHING WRONG with enjoying the fact that a person of the opposite sex finds you attractive! If that were the case, my wife would be the worst person in the world, as she turns many heads.
Oh good grief; are you still telling him to masturbate?

You suggested more than "enjoying the fact that a person of the opposite sex finds you attractive". Don't try to minimise what you said:

Originally Posted by EasyE
Allow yourself to enjoy looks from other women. This is not illegal, and it gives you a nice little boost. Think about them when you have "self time". And have lots of self time!! Don't worry if your wife knows or not. This is all about you.

To decode: "Masturbate and think about other, attractive women. Do this a lot."

Eew. Don't take up this pervy suggestion, Alias. You are a much better man than that.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 01:37 AM
Originally Posted by EasyE
My point is simply that even with counselling, even with Marriage Builders counselling, the stalemate that occurs when one spouse ignores the other's pleas for intimacy is a long, vicious one.

But.......he hasn't tried Marriage Builders counseling. I think one should try that before they give up. Many can do it yourself with a couple of books and the workbook, but when that doesn't work, it is time to try a professional, IMO.

If that doesn't work, I am a big advocate of Plan B, just as Dr Harley prescribes. When a spouse refuses to meet your needs, sometimes separation or even divorce is the definition of success.
Posted By: EasyE Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 01:53 AM
Ok, well, Sugarcane...you go, girl!
The day a man who gets no sex in his life is also cajoled to not masturbate, then that's the day that man is going to totally give up.

Period.

Posted By: Tom2010 Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 01:56 AM
Happened to want to see if Ms. Writer posted lately, and then I saw your **edit**!

Good grief **edit**, do you love to take advantage of someone who is not only down, but not trying in his marriage?? From someone who has been married for 42 years, and yeah we have the 'piece of paper', **edit** and yes, I will be surprised if you have your currnet relationship in a mere two years from now! Go back and read Sugar Cane's post to you.

**edit**
Tom
Posted By: EasyE Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 02:01 AM
Wait, WHAT?

Mr. Alias is NOT WORKING ON HIS MARRIAGE? I can't wait to see what he says about that.

Posted By: Tom2010 Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 02:01 AM
Marriage is a sacrad instituion. Because YOU have failed in your marriage, and are not settling for a perverted glass 1/4 full, please do not advise this person to entertain looks to 'get a boost'. That is an insult to me, it seems to be an insult to the many people on here who are dedicated and moral, and it makes you look like the fool you are!
Posted By: EasyE Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 02:05 AM
Tom, or anyone, if you want to take a swipe at my morals, then take it off this thread.

Your self righteous indignation is not helping anything.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 02:06 AM
Originally Posted by EasyE
Tom, or anyone, if you want to take a swipe at my morals, then take it off this thread.
Not while you post them on this thread, Easy.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 02:11 PM
Originally Posted by EasyE
Wait, WHAT?

Mr. Alias is NOT WORKING ON HIS MARRIAGE? I can't wait to see what he says about that.

After trying the books and exercises taught here for years I slowly gave up. By last August when I confessed to my wife about my, yet again, disappointment I no longer had nor cared to have the strength to keep trying. I figured if she wanted to be married it was time she stepped up and showed some initiative. Why I even told her last August the thing that bothered me the most was the ignoring of the frequency situation all the time. If it's been weeks there was never any indication that she was concerned or even thinking about the fact that my needs weren't being met. I told her I would feel better if she acknowledged that. She hasn't. However she has really stepped up the other forms of physical touch by providing plenty of hugs and I love yous and even some affirmations. So in some ways she's been better but this frequency thing has really got me down.

As of last week I am trying again ... just the fact I'm here looking for direction (and have gotten good advice) means I'm trying again. Right now it certainly is a "fake it til I make it" attempt ... some of those old feelings aren't there and haven't returned and probably won't until I see results from her comment about a fresh start. If that fails, which I'm pretty sure it will, I'll have to hire on someone else to see if they can help.

I have started a small routine of working out. Right now I'm just riding the exercise bike (planter fascitiis for years now so I can't run). Doing small exercises for my core. I hope to hit the home gym soon but I'm a little wary about my golfer's elbow. I've never really been able to 100% heal from that tendonitis. I'm going to start going back to Active Release Technique therapy which helps both of those tendonitis issues. Also I'm taking vitamins and minerals that are supposed to help with those issues.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 02:14 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by EasyE
My point is simply that even with counselling, even with Marriage Builders counselling, the stalemate that occurs when one spouse ignores the other's pleas for intimacy is a long, vicious one.

But.......he hasn't tried Marriage Builders counseling. I think one should try that before they give up. Many can do it yourself with a couple of books and the workbook, but when that doesn't work, it is time to try a professional, IMO.

If that doesn't work, I am a big advocate of Plan B, just as Dr Harley prescribes. When a spouse refuses to meet your needs, sometimes separation or even divorce is the definition of success.

I agree Melody. Don't lose hope. I suspect it will come down to me having to call on the professionals. Just give me some time.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 02:25 PM
Quote
To decode: "Masturbate and think about other, attractive women. Do this a lot."

Eew. Don't take up this pervy suggestion, Alias. You are a much better man than that.


Geez I fear to even answer this seeing my character as a man will be in question.

I have always had "self time" during our marriage. The physical ramifications of not having this means I'm constantly reminded by my hormones that "Hey you're not getting any.".

It used to be most times she'd be the one I'd visualize and fantisize about. Even if it's been 3+ months (which is where we're at today). Good God I can remember after our 1 son was born it was 13 months. But once I lost the strength ... well ... she's not the one anymore.

Anyways having self time is somewhat self medicating and keeps me from having a mind that is running rampid making bad decisions.
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I suspect it will come down to me having to call on the professionals.

You are lying to yourself. You know you can't fix this without help. Either tell us you aren't interested in fixing it. Or hire the Harleys. But don't tell us you want to fix it and think you can make it work yourself. Time for Radical Honesty.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 03:36 PM
Originally Posted by holdingontoit
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I suspect it will come down to me having to call on the professionals.

You are lying to yourself. You know you can't fix this without help. Either tell us you aren't interested in fixing it. Or hire the Harleys. But don't tell us you want to fix it and think you can make it work yourself. Time for Radical Honesty.

No I'm not. It's out of my control and it's up to her. I'm just giving her a chance. I spoke about the frequency and she said let's start fresh.

However I'm not kidding myself. Based on past experience I'm quite certain she will fall short yet again. I've said that several times now. And when that happens I will inform her of the next step I'm going to take. She can get on board with the plan if she wants to.

Meanwhile I'm going to get myself back.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 03:50 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
No I'm not. It's out of my control and it's up to her. I'm just giving her a chance. I spoke about the frequency and she said let's start fresh.

However I'm not kidding myself. Based on past experience I'm quite certain she will fall short yet again. I've said that several times now. And when that happens I will inform her of the next step I'm going to take. She can get on board with the plan if she wants to.

Meanwhile I'm going to get myself back.

There is no plan here. Having no plan is a plan to fail. Just nagging her about the frequency does not resolve the basic problem that causes the lack of frequency: she is not in love. MrAlias, you are spinning your wheels, my good friend.
Posted By: rprynne Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 03:57 PM
Mr. A,

Feel free to disregard this, but I'll share some of my thoughts, since I think I have been in a similar situation.

By all means I think the counseling would be benficial. However, I can say my wife and I did the counseling and it did not help much. I don't blame the counseling or the process, it's just simply counseling will not help a person who does not think they need help. MC or IC does great for people who say their life is terrible and need help to fix it. It's not so effective for the person who says "my life is great, I just don't understand why everyone is so upset with me."

I did not do the MB weekend, so I can't speak to whether that is more effective or not.

My wife for a long time did as you describe and consistently promised to make changes, etc, but then ultimately did not deliver. IMO, some people are motivated by seeking something better, something they want, while others are motivated by protecting what they have. I think this creates very different dynamics. The former tends take actions that improve things, while the later tends to do just enough to keep things going along. I think this has a lot to do with whether using MB was successful. Since my wife tends to be in the later group, she did not "buy" what MB was "selling." I don't mean that she didn't think it would work, I mean she did not want what it was offering. This is why I posted earlier that I didn't think MrsA wanted to be "in love."

I don't know the right answer to deal with this. Some will say, well, the spouses just want different things and all you can do is part ways. But this is not a great option if you really don't want to divorce. Plus, as you may have experienced, once one proposes divorce, the non "on board" spouse starts to up their efforts and promises, until divorce is taken off the table. But once that storm passes, they revert to old ways again. This is what a mean about protecting against losses.

This is really depressing stuff, as you can begin to feel like you do your part, and the only way you can get your needs met, is to play the D card. Not very romantic, and ultimately it becomes obvious that it isn't sustainable, because, well, you can only "bluff" the D card, so many times.

Generally, the next reaction is to try and even the tables. Start withholding what you provide in order to make it fair. However, this just starts a downward spiral, and gives the non "on board" spouse more reason to under deliver.

I found a couple of things to help me work through this. First off, I think you have to not look at things as either/or, but both. Meaning, you will do the things neccessary to improve your M, but will also keep progressing on things that are best for you. As an example, I got out of the "marriage building" business. This doesn't mean I don't meet EN's, don't avoid LB's, refuse to listen to my wife's feedback, etc., but it also means I'm not "leading" the make our M better effort, as that just depresses me.

I stay honest with my wife. I'm not manipulating her and I'm not hiding things from her. As an example, I have told her that I think the MB weekend or something like that could really help, but I'm not setting it up. Basically, if she wants our M to be like I want our M to be, then I'm all for it, but I'm not dragging her along kicking and screaming. I've told her that if our M is not how I'd like it to be, then I will leave her. But, I have no pressing reason to do that today. I may have that reason tommorrow, or the next day, but I don't really know.

Not being in the marriage building business has greatly reduced my stress and freed up a lot of time. Both of which allow me to focus on myself. Getting in better physical health, doing what I want to do, rebuilding my career, etc. Plus, frankly, I feel more like a man, as I never felt right having to bring up relationship talk all the time.

I figure 1 of 3 things will happen. My wife will one day potentially want more out of our M than what it is now and will seek out ways to improve it. If that happens, before it's too late, then I will certainly participate. Or, my wife may never change, and eventually my marriage will be a "limitation" on what I want to do and I will move on. Or something in the middle may happen, where some changes happen, but my M is not as fulfilling as I would like it to be, but it is not a limitation on my overall life being fulfilling. In which case, I would be fine.

Anyway, wish you the best.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 03:59 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I have always had "self time" during our marriage. The physical ramifications of not having this means I'm constantly reminded by my hormones that "Hey you're not getting any.".

That should drive you to find a solution to the problem that makes you both happy.
If your next step is moving out, then you might as well call the Harleys. A few sessions with them won't cost any more than the security deposit on the apartment you'll need. And they might actually get your wife to POJA with you (which is apparently the result you want).

The key is whether you are willing to do the work to reconnect with her. Not a given. I am not. If you are, then hire the Harleys to maximize the chance she will get on board. If you are not, then don't pretend you have moved out of Withdrawal.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 04:34 PM
Originally Posted by holdingontoit
If your next step is moving out, then you might as well call the Harleys. A few sessions with them won't cost any more than the security deposit on the apartment you'll need. And they might actually get your wife to POJA with you (which is apparently the result you want).

The key is whether you are willing to do the work to reconnect with her. Not a given. I am not. If you are, then hire the Harleys to maximize the chance she will get on board. If you are not, then don't pretend you have moved out of Withdrawal.

Hold I don't know what you've been reading. I never said my next step was to move out. I even went as far earlier to say that I would probably hang around until the kids were gone.

I never said I had moved out of withdrawal I just said I was going to get back with the program. I said I was doing the "fake it til I make it" method because those feelings aren't there right now.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 04:46 PM
Originally Posted by rprynne
By all means I think the counseling would be benficial. However, I can say my wife and I did the counseling and it did not help much. I don't blame the counseling or the process, it's just simply counseling will not help a person who does not think they need help. MC or IC does great for people who say their life is terrible and need help to fix it. It's not so effective for the person who says "my life is great, I just don't understand why everyone is so upset with me."

MrAlias, while the counseling did not work for rprynne, I can point to numerous other couples whose marriages were turned around by it. There are no guarantees, but the Harleys are COACHES, rather than counslors, who view their main goal as motivating couples to get on board. Most couples who show up for help have at least one reluctant spouse, and they are often successful in motivating that person to engage.

Please seek out those who HAVE resolved their marriage problems and ask them how they did it. You already know how to fail, so you don't need more direction on that.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 04:51 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
No I'm not. It's out of my control and it's up to her. I'm just giving her a chance. I spoke about the frequency and she said let's start fresh.

However I'm not kidding myself. Based on past experience I'm quite certain she will fall short yet again. I've said that several times now. And when that happens I will inform her of the next step I'm going to take. She can get on board with the plan if she wants to.

Meanwhile I'm going to get myself back.

There is no plan here. Having no plan is a plan to fail. Just nagging her about the frequency does not resolve the basic problem that causes the lack of frequency: she is not in love. MrAlias, you are spinning your wheels, my good friend.

I think you're wrong. If you were to ask my wife I think she would tell you she's deeply in love with me. I can see it. She tries hard to fill all the other needs. She just isn't good at filling this one.

She also would probably tell you as she's told me when she doesn't get out of life what she wants ... "You aren't getting what you need? ... tough ... suck it up. That's life.". That's how she was raised. I can only assume that's how she views my needs.

And as far as a plan is concerned ... well if the only plan is your plan then NO I have no plan. If I'm allowed to go at my pace and decide when I'm ready to begin counseling again or withdrawing again then you can call that my plan. I'm sorry it doesn't fit within your requirement.

I hesitate because I belive it is as rypenne says ... when they're being pushed things change ... but given time and the pushing stops ... they go back to what is comfortable. My wife was great when we were in counseling. We worked on a lot and we improved lots of aspects of our R. Things seemed to be going well. We moved on and eventually the frequency just backslide right back to where we were. There is always a reason we can't do it. My wife could write a book I tell ya (sorry for the DJ but I'm sick of the excuses). So given my wife would tell you she's in love with me ... I'm hoping there is more in store from the Harleys then just trying to regain what my wife would tell you she never lost?

I would like to get back that "in-love" feeling. I really would. But I hate to think I'm going to spend a ton of dough only to wind up right back in the same place in a few years.

My wife and I know the concepts. We've taken the surveys. We talk occassionally about where we are at and whether or not we're happy. Lately she hasn't asked because she knows the answer. We make mutual decisions about things that are of importance. It isn't a formalized method but we do it our way and it works.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 05:17 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
And as far as a plan is concerned ... well if the only plan is your plan then NO I have no plan. If I'm allowed to go at my pace and decide when I'm ready to begin counseling again or withdrawing again then you can call that my plan. I'm sorry it doesn't fit within your requirement.

MrAlias, of course you can go at your own pace. I don't have any "requirements." crazy I am only pointing out that there is no plan here. And when there is no plan, that is a plan to fail.

Quote
My wife and I know the concepts. We've taken the surveys. We talk occassionally about where we are at and whether or not we're happy. Lately she hasn't asked because she knows the answer. We make mutual decisions about things that are of importance. It isn't a formalized method but we do it our way and it works.

Ok, but that has not resolved your problems, has it?
MrA, if your plan is to coach with the Harleys if (when?) waiting doesn't work, then I suggest you skip the waiting and call the Harleys. But it is your choice. You are entitled to choose to remian unhappy. I have exercised that choice, and while I advise against it, I understand everyone has the right to be as foolish as I am.
Posted By: rprynne Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 07:08 PM
It gets a little "cultish" around here.

I think the MB coaching is very good and I have not come across a better model out there. If it is something you want to do, then I would not let the money hold you up.

I don't face the same singular issue that you are facing, but I do see similarities to my situation in the "cycle" that you are dealing with.

I took some time away from here and made a lot of progress. I'm not unhappy with my M and consider my marriage problems resolved. But I am also not bouncing off the walls with joy about my M. (I suppose some will claim that means nothing is resolved, but I don't buy that view).

I wish the coaching with the Harley's would happen for you, but I'm not sure you don't shoot yourself in the foot if you set it up. I think even if you pushed for it, your wife would give in for the purpose of appeasing you as opposed to for the purpose of marriage building. I don't think that works out very well.

If it were me, I would approach it by expressing your feelings (without coming across as whiny or nagging) and let her propose a solution. And then critically review that solution for loopholes. i.e. ask her what she expects you to do when/if she does not deliver on her committments.

While some will say this is attacking the symptom, rather than the problem (being in love), I think a few rounds of this will either work, or if it fails, it might give her an opportunity to conclude on her own that professional help is needed.

Originally Posted by MrAlias
I think you're wrong. If you were to ask my wife I think she would tell you she's deeply in love with me. I can see it. She tries hard to fill all the other needs. She just isn't good at filling this one.

By the way, I have a hard time with this logic. Did she never meet this need? If she did, then barring physical or mental issues, it seems difficult to conclude she is deeply in love with you and won't meet the need for SF.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 07:27 PM
Originally Posted by rprynne
It gets a little "cultish" around here.

I think you might be confusing enthusiasm for Marriage Builders with being "cultish." And I can understand why you would see it that way, since you have not really recovered* your own marriage. It sounds to me like nothing has really changed except you have simply lowered your standards. [*recovery as defined by MB] "cultish" is defined as:

�noun
1. a particular system of religious worship, esp. with reference to its rites and ceremonies.

The only one I worship is God. However, I am enthusiastic about a program that has brought passion and joy to my own marriage. It has changed my quality of life. So of course, I would be passionate about such a program and hope that others could attain the same thing. I want the same thing for others. Promoting Marriage Builders on this forum is not cultish. That is ludicrous.

Quote
I wish the coaching with the Harley's would happen for you, but I'm not sure you don't shoot yourself in the foot if you set it up. I think even if you pushed for it, your wife would give in for the purpose of appeasing you as opposed to for the purpose of marriage building. I don't think that works out very well.

If it were me, I would approach it by expressing your feelings (without coming across as whiny or nagging) and let her propose a solution. And then critically review that solution for loopholes. i.e. ask her what she expects you to do when/if she does not deliver on her committments.

But, since she doesn't have solutions, that seems to be an ineffective tactic? A better tactic, IMO, would be to do what others have done here and set up an appointment with Steve Harley and let HIM coach the presenting spouse on how to persuade his wife to get on the phone. Then once the reluctant spouse is on the phone, Steve Harley can persuade her to do the program.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 07:43 PM
Originally Posted by rprynne
Did she never meet this need? If she did, then barring physical or mental issues, it seems difficult to conclude she is deeply in love with you and won't meet the need for SF.

She has always been this way. It's better now then it was about 5 or 6 years ago but it's still way too little. Heck my compromise was once a week when its possible. I thought I could live with that. Up to this point I have no idea if I could because it has seldom happened.

Again I believe she is in love with me. Her theory is you can't always have everything you want. Get over it. However she has never voiced my issue in this way so I could be DJ'ing her big time.


Has she said she's in love with you? You keep saying you believe she is. This is an assumption.
Posted By: rprynne Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 08:01 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
I think you might be confusing enthusiasm for Marriage Builders with being "cultish." And I can understand why you would see it that way, since you have not really recovered* your own marriage. It sounds to me like nothing has really changed except you have simply lowered your standards. [*recovery as defined by MB] "cultish" is defined as:

�noun
1. a particular system of religious worship, esp. with reference to its rites and ceremonies.

The only one I worship is God. However, I am enthusiastic about a program that has brought passion and joy to my own marriage. It has changed my quality of life. So of course, I would be passionate about such a program and hope that others could attain the same thing. I want the same thing for others. Promoting Marriage Builders on this forum is not cultish. That is ludicrous.

Always wanting to argue. Would dogmatic have been more palitable?

The enthusiasm is great, but do you even read what people post anymore before you respond with the answer? Or does nothing else matter, MB will solve it? There is only one solution and it is MB, is that the point?

I'm getting the feeling that even in a post where someone espouses and encourages MB, you seek out the one sentence that does not fit with what you want everyone to hear and then try and shout it down. And if you don't have good logic you're more than happy to tell them they are a failure who has lowered their standards. Hopefully I'm wrong about that feeling.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 08:12 PM
Originally Posted by rprynne
Always wanting to argue. Would dogmatic have been more palitable?

Do you not understand that accusing people of being "cultish" or even "dogmatic" is insulting? When you insult someone and attempt to dismiss them you invite argument. I take issue with being branded as "cultish." How dare you.

Quote
The enthusiasm is great, but do you even read what people post anymore before you respond with the answer? Or does nothing else matter, MB will solve it? There is only one solution and it is MB, is that the point?

Yes, that is what we are here to discuss, isn't it? Did you see the sign on the door? Marriage Builders very probably can solve his problem.

Quote
And if you don't have good logic you're more than happy to tell them they are a failure who has lowered their standards. Hopefully I'm wrong about that feeling.

Isn't it logical to point out that your own suggestions have not worked for you? You proclaim yourself "in recovery" and then qualify that with "I'm not unhappy with my M and consider my marriage problems resolved. But I am also not bouncing off the walls with joy about my M." "I'm not unhappy" is not defined as recovered by MB standards. That is your standard.

That sounds to me like you have simply lowered your standards. I think its important to ask if this approach has worked for you.
Posted By: rprynne Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 08:12 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She has always been this way. It's better now then it was about 5 or 6 years ago but it's still way too little. Heck my compromise was once a week when its possible. I thought I could live with that. Up to this point I have no idea if I could because it has seldom happened.

I'm confused. So even when you were dating, the SF was low frequency? If so, I'm not sure the "falling in love" is going to solve the issue.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 08:17 PM
Originally Posted by kilted_thrower
Has she said she's in love with you? You keep saying you believe she is. This is an assumption.

I agree with this. Her actions don't bespeak someone who is in romantic love. I think people sometimes confuse caring love with romantic love and I wonder if that is not the case here.
Posted By: rprynne Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 08:24 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Do you not understand that accusing people of being "cultish" or even "dogmatic" is insulting? When you insult someone and attempt to dismiss them you invite argument. I take issue with being branded as "cultish." How dare you.

I apologize.

Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Yes, that is what we are here to discuss, isn't it? Did you see the sign on the door?

Perhaps you and I differ in our intrepretation of the sign on the door.

Quote
This forum is open not only to those who have questions, but also to those with comments or suggestions. So we recommend that all participants of the discussion forum be familiar with Dr. Harley's Basic Concepts. However, the advice given is NOT to be construed as professional advice, nor is it even endorsed by Marriage Builders, unless Dr. Harley is specifically named as the responder. It's available to you as an opportunity to explore other people's opinions as they relate to your problem.

I believe I am familiar with the concepts and am in good faith allowing people the opportunity to explore other people's opinions as they relate to their problem.

If their is a sign on the door that says my opinions must be limited to encouraging strict adherence to MB, then I must have missed it.

Originally Posted by MelodyLane
That sounds to me like you have simply lowered your standards. I think its important to ask if this approach has worked for you.

I find this to be insulting. How dare you.

My approach has worked quite well for me.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 08:33 PM
Originally Posted by rprynne
I believe I am familiar with the concepts and am in good faith allowing people the opportunity to explore other people's opinions as they relate to their problem.

If their is a sign on the door that says my opinions must be limited to encouraging strict adherence to MB, then I must have missed it.

You must have apparently. One of the reasons this man's marriage is such a wreck after coming to this forum for 8 years is because posters were not sticking to Marriage Builders concepts. They were all yapping about their own personal opinions to the detriment of those who were seeking help. And unfortunately, their best thinking screwed up their own marriages.

So, you do this man a great disservice by suggesting we don't stick to MB around here.

Substituting our own personal opinions for MB is addressed in the Announcements Section:
Quote
This announcement is to clarify our policy about the discussion of other marriage books and programs on our forum. Such discussion is acceptable, except on the threads of those seeking help for their marriages. Offering alternative methods to those in need promises to confuse and discourage them, often leading to unnecessary debates. Posters attempting to help should not be put in the position of having to debate basic principles. That is not helpful to anyone, most especially the poster in need.

In other words, we need to be sticking to the program on this thread.

Quote
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
That sounds to me like you have simply lowered your standards. I think its important to ask if this approach has worked for you.

I find this to be insulting. How dare you.

My approach has worked quite well for me.

If there is nothing wrong with your standard of simply "not being unhappy" then what is the issue with pointing that out? That is not the same standard that MB sets so I can't imagine why it would be an issue to point that out.
Posted By: EasyE Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 08:36 PM
Mr. Alias has stated that his wife is very loving, demonstrative in other ways, and an overall great partner.

For whatever reason, though,sex just isn't on her agenda. Maybe, as an example, it ranks to her as shopping for a purse ranks to a man. I wouldn't want to shop for a purse every week, let alone every month.

And even if I POJA'd to shop for a purse with my wife every month, instead of every week like she really wants, I would get a little panicky, imagining all of the months ahead in life that I need to do this thing that I really don't feel like doing.

Such is the stalemate that occurs.

I make decent money, but I would be absolutely terrified if my wife said it wasn't enough to satisfy her anymore, and she really requires more financial support.




Posted By: MBsurvivor Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 08:37 PM
I am going to caution posters to keep your posts productive and helpful to the OP. If you can help this poster with Marriage Builders concepts, we encourage your assistance. If not, then please refrain from posting! The purpose of this forum is to discuss Marriage Builders.

Any questions, shoot me an email. Thank you.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 08:48 PM
Originally Posted by EasyE
And even if I POJA'd to shop for a purse with my wife every month, instead of every week like she really wants, I would get a little panicky, imagining all of the months ahead in life that I need to do this thing that I really don't feel like doing.

That is not POJA, though. What you describe is compromise, which is bad for marriage. Agreeing to do something you find unpleasant is not a solution, it is a death sentence. Because most spouses will not do something they don't like for long. And the longer they do it, the more resentment is created. That is how incompatibility is created.

This is why enthusiasism is a critical component of POJA. It is critical. We can always wrest grudging agreements from our spouses but it will always blow up in our face. A grudging agreement is worse than no agreement.

The solution is to find a way to meet his needs that she finds PLEASANT. Women need 2 things to enjoy sex: an emotional attachment and the prospect of enjoyment. It might be that she is not in love with him [which is what I sort of suspect even though he feels otherwise] and/or does not enjoy the way he makes love. If one or more of those elements are present, then she won't want to make love to him.

And if she is the kind who does not practice radical honesty, he might never get to the bottom of the problem unless they use this program and she learns to practice radical honesty.
Posted By: HoldHerHand Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 08:58 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
My wife and I know the concepts. We've taken the surveys. We talk occassionally about where we are at and whether or not we're happy. Lately she hasn't asked because she knows the answer. We make mutual decisions about things that are of importance. It isn't a formalized method but we do it our way and it works.


Honest question; when is the last time you did the questionnaires?

I simply ask because of this; over time, you may find that your needs, and how you like them to be met, change. Sometimes, you won't even notice it.

Your top need 6 months ago may not be your top need now. Furthermore, the needs that are best met at any given time, because they are met properly, may suddenly not rank as high as those being met poorly, or not at all.

A simple review of your EN's and LB's is a great place to begin, even more so if she is willing to participate, which I hope since she is familiar with the material.

Did you do the online program?

I haven't myself, but believe that if you are having issues with follow-through and accountability that it would be a MUST. Not to mention, the price-tag is a good incentive to get off your butt and do the work.

It seems things may have gone loosey-goosey, and that it isn't working for you. Not because the concepts don't work, but because not using them properly does not.

So then you go back to basics. Do the questionnaires, get in 20+ hours of UA time since you are in crisis mode, and maintain 15+ hours some time after you restore that feeling of love.
Posted By: rprynne Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/01/11 09:07 PM
Going to drop off this thread. Good luck with things MrA
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 03:42 AM
Originally Posted by kilted_thrower
Has she said she's in love with you? You keep saying you believe she is. This is an assumption.

We both say it every day. The part I'm assuming is the part where I believe she's romantically in love with me. Have I asked her this? Nope. Been working up the courage to have that conversation. After the way we've been going lately I'm pretty sure she'd feel the need to express her disappointment in the way I've withdrawn. Which in turn has caused similar effect in herself.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 03:55 AM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
The solution is to find a way to meet his needs that she finds PLEASANT. Women need 2 things to enjoy sex: an emotional attachment and the prospect of enjoyment. It might be that she is not in love with him [which is what I sort of suspect even though he feels otherwise] and/or does not enjoy the way he makes love. If one or more of those elements are present, then she won't want to make love to him.

Sorry but there is probably a 3rd thing and that is No mental roadblocks to SF. I think my wife still continues to struggle somewhat with a bunch of factors that flow through her head when it comes to SF.

1). The sexual abuse she suffered from the hands of her brother when she was not quite a teenager. Plus an attempted rape.
2). All the horrible messages delivered by her mother that leaves my wife with a bad feeling in her stomach. "Women are meant to be seen and not heard. Sex is bad and should never be discussed in conversation."
3). She still isn't happy that I wasn't enthusiastic about more kids.

Maybe those come lumped into the prospect of enjoyment but for the most part are things I have little control over. Doesn't mean she doesn't enjoy sex or doesn't love me enough. It just means there are roadblocks.
Posted By: Vibrissa Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 04:03 AM
MrA - has she sought counseling to deal with the abuse? Is it possible she has an aversion? Have you worked through the process Dr. Harley lays out to overcome a sexual aversion? Does she, physically, enjoy sex?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 04:08 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Maybe those come lumped into the prospect of enjoyment but for the most part are things I have little control over. Doesn't mean she doesn't enjoy sex or doesn't love me enough. It just means there are roadblocks.

None of those are roadblocks, though. Most people have stuff like that in their past and it has nothing to do with the present. She can learn to enjoy sex in the present without dragging any of that stuff out.

Originally Posted by Dr Willard Harley
"First I fix the relationship, and nine times out of ten, sexual problems disappear, with or without unresolved childhood experiences. I spend very little time fixing sexual problems these days because most couples I counsel don't have sexual problems after they have learned to follow the Policy of Joint Agreement. "
here
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 04:16 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
We both say it every day. The part I'm assuming is the part where I believe she's romantically in love with me. Have I asked her this? Nope. Been working up the courage to have that conversation.

The Harleys have an actual test they give their clients to determine if they are really IN love. They MEASURE this. And keep in mind they differentiate between romantic and caring love. I have no doubt that your wife has a caring love for you, but I would question whether she has a romantic passion for you. That is usually the critical missing ingredient in marriages where the wife is not interested in sex.
Posted By: HoldHerHand Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 06:29 AM
Quote
An aversion is a negative emotional reaction that's been conditioned to a behavior. In other words, if you have bad experiences doing something, you will learn to associate those bad experiences with the task. The very thought of it will eventually create anxiety and unhappiness, and then doing it will make matters even worse.

Some psychologists, for reasons known only to them, like to shock rats. They have shown that if you subject a poor rat to an electric shock every time it takes a drink of water, it will not necessarily stop drinking water. But the rat will become very nervous whenever it does.

Humans go through the same experience. If your boss yells at you occasionally when you go to the water cooler, you will find yourself very tense whenever you drink from it. Your boss's yelling, which gives you a negative emotional reaction, becomes conditioned to your drinking from the water cooler. It's not the drinking itself that's unpleasant, it's the association of drinking with your boss yelling that triggers your reaction.

Aversions can be created in association with anything we do. Unpleasant classroom experiences can create "school phobia," something many children have great difficulty overcoming. An automobile accident can leave people with a fear of driving. Even shopping for groceries can raise anxiety in people who have had a bad grocery shopping experience.

Quote
Remember how you developed the aversion in the first place? You associated a certain behavior, having sex, with an unpleasant emotional reaction to something your husband did to you. Eventually the unpleasant reaction was triggered whenever you even thought about having sex with your husband, and certainly whenever you made love.

To overcome the aversion, you must break the association of sex with your husband from the unpleasant emotional reaction. The easiest way to do that is to associate sex with the state of relaxation.

Here

I may have to make an e-mail about it, but studies being done with PTSD cases have been using a Beta-blocker to blunt the physiological effect of memory triggers.

In the article, Dr. Harley mentions electrically shocking rats to create an aversion to drinking water. The beginning studies in this vein began by subjecting rats to a loud blast of noise.

They then administered the drug and subjected the rat to the noise again. The finding was that after treatment and exposure to the trigger (the loud noise) that the aversion, or fear reaction, to the noise faded.

A cited human case study had a PTSD case write out the traumatic event - the drug was administered, and then the patient read the description of the vent.

Again, the negative response began to fade with time.

This is not erasing the memory, but blunting the link between a memory or memory trigger and the physiological response.

The longer name for Beta-blockers is Beta adrenergic antagonists. Simply explained, they block cell receptors which are reactive to the neurotransmitter epinephrine - AKA adreneline.

This neurotransmitter is released by the sympathetic nervous system in times of crisis; in the case of a PTSD patient, this would be a memory trigger or "flashback."


Getting to the point; if she is having problems with aversion, 1) read Dr. Harley's approach to overcoming aversion, and 2) have a chat with your physician regarding Beta-blockers and PTSD symptoms.

The combination of the two would be very potent and could potentially eliminate her aversion without subjecting her to navel-gazing counseling.
Posted By: Helianthus Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 02:31 PM
I think the beta blockers are basically serving the same purpose as the deep relaxation used in Harley's steps to overcome sexual aversion.
Posted By: HoldHerHand Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 02:38 PM
Originally Posted by Helianthus
I think the beta blockers are basically serving the same purpose as the deep relaxation used in Harley's steps to overcome sexual aversion.

Absolutely.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 03:51 PM
She has been to several counselors and today takes a generic form of Zoloft. She started taking these when she was going thru postpartum depression and new found anxieties (fear of storms).

The last counselor that she/we saw used EFT and it had a very positive impact on her. Her OCD behaviors have minimized considerably ... they are still there but much less noticeable now.

To answer the other questions yes she enjoys sex. We discussed it and she said she does enjoy but she also turns around and says she could live without it. Probably 50% of the time I'm able to help her achieve orgasm (I assume that's a sign of enjoyment). The other 50% of the time I don't think she's interested in having one and its more about me being taken care of.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 03:54 PM
Originally Posted by Vibrissa
Have you worked through the process Dr. Harley lays out to overcome a sexual aversion?

She will refuse to follow suggestions from this website.

I was able to get her to participate in the EN questionaires some 8 years ago.

Since then she's more interested in us working out our own problems. She did seek counseling for her anxities and while there they also discussed all aspects of her life. If you were to ask her she would say she doesn't have an aversion, she's over the abuse. She just isn't that interested in SF. She has agreed it is important to us because its important to me.
Posted By: EasyE Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 08:02 PM
Oh boy, anti-depressants are known to be libido killers.
And the history of abuse makes it an uphill battle for sure.
Your case is very similar to what mine was.

Honestly, you are lucky things are going so well otherwise.
Posted By: EasyE Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 08:05 PM
I really think if you do a great Plan A, get yourself happy and carefree without lovebusting actions (whining aboout sex), she'll respond better than arranging some sort of POJA.

The problem is, though, the zoloft is killing her sexual desire.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 10:14 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
To answer the other questions yes she enjoys sex. We discussed it and she said she does enjoy but she also turns around and says she could live without it. Probably 50% of the time I'm able to help her achieve orgasm (I assume that's a sign of enjoyment). The other 50% of the time I don't think she's interested in having one and its more about me being taken care of.

I think the problem is that she is not in love and does not enjoy sex, but she doesn't want to hurt your feelings. She is probably a conflict avoider. Her actions don't line up with her statements. This is why I was hopeful that you could get her on the phone with the Harleys. They would get to the bottom of that in about 2 seconds flat and help her with a plan that would give her some relief. It has to be horrendous pressure pretending you feel one way when you really don't.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/02/11 10:26 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
To answer the other questions yes she enjoys sex. We discussed it and she said she does enjoy but she also turns around and says she could live without it. Probably 50% of the time I'm able to help her achieve orgasm (I assume that's a sign of enjoyment).

Not necessarily, believe it or not.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 02:28 PM
Does anyone else feel like they're cursed? Like Karma is against you and you simply can't win?

I ask because inevitably it seems there is always something that gets in the way of my wife and I filling my SF need. Lately she's pre-menopausal and so she's way irregular ... sometimes cycling every other week.

Add to that the other things that happen to her that make SF nearly impossible. She bruised her ribs falling off her horse last fall. She was untouchable for more than a month (unless I wanted to pressure her ... blech). Shortly after that she developed pneumonia. Other times the kids won't go to sleep and we're both so tired by the time they do.

It just always seems like such an uphill battle and that some of the restrictions come from things I and even she can't always control.

This weekend she was upset because we had a date night Saturday but she found she was 'out-of-commision'. She just returned to commission the weekend before (we were together that weekend). She said she was sorry, gave me a hug. I said you can't control those things and I'll be OK. We went out on our date and had a nice time.

Lying in bed Sunday I thought about my limitations to getting my needs filled. I struck up a conversation about her being out of commission and alternatives during that time. I did tell her I really was more into us sharing the experience instead of her just relieving me physically. She agreed and said she wasn't interested in taking care of me during that time. She prefers the intimacy of sharing ... I think that's important to me too. I get more out of it if I can give while I'm receiving. Limited thinking I know but I don't think I'm way off base or destroying the M for having those limitations. I suspect we should have discussed more but I didn't feel like pushing it.

I did tell her its hard ... that the physical part of it is a constant reminder. I also told her I was tired of having to take care of myself when the down time is for very long periods. That's probably the part where I should have pushed for some participation. Maybe in another talk.

I did tell her again that I was sorry that I gave up. I told her I'm trying hard to get back. I let her know I could be a great H and want to be. She said I already was and I disagreed. I told her I stopped doing the things I needed to do to be great and that I will get back there again but I need her help. I told her she deserved better than what she was receiving. She turned it all around and said I was a great H and that I deserved more. So I stated ... "So we're in agreement ... we both have some things we need to work harder on and that we both need each other for that loving support.". She said definitely. Somewhere in there she said she was fine and that I was doing a good job. So now I'm questioning what it is that I'm doing fine cuz trust me I stopped doing a lot of the things I was doing just a year or so ago. I always thought her biggest EN was Admiration ... but maybe it's more the FS I provide and the RC we share attending all of our kid's events. Something to ponder.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 02:38 PM
This sounds much more like peaceful co-existance than romantic love. I think that is going to be the key for you, MrA.
Quote
This weekend she was upset because we had a date night Saturday but she found she was 'out-of-commision'. She just returned to commission the weekend before (we were together that weekend). She said she was sorry, gave me a hug. I said you can't control those things and I'll be OK. We went out on our date and had a nice time.

Lying in bed Sunday I thought about my limitations to getting my needs filled. I struck up a conversation about her being out of commission and alternatives during that time. I did tell her I really was more into us sharing the experience instead of her just relieving me physically. She agreed and said she wasn't interested in taking care of me during that time. She prefers the intimacy of sharing ... I think that's important to me too. I get more out of it if I can give while I'm receiving. Limited thinking I know but I don't think I'm way off base or destroying the M for having those limitations. I suspect we should have discussed more but I didn't feel like pushing it.
I think she's being unfair to you and is using her 'pre-menopausal' situation to avoid SF.

What does she mean, she' 'not interested' in taking care of you 'during that time'? That's unfair of her and will ultimately work against her having an intimate relationship with you.

Sorry if I missed it, but have you considered counselling with Jennifer about this? Would she be willing to talk to someone about this?

Being 'pre-menopausal' has nothing to do with having satisfying SF. It can be done.
Posted By: sunnydaze53 Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 02:40 PM
Warning...this is way TMI but....

I have discovered during "that time of the month" that I can climax with direct stimulation with my clothes on...usually by simulating intercourse (I think teens call it dry humping). Orgasim definitely relieves any cramps or backaches. The rubbing gets my husband excited as well and then I usually feel sexy enough to continue my endeavors with him manually so that we are both satisfied.

Maybe you can use that time for a "makeout" session and see where it goes? She will hopefully feel less pressure as she knows sex isn't the end result.
Posted By: Telly Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 02:44 PM
MyAlias,

As an aside (but an important one)--has she been checked out by a doctor? Every other week seems pretty intense and out of whack. THere are things they can do with targeted hormonal replacement that can help to ease that, and may even help renew some of her desire.

Cycles like that can indicate hormonal fluctuations (extreme!) or other, more dangerous situations, like ovarian cancer.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 02:49 PM
My wife has had counseling but not specifically to talk about her sexual limitations. She's a little uncomfortable with certain aspects of sex sure ... not into oral and I am not one to push.

Clothes on ... she'd say no.

So my options are what? To convince her she needs to speak to someone cuz others here feel she's got issues? Is it wrong if we're both OK waiting for intercourse? I can be happy if we'd just get that part down to a regular pattern.

I realize it says a lot about me that I'm also gun-shy about trying/asking for things outside of the box. It's hard to break out of that comfort zone. Yet I do dream about her being more than she is from a sexual perspective. How does one go about asking for that without coming off looking or feeling like a pig?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 02:54 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I realize it says a lot about me that I'm also gun-shy about trying/asking for things outside of the box. It's hard to break out of that comfort zone. Yet I do dream about her being more than she is from a sexual perspective. How does one go about asking for that without coming off looking or feeling like a pig?

Why not be radically honest with her and show her this thread? She can't very well make changes if she doesn't know exactly what the problem is. Nor is it fair to her for us to know more about her marriage than she does.

Radical honesty, my friend..
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 02:56 PM
Originally Posted by Telly
MyAlias,

As an aside (but an important one)--has she been checked out by a doctor? Every other week seems pretty intense and out of whack. THere are things they can do with targeted hormonal replacement that can help to ease that, and may even help renew some of her desire.

Cycles like that can indicate hormonal fluctuations (extreme!) or other, more dangerous situations, like ovarian cancer.

Geez. All good things to know. Approaching her is another thing.

She just called and got offered her that accounting job we'd been hoping she'd get. Yeah!!!!!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 03:00 PM
Quote
Why not be radically honest with her and show her this thread? She can't very well make changes if she doesn't know exactly what the problem is. Nor is it fair to her for us to know more about her marriage than she does.

Radical honesty, my friend..

Yeah well I fear the reprecussions of her seeing everything I devulge here. She keeps things close to the vest. Trained by her mother to cover up the truth so she doesn't like to reveal a lot especially to strangers ... anonymous or not.

It isn't like she doesn't know most of this stuff ... it's just the way she is and she's not ready/willing to change.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 03:07 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
This sounds much more like peaceful co-existance than romantic love. I think that is going to be the key for you, MrA.

I did approach her about this state of our marriage. She said she was fine. It wasn't the answer I was hoping to get ... but then I stopped doing much of what I was doing before so ... maybe fine is better than I should have expected at this juncture.

I think I create a good portion of the problem. Always have been. I'm the coward who's so trained to leave her alone that I do. The moron martyr who can't find his Taker in an appropriate way. It's probably a good reason why she picked me to marry because I'm a bit enabling and don't push too much.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 03:23 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
So my options are what? To convince her she needs to speak to someone cuz others here feel she's got issues?

To let her know that you have an unmet emotional need and that it is important to you that this need be met in order for you both to have a fulfilling marriage, and to ask her to brainstorm with you ways to get this need met adequately, and to mention seeing a doctor as one possibility.
Posted By: ThornedRose Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 05:53 PM
MrAlias;


Quote
1). The sexual abuse she suffered from the hands of her brother when she was not quite a teenager. Plus an attempted rape.
2). All the horrible messages delivered by her mother that leaves my wife with a bad feeling in her stomach. "Women are meant to be seen and not heard. Sex is bad and should never be discussed in conversation."
3). She still isn't happy that I wasn't enthusiastic about more kids.

Maybe those come lumped into the prospect of enjoyment but for the most part are things I have little control over. Doesn't mean she doesn't enjoy sex or doesn't love me enough. It just means there are roadblocks.


Sounds like things she can address in counseling, but still isn't prepared to do..It still saddens me she isn't there yet, or afraid she will be told the abuse was her fault or something..

In reference to your not being enthusiastic about having more kids--given her beliefs that 'sex is not to be talked about', and that 'sex is bad" I'll add the unspoken attachment that typically goes along with that--"unless it's for procreation" I'm sure that is conflicting for her emotionally as well as possibly spiritually..

She says she enjoys sex..I'm sure she probably does..but sex for the sake of pleasure (given what she was taught) would be a sin, so for her to have sex on a regular basis without the possibility of procreation..could cause spiritual and mental anguish..

It's *possible* she struggles with the spiritual side of it internally, possibly even asking God to forgive her after she provides that need for you..and then deals with the weight of those false beliefs for some time afterwards..

It's possibly part of the reason she goes off by herself, or with her sister (I think I remember it's her sister she rides with?? Correct me if I'm wrong) who was probably raised to believe the same thing..to find comfort and get mom's words out of their heads.

Imagine the internal conflict she must have, knowing she enjoys sex, but being taught it's bad (a sin) "how could my husband who loves me, ask me to sin?" "Lord, it's not that I really want more children, but (my mom told me) that sex is wrong (except for procreation) so how can I make love to my husband (which I really enjoy) if he doesn't want more children and not sin against you in the process?"

IF this is the case, and the only way to really know is to ask her..(which yes, she could lie to you about) but the only way to deal with such false beliefs is the truth--which could prove to be difficult--'why would my mom lie to me about such things??'
and if it's something she also heard in church growing up..'why would a preacher lie to me about that?' (Maybe to keep a teenage girl from having sex and getting pregnant--and their not fully understanding the deeper ramifications of how it would effect her eventual marriage--unless of course she married a man who held to the same beliefs)

So how would you deal with such things? Finding a pastor SHE would be willing to meet with that understands and teaches the truth that sex is not merely for procreation, but as a way for a husband and wife to express their love for each other-one who can use the scriptures to dispel the lies..

then it will be for her to either continue to believe the lies she was taught as a child..or to believe God and what He says in His word about such things..

And as far as the attempted rape and sexual abuse from her brother, she probably carries the shame and guilt about that possibly blaming herself for those things happening..heck many people within society continue to blame the victim..


just somethings to think about..


Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 06:35 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
This sounds much more like peaceful co-existance than romantic love. I think that is going to be the key for you, MrA.

I did approach her about this state of our marriage. She said she was fine. It wasn't the answer I was hoping to get ... but then I stopped doing much of what I was doing before so ... maybe fine is better than I should have expected at this juncture.

I think I create a good portion of the problem. Always have been. I'm the coward who's so trained to leave her alone that I do. The moron martyr who can't find his Taker in an appropriate way. It's probably a good reason why she picked me to marry because I'm a bit enabling and don't push too much.

You can't very well resolve the problems if she isn't aware of how unhappy you are so that is where I would start. This is why radical honesty is so important. Complaints are what motivate change in a marriage.

Posted By: EasyE Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 09:56 PM
It seems to me, in the type of situation you are in, if you have to "ask" or "approach" her about your needs, that it becomes just another chore to put on her to-do list.

Does she respond to passionate kissing? Can you stick on some mood music and scoop her up to dance in the living room while the kids laugh at you? What would happen if you two took a bath together?

I'm just saying, anything other than having to verbally ask for it, which I can fully understand would not be attractive to her.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 10:27 PM
Originally Posted by EasyE
It seems to me, in the type of situation you are in, if you have to "ask" or "approach" her about your needs, that it becomes just another chore to put on her to-do list.

Does she respond to passionate kissing? Can you stick on some mood music and scoop her up to dance in the living room while the kids laugh at you? What would happen if you two took a bath together?

I'm just saying, anything other than having to verbally ask for it, which I can fully understand would not be attractive to her.

EasyE, of course he has to ask her for it. That is part and parcel of radical honesty. Unspoken issues in marriage lead to a lack of intimacy in marriage, and that is his basic problem. The purpose of complaints in marriage is to give the other person an opportunity to make such changes. That has what has been lacking here all along. His wife is not a mind reader and she can't be an equal partner in their marriage unless and until she fully understands what ails it.

Complaints in marriage are GOOD for marriage.
Posted By: EasyE Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 10:46 PM
I didn't mean as a point of spelling out needs. Once done, once it has been hammered into the ground, I don't see how on an individual event (like on a Saturday night) POJA'ing for sex is going to go over well.

It seems to me at some point, after EN's have long been established, the verbal approach would cause Mrs. Alias to roll her eyes and think of her to-do list.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/15/11 11:05 PM
Originally Posted by EasyE
I didn't mean as a point of spelling out needs. Once done, once it has been hammered into the ground, I don't see how on an individual event (like on a Saturday night) POJA'ing for sex is going to go over well.

It seems to me at some point, after EN's have long been established, the verbal approach would cause Mrs. Alias to roll her eyes and think of her to-do list.

I am so confused about what you mean. crazy
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/16/11 01:38 PM
Originally Posted by EasyE
I didn't mean as a point of spelling out needs. Once done, once it has been hammered into the ground, I don't see how on an individual event (like on a Saturday night) POJA'ing for sex is going to go over well.

It seems to me at some point, after EN's have long been established, the verbal approach would cause Mrs. Alias to roll her eyes and think of her to-do list.

Agreed on the part the overall informing of what ENs need to be met has long been established.

Where I struggle is having to continually ask for/push for those needs to be met. I did it for so many years and I tried it in so many various ways that lately I just don't even try. My god I'd hate to even list all of the different ways I tried to approach my wife about my complaints/concerns that my needs weren't/aren't being met.

Lately it seems there is an apparent acknowledgement from her that she knows what's expected. And she's showing a genuine concern when those expectations aren't going to be met. For me that's a pretty big thing. Up until this point most times she just tries to ignore the situation or at least tries to avoid the conversation. One can ponder the reasons behind that.

As you've stated EasyE I am no longer filing my complaints to her. She knows frequency/consistency is key. We are getting back to doing the little things that make us feel attached. A gentle hand or touch here or there, a flirtatious pinch (she does this to me mostly), kinds words of affirmation, being pleasant and attentive around each other.

This is it for me though. If I go down this path of doing what a good H should do like I've done many times in the past and nothing changes for me I will have no choice but to push for something more for us. We will have to get some help if our M is to survive.

Meanwhile I'm going to do everything I can to create the romantic love we had not that many months ago. I'm hoping this latest withdrawal stage I went through scared her enough. I know it scared and depressed me. I've certainly explained my feelings of not caring anymore to her and how much it scared me. I told her during that time that I didn't think we were going to make it.

I don't think the Mrs. rolls her eyes. It isn't that she doesn't believe I deserve these things. Does she think of it as a chore? I don't know. Its not a need for her so I would expect she does. To some extent don't we all have those days when we're not at our best that keeping the love alive can be chore-like?
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/16/11 01:50 PM
Quote
Meanwhile I'm going to do everything I can to create the romantic love we had not that many months ago.

I'm so happy to hear this! Years ago when I got here it gave me so much hope for my own life, reading about what you two had then together. I can imagine how cool it must be for your kids, growing up seeing how two folks love and respect and are thoughtful and caring to each other.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/16/11 01:55 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[Meanwhile I'm going to do everything I can to create the romantic love we had not that many months ago. I'm hoping this latest withdrawal stage I went through scared her enough. I know it scared and depressed me. I've certainly explained my feelings of not caring anymore to her and how much it scared me. I told her during that time that I didn't think we were going to make it.

That is great news! What is your plan? There is a very specific way to achieve this. If she is willing, do you have a plan to achieve this?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/16/11 02:14 PM
I'm sorry Melody. I'm sure my plan isn't what you're hoping for.

Unfortunately at this juncture I'd have to state my wife isn't interested in a plan. At least not a plan that's being thrust upon her. I tried approaching her with the idea of recreating that romantic love. She said she was fine and thought the only issue was my depression (work and physical health related). I did communicate that the lack of my needs being met were a big part of the depression and withdrawal. I mentioned getting help but she was silent.

My plan is to do what I can to create that romantic, connected love we had and see where it takes us. If it takes us back to where we were before then I feel I'll have ammunition/justification to say we need to take this one step further and get some professional help.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/16/11 02:22 PM
BTW I feel good about the plan. It gives me hope that we'll either make it on our own or we'll get help that will help us make it. It's giving me some motivation and lifting the horrible feeling I've had for over a year now.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/16/11 02:40 PM
smile That sounds awesome!
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/17/11 03:56 AM
MrA, were you and your W the couple who would fall asleep in each other's arms? I think it was you two, you're not starting from scratch, you guys have a huge head start.

I don't remember, do you two do Date Nights? Can you leave the kids home without a sitter, or do you have a sitter?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/17/11 01:51 PM
We can no longer fall asleep in each other's arms. I have sleep apnea and need to "gear" up before I go to sleep. It really plays havoc on spooning/snuggling.

We hold hands once in awhile now.

Our son is our sitter and yes we do do date nights. We've gone out with friends severals times in the last couple of months. We also leave the kids at home at times and do some shopping together, etc.

With this new project at work we spend less time together but with our kid's activities and our date nights we have to average more than 15 hours together each week.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/17/11 02:58 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
My plan is to do what I can to create that romantic, connected love we had and see where it takes us. If it takes us back to where we were before then I feel I'll have ammunition/justification to say we need to take this one step further and get some professional help.

I think thats a great plan. That is what Dr Harley calls "priming the pump" when you have one spouse who is not fully on board. You do what you are doing, priming the pump, so to speak and then taking it to a new level when her interest is piqued. Did you see the "Saved by One Spouse" series of articles? There might be some ideas in there: Saved By One Spouse?
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 02/18/11 04:59 AM
MrA, I wonder, though, how many folks never experience that, you know, how many wonderful memories you have. And how cool your 13 year old can be the sitter! My DD started doing that at that age, too, they had/have fun with it. They could watch kid movies at night on the big TV LOL.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/27/12 11:48 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
BTW I feel good about the plan. It gives me hope that we'll either make it on our own or we'll get help that will help us make it. It's giving me some motivation and lifting the horrible feeling I've had for over a year now.

Wow. It's been over 20 months since I posted this. It's surreal going back to read the things I've posted in the past.

I find myself in worse shape than ever before.

I'm stuck, trapped by my own choices. I've grown extremely apathetic about my marriage.

The plan didn't work. The suggestion to try something fell on deaf ears. I continued to try a little to create something despite not getting the professional help we needed but soon found things with her that really started to bother me. I won't list them, just say they were enough to turn me off.

I slowly became less and less interested in her and our marriage and today I find myself totally disinterested in her. We're roommates. Maybe even less than roommates.

I'm staying because I don't want to break up the family nor experience the cost of a divorce at this juncture. I try to be cordial but there is no passion and very little interaction. I'm to the point where I'm the one ensuring it stays that way. Losing all expectation has proven less painful.

My focus has been on the kids as has hers I suppose. They're wonderful. I couldn't imagine shaking up their world.

I'm not sure why I'm even posting. I guess I don't like being stuck and I don't like knowing times wasting away for an opportunity to love someone (maybe not her) and have someone love me back in a way that makes me happy.

Quote
People in your position try, usually for years, to get their spouses' attention. Those that complain often feel guilty about complaining, and their spouses often remind them that they should be grateful for what they do have, instead of being critical of what they don't do. So these people learn to say less and less as the problems becomes greater and greater. Some people never do complain because they don't want to be perceived as critical an unappreciative. But in the end, the marital conflicts take their toll -- they lose the feeling of love for their spouses.

When that happens, the person gives up. He or she comes to the conclusion that the spouse will not change and that they must get used to the idea of living without care or consideration. Some of these people remain married for the sake of their values or children, but they remain emotionally distant from their spouses to minimize their pain.
Quote
I've long given up on many of the concepts of this site.
Tell us what you have done to recover your marriage, Mr. A.
Quote
The plan didn't work.
Tell us what you did.
Hi MrAlias, I joined this site earlier this year, after you started this thread, and just now read it. The only advice I have for you is to tell you that I was in a similar situation as you, and I'm now divorced. I reached the state of Withdrawal and stayed there for several years because I didn't want to break up the family. When my kids were old enough to be on their own, I left. In hindsight, now that I found this website, I could've done things differently by trying, as MelodyLane wrote many times earlier in this thread, to restore romantic love to the marriage.

What is incredibly difficult is trying to work on your marriage while you're in the state of withdrawal.

I was in withdrawal for way too long, and I know how you feel: very depressed, almost paralyzed to do anything about your situation.

You need to get out of the state of Withdrawal. Others on this site may be able to help, or you can try professional counseling. If your wife won't agree to phone counseling with the Harley's, at least you can; start with you.

If you continue in the state of Withdrawal, you will either stay unhappy for the rest of your life or you or your wife will have an affair and your marriage will probably end. Sorry to paint such a bleak picture, but you really do need to get out of that state. Until you do, you will be unable to meet your wife's emotional needs; and even if she was trying to meet yours, it wouldn't work because your Love Bank is closed for business.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 12:01 PM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
Quote
I've long given up on many of the concepts of this site.
Tell us what you have done to recover your marriage, Mr. A.
Quote
The plan didn't work.
Tell us what you did.

If I had the energy to I would. I've been coming to this site on and off for a number of years and have done my darndest to implement anything and everything short of the counseling offered by the Harleys. We've been to marriage counseling, individual counseling, her and I did the questionaire years ago, I've read a few books namely The 5 Love Languages; to name a few. She's not interested in others telling her what she should do. She wants to do it her way ... but with her way there is no plan. You just co-exist and be happy with what you got.

I'm numb to her.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 12:12 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I've read a few books namely The 5 Love Languages; to name a few.
That is naming one.

Have you read any books by Dr Harley? This site, Marriage Builders, is for help and advice in using his materials ater all.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 12:16 PM
Keep,

I, like you, plan to wait for the kids to move on and then I'll make a decision. Right now I'm staying for financial reasons and I hope to minimize the kids pain.

I am totally paralyzed. I don't have enough feelings for her to really even care. And it appears she's feeling the same way as she is also not interacting much with me. We just communicate on the necessities.

I am done trying to rectify. I've always been the one over the last gee I don't know 10 to 12 years that has tried. I've spent countless hours asking, receiving and giving advice on this site. I've taken self improvement seminars. I good friend who is a Life Coach gave me coaching for a good stretch there. As I said earlier I've done individual and marriage counseling. That's the one thing she's done, counseling... but most of what she worked on was her post partum (now gone), her OCB (lessened) and her anxieties/phobias(nearly gone). Which was important but now when it's important to us she doesn't want to do anything I suggest and she offers nothing as an alternative.

So as you may be able to see I have NO interest in starting up again. She wants to fix it she can take the initiative. I'm cruising until the kids are grown. That's about 8 more years give or take.

I'm focusing on other areas of my life. Trying to get back into shape (lifelong struggle). I need to drop about 30 pounds but mostly I'm working out just to feel in shape. I've got a lot of physical ailments that make life painful at times.

I'm focused on the kids. Making sure I'm teaching them good life lessons (my marriage is the exception), helping them to grow.

I'm sure I'm open to someone else's attention. Fortunately there aren't any opportunities that have surfaced and I certainly am not seeking something like that.

Anyways the short of it is I'm just putting in my time unless she asks me to do something about it. My Bank is closed and my heart won't let my head try to open it again.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 12:28 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I've read a few books namely The 5 Love Languages; to name a few.
That is naming one.

Have you read any books by Dr Harley? This site, Marriage Builders, is for help and advice in using his materials ater all.

No. After reading a couple of the love languages books, reading everything on this site several times over and having received advice from this forum for over 10 years I doubt there is anything in those books that I am not already aware of.

Can our marriage be saved using the MB techniques? Heck yeah. Especially if we were to participate in counseling with the Harleys.

Will it? I doubt it. Especially now that I'm deep in withdrawal and have no interest in trying to make it work. I certainly have no interest in dropping hundreds of dollars to have a counselor tell me try what I already know and have tried. Some would say they'd be able to help my wife participate. Nope. I've been over that with her and she'll tell you "I'm not interested. There's bound to be something we can do ourselves that doesn't cost anything." Great what's the plan. Crickets. Shrugs. Grrrrr.

I'm not interested in spending another dime on this marriage unless she's the catalyst.

I'm staying for reasons other than love.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 01:54 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
Quote
I've long given up on many of the concepts of this site.
Tell us what you have done to recover your marriage, Mr. A.
Quote
The plan didn't work.
Tell us what you did.

If I had the energy to I would. I've been coming to this site on and off for a number of years and have done my darndest to implement anything and everything short of the counseling offered by the Harleys. We've been to marriage counseling, individual counseling, her and I did the questionaire years ago, I've read a few books namely The 5 Love Languages; to name a few. She's not interested in others telling her what she should do. She wants to do it her way ... but with her way there is no plan. You just co-exist and be happy with what you got.

I'm numb to her.

I would try Marriage Builders, MrA. You have never used Marriage Builders in all these years. Filling out a questionaire and posting on a chat forum will not help your marriage. You have to actually do the work.

However, when someone has the same problem after 10 years, they are not really looking for solutions.

The counseling services are FOR reluctant spouses. As Harley says, most couples that come to him for help have a reluctant spouse. He turns that around.

Five Love Languages will not help your marriage. It is a marriage program that was largely taken from Marriage Builders ["love tank"] that only focuses on communication at the expense of creating love. Communication is not the problem in your marriage, it is that you have fallen out of love.

When your own methods don't work, it is time to step it up and actually use the program. But I don't believe you are serious about finding solutions.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 01:57 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[I certainly have no interest in dropping hundreds of dollars to have a counselor tell me try what I already know and have tried.

You haven't tried Marriage Builders. But if you had been really looking for solutions, I suspect you would have.
MrAlias, it�s painful to read what you write:

Originally Posted by MrAlias
I am totally paralyzed. I don't have enough feelings for her to really even care. And it appears she's feeling the same way as she is also not interacting much with me. We just communicate on the necessities.
Originally Posted by MrAlias
So as you may be able to see I have NO interest in starting up again.
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'm cruising until the kids are grown. That's about 8 more years give or take.
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'm just putting in my time
Originally Posted by MrAlias
My Bank is closed and my heart won't let my head try to open it again.
I was there too, exactly where you are today. It�s heartbreaking to read that someone is suffering what I know from experience is so numbing and painful at the same time.

Rhetorical question: Do you really want to live like you are now for 8 more years? If you�re like me, and it sounds like you are, divorce is not an option right now because of the kids. You can try to find happiness on your own, like I did while waiting for the kids to grow up, but I�ll tell you, if I had known about Marriage Builders resources back then, I think it might�ve worked. It�s the one program I�ve seen that makes a lot of sense.

The key for you right now is to get out of Withdrawal. I applaud your attempt to get back into shape. Aerobic exercise is a great way to improve your outlook on life. Keep at it. Make sure you find something you enjoy doing because that�s what will keep you motivated. If it feels like a chore, you�ll probably quit, especially being in the state of Withdrawal where you tend not to care much about anything.

You write in another post:

Originally Posted by MrAlias
I certainly have no interest in dropping hundreds of dollars to have a counselor tell me try what I already know and have tried.
It sounds as if you haven�t tried what the Harleys can offer. A lot of other posters on your thread have encouraged you to call them. Doesn�t it pique your interest? It�s possible the Harleys can offer you a new approach, something you haven�t tried. Why not give it a shot? One phone counseling session won�t set you back that much, and then you can decide whether or not to continue. If your marriage eventually ends, how will you feel knowing that you didn�t try something that might�ve helped?

Give it a try. You don�t have much to lose, and you potentially have much to gain.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 02:59 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
I would try Marriage Builders, MrA. You have never used Marriage Builders in all these years. Filling out a questionaire and posting on a chat forum will not help your marriage. You have to actually do the work.

Thanks for minimizing all of the work I did those first 8 or 9 years. [sarcasm]It feels so good to be told all you ever did was fill out a Q and post on a forum. [/sarcasm]
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 03:10 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[quote=MelodyLane]I would try Marriage Builders, MrA. You have never used Marriage Builders in all these years. Filling out a questionaire and posting on a chat forum will not help your marriage. You have to actually do the work.

Thanks for minimizing all of the work I did those first 8 or 9 years. [sarcasm]It feels so good to be told all you ever did was fill out a Q and post on a forum. [/sarcasm]

I am sorry if I overstated it, but did you ever sign up for Marriage Builders counseling? Even go to the MB weekend seminar? All I see you did was fill out a questionaire and chat on a chat forum. That is not using the program - as you can see.

It doesn't take 8 or 9 years to transform a marriage. Those of us who have transformed our marriages using this program did it in 1 to 2 years. Here you are 9 years later no better off than when you arrived. That is because you have no used this program.

When someone has the same problem year after year, I know I am speaking to someone who is not looking for solutions.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 03:13 PM
In fact, I made several posts on this thread a few years ago that could have made the difference between success and failure. Did you follow any of that advice?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 03:13 PM
POST MADE ON 1-17-11, DID YOU FOLLOW THIS ADVICE?

Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Hi MrAlias! If you have tried and tried to implement this program on your own to no avail, I would try using the professional services at Marriage Builders. Many of us have gone to the weekend or used the counseling services with great results. For my marriage, I only got so far doing it on my own. We went to the MB weekend in 2007 and it made a huge difference.

I can see right off that the problem in your marriage is that your wife and you are not in love. I don't know how strictly you have implemented this program, but I do know that if you cut corners on crucial things like UA time and the POJA, that you are spinning your wheels. For example, Dr Harley says his program doesn't even work if you don't spend at least 15 hours of TRUE UA time per week. In your case it needs to be 25 to 30 just to create romantic love and 15 to maintain.

It's sad to see that you have been here for years and are still in the same predicament. But I am not surprised. There are others who have used this forum - for years - to discuss specific conflicts rather than implement this program. They are in the same boat as when they arrived.

This Harley quote came to mind when I read your post:

Originally Posted by Dr Harley
"First I fix the relationship, and nine times out of ten, sexual problems disappear, with or without unresolved childhood experiences. I spend very little time fixing sexual problems these days because most couples I counsel don't have sexual problems after they have learned to follow the Policy of Joint Agreement. " here
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 04:00 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I've read a few books namely The 5 Love Languages; to name a few.
That is naming one.

Have you read any books by Dr Harley? This site, Marriage Builders, is for help and advice in using his materials ater all.

No. After reading a couple of the love languages books, reading everything on this site several times over and having received advice from this forum for over 10 years I doubt there is anything in those books that I am not already aware of.

Been on Marriage Builders for 10 years and never read a single book. I rest my case.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 04:05 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I've read a few books namely The 5 Love Languages; to name a few.
That is naming one.

Have you read any books by Dr Harley? This site, Marriage Builders, is for help and advice in using his materials ater all.

No. After reading a couple of the love languages books, reading everything on this site several times over and having received advice from this forum for over 10 years I doubt there is anything in those books that I am not already aware of.

Been on Marriage Builders for 10 years and never read a single book. I rest my case.


Do you own any of Dr. Harley's books?
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 05:47 PM
Originally Posted by KeepLearning
Rhetorical question: Do you really want to live like you are now for 8 more years?

MrA, have you looked into taking any antidepressant medication. In the rare cases I've heard of where Dr. Harley has coached a husband to stay in a marriage with a traumatic situation (ongoing, active affair on the part of the wife), he has directed the husband to get antidepressant medication from a doctor to help him get through it.

If you are seriously planning to live in a bad marriage for 8 years, at a minimum, you should get some antidepressant medication.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 06:07 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
I would try Marriage Builders, MrA. You have never used Marriage Builders in all these years. Filling out a questionaire and posting on a chat forum will not help your marriage. You have to actually do the work.

Thanks for minimizing all of the work I did those first 8 or 9 years. [sarcasm]It feels so good

If there's a truck about to hit you in the road, would you prefer that we make you feel good about it, or would you prefer that we warn you you are standing in the wrong spot?

It looks like you've made only minimal investments in learning Marriage Builders, and you've assumed that it is interchangeable with other programs and that you can mix and match the methods here with suggestions from those other programs. You don't have to have professional counseling to learn and implement Marriage Builders, but ignoring the free materials (website and radio program), ignoring the books, and not getting into any of the professional options does not sound like using Marriage Builders, to me.

I'm sorry if that statement makes you feel bad. A bank overdraft statement always makes me feel bad, you know? I am going to ask my bank not to send me overdraft statements any more, so I can feel good while making financial mistakes.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 06:24 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
No. After reading a couple of the love languages books, reading everything on this site several times over and having received advice from this forum for over 10 years I doubt there is anything in those books that I am not already aware of.

Actually, if you've read the entire site, but never listened to the radio show, there is an enormous amount of material that shows up in the radio show that you are probably unaware of. Including a lot of material on marriages where the husband is motivated and the wife is not. I can think of tons of things I've heard on the radio show and not seen covered, or barely seen covered, on this website. One good example would be Type A and Type B resentment; I don't think Dr. Harley has an article about that.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 06:40 PM
I found where Dr. H talks about the two different types of resentment, but not type A and B.

Originally Posted by Dr. Harley
There are two kinds of resentment: (1) Resentment due to something one of you DID to the other that was hurtful, and (2) resentment due to something you DIDN'T do for yourself that you would have liked, but would have hurt your spouse. Your husband has the first kind of resentment because you had an affair three months into your marriage. What you did hurt him. You have the second kind of resentment because you now feel obligated to avoid seeing a friend who is a threat to your husband.
Following POJA whe you're very incompatible
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 06:45 PM
Originally Posted by BrainHurts
I found where Dr. H talks about the two different types of resentment, but not type A and B.

Originally Posted by Dr. Harley
There are two kinds of resentment: (1) Resentment due to something one of you DID to the other that was hurtful, and (2) resentment due to something you DIDN'T do for yourself that you would have liked, but would have hurt your spouse. Your husband has the first kind of resentment because you had an affair three months into your marriage. What you did hurt him. You have the second kind of resentment because you now feel obligated to avoid seeing a friend who is a threat to your husband.
Following POJA whe you're very incompatible

Wow. I didn't think that was on here!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 07:01 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I've read a few books namely The 5 Love Languages; to name a few.
That is naming one.

Have you read any books by Dr Harley? This site, Marriage Builders, is for help and advice in using his materials ater all.

No. After reading a couple of the love languages books, reading everything on this site several times over and having received advice from this forum for over 10 years I doubt there is anything in those books that I am not already aware of.

Been on Marriage Builders for 10 years and never read a single book. I rest my case.

Nice.

Sure thing. Make the assumption because I haven't read the books and followed the exercises recommended in there that I've done nothing in my marriage that employs the principles of the Harleys. Disregard the thousands of posts I've read that have directly quoted the books (ahem many of them your posts MelodyLane).

I don't own the book and have not checked out the books from the library ergo I'm an MB moron. Nice assumption. You talk in generality based on a few facts.

Melody most of your suggestions involve me trying to implement specific rules with a partner that isn't interested in implementing this plan. Up until a couple of years ago I have done my part to follow what is taught here. I upped our UA time without making it an official announcement. I know the rules surrounding POJA and have done what I could to implement those. Fortunately her and I have done well to avoid independent behavior so some parts of that were easy to implement. Other parts more difficult as she doesn't participate in the plan and therefore hasn't agreed to its policy so a mutual agreement can be difficult. I know how to read my wife and did a very good job of eliminating all LBs. blah blah blah I could go on and on yet I hate that I have to defend my understanding of the main MB policies.

Not that it's a true barometer but she said she was happy and satisfied whenever I asked how she thought we were doing.

Your disregard of the 5 love languages book IMHO is a bit off the mark. It was an excellent book that described in much similarity the same principals as the most important Emotional Needs. It just had a more generalized categorization of the needs but it went into great detail and real life examples of those concepts and I suspect it is very similar if not identical to the Drs HNHN book. It is a great book and helped me understand a lot of how her and I could/should operate. I liked it so much I bought the 5 Love Languages for Children and it has been an integral part in understanding the extreme differences in each of my kids and how I could build a loving relationship with each one of them.

Quote
These conclusions are reflected in my book His Needs, Her Needs where I explain how couples build romantic love by learning how to meet each other's most important emotional needs.

We both read the book then did the EN Q. She liked it because I implemented a change. But after that that was it. To this day she even refers to it as that stupid question/answer thingy. sigh.

Enough of me trying to defend what I've done and what I understand.

I haven't tried the professional services and the things they'd suggest. And at this particular point in our relationship you're going to have a tough time convincing me to do it now. I'm sure there are some terms and concepts I've missed not reading the books ...so I can be always be more educated while my wife gets everything she wants while I expend all my energy just to get some crumbs.

I am not saying the program doesn't work. I'm not even saying I completely committed to it. I will say I took a pretty damn big stab at it given my circumstances and if you truly knew everything I tried that one would consider MB principals you'd avoid comments like "I rest my case.".

Again I question why I came back to post. I must be a masochist and enjoy people telling me all the energy I've spent and pain I've suffered the last 10 years were a joke and that I'm nothing more than a poser.

Heck I probably don't belong on this site anymore anyways as one of the things that have turned me off is her drinking. It's gotten excessive and there's a chance there's some dependency issues. I spoke to her about it and she dialed it back. But now this week she's back at it ... I suspect to send me a message. You withdraw I stop doing what you want.

markos: I have the MB radio app installed on my Droid and have listened on average about 2 to 3 hours each month the last 5 or 6 months. Unfortunately I've been withdrawn that whole time and the program hasn't motivated me. Also I am local to their radio station and have listened over the air waves several times a couple of years ago. I haven't heard the terms Type A and Type B resentment so it's obvious I don't know it all. Thanks for the suggestion.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 07:12 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Your disregard of the 5 love languages book IMHO is a bit off the mark. It was an excellent book that described in much similarity the same principals as the most important Emotional Needs. It just had a more generalized categorization of the needs but it went into great detail and real life examples of those concepts and I suspect it is very similar if not identical to the Drs HNHN book. It is a great book and helped me understand a lot of how her and I could/should operate.

Since it doesn't seem to have fixed your marriage, why would you say that it is a great book?

I personally found that book very lacking, long before coming here. It was very long on telling me what not to do and very short on telling me what to do. I give it credit for getting across the basic concept that what means care for one person may not mean care for the other. But if I remember right it doesn't have any suggestions for what to do when your spouse isn't interested in providing care for you, which makes it useless for the reluctant spouse scenario.

Quote
I suspect it is very similar if not identical to the Drs HNHN book.

crazy

This makes no sense whatsoever. I guess if you are bent on convincing yourself that one program is the same as another so that you can tell yourself you did everything you could, then it might make sense to say it.

I've never been to Italy. I assume it is very similar if not identical to China. I'm going to go to Dallas, TX, which is probably similar to both of them, and then I'll know what it's like to go to Italy and China.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 07:17 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Heck I probably don't belong on this site anymore anyways as one of the things that have turned me off is her drinking. It's gotten excessive and there's a chance there's some dependency issues. I spoke to her about it and she dialed it back. But now this week she's back at it ...I suspect to send me a message. You withdraw I stop doing what you want.


Will she go to AA?

What about AlAnon for you?
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 07:18 PM
MrA, you sound miserable and combative. You are shooting at the rescue helicopters.

If you want to survive the next 8 years, I really think antidepressant medication would be a good idea.

Convincing us you are right won't help your situation. Even if you are right. You might win the debate with us, and still have an unhappy life.

I would like to do what I personally can to help you get to a point of happiness in life, but I'm not sure if it would do any good because you seem to fight with everyone who offers you advice, or at bare minimum, you ignore their suggestions. You sound like you are convinced you have nothing to learn and that nobody understands your situation because it is different, and that there is nothing out there that could help you and we just need to understand that.

I see no point in arguing that with you.

Originally Posted by markos
Originally Posted by KeepLearning
Rhetorical question: Do you really want to live like you are now for 8 more years?

MrA, have you looked into taking any antidepressant medication. In the rare cases I've heard of where Dr. Harley has coached a husband to stay in a marriage with a traumatic situation (ongoing, active affair on the part of the wife), he has directed the husband to get antidepressant medication from a doctor to help him get through it.

If you are seriously planning to live in a bad marriage for 8 years, at a minimum, you should get some antidepressant medication.
Posted By: CWMI Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 07:32 PM
Have you told your wife that you are only planning to stay until the kids are grown?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 08:08 PM
[
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[Your disregard of the 5 love languages book IMHO is a bit off the mark. It was an excellent book that described in much similarity the same principals as the most important Emotional Needs. It just had a more generalized categorization of the needs but it went into great detail and real life examples of those concepts and I suspect it is very similar if not identical to the Drs HNHN book. It is a great book and helped me understand a lot of how her and I could/should operate. I liked it so much I bought the 5 Love Languages for Children and it has been an integral part in understanding the extreme differences in each of my kids and how I could build a loving relationship with each one of them.

Five Love Languages doesn't have a plan to transform your marriage; Marriage Builders DOES. 5LL focuses on "communication" which is cute and winsome but is a distraction from creating romantic love in the marriage. It won't help a bad marriage because there is no PLAN to do so. Even the best communicators will end up divorced if they are not in love. The fact that you don't know the difference demonstrates your lack of understanding of this program. Not to mention the fact that it hasn't helped your own marriage.

Anyone who has been through the program and has transformed their marriage will tell you a) there is huge difference and b) you can't learn this program by reading articles and posts on this forum. For example, up until the past 2 years, the MB program wasn't even presented on the EN forum. It was little more than a chat forum where personal opinions reigned supreme and the program was cherry picked at best. The vast majority of posters were in bad marriages themselves and knew nothing about the program. Instead of applying the program to their own marriages, they made endless and volumnous posts about specific conflicts.

Quote
I am not saying the program doesn't work. I'm not even saying I completely committed to it. I will say I took a pretty damn big stab at it given my circumstances and if you truly knew everything I tried that one would consider MB principals you'd avoid comments like "I rest my case.".

You don't own a single book and by your own admission don't even care to save your marriage. That is why you have the same problem today you did when you arrived almost 10 years ago.

Quote
Melody most of your suggestions involve me trying to implement specific rules with a partner that isn't interested in implementing this plan. Up until a couple of years ago I have done my part to follow what is taught here. I upped our UA time without making it an official announcement.

In other words, you never availed yourself of the professional services on this site to help persuade your wife. AS you can see, this program doesn't work without 2 committed parties. Most of the couples who go through the MB program have one reluctant spouse. The Harleys are able to sell them on the program. I would think after almost 10 years you might accept that your own methods have been unsuccessful and get some professional help.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 08:11 PM
Originally Posted by markos
MrA, you sound miserable and combative. You are shooting at the rescue helicopters.

If you want to survive the next 8 years, I really think antidepressant medication would be a good idea.

Convincing us you are right won't help your situation. Even if you are right. You might win the debate with us, and still have an unhappy life.]

His goal is to maintain the status quo. A person who has the same problems after 10 years is not seeking solutions.
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 08:13 PM
MrA, that really explains a lot, the drinking, and I understand the reluctance to share it. It explains why she used to be so dead-set on putting time with the horse ahead of family time on the weekends, because they can both escape mechanisms. You've read the articles on an alcoholic marriage, right, you know no matter how much UA time you get and how in love with you she becomes it's not going to make her more willing to shift from the Renter mindset "how little can I do to get him off my back today" to Buyer mode, "what can I do to make us both happy." No wonder you're out of steam. Al-anon has been a great help to me getting my serenity back, and helping my kids learn tools to live with the situation. You had tried it before, right, did it click with you?

(((hugs)))
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 08:24 PM
Originally Posted by BrainHurts
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Heck I probably don't belong on this site anymore anyways as one of the things that have turned me off is her drinking. It's gotten excessive and there's a chance there's some dependency issues. I spoke to her about it and she dialed it back. But now this week she's back at it ...I suspect to send me a message. You withdraw I stop doing what you want.


Will she go to AA?

What about AlAnon for you?

I went a couple of years ago but that was when I wanted to know if I could help my SIL because my BIL is an alcoholic. I only went to 4 sessions. Got a lot out of it. But stopped as I realized this was going to a long journey and what I'd get would be minimal. I also hoped it would spur on my SIL to attend in a chapter close to her city.

Now? Because my wife is drinking? Hmmm. Not sure I would.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 08:29 PM
Quote
Five Love Languages doesn't have a plan to transform your marriage; Marriage Builders DOES. 5LL focuses on "communication" which is cute and winsome but is a distraction from creating romantic love in the marriage. It won't help a bad marriage because there is no PLAN to do so. Even the best communicators will end up divorced if they are not in love. The fact that you don't know the difference demonstrates your lack of understanding of this program. Not to mention the fact that it hasn't helped your own marriage.

bzzzt. Wrong answer. The intention of the book was to spur on action to determine what your partner's love language was and to take action from there. There was even a chapter on what to do with a reluctant spouse who wouldn't communicate their needs (love language). So while communication would prove helpful it wasn't required to complete the exercises (which I did) one would take to determine and fulfill their love language.

The fact you don't know what that book offers tells me your still on your one trick pony and aren't willing to be flexible with a process that is nearly identical to the one you're preaching.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 08:32 PM
Originally Posted by NewEveryDay
MrA, that really explains a lot, the drinking, and I understand the reluctance to share it. It explains why she used to be so dead-set on putting time with the horse ahead of family time on the weekends, because they can both escape mechanisms. You've read the articles on an alcoholic marriage, right, you know no matter how much UA time you get and how in love with you she becomes it's not going to make her more willing to shift from the Renter mindset "how little can I do to get him off my back today" to Buyer mode, "what can I do to make us both happy." No wonder you're out of steam. Al-anon has been a great help to me getting my serenity back, and helping my kids learn tools to live with the situation. You had tried it before, right, did it click with you?

(((hugs)))

The drinking is something that has started within the last 10 to 12 months. While her and I would enjoy an occasional glass of wine or beer she began drinking every day. And when we'd go out with friends or to a neighbors house she'd drink till she was hammered. Out drinking everyone that was in attendance. My best buddies made comments.

It did click NEW. Just not sure I care enough to try it again.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 08:40 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by markos
MrA, you sound miserable and combative. You are shooting at the rescue helicopters.

If you want to survive the next 8 years, I really think antidepressant medication would be a good idea.

Convincing us you are right won't help your situation. Even if you are right. You might win the debate with us, and still have an unhappy life.]

His goal is to maintain the status quo. A person who has the same problems after 10 years is not seeking solutions.

Sorry I'm not taking any AD medication. I may be withdrawn and sad from my situation but I don't need to adjust the chemicals in my head to survive.

FYI: My problems aren't the same problems.

Today I'm withdrawn whereas before I was invested and upset due to a lack of my needs being met. Whereas before my biggest concerns were the lack of need meeting in my life my problems now involve other things that have turned me off. Like the drinking. And the way she communicates with me. And some of the ways she's raising the kids. My needs are still no longer being met but then I'm no longer asking that they be met. And for about the last 8 months I've stopped doing any of the things most would consider MB principles (just not you).
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 08:41 PM
Originally Posted by CWMI
Have you told your wife that you are only planning to stay until the kids are grown?

Nope. The Policy of Radical Honesty went out the door some 8 months or more ago. Along with all other MB principles.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 08:44 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Quote
Five Love Languages doesn't have a plan to transform your marriage; Marriage Builders DOES. 5LL focuses on "communication" which is cute and winsome but is a distraction from creating romantic love in the marriage. It won't help a bad marriage because there is no PLAN to do so. Even the best communicators will end up divorced if they are not in love. The fact that you don't know the difference demonstrates your lack of understanding of this program. Not to mention the fact that it hasn't helped your own marriage.

bzzzt. Wrong answer. The intention of the book was to spur on action to determine what your partner's love language was and to take action from there. There was even a chapter on what to do with a reluctant spouse who wouldn't communicate their needs (love language).

Like I said earlier, it is a book about COMMUNICATION that does nothing to restore the romantic love to marriage and you just demonstrated this point in your bolded comment above. Good communication will not restore the romantic love but Gary Chapman does not know that. 5LL does not work to create romantic love even when followed as directed.

BUT........you already know this. IT has not worked for you.

Quote
The fact you don't know what that book offers tells me your still on your one trick pony and aren't willing to be flexible with a process that is nearly identical to the one you're preaching.

This "one trick pony" is in a ROMANTIC, PASSIONATE marriage. grin Being "flexible" and following every failed dog and cat program EXCEPT MArriage Builders has not helped your own marriage. There is only ONE WAY to create romantic love in a marriage, not several ways.

5LL is completely different from Marriage Builders. But you don't know this, because you don't even own a single MB book.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 08:45 PM
Check this out, MrA:

Effective Marriage Counseling, Dr Bill Harley:

When I found that the model I've developed had helped over 90% of those I was counseling, I gave up my career as a college professor and started counseling full-time. At the time, I didn't assume that it would save all of the marriages it seemed to help, because I felt there were factors beyond a couple's control. But after 35 years of experience with this model, I'm not convinced that it works with 100% of couples who follow it. I've yet to witness one couple out of the tens of thousands I've seen, that did not experience a healthy and happy marriage by following this model. Personally, I feel it's the only answer to the question, how can a couple have a great marriage for life?

But it's very difficult to prove that one model of marital satisfaction is superior to another. The ultimate test is to randomly assign couples to various models and to measure their marital satisfaction after the provisions of each model have been implemented.

The training of therapists is a huge problem: How can we be sure that the therapist assigned to each model was properly trained? And there's also the problem of representation and random assignment: Does the group of volunteer couples represent the population at large? And is the assignment to treatment groups really random? There's also the ethical problem of assigning couples to a control group where they receive no effective treatment. When they divorce, does the researcher bear any responsibility? Finally, if someone who has a stake in the outcome does the research, it usually shows that their approach is best. Shouldn't studies of alternative models of marital satisfaction be conducted by those neutral to the outcome?

My own personal experience led me to the model I've been using for the past 35 years. But that's not proof of it's superiority over other models. What I need is objective studies conducted by those who have no bias that compare this model to others. That's hard to find even among those who have published hundreds of articles on martial therapy.

But I can direct you to three studies that support my enthusiasm. They all deal with my book, His Needs, Her Needs, the popular application of my model, and the effect it has on couples that read it.

The readers of Marriage Partnership Magazine were asked which self-help book on marriage helped their marriages the most. In that survey, His Needs, Her Needs came out on top. I didn't know that the survey was even being conducted, so when I called the editor after the results came in, I was curious to know more. He told me that it not only was the top choice, but it was far ahead of second place (Ron R. Lee. Best Books for a Better Marriage: Reader's Survey . Marriage Partnership Magazine, Spring 1998).

In a national survey that I sponsored, people were asked if any self-help book on marriage solved their marital problems. Out of 57 books that were read, only three were reported to have actually solved marital problems. The three were the Bible, James Dobson's Love for a Lifetime, and His Needs, Her Needs (Lynn Hanacek Gravel. Americans and Marriage: National Survey of US Adults. Barna Research Group, 2001).

Finally, five out of six couples that read His Needs Her Needs were found to experience significant improvement in marital satisfaction (Julie D. Braswell. The Impact of Reading a Self-Help Book on the Topic of Gender Differences on One's Perceived Quality of Marriage. Doctoral Dissertation, 1998, Azusa Pacific University.

Granted, these findings are not conclusive evidence that the model I use is superior to every other model of marital satisfaction. But when you find one that works for every couple that actually follows it, you have to be impressed. And coming as I did from almost zero effectiveness to almost complete success, I can't begin to tell you how convinced I am that it's the solution to a very difficult problem we face in our society.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 08:52 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
The fact you don't know what that book offers tells me your still on your one trick pony and aren't willing to be flexible with a process that is nearly identical to the one you're preaching.

Nor is Marriage Builders a "flexible" program. It is a very exacting program that has very specific steps. It is not flexible and it is not a cafeteria plan when you cherry pick things you like and reject things you don't like. It only works when worked in its entirety. For example, when Dr Harley was in active practice, he would refuse to counsel anyone would not commit to necessary hours to do his program. He would tell them to go elsewhere. If he told them to a certain lesson, they had to do it or he did not go onto the next step.

No flexibility at all. Being flexible is worthless if it means you don't follow the necessary steps to change your marriage. Creating romantic love is "one trick," not several.
Posted By: HoldHerHand Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 09:03 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
The fact you don't know what that book offers tells me your still on your one trick pony and aren't willing to be flexible with a process that is nearly identical to the one you're preaching.

Nor is Marriage Builders a "flexible" program. It is a very exacting program that has very specific steps. It is not flexible and it is not a cafeteria plan when you cherry pick things you like and reject things you don't like. It only works when worked in its entirety. For example, when Dr Harley was in active practice, he would refuse to counsel anyone would not commit to necessary hours to do his program. He would tell them to go elsewhere. If he told them to a certain lesson, they had to do it or he did not go onto the next step.

No flexibility at all. Being flexible is worthless if it means you don't follow the necessary steps to change your marriage. Creating romantic love is "one trick," not several.

[Linked Image from forum.cabalonline.com]


I don't always agree with Mel, but when I do... I drink Dos Equis....
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 09:04 PM
Originally Posted by HoldHerHand
[

[Linked Image from forum.cabalonline.com]


I don't always agree with Mel, but when I do... I drink Dos Equis....

Do I have to take the car keys away from you, Mister?? laugh
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 09:40 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by BrainHurts
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Heck I probably don't belong on this site anymore anyways as one of the things that have turned me off is her drinking. It's gotten excessive and there's a chance there's some dependency issues. I spoke to her about it and she dialed it back. But now this week she's back at it ...I suspect to send me a message. You withdraw I stop doing what you want.


Will she go to AA?

What about AlAnon for you?

I went a couple of years ago but that was when I wanted to know if I could help my SIL because my BIL is an alcoholic. I only went to 4 sessions. Got a lot out of it. But stopped as I realized this was going to a long journey and what I'd get would be minimal. I also hoped it would spur on my SIL to attend in a chapter close to her city.

Now? Because my wife is drinking? Hmmm. Not sure I would.

AlAnon is for people who have a loved one with a drinking problem.

Just making sure you are aware of the difference between AA and AlAnon.

Dr. Harley does recommend Alanon to people with a spouse who has an addiction problem that is not being treated.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 09:47 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
The fact you don't know what that book offers tells me your still on your one trick pony and aren't willing to be flexible with a process that is nearly identical to the one you're preaching.

But you are demonstrating that flexibility isn't working, MrAlias.

Did you just show up to argue with MelodyLane? Honestly: "Bzzt, wrong answer?" That's ridiculous.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 09:49 PM
Does 5LL recommend anti-depressants for facing 8 years of an unhappy marriage?

Because if it doesn't, it's not really "virtually identical" to Marriage Builders.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/28/12 09:52 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
The fact you don't know what that book offers tells me your still on your one trick pony and aren't willing to be flexible

It seems to me you are the inflexible one. You insist that Marriage Builders and 5LL are basically the same thing, and you aren't willing to bend on the idea. You insist that your idea of Marriage Builders is correct and that you've therefore tried it, and you aren't willing to hear otherwise.

That sounds pretty inflexible to me.
Quote
Not that it's a true barometer but she said she was happy and satisfied whenever I asked how she thought we were doing.
And what did she say when you explained to her that you were NOT happy and satisfied? What did she say when you asked her to do MB counselling with Steve?
Quote
Nope. The Policy of Radical Honesty went out the door some 8 months or more ago. Along with all other MB principles.
How do you feel we can we help you?
Quote
Nope. The Policy of Radical Honesty went out the door some 8 months or more ago.
Telling her that you're going to leave after the kids are gone isn't being Radically Honest. It's living an honest life. You are deceiving a principal person in your life (not to mention your kids!) by shutting up and 'taking it' until your last one's graduation day.

Not to mention that it might wake her up. You are keeping a critical piece of your life's information away from your family.
Quote
I don't always agree with Mel, but when I do... I drink Dos Equis....
ROFL! rotflmao
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 09/30/12 01:25 AM
Originally Posted by Dr Bill Harley, clinical psychologist and founder of Marriage Builders
"My program of marriage recovery is exactly the same as most weight loss programs. Whenever it's followed, the marriage recovers. I know of no other program of marital recovery that can make that claim. In fact, if you follow the advice of most marriage recovery programs today, your marriage will not recover. That's why a 1995 Consumer's Report survey found marriage counseling to be the least effective form of psychotherapy. Only 16% found the experience to be helpful.

For those who complete my program of marital recovery, 100% find the experience to be more than helpful -- it solves their marital problems. But just like in dieting, the successful outcome depends entirely on motivation. Only those who are not motivated enough to complete the program fail."
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/02/12 08:40 PM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
Quote
Nope. The Policy of Radical Honesty went out the door some 8 months or more ago. Along with all other MB principles.
How do you feel we can we help you?

Help me find the will and energy to care enough to try again ... I guess. Like I said earlier I'm not really sure why I came back. Probably just needed to talk to someone about this.

I'm fully aware the path I'm taking will lead to a negative result and I realize that here I will be put in my place for that along with the path I've taken so far. It wasn't the full MB path and principles and if for that I'm wasting everyone's time I suppose I should just leave or people can choose to ignore me. At least until I change my mind on the level of participation I'm ready to take. But for now I'll continue to ramble.

Right now this path is more enticing (less painful) than trying. I'm not of the mindset that being let down again or having to go it alone again is the right choice for me. I've seen enough to feel she will never join me on a MB journey and without her on-board nothing much will change. So to spend money to go it alone for her ... for us ... just feels like a bad business decision. She won't give me her approval to go it alone not that that should stop me. But I'm in withdrawal and these types of decisions no longer come from my heart they come from my head ( which is probably screwed on backwards) and my head says it's not optimal use of the money. These are my thoughts, It is where I'm at at this juncture. "I'll get more educated and be a better man and she'll still be her."

Sorry for not posting back right away. I have back spasms infrequently but they flared up again Saturday in a big way and I've been down for the count. Back to work today but I am pretty sore. Physical therapy soon to come ... again.

I must admit that a large cause of my withdrawal is just the overall energy I have left. Part of my decline in trying much of anything is due to a feeling of being beat down. I'm out of shape and I'm having a tough time getting back in shape and even have a lesser quality of life due to a number of physical issues. It's hard to maintain anything although I have been working out. Diets don't work unless it is a new way of eating and we don't see eye to eye on what that is.

My focus lately has been on trying to implement a way back into shape. That and taking care of the kids has been the focal points. I've focused my energies on those because I feel those will give me the best ROI.
Posted By: CWMI Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/03/12 01:03 AM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
Quote
Not that it's a true barometer but she said she was happy and satisfied whenever I asked how she thought we were doing.
And what did she say when you explained to her that you were NOT happy and satisfied? What did she say when you asked her to do MB counselling with Steve?

Answer this please, and not with what you 'feel' she would say.
I'll ask again:
Quote
And what did she say when you explained to her that you were NOT happy and satisfied? What did she say when you asked her to do MB counselling with Steve?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/03/12 01:22 PM
Originally Posted by maritalbliss
I'll ask again:And what did she say when you explained to her that you were NOT happy and satisfied?


Hmmm. Which time? I've informed her at least a half dozen times that I was not happy and satisfied.

Most times she says she's trying. Other times she's informed me about things I could do better ... and of course I jumped to fix them.

Right now it's different though because right now I'm not pushing. I tried to do what I can to communicate my concerns and tried to bring her on board. The last time I again mentioned doing something with the Harleys or a MB weekend she said no. I stated to her emphatically that I was going to lose interest and stop trying and that when she saw those things she would need to be concerned.

And it has happened and she continues to pretend that the problem doesn't exist ... I don't know ... she doesn't bring it up. In the last 6 months she asks what's wrong and I say the same old things that have always been wrong. It's odd because we are acting like roommates. We talk very little. We never have a laugh together. We plan no UA together at all. She does her thing and I do mine.

Quote
What did she say when you asked her to do MB counselling with Steve?

"No. That's too expensive. They're just gonna tell me what I have to do and I don't like being told what I need to do. I'll dig my heels in and I'm not interested in that". When I ask for alternatives she suggests nothing (just shrugs) or suggests the counselor we saw before through my EAP. Uhm... she's no longer counseling remember?

What is really sad is that I am at the point I really don't like much about her anymore, she knows something is seriously wrong and it's quite possible she'd be willing to try some things now. I just don't feel like trying. The thought of having another conversation where I try to persuade her in helping me fix this only makes me dislike her even more. She wants a good marriage heh she wants a marriage? She needs to step up.

I need her to entice me back. I'm not being vindictive. It is where I'm at with her. I've really lost whatever it was I had for her and I just don't believe there will ever be enough for me to feel what it is I long to feel. It sounds like I'm rewriting history when I say this ... but I know I was in love with the concept of a loving, giving, sharing partner and always wished for it ergo I strived to obtain it. She's never really been "the one".
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/03/12 03:34 PM
What can we one trick ponies do for you? grin
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/23/12 09:20 PM
It has been a few weeks since I've last posted. I continue with physical therapy and my back is doing quite well. So much so I am more able to focus on other things.

Things around the home seem to be getting worse as the big white elephant still stomps around the home while we both pretend it doesn't exist. She's spent some time away at her sisters doing the horse thing while her sister was on vacation.

I'm to the point where something's got to give. I'm so far withdrawn it's hard to muster the energy to initiate any relationship talk. But I'm definitely unhappy about hanging around like we're roommates.

I put together a letter to send to her and will do so shortly. Feel free to critique it.

What I need help is in deciding what is going to be the most helpful for me. I'm so far withdrawn I'm going to be the reluctant one in committing to a plan ... even though I'll be proposing a plan I think we need to take.

Assuming I can get her to commit to something I suggest I just don't know where I'm willing to start. If we try doing the home study I fear we'll fail due to her long term reluctance to do MB plans and my lack of motivation and desire. If I suggest phone counseling I fear she'll pull the same old "I don't like being told what I need to do" ... which in turn I'd need to hold her feet to the fire ... this or the Big D. Scary stuff.

Her is what I thought I'd send to start the ball rolling:
Quote
It's taken me a long time to work up the energy to send this. I'm sorry it has and I'm also sorry that I have to say the things I'm about to say.

I'm sure it's no surprise we're in trouble. That you and I have drifted far, far apart. Something has definitely changed for me and I feel really sad to find where I am at today.

I've lost a lot of the love that I have for you <MrsAlias>. This is something very new for me and I'm not sure exactly why it has come to this except to say that some things have been stacked up against us and we've done a poor job of tending to our marriage. I know you've been attempting a few things trying to keep some form of a relationship going but unfortunately it isn't working for me.

We need to do something different.

Because I've lost what I once had I feel lost and trapped. I'm no longer in a position where being close to you is what I desire. The reasons are plenty and as you know some of them may not be totally in your control. Still those are things I know if we worked together on a plan many of those issues would disappear. Regardless of that I find myself in a place where I really haven't felt motivated to do something about it. I mean I'm lonely and sad and thus want things to be different but something in me is keeping me from trying anything with you or rather it just isn't appealing to me.

I can't go on like this. I don't want to live the next umpteen years feeling like I have no relationship and I cannot go on not having an affectionate relationship. As of late the kids have really kept me grounded. I really don't want to break the family apart just because I've allowed my relationship with you to die. I imagine the pain it would cause the kids and thinking of what they would have to endure brings tears to my eyes. I just can't do that to them as it would be wrong and a cowardly thing to do.

I don't want a relationship with another person. I'm happy being a Dad and really wish the next few years continuing to be that, a whole family and a Dad. That thought gives me motivation. But you and I just aren't working right now.

I have ideas/plans of things we could do. Some of them are the same things I've discussed with you earlier and some of them are a bit different than what we've discussed in the past. But I really need your assistance in initiating them if you're willing to try something to fix this. I'm pretty sure with work I can get back what is lost but I'm afraid to try, to even start.

You never talk to me about us, as I've shut down talking about us, so I have no idea where you are at. I'm pretty certain you are just as unhappy as I am.

I am interested to hear what you think.
Posted By: CWMI Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/23/12 10:17 PM
How about asking her out on a date, rather than ignoring her and then telling her you don't love her? I wasn't all that interested in having sex with my H when he was ignoring me and not dating me. Women typically don't find that kind of thing appealing.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/23/12 10:28 PM
Mralias, about the only hope I see here is to get her on the phone with Steve Harley long enough for him to sell her on the MB on.ine program. If you get her on board with the online program Dr Harley and your assigned coach can run point on keeping you both motivated. That is the only way I see any hope here.

That is the plan I would have in your back pocket when you discuss solutions.

What is your plan if she says no?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/24/12 12:50 PM
Originally Posted by CWMI
How about asking her out on a date, rather than ignoring her and then telling her you don't love her? I wasn't all that interested in having sex with my H when he was ignoring me and not dating me. Women typically don't find that kind of thing appealing.

Well ... because right now ... I'm not much in the mood to date her. And by sending her the letter I at least start a conversation. Our communication is pi$$ poor right now so a date where we talk is a bad idea. We really need an overhaul to our relationship.

I definitely am not asking her to fill a lot of my ENs (SF #1, affection, RC, DS). As a matter of fact I haven't asked for my #1 to be filled in a couple of years. It gets old asking, begging only to get some scraps now and then. I think we've had sex about 6 or 7 times in the last 2 years. It's been 3.5 months now.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/24/12 01:03 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Mralias, about the only hope I see here is to get her on the phone with Steve Harley long enough for him to sell her on the MB on.ine program. If you get her on board with the online program Dr Harley and your assigned coach can run point on keeping you both motivated. That is the only way I see any hope here.

That is the plan I would have in your back pocket when you discuss solutions.

What is your plan if she says no?

Agreed. Actually I need someone to run point on myself. I'm so tired of being the point person, of trying to make the R better. I feel like a parent.

I wish I had a plan if she says NO. I know I need to have one. I'm hoping my plead that something has to change will be enough for her to agree to anything.

It is the fear of her saying that that has paralyzed me lately. I just am not ready to break up the family. I made a commitment to these kids when we made the decision to have them. I need to do right by them. But if she says no ..... sigh.

I wish I wasn't so down on us. I really feel I could get excited about doing a program that moves our R in a wonderful direction. But she's been so reluctant to do anything in the past any thoughts I have of feeling good about trying wane with the past experiences I've had trying to get her to commit to it.

I almost sense myself not pushing to better the R knowing it could be better just to spite her and her reluctance over the last decade or more.

Her and I think so differently. She doesn't believe people change. She believes you live with cards you're dealt. I say you reshuffle the cards. I don't know how she can say this because I've changed a lot since we first were married and she knows it. Grrrr. She can really be frustrating.

I think I'm just going to send the letter. I fear she won't want to talk with Steve but I think it is exactly what we need seeing we both are reluctant albeit in different ways.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/24/12 01:09 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I think I'm just going to send the letter. I fear she won't want to talk with Steve but I think it is exactly what we need seeing we both are reluctant albeit in different ways.

You would be better off if you counseled with Steve ALONE and let *HIM* help you compose the letter and tell you how to approach her. That is what I would do. He is very creative and might be able to give you a new approach that will reach her. He actually gives people talking points to do this.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/24/12 01:16 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I think I'm just going to send the letter. I fear she won't want to talk with Steve but I think it is exactly what we need seeing we both are reluctant albeit in different ways.

You would be better off if you counseled with Steve ALONE and let *HIM* help you compose the letter and tell you how to approach her. That is what I would do. He is very creative and might be able to give you a new approach that will reach her. He actually gives people talking points to do this.

I see. OK. I'll give that some thought.
Posted By: CWMI Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/24/12 01:26 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I think I'm just going to send the letter. I fear she won't want to talk with Steve but I think it is exactly what we need seeing we both are reluctant albeit in different ways.

You would be better off if you counseled with Steve ALONE and let *HIM* help you compose the letter and tell you how to approach her. That is what I would do. He is very creative and might be able to give you a new approach that will reach her. He actually gives people talking points to do this.

I see. OK. I'll give that some thought.

You should definitely do this. I did get my H to agree to coaching, but he waffled a LOT and many times he refused to get on the phone before the call, but eventually he did get on every single one.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/24/12 02:08 PM
Catch-22.

I do feel I need to, at a minimum, let her know that I'm going to call someone even if I say it is only for me.

We still agree on financial issues and for me to go spend any money on a counselor that costs as much as the Harleys do will be a big LB for her. I definitely am trying to remain respectful despite our roommate-type situation.

However, she knows I can get free counseling from my EAP so talking to her about it will create a conflict. She'll be upset that I'm spending the money.
Posted By: CWMI Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/24/12 02:14 PM
In my sitch, I did tell him I was making the call, and he could join me if he'd like, but I did not give him the option for him to say NO to me. smile I was already on MB for quite some time and I was full-on FED UP.

I wasn't going to POJA refusing to remain in an unhealthy marriage.

After that initial call, which he did join me on (he was well aware of MB), we POJA'd buying a bulk of sessions, and then another one.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/24/12 02:52 PM
Originally Posted by CWMI
In my sitch, I did tell him I was making the call, and he could join me if he'd like, but I did not give him the option for him to say NO to me.

Which is what I'm thinking I should do.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 10/24/12 05:14 PM
MrA, Steve won't counsel you together anyway so she won't be able to join you unless it is to split the call. Even so, your marriage is not in recovery so this decision can't be held hostage to the POJA when you don't even USE the POJA. When your marriage is on the verge of collapse, you don't have the best options anyway so you have to risk the LB of IB if it helps your marriage in the end.
Posted By: MrAlias The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 02:43 PM
Today I spoke of the white elephant in the room.

I provided my wife with a list of things I needed to do to make a change and at the top of the list were both doctor related.

I need to see a doc about my T levels due to a drop in energy, drive and desire.
I need to see a counselor because I can't go on living like her and I are just mother and father.

She agreed to counseling and even said she was doing some searching the last couple of weeks. I am persuading her that we see an MB counselor. She is hesitant about phone counseling (which surprised me).

Melody, she prefers to speak with a woman counselor. I suspect that is because she's expecting the topics of her past(abuse) and doesn't want to discuss it with a man.

So it's probable that Steve is out. Doesn't Steve's wife counsel too and would she be a good fit for us?
Posted By: living_well Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 02:51 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
So it's probable that Steve is out. Doesn't Steve's wife counsel too and would she be a good fit for us?


Steve's sister Jennifer Chalmers counseled us. She was blindsided by my XH but he was a world class gaslighter. It really did not matter because the moment we tried to use the Policy of Joint Agreement (POJA) he gave the game away by agreeing not to do the thing I was not comfortable with and then going off and doing it anyway.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 02:57 PM
Originally Posted by living_well
Originally Posted by MrAlias
So it's probable that Steve is out. Doesn't Steve's wife counsel too and would she be a good fit for us?


Steve's sister Jennifer Chalmers counseled us. She was blindsided by my XH but he was a world class gaslighter. It really did not matter because the moment we tried to use the Policy of Joint Agreement (POJA) he gave the game away by agreeing not to do the thing I was not comfortable with and then going off and doing it anyway.

In your opinion if you have a couple that truly wants to make a change is Jennifer more than qualified to help with that?

I don't think my wife nor I would try to manipulate the sessions. We just need a guide and someone to hold us accountable.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 02:58 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She agreed to counseling and even said she was doing some searching the last couple of weeks. I am persuading her that we see an MB counselor. She is hesitant about phone counseling (which surprised me).

Melody, she prefers to speak with a woman counselor. I suspect that is because she's expecting the topics of her past(abuse) and doesn't want to discuss it with a man.

Steve's sister, Dr Jennifer Chalmers, a psychologist, is a super counselor. I would try her. But I caution you about leaving this selection of a counselor open to her, because if you don't get a MB counselor all of your efforts will - ONCE AGAIN - be wasted.

And they won't be talking about your wife's past "abuse." That would be a waste of time. That is what BAD counselors do.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 03:00 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[

In your opinion if you have a couple that truly wants to make a change is Jennifer more than qualified to help with that?

I don't think my wife nor I would try to manipulate the sessions. We just need a guide and someone to hold us accountable.

I think Jennifer would be PERFECT for you two. I agree with livingwell that Jennifer might not be as good with gaslighters, but your wife is not a gaslighter. Some of the best marriages on this forum were saved by Dr Chalmers. Papabear and Mamabear have a fabulous marriage today because of Dr Chalmers.
Posted By: living_well Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 03:00 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
In your opinion if you have a couple that truly wants to make a change is Jennifer more than qualified to help with that?

I don't think my wife nor I would try to manipulate the sessions. We just need a guide and someone to hold us accountable.


Yes, she will be very good for that.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 03:03 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She agreed to counseling and even said she was doing some searching the last couple of weeks. I am persuading her that we see an MB counselor. She is hesitant about phone counseling (which surprised me).

You need to make this happen, my friend, and don't squander another opportunity. I would call up Dr Chalmers and get an appt. Tell your wife you wanted to counsel ALONE to get help for your OWN PROBLEMS and then see about bringing her in. Then let Dr C tell you how to invite your wife into a session. They split sessions - they don't counsel you together anyway.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 03:09 PM
Quote
But I caution you about leaving this selection of a counselor open to her, because if you don't get a MB counselor all of your efforts will - ONCE AGAIN - be wasted.

And they won't be talking about your wife's past "abuse." That would be a waste of time. That is what BAD counselors do.


She agreed it's hard to know if a counselor is good and I explained that's because they don't have a proven plan.

I have it written in my mind that this is the way I need to go. She can join me or go her own way.

I'm sure she will follow me. SO THIS BETTER WORK OR I'M A DEAD MAN! lol

I think my wife will want to talk about the abuse as it gets in her way ... no matter how well her and I are doing. I know she's tired of living with her anxieties and OCD. But I am just speculating what she's thinking and that's not my job. Her and Jennifer will have to hash that out.

Our last counselor did a couple of techniques with my wife and they were VERY effective and a great relief for my wife. So that's why I speculate about the abuse. She wants more of the same.

Thanks for the feedback.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 03:10 PM
Close the deal!!
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 03:15 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
I know she's tired of living with her anxieties and OCD. But I am just speculating what she's thinking and that's not my job. Her and Jennifer will have to hash that out.

And see, Dr Chalmers is a licensed psychologist who is trained in those areas and she can help her with PRESENT problems without delving into childhood "issues." But like you said, you don't have to deal with that, let Dr C handle that!

The Harleys believe that delving into childhood issues is a way to keep people coming back to counseling for YEARS and serves as a distraction from solving current problems.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 03:21 PM
Why don't they list her credentials on the website? I want to send my wife some info.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 03:25 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Why don't they list her credentials on the website? I want to send my wife some info.

CALL the coaching center and ask them to send her credentials. AND MAKE THE DAMN APPOINTMENT!!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 03:54 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Why don't they list her credentials on the website? I want to send my wife some info.

CALL the coaching center and ask them to send her credentials. AND MAKE THE DAMN APPOINTMENT!!

Have a little faith. grin lol
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 04:29 PM
Hi, MrA, it's good to see you back, and fantastic to hear you guys are going to speak with Dr. Chalmers! I agree with MelodyLane: make an appointment for yourself with Jennifer, immediately with no delay. Dr. Chalmers can help you get your wife involved. Not so long ago you were posting about how you were practically paralyzed, so you need to get to speaking to her right away to get you moving.

After that, I would move toward the goal MelodyLane mentioned earlier: use Dr. Chalmers to get your wife on board with the MB online program, and then you can work directly with an assigned coach and Dr. Harley to keep you both motivated.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 05:41 PM
Originally Posted by markos
Hi, MrA, it's good to see you back, and fantastic to hear you guys are going to speak with Dr. Chalmers! I agree with MelodyLane: make an appointment for yourself with Jennifer, immediately with no delay. Dr. Chalmers can help you get your wife involved. Not so long ago you were posting about how you were practically paralyzed, so you need to get to speaking to her right away to get you moving.

After that, I would move toward the goal MelodyLane mentioned earlier: use Dr. Chalmers to get your wife on board with the MB online program, and then you can work directly with an assigned coach and Dr. Harley to keep you both motivated.

I will be making the call a little later. I can't do it at work here as there is no real place for privacy.

She agreed to me scheduling an appt with Dr Chalmers. Meanwhile I assume she's contemplating what she wants to do.

Ugh. Stupid Health Spending Acct. Marriage Counseling is not an eligible expense. Maybe I should fake a nervous breakdown so it will be covered and I can spend the money I've deposited into the account. Grrrr. frown
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 06:10 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by markos
Hi, MrA, it's good to see you back, and fantastic to hear you guys are going to speak with Dr. Chalmers! I agree with MelodyLane: make an appointment for yourself with Jennifer, immediately with no delay. Dr. Chalmers can help you get your wife involved. Not so long ago you were posting about how you were practically paralyzed, so you need to get to speaking to her right away to get you moving.

After that, I would move toward the goal MelodyLane mentioned earlier: use Dr. Chalmers to get your wife on board with the MB online program, and then you can work directly with an assigned coach and Dr. Harley to keep you both motivated.

I will be making the call a little later. I can't do it at work here as there is no real place for privacy.

She agreed to me scheduling an appt with Dr Chalmers. Meanwhile I assume she's contemplating what she wants to do.

Ugh. Stupid Health Spending Acct. Marriage Counseling is not an eligible expense. Maybe I should fake a nervous breakdown so it will be covered and I can spend the money I've deposited into the account. Grrrr. frown
You can also request an appointment by email and let them know your 3 preferred days and times. This may be sooner than waiting to call.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 07:35 PM
You can email them and ask for the appointment.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 08:13 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
You can email them and ask for the appointment.

If figure the phone call will cut to the quick.

Otherwise I could play email tag trying to find a time available that works for me. I'd have to do this before or after work and with 3 kids and school functions well ... trying to plan anything gets interesting that's for sure.

Also I would like to talk to a real body about the 5 session discount but at this point I'm unsure how many sessions we'll require. Please don't tell me 20 as I can't afford that! ;-)
Posted By: living_well Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 08:44 PM
Jennifer Chalmers does evenings, Steve does mornings.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 08:48 PM
Originally Posted by living_well
Jennifer Chalmers does evenings, Steve does mornings.

Super. That'll work out perfectly then. Not sure I'm alert enough at 6am when I'm just about to work to participate in a counseling session. Best wait til I'm at my best ... er ... uhm ... whenever that is.
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 08:54 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
You can email them and ask for the appointment.

If figure the phone call will cut to the quick.

Otherwise I could play email tag trying to find a time available that works for me. I'd have to do this before or after work and with 3 kids and school functions well ... trying to plan anything gets interesting that's for sure.

Also I would like to talk to a real body about the 5 session discount but at this point I'm unsure how many sessions we'll require. Please don't tell me 20 as I can't afford that! ;-)

I suggest you get into the online program with Dr. Harley long before 20 sessions is even on the horizon!
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 10/31/12 09:02 PM
MrA, I absolutely agree with Markos. I would get 5 sessions with Dr Chalmers in order to persuade your wife to get into the online program. You need help every step of the way and you are not going to be able to go through the whole program on your own. You need the full treatment. You will need the help of the MB coaches and Dr Harley to keep you two on the right track every step of way.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/01/12 12:23 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
MrA, I absolutely agree with Markos. I would get 5 sessions with Dr Chalmers in order to persuade your wife to get into the online program. You need help every step of the way and you are not going to be able to go through the whole program on your own. You need the full treatment. You will need the help of the MB coaches and Dr Harley to keep you two on the right track every step of way.

Thank you.

I ended up using the online form this morning seeing I got their machine this morning. I did request we see Dr. Chalmers, that I would like 5 sessions and that I was hoping my wife would take some sessions with her.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/01/12 02:02 PM
What the heck?

Dr. Chalmers doesn't offer the 5 session discount. Steve does.

Grrrrrrrrrr.

I just need a facilitator and coach to guide us into and through the program.

I am quite disappointed by this.

I don't want to hear how expensive a divorce is as the reasoning to spend that much. A divorce would be in the future not now. Granted I lose 8 more years of what could be a good marriage.

I think I'm going to book one appointment with Jennifer and one for my wife and hope that the good Dr. can get us going on the program. That's going to save us close to 8 bills. My wife has agreed that sounds like a good plan.

If she thinks we need more than the one apiece then so be it ...
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/01/12 02:11 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
What the heck?

Dr. Chalmers doesn't offer the 5 session discount. Steve does.

Wow, I never knew that!

But I am glad you guys are both going to talk to her. I would try to steer towards Dr. Harley's program, if Jennifer can sell her on it.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/01/12 02:30 PM
Wow, do they ever need to update their payment method options.

They are actually asking me to send a CC # via email to them. Uhm. NO! That is an unsecured method of communication and I'm not going to do that.

So I've picked a time for me and a time for her and now I'm going to go call the Center to give them the number over the phone. That's, at least, a little less risky.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/06/12 03:23 PM
I need a little help.

My wife and I are in counseling with Dr. Chalmers. My wife has her first session tonight. It's my hope she's able to get us going on one of the MB options so this time her and I have a better plan and eliminate the issues that make our M fail.

I still remain withdrawn however my wife and I have begun to interact more and even have had a little bit of physical contact (hugs, snuggling, etc). I'm making some effort but it's too early, of course, for me to feel invested in her. I do have a vision of where I'd like to be and I'd like it to be with her. But the past is a deterrent to those feelings and until they do I'm vulnerable.

As an admission of guilt I have the wandering eye syndrome lately and any advice that people can provide that will keep me focused will be of great help.

I'm trying to do my part. As another admission I have a good friend here at work and it is a female friend that has been a huge help to my M. She's kept me honest and is quick with the hammer to set me straight. I think she enjoys the hammer part. :-) I've already informed her that our talks as friends is going to have to change. That I can no longer talk about personal issues. She's of no threat to my M as I'm in no way interested in her nor will I ever be. She is a true friend and friend of the M. However this could be an issue in my M as my W knows I chat a lot to this girl. This is something I'd like to discuss as it is the one principles of MB that I've struggled with. All of the people that have been of huge help to me and my M have been women. Let's face it, not too many guys are into fixing their buddy's marriages or even care to talk about their Ms and I have zero male friends that even know about this program. These female friends (plus my sister) are all very familiar with MB and have used parts of the materials to help in their Ms. So where do I go from here? If I don't have a close friend to confide in and keep me honest, what should I do?

FYI: No I did not discuss this in my one session with Dr. Chalmers as I'm just admitting to myself today that I need to change it and thus do this plan the right way. I will certainly fess up in our next session.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/06/12 03:27 PM
1. stop talking about your marriage to other people except us, your wife and Dr Chalmers. STOP THAT

2. stop gawking at other women
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/06/12 03:31 PM
I think you are in the bad habit of venting and seem to enjoy doing that. It has not helped your marriage in any way, shape or form. IT has prevented you from solving marriage problems.

I noticed that you had been coming to this forum venting for years at the expense of looking for solutions. That is what I noticed immediately about you.

Venting is a distraction from looking for solutions. Stop venting and focus all your time on learning the principles of this program. You won't learn that from your female friend or your sister. You will learn that from reading the material here and implementing the principles in your marriage. Your WIFE should become your closest confidant.
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/06/12 04:39 PM
MrA, my first reaction is: HOORAY! I am so glad to hear that both you and your wife are talking to Dr. Chalmers. This is great! This is fantastic!

Regarding other women, just do it. One of the greatest things you can offer to persuade your wife to do Marriage Builders, whole hog, including the parts that matter to you is to do Marriage Builders yourself, whole hog, including the parts that matter to your wife.

As an example, last year I let my wife know from work that I was about to head out for lunch. She responded something to the effect that I got to do anything I wanted while she was always constrained by this "POJA" she didn't like. And I simply replied that since she didn't want me to go out to lunch, I wouldn't. And I hardly go out to lunch any more.

The big thing was this: my wife noticed. I was willing to put the principles into practice even when it constrained me, even when I didn't much like the result. And it helped to win her over.
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/06/12 04:41 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Let's face it, not too many guys are into fixing their buddy's marriages or even care to talk about their Ms and I have zero male friends that even know about this program.

What am I, chopped liver??? smile Seriously, I am ready and willing to help you and to be a GUY you can talk to about stuff. I like helping people learn how they can fix their marriages.

Of course the thing about being a really good friend is sometimes we have to tell each other what we don't want to hear. :P
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/06/12 05:00 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
As another admission I have a good friend here at work and it is a female friend that has been a huge help to my M. She's kept me honest and is quick with the hammer to set me straight. I think she enjoys the hammer part. :-) I've already informed her that our talks as friends is going to have to change. That I can no longer talk about personal issues. She's of no threat to my M as I'm in no way interested in her nor will I ever be. She is a true friend and friend of the M. However this could be an issue in my M as my W knows I chat a lot to this girl. This is something I'd like to discuss as it is the one principles of MB that I've struggled with. All of the people that have been of huge help to me and my M have been women. Let's face it, not too many guys are into fixing their buddy's marriages or even care to talk about their Ms and I have zero male friends that even know about this program. These female friends (plus my sister) are all very familiar with MB and have used parts of the materials to help in their Ms.

Despite all of the help you have sought from these people, it hasn't worked.

There are a lot of people who claim to "know Marriage Builders." But I'll tell you one thing, your friend with the hammer didn't hammer something she should have: she should not have talked to you about your marriage.

I help men and women on this site. (Try to, anyway.) I do not help women in person. One thing I know from Marriage Builders is that people fall in love with the people they talk to about their problems!

There's no need to let people know you won't talk about personal issues any more. Just stop doing it. If they have a strong reaction, that's a pretty good sign that you need a taller wall between you and that person.
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/06/12 05:01 PM
For all the money you are paying for Dr. Chalmers, I hope you are supplementing with the free daily help from Dr. Harley:

http://www.marriagebuilders.com/graphic/mbi4200_radio.html

Sit in class every day. I promise you it will help.
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/06/12 05:08 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I need a little help.

My wife and I are in counseling with Dr. Chalmers. My wife has her first session tonight. It's my hope she's able to get us going on one of the MB options so this time her and I have a better plan and eliminate the issues that make our M fail.

MrAlias,

I am seriously thrilled that you guys are seeing Dr. Chalmers. I hope you'll both put all of these principles into practice. You will be so happy. Even if you just start, really scrupulously doing this stuff, your wife stands a good chance of responding.

As you say, it's too early for the feelings to respond. But if you can get with it and stick with it, there is a lot of reason to be optimistic.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/06/12 05:35 PM
Originally Posted by markos
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Let's face it, not too many guys are into fixing their buddy's marriages or even care to talk about their Ms and I have zero male friends that even know about this program.

What am I, chopped liver??? smile Seriously, I am ready and willing to help you and to be a GUY you can talk to about stuff. I like helping people learn how they can fix their marriages.

Of course the thing about being a really good friend is sometimes we have to tell each other what we don't want to hear. :P

Well, for one I haven't had much interaction with you over the years Markos. The ones (male and female) that I did have interactions here with have long since moved on. Not saying that would stop me from interacting with you now just that it's hard to trust someone till they've earned that trust.

A forum , in particular this forum, is a difficult place to do that because you do get to hear the things you don't want to hear and you have to interact with people that you don't always see everything eye to eye.
There are posts that I need to let settle before I reply otherwise I react instead of processing the message properly. (I haven't always been successful in doing that BTW).

I understand the reasoning of having no personal contacts of the opposite sex. I do. I get it and am fully aware of the potential hazards of having them. I've seen them in action. For me it has always been a morale of mine that I would never have an affair. I would never do that to myself. I've seen enough infidelity within my family to know it isn't worth it. Plan A, Plan B, Plan D. Find someone else. Regardless I've already stopped doing it. As of last week I am only having those types of conversations with my sister.

This last post was meant as more than a vent. I recognize the vulnerable position I am in and am asking for people's help in keeping me accountable and seeing if they had any ideas on what to do while I feel nothing for my wife.

Things are in motion based on ME taking action. After tonight it is my hope that her and I start down the path of working the program together. If she refuses, yet again, to participate in the program then I have a decision to make, go it alone or just go. I am optimistic.

Thanks for your feedback marko.

PS: I make attempts about 2 or 3 times a week to listen to the radio program over my lunch hour (aka right now). The transmission over my smartphone isn't always successful. Some times it works other times it doesn't.

As time permits I will provide you with some info on many of the things I've done over the last 9-10 years. I've had some fascinating experiences.

Right now I'm working on some homework the Dr. gave me.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/06/12 06:14 PM
Today's Radio broadcast is about a W with H relunctant to join her in the MB program.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/07/12 01:28 PM
She said YES to the program and thanked me for doing this!!!!!!
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/07/12 01:33 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She said YES to the program and thanked me for doing this!!!!!!

hurray hurray hurray hurray hurray hurray hurray hurray hurray hurray
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/07/12 05:55 PM
That's fantastic! I am so happy to hear this!!!
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/08/12 02:08 AM
BTW, what homework did Dr. Chalmers give you? Have you completed it, yet?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/08/12 01:15 PM
A few small things. We meet together with Dr. J Sunday.

15-30 minutes of reading a day. Right now we're both rereading the tour (Hmmm I assume she is). I ordered HNHN, LBs, FILSIL. They'll be here tomorrow. Love Amazon Prime!!!

We have to fill out the EN Questionaires and the "I would love it if" document before Sunday. We're not to share them yet.

I've sent Dr. J a short letter of a "I would love it if" topic so she can provide feedback. She's helping me with my LBs (currently DJs and Dishonesty(no PORH). She pointed out my issue where I make statements where I'm trying to educate my wife. It's funny cause I heard what I was saying and knew it didn't feel right and the good Dr caught it immediately.

Our primary homework is getting 20 hours of UA time. We have a few small plans but we definitely don't have enough slated to get to 20. It's my hope we can sit down tonight and look at the RC inventory.
Last night we spent about 90 minutes together. We're going to be starting a new way of eating in the household and our new Marlene Koch cookbooks showed up yesterday. So we spent that time together looking over the 1st of her books and jotting down the recipes we'd love to try. I am really psyched about that because one of my biggest issues right now is myself, my weight and physical condition (plantar fascitiis, back spasms due to loose discs, chrondomalacia(sp?) which is a knee cap issue. If I could lose weight I will look and feel better ... and that'll go a long ways towards improving my attitude and behavior. I've been struggling trying to improve my ailments and have spent a ton of dough doing so and yet I still am having problems. It's depressing.

This weekend (well Sunday) we will begin the new eating plan. It's going to be a great opportunity for her and I to spend some quality time together. We have to plan, purchase and prepare these meals and we're going to do it together.

Marko I've got a long ways to go to get back to doing things the appropriate way. I have a sich with her right now where I can even be honest with her. I just can't get myself to tell the truth. She's going back to her sisters again this Saturday after just being there last Sunday. She lives about an hour and a half away. It's where my wife boards her 2 quarter horses. She has a legitimate reason for going but she could have taken care of it Sunday.

It's too early for me to expect her to change her ways so the fact she's going back yet we haven't discussed our 20 hours of UA time yet is concerning to me.

I've been honest with her in the past and it helped some but I really need to get back to it. I'm sort of entrenched in my bad behavior of just not caring and thus I say nothing.

Is it bad that I'm waiting for my wife (expectation) to tell me she's excited about this plan and that she sees the value in it for her, that she admits she needs to change? So far all she's said to me is thank you for doing this, I'm glad it is making you feel better and that honestly she feels she's being pushed.

I'm sure this is going to help and maybe I shouldn't care how we get to a better place, just that we get there, but it would sure be easier for me is she seemed enthusiastic about it. I realize I'm probably LB'ing for saying all of that but it has always been an indicator of to me of our situation when I hear and see her reactions to me wanting more. It says a lot about her and I know she gets to own that but it's tiring being on the receiving side of resistance. It feels like she doesn't care enough even though it's probably really more about her fears than anything.

Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/09/12 09:58 PM
MrA, all of this sounds great.

Regarding the disrespectful judgment of educating our wives: that's sure an easy temptation to fall into, isn't it? I'll confess that I found disrespectful judgments one of the hardest things to recognize and eliminate. There were just so many things that my wife found disrespectful! Because it turns out I was just really a disrespectful jerk. But I'll tell you what, systematically eliminating all of this is worth it. It's the beginning of what will make the difference.

One thing you may find is that until you completely eliminate the three abusive love busters, your wife may just plain not be enthusiastic about spending time with you. I experienced a lot of that. And I made it worse by trying to demand that my wife do these things. But of course, what woman wants to spend time with a man who is abusing her? crazy This has been the biggest reason for us taking longer than we should have to get traction with the Marriage Builders plan, so I encourage you to take the elimination of abusive love busters really seriously! And follow Dr. Harley's rule that if your wife feels something is disrespectful, demanding, or angry, then it is. I relied a whole lot on Steve Harley and then on our coach from the MB accountability program to tell me why the things my wife identified as disrespectful were disrespectful. I've got to confess, I was the epitome of "clueless husband"!!!

Loving Amazon Prime -- yes, me too!! And I think it's one of my wife's emotional needs or something. I first signed up for a "trial" Amazon Prime membership so we could get free fast shipping on a bunch of anger management materials I ordered last year, and I think most of our disposable income has gone to Amazon ever since. smile In particular, we've sent out a lot of Marriage Builders books, and bought several to give to engaged couples in our church.

One thing you'll find that Dr. Harley says is that he really puts a lot of burden on the husband for the success of the marriage. There's a lot of pump priming necessary to turn around a bad marriage, and a wife typically just does NOT have the stamina for it. What you will find is that if you patiently lead, your wife will likely follow. You'll have to lead by eliminating the love busters and establishing a new environment that is attractive for her to live in, and love busters will drive her back into withdrawal, and you'll be stuck wanting to judge her for that and claim that she's not doing the work but you'll find that that is counterproductive. Leave it to Dr. Chalmers to motivate and educate her, not you, because your wife will likely be VERY sensitive to that and trying to do it will drive her away and sabotage your efforts. Hopefully later on you guys will be able to get into the accountability program and you'll be able to continue to rely on a coach from Dr. Harley to do that.

Are you listening daily to the radio program? That's where Dr. Harley throws in a lot of those comments like the fact that he's harder on men and puts more burden on them. He's really mean that way. smile BUT, that's what has kept me motivated through a LOT of ups and downs the last couple years as we have learned to turn things around and eliminate the love busters. The prize, those hours of time together every week and that feeling of romantic love, is there for you, so lnog as you keep motivated and eradicate those love busters.
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/09/12 10:02 PM
Quote
Is it bad that I'm waiting for my wife (expectation) to tell me she's excited about this plan and that she sees the value in it for her, that she admits she needs to change?

A little.

Don't try to tell your wife what her feelings should be. She may simply not feel much of that until you are further down the road. And it will withdraw love units for you to imply that she should feel different.

Patiently take each step: eliminate love busters, solve one problem at a time, schedule time together, read the material, listen to the radio show, and her feelings will follow.
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/09/12 10:04 PM
MrA, did Dr. Chalmers administer Dr. Harley's personality test to you guys? And if so, did she discuss it? I think Prisca and I took this test when we started with Steve, and again when we did the seminar; I came back after I'd learned a lot more and requested to see my scores, and found out that I rate really, really high on that test. Which means I am an extremely "reactive" person, very likely to have an "ejection seat" personality (one of the concepts Dr. Harley mentions on the radio). It can be helpful to know where yo urate on this test. If you rate very highly you will probably have a lot of work to do to learn to control love busters.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/11/12 02:44 PM
Thanks for the reply Markos. I will definitely remain focused on the tasks at hand knowing the results of our efforts will prove worthwhile. Being withdrawn I certainly have my Taker out and it wants to know this isn't going to be another futile attempt.

We meet as a couple with Dr J tonight. She hasn't asked that we take the personality test. I know I did that some years back. It's been so long I forget what my acronym was.

Just a quick update. Her and I have been doing the affectionate things we did before. I took a leap and figured I'd better start the fake-it-til-I-make-it or this is never going to work.

So we've had a lot of intimate conversations (heh any convo would be an improvement for me. I really shut down). We've been hugging a lot and giving pecks on the cheek.

Yesterday we had a serious talk about my withdrawal and the funk I'm in. Not sure we accomplished much but she heard what I had to say and I heard her concern.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/12/12 02:44 PM
Markos, about the LoveBusters.

I get that. I'm not saying I know for a fact I'm successful at eliminating them but I'm aware that what my wife feels is how she feels and I have no right to question or convince her otherwise. I learned that long ago. Hopefully I'm aware enough that I'm not stepping all over that LB.

The education part regarding MB is tough for me. I buy into this program (learning more every day) but she doesn't. I try to phrase my beliefs in that form ... here's what I believe is true for me. It's my hope that she listens and gives consideration to what I'm saying because if she were to begin to trust and truly believe this plan is the plan to a sustainable, romantic love we'd eliminate a large obstacle. I am trying to be careful to use "I" statements and let her know what feels true for me ... not what she could/should be doing or believing.

We had another convo yesterday where we were discussing where our time with Dr J is going. My wife again said I don't buy into it. I don't believe I have to do everything everyone says or say everything in just the right way to have a good marriage. I didn't reply tempting as it was to say something. I figured I'd say the wrong thing and knowing we were meeting with Dr J later I would address it with her then. And I did and she said she's still on board so let's just keep going.

I opened up to her and let her know how bad my withdrawal had gotten. She informed me she thinks our M problems have to do with my own internal struggles. I explained my thoughts to her. That while I am struggling internally with things like my weight, physical ailments and my drop in drive those aren't the only reasons I'm unhappy in our M. I reiterated the same statement I've been saying to her for years ... "While you try to meet my most important need it has never been what I consider to be acceptable to me. It's too infrequent. I cannot wait 3 weeks to 3 months to have sex and feel I'm being taken care of."

Something my wife said then, albeit I was taken aback, gave me hope. She said she too had become withdrawn and that I too for some time hadn't been meeting her needs. I figured back a year or more ago and prior to that that I was doing well because that is what she said when I asked the question "What can I do better?". She'd reply nothing. I'm relatively happy.

Regardless, I now have hope because Dr J is taking us down a path where we practice exactly what it is our partner needs. So while I felt a bit duped or confused by her statement I realize it doesn't matter. The past is that past and I now have an opportunity to get it right this time. While depressed knowing there is conflict coming I'm excited because conflict is the only way back to intimacy. Hopefully by doing this program and me getting it right this time we will create a lifestyle that is conducive to a sustainable, romantic love. That saying the right things and doing what it takes to make each other happy and working together to protect each other and our M is really the right way for a marriage to work.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/12/12 02:53 PM
To your point Markos I can't wait to get to the LB communications because I think that is where I may learn a lot more of what I do that kills the romance for my wife.

But that is all in due time. Right now we're doing the ENs, trying to make "I'd love it if" statements and we're trying to recognize and change the LBs we know of.
Have you had a check-up lately with a primary care doctor? From some of the things you have mentioned I think you may have an issue with low testosterone. Very common and very easy to take care of it. If you do end up needing T therapy you will be amazed at how your energy level and outlook will change. You will have a spring in your step again and things that seemed hopeless will no longer seem so overwhelming. Increased T is also really helpful with exercising and getting in shape. If your T level is low it is nearly impossible to gain muscle or lose fat. My hubby started T therapy several months ago and the improvements have been amazing. He was in a "fog" and had kinda checked out on our marriage and life in general. Now he is back to being the man I fell in love with , no more depressive/funky state. I think it would be worth your while to have it checked.
Have you ever asked your wife what makes her feel loved the most? Like does she feel more loved if you bring her flowers, fix the dishwasher, or by doing a date night/spending quality time with her? A lot of times if women don't get their most important needs met it is difficult for her to be concerned with your needs. Not that she is doing it to be spiteful, it is often a subconscious thing that makes her feel unattracted to you. If you somehow find out how to make her feel more loved I think she will naturally be more attracted to you and want more sex. Stick with your plans to eat healthier and work out. **EDIT** Good luck!
Quote
**EDIT**
HUH? dontknow **EDIT** Do tell, Better2gether. Are you versed in this phenomenon?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/13/12 02:03 PM
Better, Thank you for the post. I have stated to my wife that I need to get in, not just for a T check, but for a regular physical as well.

It's time for me to stop procrastinating and do this. If I call now I can get in with my practitioner early next year .... yikes. He's a very popular guy. That works out well though as getting to the doctor is difficult to do right now as I've burned all my paid time off hours.

I still have some drive, some energy so it isn't an emergency thing that I get in. I'm still doing my 45 minute exercise routine for my back. And now that her and I are back being rather affectionate I wouldn't turn her down if she initiated SF.

I will take some time to make that call.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/13/12 02:06 PM
Oh and as far as what she needs to feel loved that will come out through our sessions with Dr. Chalmer. Her and I have to share our top 5 ENs this week along with some "I'd love it if" statements.

My wife informed me that I haven't been meeting her needs so I look forward to the opportunity to be a better husband.
It is a pretty common occurrence @maritalbliss . ***EDIT***

That's awesome. ***EDIT*** You won't waste efforts on things that don't really matter and will be able to get on the same page in your relationship. Glad you plan to get the physical. If they have a waiting list try to get on it, people cancel constantly this time of year. Once any medical issues are addressed the other things get so much easier to fix. I think all of your efforts are really going to pay off.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/14/12 01:13 PM
I had an interesting talk with my wife last night. She revealed something to me that I hadn't heard her reveal before.

As she puts it she has trouble with SF because she continually hears this message in her head that says guys only want one thing and in her life that's what she's experienced. She said I was the exception of course and that she was sorry and that she was trying.

I thanked her for sharing and let her know I'd be willing to do anything it would take to help her squash those thoughts when it came to being with me. I stopped short of recommending she see someone about it. She was quite upset and it breaks my heart to see her upset.

We also talked a little bit about the concepts of MB and she expressed her fear that it was going to make her give up things she loved to do ... like spend time with her sister and her horses. I put her mind at ease best I could by discussing the concept of win/win compromise but also informed her that I wasn't the right one to educate her on MB principles after it was apparent she could only see sacrifice coming. I encouraged her to read the books so the good Dr could explain the policies and principles.

It was a good talk. I thanked her for being open and honest and told her that that was very important to me in our relationship.

Now I'm wondering ... what should I do with this information regarding these negative thoughts she has?

Recommend she see someone?
Recommend she, at least, mention it to Dr J?
Mention it to Dr J myself?
Do nothing and just continue on with our current plan?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/15/12 01:51 PM
Never mind I sent this on to Dr J. Hopefully she doesn't mind me emailing her with these questions and concerns I have.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/15/12 02:56 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Never mind I sent this on to Dr J. Hopefully she doesn't mind me emailing her with these questions and concerns I have.
I think Dr. J is your best path. Please let us know what she says.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/15/12 03:40 PM
MrA, my first thought is, it's great that your wife was able to talk to you about these feelings and for you to receive them non-judgmentally. Absolutely HUGE. The conversation probably deposited a lot of Love Bank units in your account in her Love Bank. This is probably a big step down the road towards her being in love with you.

Just the talking about it is great! Investigating, informing, and understanding your spouse is one of Dr. Harley's four Friends of good conversation. And conversation is just about the most important emotional need in the world to winning back most withdrawn wives.

I know that's hard for men, because we hear the problem and we want to solve the problem. smile And when the problem involves us, it hits really close to home and it's easy to get emotional, and from there to irrational, and from there to love busting. Nothing strikes fear into a man's heart more than "I'm not really sure how enthusiastic I am about sex..." So the fact that you kept your cool and let her talk about her feelings shows you are really doing a good job at this.

And I have good news for you. In Dr. Harley's experience, almost all sexual problems simply vanish once the wife is in love with her husband. He's treated couples where the wife was abused, molested, victimized by incest in childhood, etc., and he's seen sexual relationships normalize once the wife is in love with the husband. He says it happens nine times out of ten.

I will share my experience: Prisca and I have been in and out of love a lot, sad to say (and I'll just say that as long as we practice the habits of Marriage Builders, we stay in love!) and during that time, Prisca's sex drive has ranged all the way from pure aversion to can't get enough. It really is true that when my account in her love bank crosses the romantic love threshold, sexual problems vanish.

I'm going to go dig up a couple of my favorite quotes and radio shows by Dr. Harley on this subject for you to read while you're waiting for Dr. Chalmers' response. smile
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/15/12 03:53 PM
Okay, here is the first article from Dr. Harley that I have in mind:

http://www.marriagebuilders.com/graphic/mbi5013_qa.html

Originally Posted by Dr. Harley
On the other hand, sexual inhibitions are relatively easy to overcome using other methods that do not require a rehash of the past. I believe you can learn to meet his emotional need for sex in spite of unpleasant experiences you may have had in your childhood.

One of the greatest sexual inhibitors is a bad relationship. If you and your husband are not getting along very well, and that seems to be the case if he is threatening to leave you, your first order of business is to resolve your marital conflicts by taking each other's feeling into account. I'm afraid that more or better sex will not accomplish that objective. When a couple has a bad relationship, I do not begin by encouraging more sex. First I fix the relationship, and nine times out of ten, sexual problems disappear, with or without unresolved childhood experiences. I spend very little time fixing sexual problems these days because most couples I counsel don't have sexual problems after they have learned to follow the Policy of Joint Agreement.

If I could be convinced that you do, in fact, have a loving and caring relationship with your husband, and you still have sexual problems, then my advice for you can be found in my response to the letter that follows.

The basic approach Dr. Harley uses to marital problem solving, he calls "concentric circles," meaning he starts with the smallest "circle," the smallest and easiest solution to the problem, and expands out from there if necessary. So in the case of sexual problems, the first thing he does is fixes the relationship: get the couple following the Policy of Joint Agreement (and the Policy of Undivided Attention), and nine times out of ten, the sexual problems disappear. In the other 10% of cases, he does have means for treating that that he would move on to.

In my next post, I'll provide a radio show from Dr. Harley that explains WHY sexual problems disappear when the relationship becomes good.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/15/12 04:02 PM
This is one of my all time favorite radio shows. Be sure and give it a listen. And if you can't listen to the radio shows, let's round up BrainHurts; she is good at troubleshooting that for people (I think if you can't listen you basically have to switch browsers or upgrade Flash or something):

http://www.marriagebuilders.com/radio_program/play_segment.cfm?sid=68

Originally Posted by Dr. Harley
There is something about romantic love that creates a special incentive to do the things that the other person needs. So a man and a woman that are in love with each other romantically -- which this person doesn't seem to value (not yet, we hope he'll get there, yes) -- if they're in love with each other romantically, your emotions kick in and encourage you to do things that you might not need yourself.

Woman become far more sexually oriented when they are in love. They are more interested in helping them out domestically; they are more interested in looking better for him. They are more interested in going to football games along with him and participating in his recreational activities.

And men, when they're in love, they're more interested in talking to her for hours at a time, to being affectionate with her; they are interested in being more honest and open. In other words, they are more interested in meeting each other's needs when they're in love.

So, the point of my seminars, and the books that I write, says, look: being in love is a big deal. It'll make your relationship really move along, and be very, very, very good for you, and all of his "utility needs" end up being met in a relationship where there is mutual love.

That's the magic that I have seen: when my wife is in love, her sexual feelings follow. When she is not in love, making love to me feels off to her; it feels like I am using her, it feels like sex is all about my needs and not about her, etc.

So I hope this encourages you, MrAlias: just keep walking down this path, keep steadily making love bank deposits and learning to avoid love bank withdrawals, and practice these new habits until they are ironclad and you are doing them all the time without thinking, and there is a 90% chance that at some point, you will know when your wife crosses the romantic love threshold, because suddenly those problems from past experiences will become much less of an issue.
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/15/12 04:11 PM
One key thing to realize about passing the love bank threshold is that it is sudden, not gradual. One day, the balance is not quite at the threshold, and she tolerates you. The next day, you've made just a couple more deposits more, and Dr. Harley says men wake up and it's like they are married to a different woman. He's had men call him and ask if he thinks their wives are taking hormones or something. Then, the love bank balance dips right back down below the threshold, and she goes back to merely tolerating her husband. And that up and down behavior may continue for awhile until he builds a big enough balance in her love bank that random dips are still not going down below that threshold for romantic love.

Here is my favorite radio show of all time, where Dr. Harley describes this. I'm not sure what segment it is in, but it's very encouraging, and it agrees with my experience:

http://www.marriagebuilders.com/radio_program/play_segment.cfm?sid=3324
http://www.marriagebuilders.com/radio_program/play_segment.cfm?sid=3325
http://www.marriagebuilders.com/radio_program/play_segment.cfm?sid=3326
http://www.marriagebuilders.com/radio_program/play_segment.cfm?sid=3327
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/15/12 05:22 PM
Hey Markos,

Thanks for the radio broadcasts. I am able to listen to them on my DROID. Listening to the first one now.

I'll respond to your other posts when I have more time to type.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/15/12 06:37 PM
Dr: Steve you need to Plan A your W for 2 years.
Steve: nah uh. No Way. I can't do that.
Dr: Sure. You can. It's like training for a marathon.

laugh
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/15/12 07:37 PM
Originally Posted by markos
MrA, my first thought is, it's great that your wife was able to talk to you about these feelings and for you to receive them non-judgmentally. Absolutely HUGE. The conversation probably deposited a lot of Love Bank units in your account in her Love Bank. This is probably a big step down the road towards her being in love with you.
I agree. I thanked her several times for being honest with me. I fear there is more she hasn�t told me. I fear it because it means she doesn�t trust me enough to be honest with me. Which means I�ve failed her somewhere along the line. BUT we�re on a new path and hopefully those will be revealed.
Originally Posted by markos
Just the talking about it is great! Investigating, informing, and understanding your spouse is one of Dr. Harley's four Friends of good conversation. And conversation is just about the most important emotional need in the world to winning back most withdrawn wives.
Yes. I think we�re on our way. I�ve certainly tried to be more open with her the last week. Using I would love it if statements where I provide feedback that is positive (void of negatives). As a matter of fact I just did that about 10 minutes ago and she reciprocated immediately. What a nice feeling.
Originally Posted by markos
I know that's hard for men, because we hear the problem and we want to solve the problem. smile And when the problem involves us, it hits really close to home and it's easy to get emotional, and from there to irrational, and from there to love busting. Nothing strikes fear into a man's heart more than "I'm not really sure how enthusiastic I am about sex..." So the fact that you kept your cool and let her talk about her feelings shows you are really doing a good job at this.
Keeping my cool hasn�t been the problem. Being open and honest and providing an environment where we can move forward in a positive direction has been my lacking. Her and I clam up, bottle it up until one day �. Withdrawal.
Originally Posted by markos
And I have good news for you. In Dr. Harley's experience, almost all sexual problems simply vanish once the wife is in love with her husband. He's treated couples where the wife was abused, molested, victimized by incest in childhood, etc., and he's seen sexual relationships normalize once the wife is in love with the husband. He says it happens nine times out of ten.
I so hope so. I have this feeling, this vision that I will move heaven and earth for this girl if I can have my needs met.
Originally Posted by markos
I will share my experience: Prisca and I have been in and out of love a lot, sad to say (and I'll just say that as long as we practice the habits of Marriage Builders, we stay in love!) and during that time, Prisca's sex drive has ranged all the way from pure aversion to can't get enough. It really is true that when my account in her love bank crosses the romantic love threshold, sexual problems vanish. [quote]
Thank you for sharing. It�s very nice to have success stories hang around here to give people proof and hope that a marriage can be recovered and/or improved.

[quote=markos]I'm going to go dig up a couple of my favorite quotes and radio shows by Dr. Harley on this subject for you to read while you're waiting for Dr. Chalmers' response. smile
I listened to those broadcasts and that is a good story. Boy I�d love to hear that things worked out for Steve.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/15/12 08:15 PM
Originally Posted by markos
That's the magic that I have seen: when my wife is in love, her sexual feelings follow. When she is not in love, making love to me feels off to her; it feels like I am using her, it feels like sex is all about my needs and not about her, etc.
So I hope this encourages you, MrAlias: just keep walking down this path, keep steadily making love bank deposits and learning to avoid love bank withdrawals, and practice these new habits until they are ironclad and you are doing them all the time without thinking, and there is a 90% chance that at some point, you will know when your wife crosses the romantic love threshold, because suddenly those problems from past experiences will become much less of an issue.
Just the fact she is walking down this path with me this time is very encouraging. I do wish for a change in our R. I�d love to use all the tools provided here to create and then protect our love. POJA and PORH are going to be huge for us. I can�t wait for the day when my W sees the beauty in the Win/Win and realizes that sacrifice in a marriage is a phrase that should never be practiced. I fear she�s been sacrificing for far too long.
Originally Posted by markos
One key thing to realize about passing the love bank threshold is that it is sudden, not gradual. One day, the balance is not quite at the threshold, and she tolerates you. The next day, you've made just a couple more deposits more, and Dr. Harley says men wake up and it's like they are married to a different woman.
For me that day will be the day that SF is no longer something that she avoids. She does so well at providing many of the other ENs I have (Affection, Attractive Spouse, Domestic Support).
Lately I have a hard time feeling attractive. To have her avoid SF gives me the gut reaction that I�m just not attractive. I associate that to my own feelings of an attractive spouse (visual) of course not what she�d view as attractive. I know I�m overweight even though I carry it well, I guess. There isn�t much up top for hair anymore. I feel feeble due to these nagging physical ailments and it�s depressing because the therapies haven�t really turned them around. I�m trying to block those thoughts though because those have nothing to do with how she views me.

If our R flourishes some of those issues won�t be so disconcerting to me.

Thanks for the replies Markos
Posted By: markos Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 11/15/12 09:32 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Dr: Steve you need to Plan A your W for 2 years.
Steve: nah uh. No Way. I can't do that.
Dr: Sure. You can. It's like training for a marathon.

laugh

The Doctor is a good motivator. smile
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/16/12 10:50 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
The education part regarding MB is tough for me. I buy into this program (learning more every day) but she doesn't.

I wanted to comment on this. Dr. Harley has said that there is still a LOT of hope for a marriage where the husband buys in and the wife does not. If you buy in and follow the program, if you are extremely consistent and effective with your love bank deposits and you eliminate the withdrawals, you are very likely to see her feelings change and then her beliefs change to match.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/19/12 01:53 PM
Originally Posted by markos
Originally Posted by MrAlias
The education part regarding MB is tough for me. I buy into this program (learning more every day) but she doesn't.

I wanted to comment on this. Dr. Harley has said that there is still a LOT of hope for a marriage where the husband buys in and the wife does not. If you buy in and follow the program, if you are extremely consistent and effective with your love bank deposits and you eliminate the withdrawals, you are very likely to see her feelings change and then her beliefs change to match.
That is my hope. I thought I was there before but evidentally I was falling short of the mark.
Interestingly the Dr is starting with our ENs. I know it�s important to get them out there but I�m thinking there are some LBs that I need to eliminate and doing that is what is going to be important for my wife to experience.
Tonight I have to communicate how I want my needs met and she�s heard these all before � time and time again ... I don�t think she�s going to be all that intrigued hearing me lay out exactly what and when and how often I want and need something. We are getting along quite well I�d almost rather I start with something that shows her some benefit. Hopefully there are some ENs she needs immediately so I can show her that benefit.
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/19/12 06:45 PM
My guess is that he's starting with ENs because he's decided you are the one who's a bigger danger to the marriage right now if your needs go unmet.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/19/12 08:01 PM
Originally Posted by NewEveryDay
My guess is that he's starting with ENs because he's decided you are the one who's a bigger danger to the marriage right now if your needs go unmet.

Of course. Not sure why I didn't think about that. It has been an OK couple of weeks so I feel more invested in the R. I do know I'm still leary and seem quick to jump back to many of those same withdrawal feelings when I see/feel/hear something that triggers them.

I hope she's ready to complete our to-do(s) for tonight. It's our last night to get that done before we meet with Dr. Chalmer again. I believe she was still working on them this weekend.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/19/12 08:40 PM
Every day I come here and SMILE. smile
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/20/12 02:08 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Every day I come here and SMILE. smile

I hope to join you in that fun some day.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/20/12 02:17 PM
ME TOO! smile
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/21/12 04:26 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
That is my hope. I thought I was there before but evidentally I was falling short of the mark.

Story of my life. smile It turns out I had a LOT of blind spots on stuff I was missing and doing.

Quote
Interestingly the Dr is starting with our ENs. I know it�s important to get them out there but I�m thinking there are some LBs that I need to eliminate and doing that is what is going to be important for my wife to experience.
Tonight I have to communicate how I want my needs met and she�s heard these all before � time and time again ... I don�t think she�s going to be all that intrigued hearing me lay out exactly what and when and how often I want and need something. We are getting along quite well I�d almost rather I start with something that shows her some benefit. Hopefully there are some ENs she needs immediately so I can show her that benefit.

As the Love Busters decrease, the rest of the program becomes a lot more effective, but you usually won't hear cheers just for fixing the Love Busters alone. Steve Harley put it to me this way: noone goes around bragging they don't abuse their wife. smile

Listening to the radio show every day?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/21/12 05:50 PM
Hello Markos,

I listen to the show on average about 3 or 4 times a week. I missed the last few as things have been hectic. Currently I've been doing about 45 minutes of reading each day in the Harley books. I�m into the LB book now.

Update on my prior questions to you: After speaking to Dr J. it was decided that we would continue forward with our plan and hope that my wife is one of the 9 out of 10 where SF issues disappear. If she's not we'll cross that bridge when we get there. Sometimes the easiest things are beyond my thinking ... doh2

We shared our ENs Monday night. It was interesting how few things she asked for for each one of her ENs. Affection: Text me once a day to ask how she's doing. That�s it and that�s what I had already been doing in the past say a year or more ago and also what I started doing again about a week and a half ago. So her statement was an I Love It When statement not an I Would Love It If statement. My wife says she�s just not that needy. Dr J. said she�s going to help her add more to her list. I can and want to do more.

This tells me it is the LoveBusters that I�m unaware of that is draining her romantic love for me. She�s going to give me 3 annoying habits this week so I can thoughtfully respond. I�m to do the same as my wife said she�d like 3 of hers as well. I can�t wait to get her honesty and openness.

Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/21/12 08:03 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Hello Markos,

I listen to the show on average about 3 or 4 times a week. I missed the last few as things have been hectic. Currently I've been doing about 45 minutes of reading each day in the Harley books. I�m into the LB book now.

Great! Keep this up!! I try to listen every day. I think for husbands trying to turn a marriage around, we usually need a lot of constant help like this, and the radio show is just perfect. Even when the show doesn't seem to pertain directly to our own situation, there is still always some helpful information that will shed light on some point, or reinforce what we've heard.

Quote
Update on my prior questions to you: After speaking to Dr J. it was decided that we would continue forward with our plan and hope that my wife is one of the 9 out of 10 where SF issues disappear. If she's not we'll cross that bridge when we get there.

Hey, that definitely sounds like a good plan to me! Really it is amazing to me how the sexual issues in our marriage pertain so directly to the relationship issues. We've seen more ups and downs than we should have (mostly due to my own love busters) and that's given me a chance to see demonstrated repeatedly that in our marriage, there is literally no sense trying to do anything about sexual issues until the answer to "Is my wife in love with me?" is a resounding "YES," and when that becomes true, there usually are no sexual issues.

Quote
We shared our ENs Monday night. It was interesting how few things she asked for for each one of her ENs. Affection: Text me once a day to ask how she's doing. That�s it and that�s what I had already been doing in the past say a year or more ago and also what I started doing again about a week and a half ago. So her statement was an I Love It When statement not an I Would Love It If statement. My wife says she�s just not that needy. Dr J. said she�s going to help her add more to her list. I can and want to do more.

From this I think we can say we are seeing the results of your wife being in withdrawal for a long time. She's not feeling a lot of needs, because in withdrawal a person doesn't want to meet needs and doesn't want their own needs met either.

BUT, during a wife's withdrawal, if the husband does not engage in love busters, and persistently, consistently, patiently makes deposits, even if they are small, they eventually add up. And people do not stay in withdrawal perpetually: they feel lonely, they poke their heads out and briefly become willing to have their needs met, and that becomes an opportunity to make a big deposit, and if there are no love busters, the next thing you know, she is in conflict and willing to have her needs met (but not willing to meet yours, and possibly not willing to refrain from love busters), and then if you hold steady, don't love bust, and accelerate the love bank deposits, the next thing you know, she is in intimacy.

When she moves more fully out of withdrawal, she may be better able to identify her emotional needs. Until then, take every opportunity Dr. Chalmers can make for you, make every deposit you can, and focus especially on conversation. Read and re-read Dr. Harley's friends and enemies of good conversation.
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/21/12 08:10 PM
Originally Posted by Extremely Lost
Rocks in a River: You find yourself on the bank of a wide river. It is too wide to jump across, and yet you still need to cross it. What do you do? You start picking up rocks and throwing them into the river. (These rocks are each small affectionate thing you do for your W). For the first 499 rocks, you see the rock hit the water, and then it dissapears. These rocks are sinking and landing on the bottom of the river. Eventually you get to rock #500 and it hits the water and part of it is sticking up above the surface. You now realize you are getting somewhere. You can finally see progress. For the first 499 rocks, you knew they were stacking up, but you had no proof other than common sense telling you that they were building up. We have to approach our relationships now as if every piece of affection is one of those rocks. We will not see any progress until a number of rocks have been thrown. However, just because we are not seeing these first 499 rocks does not mean they are not having an impact. Believe that they are, because they are.

(This is the original, but it's embedded in a long post about a bunch of other stuff. I include it only because I tend to be a historian:
http://forum.marriagebuilders.com/ubbt/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=1659425#Post1659425)

EL was relating something he had been told by Steve Harley in a phone coaching session.

Originally Posted by HoldHerHand
the first is one used by the poster DoormatNoMore;

Creating romantic love after infidelity (aka "healing") is like creating a new island by chucking buckets of sand in a lake. It's going to take a lot of sand before it begins to peek above the water. Wind, waves, rain, and storms will wash that peak away, but you have to keep chucking buckets of sand.

...

she has wrapped herself in a protective shell. There are small cracks in that shell where some light can get in. You are tossing grains of rice at this shell, hoping to give her the nourishment she needs. If you throw only a single grains, or only small amounts (not keeping up with UA, not meeting ENs) they are not likely to fall through the small cracks.

However, if you throw HANDFULS (20+ hours of UA time, becoming expert at meeting her EN's, adhering to EP's), then some grains can slip through the cracks and give her the nourishment she needs to go forward.

She is STUCK in that cave, sir. And your actions put her there. She cannot simply decide to come out. Your action is what will free her.

Original:
http://forum.marriagebuilders.com/u...in=164877&Number=2556440#Post2556440
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 02:19 PM
It has been awhile since I thought about and read again the Rocks in the River analogy.

I am sure I am very close to the surface. She told me last night she was very happy and was so happy we were communicating again.

I'm still waiting for the first of my 3 AHs she wants to communicate. We're scheduling time tonight.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 02:32 PM
Question for anyone:

I have to communicate an annoying habit to my wife tonight. But I'm unsure which to choose from.

My wife has a mild case of OCD where it creates habits that can be annoying. For instance, she overwashes her hands. So much so that they are usually dried and cracked especially in the dry winter months. (taking fish oils help). I'm not going to list that as an AH though ... I can live with it.

She also does this thing with light switches on off on off and she does it with some vigor. She broke one some years ago.

What I would really like to see her change is her eating habits and I'm not sure how much of it is just poor choices and how much is OCD. She drinks a lot of diet soda. As many as 5 or 6 a day that I know of ... she keeps a case of it at work so it could be more ... I'm not sure. Also, she doesn't eat healthy. No breakfast unless you count soda, cookies and Halloween pumpkins (candy corn stuff).

If I provide her with 1 AH do I break it up for her so she isn't overwhelmed or do I simply say I want you to eat better and that would mean cut down on the soda, treats and candies. I would encourage her to try to eat a good breakfast each day.

She is going to be upset that I'm going to "force" her to stop drinking so much soda. It's a crutch for her. We can't get in the car and go somewhere until she has at least 2 cans with her.

Thoughts?
Posted By: living_well Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 03:23 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
If I provide her with 1 AH do I break it up for her so she isn't overwhelmed or do I simply say I want you to eat better and that would mean cut down on the soda, treats and candies. I would encourage her to try to eat a good breakfast each day.

Thoughts?


An annoying habit is something that bothers YOU. Be careful that you do not let it become about lecturing or changing her which would be disrespectful.

So what is it about her eating and drinking habits that impacts you? Does she leave the empty cans in the car? Is she too fat? Drill down until you get to the right place.

Once you are at the root of the issue that is troubling you, you will need to POJA it with her. Remember, for this you just state the issue and then together find a solution. Do not make the mistake of starting with a possible solution, wrong approach.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 04:42 PM
It's unattractive to me to watch her consume so much that is bad for her. It becomes even more annoying later when she states how she doesn't feel well or that's she's fat and hates her shape.

I've watched her sister drink so much diet pop that she has about half of her teeth left. And her sister is an attractive girl. Why would anyone do that to themselves? I fear what it is doing to my wife.

Another part that bothers me is that she denies it later. I can't count the number of times I'd be preparing for bed thinking "tonight I'll ask if we can be intimate" and she'll walk in saying she doesn't feel well. Imagine the difficulty in trying not to educate her when I feel I see a problem. Imagine the difficulty I have in trying to avoid making assumptions. I don't want to disrespect her so I just clam up.

On those nights when she has a stomach ache or a headache I'll express my concern that there may be something seriously wrong and she'll say "I don't have that many". Last time it happened I asked if we could track it. She looked at me with a puzzled look. "It isn't that often. Why would you want to do that?".

And it is right there in that moment that I need the most help on how to communicate with my wife. We each have our own perspective. To me it is an AH. To her she�s fine.

I will do my best to simply state it is unattractive to me and I�d like us to work together to find a solution.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 04:54 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
It's unattractive to me to watch her consume so much that is bad for her. It becomes even more annoying later when she states how she doesn't feel well or that's she's fat and hates her shape.

I would definitely tell her your feelings about this and include it on your list. This is something that affects your feelings towards her so she needs to know.
Posted By: living_well Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 04:59 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I will do my best to simply state it is unattractive to me and I�d like us to work together to find a solution.


You need to tell her exactly what is unattractive. If it is that she is fat, come right out and say so. If it is that she is making herself ill and that this is negatively impacting you, say that. If you stick to your feelings you should be safe.

I wonder if there is an addiction that needs to be addressed?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 05:10 PM
Thanks ladies. I will stick to my feelings.

As far as addiction ... my wife is prone to addictions.

She wasn't able to quit smoking until she got a kidney stone while in her 2nd term with our first born. The 4 days in the hospital on morphine was enough to get her past the withdrawal.

Her father was an alcoholic. I had to approach my wife earlier this year because her drinking increased. She stopped when I told her I was concerned but once I really withdrew she started up again. She'll typically have at least 1 drink a day with most days being around 2 to 3.


I stated this when communicating our ENs. An Attractive Spouse: I would love it if we could create a lifestyle that would promote healthy choices in what we eat and drink. Creating a lifestyle that promotes health, for both of us, is important and attractive to me.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 05:13 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
On those nights when she has a stomach ache or a headache I'll express my concern that there may be something seriously wrong and she'll say "I don't have that many". Last time it happened I asked if we could track it. She looked at me with a puzzled look. "It isn't that often. Why would you want to do that?".

MrA, are you assuming that the pop makes her feel bad and makes her want to avoid sex rather than not being in love? I think you are blaming the wrong thing. Because if this is the case, then the real problem is that she avoids sex, not that she drinks pop. Diet pop isn't known for causing stomachaches. Sure, aspartame causes headaches in some people but it can't be assumed that is the issue.

It drives me crazy when my husband makes assumptions like that. It falls in the category of educating your spouse which is a lovebuster.

The way I would handle this is tell her that it is upsetting to you when she doesn't want intimacy. But you are both working on a plan to resolve that: falling in love. Falling in love will make her more willing to make love, NOT eliminating diet pop.

Do you blame the pop for her avoidance of SF?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 05:15 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I stated this when communicating our ENs. An Attractive Spouse: I would love it if we could create a lifestyle that would promote healthy choices in what we eat and drink. Creating a lifestyle that promotes health, for both of us, is important and attractive to me.

What are her thoughts on this? Because you realize things like this have to be POJAed, right?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 05:40 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
On those nights when she has a stomach ache or a headache I'll express my concern that there may be something seriously wrong and she'll say "I don't have that many". Last time it happened I asked if we could track it. She looked at me with a puzzled look. "It isn't that often. Why would you want to do that?".

MrA, are you assuming that the pop makes her feel bad and makes her want to avoid sex rather than not being in love? I think you are blaming the wrong thing. Because if this is the case, then the real problem is that she avoids sex, not that she drinks pop. Diet pop isn't known for causing stomachaches. Sure, aspartame causes headaches in some people but it can't be assumed that is the issue.

It drives me crazy when my husband makes assumptions like that. It falls in the category of educating your spouse which is a lovebuster.

The way I would handle this is tell her that it is upsetting to you when she doesn't want intimacy. But you are both working on a plan to resolve that: falling in love. Falling in love will make her more willing to make love, NOT eliminating diet pop.

Do you blame the pop for her avoidance of SF?
I do what I can to squash those thoughts Mel. I try take her on her word. The truth as I see it is what she eats impacts the way she feels and by the time the day is out what she�s put into her mouth all day long catches up to her and she doesn�t feel well. I think it�s excessive that she�ll feel this way at least once a week. Many times it happens when I know I�m not going to ask for intimacy because we weren�t �clicking� that day. So I deduce she�s definitely not feeling well.

It isn�t that she just drinks aspartame all day � it�s that she does things like consume candy when she should be eating a meal � or eating a healthy snack. In our home today she has over 8 bags of candy pumpkins in the house. I see that and I think to myself � OMG!
As an aside her and I started a new eating plan and her and I just decided two minutes ago that I can no longer have Splenda. I have had a headache almost every day for the last two weeks and what has changed is that I�m using Splenda instead of sugar and some of the recipes call for this as a sugar substitute. It also makes me extremely dizzy. Being a vertigo sufferer I�m more susceptible to that I presume. But to answer your other question we have started together down a path of better eating but she continues to skip breakfast, drink the soda and eat the candies.

Yes you are correct I do need to be more open and honest about the SF issues that continue to plague us. I am working with Dr Chalmers on a better way for me to go about this. She caught on quickly that I may like to educate my wife especially when it comes to MB. My biggest LB that I�m working on with her is my inability to be open and honest. And when I go about changing that that I do it in a respectful, thoughtful way. I am very apprehensive about tonight when we have to do the feedback loop on the meeting of each other�s ENs. We were supposed to do my #1 two nights ago. Today I sent her a request that we schedule time tonight to do that homework.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 06:05 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[ But to answer your other question we have started together down a path of better eating but she continues to skip breakfast, drink the soda and eat the candies.

Did she enthusiastically agree to that change? How well did you use the POJA on those changes? Because people don't usually abandon changes about which they are enthusiastic.

As far as the pop leading to her not feeling well enough to have sex, again I attribute that to the lack of emotional attachment in your marriage. You might have been clicking that day, but your marriage has suffered a lack of emotional attachment for a long time. That is what motivates women to have sex. Women are notorious for having headaches/not feeling well when they don't want to have sex. I know what it feels like when my husband ASSUMES a certain something is causing a certain something, rather than just tell me what makes him unhappy. It frustrates me when he does that.

Quote
I have had a headache almost every day for the last two weeks and what has changed is that I�m using Splenda instead of sugar and some of the recipes call for this as a sugar substitute.

It could be true that Splenda gives you headaches, but could your headaches be from sugar withdrawal? Were you in the habit of eating sugar daily? Sugar is a very addictive, toxic substance and when I stopped eating it, I thought I was going to die for about a week. I had a headache and a pounding heart and had trouble sleeping. I didn't realize what a nasty, toxic substance it was until I went 6 months without it and then ate it again. I felt so sick I had to go to bed. Then I realized that was how I used to feel all the time when I ate sugar! I tell anyone who doesn't believe this to go without sugar for a few months and then eat it again. You will find out fast how nasty sugar is!
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 06:13 PM
Would you have a problem with her eating habits if she did a good job of meeting your needs? I am concerned about you trying to impose your own perspective on her which is a disrespectful judgment. My H and I are just like you and your wife, but in reverse.

I am a health nut; I eat healthy and work out. He would eat brownies for his supper every day if he could! He has bags of candy stashed all over the place. But I don't try to educate him. But then it doesn't bother me because he meets my needs. None of his health habits interfere in our marriage in any way.

Some of the biggest lovebusters I have ever made against him was trying to dictate his food choices. I stopped doing it and our marriage improved.

I get the sense that you have categorized her poor eating habits as an annoying habit because you believe that this is the cause of her unwillingness to have sex with you. You think this because she has told you she has a headache or stomachache to avoid intimacy. I think that was the excuse, and that the real reason is the OBVIOUS and typical reason, which is that she is not emotionally attached to you.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 06:37 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Did she enthusiastically agree to that change? How well did you use the POJA on those changes? Because people don't usually abandon changes about which they are enthusiastic.

We didn't discuss her eating habits as part of POJA. I just communicated these ENs to her Monday so we haven't worked through them yet.

The new eating plan her and I started was a couple of weeks ago where we explored some options, through a co-worker I found this one, I showed it to her and she agreed it looked good. But we didn't discuss the other items you and I are talking about here.

Our homework for this week is to read up on the POJA, the Give and the Taker and the Guidelines for Negotiation.

Quote
It could be true that Splenda gives you headaches, but could your headaches be from sugar withdrawal? Were you in the habit of eating sugar daily? Sugar is a very addictive, toxic substance and when I stopped eating it, I thought I was going to die for about a week. I had a headache and a pounding heart and had trouble sleeping. I didn't realize what a nasty, toxic substance it was until I went 6 months without it and then ate it again. I felt so sick I had to go to bed. Then I realized that was how I used to feel all the time when I ate sugar! I tell anyone who doesn't believe this to go without sugar for a few months and then eat it again. You will find out fast how nasty sugar is!

I had never heard of a sugar withdrawal before. I�m not much of a sugar user. I felt great this morning after having no Splenda on Thanksgiving and now after having a cup of decaf with Splenda in it that same headache is back. I talked to my wife about it and we�re going to stop using it for a few days to see if my symptoms clear. If they do then I�m going to try using it for a bit and see if they return and if so stop again. Headaches are hard to diagnose so it could very well be something else � but so far everything points to the Splenda.

Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 06:47 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
We didn't discuss her eating habits as part of POJA. I just communicated these ENs to her Monday so we haven't worked through them yet.

How does her eating habits translate to your emotional needs? That is what I would explore. I am not seeing how they translate exactly. SF and RC are true EN's but her eating habits are not unless they are truly preventing her from meeting your ENs. On the other hand, trying to dictate eating habits is a disrespectful judgment that could be considered controlling.

Quote
The new eating plan her and I started was a couple of weeks ago where we explored some options, through a co-worker I found this one, I showed it to her and she agreed it looked good. But we didn't discuss the other items you and I are talking about here.

Our homework for this week is to read up on the POJA, the Give and the Taker and the Guidelines for Negotiation.

Good deal! If she is not adhering to that eating plan, it is likely that she was not really enthusiastic about it. My H was notorious for agreeing to things just to keep the peace. That is just a watch out for you and your wife. We have learned the hard way to avoid agreeing to things we are not really enthusiastic about.

Quote
I had never heard of a sugar withdrawal before. I�m not much of a sugar user. I felt great this morning after having no Splenda on Thanksgiving and now after having a cup of decaf with Splenda in it that same headache is back. I talked to my wife about it and we�re going to stop using it for a few days to see if my symptoms clear. If they do then I�m going to try using it for a bit and see if they return and if so stop again. Headaches are hard to diagnose so it could very well be something else � but so far everything points to the Splenda.

Do you typically put sugar in your coffee in the morning? Does aspartame give you a headache? Another good artificial sweetener that many like is Truvia. You might like that better.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 06:49 PM
So happy you are going through the program!!! laugh

hug
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 07:45 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Would you have a problem with her eating habits if she did a good job of meeting your needs? I am concerned about you trying to impose your own perspective on her which is a disrespectful judgment. My H and I are just like you and your wife, but in reverse.

I am a health nut; I eat healthy and work out. He would eat brownies for his supper every day if he could! He has bags of candy stashed all over the place. But I don't try to educate him. But then it doesn't bother me because he meets my needs. None of his health habits interfere in our marriage in any way.

Some of the biggest lovebusters I have ever made against him was trying to dictate his food choices. I stopped doing it and our marriage improved.

I get the sense that you have categorized her poor eating habits as an annoying habit because you believe that this is the cause of her unwillingness to have sex with you. You think this because she has told you she has a headache or stomachache to avoid intimacy. I think that was the excuse, and that the real reason is the OBVIOUS and typical reason, which is that she is not emotionally attached to you.

My #3 EN I listed was an Attractive Spouse. My wife had always been a thin person up until about a year or so ago. This last year that has changed. She used to be able to eat like this because she had a high metabolism. She was able to keep the pounds off, but now that has definitely changed. My drive is declining as is her attractiveness to me. Sort of a double whammy for me ... if you will.

So maybe a better option to broach this is to be open and honest about my ENs. I loved it when she was thinner. She�s a very pretty girl who had a wonderful figure. And I miss that about her. She still looks good to me but not as good as before.

Still I am concerned about her health. I�d like her to be healthy especially later on when her and I are retired. I�d like to go do things. I hope we�re both healthy enough to do that. Later on RC is going to be a big EN for me � probably her too.

I express my concern about her health when she�s feeling ill instead of communicating that I think it�s the way she eats. I have raised my concerns to her about her eating habits at other moments throughout our day not just in the context of the bedroom.


Do I associate her eating habits with our sex life? I�m looking for the things that get in the way of SF. When she doesn�t feel good then SF is off the table, of course. I won�t ask to have my needs met if she�s not feeling well. So that is one of the things that gets in the way.

Would it be safe to ask her if she thought it was her eating habits that create these headaches and stomach aches and to explore that as an option? It would be no different than her and I playing around with Splenda to see if it is the culprit in my recent headaches. You said it yourself � sugar is nasty.

Is she avoiding intimacy? Yes. I agree with you when you say �and that the real reason is the OBVIOUS and typical reason, which is that she is not emotionally attached to you.� I guess that�s why I�d say I am not associating the bad eating habits to our sex life. It does annoy me that she eats the way she does. It makes her less physically and mentally attractive to me. She isn�t as diligent as I�d like her to be with the kid�s morning eating habits either. Something we�ll need to POJA.

This week should be a good week. It is the week she begins to be open and honest with me about the things I do that she says I am not aware of that destroy her love for me. Through that process I will do whatever it takes to stop doing those things. I am excited about this new opportunity to improve the R and I hope I can do enough to gain that emotional attachment.

Mel, I am happy we are going through the program too. I am enjoying the process and look forward to the ways in which I can enrich our R. I sure hope this is the answer. I hope I can get my side of the street clean.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 07:48 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Do you typically put sugar in your coffee in the morning? Does aspartame give you a headache? Another good artificial sweetener that many like is Truvia. You might like that better.

My coffee drinking varies. Some times sugar, sometimes Equal, sometimes black. If I use too much Equal and then stop I'll get a withdrawal effect.

The last month of so I primarily was drinking it black ... which is nasty as the free stuff at work is quite bitter. But I like to drink it as it helps me avoid eating more than I care to.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 08:17 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[

My #3 EN I listed was an Attractive Spouse. My wife had always been a thin person up until about a year or so ago. This last year that has changed. She used to be able to eat like this because she had a high metabolism. She was able to keep the pounds off, but now that has definitely changed. My drive is declining as is her attractiveness to me. Sort of a double whammy for me ... if you will.

That makes perfect sense. AS is an EN and you are right to mention that her weight gain is affecting your desire.

Quote
So maybe a better option to broach this is to be open and honest about my ENs. I loved it when she was thinner. She�s a very pretty girl who had a wonderful figure. And I miss that about her. She still looks good to me but not as good as before.

Perfect. And that is exactly what I would tell her.

Quote
Still I am concerned about her health. I�d like her to be healthy especially later on when her and I are retired. I�d like to go do things. I hope we�re both healthy enough to do that. Later on RC is going to be a big EN for me � probably her too.

I think that is good to express concern for her health. My only concern here is when it becomes a DJ or becomes controlling. So think this definition of a DJ over before you say things about her eating habits:

Originally Posted by Dr Harley on Disrespectful Judgments
In the final analysis, disrespectful judgments represent an effort to force our spouses to give us what we want in marriage, but it's often cleverly disguised. Instead of making an outright demand, we present our problem as if it were really our spouse's personal shortcoming. We try to "straighten out" our spouse in an effort to get our way.

At the time we rationalize our disrespect by convincing ourselves that we're doing our spouses a big favor, to lift them from the darkness of their confusion into the light of our superior perspective. If they would only follow our advice, we tell ourselves, they could avoid many of life's pitfalls-and we would also get what we want.

A disrespectful judgment occurs whenever one spouse tries to impose a system of values and beliefs on the other. When a husband tries to force his point of view on his wife, he's just asking for trouble. When a wife assumes that her own views are right and her husband is woefully misguided -- and tells him so -- she enters a minefield.
here

Quote
I express my concern about her health when she�s feeling ill instead of communicating that I think it�s the way she eats. I have raised my concerns to her about her eating habits at other moments throughout our day not just in the context of the bedroom.

This would be a huge lovebuster to my husband. I can express my concern about his health, but lecturing him about his eating habits would harm our relationship because it is a DJ.

Quote
Would it be safe to ask her if she thought it was her eating habits that create these headaches and stomach aches and to explore that as an option?

Does that irritate her? I guess that would be the deciding factor.

Quote
This week should be a good week. It is the week she begins to be open and honest with me about the things I do that she says I am not aware of that destroy her love for me. Through that process I will do whatever it takes to stop doing those things. I am excited about this new opportunity to improve the R and I hope I can do enough to gain that emotional attachment.

GREAT! Like I said earlier, this was one of the hardest things for my DH to overcome. He thought it was a virtue to stuff his displeasure at my behavior. He still does it sometimes but usually catches himself and does a course correction.

Quote
Mel, I am happy we are going through the program too. I am enjoying the process and look forward to the ways in which I can enrich our R. I sure hope this is the answer. I hope I can get my side of the street clean.

I know it will work for you if you stick to it. I think you are the kind of person who is very thorough and methodical. Those skills will serve you well in this process. I tend to be a corner cutter and wasted several good years because I didn't follow instructions.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 08:21 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[

Mel, I am happy we are going through the program too. I am enjoying the process and look forward to the ways in which I can enrich our R. I sure hope this is the answer. I hope I can get my side of the street clean.

I predict that the biggest surprise to you will be when you start diligently following the policy of undivided attention. That is when things happen rather quickly. You will find your feelings doing an about face in about 8 weeks. And it will happen quite suddenly.

Once you hit that plateau, you will be on here acting like a zealot like the rest of us who have experienced this. grin Experiencing success in this program is what creates zealots.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 09:00 PM
A zealot eh? Sounds good. We're doing quite well on the UA stuff. We both seem to be in a much better place already. I'll see what that 8 week or so mark brings.

I am having a hard time coming up with an annoying habit that I need to communicate to my wife. I have this feeling if she�d just do the I love it ifs I listed for her I�d be quite content.

But I know I need to do this exercise. I know I need to be more open and honest with her and express some concerns to her so we get the practice of it. Well that and it�s our homework for the next week. wink

I�m trying to list some things but no matter what I come up with I can convince myself the AH is really nothing more than me trying to impose my will. Could I live with the behavior? Does it really impact my feelings for her negatively?

Initially Dr. Chalmers wasn�t going to have me provide my wife with any of her LBs. When my wife asked about that the Dr asked if she�d like some and she said Yes. I�d prefer she just focus on the EN IWLII�s ( I Would Love It Ifs (lookey there I just created a new MB acronym grin ). Having those met are going to be huge for me.

Alright ... let's try this for a topic. I�ve expressed concerns to her about this before. This has to fall into the LB category. I don�t like it.

When she is going to go to her sister�s she gets up earlier. Most times she out of the house by 6:30-7am. She�ll get up that early even if she was up late � 4 or 5 hours of sleep. If she�s not going to her sister�s she�ll sleep in both weekend days until 10am or later. I�m usually up around 7am at the latest. So I�ll get up and do a few things but for the most part I just relax. I can�t make a lot of noise because she�s sleeping so I try to respect that. But it is hurtful that she�ll get up early to go do her thing but if she�s home she�ll sleep in. If we have to be somewhere, of course, she gets up. But even if I think we�ve got a plan where she�s not going to sleep in because we have some things we want to do she�ll still sleep in. On those days I�ll wait for a while (say 9 or 9:30) but eventually I�ll have to go wake her and ask if she�s going to be getting up.

It has been this way for as long as I can remember. Except since she�s been into the horses it�s even more hurtful now because she gets up for that but not for us. A few months back I mentioned my concerns to her � but at that point we were a mess and so nothing changed. She�ll be sleeping in tomorrow no matter what time we get to bed tonight. Maybe this would be something worthy of discussing with her.??
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 09:32 PM
It really does bother you that she sleeps in? Does it really?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/23/12 09:34 PM
Men do a lot more to irritate women than vice versa. Did you know that? Dr Harley said on the radio show that he can't think of a THING Joyce does that bothers him but she is always bringing up things he does that bothers her!
Posted By: hopefulwife47 Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/24/12 01:48 AM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Men do a lot more to irritate women than vice versa. Did you know that? Dr Harley said on the radio show that he can't think of a THING Joyce does that bothers him but she is always bringing up things he does that bothers her!

I wonder if they are more like my husband and I. I can't think of a thing that irritates me about him, but I bet he can think of many things about me. For example, the example they use about glasses being left on the counter.. that is ME!! I could care less about clutter. My husband cares a lot more. Maybe that is the difference. Also, what I eat bothers my husband as well. he wants me to make healthier choices. So I have been lately ( and lost 17 pounds!!) We talked today about how much better I have been feeling.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/24/12 04:05 AM
Bravo to you for losing the weight, tiredwife!
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/24/12 11:16 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Bravo to you for losing the weight, tiredwife!
Yes, good job. hurray
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/26/12 03:33 AM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Men do a lot more to irritate women than vice versa. Did you know that? Dr Harley said on the radio show that he can't think of a THING Joyce does that bothers him but she is always bringing up things he does that bothers her!

He's also commented that women will be annoyed by things their husbands do even when in love, but men in love will typically not find their wives to have any annoying habits.

That agrees with my own personal experience.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/26/12 01:52 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
It really does bother you that she sleeps in? Does it really?

It does. It feels like I'm second fiddle to her sister and the horses. She spends quite a bit of time out of town with them and not with us. There are a lot of things her and I would like to get accomplished and I've been doing many of them on my own.

So when she sleeps in it's just more of the same.

Her and I discussed this over the weekend and she agreed she could get up. She explained to me the reasoning why she was doing this and, yet again, I�m amazed at how my perspective is so different from hers.

We made an agreement. If I would like her to get up I need to state so in a prior day. She�ll make a point of getting up after getting a healthy amount of sleep ( I certainly don�t want her sleep deprived). On days when we agree there isn�t much going on she�ll sleep as late as she�d like.

So far she shared her one AH with me after I had already showed her that I was going to be more aware. She doesn�t like being a passenger in a vehicle and hates it if I get a little too close to cars in front of me. On T-day the traffic was bad on our way to MILs house but I remembered her stating this to me a long time ago and I consciously tried to stay back a comfortable distance. She thanked me when she revealed this AH to me. I thanked her for being honest and apologized for past discretions.

Things are going really well. Her and I are having fun together again. We�re looking forward to seeing each other and spending more and more time together. We are working hard on meeting each other�s top 5 ENs. Right now she�s on the mark in all of her attempts and she�s checking in to make sure it�s making a difference for me.

We�re early into this program but so far it appears my wife is one of the 9 out of 10.

hurray
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/26/12 01:57 PM
Congrats on the 17 pounds tiredwife. That is no easy task.

My wife and I are just a couple of weeks into a new way of eating. So far the scale has only moved slightly for me but I'll take slow and steady. I'm done with the quick weight loss programs. We're focusing on these healthier, lower calorie meals that everyone is eating. So no more having to go it alone like I've done about 5 times prior.

The eating plan is becoming a part of our UA and RC time. I've been making most of the meals which is cool as it fulfills her DS need. She's been heavily involved in the planning and purchasing of meals.

It feels great to be doing this as a team.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/26/12 02:34 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
We�re early into this program but so far it appears my wife is one of the 9 out of 10.

hurray

Another day, another smile! smile
Posted By: Jedi_Knight Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/26/12 02:44 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Congrats on the 17 pounds tiredwife. That is no easy task.

My wife and I are just a couple of weeks into a new way of eating. So far the scale has only moved slightly for me but I'll take slow and steady. I'm done with the quick weight loss programs. We're focusing on these healthier, lower calorie meals that everyone is eating. So no more having to go it alone like I've done about 5 times prior.

The eating plan is becoming a part of our UA and RC time. I've been making most of the meals which is cool as it fulfills her DS need. She's been heavily involved in the planning and purchasing of meals.

It feels great to be doing this as a team.

That's wonderful
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/27/12 06:02 PM
Another encouraging day transpired.

I am going to provide some details as a way for me to document, analyze and learn from what I've heard.

Mrs. Alias and I had a very nice honest and open conversation last night. We had to do more of our homework which was an EN feedback loop exercise and communicate AH(s).

During these exercises we talked about a great many things. We explained things from our perspectives and discussed ways to handle those differences � coming up with alternative choices to what we were currently doing.

Mrs. Alias didn�t list a whole lot of to-do(s) for me in her ENs and she said she was having a hard time coming up with some AHs. But after we talked a bit she did come up with some things I could work on.

(AH #1) I already spoke of � her fears being a passenger and the way I drive. Corrective action already in place. But what was nice is last night as we were talking about this AH #1 again she shared something related that she didn�t like. When she communicates or shows signs of fear my impulse is to �see a problem, fix the problem� (AH #2). But that isn�t what she�d like from me. She�d just like me to listen. As I explained my perspective as to why I did what I did we came up with an alternate behavior for me. Instead of trying to fix it I simply empathize with her and, at times, offer up my services to help in any way I can. That way she knows she�s being heard, doesn�t feel pressured to fix something that is very difficult for her to handle and she can take me up on my offer if she wants. She feels cared for but not lectured or insulted or pressured.

AH #3. Related to the kids and my need to drone on and on when I�m trying to teach them a way to correct a poor behavior. I need to let it rest. It was hilarious � �You�re telling the kids to let it rest �. Yet you�re the one who won�t let it�. I was rolling. I was aware � but my FOO kicked in and away I�d go. So my alternate behavior is to do the one thing I learned outside of MB in another learning environment and that is to tell myself to STOP. Stop, think about my reaction and make a conscience effort to respond instead of the instinctual desire to just yammer something out from my subconscious.

I have listed these 3 AHs on a cheat sheet and placed them in the bottom of my lunch bucket along with my own defined LB cheat sheet, along with a couple of other ones related to Friends and Enemies of Good Conversation and the 4 Guidelines to Successful Negotations. I am definitely a visual person as I try to use my photographic memory (that isn�t so memorable anymore) to remember things. Sigh. I hate getting older.

I told Mrs. Alias last night that I am SO MUCH HAPPIER than I have been in a long time. She responded she was glad.

Melody. I�m cracking a bit of a smile.
smile
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/27/12 06:35 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I told Mrs. Alias last night that I am SO MUCH HAPPIER than I have been in a long time. She responded she was glad.

Melody. I�m cracking a bit of a smile.
smile

smile

I figured you would do great if you were just put on the right path. You are thorough, smart and articulate. You are doing just great!! And don't let yourself get disappointed if you run into some rough patches. My H and I have a great marriage today and we had a big fight in the grocery store when we were learning the POJA. I almost had to kick his butt in the store! sigh
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/27/12 07:30 PM
Mel,

Thanks for the kind words.

I was telling my sister how well it was going and she asked me what to attribute it to.

I said MB is a sound program, a great foundation. I went on to say that I believe both her and I probably finally had had enough of being withdrawn and getting far too little out of the M. So we joined up and now we're in it like a team and it's going really well.

FYI my sister pointed me here some 10 years ago ... yet she's never really done anything to implement it in her M. How ironic. I gave her some incentive to join us.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/27/12 07:31 PM
Oh and yes I'll be wary of the rough patches.

I certainly don't feel like getting my butt kicked. grin
Posted By: markos Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/29/12 05:14 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I told Mrs. Alias last night that I am SO MUCH HAPPIER than I have been in a long time. She responded she was glad.

Melody. I�m cracking a bit of a smile.
smile

Wow, you two -- this is great. smile I just got done reading your post about "I'd love it if" on another thread, and I am impressed! For me it was a big journey to learn how to express desires in a way that was non-demanding and respectful. And it changes so much, doesn't it? smile As you progress further into positive love bank account balance territory, you'll find that you are both more willing to meet those requests, too. smile

Regarding the rough patches, Prisca and I have had a bunch of those, and one big reason for that has been the habit of retreating back to love busters when things seem rough. I'm also just extremely emotionally reactive (scored very high on Dr. H's personality test) and when we hit a bump in the road my first feeling is "It's the end of the world, she's never going to speak to me again, this is a crisis, I've got to do something" and I panic. You strike me as a more easy going guy who is probably not going to have that problem as much, so I'm hoping you guys have an easier time of it. smile But if you do hit any difficulties, retreat first back to the basics: calm down, no love busters.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/29/12 06:37 PM
Good stuff Markos, My W and I are the same regarding our reactions to issues. When things aren't going our way we take the poor choice ... stuff our feelings, clam up.

I can't count on one finger the number of times either one of us has ever had a real angry outburt or selfish demand. Our issues have been our inability to work a successful PORH. Using POJA is going to be a nice tool for us to work out our issues instead of stuffing them. Basically her and I need to bring a healthy Taker to the table.

With experience will come the realization that we've got each other's backs and best interests at heart.

We start our work on negotiating tomorrow night with Dr J.
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/29/12 08:44 PM
MrA, I can't be more tickled to read your updates! What an amazing legacy to create for your kids!
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/29/12 08:46 PM
I'm dying to ask... does your wife sleep on your shoulder again? I remember that was one thing that gave me so much hope back in the day, to read that and remind myself it is possible to live in peace like that. If not, it's okay, I know you have a lot of ways to express on the outside the peace in your hearts smile
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 11/29/12 09:33 PM
Originally Posted by NewEveryDay
I'm dying to ask... does your wife sleep on your shoulder again? I remember that was one thing that gave me so much hope back in the day, to read that and remind myself it is possible to live in peace like that. If not, it's okay, I know you have a lot of ways to express on the outside the peace in your hearts smile

She would except I'm plugged into my life support system as they like to call it when they tease. I have sleep apnea and have to use a CPAP. Couple that with carpael tunnel and the wrist braces I wear and snuggling while we sleep isn�t very pleasant. I look like I'm going to war or something. Gotta gear up to sleep.

I should probably be wearing the soft boots I wear for plantar fasciitis to bed but that�s just too much to take. What happened to my body?

It�s my hope that this new eating plan we�re doing allows me to lose enough where I could lose the CPAP. Down another pound today � only 30 or so more to go.

weightlifter
Posted By: Telly Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/01/12 02:08 AM
Hi there, MrAlias!

I want you to know that I haven't been to MB in ages. I heard you were here and that you were actually doing well and I came back just to read your story.

I am just thrilled (THRILLED) to hear your story and how things are finally improving for you now that you and your wife are committing to the MB plan.

So thrilled in fact, that I told your story to my H and FINALLY persuaded him to begin implementing the MB principles with me. We just ordered one of his short CD's where he gives an overview of the program. I've had HNHN and Lovebusters forever, and we are going to read (re-read in my case) them together. (We are talking about possibly getting the whole seminar in the spring, too!)

For now, we have committed the video, working through and discussing the EN questionnaire and LB worksheet, as well as at least 10 hours of UA time each week. I know we need 15-20, but I am optimistic that once he finds those 10 hours enjoyable (and once we move through more of the materials) we will increase them.

Right now, we have maybe 3. So 10 will be a huge improvement.

I am committing to getting back into shape, because I do know that's one of his top EN's (I had gotten quite fit and then we miscarried about this time last year, and it's been hard for me to come back from it).

Anyway, I wanted t let you know how absolutely inspiring and encouraging i found your story. My H has disliked Harley for years (sorry, Dr. H), so using your story as an example of how important it is to have and follow a good plan was really the first thing that has ever been motivating for him.

I will keep reading your thread with interest.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/02/12 08:26 AM
Telly!!! So nice to hear from you again. And what a wonderful thing to hear that my story is making a difference for you and your H.

I am sorry to hear about your miscarriage. We experienced the same thing between #1 and #2 and it was a very difficult time for us.

Great to hear you're getting in shape as well. It's a good feeling to get off the couch and do something and to know I can eat without starving and lose weight.

It's early morning and I'm stuck working ... late night issues with a code deployment. blech.

I have something I want to share that my wife and I just talked about with Dr Chalmers that I think is going to be huge and I hope it's something you and your H can discuss. I will do that when I'm more with it.

Check back soon.

So good to hear from you dear friend.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/03/12 03:38 PM
What a brutal weekend. I need to catch up on sleep.

Despite the work issues her and I had a wonderful time this weekend. Wrestling has started for our freshman high schooler and he pinned all 3 of his opponents in the weekend tourney. Wahoo!.

I want to provide Telly with some info that I think may pertain to her situation but before I submit a post I want to list out the 2 different types of resentment that Dr. Harley talks about. My W and I are to re-read that section in his book but we were unable (in the 5 minutes we had) to find it. Does someone have that part of the book handy they could post? And where can we find it?

Thx.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/03/12 04:13 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I want to provide Telly with some info that I think may pertain to her situation but before I submit a post I want to list out the 2 different types of resentment that Dr. Harley talks about. My W and I are to re-read that section in his book but we were unable (in the 5 minutes we had) to find it. Does someone have that part of the book handy they could post? And where can we find it?

I know it is in Effective Marriage Counseling and in one of the articles here. Brainy found it in the articles recently. I will search for it and see if I can find it. It is about resentment types A and B. There are also some radio clips on it.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/03/12 04:56 PM
Hmmm. Dr Chalmers thought it was in one of the books we have. HNHN, LB or FILSIL.

If it's not I'd like to know that too ... otherwise we'd be on a wild goose chase.

If someone posts the contents of it then I can just provide it to my W.

Thx Mel.
Posted By: hopefulwife47 Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/03/12 05:04 PM
Well, i can't seem to find it in the books, but here it is on the question and answer section:

http://www.marriagebuilders.com/graphic/mbi5026b_qa.html

PS I am so proud of you and your wife.. Maybe someday.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/03/12 05:42 PM
Thanks Tired,

I have read that and will send it on to my W.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/03/12 07:10 PM
Empathy plays such a crucial part in a marriage. While I think a marriage could survive without it having it makes things so much easier.
Quote
Why would any of us hurt the one we promised to love and cherish?
Lack of empathy is at the core of the problem.
One of the most important consequences of our emotional isolation is that we cannot feel the way we affect others. And that creates the temptation to hurt others because in doing so we don't feel the pain we cause. If we were connected emotionally to others we would be far less tempted to do anything thoughtless, gaining at someone else's expense. That's because in so doing, we would be hurting ourselves as well.
Lack of empathy helps makes thoughtlessness possible. Since we don't feel what other's feel, we tend to minimize the negative effects we have on others, and consider our thoughtlessness to be benign.
How does one gain empathy if one doesn�t have it? By following the POJA. Hearing your spouse�s perspective is where you learn the truth behind their thoughts and feelings. It�s there that you learn how your actions hurt your spouse. To not only hear their thoughts but to actually seek to understand their feelings and pain � to empathize. In return no negative comments or persuading to change the spouses thoughts, just acceptance of their perspective. If they say it bothers them it bothers them. End of discussion.

While some LBs are more intense than others they still all do the same thing. They withdraw those love units and cause some form of pain for your spouse.

So cut to Friday and Dr Chalmers is taking us through POJA. My W and I had to come up with some Annoying Habits and communicate them to each other prior to our session. As such we talked about those AHs as part of POJA. And as an example we used the AH concerning my W�s diet soda consumption. We both shared our perspectives including validating the thoughts surrounding it being an AH for me. My concerns for it have several implications but we stuck with the health aspect of it.

While we were doing the brainstorming aspect of this my W had to stop and ask �
�I need to understand something. Is it the policy that regardless of what my H finds annoying I am going to have to eliminate it? If I have to do that I am going to resent him for it�.

Dr. Chalmers then used the AH I do as an example to explain the two kinds of resentment. I drive in rush hour everyday and thus I am comfortable around a lot of other cars. I am a pretty aggressive driver. When my wife is with me I know she�s uncomfortable being a passenger. She�s an aggressive driver too but being a passenger she�d like me to be more cautious. I get it. She was in a car accident, she�s not in control, etc. That has to be a horrible feeling.

�Mrs. Alias, when you�re in the car and he�s driving too close to the car in front do you have control of how it makes you feel?� No. �Right so if he decides he�s going to continue to drive that way what options do you have? You can just try to get used to it or seek therapy for your fears. But what really would happen if he continued to do that�. I�d hate him for it. �Exactly�.

My W stopped it right there and said �I get it�. Wow, it was an emotional moment for me. To actually hear my W say she gets it was huge. I was never able to explain that to her before� probably because I just didn�t get it. All those times having conversations with her not really knowing how to put it in perspective. There were always the phrases �having to give up everything� and �tit-for-tat�. Suddenly the POJA made a lot of sense to us both. And for me I suddenly understood the difference in the forms of resentment. The things I do intentionally that impact her. I have a lot of choices that could make things better and aid in eliminating her resentments of me.

Years ago I made a conscience choice to start paying attention to my driving when she was in the car with me when she explained her fear. I would do all I could to avoid the things that intentionally brought her harm especially when she had so few choices. I am embarrassed to say I allowed myself the excuse of withdrawal to stop doing what was necessary to protect her feelings for me after having done it prior to the withdrawal. I guess that is the definition of withdrawal.

The rest of the POJA example was just more affirmation of how well this process was going to work for us. Not doing anything until we have an enthusiastic agreement is the key. I think she was more at ease knowing she wasn�t going to have to give up anything until we discovered, agreed and implemented a better option.

I�m sure this example is a work in progress for her and I and it will be some time before we find the final solution. But I feel better just knowing we�re working together to find something we both will want to live with.

Posted By: Telly Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/03/12 09:25 PM
Hi MrAlias :),

I just wanted you to know that I e-mailed this to my husband a few minutes ago. We had talked into the wee hours last night and then again this morning. (I don't remember the last time we did that).

I think he will be able to relate to your post.

Thanks for sharing--and again, so happy for you, my friend. smile
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/03/12 10:50 PM
Effective Marriage Counseling pg 112 - 113

What about Resentment?

One of the most common objections to the POJA is that it creates
resentment when it�s followed. I agree; it does usually create some
resentment. But far more resentment is created when it is not followed.
An illustration will help make this important point.

George is invited to watch football with his friend Sam. He tells
his wife, Sue, that he plans to accept the invitation. Sue objects.

If George goes ahead and watches the game, he�s guilty of independent
behavior. He is not following the POJA, and Sue will be resentful.
When George does something against the wishes of Sue, I call
her resentment type A.

If George follows the POJA and doesn�t accept Sam�s invitation,
George will be resentful. When George is prevented from doing something
because of Sue�s objections, I call his resentment type B.

Which type of resentment makes the largest Love Bank withdrawals:
type A or type B? The answer is type A, and that�s why the POJA
helps build Love Bank balances. I�ll explain.

When George violates the POJA, Sue has no choice but to feel
the effect of the thoughtless decision (Love Bank withdrawals) for
as long as memory persists�possibly for life whenever the event is
recalled. But when George follows the POJA, the negative effect is
limited in time. It lasts only as long as it takes to discover an enjoyable
alternative that is acceptable to Sue.

George lets Sue know how disappointed he is with her objection
but is willing to discuss other options. Sue wasn�t invited to watch
football and doesn�t want to invite herself to Sam�s house, so she
suggests inviting Sam and his wife to their house to watch football.
George calls Sam, he and his wife accept, and the new activity puts
an end to George�s type B resentment.

Type A resentment can last forever, but type B resentment stops
the moment a mutually enjoyable alternative is discovered. Those
with poor negotiating skills may have trouble seeing the difference
because they have not learned how to resolve conflicts. They may
feel resentment about a host of issues that have been unresolved in
their marriage. But after you teach a couple to negotiate successfully,
unresolved issues are minimized. Then it becomes clear to
them that the POJA helps build Love Bank balances by eliminating
type A resentment.

Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/03/12 11:06 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I�m sure this example is a work in progress for her and I and it will be some time before we find the final solution. But I feel better just knowing we�re working together to find something we both will want to live with.

That is an amazing breakthrough, MrA. I am so very glad you all are working with Dr Chalmers. I understand your wife's outlook and will say that the POJA was the hardest thing for me to grasp because I had an entitlement attitude and felt like I could never be truly happy unless I pursued my little heart's desires. Little did I understand that my IB would lead to unhappiness because of the damage it did to my marriage.

It sounds like your wife is getting this. I know that i was much more willing to give up my independent behavior when I understood the trade off. Sort of like quitting smoking. I was trading in my IB for a happy, romantic marriage. And now she is in a position to fully understand that.

Dr Harley made an interesting observation about his own marriage on the radio show last week that caused a lightbulb to go off for me. He was discussing the practice of sacrifice and said that the REASON he and Joyce get along so good is BECAUSE they have never engaged in the practice of sacrifice. When you think about it, it really makes sense.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/04/12 02:04 PM
Sacrifice. It's funny (not really) the things I do and the thoughts that roll around in my head when I�m not communicating with my W.

So many times (you think I'd learn) when I finally have a discussion with my W about a particular area I feel I'm being LB'd where her perspective ... well puts things in perspective. Instead of radical honesty I would go with assumptions and judgments.

And I'm talking about everything ... not just the big things. All the little things that really add up. Now sometimes it feels burdensome when I have to have a discussion about every little thing, but given the alternative which always has a far better, more positive outcome it is a no brainer. I think that is what�s hard for many new couples that come here � the radical honesty � because in the beginning it really does take a lot of work and determination to work through conflicts � big or small. The task to most probably feels daunting. But in the end it is really worth it. It eliminates a lot of IB and removes the independent thinking that almost always leads to DJs.

I remember a radio clip where both Dr Harley and Joyce were talking about how hard it was to buy each other gifts and keep it a secret. Not because they didn�t like to surprise each other but that they really wanted to share their joy and excitement in what they got for each other. They said it was all they could do to keep it a secret. Almost like torture. No secrets. Full disclosure �. Er uhm � unless it�s a surprise! laugh
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/14/12 05:10 PM
Update: Well things are going relatively well. I continue to work hard to fill my W's ENs. I feel totally engaged in our M again and have no desire to go back to being withdrawn. My thoughts of her are positive in nature and thus I can say we're floating between the stages of intimacy and conflict.

I think I'm struggling a little bit because I feel devoted to following the assignments given by Dr. Chalmers but I have to be the catalyst for them and by that I mean I have to be the one to mention we have homework to do and ask if we can schedule time to do the work. Days go by sometimes and the homework isn't done. I think this is the extent of how much she wants to partipate. I get the impression she just doesn't want to do the work because she isn't self motivated to do it.

I'm looking for a little feedback.

An LB I struggle with is Dishonesty. Her #3 EN is Honesty and Openness. I struggle when it comes to communicating my feelings. I am being dishonest with my W because I tend to withhold the truth of what I'm feeling/experiencing. Some of this Dishonesty comes from what are probably DJs too.

My reasonings (internal workings) have to do with trying to not apply pressure to my W. Knowing what I know about her (she could live without SF, many times just doesn't have the energy nor desire, she has thoughts about guys only wanting one thing, etc) I tend to soft shoe around certain subjects. Not all subjects but certainly any subject that's conflictive (SF, Marriage Builders assignments, etc.)

This isn't working, of course.

Today I sent her a message explaining my relunctance to be 100% honest about what I'm feeling when it involved SF. I asked for her help in letting me know how she would like me to approach the subject. I await her response. It's possible I won't get a response ... so I guess I'll have to be diligent in continuing to ask.

I should be able to just say ... "Would you like to ...". But most times I don't. Then what happens is the specifics I gave her in my I'd love it if(s) aren't met so I'm disappointed, frustrated and worried this is just going to go back to the same old same old. I own my piece of this. I don't put all the blame on her that my need isn't met. I mean if I can't even man up enough to ask I shouldn't expect it to just happen. It would be nice but I shouldn't expect it.

I have a poor Giver and a poor Taker.

Has anyone else had this internal struggle and what were some things you did that sorta helped get passed it?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/14/12 06:29 PM
Here's something I just read:

It sounds so easy .... just speak up. Right. Like if it were that simple I'd already be doing that.

Well, I guess that is where I'd marry up the alternative behaviors that Dr. Chalmers is teaching us. To voice my displeasure ... not by being negative but by merely speaking up using thoughtful requests ... again ... I'd Love It If(s) .....

I have to get my brain around how doing that is a thoughtful request not a demand or expectation.

Here's what I read:
Quote
I�m often asked whether there�s a most common issue facing those who seek therapy, and usually I respond by saying that there really isn�t one issue that stands out, per se. However, there seems to be a common root to a significant number of issues that I help clients with, that is, �conflict avoidance�. The avoidance of conflict, both in the immediate- and long-term, not only has the ability to undermine the foundation for any healthy relationship, it more often than not eventually leads directly to its undoing. Unfortunately, this usually occurs with the direct �approval� of the avoider. In other words, if given the choice, some people would much rather see a relationship dissolve before their very eyes than risk facing the potential pain, awkwardness, or anxiety that often accompanies the act of being fully present and honest with another human being.

Couple�s therapy is often a place where this phenomenon is most evident. In fact, I can�t count the number of times that couples have stated with pride that throughout the course of their relationship they rarely, if ever, argued, as if that fact represented the gold standard for a healthy relationship. Unfortunately, it isn�t. It may be a relatively quiet and (externally) peaceful relationship, but it certainly isn�t a healthy one, primarily for two reasons: 1) it�s void of the full spectrum of human emotions, some of which include frustration, anger, and resentment, and 2) the entire relationship is based upon the avoider�s fear. Yet, upon hearing their declaration of �non-arguing�, I almost hate to disappoint them when they clearly hold it such high regard. But it�s typically never too long before I burst that balloon, and let them know that perhaps if they�d argued a bit more (in healthy and respectful ways, of course) they just might not be sitting in an office like mine.

Conflict avoidance, as is the case for conflict confronters, is a communication style that is often formed within the family of origin. For example, an adult who was raised by at least one parent who was a conflict avoider, may have learned early in life that avoiding conflict seemed to work best for that parent. (Note, however, that the concept of �worked best� doesn�t necessarily imply �healthiest�, rather it may just mean what seemed emotionally or physically �safest� for the individual under their particular circumstances.) Another scenario where a conflict avoidance style might be adopted early in life is where a child is parented by one, or both, parents who were conflict confronters � confronters who may have elicited a great deal of fear on the part of the child. Consequently, as a survival mechanism, the child will often do anything to avoid creating additional conflict within the family and will, in many cases, adopt the role of a �people pleaser� in childhood, as well as in their adult relationships, thus, becoming what we know as a �co-dependent� or �self-sacrificer� in the process.

Regardless of the origin of conflict avoidance, one thing is certain: both the avoider, and those around them, pay a huge price for the behavior � and often, as I said previously, the price paid may mean the end to many relationships over their lifetime. By definition, their relationships (other than casual acquaintances) tend to be time-limited, since it�s inevitable that all people in relationships will at one point or other experience conflict. And, if it�s not dealt with appropriately, or avoided all together, the only option is to remain silent, hoping the problem will go away by itself which, of course it never does. Consequently, the relationship dies either physically (it ends, and the people part), or emotionally (where people may stay together but where little remains between them). Regardless, it�s not that the conflict avoider is unpleasant to be around. On the contrary. The avoider tends to be on the surface, at least, easy-going, flexible, and eager to please. It�s wonderful having people like that in one�s life since one thing�s for sure, they won�t cause any conflict. But, underneath, most of these people experience huge amounts of resentment, even rage, because by sacrificing their �voice� � both literally and figuratively � their lives are often out of their own hands since they simply won�t �beg to differ�. As such, many end up experiencing lives so very different than they had originally hoped for (yet refused to fight for). Consequently, by honouring their commitment to �keep peace at any price�, most of their negative emotions are merely swallowed, at least until they find they can no longer do so successfully. At that point, the emotions of the avoider either erupt overtly or, more typically, they engage in the only form of anger they consider safest: passive aggression � another relationship killer.

So what to do? Well, if you�re an avoider, and you�re no longer willing to pay the price of seeing important relationships with others (and, by the way, with yourself, too) wither and die, then the first step is to find your voice, again, both literally and figuratively. Find the many ways in which you �hide� in relationships, and decide that you�re going to find the courage to begin speaking up, to begin showing up in your relationships, to begin to be yourself more fully. You have the right, after all, and, in doing so, you might be surprised at the freedom it offers you, a freedom that you�ve missed out on your entire life. Yes, it�ll probably mean introducing more conflict into your life, but once you experience the freedom of your own voice, you may never decide to sell yourself out ever again. And, because of that decision you�ll no doubt need to learn the sorts of tools that will help you deal with conflict. But that�s the second step. The first step is to begin speaking up, no longer being the �people pleaser�. In the �pleaser�s� place will stand a fully present and emotionally tangible person with a unique voice, who will be finally known by others, and, again, most importantly, by themselves.

So, again, how to begin? Get off the proverbial fence, take a stance, find your voice, and then�offer an opinion!
Posted By: hopefulwife47 Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/14/12 06:56 PM
Wow,, just wow... I relate to so much of this... I've just been here for so long that I have absolutely no idea how to do any of this..

Yes my father scared me to death, but my mom wasn't much better. I remember my grandparents being upset becasue they felt like both of my parents yelled at me way too much...

early in life is where a child is parented by one, or both, parents who were conflict confronters � confronters who may have elicited a great deal of fear on the part of the child. Consequently, as a survival mechanism, the child will often do anything to avoid creating additional conflict within the family and will, in many cases, adopt the role of a �people pleaser� in childhood, as well as in their adult relationships, thus, becoming what we know as a �co-dependent� or �self-sacrificer� in the process.


This describes me so much:
Regardless, it�s not that the conflict avoider is unpleasant to be around. On the contrary. The avoider tends to be on the surface, at least, easy-going, flexible, and eager to please. It�s wonderful having people like that in one�s life since one thing�s for sure, they won�t cause any conflict. But, underneath, most of these people experience huge amounts of resentment, even rage, because by sacrificing their �voice� �[/b

And this is so incredibly true...
[b]In other words, if given the choice, some people would much rather see a relationship dissolve before their very eyes than risk facing the potential pain, awkwardness, or anxiety that often accompanies the act of being fully present and honest with another human being


I am absolutely terrified of being fully present... I'm not sure how to find my voice...

Thanks for posting this... BTW, I'm not posting for 2 reasons: 1. So my thread will get buried if hubby decides to look at the site.. 2. It is time to fish or cut bait. People have given their advice. I know what I need to do. I just need to do it or live with the consequences.


Quote
I�m often asked whether there�s a most common issue facing those who seek therapy, and usually I respond by saying that there really isn�t one issue that stands out, per se. However, there seems to be a common root to a significant number of issues that I help clients with, that is, �conflict avoidance�. The avoidance of conflict, both in the immediate- and long-term, not only has the ability to undermine the foundation for any healthy relationship, it more often than not eventually leads directly to its undoing. Unfortunately, this usually occurs with the direct �approval� of the avoider. In other words, if given the choice, some people would much rather see a relationship dissolve before their very eyes than risk facing the potential pain, awkwardness, or anxiety that often accompanies the act of being fully present and honest with another human being.

Couple�s therapy is often a place where this phenomenon is most evident. In fact, I can�t count the number of times that couples have stated with pride that throughout the course of their relationship they rarely, if ever, argued, as if that fact represented the gold standard for a healthy relationship. Unfortunately, it isn�t. It may be a relatively quiet and (externally) peaceful relationship, but it certainly isn�t a healthy one, primarily for two reasons: 1) it�s void of the full spectrum of human emotions, some of which include frustration, anger, and resentment, and 2) the entire relationship is based upon the avoider�s fear. Yet, upon hearing their declaration of �non-arguing�, I almost hate to disappoint them when they clearly hold it such high regard. But it�s typically never too long before I burst that balloon, and let them know that perhaps if they�d argued a bit more (in healthy and respectful ways, of course) they just might not be sitting in an office like mine.

Conflict avoidance, as is the case for conflict confronters, is a communication style that is often formed within the family of origin. For example, an adult who was raised by at least one parent who was a conflict avoider, may have learned early in life that avoiding conflict seemed to work best for that parent. (Note, however, that the concept of �worked best� doesn�t necessarily imply �healthiest�, rather it may just mean what seemed emotionally or physically �safest� for the individual under their particular circumstances.) Another scenario where a conflict avoidance style might be adopted early in life is where a child is parented by one, or both, parents who were conflict confronters � confronters who may have elicited a great deal of fear on the part of the child. Consequently, as a survival mechanism, the child will often do anything to avoid creating additional conflict within the family and will, in many cases, adopt the role of a �people pleaser� in childhood, as well as in their adult relationships, thus, becoming what we know as a �co-dependent� or �self-sacrificer� in the process.

Regardless of the origin of conflict avoidance, one thing is certain: both the avoider, and those around them, pay a huge price for the behavior � and often, as I said previously, the price paid may mean the end to many relationships over their lifetime. By definition, their relationships (other than casual acquaintances) tend to be time-limited, since it�s inevitable that all people in relationships will at one point or other experience conflict. And, if it�s not dealt with appropriately, or avoided all together, the only option is to remain silent, hoping the problem will go away by itself which, of course it never does. Consequently, the relationship dies either physically (it ends, and the people part), or emotionally (where people may stay together but where little remains between them). Regardless, it�s not that the conflict avoider is unpleasant to be around. On the contrary. The avoider tends to be on the surface, at least, easy-going, flexible, and eager to please. It�s wonderful having people like that in one�s life since one thing�s for sure, they won�t cause any conflict. But, underneath, most of these people experience huge amounts of resentment, even rage, because by sacrificing their �voice� � both literally and figuratively � their lives are often out of their own hands since they simply won�t �beg to differ�. As such, many end up experiencing lives so very different than they had originally hoped for (yet refused to fight for). Consequently, by honouring their commitment to �keep peace at any price�, most of their negative emotions are merely swallowed, at least until they find they can no longer do so successfully. At that point, the emotions of the avoider either erupt overtly or, more typically, they engage in the only form of anger they consider safest: passive aggression � another relationship killer.

So what to do? Well, if you�re an avoider, and you�re no longer willing to pay the price of seeing important relationships with others (and, by the way, with yourself, too) wither and die, then the first step is to find your voice, again, both literally and figuratively. Find the many ways in which you �hide� in relationships, and decide that you�re going to find the courage to begin speaking up, to begin showing up in your relationships, to begin to be yourself more fully. You have the right, after all, and, in doing so, you might be surprised at the freedom it offers you, a freedom that you�ve missed out on your entire life. Yes, it�ll probably mean introducing more conflict into your life, but once you experience the freedom of your own voice, you may never decide to sell yourself out ever again. And, because of that decision you�ll no doubt need to learn the sorts of tools that will help you deal with conflict. But that�s the second step. The first step is to begin speaking up, no longer being the �people pleaser�. In the �pleaser�s� place will stand a fully present and emotionally tangible person with a unique voice, who will be finally known by others, and, again, most importantly, by themselves.

So, again, how to begin? Get off the proverbial fence, take a stance, find your voice, and then�offer an opinion!
[/quote]
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/14/12 07:05 PM
Hi tired.

Funny how I'm quick to hand out advice to you about finding your voice and yet can't do the same.

My FOO comes from a mother who suffered from major depression and a father who tried to comfort and appease her as much as possible. Most times she'd just hide in her room and cry all day. But when she came out sometimes there were explosions (suicide attempts, disrespect of my father, outright anger).

For me I associated with the "sacrifice" part of the statements ... and then the build up and "boom". I've really learned to be conscientious of that.

To this day when one of my kids cries I can only take it for so long and have to do something. I've found I try to comfort them so the crying stops ... even if they're being disciplined and hence the crying.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/14/12 07:12 PM
Today's radio clip has segments Radical Honesty, Dishonesty and Liars.

I tried to listen but it just keeps stopping on my DROID. I'd like to hear his thoughts because sometimes when things are just put into perspective (big picture) it sinks in for me ... and I muster the courage to move forward.

Maybe that'll help you too?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/31/12 02:56 PM
I thought I'd give a quick update.

Things are going better than I could have expected. My W and I are truly behaving in ways I've never seen before in my 29 years of knowing her.

We've eliminated all of the troublesome ways we used to talk (or not talk) not just on the hard topics but everything. Every conversation.

We've been spending a ton of time together (thanks to the Holidays and time off). It's been fun. We're doing things together first and foremost instead of making seperate plans ... not because we have to but because we want to.

My W approached me last night and said she needed to state some things. Wow Open and Honest communication.


She said she�s really happy and loves what has been happening lately. She loves being with me and now craves that more than anything she�s craved before � more than being with her sister or her horses or whatever. Her first desire is to be with ME!!!

She said she feels sorry for other couples (we�ve got family and friends that have some pretty ugly Ms) and she knows they�re going to be jealous of us. I agree wholeheartedly.

I am ecstatic. My needs are being met and many of the LBs I saw in her before are being eliminated. Heh, while I�m sure we�ll keep working on those LBs I hardly a concern about them now that my needs (especially #1) are being met. I couldn�t be happier and continue to be prepared to move heaven and earth to make her happy.

MelodyLane I found that smile.

grin
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/31/12 03:03 PM
hurray What a wonderful update. Thanks for sharing.
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/31/12 04:16 PM
MrA that is so awesome!
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 12/31/12 04:47 PM
Bravo to you, my friend. grin
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/01/13 01:31 AM
I just went back and read this thread from the start! WOW! What an amazing read. It is amazing how FAR you have come, MrAlias. smile
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/02/13 02:23 PM
Thanks Melody.

I hate to say it was luck that made things happen � but I know it played a part. I was fortunate (lucky) that my wife agreed to join me in MB coaching. She could have refused or continued to suggest other alternatives that probably would have kept us where we were. She gets my kudos because she loved me enough, she wanted our marriage enough, to give Marriage Builders a try.

I know it is proven you can do MB alone and make a difference � but in my situation it just didn�t work. I know we had this debate before but I was quite certain I knew nearly all of what was needed to incorporate the MB principles into my lifestyle even though I hadn�t read a Dr. Harley book. I know I put a lot of proper effort into what I was doing and got a TON of great advice and direction over the years from all the great posters here. Still not much changed for us. We�d make small little strides but we�d backslide over and over and over again. Thus I would be back, over and over and over again. Until her and I became a team, until we made the agreement we were going to do the MB plan together and give it our all then nothing much was ever going to change.

I know your push was for the coaching not so much that I hadn�t read the materials in the books. Having now read the 3 books I didn�t see much I didn�t already know. The joint agreement of following MB together was the key for us. That opened the door to what the coaching and the MB plan had to offer. It allowed my W and I to create new behaviors and habits that we�d never tried before.

The coaching was perfect for us. It was the neutral party we needed that provided the plan that we would agreed to follow, together. That made all the difference in the world. I was no longer trying to educate her on what I believe we needed to do. That was a huge LB for my W. She simply just doesn�t like it when I try to educate her � unless, of course, she asks me to. I now know better ways of opening up those types of talks. I know better ways to explain things from my perspective. Having Dr. Chalmers explain the plan and highlight areas we needed to work on was so instrumental in us working the plan. No longer was it a teacher/student or parent/child type situation for us. It was H and W working and learning together � as equals.

The one thing we learned in coaching that was critical for us was the piece on resentments. I�m sorry to say I was probably just as guilty as my wife not seeing the difference in the two types of resentments. Once that was discussed it opened our eyes as to where we were falling short in our M. It is helping us to remove those selfish areas we used to hold so dear to us.

My MB plug:
The biggest key to success, for any couple, is simply do the MB Plan ... together. It is an all encompassing plan that truly provides all the elements needed to create a completely safe and fair marriage. It is so much easier to love and give of yourself when you know you are a team and as such you are safe, you will be treated fairly and you will have your needs met.

I so look forward to continuing to build an even stronger relationship with my W.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/02/13 04:32 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I know your push was for the coaching not so much that I hadn�t read the materials in the books. Having now read the 3 books I didn�t see much I didn�t already know. The joint agreement of following MB together was the key for us. That opened the door to what the coaching and the MB plan had to offer. It allowed my W and I to create new behaviors and habits that we�d never tried before.

You are absolutely right about my push for coaching. The reason I pushed for coaching was because I know you CAN'T do Marriage Builders alone. You might be able to fiddle around the edges a bit and prime the pump, but it will all be to no avail if the reluctant spouse does not eventually get on board. You have seen yourself that it just doesn't work with one person. For example, the POJA can't be done alone because it is contingent upon a joint decision. The POJA is what makes all the difference in marriage. But even that is very hard to implement when you are not in love and in order to be in love, you have to work the program together.

I am relieved and happy for your sake that your wife was willing to get on the phone with Dr Chalmers. I think she is just awesome!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/08/13 02:40 PM
So we hit what we believe was a bit of a rough patch ... or rather her and I both could feel us backsliding a bit.

I'm not exactly sure why but this weekend I certainly wasn't as pleasant as I'd been. She seemed to pull away a bit too.

But we both recognized it and set some directives to get back on track.

For me I have to separate all other things that cause me anxiety when I'm interacting with her. She isn't the source of my issues and thus she doesn't need to feel the repercussions of them. I vowed and am following through with being pleasant when I�m around her and she vowed to do the same.

If I can do my part then she�ll always be my source of happiness. I am pleasant, she is pleasant and when we�re both pleasant to each other all other things seem less significant. It�s like a shot of meds that make all other things less painful/stressful.

We did discover we don�t work as well together as we thought. We had trouble communicating during a small project her and I were trying to work on this weekend (this may be the mood setter I talked about above). We did manage to set a course of direction for the project and are getting close to its completion but after this experience I told her we shouldn�t count on these types of projects being the thing her and I do for UA RC time. So I suggested we sit down and find other things that would make us laugh and/or make us feel happy when we�re together. We may have to pull out the RC questionnaires.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/08/13 06:08 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
But we both recognized it and set some directives to get back on track.

Perfect. You are self correcting and that is what is necessary.

Quote
For me I have to separate all other things that cause me anxiety when I'm interacting with her. She isn't the source of my issues and thus she doesn't need to feel the repercussions of them. I vowed and am following through with being pleasant when I�m around her and she vowed to do the same.

What is causing you anxiety? My DH and I have learned to avoid any anxiety producing causes [as much as possible] during our UA time. For example, traffic sends my DH over the edge. When that happens he has angry outbursts at the other drivers which is a HUGE LOVEBUSTER to me. So we carefully plan our time to avoid traffic and he has learned to not have AOs. It makes our time together much less tense.

Quote
If I can do my part then she�ll always be my source of happiness. I am pleasant, she is pleasant and when we�re both pleasant to each other all other things seem less significant. It�s like a shot of meds that make all other things less painful/stressful.

Agree to a point, but it is much better eliminate the stress whereever possible. Can you do that? And for sure, you are 100% right when you say it is much better to be PLEASANT.

Quote
We did discover we don�t work as well together as we thought. We had trouble communicating during a small project her and I were trying to work on this weekend (this may be the mood setter I talked about above). We did manage to set a course of direction for the project and are getting close to its completion but after this experience I told her we shouldn�t count on these types of projects being the thing her and I do for UA RC time. So I suggested we sit down and find other things that would make us laugh and/or make us feel happy when we�re together. We may have to pull out the RC questionnaires.

You are doing the right thing! When you run into minefields, the solution is to make a course correction. Your focus is absolutely right: the make your time as pleasant as possible!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/08/13 08:16 PM
Our anxieties (she has some as well) are just normal issues everyone faces. It isn�t that they�re present as part of our time together � just that we�re still feeling the impacts of everyday life which spills over into our time together.

Mine revolve around work pressures, deadlines, management duties, etc. Hers seem to be around the gals at work and their poor behaviors. And, of course, the children. The little angels. Life is sometimes hectic.

The plan is be pleasant and not let those outside influences impact our time together. Well ... that's my plan anyways. I think she just needs me to be happy and pleasant. It makes all the difference in the world to her. It�s not that hard when I think of the payoff I get for doing so.

I like your solution to the traffic situation. I know I wouldn�t have AOs in traffic when she�s with but I certainly communicate to her my disdain for the people that are in my way. It�s my highway � move over. Hee-hee. grin

Thanks for the feedback Mel.

PS: DS15 recognized that things had backslid a little and communicated to Mrs. Alias his concerns. I think this really prompted us to have a more in-depth discussion on what to do about it.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/08/13 08:31 PM
It's really funny how couples get into the bad habit of unpleasant behavior when they are together, without ever realizing it. One of my bad habits was venting. It could be about politics, people at work, etc. My H used to do the same thing. Now we stop ourselves and we even say to each other on the way home "have I been pleasant enough tonight?" Being consistently pleasant has made such a dramatic difference.

Do you listen to how the Harleys communicate on the radio show? They are always so pleasant so it is no wonder they are in love!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/08/13 08:34 PM
I do. It's almost so foreign (maybe not so much now) that it felt phoney to me. Can they really be that pleasant, comfortable and vulnerable with each other?

The answer is a definitive yes. It's just a matter of choosing to be that way.

"have I been pleasant enough tonight?" I like that. I'm sure you won't mind if I borrow it.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 03:51 PM
I thought I'd share some things with everyone here. This is an email I sent to my wife.

The intent of the letter is to

1). Improve our R by increasing our RC items and Conversation topics
2). Practice my speak. Don't try to educate her but also be open and honest at the same time.

If you see anything glaring or have something to share that's helpful please do.

Originally Posted by Mr.Alias
To: Mrs. Alias
Subject: Recreational Companionship and Conversation
Hi Sweetie.

I was doing some reading this morning and stumbled across this from Dr. Harley:

It simply makes good sense for couples to take every opportunity to share recreational experiences because it's such an easy way to sustain the feeling of love.

But for some, especially men, recreation is not only an enjoyable diversion, but it also meets an important emotional need. It's something that often "keeps them going" For these people, recreational companionship is particularly satisfying. Those who share their favorite recreational activities with them build massive Love Bank accounts if they are of the opposite sex.

I encourage couples to spend most, if not all, of their recreational time together. It's one of the most efficient and effective ways to build the feeling of love.



... and that started me thinking about you and I. I've thought about this for years ... how you and I have sort of independent lives. I do my thing. You do your thing. We spend some time together but a lot of what we do together are things of necessity or family oriented activities versus things that just you and I do. It's like we're dependent on other things or other people to find things of interest to do. Well ... except for the remodeling stuff we've been doing and as we've found that seems to have created some pressure on us and isn't as fun as we'd hoped it would be. Although I am quite happy with how that little project is coming along. Thanks for the wonderful idea.

I would love it if we could find a few things that you and I would do together consistently that makes things fun for us.

I would love it if we had more to talk about then just my job, your job, our friends or families lives or things about the kids. Maybe if we found some fun things to do together we'd have more to talk about too.

If I don't know them all I would love to know what your dreams are.


Dr. Harley went on to say:

Most couples share favorite recreational activities during courtship. It's an important reason that they fall in love. But after marriage a host of circumstances prevents these activities from being shared, and before long they find it easier to engage in recreational activities independently. Since they do not join each other anyway, they pick new recreational activities that the other spouse would not enjoy. Eventually, such couples realize that they've "drifted apart" and wonder why.

In our case I started thinking ... what was it you and I did together when we were young and courting ... and all I could remember was that we'd simply be together ... and we'd go partying/drinking. That kind of saddened me. I thought there was more to us than that and maybe there is but my poor memory just can't recall what it was we did.

As I see it you and I get along pretty well. We have some communication issues where we kind of clam up and aren't always open and honest but we're working on that and I'm really encouraged. I hope you are too. I can see why we picked each other .... why we're together as we seem to try to be good to each other. We're both really "good" people and I must say I'm very lucky to be with you.

Still I'm a little nervous because I think there should be more to us than just being good to each other. My open and honest feelings are ... I'd like more than that for you and I.

Partying. I don't mind having an occasional drink, maybe a glass of wine a couple days a week or so, nor do I mind going to a party now and then where we have a few. But long gone are the days where that's all I want to do and I really don't care to drink a lot anymore. I think we differ a little on that and I know it's important for me to be honest about my feelings.

So I was wondering what your feelings were about where we are at in terms of stuff we do together. And do think you'd like to find other things to do together that would maybe increase our desires to be together?

If you would like to find other things could we look at one of Dr. Harley's lists on recreational activities and see if it helps? It's a questionaire. Would you be interested in going over it and putting in your opinions about these items?

If so this is the link to that webpage I was reading. At the bottom is the recreational inventory questionairre he's put together. There's room to add more if we have other interests we'd like to discuss and/or try.

http://www.marriagebuilders.com/graphic/mbi4505_rei.html

Thanks and I love you.
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 04:56 PM
Wow MrA that's a toughie. I understand what you're saying totally but given that the main LB you've overcome is educating her, I'd leave out the "In our case I started thinking ... " and "Partying." paragraphs. Just rate partying appropriately low on the inventory if it's on there.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 05:13 PM
I suppose I could have left out the "In our case I started thinking" paragraph but I did think it relevant to our situation. I think I should have said that it was related to RC activities as it isn't obvious that's what I meant. I may have made it sound like there was nothing else.

When we discuss it I'll be sure to point out my error.

I shouldn't have said Partying. I should have said drinking. This isn't the first time I've tried to broach the subject with her. And while I'm reading this I realize my intent was to raise my concern about the amount of alcohol she drinks. I did it off-handedly and wasn't direct. Instead of just flat out saying I don't like how much she consumes and POJA it I explained the choices I've made.

This one is a tough subject for me. I'm not sure if this in an LB for me or if I'm just trying to impose my will or genuinely am concerned it's getting out of hand.

And because I'm unsure I dance around it. Sigh and yuck.
Posted By: living_well Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 06:33 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I shouldn't have said Partying. I should have said drinking. This isn't the first time I've tried to broach the subject with her. And while I'm reading this I realize my intent was to raise my concern about the amount of alcohol she drinks. I did it off-handedly and wasn't direct. Instead of just flat out saying I don't like how much she consumes and POJA it I explained the choices I've made.


I don't think this is an issue you should either raise indirectly or POJA. It is a valid complaint. I would come right out and tell her that her drinking makes you uncomfortable. Stop right there and see how she responds. She may share your concerns and ask for help in finding a way to drink less.

Approaching it indirectly is not going to do anything useful and will distract from the positive message.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 07:18 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I
I shouldn't have said Partying. I should have said drinking. This isn't the first time I've tried to broach the subject with her. And while I'm reading this I realize my intent was to raise my concern about the amount of alcohol she drinks. I did it off-handedly and wasn't direct. Instead of just flat out saying I don't like how much she consumes and POJA it I explained the choices I've made.

I really like your letter and I think its a great way to get her thinking about making each other your favorite recreational companion. One thing I would suggest is asking her out for date nights to go out for dinner. Try to plan them at a nice restaurant an hour away. That gives you an hour to chat on the way there and an hour on the way back. One thing DH and I do that makes it more romantic is to share an entree [which is cheaper and avoids having a bunch of leftover food] and sit next to each other in the booth. It makes it a very intimate evening.

And I agree very much with livingwell that her drinking should be handled as a complaint and addressed directly. If her level of consumption bothers you, that needs to be expressed openly and honestly.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 07:19 PM
Is she an alcoholic? A heavy drinker?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 07:48 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Is she an alcoholic? A heavy drinker?

A month or so before we started to see Dr. Chalmers I did send her an email explaining my withdrawal. In that email I expressed quite a few complaints. Maybe too much at once. In that email I told her flat out how her drinking affected me. She responded by cutting way back, not drinking during the week and paced her drinking to mine when we'd go out with friends. She didn�t seem too pleased at the time. Now mind you we were in a bad place at that time and so her attitude wasn't one of happiness. I'm unsure if it was due to the state of our marriage or that I complained or that she had to cut back cuz she knew I wanted her to or a combo of all those things.

This is where her and I need to keep working on our R. These are the kind of intense discussions that we usually (used to) avoid.

In my opinion she�s suspect to addictions. I�ve talked about this before. She had a horrible time quitting smoking. She complains about her weight and yet fights me tooth and nail when I suggest anything low carb, low sugar, etc. She eats a lot of sugars and carbs. Her eating habits is one of the things we discussed with Dr. J regarding my need for an attractive spouse. She�s still eating a lot of those things and I still find them less than attractive.

I want to believe she could quit the drinking if she chose to. It appears to be a recreational thing for her. I don�t know if she is an alcoholic.

I do know her father was never clinically diagnosed as an alcoholic that I know of but he�d drink every day. He�d head down to the local pub for breakfast and a [sarcasm]cup of coffee. Yeah right.[/sarcasm] He had emphysema and smoked until he died of respiratory failure. So you can about imagine what plays on in my head. Like father like daughter. Once a year she�d join him for �breakfast�.

Is she a heavy drinker? I think so. On an average day like now � if time allows she�ll drink about 30 or more ounces of beer or have a couple 3 glasses of wine (say half a bottle). When we go to a party or have a party � she�ll have about 6 or 7 beers at a minimum.

I fear this is going to escalate. Being the conflict avoider I�m unsure how to broach the subject. Especially now that she knows how I feel about it. We�re doing so well. Yet she�s swinging back into her drinking. Within the last year or two it�s grown to this.

Can you tell me � should I be extremely concerned? Is the amount she drink relevant? I have no experience diagnosing alcoholism.

The one thing I think that gauges my concern is a scenario. Let�s say we had a bit of a tiff and things got a little heated or one of the kids drove her to anger. She�d reach for a beer. I�ve seen it happen before and I think that's a warning sign.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 07:59 PM
New, living_well and Mel.

Thanks for your responses BTW.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 08:03 PM
She sounds to me like she is an alcoholic or a heavy drinker. Your wife drinks to escape life and that is what alcoholics do. Another thing we do is to make sure no one really knows how much we drink. She might be drinking alot more than you think.

And we are not clinically diagnosed as alcoholics, we can figure it out on our own if we are honest. Alcoholism is an addiction to alcohol and it sounds like she is addicted.

I would definitely bring it up to her and tell her you are very worried about her drinking. Ask her to quit drinking and see how she responds.

Does she get drunk? Does she go drunk driving?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 08:13 PM
Some more thoughts of mine... She does not have an alcoholic personality from the sounds of it. For example, she is not extremely independent, destructive or thoughtless. Most alcoholics absolutely will not follow the POJA. That is not the case with her.

But I would look around to see if you can find any signs of hiding drinks. If you brought this up in the past, she might be trying to demonstrate normal drinking, which means she would let you see her drink 2 to 3 drinks and but would hide the other 5-10 drinks. And alcoholics don't necessarily get drunk. They can drink massive amounts of alcohol just to feel normal.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 08:26 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
I would definitely bring it up to her and tell her you are very worried about her drinking. Ask her to quit drinking and see how she responds.

Does she get drunk? Does she go drunk driving?

Thanks Mel. If I ask her to quit I assume I would need to do the same. I mean if it's a problem for her then I have no issues giving up recreational drinking. Heck half the reason I drink as little as I do is because of how much she does. I'm trying to be a good role model and set the tone of what I believe is controlled.

I can assure you she will be upset if I ask her to quit drinking, just as she would if I asked her to stop eating so much garbage. She doesn�t like to be �told� what she should do. I wish she was more open to feedback. It is one of the things that bothers me. She listens and reciprocates but always with a hint of something negative (depression, resentment, something ). I don�t know what she�s feeling because she doesn�t answer when I ask if there is something wrong. I always feel she�s saying �Oh I hear you and I�ll do as you ask but I am not going to be happy doing it.�. This is one of the dynamics I�m hoping we continue to work on. We�re being more open. I need to hear her perspectives.

After about 4 beers yeah I can tell she�s drunk. She starts to loosen up some. She�s a happy drunk.

She doesn�t drink outside the home unless she�s with me and I always drive in those cases. So no she doesn�t drink and drive.

She does not hide her drinking. I can attest to the amount she drinks with certainty.

On the flip side I think if it meant enough to me she�d quite drinking.

Tomorrow we�re going to my buddy�s house for a party. It�s over an hour away through the metropolitan area. I told her I would drive (she hates metro driving especially in the dark). She said it�s XXX�s party. You should have fun with your buddy and have a few drinks so I�d like to drive but you know I hate driving under those conditions. I volunteered to be the DD as I drive into the metro every day. Point being she did offer to stay sober and drive and does this quite regularly when she knows I�d like to have more than just a beer.


Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 08:30 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Some more thoughts of mine... She does not have an alcoholic personality from the sounds of it. For example, she is not extremely independent, destructive or thoughtless. Most alcoholics absolutely will not follow the POJA. That is not the case with her.

But I would look around to see if you can find any signs of hiding drinks. If you brought this up in the past, she might be trying to demonstrate normal drinking, which means she would let you see her drink 2 to 3 drinks and but would hide the other 5-10 drinks. And alcoholics don't necessarily get drunk. They can drink massive amounts of alcohol just to feel normal.

Thanks Melody. These things are very reassuring coming from someone who has experience in this area. I appreciate your candor.


Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 08:45 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[ Point being she did offer to stay sober and drive and does this quite regularly when she knows I�d like to have more than just a beer.

Would you be ok with it if she just cut back considerably? This comment above tells me she is probably not an alcoholic; that along with your certainty that she is not hiding drinks. An alcoholic wouldn't just have 2 or 3 drinks, for example. That would be stupid. Better to have none than not enough! UNLESS she is trying to demonstrate normal drinking to get you off her back.

If you are not bothered by light drinking, I would just tell her that it bothers you when she drinks alot and ask her to cut back. The important thing is that you are honest about your feelings.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 09:20 PM
Thanks Melody. I will approach her again with this and reiterate my concern for the volume and frequency that she drinks. I suspect it will come up when we discuss the email I sent out earlier today.

Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 09:23 PM
And honestly, if she can't control it, then she does have a serious problem. She is a problem drinker NOW just for the sheer fact that it bothers YOU.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 09:24 PM
If your wife told you that it bothered her when you ate popcorn, wouldn't you just stop eating popcorn? I know I would... So she should have no issue with just cutting back dramatically. Unless........she is addicted.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 09:26 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
She is a problem drinker NOW just for the sheer fact that it bothers YOU.

True.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 09:37 PM
Melody.

I want to thank you for taking the time to answer and help with this today. I know are very busy on this forum so I appreciate your time.

Signing off for now.

Have a great day and thanks again.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/11/13 10:00 PM
Have a great weekend, MrA!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 03:29 PM
I apologize for the length of this.

MB folks I'd like some feedback on my communication to Mrs. Alias. I am trying to communicate in a positive manner to my wife but doing so I find it difficult speaking the truth about what I see. When I speak the truth it comes off sounding like I am trying educate her (an LB of mine) which I probably am but as you'll see some of these things are quite obvious (DJ alert?) and I just don't know how to use positive statements only to get my message to her.

The first is her lack of open and honest communication. Each week or every other week I've been trying to work parts of MB. I sent her an email some time ago to discuss our UA/RC time. Nothing. I mentioned the email to her twice and she doesn't respond. She said she read it ... and that's it. This doesn't add deposits to my LB when topics are ignored. This is on top of the fact during counseling I'd do the homework and she'd skip much of it. But because my needs were getting met (one of my biggest concerns) I chose to keep going. Monday night she played with the dog while we were on the speaker phone with Dr. J. I let her know how that was distracting to me. I couldn't focus on what she was saying as there was a distraction in the room.

So for a while now I've questioned her dedication to this new life we're supposedly creating. I think she just wants me to be happy ... but what would make me happy is if she showed more dedication. Sigh ... that's for another day somewhere's down the road. For now I'm going to work my side of the program.

The first concern I have is my need for an attractive spouse. My W used to always be thin and had a lovely shape. But the last couple years metabolisms have changed and so has she. We're trying to eat healthy but she continues to do things that put the kabosh on those plans.
Here are a few of those things:
- She eats a lot of candy, keeps it in her vehicle so she can grab some whenever she wants ... bags and bags of candy pumpkins (blech)... I think there are like 8 bags in our home right now.
- She is a bit of heavy drinker and in the last couple of years she's upped the volume and frequency of consumption. She drinks light beer nearly everyday. She likes for us to have a drink together. She enjoys that.
- She's a snacker and thus our pantry is full of boxes of snack crackers, muffin mixes, bread mixes, dessert mixes, etc.

So while I see everything she does that's counter to her attempts only to hear her complain "I'm fat!" in an angry tone then turn around and say "I'm upset that this eating plan isn't working for me especially when I see it working for you" I don't know how to communicate what I see without sounding negative. When I'm frustrated with those comments I so wanna educate her on what she's doing wrong. I've made one comment and said well I don't think you and I are eating the same each day.

The next topic is her drinking. This won't be a hot button for her yet I doubt we'll discuss it (DJ). After I mention it she'll just make a change (I assume) like she did before but I fear, like before, she'll be upset about it. That isn't POJA and I walk around feeling guilty while she walks around being upset. blech.

Here is what I jotted down so far ... hack away at it please. This is very good practice for me and these are items I really would like to see some change.

Quote
My darling Mrs. Alias,

As you know one of my LBs is my dishonesty. I tend to hold things in that create internal debates/conflicts in my head. Things that may be upsetting me aren't being communicated.

Dr. J has helped me to find ways to communicate things in the form of a request not a demand and in such a way that I am not trying to educate you.

One of the reasons I tend hold stuff in is that when I communicate things to you (even when I do them as Dr. J has helped me do) I don't get a response back. I don't get back the open and honest communication that would help us POJA a solution. It isn't that I need reassurance that you aren't hurt or offended or are even OK with what I said. It's just so I know what your thoughts are. My mind races trying to decide what to do next. I don't want you to sacrifice and I love finding a solution that makes us both happy.

I would love it if when I communicate my complaints/concerns to you you let me know if you're feeling hurt, feeling depressed, agree with what I said or simply need time to think. I would love it if we could schedule some time to discuss the issue later on.

With that said there are a couple of things I hope to discuss with you. They are in some ways related to one another.

I would love it if you were in better shape. I am still very attracted to you but I know you can and have looked better. I love it when we eat healthy. I have been making efforts to plan and prepare most of our dinners so we are eating very healthy. I love that we agreed on this eating plan as I feel it has been very beneficial to me, hopefully you and even the kids. I would love it if both of us could stick to the plan to get the maximum results out of it. Let me know if you are open to feedback.

Next, I've mentioned this to you before but we never discussed it. You made some attempts to change when I mentioned it earlier even though we weren't in a good place and that made me very happy. Now that we're doing well you went back to it. The fact you went back to it is creating some negative thoughts for me.

I would love it if you were an occasional drinker. It worries me the amounts you drink as you tend to drink everyday. I would love to discuss a way we could both be happy as I know this is something you enjoy.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 04:00 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
The next topic is her drinking. This won't be a hot button for her yet I doubt we'll discuss it (DJ). After I mention it she'll just make a change (I assume) like she did before but I fear, like before, she'll be upset about it. That isn't POJA and I walk around feeling guilty while she walks around being upset. blech.

I want to think about your letter for a minute, but I wanted to comment on the above in the meantime. The reason your wife is upset is because it is not easy to develop new habits. That is not a violation of the POJA. Of course she is not going to feel enthusiastic about cutting back on drinking, and that is ok. [but concerning] I DID NOT feel enthusiastic when I quit smoking 4 packs of cigarettes a day, but it was the best thing for my health. Cutting back on her drinking is good for your marriage.

I have to ask, though, why do you want her to cut back on her drinking? What bothers you about that?

While reading your post I thought that joining a gym with your wife might be the ideal solution for you both? You can get a personal trainer who will lead your workout schedule and your diets. And you can get in some GREAT UA time working out together. Dr Harley says that working out together is a great UA activity because you are together as you produce endorphins. That would help you get to your UA goal, help her lose weight and clean up her health.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 04:46 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
I have to ask, though, why do you want her to cut back on her
drinking? What bothers you about that?

I suppose a couple of factors.
1). I associate the amount she drinks to poor health especially body weight. She isn't one for working out and to your next point ... she definitely doesn't like to work out in a group or even alone with me. We've discussed it. However she did do yoga with a GF for a while (so I wonder why she doesn�t want to work out in a group) and I could encourage she do yoga again.

2). I don�t like what it is teaching our kids. It feels a little irresponsible to drink every day and if they see it � they�ll think it is OK (which maybe it is OK) � which could lead to some poor choices.

The heavy drinking �
3). She gets a little plowed some times and when we're out with friends I feel a little embarrassed. Other than 1 or two of the guys she�s the only one getting smashed. My best friend commented once about it � and I was kind of embarrassed.

4). It reminds me of the old days where she�d go partying and stay out all night long while I waited at home for her to return. I�d go to work in the early weekend mornings and she�d come in with her drunk friends and I�d be totally turned off. So it's a trigger for me which I have to work with her to find a solution. But still it feels irresponsible to me to get that drunk.

5). Usually after a night of fun and drinking I�m wishful for some SF time (probably a bad idea). Because of the amount she drinks she�s usually in a position where it won�t happen as she�s no longer feeling so hot.

Quote
While reading your post I thought that joining a gym with your wife might be the ideal solution for you both? You can get a personal trainer who will lead your workout schedule and your diets. And you can get in some GREAT UA time working out together. Dr Harley says that working out together is a great UA activity because you are together as you produce endorphins. That would help you get to your UA goal, help her lose weight and clean up her health.

Her and I have purchased enough equipment to have our own home gym. Exercise bike, home gym, pull up bars elliptical, etc. Now we could always sell that and join a gym � but we tried that in years past and didn�t stick to it. For me I�ve always been a work out at home guy and have had a lot of success doing so. I�m not sure what would motivate her to be consistent with it. Other than the yoga she never sticks to anything for more than a week maybe two. She hates sweating is what she says.

As far as someone to guide us � that is a great idea. However this time with Dr J. hasn�t proven to be what I wished it would have been. She�s very adverse to being told/coached on what to do. Sigh. I�m sure that�s why I try to be logical with her � which ends up being me trying to educate her � I guess. Weird cyclical effect.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 04:49 PM
How much UA time are you getting every week?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 04:58 PM
This week not enough. Last week ... a lot. Our closet remodel plus we spent some of it watching our kid wrestle. His involvement lasts about 30 minutes total throughout the 4 to 8 hours we're getting splinters in our rears. Inbetween his matches we'd spend time just talking ... about whatever. Most of the other parents aren't even sitting next to each other. Fools.

I'd say last week it was pushing 22 hours or so. This week ... probably only about 6 so far.

As of yesterday we're going to have more time on our hands. Our oldest injured his knee in wrestling practice and he may be done for the season. HOpefully he's back in a couple of weeks. We're both bummed about that. Hard to watch him hurting and having to miss something he was really enjoying.

But UA is becoming problematic hence why I sent the RC email to her ... and brought up again after our last session with Dr. J Monday night ... which she didn't provide any response to.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 05:18 PM
See, I think you should spend all of your energy on getting the UA time and I will tell you why. Once you get consistent, her feelings will change. Dr Harley says it typically takes about 8 weeks of being consistent. [of course that is going to vary with every couple but it is an average]

I think she will be much more open to changes if she is in love with you.

Are you and your wife scheduling out the time for your week?
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 05:32 PM
MrA, living with casual daily drinking bothered me, too, especially because there was a lot of alcoholism in the family, and I didn't want my kids growing up thinking daily drinking is "fine." Maybe it is for some folks but for families who have already been put through the wringer over and over again with other family members, let's give it a rest already.

Like for example some families like to do Civil War re-enactment stuff and that's great, but if a family just lost a kid in Iraq you would understand if the Dad said okay let's lay off the war stuff.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 05:44 PM
Mel,

Thanks for the thoughts. I will contemplate them while working to ensure we get our UA time in before I even consider communicating some of these other issues. Maybe I am a little ahead of the game and need to keep building us up before I try to hit too many of these.

My concern is letting the MB principals die especially now that we're sorta on our own again. I've got this sinking feeling that she is just sorta playing along with the MB principals because she knows it appeases me. Her actions or lack thereof are my indicators. I wish I had some way of knowing how much she buys into it. I commented to her Monday after we talked with Dr J. when she seemed (again) distracted during our session that I wasn't sure how much of the MB concepts, if any, she agrees with. I also told her how her actions during the call made me feel. She doesn't respond. Radio silence.

Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 06:14 PM
MrA, you are going to think I sure am free with your money, but do you remember me saying I thought it would take a 2 prong approach to keep you rascals in line? On the online program, you get weekly lessons and have to complete a survey to make sure you have done it. If you have not done it, your coach contacts you. [and you can also contact her and/or Dr Harley when need be] This is done on a weekly basis so it is harder to skip lessons. And if your spouse is lollygagging around and won't respond to the coach, then Dr Harley will sometimes step in.

You guys are going to need every bit of help available, IMO.

But I also think that if you can use all your might to push the UA time on a consistent basis that you will get the results you want. I don't have a tough time getting my needs met OR getting my DH to quit annoying behavior because we are in love. We are both very open to suggestions and are motivated to continually improve. The UA time will get you to that place if you are doing a great job of effectively meeting each others needs.
Posted By: kilted_thrower Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 06:29 PM
Does she like any type of exercise at all? Lifting weights, biking, rowing, P90x? Maybe you could get her try a Crossfit and the two of you could train together?

Here's a cool suggestion. Check out this website www.fitstream.com . They have any and every kind of workout/training setup you can imagine. Want a 10 minute bodyweight workout? How about 20 minute kettlebell and resistance band workout? Maybe you feel like just hitting some biceps and triceps for 15 minutes? Or follow the 40 minute burpee workout. There's a small monthly subscription fee but it's definitely worth it.

If one of the mods will allow us to exchange email addresses, I have a ton of recipes that I have on my dropbox account that I could email you the link to. Everything from breakfasts to beef dishes to desserts to side dishes to dressings to desserts (I noticed you said she likes to eat a lot of sweets). The recipes have pictures, ingredients, cooking instructions, and the meals are broken down into calories, protein, carbs, fat, fiber, etc

It's important to get that diet in check. What and how we eat has the biggest impact on our physique.

I don't know man. I don't have a lot of sympathy for people that complain about issues they create for themselves. In this case your wife is eating in a manner which leads to the results she doesn't want and then gets angry at the results. One of my seniors decided he didn't have the time to get his oil changed in his car. Well, one day that engine blew and he was without a car and complained about having to ride the bus and not having a car. I remember when I was in my early 20s and I was mad that I had to wear a seatbelt. So I started refusing to wear one. And I continually got pulled over and ticketed for not wearing a seat belt. Of course I complained about all the money I was spending on tickets. A funny thing happened when I decided to wear my seat belt--I didn't have to complain about the cost of tickets.

Although it might not fly, when she complains about how she looks or what not, tell her you're sorry she's unhappy with the way she looks and what would be necessary to not be unhappy about her body.

The issue with alcohol and body fat isn't the alcohol by itself but when combined with food. The body will burn the alcohol calories first which depending on amount can take a long time and the calories from the food accumulate without being digested. Check out Lyle MacDonald over at www.bodyrecomposition.com for a much more detailed breakdown. If you like nutritional biochemistry as much as I do, you'll love the site.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 06:41 PM
Originally Posted by kilted_thrower
Check out Lyle MacDonald over at www.bodyrecomposition.com for a much more detailed breakdown. If you like nutritional biochemistry as much as I do, you'll love the site.

He sounds like my kind of guy! Here is what I read about him on another website:


Quote
I just read something on his [Lyle] forum (first found it yesterday) Someone had ask him some questions and it was a well thought out posts with bullet points etc. He answered "I"m not reading all that"
rotflmao
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 07:38 PM
Quote
MrA, you are going to think I sure am free with your money,


laugh

... and so begins the debate between her and I. Just how far do we need to go to make this a great marriage? She'll say if I can just be happy she'll be happy. A status quo kind of mentality. Me? I like working on myself and working on this M. So if it�s going to keep getting better I believe I'll have to do the pushing � which is hard to do as a conflict avoider. More hemming and hawing from Mr.Alias.

I am certainly happier now that she�s meeting my needs and fairly consistently too. Why it was so hard to before is beyond me. It�s not like I�m doing a whole lot more or a whole lot less than I was all those years before. My mind will drift off on the why(s) but maybe it�s best to leave that be.

Is it possible she needs less (less security, less PORH, less POJA) to be happy and feel gushy in-love? And that, for her, this program is a lot of work for my benefit only?

I do know, now that she�s participated and read all the material, I�m in a much better position (confidence-wise) in being able to approach her and be more open and honest. Until she tells me she doesn�t buy into it I�ll approach it like she does.

I don�t want to do this sloppy or halfa$$-ish but I don�t want to become a pain to her either. Do we need to be MB experts and follow it to the letter to have a sustainable, romantic marriage? I wish I knew. She keeps meeting my needs maybe that is all I need.

I do know right now I�m happy and I definitely am in love with her � but I�m not falling down drunk with romantic love either. I�m guessing most of that has to do with just how our counseling and subsequent lack of committed effort I saw out of her went. I�m feeling a little perturbed about that.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 07:54 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I don�t want to do this sloppy or halfa$$-ish but I don�t want to become a pain to her either. Do we need to be MB experts and follow it to the letter to have a sustainable, romantic marriage? I wish I knew. She keeps meeting my needs maybe that is all I need.

YES!! And that is my point.

She will not be meeting your needs for long if she is not in love. That is why you need to drive this ship all the way home. Saying that she is happy because you are happy is NOT ROMANTIC LOVE.

Romantic love would cause her to be highly motivated to meet your needs on a continual basis. THAT is what you should strive for. Otherwise, all this good stuff is going to taper right off after awhile and pretty soon you will be back where you were 2 years ago.

Quote
Is it possible she needs less (less security, less PORH, less POJA) to be happy and feel gushy in-love? And that, for her, this program is a lot of work for my benefit only?

She needs less because she is not in love. She is happy, sure. But that is not the goal here. The goal is to have a happy, romantic marriage that is created by developing habits will SUSTAIN that marriage.

You both have not developed those habits yet, hence your trouble getting her motivated.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 07:56 PM
My thoughts were for you to get motivated via coaching and then learn and implement the program via a more regimented, hands on program like the online program. IMO, you guys are not disciplined or motivated enough to do that on your own. You need every bit of coaching and direction you can get.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 07:59 PM
Thanks for the reply Kilted.

The whole working out thing is something I've learned to avoid. I've spent thousands of dollars on equipment because she felt it was going to be the right thing for her. Bottom line she just isn't disciplined enough or motivated enough to stick with anything.

She doesn't like people telling her what to do and so I don't push. She likes to decide what she wants to do on her own and away she goes only to stop a short time after getting started.

She has often said she is jealous that I am very determined. When I set my mind to something I generally do a good job of continuing to get the results I wanted. I used a variety of lame diet and eating plans by myself to lose the weight (low fat, low carb (South Beach), Medifast). All worked well but then not really because they weren�t things I could or should stick with long term. Nor could I continue to do it alone. It was far too dysfunctional for our family and she wasn�t on board.

So as you can see I am very excited that we�re now following recipes from some Marlene Koch cookbooks together. Everyone eats what I eat. It is going well although the holidays set me back a bit. I dropped about 9 pounds the first 4 weeks or so.

I, too, don�t have a lot of sympathy for my W when it comes to her issues regarding her weight. But that doesn�t change the facts that she feels the need to complain all the while she�s wrecking the plan set forth by us together. It makes it difficult to not throw things back in her face so to speak. As far as telling her I�m sorry she isn�t happy well I have done that. And I have mentioned I�m having success while she�s not but we�re not eating the same things 24x7 � but just the one time.

She has no interest in me being her accountability partner. Nor does she want one � at least not yet.

The need for an email seemed necessary given what this situation is doing to us.

Anyways thanks for the suggestions. I don�t want to come here and just vent so the fact I�m getting some ideas on what to try swing my vents into requests for help. grin
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 08:07 PM
Mel. I agree with you 100%.

In order for us to get there I'll have to let her know what she's doing and what we're doing right now isn't complete ... it isn't enough.

Every ounce of my being wants to avoid the conflict especially when it's going well. I picture the conversation with her and I can see the puzzled look on her face. This is based on how she responded to Dr J.s tutelage.

I am not saying I won't. I just need time to let it soak in with me and to build a sound reasoning that would resonate with her should I explain why I feel it necessary.

Please keep reminding me as I'm sure I'll be back with more venting. It's my favorite passtime.

Thanks for the advice and feedback ... again.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 08:28 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
T
The whole working out thing is something I've learned to avoid. I've spent thousands of dollars on equipment because she felt it was going to be the right thing for her. Bottom line she just isn't disciplined enough or motivated enough to stick with anything.

I have come to the conclusion that most people are like that. I know I am!! I could never stick to an exercise routine or diet until I found ones I liked. For ME, I get so much enjoyment out of the old The Firm workouts that I got into the habit of working out. Maybe she just needs to find a workout routine that she really enjoys?

I tend to stick to things that have the greatest return on my investment. And what I mean by that is that I have to get paid for my investment. With those workouts they promised to see a difference in 10 workouts. And i did see that. I could see that there were no wasted moves versus many of the workouts that contain alot of superfluous flopping around. grin And I just LOATHE jogging because it is so boring to me.

As far as a healthy diet goes, the only one that really paid off for me was a low carb diet. They are the easiest to lose and maintain the weight loss on. For example, when I went on it, I lost 40 pounds in 4 months. That was the hook for me.

My point in all this is that maybe she needs to see an immediate payoff to get and stay interested in a new program? Which is one of the reasons I was suggesting really pushing the UA time. If you can get that nailed down, then she will be in love sooner and will be more motivated to do the lessons.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 08:50 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
My point in all this is that maybe she needs to see an immediate payoff to get and stay interested in a new program? Which is one of the reasons I was suggesting really pushing the UA time. If you can get that nailed down, then she will be in love sooner and will be more motivated to do the lessons.

I agree.

How disappointing that she could have seen an immediate payoff with this new eating plan (low carb, low sugar, good fats, etc) as she sabatoges it with other bad habits. I am not giving up that this is going to work for her too. The meals are fabulous.

I will give her credit she sure is diligent in her efforts to search for something that will work. I wish I could write the quote she says of what plays in her head when she�s trying to be determined. It sounds like a struggle within herself. Like the saboteur is herself but she can�t be blamed for herself well because someone (the author of the cookbook) is telling her what to do. Huh? She makes me chuckle sometimes.

I will get back on the pushing of UA time. Tonight we�ll have that aged cheese and a glass of wine (enabler that I am) together. I�ll put down the book I�m reading to help her complete her painting project in our mudroom. Mostly I�ll just insist we be together and not go off on our own like we�ve done the last two nights. Tonight we�ll probably only get 2 hours but that�s better than zero.

A corney invitation to a wine and cheese tasting was just sent. Corn Ball that I am.
Her response: LOL. I would love to attend. smile
Posted By: hopefulwife47 Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 08:50 PM
For me, it was finally understanding that my health was a love buster for my husband.. I never thought about it withdrawing love units. So at first, I ate better and worked out ONLY because I didn't want to make any withdrawals. I was working my butt off to make deposits, hoping he would do the same... But a couple of months into it, I felt so much better that when he did something that upset me and I was tempted to buy those sugary treats at the bakery to make me feel better, I didn't... Because I wanted to be good to me!!! I wouldn't be punishing him, I would be punishing myself. I don't feel good after eating that stuff ( well, I do at first then don't later). So now I do it because I like the way I look and feel.. Praying your wife finds the same kind of motivation. ( though hubby's positive comments certainly help!(
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 09:09 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
A corney invitation to a wine and cheese tasting was just sent. Corn Ball that I am.
Her response: LOL. I would love to attend. smile

Nice!

Do you send her flirty texts? My DH sends me flirty texts all day and it is soo endearing. I wonder if she would enjoy that?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 09:12 PM
Originally Posted by tiredwife45
. But a couple of months into it, I felt so much better that when he did something that upset me and I was tempted to buy those sugary treats at the bakery to make me feel better, I didn't... Because I wanted to be good to me!!! I wouldn't be punishing him, I would be punishing myself. I don't feel good after eating that stuff

That is EXACTLY why I avoid sugar like the plague! It makes me feel like holy hell, which is enough motivation for me! I discovered this several years ago when I gave up sugar. I was going to "reward" myself with some carrot cake on a visit to Las Vegas. I hadn't had sugar in 3 months. I ended up in bed that night feeling horrible! So I am very motivated to avoid sugar.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 09:51 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
A corney invitation to a wine and cheese tasting was just sent. Corn Ball that I am.
Her response: LOL. I would love to attend. smile

Nice!

Do you send her flirty texts? My DH sends me flirty texts all day and it is soo endearing. I wonder if she would enjoy that?

One of her EN requests is that I send a check-in text to her each morning during the work week. So I usually send something endearing. Occasionally flirty but mostly either caring or humorous. I love to make her laugh. She likes to laugh.

We text a lot about a lot of different things throughout the day.
Posted By: kilted_thrower Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 10:29 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
My thoughts were for you to get motivated via coaching and then learn and implement the program via a more regimented, hands on program like the online program. IMO, you guys are not disciplined or motivated enough to do that on your own. You need every bit of coaching and direction you can get.

At the studio I work at as a fitness (personal) trainer and nutritional consultant, the clients are like this. They have absolutely no motivation and discipline to do it on their own. So they pay A LOT of money to be told what to do, how to do it, when to do it, how long to do it. Essentially it's coaching. Good coaches are worth the investment because they get results. We had a biggest loser Oklahoma last year. Three of my clients competed in it. They placed 1st, 2nd, and 3rd
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/16/13 11:22 PM
Originally Posted by kilted_thrower
[We had a biggest loser Oklahoma last year. Three of my clients competed in it. They placed 1st, 2nd, and 3rd

Wow, that is great! Congratulations!!
Posted By: kilted_thrower Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 07:58 AM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by kilted_thrower
[We had a biggest loser Oklahoma last year. Three of my clients competed in it. They placed 1st, 2nd, and 3rd

Wow, that is great! Congratulations!!

Thanks! It wasn't easy. The competitors put in a lot of effort and dedication. Self-improvement is often an uncomfortable endeavor.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 02:46 PM
Originally Posted by kilted_thrower
At the studio I work at as a fitness (personal) trainer and nutritional consultant, the clients are like this. They have absolutely no motivation and discipline to do it on their own. So they pay A LOT of money to be told what to do, how to do it, when to do it, how long to do it. Essentially it's coaching. Good coaches are worth the investment because they get results. We had a biggest loser Oklahoma last year. Three of my clients competed in it. They placed 1st, 2nd, and 3rd

I would like if if she was willing to sign up for a coach. She�s often suggested I go do it but says she�s not interested when I ask that we get one together or at least she should have one too. Lots of excuses, we don�t have the money, she doesn�t have enough time and the big one �I simply do not like people pushing me , telling me what I need to do.�. I am so tired of hearing that one. Especially after what I saw in our counseling with Dr. J.

I don�t think physical fitness is that important to her. She wants to be thin, look good, but does not want to do the work it takes to get there. Example: For Xmas on her list she put down a gift cert for a body wrap at her frequented tanning salon. Evidently these wraps make you sweat while you lay there � and they�re supposed to help you slim down. That�s more her style. Less physical exertion but oddly enough something where you sweat. She got that cert for Xmas. Has yet to use it although she tried once and they were booked up.

Now I say that but there have been times like this fall where she tried to go walk every day. So she will exert herself. She even involved the kids �We�re getting out of the house and making the loop around the development every day .�. She did it for 3 or 4 days then stopped. Despite my encouragement she just does not remain determined. I cannot join her there as walking/running is difficult/painful (planter fasciitis 8 years and still going � sigh). This foot defect really ticks me off because walking is something she likes to do and if I were to ask her to come along every day I suspect she would. Add to it I�ve spent 8 years on and off in tons of different therapies and countless arch supports, etc and it is still there. Grrrrrrrrr. I am trying to rack my brain on something we could both do and enjoy and stick with it. I�ve asked her about doing some other things she enjoys � like joining her in a yoga class � but she just doesn�t seem interested.

BTW I do need to get back working out. I am so on and off with that. I�ll stick to it for 6 months or longer and then something will happen and I�ll stop. This latest time my back spasm�d again. Another one of my long term issues with some lower vertebrae. I am only doing some goofy little exercises right now to strengthen my lower back. So I need to do more and set a good example � although that hasn�t helped her in the past.

I have to avoid educating her. It evidently is an LB for her � I guess. She�s never said so directly. Talking about issues and not doing that is difficult for me to do so I usually just butt out. I�m not sure me avoiding educating her is working for us � as it seems she needs more that just encouragement to get motivated and stay motivated. I suspect if we were to hire you, kilted, you�d see her for about a week, maybe two and then that would be it.

If you guys could help me find a way to help her stay determined you would be my new best friends.

I think I�m going to ask her in my morning text if she�d like to discuss and brainstorm ideas for being more physically active. I hate to sell the equipment we�ve got because I really enjoy using it. The idea of a gym isn�t enticing to me. I do not like having to leave home to work out and usually that deters me from going. Also I don�t enjoy having other people watch me work out. Too many distractions. Private training is really expensive. I may be more inclined to sell it and use it to pay for a gym if I knew she'd be committed to it. Otherwise I may end up with nothing changing except I no longer have the home gym.

Posted By: living_well Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 03:39 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
walking/running is difficult/painful (planter fasciitis 8 years and still going � sigh). This foot defect really ticks me off


Have you ever tried Birkenstocks? They saved my life when I had a foot condition (since repaired) and more recently my brother got them after a horrible blood clot nearly cost him his foot (thank you British NHS). Even my wonderful foot doctor's inserts were not able to get me walking without pain but with these I was able to walk all day.

I got the fabric clogs, my brother got the sandal type. Because the size really matters, get them fitted by a professional the first time, later you can buy on line. You may even need a Birkie insert on top of the sole. Just tell them what your problem is and they will solve it - I promise!
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 03:48 PM
What if you got a home workout DVD and asked her to join you? I have about 100 workout DVDs and my own home gym and I love working out at home. What keeps me motivated is an enjoyable, targeted workout that gives me fast results. [without alot of superfluous flopping around]

I use free weights, bar bells, steps, resistance bands [that might be good for you!], and whatnot, and I get a really good workout. I joined a gym one time and the workouts I was doing there were tame in comparison. [the PT helped me tremendously with my form]

The tapes that have kept me motivated all these years [and there is a whole cult following of us] are The Firm workouts, particularly the older tapes. You could get a couple off ebay for cheap and see if you like them. If you like them, you can invite her to join you.

Those workouts really got me interested in working out. I have pretty much stuck to them for 15 years now.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 03:50 PM
The workouts I am referencing are either weight lifting or cardio or a combination of both. in your case, it sounds like you need to stay away from cardio because of your foot. But can you do weight lifting?
Posted By: kilted_thrower Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 04:37 PM
Alias, have you been to see a sports medicine doctor? And specifically one that has experience in dealing with athletic recovery? Plantar fasciatis is definitely treatable but you have to find the right doctor to tackle the issue.

Go sign up for the streamfit.com site. I think it offers a trail period so you can see if you like it. What's nice about the site is you can do the workouts from home. They have everything from 10 min quick metabolic burn to 15 min no equipment needed bodyweight cardio to 60 min kettlebell to 28 day transformation programs. You pick which workouts you want to do that day based on what equipment you have access to. They have male trainers and female trainers. They're excellent and motivating. I personally give it my stamp of approval (and that says a lot). Another thing that's nice about it is it takes the thinking aspect out of figuring out things/setups and let's say you only have 15 min to spare for the day, no problem...pull up the site and find a 10-15 min workout and done!

Honestly, I hate cardio. Almost all of my cardio is done by playing indoor soccer. The exception to my dislike for cardio is the rowing machine which I absolutely love. One of my favorite quick workouts is to do pullups to failure, weighted dips that get me in the 8-12 rep range, 10 box jumps, row 200 meters. Do that 3-4 times and call it a day and you're done in about 15 min. When I do my physique contests, cardio does become a necessary evil to get to that 5-6% bodyfat level.

Here's another thing about cardio--cardio is about getting the heart rate up to a certain point for a certain amount of time. We're supposed to hit that magical 'fat burning zone'. Unfortunately no one really knows where that zone is. Is it at 40 minutes, 30 minutes, 60 minutes? And when you're done, you're done with burning calories. Now, go spend that amount of time getting your heart rate up just the same by using high intensive circuits using low impact plyometric movements and weights (or slam balls/resistance bands/sleds/etc). What happens is you burn overall calories, your metabolism goes sky high, and you continue to burn a greater amount of calories for up to a 48 hour period. Richard Simmons did a ton of cardio and he looked terrible.

When I train clients, I tend to use a lot of timed intervals with 2-4 exercises grouped. So, I might take Joe and have him work 30 seconds on, 15 seconds off and do kettlebell swings and dumbbell curl and press and then mountain climbers. Repeat this two more times. Then we move onto 40 seconds on, 20 seconds off and rotate between dumbbell step ups, kettlebell goblet box squat, and low box burpees with plank jacks. Repeat that one or two more times. Stuff like that keeps it fast paced but not too crazy that it's overwhelming. And for a session like that, I need four dumbbells, a kettle bell, and a step up box. And, really, one of the dumbbells can be used in place of the kettlebell. And a chair or the couch can be used in place of a low step box.

I don't mean to brag but I am good at this. The problem with personal trainers a lot of times is that they are not good coaches and motivators and they're not creative or able to think out of the box. The studio I work at is a bit different. We only do 1 on 1s or small group training which is 2-4 people. Everything is done by appointment. We have the training area divided into four separated rooms. Since the rooms are seperated by walls, it gives the client and their trainer a private area. There are three of those and then a larger room for the pack training (small groups).
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 04:50 PM
Originally Posted by kilted_thrower
Now, go spend that amount of time getting your heart rate up just the same by using high intensive circuits using low impact plyometric movements and weights (or slam balls/resistance bands/sleds/etc). What happens is you burn overall calories, your metabolism goes sky high, and you continue to burn a greater amount of calories for up to a 48 hour period. Richard Simmons did a ton of cardio and he looked terrible

This is exactly what I have been reading about in my fitness/nutrition blogs and I recently bought some low impact circuit training workouts from Cathe. They are so much fun! I am not a big believer in cardio myself, but for ME I have learned it is essential for glucose metabolism because I was leaning towards pre-diabetic type 11.

Quote
Go sign up for the streamfit.com site. I think it offers a trail period so you can see if you like it. What's nice about the site is you can do the workouts from home. They have everything from 10 min quick metabolic burn to 15 min no equipment needed bodyweight cardio to 60 min kettlebell to 28 day transformation programs. You pick which workouts you want to do that day based on what equipment you have access to. They have male trainers and female trainers.

That sounds very interesting and I know I will check into that too! Sorry to highjack your thread, MrA, but KT is speaking my language here! grin

I feel like I am getting to an age where I really want to stay fit but I don't want to do something stupid to my body. It seems that some of my workouts leave me crippled for several days so I am veering to the shorter, less intense workouts.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 04:57 PM
Is that site just for GUYS?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 06:34 PM
Plantar Fascitiis.

Have I tried Birkenstocks? No. For 8 years I have been using custom orthotics created for me by a podiatrist. Priority #1. I move them to whatever pair of shoes I�m wearing (except my atheletic shoes)

In the 8 years I have tried walking in the earlier years as a daily exercise hoping it would help but it only exasperated the condition. To this day I stretch each day to lengthen the Achilles and calf muscles in my leg (that tendon goes from the ball of your foot to your knee.) Doing the stretches makes a difference as far as daily comfort but doesn�t erase the condition. I also try to avoid doing much of anything without some type of shoe on unless it�s sitting, laying down.

I have seen therapists that have done the following:

Simple foot massage
Ultrasound treatments that infuse a steroid cream into the foot
Active Release Technique
Graston Technique

Both of those last 2 treatments gave me the best results (although they can be quite painful) but neither completely resolved the issue. The podiatrist has stated that this injury is a self healing injury. Eventually through the destruction and reconstruction of the tissues (microfiber tendons now become bone where they tear) the distance between the connected areas the fascia needs will eventually become adequate. The length of the troubles he said varies in patients from a few months to as long as 20 years.

It is better now than it was 8 years ago but it is still burdensome enough that I don�t push it. If I have to stand in one place for awhile � 30 minutes or more then I start to feel like I�m on needles. If I try to run or walk they get so sore I spend quite of bit of time just staying off them. I have a desk job which helps � but also may hinder.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 06:36 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
I use free weights, bar bells, steps, resistance bands [that might be good for you!], and whatnot, and I get a really good workout. I joined a gym one time and the workouts I was doing there were tame in comparison. [the PT helped me tremendously with my form]

The tapes that have kept me motivated all these years [and there is a whole cult following of us] are The Firm workouts, particularly the older tapes. You could get a couple off ebay for cheap and see if you like them. If you like them, you can invite her to join you.

Those workouts really got me interested in working out. I have pretty much stuck to them for 15 years now.

Interesting. We have all of that equipment (except a full set of free weights as we have the home gym) and I believe she has one or two of those The Firm workout DVDs. I know she�s got like 4 or 5 DVDs for workouts, yoga and something else ???? Just like everything else � one week or so and nothing more.

For me, my concern is that she look good and of course is healthy. She�s pretty active as far as doing chores and definitely gets a workout taking care of her horses. So while I think it would be great if she worked out I don�t think she�ll ever like it or do it. And while I may continue to make workout/exercise suggestions I won�t push.

I believe that is why I was more concerned or focused on what she eats that sabatoges the healthy eating plan we�re trying to follow versus working out.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 06:57 PM
Originally Posted by kilted_thrower
Alias, have you been to see a sports medicine doctor? And specifically one that has experience in dealing with athletic recovery? Plantar fasciatis is definitely treatable but you have to find the right doctor to tackle the issue.

Go sign up for the streamfit.com site.

I have been to therapists for my feet not a sports medicine doctor. However I have seen a sports med guy for an knee issue I have (chondromalacia) and recently went to a physical therapist to help with my lower back issue.

Whatever happened to my beautiful body? I have always been pretty active. In the earlier years I loved to play baseball and softball. I love to shoot hoops not play in a pickup game just shoot.

Once I hit 30 everything started going south. I had to give up playing softball because of a shoulder injury that took close to 18 years to heal. I think finally now that I�m close to 50 I can actually toss a ball around with little to no pain.

I still golf � a lot. But I no longer walk much as that can be damaging. Interestingly enough my golf shoes give good support and if I don�t walk I�m OK afterwards.

I have a routine for a workout all laid out on my whiteboard in our exercise room. We have the home gym with an added leg press machine which can do about 30 different exercises. We have a pretty nice exercise bike that has great programming for getting in a varied exercise. I have a pull up bar and a dip station for doing hanging leg raises.

So I have a decent set up. The latest workout I was trying to use is a routine of about 20 different exercises all with light weight and high reps with 5 breaks of 5 minute cardio in between. I use the bike for the cardio. I haven�t started back again since my back flared up 3 months or so ago. But I'll get back to it soon enough. I always do.

Geesh I forgot to mention I got the planter fasciitis when I was using a tread mill I had purchased. I wanted to make sure I did it right and got a high quality machine and went to a specialty store for runners to get my running shoes. Pronate versus supinate. Got the right shoes but got shin splints so bad I couldn�t continue. The store gladly exchanged those for a more shock damage control shoe � which I think started my issues. They didn�t have enough arch support and so began the troubles �
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/17/13 09:09 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Interesting. We have all of that equipment (except a full set of free weights as we have the home gym) and I believe she has one or two of those The Firm workout DVDs. I know she�s got like 4 or 5 DVDs for workouts, yoga and something else ???? Just like everything else � one week or so and nothing more.

For me, my concern is that she look good and of course is healthy. She�s pretty active as far as doing chores and definitely gets a workout taking care of her horses. So while I think it would be great if she worked out I don�t think she�ll ever like it or do it. And while I may continue to make workout/exercise suggestions I won�t push.

I believe that is why I was more concerned or focused on what she eats that sabatoges the healthy eating plan we�re trying to follow versus working out.

I gotcha, and I agree. Diet will do more to control weight than exercise. The fun Firm workouts are the old volumes that came out in the 90's. They have recently transistioned to DVDs. Those are the ones I enjoy the most. But I agree with you that her diet is the biggest issue.
Posted By: kilted_thrower Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/18/13 04:51 AM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Is that site just for GUYS?
Absolutely not Mrs. Lane. They have a couple of female trainers. Every workout posted is geared towards any gender, age,or strength level.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/28/13 08:21 PM
Looking for some insight.

Brief recap of my history.

I came to MB almost 10 years ago to find a solution to a problem/conflict my W and I were having. Having more children. From that issue I continued on here and went to work on other parts of our M. Until recently we weren�t too successful but now after having seen Dr. Chalmers we�re moving forward being more open and honest. That�s helping us to work out our issues to find a winning solution. Slow progress but we�re moving nonetheless.

This weekend something was off with my W. Saturday she and my DD were attending our niece�s baby shower. My sis has two adult DDs and one delivered her first child in November and her 2nd DD is due end of March. This shower was for DD #2 of course.

I approached my W Saturday morning as she was definitely not in the best of moods on Friday and again Saturday. When asked what was wrong she said she�d been feeling bad, mad, upset and sad. She said she wished she could go back in time and do things over, do things differently. I asked what would she do differently. I think she went right to the truth and stated she was upset that she couldn�t have more children. For some reason she was triggered due to this shower but not the first one (not sure why she wasn�t after the first � maybe she was).

We talked about it for a while. Of course I explained to her my feelings of hopelessness as I�m totally unsure what to do in this situation. I let her know I was there. I gave her what comfort she�d accept (some warm hugs and empathy and wishes that this wasn�t so hard for her). She wasn�t angry with me but definitely unhappy.

So this issue continues to plague us and makes things difficult here�s why. The timing of this was hard. I�m still having to be the one to try to make the meeting of my #1 EN be a priority while it seems she�s more interested in other things (I could give examples but I�ll spare everyone). This feels like old times for me. Despite being asked in our sessions by Dr J to schedule our time for SF the schedule is never set. It seems she more comfortable not planning it � so I�m clueless when, if ever, it is going to happen until it happens. I�m OK with that so long as it actually happens and have found that if I hint around the subject it usually does � eventually happen.

She�s been given what I would want specifically for meeting that need and we�re not hitting the mark. It�s closer than it ever has been but still it�s falling short. So � on to this weekend and it�s already been over two weeks of waiting and this comes up (which I understand and empathize). She�s too upset to take care of my needs but then I�m the one who misses out on Need meeting. And round and round we go.

So we discussed this a bit but I didn�t want to beat on her when she was feeling down. I mentioned that I thought one of the things that could help her is if she had something else to fill the void (somewhat) of what she�s missing out on. I thought if we could find more fun things to do, more things she could be excited about and happy in doing that maybe this other would hurt less. She listened but didn�t really answer my suggestion.

I think she�d rather just let the feeling subside and then try to move on � which is probably what will happen and may be best because it is something she has to work out but meanwhile � I am triggered and sad.

I let her know I was saddened this morning and she was honest in why it didn�t happen. So, hey, we�re being more open and honest . Maybe that�s all I can hope for and that this thing that gets in our way will pop up now and then.

I�m not sure where we�d end up if we tried to negotiate this.

Meanwhile she says she�s going to get in with the Dr and discuss this and her anxieties and her prescription.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/28/13 09:06 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I�m still having to be the one to try to make the meeting of my #1 EN be a priority while it seems she�s more interested in other things (I could give examples but I�ll spare everyone). This feels like old times for me. Despite being asked in our sessions by Dr J to schedule our time for SF the schedule is never set. It seems she more comfortable not planning it � so I�m clueless when, if ever, it is going to happen until it happens. I�m OK with that so long as it actually happens and have found that if I hint around the subject it usually does � eventually happen.

MrA, why are you not sitting down once a week and scheduling your UA time? That is the grease that makes this all work. You do understand this program does not work without the UA time? She is NEVER going to feel like meeting your ENs if hers are not met during UA time. We sit down every Sunday afternoon and schedule out the next week. Once you get into the habit, it is old hat. Do you have babysitters? Are you going out on your dates?

And SF should be scheduled just Dr Harley describes in How to get the sex you want in marriage. It should be an EVENT, not a one-off.

Do you have template of the UA schedule?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/29/13 02:11 PM
We don't have a schedule. No I haven't used the UA schedule. Dr J never brought it up in counseling. I think she figured we did OK in that area based on what we told her. Her and I do discuss what our week looks like and especially have talked about weekend plans well in advance.

<rhetorical>Should we use these Schedules?
I'd have to make this a requirement for us ...which means me pushing on her and her being resistant or ignoring what I ask� again. This is evident by everything that�s happened (even since talking with Dr J). She finally did mention the email I sent her over two weeks ago (that I mentioned to her several times since) regarding RC time and finding things to do that we�d like. Her response seems to be she�s only interested in doing the ones we already do. Ahem. Partying, shopping, dinner dates, movies, games with kids, etc. She�s not interested in going through the list together. Sigh.

So do I want to bring up another document that we should look at? Not really.

All of this brings me to where I�m at today. She wants things to be better but she doesn�t want to do much to change the dynamics. She attended counseling with Dr J to appease me. I feel somewhat of a fool.

Now she�s being more open and she sometimes makes attempts at UA time but she did very little of the things that required work that Dr J assigned us. The things she did were because we had to do them together before our next session and I was the catalyst for them getting done. If I ignored some homework she�d just let it slide.

A UA schedule? Pfft. I can already hear her silence at the suggestion. I can tell she doesn�t like having assignments as part of M.

Quote
She is NEVER going to feel like meeting your ENs if hers are not met during UA time.

I�m not sure that�s really the issue. I�ve certainly been working on this, making sure it�s happening. My Taker is starting to scream a little because I feel I�m been hitting the mark on much of her ENs.

The rest of this is just a rant so read at your discretion.

Her ENs. (Some met during UA time. Others outside of it).
Conversation. Yep doing that throughout the day. Sometimes I have to go find her so she can get her EN filled. We text throughout the day when we�re apart. She only asked for one text as a check-in a day during the work week as a minimum I usually send a few.
Admiration. I send her little tidbits at least 3 times a week. I could do better with this in regards to her appearance. I�m letting my feelings towards some of her behavior in taking care of her body get in the way of complimenting her looks. I�m not sure how to do that without it feeling like a lie.
Domestic Support � I cook nearly every meal nowadays. Saturday I spend 3 hours cleaning while she was at the shower. Friday, Saturday and Sunday did several loads of laundry each day.
Openness and Honesty. I�m making strides here. Being careful not to simply blurt out every thought I have as sometimes some of them aren�t good. ;-)
Affection. She didn�t list this but she has made comments about being disappointed that I don�t wake her in the morning before I leave to say good bye and say I love you. So I�ve been doing that for months now.
My ENs
SF � sporadic. Better but still far below the consistency I�d like.
Affection � Until this weekend she�s done well meeting this need.
Attractive Spouse � She always dresses nice and cares for her looks (makeup, etc). However for physical fitness and body I�d like her to change some behaviors. I�m making healthy dinners yet she continues to drink every day, make baked goods, etc and eats other things that diminish the eating plan. I need to broach this subject with her � again.
DS � Sigh. She�s diligent about some things yet others, like our bedroom, are bothersome for me.
O&H � She�s doing much better in this area but there is still room for improvement. She still is holding things in.

UA Time.
Our kids are old enough .. .they stay home alone� so no need for a sitter. When we are at home we also can get in quite a bit of UA time as the kids normally go off and do their own thing once we�ve got chores and homework done.

So how are we doing with UA time? We go in spurts. Week before last it wasn�t good. This last week it was good.

We always get in a few hours each week when we get home from work we talk. Ask about each other�s day, start getting dinner ready and the table set, etc. We chat during dinner.

This weekend her and I went out on date Friday (a long dinner at a new restaurant and then a movie) then back home to work on a jigsaw puzzle and have a nightcap (6 hours counting the 2 hour movie of course).

Saturday night after the shower we hung out and had fun with the kids. This is where the lack of things being scheduled are problematic. It�s where I took issue. We played board games and watched a movie together. By the time the movie was over it was late. To my disappointment she was obvious there wasn�t going to be any UA time or SF time. She admitted yesterday she isn�t in the mood because of her sadness.

Sunday her and I went clothes shopping, made dinner together, sat down to plan for a trip we�re taking in Feb. (5 hours)

Monday morning I sent her a text letting her know I was saddened that there was no time for intimacy over the weekend. She explained she was in no mood for SF due to her sadness surrounding her loss of what she wish she had. This will continue for I�d say another week or so. So I can forget getting my needs met. Despite me continuing to do all the things I was asked to do in meeting her needs.

Last night we took the kids out to celebrate our freshman's completion of finals at high school (He�s still getting straight As). Last night was a good example of where I�d like the dynamic to change � or I, at least, need to understand how I�m supposed to behave. We enjoyed ourselves while in the restaurant but as soon as we�re in the car making the, evidentially dreaded, car ride home her behavior changed. She was no longer talkative. When we got home she treated me like I didn�t exist, etc. I asked if she�d like to do something together. �Well I want to do this and want to do that.� None of it was UA related stuff but I made some attempts to help her so we could be together. She and DD were doing some straightening in her room. I put in new shelving in DD�s closet last week. So now I�m trying to help with the straightening but she made me feel unwelcome and like I was in the way so I just left them alone. Of course she�s hardly speaking to me so I�ve no idea what the hell is going on. Sometime later I said goodnight and went to bed knowing another night passes and I can just forget about any needs I have.

The DJ side of me says it�s her way of getting what she wants � that I go away and have no expectation of SF. She�s admitted she isn�t in the mood.
The respectful side of me understands she�s sad and tries to give her space.

Posted By: living_well Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/29/13 02:26 PM
What is the sadness about?

Is she drinking alcohol and eating sugary things as a coping mechanism?
Posted By: hopefulwife47 Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/29/13 02:41 PM
I was wondering the same thing. Wondering if the alcohol is not allowing her to work on your marriage. I really don't have any advice. Hoping Melody and other vets can chime in. Just praying..
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/29/13 03:00 PM
Originally Posted by living_well
What is the sadness about?

Is she drinking alcohol and eating sugary things as a coping mechanism?

She is upset that she can't have more children and that she doesn't have more children. She says she tries not to let it affect how she views me but my needs go unmet because it's directly correlated to procreation.

She's always used booze as a crutch. She's angry she reaches for a drink. That's why I spoke to Melody about this. I have concerns that it's alcoholism.

As far as the sugary stuff who knows. She knows what she likes and she usually gets what she wants � except for more kids.

She has a mild case of OCD and anxiety issues. So it�s possible everything I view as bad are coping mechanisms she has that are somewhat or not related to her anxieties and OCD. I�m not a Dr and I try not to psycho-analyze her too much. I do know what I like about her and what I don�t.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/29/13 03:10 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
We don't have a schedule. No I haven't used the UA schedule. Dr J never brought it up in counseling. I think she figured we did OK in that area based on what we told her. Her and I do discuss what our week looks like and especially have talked about weekend plans well in advance.

ok, that is too long to read and I am heading out the door so I will be quick. I will give the benefit of some key learnings of those who have gone through the MB seminar and who ARE getting our UA time in every week.

First off, this program does not work without taking this step. Does not work! You are wasting your time and money if you gloss over this step. It is too important of a step to miss. When Dr H was in private practice, he wouldn't even take on a client wouldn't commit to this step.

As Dr Harley told us, it is much harder to put off time that is scheduled. When you wing it, anything ELSE that comes up will be used as an excuse to abandon your time together.

So get out the worksheet that is in the back of the Five Steps to Romantic Love workbook and make several copies. Sit down once a week and write in the date, time and planned activity.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/29/13 03:15 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Monday morning I sent her a text letting her know I was saddened that there was no time for intimacy over the weekend. She explained she was in no mood for SF due to her sadness surrounding her loss of what she wish she had. This will continue for I�d say another week or so. So I can forget getting my needs met. Despite me continuing to do all the things I was asked to do in meeting her needs.

She is in no mood because you are not getting in your UA time. Are you spending 3 hours with her meeting her ENs for conversation and affection? Because that must precede SF. It has to be an EVENT just like Dr Harley suggested. You have to warm up the oven first.

Quote
We always get in a few hours each week when we get home from work we talk. Ask about each other�s day, start getting dinner ready and the table set, etc. We chat during dinner.

Your children are gone? Where are they? They don't eat with you? Because what you describe is not UA time if there are others there. UA time needs to be in blocks of 2 to 4 hours to be effective. Passing each other in the kitchen or in the hallway on the way to the bathroom is not UA time.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/29/13 06:22 PM
Thanks Mel.

I hear what you're saying and I will go to work on the UA time. If what we're doing doesn't count for much I suspect I've got an uphill battle getting her on board. Heck I'm trying to wrap my brain around it. Her and I ... we don't have enough to talk about as it is. If we have to discuss longer we're gonna need something to talk about ... which I realize is partly my responsibility and why I was pushing for some more RC ideas. Ugh, if I have to listen to her complain about the catty women at work more than I already do I'll go bonkers. frown

I don't have the 5 steps book. I have FILSIL, HNHN and LB. Not sure I recall seeing that schedule in any of those but I'll look.

Life balance. Enough time with her, enough time for the kids, enough time for work, enough time for friends, enough time for me.
Posted By: hopefulwife47 Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/29/13 07:40 PM
I'm surprised that Dr Chalmers isn't requiring the 15 hours.... I thought that was the first thing they required BEFORE doing any of the worksheets.. Actually spending the time is making a difference for us. For example, before when hubby would call me during my stuff ( children's choir, class, etc.) I was so incredibly irritated. Why are you bothering me during MY stuff. This past week he called me while choir practice was going on and I was just happy to hear from him. It didn't stress me out at all.... I was thinking what a change that was..

I would talk to Dr Chalmers about UA time first thing.. She will have to convince your wife that it is important.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/29/13 07:59 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Thanks Mel.

I hear what you're saying and I will go to work on the UA time. If what we're doing doesn't count for much I suspect I've got an uphill battle getting her on board. Heck I'm trying to wrap my brain around it. Her and I ... we don't have enough to talk about as it is. If we have to discuss longer we're gonna need something to talk about ... which I realize is partly my responsibility and why I was pushing for some more RC ideas. Ugh, if I have to listen to her complain about the catty women at work more than I already do I'll go bonkers. frown

Here is what I was hoping for: that Dr Chalmers would motivate her to TRY. And once you started meeting each others needs and getting in your UA time, she would become motivated. Because once you exceed the romantic love threshhold, you aren't going to let anything get in your way. You are eager to do it. Make your conversation as pleasant as possible. If she is talking about something unpleasant, then tell her! Or maybe you can discuss this before you go out. Say, I want to make sure I am as pleasant as possible when we are out together, which subjects should I avoid? And then you tell her about subjects you don't like. You LEARN how to be so enjoyable with each other that you never want to miss your time together.

Quote
I don't have the 5 steps book. I have FILSIL, HNHN and LB. Not sure I recall seeing that schedule in any of those but I'll look.
I might have the scanned sheet. I will check when I get home. Five Steps is the workbook.

Quote
Life balance. Enough time with her, enough time for the kids, enough time for work, enough time for friends, enough time for me.

And the priority should be:

1. marriage
2. job
3. family time

YOUR time is with your wife and the friends can go last on the list.
Posted By: living_well Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/29/13 10:36 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by living_well
What is the sadness about?

Is she drinking alcohol and eating sugary things as a coping mechanism?

She is upset that she can't have more children and that she doesn't have more children.

'upset' makes more sense than 'sad' but either way it is unusual not to be happy if you love children and are lucky enough to have three.

Originally Posted by MrAlias
She has a mild case of OCD and anxiety issues. So it�s possible everything I view as bad are coping mechanisms she has that are somewhat or not related to her anxieties and OCD. I�m not a Dr and I try not to psycho-analyze her too much. I do know what I like about her and what I don�t.


OCD is another coping mechanism. So anxiety is what is making her sad? Would she talk about what makes her anxious when you are having UL time? Sometimes that is enough to shrink the monsters.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 01:28 PM
Originally Posted by tiredwife45
I'm surprised that Dr Chalmers isn't requiring the 15 hours.... I thought that was the first thing they required BEFORE doing any of the worksheets.. Actually spending the time is making a difference for us. For example, before when hubby would call me during my stuff ( children's choir, class, etc.) I was so incredibly irritated. Why are you bothering me during MY stuff. This past week he called me while choir practice was going on and I was just happy to hear from him. It didn't stress me out at all.... I was thinking what a change that was..

I would talk to Dr Chalmers about UA time first thing.. She will have to convince your wife that it is important.

Oh we both know it and yes Dr Chalmers does require it first and foremost. We do try to work together / suggest things to reach at least 15. We just don�t schedule it which I could see being a great tool. I could see how we�d use that as an accountability tool.

It�s good to see things moving in the right direction for you TW. It�s always the hope that it two steps forward even though there�ll be a one step back now and then.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 01:44 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Here is what I was hoping for: that Dr Chalmers would motivate her to TRY. And once you started meeting each others needs and getting in your UA time, she would become motivated. Because once you exceed the romantic love threshhold, you aren't going to let anything get in your way. You are eager to do it. Make your conversation as pleasant as possible. If she is talking about something unpleasant, then tell her! Or maybe you can discuss this before you go out. Say, I want to make sure I am as pleasant as possible when we are out together, which subjects should I avoid? And then you tell her about subjects you don't like. You LEARN how to be so enjoyable with each other that you never want to miss your time together.

I really don�t know how her conversations with Dr J went. She never volunteered any of their discussion. She certainly emphasized the UA time. It was always on the docquette for this week�s marching orders. Do this, this and get in those 15 to 20 hours of UA time.

I just texted my wife that I missed her yesterday. She was stuck working till my bedtime last night so we got zero UA time in last night. Sigh � and she�s probably gonna have to work late tonight too. Anyways I asked her if she�d be open to creating a UA schedule. She�ll see it when she gets up.

I know that I have that feeling of wanting to be with her and I definitely can see how molding our conversations to be enjoyable (versus the stuff that feels unpleasant to either of us) will only make that grow stronger. I hate to keep repeating what I�ve said to her. Seems I tell her once or twice about LBs you think she�d want to change it � but it doesn�t.

Quote
I might have the scanned sheet. I will check when I get home. Five Steps is the workbook.


I appreciate that.

Quote
And the priority should be:

1. marriage
2. job
3. family time
YOUR time is with your wife and the friends can go last on the list.

This made me laugh because my buddy just got through complaining about me being Missing In Action. He�s supportive of my efforts though as he knows my struggles and of the plan I�m following. His a great guy who�s married to a great gal and they really seem to click as a couple. Mrs and I love hanging with them because of that fact.

Mrs and I discussed our interactions over the last few days. She was upset that I communicated my feelings of sadness concerning missing out on SF time this weekend. She thought I was insisting it happen despite how she felt. I explained that that wasn�t what I meant. That I was merely trying to communicate my feelings just as she was concerning her sad feelings. I explained I was being as open and honest as I could and explained that is where we often struggle. That we tend to ignore the elephant in the room. After talking I think we�ve ironed that out � or at least eliminated the bad vibe that was going on.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 01:54 PM
Originally Posted by living_well
'upset' makes more sense than 'sad' but either way it is unusual not to be happy if you love children and are lucky enough to have three.

I am not her but for me ... I'd rather appreciate what we do have. This one really affects her and although I know she appreciates what she has it doesn't seem to override these other feelings that enter her head. I wish she had better control. When she's upset from that we all feel it's effects.

Originally Posted by MrAlias
OCD is another coping mechanism. So anxiety is what is making her sad? Would she talk about what makes her anxious when you are having UA time? Sometimes that is enough to shrink the monsters.

We talk about what she�s feeling quite often. She�ll even avoid the things she doesn�t like (OCD behaviors) by getting me involved. For instance she�ll ask that I be the last one to come up for bed so I can turn off the lights.

I think the best I can offer her is an ear. Just listen as I always do � when she�s willing to discuss. It�s like pulling teeth. What�s wrong. Nothing or I don�t know or I�m fine. Hmmm. You seem upset. I�m here if you want to talk. Would a hug help? She�s gotten good at asking for hugs now when she really, really needs one.

The other thing I can do is encourage her to get back in to see her Doc. Actually she�ll have to. They won�t renew her prescription again without doing so and she is not interested in getting off the meds.
Posted By: 1995droptopz Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 02:13 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias[/quote
I hate to keep repeating what I�ve said to her. Seems I tell her once or twice about LBs you think she�d want to change it � but it doesn�t.


This sounds like an issue with my wife and I, but reversed. She asks me to stop certain LBs, and gets upset when I do not stop the behavior immediately. Last night she said it makes her feel like I have no respect for her since she asks me to stop and I don't listen to her. It came very clear to me how she felt when she explained it in that way.

I struggle with changing these behaviors because often times my mind is somewhere else and I do it subconsiously. When I am focused I do not commit the LBs. I personally find it encouraging to get praise when I avoid an LB. While I don't think she should have to praise me for me to want to make her happy, it helps encourage me because she noticed that I cared. It makes me want to avoid that LB again. After a while it becomes the habit to avoid the LB, instead of the other way around.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 02:42 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[quote=MelodyLane]


Quote
I might have the scanned sheet. I will check when I get home. Five Steps is the workbook.


I appreciate that.

ok, I scanned a blank copy. Can you mod notify this post and give them your email address and ask them to send to me? I will shoot you the PDF copy of the worksheet.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 02:59 PM
Originally Posted by 1995droptopz
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I hate to keep repeating what I�ve said to her. Seems I tell her once or twice about LBs you think she�d want to change it � but it doesn�t.
[/quote
This sounds like an issue with my wife and I, but reversed. She asks me to stop certain LBs, and gets upset when I do not stop the behavior immediately. Last night she said it makes her feel like I have no respect for her since she asks me to stop and I don't listen to her. It came very clear to me how she felt when she explained it in that way.

I struggle with changing these behaviors because often times my mind is somewhere else and I do it subconsiously. When I am focused I do not commit the LBs. I personally find it encouraging to get praise when I avoid an LB. While I don't think she should have to praise me for me to want to make her happy, it helps encourage me because she noticed that I cared. It makes me want to avoid that LB again. After a while it becomes the habit to avoid the LB, instead of the other way around.

So ask her to encourage you.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 03:00 PM
Mel,

I'll have to create a new temporary email as my personal one would reveal my identity.

I won't be able to create one until I get home tonight.

Thanks again.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 03:02 PM
I can just email it to the mods and have them email it. Do they have your email address?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 03:09 PM
They do now. I had to change the one I use here to the one that would reveal my identity. I no longer use that old account.

Feel free to send them the email.

I will hit notify to let them know I wish to receive your email.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 03:22 PM
ok, done!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 03:28 PM
Got it. Thanks a bunch.

Thanks Fireproof.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 03:33 PM
The nice thing about the worksheet is that you are not struggling with this on a daily basis. Since you have already scheduled out your week, you have scheduled SF and don't have to worry and hope that you might get some time together every day. You sit down together ONE TIME a week and just write it all out. That way you and your wife can set up babysitters and plan to leave work on time.

One thing I didn't like is when I was exhausted and frazzled and my DH would approach me for SF. It really made me angry. But when it is on the schedule and is preceded by a nice relaxing dinner and some shopping, I actually look forward to it. I am not caught off guard.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 06:01 PM
I hope I can get her participation. So far she's wishy washy on this kind of work.

Wow. A schedule. That'd take so much pressure and stress off of me.

I suspect she'll say just the opposite. She'll commit when the moment strikes her not when a schedule suggests it. Otherwise it's too much pressure. "How do I know if I'll be in the mood at that time?".
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 06:21 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I hope I can get her participation. So far she's wishy washy on this kind of work.

Wow. A schedule. That'd take so much pressure and stress off of me.

I suspect she'll say just the opposite. She'll commit when the moment strikes her not when a schedule suggests it. Otherwise it's too much pressure. "How do I know if I'll be in the mood at that time?".

She will not be in the mood! That is what we are trying to alleviate. Bring the body and the mind will follow! She needs to do this step in order to get the PAYOFF of the program. This is the key to romantic love, which is the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow.

More time together leads to -----> in the mood to be together and meet each others needs
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 08:44 PM
Would it be your suggestion to just leave SF off the schedule for now? If it happens so be it, if it doesn't at least her and I will assured the UA time we need to create the love we need.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 09:38 PM
Yes, you should schedule SF for the end of every date. But keep in mind that she will feel more like it at the end of an evening where you have just spent 2-3 hours meeting her needs. She will feel warmed up. Unspoken issues lead to a block in intimacy so be sure and have the pleasant topic conversation that I suggested.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 09:39 PM
Having SF will motivate you to meet her needs for several hours.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/30/13 09:57 PM
OK. I'm dreading her response to that request. I may just have to bring DR J back one more time (before our 6 month check up) to discuss this scheduling requirement.

We never discussed it and certainly didn't discuss whether or not we were scheduling UA time to meet those 4 needs. She did ask how we were doing in getting in the minimum hours.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/31/13 12:43 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
OK. I'm dreading her response to that request. I may just have to bring DR J back one more time (before our 6 month check up) to discuss this scheduling requirement.

We never discussed it and certainly didn't discuss whether or not we were scheduling UA time to meet those 4 needs. She did ask how we were doing in getting in the minimum hours.

I bet Dr Chalmers thinks you are scheduling it.

Hasn't your wife already agreed to do this? It sure sounds like Dr. Chalmers has been discussing it with you.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/31/13 01:52 PM
She never discussed a schedule. As far as meeting my need for SF she had me ask that it take place when my W had the most energy and least amount of distraction ... but never did the talk of a schedule ever come up.

Get in those 20 hours of UA time was all that was said to me and to us. But it's OK. If we struggle to get in the UA time I'll keep bringing it up so we get better at hitting those hours. That doesn't help schedule the SF which will have to be a part of this schedule. Resistance #2 I'm guessing.

My W is busy right now so I may be jumping the gun but I did text her the question of creating a schedule yesterday and she didn't respond. I usually give her time to digest things ... don't wanna look pushy or rude. She worked late again last night. I dropped off dinner for her and when she finally did get home I asked if she'd like to do something. She said
"Yes, you're going to poor me a glass of port and we're going to do something fun. Wanna play words with friends while we snuggle?"
"Most definitely".
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/31/13 02:14 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She said
"Yes, you're going to poor me a glass of port and we're going to do something fun. Wanna play words with friends while we snuggle?"
"Most definitely".

Were your kids home?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/31/13 03:07 PM
At first but they soon were sent upstairs to their rooms. There they were either reading or sleeping.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 01/31/13 03:10 PM
While we played she talked about her fun at work (sarcasm). She sure works with a volatile group and a manager who is a conflict avoider.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 03:24 PM
I'm not sure I made the right decision ....

My W and I are both unhappy with our physical shape. We're both overweight (nothing obese) but certainly could stand to lose 10to20% of our body weight.

We've been tossing around a few ideas on what to do about it. We definitely have different ideas on how to go about this. So far no enthusiastic agreement.

Last week she approached me with this idea. A challenge. We challenge each other to see who can lose the most weight (I suspect she means percent-wise � not sure). I asked how she thought we�d go about actually losing weight. She said she would start working out and that we�d establish a schedule on when she would and when I would work out. I threw out the idea of working out together � maybe with a personal trainer in private sessions. She didn�t like the idea of a trainer (cost and someone watching, etc). I said I�d be willing to sell the weight room equipment to offset a good portion of the costs. She still wasn�t interested in a trainer or her and I working out together.

I stated I thought working out together would be a great opportunity for some UA time. That I know we�re struggling to find things we can do together � besides more of the same of what we do today. She still didn�t like the idea. She doesn�t want anyone (maybe just me) watching her workout. She�s taken Yoga classes before � not sure why she isn�t interested in doing the other. I didn�t push it. Makes me sad though cuz the idea feels like a good one.

I like the idea of a trainer because as I age I find I end up hurting myself (bad back, elbow tendonitis, bad knee caps, and of course the lovely plantar fasciitis). A trainer could help me maintain progress without injury. That did nothing to sway her enthusiasm � I realize it shouldn�t. I just wanted to be honest with her.

I was honest and said my initial reaction is that I don�t like the idea of a competition. That it may become something ugly or make someone feel bad if they weren�t having success. I told her I was looking for encouragement and an accountability partner not necessarily a competitor. She said she could try to do that if that is what I needed. She isn�t a nag so I have a hard time picturing her in this role.

During this talk I tried to negotiate the foods we keep in the home. I expressed my concern for having a hard time avoiding the bad foods in the home. If they are there I can�t seem to keep from consuming some of them. She�ll make cookies, breads, buy desserts from the grocery store, etc. Those things sabotage our efforts to lose weight. Meanwhile I continue to make about 90% of our meals and about 70% of those come from the Marlene Koch cookbooks.

She said I was just going to have to learn to stop eating them. Lol. Uhm � I just can�t seem to stop and it would be so much easier if they weren�t there � or if they were under lock and key (I�ve had her hide stuff from me).

I�m thinking the win/win is going to be her and I working out alone but working together to monitor, encourage and keep each other accountable. I am going to have to ask her to keep me honest on what I put in my mouth as I�m sure there�ll be all kinds of tasty but bad foods in the home.

I�m open to some feedback.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 04:35 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
maybe with a personal trainer in private sessions. She didn�t like the idea of a trainer (cost and someone watching, etc). I said I�d be willing to sell the weight room equipment to offset a good portion of the costs. She still wasn�t interested in a trainer or her and I working out together.

Would she be willing to use a trainer only to start you both off? A trainer could help you both establish a workout routine and watch you work out to spot problems. At our age, that is really important. I hired a PT once to watch me work out because of bad form when doing squats.

And would she be willing to TRY working out together to see if she liked it? Dr Harley considers UA time while working out together to be one of the greatest lovebank depositers because of the endorphins produced while working out. Or perhaps you could do your workouts alone and then go for a walk together every day?

I agree with you that competing would not be a good thing.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 05:19 PM
Hi Mel, thanks for the thoughts.

Would she be willing to use a trainer only to start you both off?

I won't know unless I ask. If I had to guess (based on my years of experience with her) she's self-conscious about her looks. She has stated she doesn't want to sweat in front of others . Again I assume it is due to her desire to always wear makeup. She has a scar. I, figuratively, don't even see it (it is a large scar) but I don't have to live with it every day. I wish I could make that go away for her.

And would she be willing to TRY working out together to see if she liked it?

I don't know. This isn't the first time I've suggested working out together in all the years we've been married. Some time years ago we went to a health club together. But she was in pretty good shape, shape-wise, back then.

Or perhaps you could do your workouts alone and then go for a walk together every day?

I often think about walking but then I�m always brought back to the pain I�ll endure with my fascia. If I could fix my feet a lot of my problems would go away. I can barely get through making a meal without creating quite a bit of discomfort. Walking would do me in. It normally does.

I agree with you that competing would not be a good thing.

I know. I was quite surprised at her idea. We both are kind of iffey when it comes to competition in other aspects of our lives. We do well to avoid them if possible.

Your comment about the good Dr is exactly why I thought this would be a great idea. I heard him say just that on a radio show. I would be so excited to see her make some positive steps toward making herself happier and at the same time more attractive. What better way to do it then to do it together. It would lead to some interesting conversations which is another thing we need.

Sigh. I have been mentioning that we need to find enjoyable things to do together. That the current list of stuff we do just isn�t that much fun for both of us. She just likes doing stuff together. I�d rather it be enjoyable for the both of us. This weekend she asked if I would go with her to return some stuff at about 2 or 3 clothing stores. Yikes. Uhm. Not really. I was going to do some necessary basement re-straightening. We were under a time crunch so we couldn�t do both. So unfortunately we went our separate ways for a few hours.

I, again, mentioned a UA schedule. She didn�t respond. Maybe she�s still thinking it over.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 05:29 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Hi Mel, thanks for the thoughts.

Would she be willing to use a trainer only to start you both off?

I won't know unless I ask. If I had to guess (based on my years of experience with her) she's self-conscious about her looks. She has stated she doesn't want to sweat in front of others . Again I assume it is due to her desire to always wear makeup. She has a scar. I, figuratively, don't even see it (it is a large scar) but I don't have to live with it every day. I wish I could make that go away for her.

You can hire a PT to coach you alone, though. I don't like working out with other people either, so I would go when the gym was closed, around 7am.

Quote
And would she be willing to TRY working out together to see if she liked it?

I don't know. This isn't the first time I've suggested working out together in all the years we've been married. Some time years ago we went to a health club together. But she was in pretty good shape, shape-wise, back then.

Maybe the PT could help you find exercises you can do together.

Quote
Or perhaps you could do your workouts alone and then go for a walk together every day?

I often think about walking but then I�m always brought back to the pain I�ll endure with my fascia. If I could fix my feet a lot of my problems would go away. I can barely get through making a meal without creating quite a bit of discomfort. Walking would do me in. It normally does.

But you get my point, right? If not walking, then something else. Maybe you could do weight lifting together at home? I think you can hire PTs to even come to your home and help you.

That might be the perfect solution for you both. Since she doesn't like working out in front of others, have the PT come to your house and work out in your home gym.

Quote
I, again, mentioned a UA schedule. She didn�t respond. Maybe she�s still thinking it over.

Why don't you start filling it out and invite her into the study to help you finish it? Don't get so hung up on activities. Just make it easy for now by planning dinners out, etc. Maybe target restaurants that are an hour away so you can enjoy the conversation to and from.

And if your wife LOVES to go shopping, why not prime the pump and add some shopping to your night? You can stand it for 30 minutes a couple of times a week, can't you? Even Dr Harley and my husband can stand it for a short time. And that short time MEANS SO MUCH.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 05:35 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Sigh. I have been mentioning that we need to find enjoyable things to do together. That the current list of stuff we do just isn�t that much fun for both of us. She just likes doing stuff together. I�d rather it be enjoyable for the both of us.

Doing stuff together is GOOD! It gives you a chance to meet the ENs of affection and conversation. Were you holding out for the Super Bowl?? grin You need to just jump into this initiative and start priming the pump. The more you are together, the more you will love being together, and the faster you will be able to find things you both like.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 05:38 PM
Thanks Mel. These are all great ideas.

And thanks for the UA suggestions. That makes a lot of sense ... now that YOU stated it. lol.
Posted By: optimism Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 05:57 PM
Mr.A,
I agree that a competition would not be very MBish.

I would like to alert you to some nutrition information you might not be familiar with, if I may.

A few months ago, NatureGirl mentioned that she was concerned about her heart health since her mother and brother have some cardiac issues. I had heard a doctor speaking on MD radio about atheroserosis and "making yourself heart attack proof."

So I mentioned it, she looked it up on the web, we read the guy's book (together) and next thing I know we've cut fat from out diet.

Thing about this way of eating is that you learn that the fat/oil/cholesterol in the Standard American Diet is addictive. And, like Dr. Harley advocates, after 12 weeks of eliminating it, the addiction loses it's grasp on you and you no longer crave it. You also find a tremendous level of satisfaction and excitement eating things that you know are actually promoting your health and not killing you.

My BMI is 22 and I have energy like I never did before. I have minimal joint pain (still have a disc problem that feels better since we've started doing yoga on the wii a few weeks ago). I sleep great, and actually feel smarter (!!). I can walk up 8 flights of stairs, take a couple breaths and have a normal conversation. It's bizarre. And I love the food we eat. I'm not feeling deprived at all (except for that feeling of bloated fullness, lethargy, yuckiness I used to have a lot).

So, if this sounds interesting to you I would recommend a couple of resources to investigate for yourself.

Netflicks -- "Hungry for Change" , "Forks over Knives"
You tube -- "Dr. Esselstein" -- any speech, and "T. Colin Campbell"
Print -- "Prevent and Reverse Heart Disease" and "the China Study"

I like not having to worry about a heart attack (not that I did before, but I was gaining 5-10 pounds a year). Or Stroke, Obesity, Diabetes, Arthritis, or all the other chronic diseases that kill people in this country to the extent that we might represent the first generation in history that doesn't outlive our parents...

And since we do it together, we are accountable to each other. Since we practice radical honesty and openness, the temptations to eat something fatty is mitigated by MB principles!

Good luck!

opt
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 06:01 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Sigh. I have been mentioning that we need to find enjoyable things to do together. That the current list of stuff we do just isn�t that much fun for both of us. She just likes doing stuff together. I�d rather it be enjoyable for the both of us.

Doing stuff together is GOOD! It gives you a chance to meet the ENs of affection and conversation. Were you holding out for the Super Bowl?? grin You need to just jump into this initiative and start priming the pump. The more you are together, the more you will love being together, and the faster you will be able to find things you both like.

We are definitely in the mode of wanting to do stuff together. Each and every day once we�re reunited we toss out ideas of what to do that night. It�s nice knowing we want to be together even if we know we can�t always be.

One thing I think I�ll mention is that we are growing. We are working together as a team to improve the marriage. We don�t just go to our neutral corners hoping the problem will just magically go away.

For instance we had a lot of fun Saturday albeit it wasn�t UA time. The neighbors came down � less his wife. They have kids our kids� ages. This guy is a good friend � but he�s also been a source of contention for her and I because she crosses a line with him, at times, with their antics together. We�ve discussed this quite extensively the last month or so and so as soon as he left she checked in for a progress report. She did some nice things throughout the night where she was sure to be with me and not so much with him. She avoided any innuendos � that I can recall.

Interestingly though she continued to ask where she could do better and when I told her some things from my perspective (things that made me edgy) she got a little defensive and eventually told me (calmly) that she thought the problem was mine. I let her know that it bothered me. She agreed several times but each time went back to saying I was the one who may need to change. At that point I walked away. I had to as I was none too pleased.

We discussed it again the next morning and she agreed I was right. She said she just couldn�t see it from her side of the fence and that she�d need help down the road if and when it happened again. We may need a secret look or something so she can get the hint.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 06:15 PM
Another really good book on heart health is "Calories In and Calories Out" by Gary Taubes. He is a science journalist that has been published in several peer reviewed magazines such as Science Magazine. He reviews all of the major studies done on nutrition in the past 60 years.

Our knowledge base of nutrition for past 30 years has been very Unscientific because it has been politically motivated and is mostly complete nonsense. ["low fat" fad diet] I lost 50 pounds and greatly improved my lipid profile. My HDL [good cholesterol] is the highest my doctor has ever seen. [103] My cholesterol went from 318 down to around 200 with triglycerides going from 495 to 61, which is a great indicator of heart health.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 06:16 PM
Thanks Opt.

I've done a bunch of different "ways of eating". Low Fat. South Beach. Paleo. I had success with each but nothing long term as I was going it alone. Currently today I am preparing meals from a Marlene Koch set of cookbooks as it was the only eating plan I could get my W to agree on. The entire family eats what I prepare.

Our current conundrum. She likes her carbs (cookies, cakes, brownies, breads, etc). Heck I like them too but could live without them. She refuses or shuts down when I ask if they could be removed from the home.

I find trying to find the win/win in a situation like this requires a lot of brain power ... and patience. Fortunately she is suggesting ideas so that�s a step in the right direction.

FYI: I saw on another post that people with anxieties have a lot of trouble with addictions. That is my W to a tee. She�s taking meds for her anxieties and OCD (just went to her Doc to up them) but she is very susceptible to addictions. Just like her father who smoked and drank himself to death. It took a kidney stone and 4 days in the hospital while in her 2nd trimester of pregnancy to quit smoking. I fear she�s headed down the same path with her drinking and so-so eating habits and I�d like to see that change.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 06:22 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
We are definitely in the mode of wanting to do stuff together. Each and every day once we�re reunited we toss out ideas of what to do that night. It�s nice knowing we want to be together even if we know we can�t always be.

One thing I think I�ll mention is that we are growing. We are working together as a team to improve the marriage. We don�t just go to our neutral corners hoping the problem will just magically go away.

Ok, but you don't want to lose all this, do you? You need to really take this to the next level or this is going to fade. That happens by scheduling your UA time and getting that nailed down.

Quote
This guy is a good friend � but he�s also been a source of contention for her and I because she crosses a line with him, at times, with their antics together. We�ve discussed this quite extensively the last month or so and so as soon as he left she checked in for a progress report. She did some nice things throughout the night where she was sure to be with me and not so much with him. She avoided any innuendos � that I can recall.

What is the issue with this guy? Is he someone that should be in your lives? Because it sure doesn't sound like it to me.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 06:33 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
We are definitely in the mode of wanting to do stuff together. Each and every day once we�re reunited we toss out ideas of what to do that night. It�s nice knowing we want to be together even if we know we can�t always be.

One thing I think I�ll mention is that we are growing. We are working together as a team to improve the marriage. We don�t just go to our neutral corners hoping the problem will just magically go away.

Ok, but you don't want to lose all this, do you? You need to really take this to the next level or this is going to fade. That happens by scheduling your UA time and getting that nailed down.

Quote
This guy is a good friend � but he�s also been a source of contention for her and I because she crosses a line with him, at times, with their antics together. We�ve discussed this quite extensively the last month or so and so as soon as he left she checked in for a progress report. She did some nice things throughout the night where she was sure to be with me and not so much with him. She avoided any innuendos � that I can recall.

What is the issue with this guy? Is he someone that should be in your lives? Because it sure doesn't sound like it to me.

I�m certainly not sitting dormant Mel. I think we are getting to the next level it is just taking a while and some persistence from me to make it happen. When I push she isn�t resistant although sometimes it takes a long while before we get to it.

As far as this neighbor. He is a good guy. Unfortunately he�s also a guy that I�ve pointed in the direction of the Harleys. They don�t have a great marriage. Him and I are good friends. We hang out. He is a guy that shares his M troubles with me.

It is probably time I had a frank discussion with him about his behavior around me and my W. I know if and when I have this conversation he will be very apologetic and he will do as I ask. Right now my focus is her and I establishing EPs � maybe it�s time that changed.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 06:51 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I�m certainly not sitting dormant Mel. I think we are getting to the next level it is just taking a while and some persistence from me to make it happen. When I push she isn�t resistant although sometimes it takes a long while before we get to it.

Close the deal before you make me pop a blood vessel!!! grin

Quote
It is probably time I had a frank discussion with him about his behavior around me and my W. I know if and when I have this conversation he will be very apologetic and he will do as I ask. Right now my focus is her and I establishing EPs � maybe it�s time that changed.

ARe they flirting?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 07:41 PM
Close the deal before you make me pop a blood vessel!!!

Oh my. I wouldn't want that to happen. I must teach you apathy.

Are they flirting?

Well ... she's stopped since we had our EP talk with Dr. Chalmers. But before that yes.

I often communicated to her of the double standard we have/had in our R. That she could flirt and it was supposedly allowed but if a woman simply struck up a convo with me she'd be right there in between us. Ugh I can remember a time when she was leading some guy on in a bar (way back) and she actually asked me to just let it go because she was having fun. I almost got into a fist fight with this guy because of her actions. I am not a fighter. Ahk dwelling on the past. Young and immature we were.

I put a few EPs in place myself. There are a couple of the females I know here at work that I would sometimes cross the line in communicating personal stuff. Very professional now. No personal talk. With me I laid it out there with these ladies. I told them I was making a mistake by confiding in them (even though they appeared to be friends of the M). They understood and we've moved on.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 07:45 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Close the deal before you make me pop a blood vessel!!!

Oh my. I wouldn't want that to happen. I must teach you apathy.
rotflmao You're killing me!!

Quote
Are they flirting?

Well ... she's stopped since we had our EP talk with Dr. Chalmers. But before that yes.

I often communicated to her of the double standard we have/had in our R. That she could flirt and it was supposedly allowed but if a woman simply struck up a convo with me she'd be right there in between us. Ugh I can remember a time when she was leading some guy on in a bar (way back) and she actually asked me to just let it go because she was having fun. I almost got into a fist fight with this guy because of her actions. I am not a fighter. Ahk dwelling on the past. Young and immature we were.

I put a few EPs in place myself. There are a couple of the females I know here at work that I would sometimes cross the line in communicating personal stuff. Very professional now. No personal talk. With me I laid it out there with these ladies. I told them I was making a mistake by confiding in them (even though they appeared to be friends of the M). They understood and we've moved on.

Wow, are you sure you want to even be around that guy!? And I applaud you for putting EPs in place for yourself.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 09:07 PM
Wow, are you sure you want to even be around that guy!?

I think so. I don't want to say he's harmless. That would be naive. The one thing I know for sure is he is a good man. He�s very good to his W who treats him very disrespectfully. He just takes it most of the time. He�s a super Dad. Very devote to his kids. He�s a great neighbor always quick to lend me a hand or borrow me a tool, etc.

I see his devotion to his W slipping. His talks with me are filled with more and more distain as the months go by. I so want to help them. They seem like prime candidates for this program. So far I don�t think he�s bit on my suggestion to visit here.

I envision him being cautious with my W if she puts into practice the EPs we discussed. Most of the time they are very neighborly, if you will. Seems it's when we're having a few drinks and inhibitions are lowered where things can cross the line.

I applaud her for trying and being devote in following up with me since we�ve started MB together. That's not how the old us used to operate.

My W is quick to point out that I can be overly neighborly with women too. Almost an attack mechanism as it never comes up until I�m pointing out what she�s doing. I�m not sure what I�m putting out there as there is no one I have thoughts of even being good friends with. I like to hang with my guy friends.

This neighbor�s wife isn�t marriage material (at least not what I would want in a wife) yet my wife says I flirt with her. I�m stupefied. I am friendly. I have friendly conversations with people. I don�t want to be standoff-ish. But I keep my distance at all times and I never insinuate anything that crosses the line. I asked her if she could be specific but she couldn�t recall the exact details.

She has a divorced friend that comes over that is the type to flirt with other guys. She�s attractive. I am careful to keep my distance. Most times I hang close to my W so as not to be put in a bad position.

Her and I definitely need a secret wink or something. I don�t want her experiencing that insecurity. I know how it feels.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/18/13 09:55 PM
Mel, this is a bit of a tangent but I wanted your input regarding these neighbors.

I haven't told you much about them and I won't go into their details. There is one thing about their situation that I need help with.

Our neighbor's wife is quite controlling, demanding, etc but mostly I see her being disrespectful openly about him. She talks about his shortcomings to lots of people. I guess it is what her father did to her. She complains to me about him. Talks him down. Doesn't call him names mind you but it seems he can't do anything right. Yet I see him running his butt off trying to please her.

Anyways when she starts to lambast him directly to me what would be a good reaction for me? In the past I�ve just let her talk but I�m thinking I should do more. At a minimum she shouldn�t be sharing those personal things with me. So how would you phrase something in response to her when she starts in?

�Listen, Mrs. Neighbor, I�m sorry Mr. Neighbor is upsetting you. Still I don�t think you should be telling me these things. It�s none of my business and quite frankly it makes me feel uncomfortable.�

She�ll probably get her feathers ruffled but I almost don�t care as it is very hard to listen to her blast this guy who by all appearances seems to be a good guy.
Posted By: kilted_thrower Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/19/13 06:24 AM
Tell her you don't care to hear her insult her husband just like you'd be offended if your wife were complaining about you too another man.

I don't like any diet that cuts out all fat. Men need to research the relationship between saturated fat, cholesterol, and testosterone. If you want to read up on nutrition, look up Lyle MacDonald and John Berardi.

I have a fair share of couples I train. It only takes a session if you have a good trainer that the hesitation should fade away.
Posted By: kilted_thrower Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/19/13 06:27 AM
To lose fat, you don't have to touch cardio in the traditional fashion. I only touch cardio myself when I have to get low single digit body fat numbers for a competition.

Hopefully you're wife can get rid of her apprehension. Being nervous in front of a trainer is like being nervous to have a physical from a doctor.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/19/13 01:46 PM
Thanks kilted.

It's not that she's nervous about being in front of a trainer. It's that she doesn't want people watching her.

My conundrum is that I have had zero success getting her to even give things a try. Most of that has to do with her anxieties. I try to nudge her some but I don't want to become a source of anxiety for her either.

I try to find the balance between being the one she looks to and being the one that motivates her to branch out.
Posted By: kilted_thrower Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/19/13 03:40 PM
You could always start with a trainer and then ask her if she would like to try a session. And if she doesn't like it, she does not have to do any more sessions with the trainer. I always recommend a trainer even for a short term basis. Most people do not realize how bad their form is. And most people do not know how to create an effective training program.

The tricky part of this is finding a good trainer. Most trainers are only rep counters and do not even look like they work out. And most trainers do not have a clue when it comes to nutrition relating to making physique changes.

What is your budget per month that you can spend on a trainer? What state do you live in?

If the moderators will allow us to exchange emails I might be a able to help you with the training portion or help locate a good trainer
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/19/13 05:09 PM
Thanks kilted but I'm not ready to make any moves regarding a trainer. The budget doesn't really allow for it hence why I mentioned to her that we sell some of our equipment. Unless she's agreeable to that then I won't be going to a trainer solo.

Right now my best option is to simply go back to doing my own workout routine skipping the exercises that create issues for my back.
Posted By: catwhit Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/19/13 05:45 PM
She said she liked yoga. Why not you both try some yoga together? You can get a free DVD from the library, or just download online. Might be fun for you. And very easy on the back/feet...
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/19/13 06:33 PM
Thanks Cat, I'm not sure yoga is going to be my thing but I'm willing to give it a shot. My W has a couple of videos already. LOL. As I've mentioned to Mel ... she's got tons of stuff she could use but she doesn't remain committed.

See ... that's why signing up for some personal training could prove so helpful. Spending the money is incentive to go.

Her and I are sitting down to do a budget tonight. Our spending is getting out of hand and our bank account is being depleted. We need to get a hold of things and from there see what we can shake out for more important expendable items like a PT.

Posted By: kilted_thrower Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/19/13 06:43 PM
I have a suggestion that might work for the both of you. Go check out www.streamfit.com . You can get a free trial period to see if you like it. Then if you want to keep using it, it's a small monthly subscription. They have pre setup workouts from awesome trainers. It has everything from 10 min sessions to hour long and from bodyweight only to using kettlebells to resistance bands, dumbbells, etc. You pretty much choose what equipment you want to use and/or how long you want the session to be and it'll give you a bunch of sessions to choose from.

What's wrong with your back? What exercises aggravate it?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/19/13 07:25 PM
I�m not sure you want to hear but I�ll give you the sorry rundown of my ailments. This is probably gonna sound like some big sob story. It is definitely something that depresses me. FYI I communicate this to my W profusely.

I have a condition in my back that creates back spasms. Bending, stooping, lifting my legs will cause a disk or two to shift in my lumbar area. After enough aggravation eventually the back spasms and I'm out for the count for a few days and am sore for weeks. Interestingly enough and thankfully the twisting motion needed to golf isn�t a problem. I am a very, very avid golfer.

I was going to physical therapy and doing home exercises for several months for the back condition. Like all PT I've taken long term commitment in doing the prescribed exercises doesn't stick. I have no excuses. I�m just lazy, get bored and/or get frustrated with the types of exercises I need to do.

The therapist said I will never be able to completely stop the shifting but could only hope to minimize it by strengthening the muscles around it. So after several months of having to do extremely minimized range of motion to avoid the pop, crunch, shift (whatever you want to call it) I got frustrated and quit. This is what I usually do � I start feeling better and stop doing what I should be doing. Heh, my wife isn�t the only one here who needs to find commitment.

I�ve always been a weight lifter. I have a Hoist V3 home gym and I enjoy using that. There are several exercises I have to be very careful with or I aggravate my chrondomalacia condition in my knees (most predominately in my left knee).
I recently added a dip station and pull up bar which I figured doing leg raises and what not would help me with my core. That�s when I aggravated my back.
We have a Life Fitness recumbent bike. Which works well except my bum gets sore sitting on it and I wish I would have seen that coming and bought an upright one. That�d give me the option of standing once in awhile.

A year and half ago I came down with tendonitis (golfer�s elbow) and that slowed up my workout routine I was doing back then. I can still feel it a little but for the most part the elbow is good.

I work in IT so I spend my days typing (ahem) which means I have some issues with carpael tunnel. I can�t do a push up unless it�s on my knuckles. I wear wrist braces every night when I sleep to minimize the numbness I feel in the morning which can extend into the day. Thought about going in to get the surgery but wearing the braces for about the last 7 or 8 months has helped a lot.

My feet are the worst. They are a daily reminder of how messed up they are. There isn�t a day that has gone by in the last 7 years or so that I haven�t had a pain free day. The pain I experience now is just extreme discomfort and isn�t as painful as it has been. I�ve spent I don�t know what? � over $2500 in therapy sessions (co-pays) trying to fix it. Foot therapy, Active Release, cortisone cr�mes with ultrasound, Graston technique, etc. After on and off again therapy over a 6 year stint I finally stopped going about a year ago as I realized it wasn�t resolving the issue. The podiatrist said it�s a self healing condition which may take as long as 20 years to correct itself.

I�m sure I sound like a whiner but I really do need someone to keep me committed, motivated and help me to avoid over doing it. I�ve let these injury issues get me down, feeling depressed about it at times.

Wait???? What does this have to do with Marriage Building? grin
Posted By: TheRoad Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/20/13 01:01 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
unhappy with physical shape. overweight (nothing obese) but certainly could stand to lose 10to20% of our body weight.


During this talk I tried to negotiate the foods we keep in the home. I expressed my concern for having a hard time avoiding the bad foods in the home. If they are there I can�t seem to keep from consuming some of them. She�ll make cookies, breads, buy desserts from the grocery store, etc. Those things sabotage our efforts to lose weight.

She said I was just going to have to learn to stop eating them. I just can�t seem to stop and it would be so much easier if they weren�t there

I have said those things for over 30 years. Been told it is my problem that I do not have self control.

I then ask if I was an alcoholic would she always make sure there is a bottle of whisky in the house. To which I would get you are crazy look for talking such baloney.
Posted By: TheRoad Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/20/13 01:11 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Sigh. I have been mentioning that we need to find enjoyable things to do together. That the current list of stuff we do just isn�t that much fun for both of us. She just likes doing stuff together. I�d rather it be enjoyable for the both of us.

Doing stuff together is GOOD! It gives you a chance to meet the ENs of affection and conversation. Were you holding out for the Super Bowl?? grin You need to just jump into this initiative and start priming the pump. The more you are together, the more you will love being together, and the faster you will be able to find things you both like.


For instance we had a lot of fun Saturday albeit it wasn�t UA time. The neighbors came down � less his wife. They have kids our kids� ages. This guy is a good friend � but he�s also been a source of contention for her and I because she crosses a line with him, at times, with their antics together. We�ve discussed this quite extensively............


Whoa, stop, put on the breaks.

There is nothing to dicuss. You had a WW?
This guy is no friend.
This OM predator knows about your WW being easy once before and his mind is saying if he plays his cards right your WW will be easy with him again.

This OM is quietly laying the ground work to lay your WW.

And, if I remembered wrong and your wife was the BW this OM is laying the ground work to help your BW have a revenge affair.

This low life, sneaking, snake in the grass, wife stealing bum is not a friend.

You and your WW and kids must go NC with this OM and his whole family. ASAP. Today.
Posted By: TheRoad Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/20/13 01:22 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I have a condition in my back that creates back spasms. Bending, stooping, lifting my legs will cause a disk or two to shift in my lumbar area. After enough aggravation eventually the back spasms and I'm

The therapist said I will never be able to completely stop the shifting but could only hope to minimize it by strengthening the muscles around it. So after several months of having to do extremely minimized range of motion to avoid the pop, crunch, shift (whatever you want to call it) I got frustrated and quit.

I�ve always been a weight lifter. or I aggravate my chrondomalacia condition in my knees (most predominately in my left knee).
I recently added .............. and what not would help me with my core. That�s when I aggravated my back.

A year and half ago I came down with tendonitis and that slowed up my workout routine I was doing back then. I can still feel it a little but for the most part the elbow is good.

I work in IT so I spend my days typing (ahem) which means I have some issues with carpael tunnel.

grin

You were a weight lifter. As in the past.

Time to grow up instead of just older.

You have worked/abused your body too long too hard.

Time to forget weight training for power and just go light for tone and to burn calories.

You can't see how you still seek ways to work out hard and that it only causes your body to break down in new ways. rant2
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/20/13 01:39 PM
Road,

There is no infidelity in my M.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/20/13 01:43 PM
Just because I lift weights doesn't mean I'm going for power. To tone ones body using weight one just uses lighter weights and more reps. This is what I was doing that last time I was working a routine and my back spasmed.

Thanks for the thoughts.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 02/20/13 01:47 PM
Quote
I then ask if I was an alcoholic would she always make sure there is a bottle of whisky in the house. To which I would get you are crazy look for talking such baloney.


Maybe but I would never say that to her. I communicated my struggles but they are my struggles. To this point I don't resent her for what she feels unenthusiastic about doing. It is my job to learn some self control and stop eating the things that keep me from where I want to be.

So far I've dropped 10 pounds using this new way of eating but I've gone back to some bad habits the last month or so. I need to get a handle on that ... recommit myself to a better way.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: The next chapter in our marriage? - 07/08/13 02:26 PM
Yesterday was a dreaded milestone. But now that it has come and gone I�m feeling better about it. Hopefully that feeling continues.

For my birthday my W did something for me in an effort to meet my #1 EN that she has never, ever done before. I was blown away and am still riding the high from it. Not so much what she did but more so when she did it.

Things are going pretty well in our M. I still continue to be the impetus in her and I trying to get in enough UA time and looking for things to do during that time. She isn�t resistant but I definitely have to be the catalyst most of the time. And that�s OK.

I have really being emphasizing to her how I feel disconnected from her if we don�t get in enough UA time. I really do feel it. We don�t schedule SF time and if I�m feeling disconnected from her I find it difficult to ask for it. So my #1 purpose in getting my needs met is to ensure we�re getting in enough UA time and making it be quality UA time.

We�ve spent quite a bit of time golfing which is great. I love it , she really likes it. We ride the cart together. I get to help her improve, I get to give her admiration when she does well, I get to flirt. Loads and loads of quality UA.

We also have a standing date on one of the two weekend mornings. Instead of her sleeping until 10 or 11 am she now gets up (I�m up at 6:30-7:30) and we go have a cup of coffee and bagel at a local shop.

This week we�re busy but this weekend we�ll be spending a lot of time together working in the yard. Lots to do � not enough time.


Posted By: MrAlias Came back to take some medicine - 01/06/16 02:30 PM
Hello MB friends, it has been a long time since I've posted. It's good to see familiar posters still here, Mel, Marko, Brain.

I must be a masochist as I continue to come back here with the same and/or similar story every time. I read my posts from several years ago and I sound like a broken record. Much of the same BS has been going on since my last posts here.

I'm no longer in love with my W, haven't been for a long time, but have simply been co-habitating. The MB counseling and our efforts were only a temporary thing. Something she put minimal effort into. I failed to push the issue.

Same thing that happened a few years ago the same neighbor came down without his wife and my wife (who has been getting zero attention/affection from me) spent the night flirting with him. Can't say I blame her desire to have some attention but just shows how idiotic I've been to think I could co-habitate with her.

Problem #1 is her drinking. I'm quite certain she's an alcoholic. Drinks nearly every day and does dumb stuff when she's intoxicated.

I am so uncertain what to do anymore. I had a long talk with her on New Years and told her things needed to change drastically or I was going to leave her. She apologized for her actions on that drunken night. Said it would never happen again. Sorry honey but I've heard that before.

I told her if she really was serious about saving this marriage there were definitive things that would have change.

No more drinking. She's squaking at that but she's stopped ... for now.

To help I've tried to throw myself back into the program and do all the work that Jennifer and my experience has taught me. This is really it, the last time you'll hear me say I'm trying one more time. I've spent the last 2 years being extremely withdrawn and unhappy. I have better things to do with my life then spend it miserable.

Trouble is my W doesn't throw all in with the MB program. I know the right thing to do is give her the mandate that we follow it to the letter or it won't work. I don't know, maybe I have my answer and shouldn't even bother giving it one more go.

Not sure I should even be pushing the MB program right now. She needs my support if we're to get through this but I think her abuse of alcohol has to be addressed before anything. It is difficult to be supportive when you're withdrawn.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/06/16 03:29 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Hello MB friends, it has been a long time since I've posted. It's good to see familiar posters still here, Mel, Marko, Brain.

I must be a masochist as I continue to come back here with the same and/or similar story every time. I read my posts from several years ago and I sound like a broken record. Much of the same BS has been going on since my last posts here.

I'm no longer in love with my W, haven't been for a long time, but have simply been co-habitating. The MB counseling and our efforts were only a temporary thing. Something she put minimal effort into. I failed to push the issue.

Same thing that happened a few years ago the same neighbor came down without his wife and my wife (who has been getting zero attention/affection from me) spent the night flirting with him. Can't say I blame her desire to have some attention but just shows how idiotic I've been to think I could co-habitate with her.

Problem #1 is her drinking. I'm quite certain she's an alcoholic. Drinks nearly every day and does dumb stuff when she's intoxicated.

I am so uncertain what to do anymore. I had a long talk with her on New Years and told her things needed to change drastically or I was going to leave her. She apologized for her actions on that drunken night. Said it would never happen again. Sorry honey but I've heard that before.

I told her if she really was serious about saving this marriage there were definitive things that would have change.

No more drinking. She's squaking at that but she's stopped ... for now.

To help I've tried to throw myself back into the program and do all the work that Jennifer and my experience has taught me. This is really it, the last time you'll hear me say I'm trying one more time. I've spent the last 2 years being extremely withdrawn and unhappy. I have better things to do with my life then spend it miserable.

Trouble is my W doesn't throw all in with the MB program. I know the right thing to do is give her the mandate that we follow it to the letter or it won't work. I don't know, maybe I have my answer and shouldn't even bother giving it one more go.

Not sure I should even be pushing the MB program right now. She needs my support if we're to get through this but I think her abuse of alcohol has to be addressed before anything. It is difficult to be supportive when you're withdrawn.
The alcoholism MUST be addressed. She cannot do MB if she is drinking. Remind us what happens when you discuss AA with her.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/06/16 06:49 PM
I agree. Will she get into an AA program? And it needs to be an all female AA program. Are you in Alanon?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/06/16 08:19 PM
We have never discussed AA. Not for her. Just our BIL who is an alcoholic.

I suppose I need to be more direct with her and ask her what she thinks of her drinking and if she thinks she is an alcoholic.

Am I in Alanon? No. I went to our local chapter some years ago to get an understanding of what happens in those programs. I was trying to convince my SIL to consider it seeing she has an alcoholic husband.

The 5 or so meetings I attended weren't very productive. As a new member I didn't really felt like I was given any kind of intro to Alanon, what their hope for me would have been, etc. And I just didn't see what the benefit was. I didn't see a lot of advice being given.

To be frank ... if that is what I need to do to recover our marriage I'll probably just cut bait and file for divorce. I've grown so tired of all the effort I've put into this relationship over the years and at this point am so withdrawn from her it's simply not worth it to me. I'd rather cut my losses and maybe some day start fresh with someone else.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/06/16 09:15 PM
Well, you need to decide what you are going to do.

If you want to give the marriage another chance, she needs to be in AA.

If she won't go to AA, you can stay with her and be her carer, without any expectation that you will have an MB marriage. For how long could you keep that up, and why would you do it? How old are your kids now? Is your signature up to date?

You can do what Dr Harley recommends in a marriage affected by addiction, which is to "run for your life". You could separate, taking the kids with you. You could divorce after a time if she shows no sign of getting into AA and abstaining.

What are you going to do?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/06/16 10:15 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I suppose I need to be more direct with her and ask her what she thinks of her drinking and if she thinks she is an alcoholic.

Hi MrAlias! Sorry to hear things are not going well. The fact that she is an alcoholic explains why your marriage has never changed. You have been spinning your wheels for years with a wife who is CHECKED OUT. Dr. Harley says this program does not work unless the addiction is resolved.

I would plan to separate if I were you.
Originally Posted by Dr Harley
Why would anyone want to put up with an alcoholic husband? It's usually because he or she keeps holding out hope, as you have, that some day the addiction will be over. But as you become older, and the best years of your life seem to be behind you, a feeling of hopelessness will grip you, and a deep and pervasive depression caused by the destructive behavior of your alcoholic spouse will overcome you.

If you want to remain married to your husband, and avoid depression at the same time, I highly recommend that you do something other than hold out hope for his recovery. I suggest that you prepare for a separation. Don't threaten him with it -- simply do it. After you are separated, explain to him that he can have a relationship with you or alcohol, but not with both.

You must learn to regard your husband as hopelessly lost to his alcohol, and that any effort you make to try to please him will not be reciprocated. His lover will always be alcohol and that's that. You have never had a chance for a normal marriage with him and never will have a chance as long as he's addicted.
here
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/06/16 10:48 PM
oooh, I love this line!! " After you are separated, explain to him that he can have a relationship with you or alcohol, but not with both."

Actually, this is sort of what my XH told me on April 27th, 1985: It's AA or the highway. Make your choice now, because if you ever drink again, I will put you on a bus to your mother's and I will keep the kids."

I have not had a DROP since! laugh
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/06/16 11:31 PM
Hi Mel,

Thanks for the replies.

I have things to decide. I'll be back when I do.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/06/16 11:35 PM
I did update my profile just now SC.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 12:56 PM
Mrs Alias and I have taken time each night this week to talk about our relationship.

I, of course, mainly raised concerns about the drinking. She was very open about the whole thing. We discussed alcoholism.

How would we know if she's an alcoholic?

She's made some statements that lead me to believe that this is more of a behavioral thing versus an addiction but how can any truly know if it is addiction?

We aren't drinking right now. However she has said that she does feel upset when she thinks she can't do what she wants. She really enjoys having a beer or two a time or two during the week. She'll come home, work on her afghan and sip a beer or two then we go to bed. Or if we go to dinner she'll have one or two.

Until I know she needs to be in AA I'm not sure how to move forward.

We discussed and agreed on many things. We both know we've spent a lot of time hurting each other and that we seem to struggle making each other happy. We've agreed that we should give this one last effort and if that doesn't work then we should go our separate ways.

Which brings me back to the alcohol because I really don't want to waste my time working the MB program if she is an alcoholic. I know that it doesn't work. However I'm too amicable. Too chicken or whatever. I have a hard time mandating things with her. She's stubborn and doesn't like it when people tell her what she should do. Even if she knows they're right. Reflecting on that I can see that she has me programmed.

Knowing that I have a hard time insisting she go to AA. I don't think she'd go. Is that the only way we'd truly know whether or not she should stop drinking entirely and work a program without alcohol?

Thanks in advance for your advice.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 01:15 PM
I found this interesting as I just saw it on another thread.

Quote
I, of all people, understand how the concepts of co-dependency started. I had a one-year internship in a treatment center for chemical dependency, and I owned and operated ten such centers myself. Co-dependency was something all of us addressed in marriages where one or both spouses were addicted to drugs or alcohol.

When an alcoholic is married to a loving and caring spouse, the spouse's love and care is sucked in like a black hole. It drains the caring spouse of everything they have, leaving him or her not only exhausted, but also having failed to meet their sick spouse's needs. In these cases, the non-alcoholic spouse must emotionally detach themselves or becomes emotionally destroyed.

I have spent the better part of the last 2 years withdrawing from my wife. I decided I was just going to skate thru life until the kids were grown and quite frankly I was almost certain I would then leave her. Stupid I know.

As I pulled away she continued to drink and in my eyes (not her perception) she drank more and more. I withdrew even more. I wasn't happy but I wasn't in a freaked out state.

I am terrified of being divorced. I really do love my wife and I really wish we could be happy and live together forever. I fear what it will do to the kids and my finances and on and on. Hence my resistance to any type of separation and why I do the lame martyr thing.

Now that I've decided I want to give this another go (depending on the alcoholism question) I am nervous as all get out. Having trouble focusing on work. All I want to do is fix my marriage. I want to make her happy so she can make me happy and I can go back to feeling comfortable and not so on edge.

I'm not sure where I'm going with this post if anywhere. Just wanted to have an outlet to communicate my thoughts and struggles.

[Edited to add] Switching to decaf.
Posted By: TheRoad Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 01:29 PM
When you must have a beer or two every night it points to alcoholic.

There are lots of people that nurse a beer or two though never get drunk, never act inappropriate. Though will not insist they have to have a beer when none is in the house.

People that have a glass of wine with diner. That is a glass of wine when they sit down. Never pour a full glass. Are ok with the bottle going dry and not buying any more because wine is not in the budget.

Not a 1st glass as they cook, not a 3rd glass after done eating to get the motivation to do the dishes.

They know when to stop before they feel a buzz.

Or the old I'm not an alcoholic because they hold down a job M-F yet have/must to get drunk every weekend.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 01:32 PM
Sorry I did want to qualified what I said to my wife about the drinking.

"I struggle with the drinking because I'm no expert and I have no way of knowing if you have an addiction or not. I do know that you're drinking is a problem for me and thus a problem in our marriage.

I attribute the drinking to two things:

1). You get too drunk some times and do things that I am embarassed about. We talked about this, you get so drunk you slur. (FYI she had done really well on this for months and months until New year's eve). And you do hurtful things that flirt with neighbor guy and in my eye very inappropriately, dancing and wiggling around directly in front of him as if to show him your stuff.
2). You drink sometimes 4 or 5 nights a week. I figure that is the reason you have all this extra weight you put on.

If you don't have an addiction I would be OK with you have an occasional drink or two if you were to lose some of the weight you've gained in the last 2 years. But if you start having a beer or two now I would need you to tell me of any progress you were making losing weight."

We've been working out every night this year so she's trying to get in shape. She even thanked me for confronting her this time and she was ready to make a change. She'd just given up on us too. What came first the chicken or the egg?

She doesn't want to be overweight and she does want to have a happy marriage and she certainly doesn't want to be embarrassed by her drinking.




Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 01:42 PM
Thanks for the reply TheRoad.

I'm not sure if your post helps me.

She doesn't have a beer every night. Sometimes 3 or 4 or 5 times a week. And she will only have 1 maybe 2, other times 3. Quantify that though she drinks the big 16 oz cans not the 12s. Seems the bigger cans are cheaper.

She attributes fun things with drinking. We go to dinner, drinks, we go to a party, drinks (so do I), we go do something fun like lay on a beach or golf or whatever if she can drink there she will.

She never acts inappropriately when she's just had 1 or 2 or 3. It's when she pounds 'em down like on New Year's where she probably had I don't know 4 beers, her and the neighbor polished off a bottle of champagne (I don't like the stuff) and a some other goofy purple drink that has silver swirls in it. Slurring, dancing, getting way too close to the neighbor guy. I came downstairs to see him standing behind her just staring at her backside and he didn't look away until he noticed I was back. At that point I gave him a look and he got it and did well to steer away from her.

Sigh. I like the guy. Good buddy except for this. I trust nothing would happen as his world would crumble if his wife found out he was doing anything inappropriate. They have a shaky relationship but he's a family man too.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 02:03 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
How would we know if she's an alcoholic?

She's made some statements that lead me to believe that this is more of a behavioral thing versus an addiction but how can any truly know if it is addiction?

She is an alcoholic if she is addicted to drinking. However, it is easy enough to answer that if she can just quit drinking. And it doesn't matter if she is an alcoholic or not, what matters is that you don't like it and it is wrecking yoru marriage. She can just stop drinking. If she won't stop drinking then you have a bigger problem than the alcohol, and that is extreme thoughtlessness. She wants to gain at your expense.


Quote
Which brings me back to the alcohol because I really don't want to waste my time working the MB program if she is an alcoholic. I know that it doesn't work.

Yes, it does work. I am an alcoholic and I have a wonderful marriage. But she has to stop drinking in order for it to work. She can do that. Anything that comes before your marriage will come between it.

Originally Posted by MrAlias
She never acts inappropriately when she's just had 1 or 2 or 3. It's when she pounds 'em down like on New Year's where she probably had I don't know 4 beers, her and the neighbor polished off a bottle of champagne (I don't like the stuff) and a some other goofy purple drink that has silver swirls in it. Slurring, dancing, getting way too close to the neighbor guy. I came downstairs to see him standing behind her just staring at her backside and he didn't look away until he noticed I was back. At that point I gave him a look and he got it and did well to steer away from her.

Alcoholics very often have affairs because they are out of control when they are drinking. It is clear she loses control and her personaltiy changes when she drinks alot.

And I am curious how you know how much she drinks? How would you know?

Quote
Sigh. I like the guy. Good buddy except for this. I trust nothing would happen as his world would crumble if his wife found out he was doing anything inappropriate. They have a shaky relationship but he's a family man too.

Defines just about every person who has an affair. Don't understand why you would imagine he would be immune. He is not. Your wife is not.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 02:06 PM
It's real simple. She can just stop drinking. If she won't, then you know that drinking is more important than your marriage and your marriage won't last.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 02:12 PM
Quote
). You get too drunk some times and do things that I am embarassed about. We talked about this, you get so drunk you slur. (FYI she had done really well on this for months and months until New year's eve). And you do hurtful things that flirt with neighbor guy and in my eye very inappropriately, dancing and wiggling around directly in front of him as if to show him your stuff.


Yes, she has an addiction. She is addicted to alcohol and has a dramatic personality change when drinking. If she doesn't have an addiction, then what's the problem with giving it all up right now? Any normal person would just give up a beverage or food that caused them to act so outrageously that it alienated her spouse.

Originally Posted by MrAlias
If you don't have an addiction I would be OK with you have an occasional drink or two if you were to lose some of the weight you've gained in the last 2 years. But if you start having a beer or two now I would need you to tell me of any progress you were making losing weight."

No, she should not drink at all. If drinking has been poison in your marriage, then eliminate the poison. Don't settle for a little poison. Secondly, it is not the 10th drink that is the problem, but the FIRST drink with an alcoholic.

I am concerned that you are wasting alot of valuable time debating whether she is or isn't an alcoholic and that misses the point. The point is that drinking is wrecking your marriage. STOP DRINKING.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 02:15 PM
My urologist told me last year to stop drinking tea because aggravates my bladder. I didn't need to sit around and have endless discussions about whether I should have a little or a lot or if I am or am not a tea-aholic. I just stopped drinking tea.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 06:37 PM
Thanks Mel.

She has stopped drinking ... for now. But has already stated she feels upset when she knows she's being asked to never drink again.

Going back to your comment about thoughtlessness ...

I told her I would give up coaching softball, golf, etc whatever if it meant we would improve our marriage. I didn't say it to her as a comparison to her drinking but I'm seeing a comparison now just thinking about it.

She has said she'd like to have a drink or two if we go to dinner and/or she comes home from work and wants to unwind. She says she doesn't have to drink she'd just like to.

I know how much she drinks because she doesn't hide it. I'm home most every night especially here in the winter. Nothing to do. Even if I'm upstairs and she's downstairs I know how much as I hear every can she opens. Not to mention checking the beer cooler and recycling. On the weekends she may drink more than I know because I go to bed a lot of times long before she does. She'll sit up and watch shows with our teenagers.

She grew up watching her parents have a beer or two every night. She relates to it. Likes to do the same. The party girl in her is what comes out when she's had too much.

BTW one of her biggest complaints is that I don't put her first. The simple fact that I share some of our struggles with my support group (buddies, relatives, etc) makes her lose love for me. Or so she says.

Considering drinking is an issue gee tough I'm not going to cover up or enable the drinking habits.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 06:51 PM
Quote
Quote:
). You get too drunk some times and do things that I am embarassed about. We talked about this, you get so drunk you slur. (FYI she had done really well on this for months and months until New year's eve). And you do hurtful things that flirt with neighbor guy and in my eye very inappropriately, dancing and wiggling around directly in front of him as if to show him your stuff.



Yes, she has an addiction. She is addicted to alcohol and has a dramatic personality change when drinking. If she doesn't have an addiction, then what's the problem with giving it all up right now? Any normal person would just give up a beverage or food that caused them to act so outrageously that it alienated her spouse.

Well ... we really haven't been operating as spouses. Just co-habitating as parents. There was very little care and consideration for each other. I stopped doing things for her once the bad habits of hers came creeping back.

This last event she was angry with me. I've abandoned her (I won't get into her role in this) as her husband and she was longing for some attention. Considering she started trying to warm up to me that night and I did the usual cold shoulder thing she moved on to anyone that would pay attention (aka the neighbor guy was there).

Is it cut and dry? She should just stop drinking completely and never have another one? The desire to have one to relax isn't an option?

For me I can live with her having a beer or two to unwind. I do. So long as she's diligent about meeting my needs (AS,SF). I cannot, will not tolerate the heavy drinking.

If she isn't an addict, stops drinking for a certain length of time does that eliminate the addiction discussion?

I feel like if she could do that and we could rekindle the marriage then she would never drink heavy and hurt me again.

It hasn't always been bad. We made great strides when we were working with Jennifer. I never asked her at that time to quit drinking though. It felt like less of a problem back then. I certainly drink far less than I used to. I changed. She hasn't.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 09:21 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She has said she'd like to have a drink or two if we go to dinner and/or she comes home from work and wants to unwind. She says she doesn't have to drink she'd just like to.

That is great. Just ask her to stop for life. It's not a big deal. If it is a big deal, then you know the problem is much bigger than you thought. And don't make the mistake of asking her to limit it to 2 or 3 because having ONE will trigger the desire for more. Just cut it out entirely.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 09:27 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Quote
Quote:
). You get too drunk some times and do things that I am embarassed about. We talked about this, you get so drunk you slur. (FYI she had done really well on this for months and months until New year's eve). And you do hurtful things that flirt with neighbor guy and in my eye very inappropriately, dancing and wiggling around directly in front of him as if to show him your stuff.



Yes, she has an addiction. She is addicted to alcohol and has a dramatic personality change when drinking. If she doesn't have an addiction, then what's the problem with giving it all up right now? Any normal person would just give up a beverage or food that caused them to act so outrageously that it alienated her spouse.

Well ... we really haven't been operating as spouses. Just co-habitating as parents. There was very little care and consideration for each other. I stopped doing things for her once the bad habits of hers came creeping back.

I don't see what your comments have to do with my point. I don't care if you haven't been operating as spouses. My point was that when a food/beverage causes problems, a normal person will stop it. Her drinking is a problem. If you ate bananas and they gave you a horrible rash would you just quit eating bananas or would you find a way to eat 2-3 a day or just quit them for a while? Of course not.

Quote
Is it cut and dry? She should just stop drinking completely and never have another one? The desire to have one to relax isn't an option?

Just cut it out completely. No one needs a "drink" to relax. Normal people don't have to drink to get "relaxation." Normal people do not have to drink to have a good time.

Quote
If she isn't an addict, stops drinking for a certain length of time does that eliminate the addiction discussion?

If she isn't an addict, then it won't be a problem to give it up for life. IF she can't do that, then she likely should be in AA to handle her addiction.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/08/16 09:32 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I feel like if she could do that and we could rekindle the marriage then she would never drink heavy and hurt me again.

Your marriage is an absolute wreck because of her drinking. Why in the world would you even consider agreeing to drinking a "little" or drink again in the future? It is not the 10th drink that causes the problem, but the FIRST DRINK. The first drink sets up the craving and sometimes she doesn't stop. Why play with fire?

If you get hit by a car playing chicken, should you:

1. get your [censored] out of the street
2. just play 2-3 times a week?
3. just quit playing chicken for while
Posted By: markos Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/09/16 04:19 PM
MrA,

I am glad to see you back, but definitely sorry for what brings you here. There are parts to the story here that I don't believe you've ever told before. Stay with us this time and become a Marriage Builders full-timer. Get all the details out there and get the help you need.

Originally Posted by MrAlias
I feel like if she could do that and we could rekindle the marriage then she would never drink heavy and hurt me again.

Now, you know that's not right. Bad marriages don't make people drink. You don't make your wife drink. That is her choice.

It's just like an affair, right? You must have read it here a hundred times. People don't have affairs because of unmet needs, love busters, bad marriages, fights, or something else their spouse did. They have affairs because we would all have affairs if we didn't take extraordinary precautions to prevent them.

Drinking is absolutely the same. Lots of people are in bad marriages and don't respond by drinking. Lots of people are in bad marriages and don't respond by having affairs. I notice that you are in a terrible marriage and are not responding by drinking.

Your wife is an alcoholic and she needs to pledge to go into treatment any time she ever takes a drink again as long as she lives. Please talk to Dr. Harley on this. Please listen to what the posters here are saying about this.

Drinking is not part of life.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/11/16 07:20 PM
Thanks for all the posts Mel and Markos great to hear from you too.

I continue to ask her to seek an assessment and advice of a professional regarding alcoholism. I haven't mandated anything as of yet.

Without that I have little to back my requests that she quit entirely versus try to control her consumption.

Right now she says her plan is to only have a few beers on Friday and Saturday. Anywhere's from 1 to 4.

I'm putting my spy glasses on because now is when she'll probably start to hide it. If and when she fails I will then mandate she seek professional help. "We made a plan together, you failed, you have a drinking problem and are most likely an alcoholic. It's time to see someone. It's either that or I will be separating."

Meanwhile I am being pleasant and letting her know there is something for her to come back to.

I have my retort to the things she says that make her say Just give me a chance. Trust me. All babble talk I know if she's an addict.

Quote
Signs of Alcoholism

Drinking to De-Stress: Many people develop a drinking problem because they are trying to �relax� from work and decrease stress. Alcohol is a sedative drug, and the more a person uses it, the more it takes to feel the same effect. It is generally a very slow process that creeps up on a person without the person really realizing it. Family members ALWAYS see the signs faster than the person who is using the alcohol. Many times, people will get drunk after a long day at work or a stressful event happens and the person will justify the action by saying �I had a hard day�, or �I deserve it�.

You�ll want to drink if you�ve had a bad day, are upset about something and you also want to drink to �relax�. You also drink to have fun and let your hair down.

Repeatedly Neglecting Responsibilities
Nope this isn't you. You are very responsible and have yet to shirk any responsibilities related to work or taking care of things at home.

Alcohol Use in Dangerous Situations:
Nope this isn't you. You don't drink and drive. And you wouldn't argue if you wanted to and I told you No you've had too much.

Legal Problems Due to Drinking:
Nope this isn't you.

Continuing to Drink Despite Relationship Problems: It comes to a point with a person�s drinking where alcohol begins causing or making small problems become large with friends, family and the person will still continue to drink. Typical examples that are reported frequently: fighting with family members because they do not like how a person acts when they are drunk or going out drinking with �friends� even though the wife or girlfriend will not be happy.
Alcohol abuse is a pattern of drinking that results in harm to one�s health, interpersonal relationships, or ability to work.

This one is a big old red flag for me. I've talked to you about your drinking several times now and have asked if we could just quit. You continue to tell me you don't want to quit completely.

Why do people choose alcohol to cope?
The signs of alcohol abuse may not always become apparent to close family members until the disease has taken a good hold on the individual abusing the alcohol. Alcoholics typically hide their alcohol. It is true though that most close family members of severe alcoholics report to us in the pre-intervention process that when intoxicated, they become belligerent or bellicose, meaning �of warlike character; aggressively hostile�. This is not something that an intoxicated alcoholic is able to control. This feature of an alcoholic�s personality is the hallmark symptom that his or her drinking has gotten out of control and that the person no longer has control of the alcohol.

I am not with you all the time. I believe you aren�t hiding anything from me. If you are I really need you to be honest with me about it. I am trusting you that you are and have been honest. I know there have been plenty of times in the past where I�ve gone to bed and you�ve continued to drink. But to me that isn�t hiding, that is just you continuing to drink what you feel is acceptable.

People choose alcohol to cope with life�s situations for two reasons: 1. Because the alcoholism gene was passed through to them via heredity; or 2. The person is trying to change the way he or she feels, possibly because of some underlying mental health condition whether properly diagnosed or not.

Knowing what your Dad did drink every day and quite possibly was dependent on alcohol this scares me. We know you have an addictive personality. Yep, I�m terrified when I read this.

Knowing you reach out for a drink many times when you are sad, mad, need it to feel relaxed or happy scares me. When I�m mad I never think about a drink.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/11/16 09:45 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Thanks for all the posts Mel and Markos great to hear from you too.

I continue to ask her to seek an assessment and advice of a professional regarding alcoholism. I haven't mandated anything as of yet. Without that I have little to back my requests that she quit entirely versus try to control her consumption.

This misses the point. The point is that her drinking makes you unhappy. The fact that it makes you unhappy backs up your request entirely. You don't have to PROVE that she is an alcoholic, it is irrelevant. You know that one drink leads to the next. Therefore, you should ask her to stop drinking. You are making this much more complicated than it needs to be.

If she can't stop, that is evidence that she is an alcoholic. This is just a beverage, after all. If it is bigger than just a mere beverage, that is an indication of a bigger problem.

Quote
Right now she says her plan is to only have a few beers on Friday and Saturday. Anywhere's from 1 to 4.

This is just conflict avoidance and kicking the can down the road. Go to her and ask her to stop drinking for life. Don't delay.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/11/16 09:51 PM
You are distracting yourself from the issue by quibbling over whether she is an "alcoholic" or not. That is not the point. This enables you to avoid the conflict, which just makes the problem worse. She is a problem drinker and her drinking makes you very unhappy. Therefore, you are not enthusiastic about her drinking. She needs to STOP drinking.

Since she claims she is not an "alcoholic," then giving up drinking should be a no brainer. When the urologist told me to give up iced tea, I did not hesitate, I just gave it up.

The fact that you are going through all these loops tells me you are committed to enabling her addiction. If it is not a big deal, just stop it. But, you know it is a very big deal because you are making a big deal out of it. You know she won't quit.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 01:52 PM
"You are distracting yourself."

Yep I am fully aware of what I could be doing. But am choosing NOT to do that for my own comfort level. I have told her I would prefer she stop drinking completely. That the negatives of her drinking right now is the #1 problem we have in our relationship.

Right now I'm giving her a little rope. When she fails to stick to it and she backslides even a little then it will be easy for me to tell her this is more than just a behavioral thing. It's an addiction. It is always chosen over what should be far more important, us. If that happens I will mandate the drinking stop or I'll be forced to separate. I won't play second fiddle to an addiction.

To say her drinking makes me unhappy needs more context.

I have a problem with her drinking when she drinks too much and embarrasses herself. Slurring, flirting, etc. This has happened maybe 3 or 4 times in the last 2 years.

I have a problem with her trying to squeeze in one more drink when it is totally unnecessary and then chugging it because of time constraints.

I have a problem with her drinking continually as I attribute her weight gain to all those extra calories.

I enjoy having a drink or two with her. It is something we've done for a very long time.

I wouldn't be unhappy with her if she were able to control her drinking (assuming it is not an addiction). By control I mean no more excessive drinking, no more "trying to get in another" or chugging and limiting the number of days to drink.

The one thing that bothers me about our current decision and I told her this is that I still feel like the booze is far more important than me. And maybe it is. Maybe she really doesn't care if I leave and envisions herself with some other guy or merely just being alone to do as she pleases (addiction).
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 01:58 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
The one thing that bothers me about our current decision and I told her this is that I still feel like the booze is far more important than me. And maybe it is. Maybe she really doesn't care if I leave and envisions herself with some other guy.

It is more important than your marriage and that is the point I have tried to make to you. You ARE playing second fiddle to an addiction/drinking problem.

Quote
Right now I'm giving her a little rope. When she fails to stick to it and she backslides even a little then it will be easy for me to tell her this is more than just a behavioral thing. It's an addiction.

I don't understand what this means. An alcohol addiction *IS* a "behavioral thing." So what do you mean? One of the definitions of alcoholism is a behavioral change brought on my alcohol use.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 01:59 PM
Sorry I'm not fully educated on behavioral versus addiction and may be confusing this with chemical imbalance versus behavioral issues.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:01 PM
I'm quite certain if I tell her she HAS to stop drinking she will but she'll make my life uncomfortable. I'll get the cold shoulder because I'm not letting her do it her way.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:05 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'm quite certain if I tell her she HAS to stop drinking she will but she'll make my life uncomfortable. I'll get the cold shoulder because I'm not letting her do it her way.

You contribute to the problem by agreeing to a "little" drinking, because a little drinking always leads to a lot of drinking with problem drinkers. This is what I mean when I say you are just kicking the can down the road. I get the sense that alcohol is very important in your lives.

Don't tell her to stop drinking, but ask her to stop drinking forever because it makes you very unhappy.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:06 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'm quite certain if I tell her she HAS to stop drinking she will but she'll make my life uncomfortable.

Your life *IS* uncomfortable.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:13 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'm quite certain if I tell her she HAS to stop drinking she will but she'll make my life uncomfortable.

Your life *IS* uncomfortable.

I still think I need to know if she IS an alcoholic. I can't work MB if she isn't working a program as an alcoholic.

My life prior to 2016 was uncomfortable because I was dealing with her crap and was totally withdrawn from her.

Now it is less uncomfortable because she is making improvements and I am coming out of my withdrawal.

It is still uncomfortable because she won't quit drinking. Other than requiring her that she quit drinking I don't know what the next step is.

If she fails I will know definitively what the next step is. I know that isn't how you feel I should handle this. I've been so uncomfortable for so long I'm not afraid for it to continue temporarily. It's better than having to deal with the anxiety of a separation.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:21 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[

I still think I need to know if she IS an alcoholic. I can't work MB if she isn't working a program as an alcoholic.

But you aren't working MB so I don't understand what you mean. You need to eliminate alcohol so you can repair your marriage. But you won't do that.

Your wife is a problem drinker at the very least, which has the same effect as if she were an alcoholic. The reason that MB won't work with an addict/problem drinker is because they won't follow the policy of joint agreement.

So while you are tying yourself into logical pretzels you miss the point. The point is that if anything comes BEFORE marriage - as alcohol does - it will come between you. THAT is why MB does not work in these situations. The program can't work if one of the parties won't follow the POJA.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:23 PM
I'm sorry. I always thought the rule was that MB didn't work in the case of an addiction.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:24 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'm sorry. I always thought the rule was that MB didn't work in the case of an addiction.

Did you read my post?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:25 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'm sorry. I always thought the rule was that MB didn't work in the case of an addiction.

MB has not "worked" in your marriage. Can you see why now?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:27 PM
Quote
But you aren't working MB so I don't understand what you mean. You need to eliminate alcohol so you can repair your marriage. But you won't do that.

Your wife is a problem drinker at the very least, which has the same effect as if she were an alcoholic. The reason that MB won't work with an addict/problem drinker is because they won't follow the policy of joint agreement.

So while you are tying yourself into logical pretzels you miss the point. The point is that if anything comes BEFORE marriage - as alcohol does - it will come between you. THAT is why MB does not work in these situations. The program can't work if one of the parties won't follow the POJA.

This one? Yes. I read it. Your statement that they won't follow POJA makes sense only as it pertains to the drinking. Everything else her and I are able to negotiate. Interestingly enough we used POJA to negotiate her drinking, not the elimination of the drinking, but something we felt we could both live with.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:30 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'm sorry. I always thought the rule was that MB didn't work in the case of an addiction.

MB has not "worked" in your marriage. Can you see why now?

It failed because I wasn't diligent in working the program once I became discouraged. That we lost sight of doing what we needed to to stay on track.

Had we continued to talk about the issues (the drinking, weight gain, me being a couch potato, etc) I would not have come back here for help.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:32 PM
It was easier for me to give up and withdraw then to do the work.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:33 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[

This one? Yes. I read it. Your statement that they won't follow POJA makes sense only as it pertains to the drinking. Everything else her and I are able to negotiate. Sadly we used POJA to negotiate her drinking, not the elimination of the drinking, but something we felt we could both live with.

One of the reasons that POJA is not effective with an addict/problem drinker is because they will agree to anything to protect their drinking. The alcohol comes before everything as it is their first love. AS long as it is her first love - which it is - you can't compete. I think if you are really honest with yourself, you will be able to see your situation in this article: Alcoholic Spouse

Have you considered emailing Dr. Harley on the radio show and getting his advice? [it is free]
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:38 PM
Thanks for the article Melody. I will take some time to read it today.

I haven't really thought about emailing Dr. Harley but I will give that some thought too. It's hard enough to get your great advice which tells me what I know is best approach to his principles from you. I let my fear control me too much, I know.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:42 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Thanks for the article Melody. I will take some time to read it today.

I haven't really thought about emailing Dr. Harley but I will give that some thought too. It's hard enough to get your great advice which tells me what I know is best approach to his principles from you. I let my fear control me too much, I know.

He could speak to you and your wife on his radio show and help you solve this problem. He is amazing. Do you listen to the radio show?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:51 PM
I used to, from time to time. Not anymore. Not for over 2 years. I went into withdrawal from her and abandoned most everything MB related.

I remained respectful to her but that's not always easy when I'm forcing distance between us.

She got a lot of "Do whatever you want. I don't much care.".
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 02:55 PM
As far as us being on the radio show, I'm about 99.9% sure she won't want to do that. It was all I could do to get her to meet with Jennifer.

She also won't be enthusiastic about me airing our dirty laundry over the air waves. I'm a bit of an open book, she keeps things close to the vest.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 03:22 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
As far as us being on the radio show, I'm about 99.9% sure she won't want to do that. It was all I could do to get her to meet with Jennifer.

She also won't be enthusiastic about me airing our dirty laundry over the air waves. I'm a bit of an open book, she keeps things close to the vest.

Since you aren't really working the program anyway, I would go ahead if I were you. You can speak to Dr Harley on his show and play it back for your wife. He might be able to get through to her.
Posted By: markos Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 03:53 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I used to, from time to time. Not anymore. Not for over 2 years. I went into withdrawal from her and abandoned most everything MB related.

I remained respectful to her but that's not always easy when I'm forcing distance between us.

She got a lot of "Do whatever you want. I don't much care.".

I hate to sound like Dr. Phil, but how's that working for you, MrAlias? Not too well, I imagine. frown
Posted By: markos Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 03:54 PM
When the wife is not interested in doing Marriage Builders, the husband needs to increase his involvement in Marriage Builders about 1000%. He has to carry the load. He can't be the one who doesn't know what Dr. Harley would recommend a guy do in his situation. He can't be the one not listening to the radio show.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 04:17 PM
Originally Posted by markos
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I used to, from time to time. Not anymore. Not for over 2 years. I went into withdrawal from her and abandoned most everything MB related.

I remained respectful to her but that's not always easy when I'm forcing distance between us.

She got a lot of "Do whatever you want. I don't much care.".

I hate to sound like Dr. Phil, but how's that working for you, MrAlias? Not too well, I imagine. frown

I was able to keep my sanity. Watching her drink was painful, depressing. I withdrew to survive.

It worked until she failed to control her drinking in front of the neighbor and the kids at the end of the year.

I started the conversation by saying something has to change and drastically or I will be forced to leave you.

I never said she wasn't willing to work the MB program. We both know many of the tools we were taught were helpful. We've both communicated to each other what we needed to get this relationship back on solid ground. I communicated I'd prefer she stop drinking. She negotiated that she change her behaviors and patterns but not quit drinking entirely. That she would be more responsible.

"I don't want to be the wife who is the lush. I don't want you to be embarrassed to be with me.".
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 04:28 PM
Melody,

I don't know if this makes any bit of difference or if you could help me rephrase something to her based on the following statements she's made ....

"I don't think I'm an alcoholic. I don't crave it. I do like to have a few beers to relax. I do know I sometimes drink too much and so I'm thinking it is more of a drinking problem than alcoholism.

I did some research on this and based on what I heard I would like to try something to see if I can control the drinking where it is no longer a problem for you or I."

This is when she communicated that she'd limit her drinking to 2 days and no more than 4 beers on those 2 days.

I get you think I'm not being smart agreeing to this. I explained my thinking best I can.

After we discussed and I agreed to this I added a couple of caveats to it.

1). No more chugging beer. If there isn't enough time to finish the drink it gets left behind.
2). No more trying to get in another drink. If you need to, take my lead. If I'm not having another you shouldn't either.

Posted By: SugarCane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 04:59 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Melody,

I don't know if this makes any bit of difference or if you could help me rephrase something to her based on the following statements she's made ....

"I don't think I'm an alcoholic. I don't crave it. I do like to have a few beers to relax. I do know I sometimes drink too much and so I'm thinking it is more of a drinking problem than alcoholism.

I did some research on this and based on what I heard I would like to try something to see if I can control the drinking where it is no longer a problem for you or I."

This is when she communicated that she'd limit her drinking to 2 days and no more than 4 beers on those 2 days.

I get you think I'm not being smart agreeing to this. I explained my thinking best I can.

After we discussed and I agreed to this I added a couple of caveats to it.

1). No more chugging beer. If there isn't enough time to finish the drink it gets left behind.
2). No more trying to get in another drink. If you need to, take my lead. If I'm not having another you shouldn't either.
MrA, if you've agreed to all this, and it's working, then what is the problem?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 05:25 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Melody,

I don't know if this makes any bit of difference or if you could help me rephrase something to her based on the following statements she's made ....

"I don't think I'm an alcoholic. I don't crave it. I do like to have a few beers to relax. I do know I sometimes drink too much and so I'm thinking it is more of a drinking problem than alcoholism.

I did some research on this and based on what I heard I would like to try something to see if I can control the drinking where it is no longer a problem for you or I."

This is when she communicated that she'd limit her drinking to 2 days and no more than 4 beers on those 2 days.

I get you think I'm not being smart agreeing to this. I explained my thinking best I can.

After we discussed and I agreed to this I added a couple of caveats to it.

1). No more chugging beer. If there isn't enough time to finish the drink it gets left behind.
2). No more trying to get in another drink. If you need to, take my lead. If I'm not having another you shouldn't either.
MrA, if you've agreed to all this, and it's working, then what is the problem?

I'm not sure how to answer that. I've been getting advice from Mel who I know is very knowledgeable about this topic and MB of course.

I know I'm not thrilled that she doesn't want to quit drinking. Even if just for a little while. That is why I stopped in to get some advice/feedback.

I'm thinking she has a definite problem so right now I'm just trying to work out my next steps. I've outlined what my current plan is.

This week I'm talking about it because after we agreed to the intial terms of drinking a little on weekend I was triggered. This weekend she did drink both Fri and Sat after our agreement. She had 2 on Fri and then 3 beers on Sat over a long period time throughout each evening. I was triggered because she had to have another one time and had to try to drink it fast when she simply shouldn't have ordered another. Hence I added a couple more rules to her plan.

Which is all ridiculous or a waste of time if she truly can't control the drinking,
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 05:28 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Melody,

I don't know if this makes any bit of difference or if you could help me rephrase something to her based on the following statements she's made ....

"I don't think I'm an alcoholic. I don't crave it. I do like to have a few beers to relax. I do know I sometimes drink too much and so I'm thinking it is more of a drinking problem than alcoholism.

I did some research on this and based on what I heard I would like to try something to see if I can control the drinking where it is no longer a problem for you or I."

This is when she communicated that she'd limit her drinking to 2 days and no more than 4 beers on those 2 days.

I get you think I'm not being smart agreeing to this. I explained my thinking best I can.

After we discussed and I agreed to this I added a couple of caveats to it.

1). No more chugging beer. If there isn't enough time to finish the drink it gets left behind.
2). No more trying to get in another drink. If you need to, take my lead. If I'm not having another you shouldn't either.
MrA, if you've agreed to all this, and it's working, then what is the problem?

The problem is that she can't stop drinking, so he capitulated with a plan to keep her drinking.

Her next move will be to hide her drinking better.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 05:31 PM
Quote
Her next move will be to hide her drinking better.

That is a fear I have yes. That she will start to hide it if she already hasn't.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 05:42 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Quote
Her next move will be to hide her drinking better.

That is a fear I have yes. That she will start to hide it if she already hasn't.


See, an alcoholic will agree to anything to get her spouse off her back. The fact that she won't/can't give it up indicates she is addicted. She "needs" it to relax. This is why I want you to write Dr. Harley. He once specialized in addictions and can help you with this.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 05:42 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'm not sure how to answer that. I've been getting advice from Mel who I know is very knowledgeable about this topic and MB of course.
Are you following Mel's advice?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 05:52 PM
Not yet.

To date I am still acquiescing to her desire to prove it isn't a drinking problem or alcoholism.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 05:54 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Not yet.

To date I am still acquiescing to her desire to prove it isn't a drinking problem or alcoholism.
So, how can we help?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 05:55 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Not yet.

To date I am still acquiescing to her desire to prove it isn't a drinking problem or alcoholism.

A drinking problem is defined by drinking that causes a problem. That has already been established. That is why we are having this conversation. So playing along with her ploy only serves to give credence to something you know is not true.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 06:13 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Not yet.

To date I am still acquiescing to her desire to prove it isn't a drinking problem or alcoholism.

A drinking problem is defined by drinking that causes a problem. That has already been established. That is why we are having this conversation. So playing along with her ploy only serves to give credence to something you know is not true.

And how do I get her to agree that it is a drinking problem? I can't. I'd hazard to guess that she would argue that point. I know that she doesn't fully incorporate POJA like Dr Harley would recommend we do. Despite the counseling she prefers to pick the parts of the program or levels in which one incorporates the MB program. Remember she doesn't like people telling her what she should do (FYI today's radio show is hitting on this. I'm listening.)

I've already stated I'm pretty certain she has a drinking problem and she can't control it. Your next step is mandate the drinking stop or separate. I'm not prepared to do that just yet.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 06:15 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I've already stated I'm pretty certain she has a drinking problem and she can't control it. Your next step is mandate the drinking stop or separate. I'm not prepared to do that just yet.
Once again, how can we help?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 06:18 PM
I sent her a letter the other day and she took her time but she just now replied.

Here is what she had to say when I asked her to seek professional help so that we could decide whether or not she quit drinking completely.

Quote
I am responding to the letter that you wrote.

First off: You said that you would like me to seek professional help and that you are not happy with the plan that I made.

This is a perfect example of what I was trying to tell you that you do that I would love it if it were changed.
You told me that you did not like my getting drunk and drinking all of the time. I agreed and came up with a plan that I thought that I could do and would meet your request to not drink all of the time and not get drunk.
At first you seemed to agree with it and I was very happy but then you decided that you didn�t like my plan
And thought it should be different because you saw some �red flags�. I am not perfect. I am trying very hard
And thought that I was doing really well. I told you that I would still like to drink because I like to go out and
Have a few but that it would now be just that�.a few. I am sure there will be times that I have more than you
Think I should but remember, I have to want to do this or it will not be successful. Either way if I continue
Like I did last week to not drink during the week and only a few on the weekends I would think that would
Be a big change and feel that you should be ok with that because it gets us both what we want. I know that
You don�t want to drink but that is you, not me. I am also aware that, as I told you, if I can�t keep it under
Control then maybe I will need to seek help but since it has only been a week, and I stuck to the plan that I
Had, I do not think that I need outside help. Changes are not going to happen overnight. This will take time.

Like I said this, is an example of the fact that when you want to make changes you want them done your way or they do not seem to be good enough. I understand your concern that I have a problem, I am working on that problem, and if my way does not work would be willing to consider a different approach. I would love it if that could be good enough. You commented that I was not putting you first if I did not do it your way. I do not think that is fair. I feel that this is putting you first without out me loosing myself in the deal. I enjoy hanging with friends and having a few but I let that get way out of hand and am trying to change that. So far I have been successful but I need your support, not criticism to continue. Isn�t the fact that it has changed for the better the ultimate goal anyway?


You said that you had found your re-attraction and desire to me even though my appearance is not what you would like it to be and now are looking for SF. It has only been a week and I am sorry that I don�t yet feel that we are close enough that this would be an option. Right now it would feel like�.hey I decided that I want this to work, spread em��.i know that sounds crass and that it is your way of feeling close but we have both spend a long time closed off towards each other and I just am not quite ready to take it to the next level. Can we just give all of this some time?

Hopefully you understand what I am trying to say that I need. I am very glad that we are working on this and hope we can find a way to make this work that makes us both happy.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 06:19 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I've already stated I'm pretty certain she has a drinking problem and she can't control it. Your next step is mandate the drinking stop or separate. I'm not prepared to do that just yet.
Once again, how can we help?

You probably can't. But thanks.
Posted By: markos Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 06:43 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
And how do I get her to agree that it is a drinking problem? I can't.

Why do you need to get her to agree that it is a drinking problem, MrA? Is that something MelodyLane, SugarCane, or one of the other excellent posters here recommended to you? Is getting her to agree she has a problem one of the steps in Dr. Harley's marital recovery plan?

You are fixating on something you don't need to do. Notice this, stop doing it, and move on with the plan! Do you have a todo list made yet of the recommendations that have been given to you?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 06:45 PM
You mean pack my bags and separate?

I'm pretty sure that is the list. Mandate that she quit drinking, find counseling and if she says no then it's time to protect myself.

Edited to add:

Prior to making mandates to quit drinking I ask her to go on the radio show.

As you can see I asked her to seek professional help and her reply was "Why? Why is my compromise not good enough for you? It's never good enough.".

Posted By: markos Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 07:14 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
This is why I want you to write Dr. Harley. He once specialized in addictions and can help you with this.
Posted By: markos Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 07:16 PM
Originally Posted by markos
When the wife is not interested in doing Marriage Builders, the husband needs to increase his involvement in Marriage Builders about 1000%. He has to carry the load. He can't be the one who doesn't know what Dr. Harley would recommend a guy do in his situation. He can't be the one not listening to the radio show.
Posted By: markos Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 07:17 PM
Originally Posted by markos
Stay with us this time and become a Marriage Builders full-timer.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 07:34 PM
Email your questions to Joyce Harley at mbradio@marriagebuilders.com. When your email question is chosen to be answered on the radio show, you will be notified by email directing you to listen to the rebroadcast. If you would like to consider being a caller, include your telephone number. You will be called by us to explain the procedure to you. Every caller will receive a complementary book by Dr. Harley that addresses their question.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 08:02 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Not yet.

To date I am still acquiescing to her desire to prove it isn't a drinking problem or alcoholism.

A drinking problem is defined by drinking that causes a problem. That has already been established. That is why we are having this conversation. So playing along with her ploy only serves to give credence to something you know is not true.

And how do I get her to agree that it is a drinking problem? I can't. I'd hazard to guess that she would argue that point. I know that she doesn't fully incorporate POJA like Dr Harley would recommend we do. Despite the counseling she prefers to pick the parts of the program or levels in which one incorporates the MB program. Remember she doesn't like people telling her what she should do (FYI today's radio show is hitting on this. I'm listening.)

I've already stated I'm pretty certain she has a drinking problem and she can't control it. Your next step is mandate the drinking stop or separate. I'm not prepared to do that just yet.

You don't need her to agree she has a drinking problem, you need her to respect your feelings and stop drinking. One of the reasons your marriage has never changed in all these years is because it is impossible to meet the needs of an alcoholic. They will always be checked out of the marriage because their passion lies with alcohol.

And her comment that this will take time is a classic delaying tactic to get the spouse off her back.

Please email Dr Harley with the problem and include your phone # so he can call you.
Posted By: apples123 Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 08:49 PM
Fridays show (1/8/16) covered this
Posted By: apples123 Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/12/16 08:50 PM
Also, they talked about it yesterday too.
Posted By: mrEureka Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/13/16 11:07 AM
You are handling your wife's alcoholism just like my sister in law handled my younger brother's alcoholism. It is a well worn path. She enabled him just like you are now doing. It didn't end until he was dead.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/13/16 12:31 PM
Originally Posted by apples123
Also, they talked about it yesterday too.

Thanks Apples. The Android MB Radio app didn't list the days so so far I haven't been able to listen.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/13/16 12:32 PM
It was a busy day yesterday so I didn't have time to put together an email to the Harleys. I will try to find some time to do so today.

In the meantime I'm trying to decide if I even reply back to my wife. She knows I'm not happy seeing I didn't reply yet.
Posted By: mrEureka Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/13/16 01:18 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by apples123
Also, they talked about it yesterday too.

Thanks Apples. The Android MB Radio app didn't list the days so so far I haven't been able to listen.
What specifically is the issue? Yesterday's show is now playing until 1 PM CST today. If you start listening before 1 PM, the link to that show will persist until your device dismisses the media player. As long as you don't hit the stop button or do so many other things on your phone that the system releases the media player from memory, you can keep listening to the same show for days.

As far as the app not listing the days, I don't understand your comment.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/13/16 01:28 PM
I listened to the first 20 minutes of yesterday's show. They talked about something relevant regarding POJA and people not following through.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/13/16 01:29 PM
Struggling this morning. I let my wife know I wasn't doing well and that I had something to tell her but just can't seem to send it.
Posted By: mrEureka Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/13/16 01:37 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I listened to the first 20 minutes of yesterday's show. They talked about something relevant regarding POJA and people not following through.
Well, keep on listening when you find the time. The app should hold your place as long as you keep listening. Just use the pause button on the scrubber overlay when you need to stop listening for a while, and don't hit stop. You can drag the scrubber to the 20 minute position to resume where you left off.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/13/16 01:45 PM
Thanks Mr. E
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 01/20/16 01:47 PM
Update:

My wife and I have decided, at this time, to not seek professional help or require her to quit drinking completely. I know that goes against the advice I have received here but I have decided to let her try to control the drinking and see where it goes.

We haven't sent anything to Dr. Harley at this time. That is an option I will keep ready should there be any struggles with the plan her and I worked out together.

She's agreed that if she cannot stick to this plan then she'll seek help in dealing with her drinking problem. Based on the research she's done and self-reflection she feels she is an alcohol abuser and not an alcoholic. She wants to follow some advice she's read geared towards those that abuse alcohol.

I'm willing to let her try this her way. If it goes South then more drastic measures will be taken.

Right now she will limit her drinking to Friday and Saturday. We've worked out a very limited amount of drinking and I'm pleased to report she is drinking even less than what we agreed to be an acceptable level.

She won't drink when she's angry, sad and she will never drink more than one drink each hour or so which means the alcohol shouldn't have a large effect in changing her state of mind. Her perception is that she never drinks when she's mad or sad. It's the one red flag that I've seen that, for now, we've agreed to disagree.

She's being very honest on her drinking. Letting me know when she's thinking about having one and letting me know she isn't going to have one because we have an agreement. That shows me she can control the drinking. So far last night is the first night she told me she felt like a glass of wine after dinner.

Meanwhile her and I are hard at work POJA'ing our daily behaviors in an effort to rekindle our love. We've had a couple of nice weeks together, spending a lot of time together doing whatever we can to entertain ourselves. We continue to explore new things to do together.

We're both still exercising and encouraging each other to drop the 15 pounds or so that we'd both love to lose. So far I'm down 9 pounds, with 15 more as my goal. She's down 5 or 6.

No SF at this point. She's hoping those feelings come back the more we continue down this path.

I'm sorry I didn't follow the advice given. I'm hopeful that my wife has self-diagnosed herself properly. If she hasn't then we have an agreement to take the next step.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 02/02/16 02:32 PM
Quick Update:

So far so good. She's been sticking to her plan and although she's struggled a little denying herself she's kept it up.

Meanwhile her and I have been a lot more in tune, are really enjoying each other's company and being back in love with each other.

Saturday night we had a bunch of folks over after our DD's softball game and we kept the drinking to almost nil and had a really nice time. The next day she commented several times how much fun she had.

So far ... thumbs up.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: Came back to take some medicine - 02/02/16 03:51 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Quick Update:

So far so good. She's been sticking to her plan and although she's struggled a little denying herself she's kept it up.

Meanwhile her and I have been a lot more in tune, are really enjoying each other's company and being back in love with each other.

Saturday night we had a bunch of folks over after our DD's softball game and we kept the drinking to almost nil and had a really nice time. The next day she commented several times how much fun she had.

So far ... thumbs up.
So how much is she drinking?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 02/05/16 03:00 PM
Last weekend she had one beer at a dinner with friends, one more later when her and I were home watching a show together.

Saturday after our DD's game we had about a dozen people to our house for pizza and drinks. She had 1 beer while they were there and then one more after they left.

So far that's been the norm. Friday and Saturday somewhere around 4 or 5 drinks total.

We spoke on Sunday and we both commented how much fun we had. She communicated a revelation that she didn't miss drinking a lot while others drank and had a lot of fun because she wasn't missing it.

Seeing that is going so well her and I have been focusing on our MB principals almost out of habit. Right? We're back to where we were when Jennifer helped us get on a good path.

It's pretty cool. Right now I am extremely happy.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Came back to take some medicine - 02/05/16 03:50 PM
That's great!
Posted By: Glorya Re: Came back to take some medicine - 02/11/16 06:41 PM
Mr Alias, I am sorry you are going through this, and I think MelodyLane is correct, even if she isn't an alcoholic it's a problem for your marriage so she needs to stop.

That being said, if she is addicted this will take a lot of patience and support on your part to get her in and through recovery if she is willing.

I agree with what Dr. Harley says about it here when trying to tell if the spouse is addicted:

"Dear G.B.,

Alcohol addiction can sneak up on a person. It's an addictive substance, which means that if you drink enough of it, you will develop a physical and emotional need for it. Even you could become an alcoholic if you got into the habit of drinking regularly. Who knows, maybe you are already an alcoholic and don't even know it.

A good test of whether or not you are an alcoholic is to ask yourself, am I willing to stop drinking entirely if it would make my spouse feel more comfortable? If total abstinence from drinking would be very difficult if not impossible for you, even if it made your wife more comfortable, you're an alcoholic. Alcohol, in that case, would be more important to you than your wife's feelings.

My test for alcohol addiction is simply an application of the Policy of Joint Agreement. In every marriage, spouses should avoid gaining at each other's expense, and the policy is followed, thoughtless behavior is eliminated. But when something is so important to a spouse that it prevents him or her from following it, whatever is that important will ruin the marriage."

http://www.marriagebuilders.com/graphic/mbi5048b_qa.html

I myself have just recently recovered from alcohol addiction and I can tell you that nothing else mattered to me but alcohol, even when I was successfully moderating at 2 or 3 drinks a day 3 times a week. It was still active addiction. Nothing can be resolved until the alcohol is out of the way, the addiction makes healing impossible since all an addicts energy goes to feeding the addiction.

Now that I don't have alcohol, my spouse and I have a lot to work on with both of us, as I was ignoring many problems and just drinking them away. My giving up alcohol has revealed many problems I have with my spouse that I was willing to ignore before, and we fight much of the time for now. Many people with addiction problems can not cope or quit without professional help, counseling, therapy, group therapy, etc. Addiction is hard to overcome, and effects both of you, I personally would not try to do this without professional help.
Blessings and best wishes to you.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 02/16/16 01:31 PM
Glorya,

Thank you very much for sharing your personal story.

I am prepared to get the professionals involved should this drinking become problematic again. For now she seems to be doing quite well just maintaining her current plan. We are being very open and honest about the drinking right now whereas before we tended to only deal with it after she had a night of getting way too drunk.

I'm willing to maintain this status quo so long as it doesn't progress. We have already had a conversation about this and I continue to let her know if I get triggered by something I see in her drinking.

I am being alert to her drinking. Not so alert that I'm obsessing but I pay attention enough. I will not go back to the way things were and she's fully aware I'm willing to separate if the drinking becomes a problem again.

Right now we're doing really well. I'm obsessing about my wife again which is a really nice feeling; especially after being withdrawn for years.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Came back to take some medicine - 02/16/16 01:37 PM
We just had the nicest Valentine's day that we have ever had!!!!

Spent most of the evening with the family doing some fun little events and having some nice food which I coordinated. I can't remember the last time her and I kissed passionately in front of the kids. "cover your eyes kids.".

Everyone had a great time and everyone thanked me over and over for planning and taking care of the fun night.

Then later her and I had a lot of "us' time.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Celebration! - 09/23/16 01:39 PM
We're celebrating our 27 year anniversary today !!!!!
dance2
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Celebration! - 09/23/16 02:32 PM
Congratulations!!!
Posted By: Prisca Re: Celebration! - 09/23/16 03:48 PM
hurray
Posted By: markos Re: Celebration! - 09/23/16 04:34 PM
Congratulations, Mr and Mrs A. smile
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: Celebration! - 09/23/16 05:59 PM
Congratulations dance2
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Celebration! - 12/05/16 02:49 PM
Hello good people of the forum,

I'm sorry to say that things have taken a bit of a turn for the worst in our home. Despite my wife's honest attempts to control her drinking, in the last couple of months, she has started to slide back into some her bad habits. Drinking more, drinking faster and more frequently.

I told her I can't live like this anymore. That her drinking is ruining it for me, That I'm triggered every time I see her drink.

I've informed her that I see the only solution to resolve this would be for her to commit to stop drinking entirely.

Outside of me communicating that to her, getting myself to Al-Anon, is there anything else I could be doing? Is it recommended to get others involved or, at least, communicate to some of the important ones that her drinking has become a problem?
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Celebration! - 12/05/16 03:52 PM
Have you read Dr Harley's Q&A articles on alcohol abuse?
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 03:57 PM
PS: I thought this thread title needed a change. I'm sorry about what's happening.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 04:01 PM
You started this thread in 2011 with the title "Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately." You've used a version of that title at least once more, and here you are again today.

It's time to start doing something different, unless you want to accept that your marriage will always be...unfortunate.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 05:44 PM
Thanks SC.

I totally agree with doing something different. I'm stuck in this mode of asking her to make changes and her defending her position, putting things back on me, deflecting, or what have you.

Reading Dr Harley's stance on addiction makes perfect sense to me.

I've asked her again the last couple of days to quit drinking for us and she skirts around the issue. Stating she can control her drinking and states she proved it to me this weekend (ahem) by only having one beer Friday and then a few beers with friends Saturday afternoon but didn't drink once she came home.

She hasn't came right out and said it but I don't think she's going to quit drinking. I haven't even asked about getting her some help because I don't think she's ready to admit she needs it. Nothing new here of course if she's an alcoholic.
So, the only thing I can think of doing differently is to separate. It's a huge step and admittedly one I am terrified to take.

However the drinking causes me to withdraw from her so I'm prone to do something to make this dynamic change.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 05:58 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Thanks SC.

I totally agree with doing something different. I'm stuck in this mode of asking her to make changes and her defending her position, putting things back on me, deflecting, or what have you.

Reading Dr Harley's stance on addiction makes perfect sense to me.

I've asked her again the last couple of days to quit drinking for us and she skirts around the issue. Stating she can control her drinking and states she proved it to me this weekend (ahem) by only having one beer Friday and then a few beers with friends Saturday afternoon but didn't drink once she came home.

She hasn't came right out and said it but I don't think she's going to quit drinking. I haven't even asked about getting her some help because I don't think she's ready to admit she needs it. Nothing new here of course if she's an alcoholic.
So, the only thing I can think of doing differently is to separate. It's a huge step and admittedly one I am terrified to take.

However the drinking causes me to withdraw from her so I'm prone to do something to make this dynamic change.
Did you read Dr Harley's suggestion of an intervention?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 06:52 PM
I haven't read that. If there is more to his words if you could point me there I appreciate it.

At this point I don't know who's support I would have for conducting an intervention. My kids don't seem to be negatively impacted by her drinking in "their" eyes. (I don't like the message it sends to them). I suspect they'll be upset and surprised if I tell them we need an intervention.

Her sister continues to live her IB lifestyle with her alcoholic husband. Her father drank everyday and her mother sort of enabled it. The only family on my side that I would asked to support me would be my sister and H but my Sis is going through Chemo for the next 5 months so I wouldn't want to ask her. I have friends that would support me but they wouldn't be able to influence her. Her friends are friends she drinks with.

We live hours away from any family.

She just now stated if I insist she will quit drinking for a couple of months but not until after the Holidays.

Despite my desire to have an MB marriage I really don't have one. She isn't truly on board and dismisses a lot of the principles (UA, IB).
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 07:11 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I haven't read that. If there is more to his words if you could point me there I appreciate it.
In Letter no.2, which I linked above:

"Sometimes those who love and care for someone addicted to alcohol get together to encourage him or her to admit themselves to treatment. It's called an intervention. Your wife's alcoholic behavior is described to her by each person in the group who has witnessed it, and a treatment program that you have already investigated is ready to admit her immediately.

Your local chapter of Alcoholics Anonymous can help you learn what it is and organize one for you. If your wife has a mother and three siblings who are alcoholic, at least one of them may have already been exposed to an intervention, and may be willing to help you with it.

The down-side of an intervention can be resentment. Alcoholics often feel that the very ones who have cared for them the most are ganging up on them. They often agree to go to treatment, not because they think they need it, but because of the threats made by their friends. When the treatment has ended, they no longer feel that they can trust their friends.

In your case, you may be able to encourage your wife to enter treatment without making any threats. And during treatment you may be able to prove to her that you care about her as much as ever. If it's done right, when treatment is over, she will have a better relationship with those who joined the intervention than she had with them before it happened.

Since your wife became addicted to alcohol, it has become her lover, and you will not be able to compete with it. Her need for alcohol will override all of her other interests, including you and your children. When you suggested to her that she slow down on her drinking, she became angry with you, because she needs it so badly.

She does not want to believe that her drinking is a problem, and short of an intervention, you may not be able to convince her. Your efforts will only make her angry, and she may try to find someone else who will support her dependency. An intervention has proven to be one of the best and most effective ways of delivering help, and it may be your only reasonable option."
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 07:12 PM
Have you ever written to Dr Harley about this specific thing? Remember, he used to run a chain of addiction clinics.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 08:29 PM
I haven't written to him yet. I will do so here shortly.

Sorry I'm at work and didn't click into the links you provided above. I will find some time to read through everything in those links tonight.

Here is something that I am struggling with.

I thought it was clear to me; follow MB and the POJA. If either of us doing something that bothers the other bring it out in the open to help resolve it. I have told her my thoughts. I think she has more than a drinking problem, that she is addicted. She communicates she doesn't think so merely just a drinking problem so I avoid the argument or pressing her on it. Instead I've spent my time making the point that her use of alcohol is a problem for me and thus it's a problem for the marriage. I've encouraged her to stop drinking.

I'm no expert on alcoholism. I'm only stating what I feel in my gut regarding her use of booze. Therefore I tiptoe around the addiction issue. I don't know if I have enough to prove to anyone that she has more than a drinking problem. That it's possible she's careless, at times, with her drinking but could, in fact, live without it. I simply am unsure. So any talk of an intervention causes me pause.

Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 09:13 PM
I don't know that there is any difference between "a drinking problem" and alcoholism. She can't and won't stop. She doesn't have to be drinking herself into the gutter each night for her to be an alcoholic.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 09:49 PM
She read something that said there is a difference. She showed me the articles. Said she wanted the opportunity to prove it to herself that that's all it is. Not that a drinking problem is any small thing mind you.

Her finding that only reaffirms her belief she isn't an alcoholic.
Posted By: Prisca Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 10:27 PM
Six of one, half a dozen of the other. Who cares what you or she calls it. It must end, regardless. If she won't end it herself, then she needs an intervention. Tiptoeing around the issue is not helping her or your marriage. Arguing over whether she has a drinking problem or is an alcoholic is simply conflict avoidance.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 11:15 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She read something that said there is a difference. She showed me the articles. Said she wanted the opportunity to prove it to herself that that's all it is. Not that a drinking problem is any small thing mind you.

Her finding that only reaffirms her belief she isn't an alcoholic.

I don't Understand why you allow yourself to get roped into these lunatic discussions about definitions. What difference does it make? It is cute and winsome to split hairs but at the end of the day it is [censored]. The bottom line is it is ruining your marriage do that is all the reason she needs to quit.

If she won't quit, that is proof positive she is addicted. You have a tendency to have the same problems for years on end. In fact we have already addressed this very ploy with you years ago. AND HERE WE ARE AGAIN.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/05/16 11:17 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She read something that said there is a difference. She showed me the articles. Said she wanted the opportunity to prove it to herself that that's all it is. Not that a drinking problem is any small thing mind you.

Her finding that only reaffirms her belief she isn't an alcoholic.

Then she should have no issue quitting, should she? It should be no more troublesome than giving up Cheerios.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 02:43 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
If she won't quit, that is proof positive she is addicted. You have a tendency to have the same problems for years on end. In fact we have already addressed this very ploy with you years ago. AND HERE WE ARE AGAIN.

Yes, you have Mel. I won't apologize, of course. That would be lame. I appreciate your being candid with me. It's a huge help.

Here is the latest I've stated to her. I'm waiting to see what she says.

Quote
Here is what I know. Last fall I had had enough of having to deal with the drinking. Our relationship was shaky at best. New Year�s Eve was the straw that broke the camel�s back. I reluctantly agreed to your plan to let you test the waters on this concept of alcohol abuse. I continued to communicate then and I do now that this is more than alcohol abuse. That you simply cannot live without alcohol. It appears you won't live without it.

We are in two different places. You have a habit that causes me grief and argue with me constantly about giving it up. It�s so important to you that you hardly give quitting a thought. I push because I love you and want to be with you. Your response back sounds like nothing more than a favor to me: If it means that much I will quit drinking for a couple months. Don�t do me any favors. If you don�t think you have a problem and need to quit drinking then don�t. If it is that important to you then do whatever it is that makes you happy. I will figure out what I want and need and act accordingly. However, you need to know I need you to get this fixed or we can�t be together.

Mel I suspect your advice to me hasn't changed. If she won't quit drinking then I should separate.

I hear you. I also know I'm chicken-sh** and would rather I fight with her to get her to change. I don't want to have to defend myself against all the enablers in her family that will ask me what's so bad that I needed to separate.

I've contemplated reaching out to her sister for support. She doesn't drink yet lives with her alcoholic H who continues to drink. If I do that she will, of course, immediately tell my W that we talked. I wish I had a guarantee she'd support me. I don't know if she become friend or foe in my attempts to intervene on my W's drinking habits.

Which leads me back to thinking I'd simply just have to separate. When to call it quits when you're a capitulator and procrastinator?
Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 03:08 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Your response back sounds like nothing more than a favor to me: If it means that much I will quit drinking for a couple months. Don�t do me any favors. If you don�t think you have a problem and need to quit drinking then don�t. If it is that important to you then do whatever it is that makes you happy. I will figure out what I want and need and act accordingly.

You just asked her to not MB you. This is the opposite of purposefully stopping love busters because they bother the other person.

This ended with your threat of independent behavior.

Why are you sabotaging her offer to stop drinking?

If she wants to resume in the future, you can again request not. In the meantime you can plan A so she has something to lose if she does.

Threatening to separate is a huge lovebuster. It destabilizes the other person tremendously and disincents them to care about the marriage.

It is much better to simply separate if the drinking resumes.

Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 03:18 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I don't want to have to defend myself against all the enablers in her family that will ask me what's so bad that I needed to separate.

I've contemplated reaching out to her sister for support. She doesn't drink yet lives with her alcoholic H who continues to drink. If I do that she will, of course, immediately tell my W that we talked. I wish I had a guarantee she'd support me. I don't know if she become friend or foe in my attempts to intervene on my W's drinking habits.

This is way too many people running your marriage based on your hypothetical speculations.

Mr. Alias, you gave me some really good advice when I was going through my difficult times. It seems like you (like me and everyone else) often can't see as clearly into our own situation as we can into others'.

You would do better to focus on your problem (requesting your wife to agree to stop drinking because it's a lovebuster) and not care what the crowds say. They aren't married to your wife, you are.

If your wife, during her voluntary time of not drinking, resumes because she is too addicted not to, then deal with that. For now, take her offer as a start and give her the opportunity to show you she is not addicted.


Edited to add: Supposing she is successful, there will be a time in the future that she wants to discuss resuming. You can continue to request not if at that time it is still a lovebuster. Here again, if she disregards you and displays an addiction then you have choices to make at that time. Expressing a threat to separate shouldn't be one of them.

Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 03:28 PM
Have you read the Q&A columns that I linked yet?

Have you written to Dr Harley yet?
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 03:34 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She read something that said there is a difference. She showed me the articles. Said she wanted the opportunity to prove it to herself that that's all it is. Not that a drinking problem is any small thing mind you.

Her finding that only reaffirms her belief she isn't an alcoholic.
Your wife is an alcoholic.

She fits this definition by Dr Harley:

"Some people wonder if they are really alcoholics. They may not go to bars, and they may not even get drunk very often. What is an alcoholic? My definition of an alcoholic is someone who cannot follow the Policy of Joint Agreement because of their craving for alcohol. If your drinking in any form bothers your spouse, and you cannot or will not give it up for his or her sake, I consider you an alcoholic because alcohol is more important to you than the feelings of your spouse."

What to do with an alcoholic spouse: Letter no.1
Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 03:59 PM
Per Dr. Harley: "Some people wonder if they are really alcoholics. They may not go to bars, and they may not even get drunk very often. What is an alcoholic? My definition of an alcoholic is someone who cannot follow the Policy of Joint Agreement because of their craving for alcohol. If your drinking in any form bothers your spouse, and you cannot or will not give it up for his or her sake, I consider you an alcoholic because alcohol is more important to you than the feelings of your spouse."

She just agreed to give it up for several months. This is different from her prior agreement to only cut it back (which still ended up with lovebusting situations).

I think Dr. Harley would advise you to support her in her decision to give it up, Plan A her in the meanwhile and prepare for separation (without threatening her about it) in the event she reverts back to drinking in disregard to your feelings.

When you hear back from him, let us know what he says.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 04:22 PM
I don't know that this fixes the problem Sunny. She already put stipulations on it. Please not until after the Holidays. I believe she may have the fortitude to not drink for a couple months (she didn't say a few) where she will then simply resume drinking. If she makes it through that she'll state that that proves her point that she's not an alcoholic.

I agree it probably would have been best to just separate instead of letting her know that's my plan. Doesn't mean I can't still separate if she doesn't stop.

I brought back out our discussion (her plan) we had early this year. In her plan she said if she struggled to follow the plan she'd seek help. I'm holding her to her promise.

SC I haven't written to Dr Harley but I intend to as soon as I have some spare time. I've slated some time tomorrow to do that.
Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 04:57 PM
If waiting until after the holidays doesn't work with you, then continue to POJA based on what bothers or hurts you.

Did she state that she was done POJA'ing the issue and that you could take a hike? "please not until after the holidays" sounds like she's still engaging.

You can respond that it hurts you too much now, and that waiting until after the holidays will be too painful.

Based on your recounting of the conversations, you haven't pursued the negotiation to the end, where she chooses the alcohol over you. You fear she will based on her past behaviors, but she hasn't done so yet.

All of those behaviors were prior to your raising the bar to no more alcohol at all. The bar of cutting back on the alcohol was not high enough since her version of "cutting back" is still LBing you.





Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 05:09 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I agree it probably would have been best to just separate instead of letting her know that's my plan threatening her.

Understatement of the year.

If someone's being threatened, they naturally close themselves off to the threat in self defense instead of opening towards you to resolve the problem. You achieved the opposite of what you were hoping for. You became a threat instead of part of the solution.

There is a lot of underlying wisdom in Dr. Harley's experiential advice. If you can act on it before you 'treat' yourself to the experience you'll save yourself a lot of grief.

Dr. Harley says to never threaten separation prior to actually doing it. From receiving these threats from my xH, I can tell you that they were a large factor in destroying my love for him due to instinctive self preservation.


Posted By: SusieQ Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 06:03 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
SC I haven't written to Dr Harley but I intend to as soon as I have some spare time. I've slated some time tomorrow to do that.

I think what you wrote in your first post is fine to use and will save you time:

"I'm sorry to say that things have taken a bit of a turn for the worst in our home. Despite my wife's honest attempts to control her drinking, in the last couple of months, she has started to slide back into some her bad habits. Drinking more, drinking faster and more frequently.

I told her I can't live like this anymore. That her drinking is ruining it for me, That I'm triggered every time I see her drink.

I've informed her that I see the only solution to resolve this would be for her to commit to stop drinking entirely.

Outside of me communicating that to her, getting myself to Al-Anon, is there anything else I could be doing? Is it recommended to get others involved or, at least, communicate to some of the important ones that her drinking has become a problem?"
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 06:21 PM
This post, from January 2016, is also useful, as it gives a bit of history:

Originally Posted by MrAlias
Hello MB friends, it has been a long time since I've posted. It's good to see familiar posters still here, Mel, Marko, Brain.

I must be a masochist as I continue to come back here with the same and/or similar story every time. I read my posts from several years ago and I sound like a broken record. Much of the same BS has been going on since my last posts here.

I'm no longer in love with my W, haven't been for a long time, but have simply been co-habitating. The MB counseling and our efforts were only a temporary thing. Something she put minimal effort into. I failed to push the issue.

Same thing that happened a few years ago the same neighbor came down without his wife and my wife (who has been getting zero attention/affection from me) spent the night flirting with him. Can't say I blame her desire to have some attention but just shows how idiotic I've been to think I could co-habitate with her.

Problem #1 is her drinking. I'm quite certain she's an alcoholic. Drinks nearly every day and does dumb stuff when she's intoxicated.

I am so uncertain what to do anymore. I had a long talk with her on New Years and told her things needed to change drastically or I was going to leave her. She apologized for her actions on that drunken night. Said it would never happen again. Sorry honey but I've heard that before.

I told her if she really was serious about saving this marriage there were definitive things that would have change.

No more drinking. She's squaking at that but she's stopped ... for now.

To help I've tried to throw myself back into the program and do all the work that Jennifer and my experience has taught me. This is really it, the last time you'll hear me say I'm trying one more time. I've spent the last 2 years being extremely withdrawn and unhappy. I have better things to do with my life then spend it miserable.

Trouble is my W doesn't throw all in with the MB program. I know the right thing to do is give her the mandate that we follow it to the letter or it won't work. I don't know, maybe I have my answer and shouldn't even bother giving it one more go.

Not sure I should even be pushing the MB program right now. She needs my support if we're to get through this but I think her abuse of alcohol has to be addressed before anything. It is difficult to be supportive when you're withdrawn.
I'd forgotten that you coached with Jennifer Chalmers for a while. I think that gives an important context; it shows that you have been working hard on the marriage for years, but that your wife's alcoholism prevents her from using POJA, or anything else from MB.

You need to let Dr Harley know that you have been trying to use MB in your marriage since you first posted here (when was that?), that you have coached with Jennifer, and that only in January this year did you tell the forum the full extent of your wife's drinking. Having taken our advice, you have tried to get her to stop. She would only agree to cutting down, but after nearly a year, it is clear that this has not worked. She is now offering to stop for two months, starting after Christmas. Should you take her up on that offer, and what else could you do? Is an intervention in order? Should you separate if she won't stop?
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 06:31 PM
I believe that Dr Harley tends to offer different solutions to marital crises, depending on whether the husband is the victim, or the wife.

With wives, he tends to insist on a hard line, straight away. With an affair: Plan A for 3 weeks only, unless the husband is carrying on the affair in front of your face, in which case, kick him out today. With domestic violence: leave today, before he kills you. With OCD, the husband needs to not inflict his tendencies on his wife. She should not deal with them. He needs to use therapeutic methods, right now.

The Q&As about drinking are similar: the first one, with the alcoholic husband, stresses the need for separation, but the second one, with the alcoholic wife, suggests more patience, in the form of an intervention. It could be that with alcohol, as with other issues, Dr Harley recommends men to be more protective towards their wives, and not simply to abandon them until they come around. That is what he tends to tell women to do.

What I don't know, from those letters, is whether, and at what point, Dr H would tell a husband to separate from an alcoholic wife. I assume he would not want you to go on protecting her forever. That's why I think he needs to know about how long you have been trying to improve your marriage using MB, and for how long alcohol has been her first love (I presume for the same years that your marriage has been in crisis).
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 08:20 PM
Thanks everyone. I did find some free time this afternoon (cancelled a meeting to make the time) and sent an email to Joyce and Dr Harley.

SC I did mention that we counseled with Jennifer but I didn't really cast blame on her alcohol being the reason we can't POJA or implement his program. We do agree on most everything and she did approach this drinking situation as a negotiation. That was a bad idea on my part and I knew it was at the time but thought I'd give it a shot anyway.

The MB program hasn't worked for us for several reasons. As you can tell I sometimes struggle doing the right thing in the moment. Even when I give my communications to her with some fore-thought I do things that Dr Harley and you fine folks say "Don't do". I accepted a half effort on her part to implement the program as progress thinking we'd get there eventually.

The other reason is she doesn't believe in all of the principles. She doesn't believe it's imperative to eliminate time away (she has horses 1.5 hours away) or schedule UA time (we don't get enough UA time in ... no where near enough). We don't have a lot in common and despite some effort still don't have a lot we like to do together. Go out to eat, movies, watch our kid's sporting events. Most things that don't qualify for UA time.

Mel once told me I should just take her shopping ... well I hate shopping. Shopping means spending money we don't have and bringing more junk into our home that I don't want lying around. Our office/den looks sort of like a hoarder's room. Crap lying around in our bedroom, an ugly plastic dresser thingy to house her out-of-season wear in because everything else is packed tight with stuff. I've asked nicely for years that this be addressed but it's still there.

Anyways, that's getting off topic.

I'm looking forward to what Dr Harley says.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: anti-Celebration - 12/06/16 10:33 PM
Let us know what Dr. Harley says.
Posted By: HoldHerHand Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:46 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Mel once told me I should just take her shopping ... well I hate shopping. Shopping means spending money we don't have and bringing more junk into our home that I don't want lying around. Our office/den looks sort of like a hoarder's room. Crap lying around in our bedroom, an ugly plastic dresser thingy to house her out-of-season wear in because everything else is packed tight with stuff. I've asked nicely for years that this be addressed but it's still there.

Don't let this bit discourage you, though.

This is more of a symptom than a problem. And it's the symptom of an empty Love Bank r/t a neglected marriage.

You definitely have bigger hurdles to cross, but this little bit here is something that gets solved here all the time.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 01:57 PM
Thanks Hold.

Actually it is more a problem or it's indicative of the problem. I've always struggled to get my W on board with the MB concepts. Even after meeting with Dr Chalmers and reading all of the materials in HNHN, LBs and FILSIL she still maintains a wish to pick the parts she thinks are needed and dismisses the ones she disagrees with. For instance she doesn't believe in the UA requirement despite it being obvious to me that that's the piece that's missing from our R. We need more RC and UA time. There are things she likes I don't and vice versa. So we spend a lot of time just doing our own things ... not bonding, building our love for each other.

I always feel stuck between a rock and a hard place. I believe in Dr Harley's principles. 100%. She doesn't. I say I believe in them 100% but I, myself, have been less than effective in my part (for whatever reason) in implementing them and sticking to them.

I haven't given up though. I remind her consistently (not incessantly) that I have a desire for us to do more fun things together, to find more alone time. She doesn't resist, we banter ideas around all the time, never really coming up with much of anything.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 02:01 PM
I was sure to connect with my W yesterday. That, although I threw something out there that was threatening, I am still very much in love with her and want to make our M work. Instead of being silent I was sure to reach out to her to talk about every day things. When we were together (which was briefly) I asked for a hug and looked in her the eyes with a soft heart. Told her I loved her last night, this morning before I left like I always do.

I want her to know I'm on her side, on the side of our M and that she has something great here that's worth fighting for.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 02:41 PM
How did she respond?

Posted By: Prisca Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 03:43 PM
Quote
I've always struggled to get my W on board with the MB concepts. Even after meeting with Dr Chalmers and reading all of the materials in HNHN, LBs and FILSIL she still maintains a wish to pick the parts she thinks are needed and dismisses the ones she disagrees with. For instance she doesn't believe in the UA requirement despite it being obvious to me that that's the piece that's missing from our R. We need more RC and UA time. There are things she likes I don't and vice versa. So we spend a lot of time just doing our own things ... not bonding, building our love for each other.
This can be solved once she gives up alcohol.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 05:13 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
How did she respond?

She reciprocated. Hugged me back, said she loved me too. Again we're very civil to each other. No hostility. Definitely some tension.

I think I can sense that she loves me. We talk a lot as if there aren't these conflicts and tensions.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 05:15 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
I've always struggled to get my W on board with the MB concepts. Even after meeting with Dr Chalmers and reading all of the materials in HNHN, LBs and FILSIL she still maintains a wish to pick the parts she thinks are needed and dismisses the ones she disagrees with. For instance she doesn't believe in the UA requirement despite it being obvious to me that that's the piece that's missing from our R. We need more RC and UA time. There are things she likes I don't and vice versa. So we spend a lot of time just doing our own things ... not bonding, building our love for each other.
This can be solved once she gives up alcohol.

I agree. First things first.

The drinking causes me to lose my love for her. Big time. Until that is resolved it will be very difficult for me to focus on trying to fix other areas of our M.

We do still POJA most other matters. We still continue to discuss things we can do to have more time and fun together. We just don't agree on the drinking.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 05:43 PM
Update:

I just heard from Dr Harley.

To summarize his advice:

The solution is to quit drinking entirely. Controlled drinking doesn't work. (I agree).
Find a good treatment program that won't ruin our marriage. (Good to know)
Some reading for me on Codependency. (I believe I've read it before. I will read it again).
Does not recommend separating but I may want to consider an intervention that involve my kids. (Definitely a possibility).

I will reach back out to him but I'll ask here too.

Would the first step be to have the intervention? If so what does that look like? Do the kids and I just do that or do we hire someone who can facilitate the process?

An intervention frightens me. I know her. I know she will be very angry. May never forgive me.

With that said would it be more logical to first suggest she seek professional help? I will be sure to help facilitate that should she agree.
Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 06:00 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
An intervention frightens me. I know her. I know she will be very angry. May never forgive me.

I would complete your POJA about stopping drinking now before considering this. If she agrees to stop, no need for an intervention UNTIL she quits stopping.

If she won't agree to stop, then it would also be time to consider it.
Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 06:09 PM
In your final POJA approach, I'd be very careful to be humble, affirming of your love for her both in words and affection - to sell her on your care and desire for her.

Think ahead of any SDs that might pop out of your mouth ahead of time and purposefully plan to not engage them.

Since you've indicated you're a Christian, another thing you might want to consider is to pray beforehand for wisdom in your words (James 1:5). And also to keep yourself from pride.

However, you do need to stop avoiding this conversation with her. You are spending a lot of energy thinking about and being affected by her lovebuster instead of handling it. This is only depleting your account and is not helping your marriage.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 06:27 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Update:

I just heard from Dr Harley.

To summarize his advice:

The solution is to quit drinking entirely. Controlled drinking doesn't work. (I agree).
Find a good treatment program that won't ruin our marriage. (Good to know)
Some reading for me on Codependency. (I believe I've read it before. I will read it again).
Does not recommend separating but I may want to consider an intervention that involve my kids. (Definitely a possibility).

I will reach back out to him but I'll ask here too.

Would the first step be to have the intervention? If so what does that look like? Do the kids and I just do that or do we hire someone who can facilitate the process?

An intervention frightens me. I know her. I know she will be very angry. May never forgive me.

With that said would it be more logical to first suggest she seek professional help? I will be sure to help facilitate that should she agree.
You only gave us notes from what Dr Harley said, and you did not tell us what you asked. It's much better for us to see the full question and answer. However, based on the notes you provided, this is the order of battle:

1. See what single-sex treatment programmes are available in your area. Is there a single-sex AA centre nearby? Talk to them about what help they can offer your wife.

2. Armed with that knowledge, ask your wife to stop drinking altogether; not just for two months, and starting right now, not after the holidays. Tell her about the support she will receive from the local AA.

3. If she refuses, or tries to negotiate starting after the holidays, or giving up for only two months, get your kids involved in the intervention. In fact, you could tell your kids right now that their mother is an alcoholic and you intend asking her to stop drinking altogether, and you might need their help with this later.

4. If she refuses, and the intervention does not help, write to Dr Harley again.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 06:35 PM
MRAlias, I just want to ask you to take a more proactive approach towards the problem. I notice Dr Harley gave you is the same advice I gave you about her drinking a long time ago. I told you that controlled drinking does not work yet it was suggested AGAIN yesterday on this thread. It is only an exercise in kicking the can down the road. And here we are.....down the road.

I am not trying to beat you up, only to point out that kicking the can down the road always results in YEARS of dealing with the same problem. I hope you follow his advice to the letter.
Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 06:43 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
In fact, you could tell your kids right now that their mother is an alcoholic and you intend asking her to stop drinking altogether, and you might need their help with this later.

Sugar Cane is really awesome, but I would disagree with telling the children this until after she has refused to quite or until after she has stopped quitting.

This could be an enormous lovebuster which could cloud her desire to work with him on his objective. I also don't think it is a just action to take prior to concluding his own conversations with her.

The reason he has not concluded his conversations is because he is avoiding conflict. Involving the kids in the mess of his own creating before he cleans it up doesn't seem fair to her at all.

My exH tried an "intervention" on me for unjust reasons and I literally hated him for it every time I remembered it. Scalding, burning hatred.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 06:48 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
I would complete your POJA about stopping drinking now before considering this. If she agrees to stop, no need for an intervention UNTIL she quits stopping.

If she won't agree to stop, then it would also be time to consider it.
You realise that we shouldn't POJA health and safety issues, don't you?
Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 06:52 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
I would complete your POJA about stopping drinking now before considering this. If she agrees to stop, no need for an intervention UNTIL she quits stopping.

If she won't agree to stop, then it would also be time to consider it.
You realise that we shouldn't POJA health and safety issues, don't you?

Yes, but he hasn't finished his task of asking her to stop yet.

If she refuses to stop, or stops stopping, then it becomes a health and safety issue.

I would not agree this issue has crossed the threshold of health and safety until one of those things happened.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 06:52 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
Originally Posted by SugarCane
In fact, you could tell your kids right now that their mother is an alcoholic and you intend asking her to stop drinking altogether, and you might need their help with this later.

Sugar Cane is really awesome, but I would disagree with telling the children this until after she has refused to quite or until after she has stopped quitting.

This could be an enormous lovebuster which could cloud her desire to work with him on his objective. I also don't think it is a just action to take prior to concluding his own conversations with her.

The reason he has not concluded his conversations is because he is avoiding conflict. Involving the kids in the mess of his own creating before he cleans it up doesn't seem fair to her at all.

My exH tried an "intervention" on me for unjust reasons and I literally hated him for it every time I remembered it. Scalding, burning hatred.
You're injecting a great deal of your own feelings into the advice you're giving here. I am simply trying to follow Dr Harley's advice as he wrote it. I would say that today, you have responded to what Dr Harley told MrAlias by pretty much telling MrAlias not to do what he said.

You seem to be against the intervention partly because your ex used one on you for unjustified reasons.

This is not an unjustified reason.

MrAlias's wife is an alcoholic, and Dr Harley has told Mr A to shoot for a complete and permanent cessation of drinking, and also, to consider an intervention.

Please don't try to put him off doing an intervention because you didn't like it when it was done unjustly to you.
Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 06:59 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Dr Harley has told Mr A to shoot for a complete and permanent cessation of drinking

I agree with your positions, except that by Mr A's description he hasn't done this yet.

He left it at her wanting to stop drinking after the holidays. He never came back to tell her that wouldn't work for him. He owes her that before an intervention.





Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:03 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
Yes, but he hasn't finished his task of asking her to stop yet.

If she refuses to stop, or stops stopping, then it becomes a health and safety issue.

I would not agree this issue has crossed the threshold of health and safety until one of those things happened.
She is already an alcoholic, and MrAlias has already asked her to stop drinking. and she has already refused. She has bamboozled (pardon the pun) him with arguments about "controlled drinking", and about her not being an alcoholic, but perhaps only a problem drinker. She has not managed to control her "controlled drinking", and when he recently asked her to stop, she tried to negotiate stopping only temporarily, to prove that she is not an alcoholic - with the intention of resuming immediately the two months is up - and she tried to negotiate starting only after the holidays - so that she can spend another few weeks using her crutch. It is clear that the idea of not drinking at this festive time is something she cannot face, which is a sure sign of her alcoholism.

This negotiating the kind of deal she can cope with is the same behaviour as the person having an affair, who tries to negotiate staying in contact with the affair partner; it's just a friendship, the feelings are not sexual, they are not in love, they can still work together and not jump into the sack together...

You are not helping MrAlias by telling him that the it would be a love buster for him to ask his wife to stop drinking. Their marriage is in crisis, and this is a health and safety issue today, and she needs to stop drinking today.

And just as we do not tell people to wait before exposing the affair to kids, we do not tell them to wait before exposing any other kind of harmful, destructive behaviour. We do not tell them to wait until the wife-beater beats up his wife again, and we do not tell them to wait until the alcoholic drinks again He needs his kids to know that his wife is an alcoholic, regardless of whether she drops drinking this second, or not. He needs their support, and he needs them to be prepared for the intervention that might have to happen.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:06 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
I agree with your positions, except that by Mr A's description he hasn't done this yet.

He left it at her wanting to stop drinking after the holidays. He never came back to tell her that wouldn't work for him. He owes her that before an intervention.
Well, that is what I said, so why are you arguing with me? I never said to do an intervention without first asking her to stop.

Here is what I said:

Originally Posted by SugarCane
You only gave us notes from what Dr Harley said, and you did not tell us what you asked. It's much better for us to see the full question and answer. However, based on the notes you provided, this is the order of battle:

1. See what single-sex treatment programmes are available in your area. Is there a single-sex AA centre nearby? Talk to them about what help they can offer your wife.

2. Armed with that knowledge, ask your wife to stop drinking altogether; not just for two months, and starting right now, not after the holidays. Tell her about the support she will receive from the local AA.

3. If she refuses, or tries to negotiate starting after the holidays, or giving up for only two months, get your kids involved in the intervention. In fact, you could tell your kids right now that their mother is an alcoholic and you intend asking her to stop drinking altogether, and you might need their help with this later.

4. If she refuses, and the intervention does not help, write to Dr Harley again.


Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:11 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
You are not helping MrAlias by telling him that the it would be a love buster for him to ask his wife to stop drinking.


We are in full agreement that he needs to ask his wife to stop drinking.

All of my posts have specifically been telling him to ask his wife to stop drinking.

He has been "kicking the can down the road" by not clearly doing so.

Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:13 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
Originally Posted by SugarCane
In fact, you could tell your kids right now that their mother is an alcoholic and you intend asking her to stop drinking altogether, and you might need their help with this later.

Sugar Cane is really awesome, but I would disagree with telling the children this until after she has refused to quite or until after she has stopped quitting.

This could be an enormous lovebuster which could cloud her desire to work with him on his objective. I also don't think it is a just action to take prior to concluding his own conversations with her.

The reason he has not concluded his conversations is because he is avoiding conflict. Involving the kids in the mess of his own creating before he cleans it up doesn't seem fair to her at all.

My exH tried an "intervention" on me for unjust reasons and I literally hated him for it every time I remembered it. Scalding, burning hatred.

The part in red is the only part of your post that I disagreed with.

I don't think it's fair to tell the kids right now that she is an alcoholic when he hasn't finished asking her to stop drinking.

Also, Dr. Harley did not suggest such a step *right now*.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:15 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
I would disagree with telling the children this until after she has refused to quite or until after she has stopped quitting.

This could be an enormous lovebuster which could cloud her desire to work with him on his objective. I also don't think it is a just action to take prior to concluding his own conversations with her.

The reason he has not concluded his conversations is because he is avoiding conflict. Involving the kids in the mess of his own creating before he cleans it up doesn't seem fair to her at all.

My exH tried an "intervention" on me for unjust reasons and I literally hated him for it every time I remembered it. Scalding, burning hatred.
How would his telling his kids that he intends to ask his wife to stop drinking altogether, and that if this does not work, he might need their help, "cloud her desire to work with him"? How would she know?

I did not say to tell the kids and get them to talk to their mother today. I said to tell the kids that he might need them to do this, together with him, soon.

And again, when it comes to the time for the intervention, how would this be "for unjust reasons", as it was in your case? Is trying to get his wife to stop drinking for good an "unjust reason"?
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:21 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
I don't think it's fair to tell the kids right now that she is an alcoholic when he hasn't finished asking her to stop drinking.
So, if she agrees to stop drinking, there is no need to tell them that she is an alcoholic?

Why would he keep that a secret? Is it Harley advice to keep such a thing secret from our kids? Is it his advice to keep affairs, abuse, or other kinds of marital problems, secret from the kids?

If she stops drinking, is she no longer an alcoholic? Is that why he would not need to tell them? I think you know that she would still be an alcoholic, so why shouldn't her kids know this? Might it not help her for them to know this?

Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
Also, Dr. Harley did not suggest such a step *right now*.
Well, he did not suggest that an intervention would be unjustified, either, but that did not stop you from implying that it would.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:21 PM
I can't post much now because I am swamped at work, but this post frustrates me terribly. Almost as much as the endorsed notion yesterday of stopping for 2 months.. He should tell the kids now. They need to know what is going on. DR Harley is very clear about honesty with families. Additionally, AA advises members to inform family and close friends. I have been in AA for 32 years and there is no benefit to anyone concerned to keep this a secret. Alcoholics are notorious for hiding their drinking problems. It doesn't help her one bit by engaging in the secrecy.
Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:26 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
How would his telling his kids that he intends to ask his wife to stop drinking altogether, and that if this does not work, he might need their help

Well, that wasn't exactly what you originally said..you had said to tell them today "she is an alcoholic".

That label to the kids isn't exactly fair to her because he hasn't told yet her that her idea to wait until the holidays are over will not work for him and that he needs her to stop completely.


Originally Posted by SugarCane
I did not say to tell the kids and get them to talk to their mother today. I said to tell the kids that he might need them to do this, together with him, soon.

Dr. Harley did not go as far as to tell him to involve the kids today. He said to consider an intervention.

I think it is wise that he tells her TODAY that he needs her to stop drinking, and if she refuses, to tell the kids TOMORROW this has occurred and he will need their help. Telling them anything prior to his final request is premature.

Originally Posted by SugarCane
And again, when it comes to the time for the intervention, how would this be "for unjust reasons", as it was in your case? Is trying to get his wife to stop drinking for good an "unjust reason"?

If she refuses to stop drinking, or stops and then starts up again, then it is not an unjust intervention. At that time she is proving she will chose alcohol over the family and the family deserves to have some say/take action about that.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:27 PM
SC.

Thank you for the 4 point list. I believe you are right on the mark and I will follow through with that advice.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:30 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
Well, that wasn't exactly what you originally said..you had said to tell them today "she is an alcoholic".

That label to the kids isn't exactly fair to her because he hasn't asked her to stop yet.
I did say to tell them today that she is an alcoholic, and I stand by that term.

His wife IS an alcoholic, and MrA, his wife AND THE CHILDREN need to face that fact.

She is an alcoholic whether she stops drinking this second, or not.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:32 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
I think it is wise that he tells her TODAY that he needs her to stop drinking, and if she refuses, to tell the kids TOMORROW this has occurred and he will need their help. Telling them anything prior to his final request is premature.
Why is it premature?

She is an alcoholic.

Why is it premature to tell his kids the truth?
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:33 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
If she refuses to stop drinking, or stops and then starts up again, then it is not an unjust intervention. At that time she is proving she will chose alcohol over the family and the family deserves to have some say/take action about that.
So why mention an "unjust" intervention?

Who told him to do an "unjust" intervention?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:40 PM
Being an alcoholic is not a "label." It is a FACT. if I say I am a girl, that is not a "label," but a statement of fact. Of course he should tell his children the FACTS about their mother.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 07:52 PM
For what it's worth my W hasn't agreed to stop drinking entirely. Only temporarily after the Holidays. She has not responded to my lastest emails sent yesterday morning.

Originally Posted by ToMrsAlias
I asked you last year to quit drinking. You spent your time convincing me that you could control your drinking. You can�t. You were good for a while and then you slipped back into some of your old habits.

Remember this wasn�t �my way� or anything I asked you to do. I wanted you to quit entirely. This last year was your way. For the sake of our marriage you promised me you�d be good or get help. Well here we are almost one year later and I see you trying but not succeeding. And now you're asking me to continue to reset and try again? Am I now supposed to believe this time is going to be different?

Bottom line: I�m asking you to stop drinking. You�re holding on to it like it�s something really important. It must be if you aren�t willing to stop.

I reread this and realize my wording sucks. My words tend to have a demeaning tone and it's something I need to work on. However I do believe I've made it crystal clear what I want her to do.

Later on I followed this up with this:
Originally Posted by ToMrsAlias
My hope would be that you see someone about this. Get a professional opinion. I would hope they would offer up something that would give some direction. I would be there to help you every step of the way. I love you and want us to have a happy and romantic relationship. That can�t happen if we continue on this merry-go-round.

I definitely believe I should talk to my kids about this soon if not right away. My W tried to convince me not to unless I was ready to split but that's just nonsense. I suspect I know the reasons why she'd say that. She'd feel ganged up on.

My timing couldn't be worse what with the Holidays coming up ... although it was the last Holiday (Thanksgiving) that prompted me to say something now. Enough capitulating and ignoring the elephant in the room.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 08:04 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I definitely believe I should talk to my kids about this soon if not right away. My W tried to convince me not to unless I was ready to split but that's just nonsense. I suspect I know the reasons why she'd say that. She'd feel ganged up on.
But even you spoke to them today, she would not necessarily know today. I did not suggest that you stage the intervention today. I only said that you should speak to them today. I did not say that they should then speak to her right away after you told them. I specifically suggested only staging the intervention when (if) she refused your request for her to stop altogether - to stop right now (not after the holidays).

Their speaking to her is the intervention, and that needs to handled properly, in the way Dr Harley described in the Q&A letter. He even suggested getting advice from AA on how to do it, and possibly, getting AA to be involved in the event.

An intervention is a staged event, and therefore, requires planning. It isn't just one or more of your kids having a go at your wife.

And thank you for clarifying that you have, indeed, clearly asked your wife to stop drinking altogether, and she has already refused. That is what I gathered from what you have written on this board for some time, and also from what you wrote yesterday. I don't know where the idea came from that you have not articulated your desire for her to stop altogether.
Posted By: SusieQ Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 08:07 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
I would complete your POJA about stopping drinking now before considering this. If she agrees to stop, no need for an intervention UNTIL she quits stopping.

If she won't agree to stop, then it would also be time to consider it.
You realise that we shouldn't POJA health and safety issues, don't you?

Dr Harley did *not* say to "POJA" this drinking issue. And I don't understand why you would inject your own twist like this on Dr Harley's advice. He is clear in what he said and on his feelings on this topic.

Please Mr Alias, I would advise you to listen to SC and ML. They will not steer you wrong.

Posted By: Toujours Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 08:28 PM
Please advise this poster using Marriage Builders principles, not your own experiences or feelings.

Any questions, shoot me an email.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 08:31 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I definitely believe I should talk to my kids about this soon if not right away. My W tried to convince me not to unless I was ready to split but that's just nonsense. I suspect I know the reasons why she'd say that. She'd feel ganged up on.
But even you spoke to them today, she would not necessarily know today. I did not suggest that you stage the intervention today. I only said that you should speak to them today. I did not say that they should then speak to her right away after you told them. I specifically suggested only staging the intervention when (if) she refused your request for her to stop altogether - to stop right now (not after the holidays).

Their speaking to her is the intervention, and that needs to handled properly, in the way Dr Harley described in the Q&A letter. He even suggested getting advice from AA on how to do it, and possibly, getting AA to be involved in the event.

An intervention is a staged event, and therefore, requires planning. It isn't just one or more of your kids having a go at your wife.

And thank you for clarifying that you have, indeed, clearly asked your wife to stop drinking altogether, and she has already refused. That is what I gathered from what you have written on this board for some time, and also from what you wrote yesterday. I don't know where the idea came from that you have not articulated your desire for her to stop altogether.


SC, yes thank you. I understand she wouldn't know right away. That wasn't was I was implying. Just that I know, no matter what, she'll eventually be furious. I suspect even if she were to enter in therapy and then realize what I did was something beneficial she would still, most likely, hold that against me. Like it was a ploy to prepare to gang up on her.

I've had many a convo about my W's admittance to holding grudges, needing to keep everything a secret for sake of a false integrity etc. There are times things should remain internal to a family or set of individuals (the whole world doesn't need to know). I agree this isn't one of those times. I don't know that she would ever agree with that.

She's always said one of the biggies that causes her to lose her love for me is that she doesn't feel cared for. That I often put others before her. Meaning I share things with people (aka the MB Forum) that she doesn't want me sharing. This would be one of those situations where she would say fits into that category.
Posted By: markos Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 08:32 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
I would complete your POJA about stopping drinking now before considering this.

What does that mean? He's asked her to stop and she won't. The POJA states that she shouldn't have another drink since he's not enthusiastic, but she won't follow that.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 08:35 PM
MrA, the goal here is not to avoid her anger at all cost, but to save your marriage. You need to stop operating from a position of fear and cuckhood and focus on your marriage. Discuss her alcoholism with your children and then ask her to stop drinking. There is no need to talk it to death for years, just do it.

We can even help you with the right words, but you need to move this forward.
Posted By: markos Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 08:36 PM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
Originally Posted by SugarCane
In fact, you could tell your kids right now that their mother is an alcoholic and you intend asking her to stop drinking altogether, and you might need their help with this later.

Sugar Cane is really awesome, but I would disagree with telling the children this until after she has refused to quite or until after she has stopped quitting.

She has refused to quit, right?
Posted By: Prisca Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 08:36 PM
Quote
An intervention frightens me. I know her. I know she will be very angry. May never forgive me.
You really need to stop being scared of your wife and her anger. Of course she will be angry, she is an addict. Addicts are always angry when the source of their addiction is threatened.

Stop being scared of her and start doing what needs to be done to RESCUE her.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 09:44 PM
Originally Posted by markos
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
Originally Posted by SugarCane
In fact, you could tell your kids right now that their mother is an alcoholic and you intend asking her to stop drinking altogether, and you might need their help with this later.

Sugar Cane is really awesome, but I would disagree with telling the children this until after she has refused to quite or until after she has stopped quitting.

She has refused to quit, right?

She has refused, in the past, to quit drinking entirely. Right now the only thing she's stated she's willing to do is quit for a couple of months after the Holidays (If it means that much to me).

I'm totally aware this isn't acceptable.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 09:49 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
MrA, the goal here is not to avoid her anger at all cost, but to save your marriage. You need to stop operating from a position of fear and cuckhood and focus on your marriage. Discuss her alcoholism with your children and then ask her to stop drinking. There is no need to talk it to death for years, just do it.

We can even help you with the right words, but you need to move this forward.

Thanks Mel. I am definitely aware of where I need to focus and to stop letting fear stop me.

I will find some time to sit down with my youngest two and also call my oldest who's off to college.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 09:54 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
An intervention frightens me. I know her. I know she will be very angry. May never forgive me.
You really need to stop being scared of your wife and her anger. Of course she will be angry, she is an addict. Addicts are always angry when the source of their addiction is threatened.

Stop being scared of her and start doing what needs to be done to RESCUE her.

The amount she consumes doesn't feel like a health and safety issue. Not yet. Maybe a 12 pack a week at most right now stretched over a 2 or 3 day period. If she's an alcoholic then eventually she will get there. It's a progressive disease right?

I need to do what needs to be done to salvage our M.

Me telling her she's an alcoholic isn't going to change her mind. She has to figure that out for herself.

I need her to quit drinking because I cannot live it. I am going to do what it takes to save our M. Hopefully she agrees to do her part.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: anti-Celebration - 12/07/16 10:35 PM
Would you please post Dr. Harley's exact letter to you and yours to him? I know you posted his highlights, but I would like to see what he wrote you. I like to read how Dr. Harley writes his advice.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 12:33 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[

The amount she consumes doesn't feel like a health and safety issue. Not yet. Maybe a 12 pack a week at most right now stretched over a 2 or 3 day period. If she's an alcoholic then eventually she will get there. It's a progressive disease right?

The amount has nothing to do with it. Some alcoholics are fine with smaller amounts, others with great amounts.

I get the sense you are still lost in the game of definitions.

Quote
Me telling her she's an alcoholic isn't going to change her mind. She has to figure that out for herself.

I need her to quit drinking because I cannot live it. I am going to do what it takes to save our M. Hopefully she agrees to do her part.

That is the right approach. However, if she is not an alcoholic, she would just quit. That is what normal people do.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 12:36 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
The amount she consumes doesn't feel like a health and safety issue.

This is not something that is subject to the POJA, that was the point. Alcoholism is defined by an addiction, not by the amount one drinks. Some need massive amounts and others need small amounts.

Alcoholism is a health and safety issue, but that is beside the point.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 12:52 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[quote=ToMrsAlias]
I asked you last year to quit drinking. You spent your time convincing me that you could control your drinking. You can�t. You were good for a while and then you slipped back into some of your old habits.

Remember this wasn�t �my way� or anything I asked you to do. I wanted you to quit entirely. This last year was your way. For the sake of our marriage you promised me you�d be good or get help. Well here we are almost one year later and I see you trying but not succeeding. And now you're asking me to continue to reset and try again? Am I now supposed to believe this time is going to be different?

Bottom line: I�m asking you to stop drinking. You�re holding on to it like it�s something really important. It must be if you aren�t willing to stop.

love it!!! It is this brand of forthrightness that is necessary.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 01:04 AM
Originally Posted by Sunnytimes
[
That label to the kids isn't exactly fair to her because he hasn't told yet her that her idea to wait until the holidays are over will not work for him and that he needs her to stop completely.

Sunnytimes, alcoholism is not "fair" to children or spouses. It is not fair that MrAlias has been robbed of his marriage due to alcohol. He has been cheated by alcohol. The kids are cheated by an alcoholic parent. Saying that an alcoholic is an alcoholic is very fair because it is true. I am an alcoholic. That is a true fact. My children have always known this.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 01:27 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
I get the sense you are still lost in the game of definitions.

Maybe. Doesn't matter. I know I need for her to quit drinking. I'm tired of the merry-go-round.

Quote
Me telling her she's an alcoholic isn't going to change her mind. She has to figure that out for herself.

I need her to quit drinking because I cannot live it. I am going to do what it takes to save our M. Hopefully she agrees to do her part.

That is the right approach. However, if she is not an alcoholic, she would just quit. That is what normal people do.

She is very stubborn if she's being told she should do something. Her open claim to fame is that "If someone tells me what to do I normally dig in my heels and do the opposite".

So is it that she's an alcoholic or again just digging in her heels? Doesn't matter. I can't live with her inability to control the drinking.

I want to avoid any argument with her about whether or not she is an alcoholic. That's just an endless circle. She needs to figure this out. I highly doubt she'll find a therapist/doctor that would tell her she is fine to try to work a controlled drinking program. I'm hanging my hat on it. If she gets bad advice from them then it could possibly mean the end for us. Unless by some miracle she decides she wants to quit drinking for me. I don't see her doing that. The end result is something that is thoughtless behavior ... welcome to my world.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 01:35 PM
Here ya go BH.

To Dr Harley:

Hello Joyce and Dr Harley,

I need some help in resolving a problem in my marriage.

A little background. I've been an MB follower for a long time. I love the principles and believe in them entirely. Making them work in my marriage is another story. My wife and I are in our early 50s, been married 27 years and have three beautiful children ages 14 to 19.

A few years ago my wife and I did some counseling with your daughter Jennifer. We read HNHN, LBs and FILSIL. Worked the assignments assigned to us and seemed to make a bit of progress while in sessions with Dr Chalmers. We've had our good moments and bad over the years. We get along well, never really argue and certainly do not have angry outbursts of any kind. Probably just the opposite, we hold stuff in and let it fester. My wife says her mantra is it is what it is and you just suck it up. I believe what the good Dr states; complaints are good for a marriage if delivered respectfully. Mind you I believe in these tactics but sometimes struggle on delivery.

On to the current dilemma. After having counseling we didn't follow through to the letter and backslid. To add to the struggle maintaining a romantic relationship my wife is and always has been a heavy drinker. Over the years I've changed from being one myself to one who drinks only a little.

After several incidents where my wife drank too much and I felt embarrassed I decided it was time to approach her. She said she would change. She didn't. I became more withdrawn to the point where about a year ago I'd had enough and contemplated a separation. I told her something needed to change, that I felt she was an alcoholic and that I'd like her to quit drinking. She had done some reading and felt she was an alcohol abuser. I, with some doubts, agreed to support her in her efforts to control the drinking. She did quite well for a few months.

I'm sorry to say that things have taken a bit of a turn. Despite my wife's honest attempts to control her drinking, in the last couple of months, she has started to slide back into some her bad habits. Drinking more, drinking faster and more frequently. Nothing as bad as before but still enough where I feel triggered.

This week I told her I can't live like this anymore. That her drinking is ruining it for me, That I'm triggered every time I see her drink.

I've informed her that I see the only solution to resolve this would be for her to commit to stop drinking entirely. She feels she should just continue to try to control it. I've also asked that she seek a professional's help on the matter.

Outside of me communicating that to her, getting myself to Al-Anon, is there anything else I could be doing? Is it recommended to get others involved or, at least, communicate to some of the important ones that her drinking has become a problem?

Do I need to separate?

I'd love to hear your recommendation for next steps.


From Dr Harley:
The solution to problem drinking is to give it up entirely. As you've noticed, "controlled drinking" simply doesn't work. If she goes through a treatment program, make sure that they are known for their effort to keep marriages together. In my experience, many couples divorce after going through treatment because they tend to advocate rules that keep a person sober, but ruin marriages. Read my article "Why the Codependency Movement is Ruining Marriages." I would not separate, but you might want to consider an intervention that would involve your children.
Dr. Harley
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 01:38 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
She is very stubborn if she's being told she should do something. Her open claim to fame is that "If someone tells me what to do I normally dig in my heels and do the opposite".

It is not a matter of being "stubborn," it is a matter of being addicted. All alcoholics dig in their heels so she is no different. You don't have to argue with her about whether or not she is an alcoholic; she doesn't have to agree. But she does have to agree to stop drinking.

Just make sure that you and your family are not supporting her denial by avoiding use of the term alcoholic. You shouldn't enable her.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 01:44 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[Me telling her she's an alcoholic isn't going to change her mind.

Maybe not, but not saying it isn't going to change her mind either. It only serves her DENIAL. You don't need to help her in her denial.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 01:56 PM
Thanks Mel,

I've been trying to find resources in my area that I could direct my W to.

There is a local chapter of AA in our hometown. It is the same building I went to when I went to Al-Anon meetings a few years ago. It is not a single sex AA facility but it is open to the public.

I don't see any way to contact them other than showing up.

Would you recommend I attend a meeting and ask for some support there?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 02:02 PM
AA usually has a hotline # in the phone book. I would call them and ask for a list of meetings in the area. Ask if they have any all female meetings and/or open meetings in the area. Ask also for the # of a female sponsor that your wife can contact if she agrees to join AA.

If you can't find a #, then yes, it would be a good idea to just go there and see if you can get some help.

Most AA people, while well meaning, don't really understand how damaging AA is to marriages so don't get discouraged if you hear objections to the all female meetings idea. Co-ed AA meetings are pick up joints.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 02:12 PM
Thanks again Mel.

Co-ed AA meetings are pick up joints.

In that case would it be a good or bad idea for me to go to these meetings with my wife? If they're open to the public.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 02:14 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Thanks again Mel.

Co-ed AA meetings are pick up joints.

In that case would it be a good or bad idea for me to go to these meetings with my wife? If they're open to the public.

Yes, you can go to open meetings with her - usually a person gives a talk. But you can't go to closed meetings and she will need to attend those too.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 02:22 PM
Alrighty. Thank you.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 02:36 PM
Good luck!! laugh
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 04:26 PM
Next steps?

Her response to my question of wanting to know what her plan is and if she'd seek professional help.

Originally Posted by FromMrsAlias
stop drinking

Not talking to a professional because we can't afford it and i don't think i have a problem. I enjoy a drink or two and have been drinking less than i used to (even though you think that it is the other way around)

Yes i have had a drink or two during the week....yes i drink on the weekends but i limit it to 4....i am not staying up late to drink more i am just a night person...there have been a couple occasions where i went over the 4 limit but there have also been some where i only have less than 4 on the weekend.

Bottom line is you seem to have a zero tolerance for me drinking even just one so i will quit.

I have not responded because I want to be sure I pick the right path and make an appropriate response (if I respond at all).
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 04:28 PM
I sent this on to Dr Harley and ask for his advice as well.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 06:42 PM
I'd be happy to hear from others on this.

I'm thinking I should be happy to hear this. But her message reads loud and clear she isn't happy that I'm "ahem" forcing her into this.

That is going to make it tough to build that romantic relationship I long for.
Posted By: Sunnytimes Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 10:37 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Next steps?

Her response to my question of wanting to know what her plan is and if she'd seek professional help.

Originally Posted by FromMrsAlias
stop drinking

Not talking to a professional because we can't afford it and i don't think i have a problem. I enjoy a drink or two and have been drinking less than i used to (even though you think that it is the other way around)

Yes i have had a drink or two during the week....yes i drink on the weekends but i limit it to 4....i am not staying up late to drink more i am just a night person...there have been a couple occasions where i went over the 4 limit but there have also been some where i only have less than 4 on the weekend.

Bottom line is you seem to have a zero tolerance for me drinking even just one so i will quit.

I have not responded because I want to be sure I pick the right path and make an appropriate response (if I respond at all).

Yay!! This was a beautiful response. You finally completed your conversation with her to quit drinking; she agreed to quit.

I don't understand why you think you shouldn't respond?? What else did you want?

Support her. Thank her nicely, be sweet to her and take her on a date. Show her your appreciation that she would do something so nice for you since it was lovebusting you.

If she stops quitting further action would be warranted, but give her a chance.
Posted By: kerala Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 10:45 PM
You can't control her feelings. Nor, really, can she.

You can only ask her to refrain from doing things that make you unhappy.

She can't control how she feels about her drinking, but she can control her drinking. That is what she has agreed to do.

It's up to you to decide whether to insist that she also seek out counselling. Remember, though, that is requiring her to DO something. If the problem is the drinking, and she has agreed to stop, maybe go with that for a while. It may be that, once she stops drinking, her insight into it will change and she will seek out further support..
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 11:22 PM
Is she going to stop right now?
Posted By: Prisca Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 11:31 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Is she going to stop right now?

That's what I'd like to know.
Is all the alcohol being poured down the sink as we speak?

Is she open to being accountable? Can you check up on her?

Have you told your kids yet? They need to know, so they can tell you if she still drinks.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/08/16 11:49 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Next steps?

Her response to my question of wanting to know what her plan is and if she'd seek professional help.

Originally Posted by FromMrsAlias
stop drinking

Not talking to a professional because we can't afford it and i don't think i have a problem. I enjoy a drink or two and have been drinking less than i used to (even though you think that it is the other way around)

Yes i have had a drink or two during the week....yes i drink on the weekends but i limit it to 4....i am not staying up late to drink more i am just a night person...there have been a couple occasions where i went over the 4 limit but there have also been some where i only have less than 4 on the weekend.

Bottom line is you seem to have a zero tolerance for me drinking even just one so i will quit.

I have not responded because I want to be sure I pick the right path and make an appropriate response (if I respond at all).

That is great! Tell her you love her and appreciate her note.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 12:06 AM
As Prisca says, your house needs to be cleared of all alcohol, right away. Also, you and the kids must not bring any alcohol into the house after that. Your wife needs to live in an alcohol-free zone.

You then need to be with her whenever she is not working, so that you know she is not drinking.

For an alcoholic to give up drinking takes more than giving her word. It will be a struggle for her to stop, and you need to help her, but also verify that she is not drinking, anywhere.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 02:12 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I sent this on to Dr Harley and ask for his advice as well.
Could you please post both of your letters to Dr. Harley here to us and Dr. Harley's response?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 12:57 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Is she going to stop right now?

I believe so. She hasn't said definitively but we weren't together for very long last night (other than to sleep) so we didn't discuss this in-depth.

She had her dance class last night so I took our daughter to watch a high school sporting event. When I got home she was already there and was doing some knitting.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 01:04 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Is she going to stop right now?

That's what I'd like to know.
Is all the alcohol being poured down the sink as we speak?

Is she open to being accountable? Can you check up on her?

Have you told your kids yet? They need to know, so they can tell you if she still drinks.

I have not poured anything out, hadn't thought of that. There is a LOT of wine and beer in our bar. Yes we have a bar. Sigh. She rarely drinks wine even though many of the bottles are hers. I suspect there is close to a case of light beer (big 16 oz cans) in the cooler. Hers.

She'll think I went off the deep end if I start pouring out all the booze. She doesn't think she has a problem and is only doing this because I asked her to. Sacrificing is what she'd call it.

I haven't talked to the kids yet. My son should be with us this weekend. So I plan to sit them down tomorrow. Unfortunately my wife won't be with us Saturday. She's made plans to be with her sister doing some Xmas shopping, 1.5 hours away. Her sister doesn't drink and while I'm sure I'll regret it she will be getting an email today letting her know what's been going on. I doubt she's aware there is this drinking problem.

I will look to clean out the booze tomorrow when she's gone. Tonight her and I will be together every minute of the evening.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 01:06 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
That is great! Tell her you love her and appreciate her note.

Yup did that.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 01:27 PM
Originally Posted by BrainHurts
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I sent this on to Dr Harley and ask for his advice as well.
Could you please post both of your letters to Dr. Harley here to us and Dr. Harley's response?

I will post his response when I receive it, sure.

My reply to him was this:

Dr Harley, can I ask for next steps based on my wife's recent reply?

< MrsAlias's response here>

I'm fearful this is her being angry and upset with me thinking this is my problem not her's and that she will go on resenting me. I don't want that, obviously, so what would you recommend I do?
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 03:09 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I have not poured anything out, hadn't thought of that. There is a LOT of wine and beer in our bar. Yes we have a bar. Sigh. She rarely drinks wine even though many of the bottles are hers. I suspect there is close to a case of light beer (big 16 oz cans) in the cooler. Hers.

She'll think I went off the deep end if I start pouring out all the booze. She doesn't think she has a problem and is only doing this because I asked her to. Sacrificing is what she'd call it.

I haven't talked to the kids yet. My son should be with us this weekend. So I plan to sit them down tomorrow. Unfortunately my wife won't be with us Saturday. She's made plans to be with her sister doing some Xmas shopping, 1.5 hours away. Her sister doesn't drink and while I'm sure I'll regret it she will be getting an email today letting her know what's been going on. I doubt she's aware there is this drinking problem.

I will look to clean out the booze tomorrow when she's gone. Tonight her and I will be together every minute of the evening.
You need to do this properly, MrA. You know that she will very likely take the first opportunity to sneak a drink when she is away from you. If you've got a bar full of booze, and you get back and she's already home knitting, you can bet that she'll have a swig or two before you get home.

You need to find a way not to leave her alone, or to have her always in the presence of someone who knows that she has a problem and is getting family help to stop.

it would be okay for her to go shopping with her sister, if her sister knows about the plan and will not let her drink, but she can't go out with her girlfriends, for example.

If she means what she says, she will happily comply with being accountable at all times. I suspect she won't be happy and she won't comply.

If you and the kids and not drinking in the house (and it sounds as if the two still at home are too young to drink), it should be easier to smell alcohol on her if she does drink.

My point is that this will take vigilance, and compliance with that from her. Also, you need to get her to an AA meeting, with you there if it is mixed-sex.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 03:10 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'm fearful this is her being angry and upset with me thinking this is my problem not her's and that she will go on resenting me. I don't want that, obviously, so what would you recommend I do?
Dr Harley addresses this point in the "Intervention" Q&A.
Posted By: Prisca Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 03:20 PM
Quote
She'll think I went off the deep end if I start pouring out all the booze.
So? It shouldn't be a problem if she agreed to quit.
And, if the alcohol is around the house, it will be no time before she starts drinking again. If she's really going to quit, she needs to be in an alcohol-free home.

Quote
I haven't talked to the kids yet. My son should be with us this weekend. So I plan to sit them down tomorrow.
Very good!

Quote
Unfortunately my wife won't be with us Saturday.
Perfect time to get rid of the alcohol.

Quote
She's made plans to be with her sister doing some Xmas shopping, 1.5 hours away. Her sister doesn't drink and while I'm sure I'll regret it she will be getting an email today letting her know what's been going on. I doubt she's aware there is this drinking problem.
Also very good! Your wife will need this support system to stay sober.

I will look to clean out the booze tomorrow when she's gone. Tonight her and I will be together every minute of the evening.

Posted By: SusieQ Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 04:13 PM
I agree with SC and Prisca, get rid of the alcohol in the house and be a good support system to help her stay sober.

I also agree if she's serious about not drinking, it should not matter if you get rid of the alcohol.

Her agreement to stop drinking is a good start but not enough. Have you seen Dr Harley's writings on NC after an affair? He does not want people to rely on willpower, when willpower has failed in the past. He advocates changing your lifestyle and the conditions. It's the same idea here.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 04:15 PM
Honestly folks I believe she will quit drinking.

I've spied on her for a long time when we're at home but in different parts of the home and have yet to find her sneak a drink. We're usually in proximity and I would have smelled it had she done so.

She isn't a falling down drunk or someone that hides it. She openly drinks in front of me ... especially since she started trying to manage the volume of her consumption.

That doesn't mean I won't be getting rid of the booze but I thought a level-set of what I see from her is important.

Posted By: Prisca Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 04:30 PM
Quote
I've spied on her for a long time when we're at home but in different parts of the home and have yet to find her sneak a drink.
She has had no reason to hide it before.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 07:10 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Honestly folks I believe she will quit drinking.

I've spied on her for a long time when we're at home but in different parts of the home and have yet to find her sneak a drink. We're usually in proximity and I would have smelled it had she done so.

She isn't a falling down drunk or someone that hides it. She openly drinks in front of me ... especially since she started trying to manage the volume of her consumption.

That doesn't mean I won't be getting rid of the booze but I thought a level-set of what I see from her is important.

Even the dumbest alcoholic can figure out to sneak drinks and you would never know it. There are lots of ways to do this. So please don't think you know everything she does.

I would just quietly pour it all out at the first opportunity and take the bottles to the dump.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 08:03 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
I've spied on her for a long time when we're at home but in different parts of the home and have yet to find her sneak a drink.
She has had no reason to hide it before.

I suppose. You think you know someone until they do something that is so out of character you no longer recognize the person in front of you. If she truly is alcoholic I suspect I may find I lost the person I used to recognize if I'm not careful.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 08:10 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Even the dumbest alcoholic can figure out to sneak drinks and you would never know it. There are lots of ways to do this. So please don't think you know everything she does.

I would just quietly pour it all out at the first opportunity and take the bottles to the dump.

That wine rack is going to look awful bare with no bottles in it. Maybe I'll replace the wine with sparkling apple juice. So it doesn't look so bare. The kids love that stuff especially on Xmas day/New Year's. Or is that a bad idea ... too much like promoting alcohol because they come in champagne-like bottles?
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 08:15 PM
It's the wine rack that reminds one of alcohol! Ditch the wine rack, and get sparkling juice that does not look like champagne, and keep it in the fridge (or a cupboard until the fridge has room).

Don't let you kids drink much juice. It's bad for the teeth and the blood sugar levels. Sparkling water with ice is sugar-free, and addictive (although I've read some reports that the bubbles are not great for the teeth, either).

Are you going to take an axe to the bar itself? You need to! Redecorate the room it lives in!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 08:16 PM
If and when she screams at me for emailing her sister and telling the kids do I simply tell her I told them because they have a right to know what's going on, I'm fighting to save our marriage and I need some support?

Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 08:19 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
It's the wine rack that reminds one of alcohol! Ditch the wine rack, and get sparkling juice that does not look like champagne, and keep it in the fridge (or a cupboard until the fridge has room).

Don't let you kids drink much juice. It's bad for the teeth and the blood sugar levels. Sparkling water with ice is sugar-free, and addictive (although I've read some reports that the bubbles are not great for the teeth, either).

Are you going to take an axe to the bar itself? You need to! Redecorate the room it lives in!

No SC we won't be redoing that bar. We spent a lot of money to put it in and I'm not throwing good money away. In hindsight it looks like it was a horrible idea but I had no idea I would be where I am today. It's only been since I asked her to curb her drinking that I realized this is a bigger problem than I thought.

Just because it has coolers and a wine rack doesn't mean we have to drink alcohol in it. It can be used to house water and other non-alcoholic beverages.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 08:23 PM
Do I need to avoid restaurants that serve alcohol now that she's stopped drinking?

That pretty much eliminates any place to eat out (where we spend UA time) except for unhealthy fast food joints.
Posted By: Prisca Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 08:37 PM
You need to get rid of the bar. As sugarcane said, it's going to be a trigger.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 08:53 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
You need to get rid of the bar. As sugarcane said, it's going to be a trigger.

I will bring it up to her. But not right now. She hates me already. I push the issue she'll say enough is enough, get out.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 08:57 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Do I need to avoid restaurants that serve alcohol now that she's stopped drinking?

Just stay out of bars.
Posted By: Dr. Harley Re: anti-Celebration - 12/09/16 09:53 PM
MrAlias:

My advice to you is to make your home and lifestyle alcohol free. You can't expect your wife to give up drinking with any alcohol available in the house or her lifestyle. Tell your boys now about their mother's commitment, and that you will all be helping her by giving up alcohol completely as a family. Let them know that you give up drinking yourself and will not drink at parties or sports events or while dining out. It will set a goal for your boys as well. But at the first sign of her sneaking a drink, whether in the house or in her car or anywhere else, I recommend an intervention and referral to a treatment program. By that time, your boys will already know what's going on. The more eyes on your wife, the better.

Your wife will probably try to lobby your boys to make them think that you are being unreasonable. So you should anticipate that by explaining to them your history (that you both drank heavily early in your marriage because you didn't think anything was wrong with it), but that you became alarmed by the way your wife behaved when under the influence. You can now see how much damage drinking can do when it's done to excess. You might also explain that there are some people who can handle moderate drinking, and never have more than one drink. But there are others that drink to excess, and they are the ones who should not drink at all. Tell them that they are likely to have inherited a predisposition to be alcoholics, so they should avoid alcohol completely.

You might also explain the difference between a problem drinker and an alcoholic. There isn't any. As soon as drinking alcohol becomes a problem, whether it's DWIs, becoming socially inappropriate, flirting, becoming belligerent, or any other way that alcohol affects behavior negatively, it should be avoided completely. When consuming alcoholic beverages can't be avoided by commitment, the person needs professional help.

Even if your wife refuses help, and continues drinking for the rest of her life, you children should see that behavior as something that they should not tolerate in themselves.

Dr. Harley
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/10/16 05:12 PM
Thank you Dr Harley and thank you for the return email.

I have done as you recommended. I spoke early today with my oldest son before he left for work and then my younger two (DD16 and DS14). I discussed our history and let them know it was affecting our relationship. I let them decide if they wished to bring it up with their mother but certainly encouraged them to let her know how, if in any way, this negatively impacted them and that is was OK for them to encourage her not to drink.

I told them the details of our current agreement. That she's agreed to stop drinking but I also told them she still doesn't see her drinking as a problem. I let them know I was hopeful that this was going to work out and that Mom and Dad would get past this and get back to building a great marriage.

These are tough conversations for me. I am an emotional person in certain situations. Having to look my kids in the eye and explain to them what I've been going through makes it hard to keep it together. Today was one tough deal and I couldn't hold back my emotions. I had hoped I could keep it together to minimize any stress this conversation would bring for them but I wasn't successful in doing that. They obviously now know how much this has been bothering me.

I am in the process of removing all the alcohol from our home.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/10/16 05:19 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Do I need to avoid restaurants that serve alcohol now that she's stopped drinking?

Just stay out of bars.

We don't go to bars however all restaurants have bars nowadays. We did our drinking at restaurants before, during and after dinner. She does her drinking there and at home and stupid places like the parking lots at our daughter's summer softball games between games. A few of the other softball Moms are a bad influence. Nice ladies but I don't like them for this reason.

Basically, she drinks wherever there is alcohol to be honest.


Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/10/16 05:27 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
These are tough conversations for me. I am an emotional person in certain situations. Having to look my kids in the eye and explain to them what I've been going through makes it hard to keep it together. Today was one tough deal and I couldn't hold back my emotions. I had hoped I could keep it together to minimize any stress this conversation would bring for them but I wasn't successful in doing that. They obviously now know how much this has been bothering me.

I am in the process of removing all the alcohol from our home.

I am so proud of you!! It is a good thing that your kids were able to see how devastating this has been to you. That helps them understand the gravity of the problem. I know this was very hard for you and I applaud you for forcing yourself to take tough steps. This is major progress.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/10/16 06:24 PM
You're doing really well, MrA. I'm sorry; this is such an upsetting thing to go through.

Originally Posted by MrAlias
We don't go to bars however all restaurants have bars nowadays. We did our drinking at restaurants before, during and after dinner. She does her drinking there and at home and stupid places like the parking lots at our daughter's summer softball games between games. A few of the other softball Moms are a bad influence. Nice ladies but I don't like them for this reason.

Basically, she drinks wherever there is alcohol to be honest.
If you go to a restaurant together, then obviously, if she is still claiming not to drink, you stay away from the bar area and go straight to your table. However, if you think that avoiding the elephant (bar) in the room will still be stressful and and an unpleasant factor in your evening out, then you'll need to avoid restaurants altogether and find other things to do.

(In London where I live, we can quite easily find restaurants with a "bring your own" policy, so there is no bar, and also, restaurants with middle-Eastern cuisines usually don't like serving alcohol. They might have a bar, but they are miserable little things in a corner of the room, and they make you feel really bad to ask the server to get you a drink! An atmosphere like those, where alcohol doesn't exactly slosh around, might be easier places in which to enjoy a date.)

What are you going to do about her normally drinking at softball games, and all her usual places? Could you ask her how she's going to manage not drinking, when she's been used to drinking there? Could you suggest that you go, instead? Alternatively, could your daughter be escorted and supervised by another mother?

Could you try bringing her onside to join you in brainstorming? Don't assume that she won't do this. You don't know until you try.
Posted By: BedofRoses Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 06:40 AM
Hi MrA,

I usually lurk but I wanted to share my story, since it's similar to yours. I reached out to Dr H in Jan of this year, afraid that my otherwise good marriage was going to end due to my husband's drinking.

My h and I had both been daily or near-daily drinkers. Our friends and families all drink. Neither of us had any obvious problems and no one considered either of us to be problem drinkers. No missed work, no relationship, legal, or financial problems, etc.

So everyone, my H included, was surprised when I quit in Dec a few years ago. My husband shouldn't have been surprised because I shared my despair with him over my drinking (feeling sick, ashamed because either I'd behaved badly or worse, couldn't remember my behavior, etc.) However, regardless of what I said in the morning, I still ended up drinking most nights. I spent a full year trying to control my drinking before finally realizing that if I had to control something, it was only because it was controlling me. I stepped out of the ring, away from the fight, and gave up drinking.

However, this tremendously upset the balance in my marriage. Drinkers seem to just accept boorish, rude, stupid behavior as things that just happen, but I could no longer roll with these behaviors from my husband or family and friends. I really understand how you feel when the people who drink think you're making big deals out of nothing. My husband felt that nothing had changed for him: he still went to work, he still had no legal or financial issues, he didn't have any red flags and was drinking like he always had, like everyone we know drinks. So he saw no reason to stop. He'd support me, as far as watching our son when I went to my one weekly AA woman's group meeting. He did not think I was an alcoholic and he certainly didn't think he was one. Our marriage was getting rocky.

Unfortunately, over the next year, my husband had two episodes that went beyond the normal drunken stupidity. The first endangered our son, and afterwards my husband started to try to control his drinking. He had some early success and our marriage improved; but a few months later, he took a day off, got very drunk, and got himself into a very dangerous situation. Thankfully I was able to locate him using his phone and get him home.

Neither of these episodes were enough to get him to commit to quitting drinking. He would have a few drinks with family and friends sometimes and be ok. He was definitely trying to cut down. But one night, a few weeks after the 2nd episode, I I came home with our son to find my husband drunk and passing out on the couch. I moved into a different room and began making plans to separate.

His family thought this was a huge over reaction and highly unnecessary. I figured that I wouldn't be dealing with them anymore so they could talk amongst themselves all they wanted...but I did wonder if they were right. The trend had been for my husband to drink less, and we really got long well during those times. I emailed Dr H and Joyce. They invited us to speak with them on the radio. I sent my husband a copy of the letter I sent them and asked if he would join me. My h knew I was serious about being ready and able to separate, and he agreed.

I will be forever grateful to Dr H and Joyce for that call. It really ticked my husband off- to him, it felt like an intervention. Dr H spoke with my husband and was able to get my h to agree that his drinking was causing problems. It didn't matter whether or not he was alcoholic or "just" a problem drinker, because the answer is the same: complete abstinence. On the call, my husband agreed to stop but said he was angry because when I quit, it was a choice I made, whereas someone else (me, the wife) was making the choice for him.

The next few months were not fun. My husband had a lot of resentment. I was grateful and relieved that he had made the choice to stop and I didn't put any demands on how he worked it out. He told me that he didn't want to go to AA and didn't think he needed it. I told him that I didn't really care how he did it, as long as he got and stayed sober so that we could have a great marriage.

Still, we did not have a great marriage for several more months. I didn't trust him, he didn't like me very much. I wasn't sure that we were going to make it and built a contingency plan just in case I needed it. Dr Harley asked us on the call to commit to sending H to rehab if he drank again. I didn't know if I would even bother, if he kept on drinking.

I tried the best I could to work the MB program. My h did not want anything more to do with MB, so I didn't bring it up with him. As long as my h was generally pleasant, i stayed nearby, watched movies together. I found as much as I could to genuinely give him admiring compliments. I try to keep all love busters at bay. If he was being unpleasant, I'd either just get out of the away and give him space or I'd ask if there was anything I could do to cheer him up, and if not, I'd find something to do apart from him until/unless he got over his mood. So as long as he was acting ok, I spent as much time as I could with him. He started a new job and he wanted to talk about it often, so we did. He had almost entirely stopped initiating or accepting my advances soon after I stopped drinking, so the SF avenue had already been closed. Instead, we shared foot rubs, held hands in the car, etc.

Somewhere around month six or seven, things changed. It's like his resentment dissipated. He was pleasant and fun almost all of the time. He was interested in SF again. We got through several events with family/friends who were drinking, and he had sailed through them. He must have said something to his family, because no one batted an eye or said a negative word. He's just been happier, and our marriage has vastly improved.

From what I can see, he has not had a drink since that call. His attitude has changed and recently, it seems he's gained a new perspective on his past drinking. He is talking about things that happened in the past, framed as issues that were likely caused by drinking. He hadn't connected these things with drinking before. He identifies as a non-drinker now. He's been a type 1diabetic since he was a young boy, and for the first time as an adult, his blood sugars are in the "controlled diabetes" range! That stat gives me additional confidence that he's truly been sober.

Anyway, I typed all this out as a real-life recent example of Dr H's plan in action re: alcohol (or at least my attempt at following his plan, as I've not carried it off perfectly!)

I am not afraid of conflict, but I do pick my battles. I had- and still have- a "hands off" attitude towards my H's drinking. When he complained that I made the choice for him, I told him that I could understand why he'd feel that way, and that he was right because if I weren't insisting on it, he'd keep drinking. But I wanted him to know that I had tried for over a year to live with him drinking, and I simply could not continue to live like that. If he wanted to keep drinking, that was fine for him but I needed to leave so I could have peace in my life. I was always waiting for the shoe to drop if he was drinking. Sometimes he was ok but not always, and he couldn't control or predict when things would go sideways ( if he could control or predict it, he could ensure that things *never* went sideways.) I told him that I would stay and work with him to build an amazing marriage with him, but it was only possible if he stopped drinking. He hated it but agreed to it. I hope and pray that he continues on his current path.

I also wanted to agree with the other posters who say, don't worry so much about her anger. She is going to be angry. Maybe, like my husband, she will hold onto her anger and resentment for a long time. Hopefully she will move past the anger in time, if you're able to meet her ENs.

Lastly, re the "I'm not an alcoholic!" battle. On our call, Dr H told my husband that I was not an alcoholic because I was able to give up drinking easily. But, I was clearly a problem drinker and I made the best decision possible to quit. My husband was also at a minimum a problem drinker. He'd find out if he was addicted once he tried to stop, but problem drinker or alcoholic, the best way forward is sobriety.

I still go to AA. Nothing has changed for me. There are many of us there with "high bottoms", with few or no discernible consequences from drinking. Outside of AA I identify as a non-drinker; inside AA I self identify as an alcoholic, which simply means to me, someone who has problems if she drinks. For me it's much easier, and immeasurably better, to stay sober. I had a horrible time trying to moderate; it defeated me. I hope your wife is willing to go, it's such a great program!

I wish you and your wife the best of luck.


Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 01:03 PM
BedofRoses,

Thank you very much for sharing your personal experience with me, with us. And welcome to the MB Forum!

You story strikes a very similar chord. And I certainly appreciate hearing how, so far, things have taken a wonderful step in a positive direction.

I appreciate your support as of now I am devoted to making this work and saving my marriage.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 01:37 PM
My wife has been wonderful this weekend.

We haven't spoken about drinking or her commitment to stop drinking but I don't think we need to just yet.

Friday night we went Xmas shopping, took the oldest with us while he was in town. She was a little quiet, a little upset but she was conversing with me and for the most part was pleasant.

She arrived home Saturday night in a good mood. She spent the day shopping with her sister (who isn't a drinker) and a little time having dinner with her Mom ( who seldom drinks).

Yesterday was a good day. She continued to be in a good mood. She spent the majority of the day baking Xmas goodies. I helped where I could and even ventured out into town to get her some baking needs. We received a good half foot of snow Saturday night so the trip in wasn't just a fun little ride. She was very appreciative.

I don't know if she's noticed what I did while she was gone. She hasn't said anything.

I can't help but think she is really just a problem drinker. Regardless the end game as you have all said including Dr Harley is to simply quit drinking. I hope she comes to that same conclusion herself. However the horrible little guy that sits on my shoulder tells me this is nothing more than her trying to prove to me she isn't an alcoholic and that after a couple of months of abstinence she will be telling me it should be OK to let her go back to controlling her drinking.

Cross that bridge when we come to it. For now I am cautiously excited about her behavior/attitude.

Also I was very happy to hear back from her sister. She said she would keep my email to her a secret (for now) and that she will monitor her while she is there. She also provided me the history of what my wife would drink on days she stayed overnight at her home. She didn't drink much.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 02:21 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I can't help but think she is really just a problem drinker.

Please don't go down the rabbit trail again! The tendency is to minimize her drinking problem and when you do that, you tend to get into bargains for "controlled" drinking. Your wife is an alcoholic and you have been drawn into her alcoholic denial. Denial always leads to thought patterns that end with "I can handle it this time." I would just stop this narrative in your head now and move on. This is a dangerous narrative!!
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 02:34 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I don't know if she's noticed what I did while she was gone. She hasn't said anything.
You mean that you've cleared every scrap of alcohol from your home?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 03:48 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I can't help but think she is really just a problem drinker.

Please don't go down the rabbit trail again! The tendency is to minimize her drinking problem and when you do that, you tend to get into bargains for "controlled" drinking. Your wife is an alcoholic and you have been drawn into her alcoholic denial. Denial always leads to thought patterns that end with "I can handle it this time." I would just stop this narrative in your head now and move on. This is a dangerous narrative!!

I'd rather not bargain with her. So my mentioning this was to get some feedback on what to say when she comes to me in a couple of months and says "I did as you said. I proved to you that drinking isn't something I have to have. That I can quit drinking without it causing us any issues. I think I should be able to drink.".

This day is coming. She is only doing this for me and/or to prove me wrong. I highly doubt she plans to quit forever.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 03:51 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I don't know if she's noticed what I did while she was gone. She hasn't said anything.
You mean that you've cleared every scrap of alcohol from your home?

Not entirely. The beer which she could see is gone. Some of the wine is gone. Some of the wine I plan to give to friends and family is locked up in a liquor cabinet (hidden) and I have hidden the key. There is no alcohol in the home that she can see or get to.

She hasn't asked so I haven't told her where it went.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 04:24 PM
BTW I thought I would mention that our bar is really more of a kitchen. A whole room with cupboards. It has a sink, small cooler, counter-tops and yes on one end is a short bar top.

I have considered calling the cabinet shop and having them fit the room with a cupboard where the wine rack is today. Unfortunately finances are a problem right now so that'll have to wait until we can figure out a way to pay for it. I can't make financial decisions independent of her as it impacts the both of us.

And to tear it out would mean an eye sore left in its place. Either way one or the other will be a trigger for her. She will never agree with me making a decision to take an axe to it.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 05:26 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I can't help but think she is really just a problem drinker.

Please don't go down the rabbit trail again! The tendency is to minimize her drinking problem and when you do that, you tend to get into bargains for "controlled" drinking. Your wife is an alcoholic and you have been drawn into her alcoholic denial. Denial always leads to thought patterns that end with "I can handle it this time." I would just stop this narrative in your head now and move on. This is a dangerous narrative!!

I'd rather not bargain with her. So my mentioning this was to get some feedback on what to say when she comes to me in a couple of months and says "I did as you said. I proved to you that drinking isn't something I have to have. That I can quit drinking without it causing us any issues. I think I should be able to drink.".

This day is coming. She is only doing this for me and/or to prove me wrong. I highly doubt she plans to quit forever.

The day is HERE that you not get lost in these rabbit trails. She needs to commit to quitting for LIFE. If she cannot do that, then that is proof she is an alcoholic. Normal people don't continue to use substances that causes problems in their lives. That is the behavior of an alcoholic.

Think about her "logic." Lets say a person goes crazy and breaks out into a massive rash when they eat bananas. Wouldn't it be insane to just stop eating bananas for a couple of months and then go back to eating them? '

My point is that normal people just quit the substance that gives them problems.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 05:28 PM
By the way, you should know that it takes about 12 months for all the alcohol to leave her system. That means that it will take 12+ months for the anesthesia to wear off so her brain properly functions.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 05:31 PM
Every alcoholic knows how to play the game of quitting temporarily to get someone off their back. It is a game and you shouldn't play that game with her. Once again, a normal person just quits. So if she comes back and says she should drink again, you should point out that this demonstrates she CAN'T quit.
Posted By: HoldHerHand Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 08:32 PM
Well, if you are going to allow it to be more important than saving your marriage...



How about repurposing it into a coffee/desert bar? You could use the wine rack for coffee syrups.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 09:08 PM
Thanks for all of the helpful facts Mel. I certainly don't know much about this disease.

She won't quit on her own forever. My prediction. That she is doing as you say, quitting temporarily to prove some point to me. And thus providing her ammunition to tell me to get off her back about the drinking. I sense I've got a long and probably quite tiring road ahead of me should I decide to continue to fight for our M. Or a short trip to a new life. I don't like either option.

Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 09:26 PM
Originally Posted by HoldHerHand
Well, if you are going to allow it to be more important than saving your marriage.

Sorry, mini rant.

I, of course, would like to think I haven't allowed anything to be more important. I mean I come her to get guidance because these are things I know are important. However it is just one more thing I'd be trying to force upon her. One more time she looks at me like I'm the nut case that has his head screwed on backwards. In regards to her drinking at some point she needs to pony up and drive her own bus to sobriety. Then when she is there we can have an honest discussion about a dessert bar and syrup rack.

I believe in an integrated marriage as Dr Harley says. I definitely believe his principles lead to a happy and romantic marriage. I want that, I hope for each day. I, however, grow tired of feeling I'm the only one who seems to think there is more for us there. That what we have is half of what it could be, should be.

Tired of coming here being told how to have a happy marriage when I know what it takes to have it but can't seem to get there with a spouse who isn't on the same page as me. I so wish she'd have read Dr Harley and tried to push for his principles in our M. But it wasn't her. It was me, looking, hoping for more.

Tired of pushing for her to fix her drinking, having to tell her that I don't agree with her assessment of it and do things like pour money down the drain when she doesn't see the need.

She's happy with the status quo. I'm not. She says I'm never happy. She says that no matter what she does, in my eyes, there is always something wrong with her and that I am always trying to fix her. I am so tired of that aspect.

I want someone that wants to partner with me and not make me feel bad for the things that create issues for me, for us, in our M. Ya know what I mean?

End of mini rant. I needed to get that off my chest.
Posted By: HoldHerHand Re: anti-Celebration - 12/12/16 10:43 PM
So, coffee bar?
Posted By: markos Re: anti-Celebration - 12/13/16 04:17 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
In regards to her drinking at some point she needs to pony up and drive her own bus to sobriety. Then when she is there we can have an honest discussion about a dessert bar and syrup rack.

She can't get there now though because there's a BAR in her house.

Quote
Tired of coming here being told how to have a happy marriage when I know what it takes to have it but can't seem to get there with a spouse who isn't on the same page as me.

We don't just tell people how to have a happy marriage here.

We tell them what they can do to solve the problem when their spouse isn't on the same page as them and doesn't want to read Dr. Harley and use his principles and strive for more.

So

Coffee bar?
Posted By: HoldHerHand Re: anti-Celebration - 12/13/16 06:01 AM
Again, MR. A - your love bank is empty.

You've got enough time in here to know that.


You've got enough knowledge and experience cultivated from your time here to know exactly what you should be doing - but with an empty love bank, your taker bucks at every suggestion that you need do anything more.

However, you also know that as men, more is expected of us when it comes to creating a safe and romantic marriage.

You have the knowledge and tools to do this. Now find the will.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/13/16 02:00 PM
Thanks for all the advice and encouragement.

Right now she seems to be doing just fine (almost better than fine) without me taking any additional steps. So I guess I'm doing myself no favors by ruminating about what might happen in a couple of months, assuming she doesn't drink before then.

My preference, as I suspect her preference as well, would be to discuss the impact of the bar at a time when she's ready to discuss it. I'd much rather come to an agreement together than trying to continue to force my will on her.

And again, other than removing the wine rack and possibly the cooler there isn't a whole lot we can do at this time. We are already strapped for cash. So much so we, again this year, aren't exchanging gifts for each other.

How would one convert a mini kitchen with a bar to look like a coffee bar? My W hates coffee. That one confuses me. We have this beautiful lacquered Alder bar. We use it to eat at, simply gather around it to socialize, as well as drink.

Hot cocoa bar.

Hold, I'm not sure my tank is empty. So your response is giving me pause. I want to think about that a bit. Maybe I'm just being selfish or childish and letting my Taker dictate.

Posted By: Prisca Re: anti-Celebration - 12/13/16 02:33 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
My preference, as I suspect her preference as well, would be to discuss the impact of the bar at a time when she's ready to discuss it. I'd much rather come to an agreement together than trying to continue to force my will on her.
"I'd like to discuss the impact of that ring the OM gave her at a time she's ready to discuss it. I'd much rather come to an agreement together than trying to continue to force my will on her."

Do you really want her to stop drinking? Your reluctance to remove triggers makes me wonder ...

Quote
Maybe I'm just being selfish or childish and letting my Taker dictate.

You don't really understand the Giver and the Taker if you would call the Taker childish or selfish.
Posted By: markos Re: anti-Celebration - 12/13/16 02:35 PM
Originally Posted by Prisca
Quote
Maybe I'm just being selfish or childish and letting my Taker dictate.

You don't really understand the Giver and the Taker if you would call the Taker childish or selfish.

Your Taker is not bad, MrA. Your Taker is looking out for you. It is God-given. In this case it is protecting you from her Independent Behavior that is destructive to you AND her AND your children.
Posted By: markos Re: anti-Celebration - 12/13/16 02:36 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
My preference, as I suspect her preference as well, would be to discuss the impact of the bar at a time when she's ready to discuss it. I'd much rather come to an agreement together than trying to continue to force my will on her.

Do you want us to let you know if following your preference will work or not?
Posted By: markos Re: anti-Celebration - 12/13/16 02:38 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'd much rather come to an agreement together

Yeah, we'd all rather do that but
YOU CAN'T COME TO AN AGREEMENT WITH ALCOHOL IN THE PICTURE
so this is just an irrelevant fantasy.

Quote
than trying to continue to force my will on her.

Her drinking is HER forcing her will on YOU.
Having a bar is HER forcing her will on YOU.

You not tolerating her drinking is you preventing her from forcing her will.
You getting rid of the bar is you preventing her from forcing her will.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/13/16 06:02 PM
I'm being tag teamed. LOL.

Prisca and Markos. Thank you for the responses. I will re-read and respond later when I have some time.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/14/16 06:11 PM
Originally Posted by markos
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I'd much rather come to an agreement together

Yeah, we'd all rather do that but
YOU CAN'T COME TO AN AGREEMENT WITH ALCOHOL IN THE PICTURE
so this is just an irrelevant fantasy.

Quote
than trying to continue to force my will on her.

Her drinking is HER forcing her will on YOU.
Having a bar is HER forcing her will on YOU.

You not tolerating her drinking is you preventing her from forcing her will.
You getting rid of the bar is you preventing her from forcing her will.

Does it matter that she wouldn't see it as her forcing her will onto me, in fact, she sees it the other way around?

I'm sure the answer is no because it's related to her drinking but the fact is it does create resentment for her , albeit Resentment Type B. I'm quite certain she isn't familiar with A and B and in her eyes I'm the one doing stuff that makes her dislike me.

I'm up against others here. She came home yesterday with a gift from the gals from work. An ugly Xmas sweater with lots of pockets ... of course the pockets are filled with little bottles of booze. I was wondering why she felt off during a phone conversation we had while she was at work. I suspect she was dreading having to bring this gift home and show me. Yet when I got home and saw it she came to me and explained the story and said she thought it was a cute idea. I thought, well if you didn't have a problem with alcohol it might be cute.

I assume I'm to ask that she pour those out or should just do that myself. Me making another bold move, again in her eyes, forcing my will onto her. I suspect her response will be "I don't have a drinking problem, you are the one who is intolerant and incorrectly diagnosing me, so why do we need to pour out all the booze?".

She still hasn't commented about what I did this weekend. Ignore the elephant in the room. We're good at it.

She hasn't had a drink in over a week now. And she continues to be quite pleasant. We've had some nice conversations the last 4 or 5 days.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 02:49 PM
I recently texted my W after she informed me she was going out with a coworker after work. This means going to a bar and having drinks.

Text: I'm confused. You said you would stop drinking. I was very happy to hear you say that. I'm in the dark what your plan is for committing to doing just that. Sounds like you aren't committing after all.

Originally Posted by From:MrsAlias
My plan is that i will not drink at all for a time....so far i have been doing it and no problems. I feel resentment towards you sometimes and want to but only because i always want what i tell myself i can't have (this is why i don't do diets well). I was hoping that occasionally maybe we could have a glass of wine together but judging from your reaction last night when i brought a bottle home i am not sure your are up for that. I would still like to be able to have A drink with friends or maybe a couple on xmas eve with family and on New Years Eve. I am not sure how you feel about that. I think my plan is that it should not be an every day/week thing but occasionally. I agree that the softball thing is out of line and i know that i never felt right about it but went along with it anyway. I need to be stronger and do what i think is right and not let others influence me.

Not sure if this helps or not....is this something you can live with? I thought it was a good start, to show you that i am serious about the occasional thing, to call off tonight as we are going next week and thought two weeks in a row would be not as occasionally as i had planned.

Maybe its wierd but i always picture us curled up by the fire talking or doing a puzzle or something and maybe having a glass of wine or something. To me that sounds romantic but i think you believe that i have a problem with drinking so that it would only irritate you.

I have been reading stuff and understand that you think i have a problem. The things i have read say that it isn't necessarily a drinking problem but that we have a relationship problem. We need to fix that. I have to understand that it bothers you and show consideration for your feelings about it. I plan to do that. I am hoping we can work this out.

Let me know your thoughts.


Originally Posted by MrAlias
Thanks for the kind response. I am very happy you are openly discussing this with me.

I wish I could trust that you could control it. It�s been a problem for us for some time, unfortunately I�ve done my share of keeping it bottled up and now I have built an aversion to it. I feel triggered when I see it. Just to clarify, I don�t know if irritated is the right word. I try not to get angry about this stuff anymore because my anger only hurts me and certainly hurts you and our relationship. So I feel more hurt than anything. Us guys you know, we turn pain into anger. So I�m trying really hard to deal with this for what it is, a hurt not an irritant. The best way to avoid hurt is to avoid the things that trigger the pain.

I love your picture. I, too, imagine us having a very romantic marriage doing fun things like curling up, playing and enjoying each other. I so want that for us!!! Does drinking really have to be a part of it?

I want you to know I really don�t like what I feel I�ve had to do. I don�t want to parent/police you anymore than you want to be policed/controlled/etc. It�s taken me a long time to get to the point where I felt I needed to step up and say something. I�m very hopeful that we can work this out too.

I am very happy that you said this: "I have to understand that it bothers you and show consideration for your feelings about it."


Could we have a marriage where you drink in it? It�s hard for me due to the history. It feels like it is so important to you � but to me it�s just alcohol. I don�t need it to be happy. I need a great, happy, romantic marriage with you to be happy. I love you, I don�t want to be alone and I don�t want to be without you.

I would love it if you could prove to me and yourself that the drinking isn�t something you have to have. I understand skipping tonight because you wanted to avoid drinking. The fact you have to avoid a place to not drink doesn�t make me feel any better. Almost tells me the need for the drink is stronger than your will to not have one even though everyone else is. But all that talk is about making me feel better and doesn�t really answer the question about whether or not this is a disease or not. I don�t have any answers for you on this one.

I have a proposal but I�m not sure you�ll accept. I have been emailing back and forth with Dr Harley about our situation. I have been following his advice because he believes the drinking is a big hindrance to our marital happiness and I agree. He is well versed on alcohol and drug addiction. Would you be willing to exchange emails with him and get some advice from him? It�s free!!


I followed that up with:
Quote
Just so we�re clear � right now I would really like it if we stopped drinking. I know you think the timing sucks but there is never a good time. There is always a reason or influence that leads to drinking. Right now I�d like to put all our efforts into creating that picture we both want (minus the drink).
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 04:23 PM
Do I understand correctly from this that she;

1. Brought home a bottle of wine last night? How did she square this with not drinking? How did she manage not to drink it last night? Where is it now?

2. Has not touched a drop since your agreement?

3. Called off tonight's drink, but still plans to go next week?

4. Still hopes to "have A drink with friends or maybe a couple on xmas eve with family and on New Years Eve" - despite her pledge not to drink at all? And that she is still asking you for this privilege, as of this recent text? There is nothing in that text to suggest that she has abandoned that idea.

How is this "not drinking"? As far I can see, she does not promise not to drink. She is still negotiating how much she can drink over the Christmas season.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 04:31 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I recently texted my W after she informed me she was going out with a coworker after work. This means going to a bar and having drinks.

Text: I'm confused. You said you would stop drinking. I was very happy to hear you say that. I'm in the dark what your plan is for committing to doing just that. Sounds like you aren't committing after all.

Originally Posted by From:MrsAlias
My plan is that i will not drink at all for a time....so far i have been doing it and no problems. I feel resentment towards you sometimes and want to but only because i always want what i tell myself i can't have (this is why i don't do diets well). I was hoping that occasionally maybe we could have a glass of wine together but judging from your reaction last night when i brought a bottle home i am not sure your are up for that. I would still like to be able to have A drink with friends or maybe a couple on xmas eve with family and on New Years Eve. I am not sure how you feel about that. I think my plan is that it should not be an every day/week thing but occasionally. I agree that the softball thing is out of line and i know that i never felt right about it but went along with it anyway. I need to be stronger and do what i think is right and not let others influence me.

Not sure if this helps or not....is this something you can live with? I thought it was a good start, to show you that i am serious about the occasional thing, to call off tonight as we are going next week and thought two weeks in a row would be not as occasionally as i had planned.

Maybe its wierd but i always picture us curled up by the fire talking or doing a puzzle or something and maybe having a glass of wine or something. To me that sounds romantic but i think you believe that i have a problem with drinking so that it would only irritate you.

I have been reading stuff and understand that you think i have a problem. The things i have read say that it isn't necessarily a drinking problem but that we have a relationship problem. We need to fix that. I have to understand that it bothers you and show consideration for your feelings about it. I plan to do that. I am hoping we can work this out.

Let me know your thoughts.


Originally Posted by MrAlias
Thanks for the kind response. I am very happy you are openly discussing this with me.

I wish I could trust that you could control it. It�s been a problem for us for some time, unfortunately I�ve done my share of keeping it bottled up and now I have built an aversion to it. I feel triggered when I see it. Just to clarify, I don�t know if irritated is the right word. I try not to get angry about this stuff anymore because my anger only hurts me and certainly hurts you and our relationship. So I feel more hurt than anything. Us guys you know, we turn pain into anger. So I�m trying really hard to deal with this for what it is, a hurt not an irritant. The best way to avoid hurt is to avoid the things that trigger the pain.

I love your picture. I, too, imagine us having a very romantic marriage doing fun things like curling up, playing and enjoying each other. I so want that for us!!! Does drinking really have to be a part of it?

I want you to know I really don�t like what I feel I�ve had to do. I don�t want to parent/police you anymore than you want to be policed/controlled/etc. It�s taken me a long time to get to the point where I felt I needed to step up and say something. I�m very hopeful that we can work this out too.

I am very happy that you said this: "I have to understand that it bothers you and show consideration for your feelings about it."


Could we have a marriage where you drink in it? It�s hard for me due to the history. It feels like it is so important to you � but to me it�s just alcohol. I don�t need it to be happy. I need a great, happy, romantic marriage with you to be happy. I love you, I don�t want to be alone and I don�t want to be without you.

I would love it if you could prove to me and yourself that the drinking isn�t something you have to have. I understand skipping tonight because you wanted to avoid drinking. The fact you have to avoid a place to not drink doesn�t make me feel any better. Almost tells me the need for the drink is stronger than your will to not have one even though everyone else is. But all that talk is about making me feel better and doesn�t really answer the question about whether or not this is a disease or not. I don�t have any answers for you on this one.

I have a proposal but I�m not sure you�ll accept. I have been emailing back and forth with Dr Harley about our situation. I have been following his advice because he believes the drinking is a big hindrance to our marital happiness and I agree. He is well versed on alcohol and drug addiction. Would you be willing to exchange emails with him and get some advice from him? It�s free!!


I followed that up with:
Quote
Just so we�re clear � right now I would really like it if we stopped drinking. I know you think the timing sucks but there is never a good time. There is always a reason or influence that leads to drinking. Right now I�d like to put all our efforts into creating that picture we both want (minus the drink).
I think that all of your first text, apart from the suggestion to email Dr Harley, was unnecessary. It was rambling and unfocused, and it entered into the negotiations that she is trying to open up.

All you needed to say was what you said in your second text:

It upsets me when you drink. I do not like your drinking. Are you willing to avoid hurting me by giving up drinking altogether?"

You don't need to explain anything else, or answer any of her points. When you do that, it creates a situation in which you are trying to explain or justify your feelings; and the problem is that you will NEVER be able to explain or justify your feelings to her satisfaction, no matter how long you spend explaining them, or how thoughtfully you choose your words.

Don't agree with her picture...minus the glass of wine. Don't you see that the glass of wine is in fact the focal point of that picture? Take out the wine, and that isn't her picture. If you want her picture, you need to put the glass of wine back in it.

Just stop it.

Her drinking hurts you. Will she stop, in order to stop hurting you?

That's all you need to explain, and to ask.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 05:02 PM
1. Brought home a bottle of wine last night? Two nights ago, yes. How did she square this with not drinking? She didn't. Her commitment to me was a single statement. She would stop drinking. How did she manage not to drink it last night? She isn't drinking. For some reason she thought I'd be OK sharing it. I told her I'm not drinking. Where is it now? Right were she sit it down on the counter. It hasn't moved.

2. Has not touched a drop since your agreement? Correct.

3. Called off tonight's drink, but still plans to go next week? That was what she said yesterday. I informed her I don't want her to drink.

4. Still hopes to "have A drink with friends or maybe a couple on xmas eve with family and on New Years Eve" - despite her pledge not to drink at all? And that she is still asking you for this privilege, as of this recent text? There is nothing in that text to suggest that she has abandoned that idea.

How is this "not drinking"? As far I can see, she does not promise not to drink. She is still negotiating how much she can drink over the Christmas season.

Yep. She continues to place the importance of having a drink over the hurt it causes me. She hasn't responded to my email.

Even though I rambled as you stated, she knows what I'm saying. Her drinking hurts me. She wants to consider my feelings.

Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 05:37 PM
Thank you for clarifying.

I'l be back later, but for now, I also want to point out that her "informing" you that she was going out for the drink with a colleague is very Independent Behaviour, as well as breaking her pledge to you.

It isn't okay for either of you to "inform" the other of your separate social lives, and she should know this, since you have done MC coaching. You mesh your social lives together. You make plans to go out with each other, and you pretty much don't go out alone with other people. You can only go out with other people IF

1. Your UA time is regularly met, and is satisfying to both of you;

2. You ASK each other, rather than inform each other, about going out with other people, and;

3. Having been asked, you are enthusiastic about your spouse going out with those particular people, to do that particular activity.

When your spouse "informs" you of her plans to go out, none of those criteria is met.

Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 05:42 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
1. Brought home a bottle of wine last night? Two nights ago, yes. How did she square this with not drinking? She didn't. Her commitment to me was a single statement. She would stop drinking. How did she manage not to drink it last night? She isn't drinking. For some reason she thought I'd be OK sharing it. I told her I'm not drinking. Where is it now? Right were she sit it down on the counter. It hasn't moved.
I don't understand the bolded bits. if she isn't drinking, how did she expect you to "share" this bottle?

Did she bring it home for you to drink by yourself - she would not touch a drop? Or,

Did she bring it home for you to share with her - which means she would have some?

If she brought it home to share, why didn't she drink any of it? Did you tell her you did not want her to?

Where did she get it from? Did she go to a shop and buy it?

Why haven't you removed it from your home? For example, why didn't you offer to take it back to the shop for a refund?
Posted By: DidntQuit Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 05:54 PM
Alias, the way you talk to your wife gives the impression of wiggle room- that you are just trying this out.

Be clear and use the words that SugarCane gave you. Let your wife know that you need for both of you to stop drinking entirely forever. Let her know you dont want alcohol in the home, or for either of you to go on drinking dates with each other, friends or family.

Even if she agrees to stop, you have your work cut out because she is going to struggle. She is trying every avenue to get you to bend, then she may raise the volume.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 06:01 PM
Originally Posted by DidntQuit
Alias, the way you talk to your wife gives the impression of wiggle room- that you are just trying this out.


Agree 100%. There are holes so big a wetbrain could drive a MAC through it!! You are not being clear and forthright at all. You need to be very very forthright and specific with an addict.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 06:06 PM
While this is written for adulterers, the principle is the same because they are both addicts:

Originally Posted By: Dr. Harley Effective Marriage Counseling pg 94
"Granted, there are situations when demands may be necessary in marriage. During a spouse's affair, for example, I recommend that the betrayed spouse demand there be no contact with the lover. If there is continued contact, separation or even divorce would be the logical consequence. While normally demands don't work, in this case there are no reasonable alternatives because thoughtful requests are even less likely to separate lovers."
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 07:01 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Thank you for clarifying.

I'l be back later, but for now, I also want to point out that her "informing" you that she was going out for the drink with a colleague is very Independent Behaviour, as well as breaking her pledge to you.

It isn't okay for either of you to "inform" the other of your separate social lives, and she should know this, since you have done MC coaching. You mesh your social lives together. You make plans to go out with each other, and you pretty much don't go out alone with other people. You can only go out with other people IF

1. Your UA time is regularly met, and is satisfying to both of you;

2. You ASK each other, rather than inform each other, about going out with other people, and;

3. Having been asked, you are enthusiastic about your spouse going out with those particular people, to do that particular activity.

When your spouse "informs" you of her plans to go out, none of those criteria is met.

We aren't following MB. She isn't 100% on board even after counseling with Jennifer. She buys into pieces of it but not all of it.

I wish that was different but it isn't. I continue to communicate that I would like for us to have a happy, romantic M but we simply don't today. It has it's moments but they are fleeting. Throw in a drinking problem and it's a total sham.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 07:08 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
[quote=MrAlias]1. Brought home a bottle of wine last night? Two nights ago, yes. How did she square this with not drinking? She didn't. Her commitment to me was a single statement. She would stop drinking. How did she manage not to drink it last night? She isn't drinking. For some reason she thought I'd be OK sharing it. I told her I'm not drinking. Where is it now? Right were she sit it down on the counter. It hasn't moved.
I don't understand the bolded bits. if she isn't drinking, how did she expect you to "share" this bottle? I have no idea. I am still upset that she brought it home. I chose not to make a scene at the time seeing the kids were standing there. I don't know if she knows I spoke to them about her drinking and her commitment to quit. I don't do well in the moment so I avoided bringing it up right then and there. I was certainly disappointed.

Did she bring it home for you to drink by yourself - she would not touch a drop? Or,

Did she bring it home for you to share with her - which means she would have some?

To share. My response. "I am not drinking." I can only control myself.

If she brought it home to share, why didn't she drink any of it? Did you tell her you did not want her to?

Where did she get it from? Did she go to a shop and buy it? I don't know where. I was upset and let her know I wasn't going to drink. That was the end of the conversation.

Why haven't you removed it from your home? For example, why didn't you offer to take it back to the shop for a refund?
Probably because I'm lazy and to some extent want her to take some ownership of this problem. I've been fighting for us for quite some time and have the same mantra year after year, it's not good, it's not totally horrible, when is it bad enough?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 07:18 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[

We aren't following MB. She isn't 100% on board even after counseling with Jennifer. She buys into pieces of it but not all of it.

But, do you buy into it? It doesn't sound like you do yourself so it has not been an issue.

I see a pattern here, my friend, where you avoid conflict by being vague and unclear with your wife so she never really understands what you mean. This is especially damaging when dealing with an addict because addictions are much more powerful than ones feelings about the marriage. You can see this is the case.

Please note I didn't say "alcoholic" because I don't want to go down that rabbit chase with you again. Let's just agree that she is obviously addicted and can't quit.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 07:20 PM
Originally Posted by DidntQuit
Alias, the way you talk to your wife gives the impression of wiggle room- that you are just trying this out.

Be clear and use the words that SugarCane gave you. Let your wife know that you need for both of you to stop drinking entirely forever. Let her know you dont want alcohol in the home, or for either of you to go on drinking dates with each other, friends or family.

Even if she agrees to stop, you have your work cut out because she is going to struggle. She is trying every avenue to get you to bend, then she may raise the volume.

It becomes an argument. I think she has a drinking problem, she doesn't think it is one.

I have told her it hurts me, she says she wants to consider my feelings, I am hanging my hat that she is sincere and will stop drinking because I AGAIN asked her to stop.

"Just so we�re clear � right now I would really like it if we stopped drinking. "

I did reread this part and the RIGHT NOW words shouldn't be in there. That is where the wiggle room shows up.

So to provide better clarity I sent this:

Quote
Sorry, even that message wasn�t clear.

I would love it if we stopped drinking completely, forever. I see that as the only way this is going to work. I would like to replace what you associate with drinking to something else we do together, as a couple, that builds a happier, stronger marriage.

Is that something you could live with?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 07:22 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
Where did she get it from? Did she go to a shop and buy it? I don't know where. I was upset and let her know I wasn't going to drink. That was the end of the conversation.

Why haven't you removed it from your home? For example, why didn't you offer to take it back to the shop for a refund?
Probably because I'm lazy and to some extent want her to take some ownership of this problem. I've been fighting for us for quite some time and have the same mantra year after year, it's not good, it's not totally horrible, when is it bad enough?

This is all conflict avoidance. Waiting for her to "take ownership" of an addiction is conflict avoidance. Thats why your marriage is no better after being here for 13 years.

What should have happened is that you should told her that she has to stop drinking 100% for life. Your kids should have been informed that she is an alcoholic and they are to tell you if they see her drinking. So when she brought the booze home you could have told her - RIGHT IN FRONT OF THE KIDS - "please take that alcohol out of our home, you told me you would stop drinking."
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 07:24 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
While this is written for adulterers, the principle is the same because they are both addicts:

Originally Posted By: Dr. Harley Effective Marriage Counseling pg 94
"Granted, there are situations when demands may be necessary in marriage. During a spouse's affair, for example, I recommend that the betrayed spouse demand there be no contact with the lover. If there is continued contact, separation or even divorce would be the logical consequence. While normally demands don't work, in this case there are no reasonable alternatives because thoughtful requests are even less likely to separate lovers."

Thanks Melody, you of all people have seen me struggle to be the type of person who can follow through with these requests or demands. Guilty or fearful feelings or whatever, it sometimes takes every ounce of my being to move in the right direction.

I come here and get the right feedback from you (and others) and I get there ... eventually. You wouldn't believe the struggled conversations I have with myself, knowing I have the advice that is the right advice yet struggling to get out of my own way to follow through.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 07:26 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by DidntQuit
Alias, the way you talk to your wife gives the impression of wiggle room- that you are just trying this out.

Be clear and use the words that SugarCane gave you. Let your wife know that you need for both of you to stop drinking entirely forever. Let her know you dont want alcohol in the home, or for either of you to go on drinking dates with each other, friends or family.

Even if she agrees to stop, you have your work cut out because she is going to struggle. She is trying every avenue to get you to bend, then she may raise the volume.

It becomes an argument. I think she has a drinking problem, she doesn't think it is one.

I have told her it hurts me, she says she wants to consider my feelings, I am hanging my hat that she is sincere and will stop drinking because I AGAIN asked her to stop.

"Just so we�re clear � right now I would really like it if we stopped drinking. "

I did reread this part and the RIGHT NOW words shouldn't be in there. That is where the wiggle room shows up.

So to provide better clarify I sent this:

Quote
Sorry, even that message wasn�t clear.

I would love it if we stopped drinking completely, forever. I see that as the only way this is going to work. I would like to replace what you associate with drinking to something else we do together, as a couple, that builds a happier, stronger marriage.

Is that something you could live with?

Honestly, MrAlias, why so wimpy?

Dear wife, your drinking hurts me terribly and has for years. I am asking that you stop drinking forever. If you can't stop drinking on your own, I would be willing to help you by seeking out treatment centers. I want to have a happy, fulfilling marriage and that can only happen if you stop drinking.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 07:27 PM
After you send that, then tell the kids what is going on and dump out the liquor. You can't take a timid approach to an addiction, I assure you. She is an EXPERT at looking for loopholes. As you can see!!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 07:33 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Honestly, MrAlias, why so wimpy?

Trying to avoid the tone that is going to lead to a big blow up. I grew up with a mother who was notorious at big blow ups. Everything blown out of proportion. I have a wife who admittedly digs in her heels if someone try to force their will on them. I avoid those tenuous moments by trying a softer approach.

She will be upset that I'm making a demand the way I just did, no big surprise. I can feel the tension building already. It's my hope that what I get back as a response is something I can deal with calmly and intelligently. I'm not the sharpest tool in the chest when I get triggered.


Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 07:52 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I have no idea. I am still upset that she brought it home. I chose not to make a scene at the time seeing the kids were standing there. I don't know if she knows I spoke to them about her drinking and her commitment to quit. I don't do well in the moment so I avoided bringing it up right then and there. I was certainly disappointed.

Did she bring it home for you to drink by yourself - she would not touch a drop? Or,

Did she bring it home for you to share with her - which means she would have some?

To share. My response. "I am not drinking." I can only control myself.

If she brought it home to share, why didn't she drink any of it? Did you tell her you did not want her to?

Where did she get it from? Did she go to a shop and buy it? I don't know where. I was upset and let her know I wasn't going to drink. That was the end of the conversation.

Why haven't you removed it from your home? For example, why didn't you offer to take it back to the shop for a refund?
Probably because I'm lazy and to some extent want her to take some ownership of this problem. I've been fighting for us for quite some time and have the same mantra year after year, it's not good, it's not totally horrible, when is it bad enough?
We would never advise that you make a scene. I don't quite know what kind of "scene" you meant, but it sounds as if blowing up and having an angry or tearful outburst was the alternative to saying nothing. As you know, those things should never be done.

Your kids have already been told about her problems with alcohol and that you want this to stop, and that you might ask for their help soon, so why was this something you felt you could not put your foot down about in front of them?

And when she said "I brought this home. I thought we could share it", your response should have been to remind her that she'd agreed to stop drinking, not to tell her that YOU are not drinking.

I think you have already been very direct in your request that she stop drinking for good. I agree with your earlier statement that she knows exactly what you want her to do. Now, you need to be like a broken record when she brings up drinking.

"You agreed to stop drinking altogether. It hurts me when you drink."

"Please do not bring alcohol home. You promised to stop drinking altogether."

"Please do not go out drinking with your colleagues. You promised to stop drinking altogether. It hurts me when you drink."

You need to give the same message, all the time: "Please do not drink, as you promised, in order to stop hurting me".
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 09:45 PM
Something else that really stands out to me is the fact that you are in the habit of ignoring the elephant in the room. Were you aware this is a dysfunctional trait of alcoholic families? Everyone pretends like there is not a problem. So when she brought the bottle of alcohol home, it should have been openly addressed.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 09:59 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Something else that really stands out to me is the fact that you are in the habit of ignoring the elephant in the room.

Totally aware ... and it is not confined to the drinking either.

Again we don't have an integrated relationship. It is far from an MB marriage. I should be able to talk to her about this stuff without any issue. But we don't see eye to eye on all areas of our relationship and tend to ignore the elephant that arises from that.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/21/16 10:02 PM
Quote
We would never advise that you make a scene. I don't quite know what kind of "scene" you meant, but it sounds as if blowing up and having an angry or tearful outburst was the alternative to saying nothing. As you know, those things should never be done.


Agreed. And I am never sure whether or not I can control my response when I've been triggered so I walk away or avoid the confrontation to ensure I don't have an AO or say something stupid (DJ).

The scene could be created by me.
Posted By: AnyWife Re: anti-Celebration - 12/22/16 02:16 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Honestly, MrAlias, why so wimpy?

Trying to avoid the tone that is going to lead to a big blow up. I grew up with a mother who was notorious at big blow ups. Everything blown out of proportion. I have a wife who admittedly digs in her heels if someone try to force their will on them. I avoid those tenuous moments by trying a softer approach.

She will be upset that I'm making a demand the way I just did, no big surprise. I can feel the tension building already. It's my hope that what I get back as a response is something I can deal with calmly and intelligently. I'm not the sharpest tool in the chest when I get triggered.

Except that you are not really "making a demand" rather, you are giving your wife valuable information about the true state of your marriage and what you are no longer willing to tolerate.

Take a look at Melody's wording again:

"Dear wife, your drinking hurts me terribly and has for years..."
1. You are informing her, clearly, how you feel about something she is doing that affects you and the family.

"I am asking that you stop drinking forever."
2. You are asking , not demanding.

"If you can't stop drinking on your own, I would be willing to help you by seeking out treatment centers."
3. You are offering to help her.

"I want to have a happy, fulfilling marriage and that can only happen if you stop drinking."
4. You are telling her the standard for what you want from your marriage - a happy fulfilling marriage - and letting her know that you will not feel happy and fulfilled as long as she is drinking.

Your wording was probably more likely to result in conflict because it is confusing and comes across as manipulative - your words completely leave the door open for her to do whatever she wants, but you both know you're trying to get her to do something (stop drinking). Also, it's clear you're trying to avoid conflict and seems weak in a way that I don't think is attractive to most women.

I am an extremely conflict avoidant person and it definitely has not served me well over the years. But I have found magic and some strength in learning to word things the way Melody worded that. "This is what I am feeling." "This is what I need to be happily married." If she blows up, or you feel tempted to, definitely walk away, but don't back down or appear uncertain about your message. Be prepared with good wording in advance and if she twists things, just be a broken record with your reasonable request.

And it is simply a request. And, if the reality is that you are not willing to continue to be married to her under the current circumstances, she has a right to know that. You need to be CLEAR with her.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/22/16 02:05 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[

We aren't following MB. She isn't 100% on board even after counseling with Jennifer. She buys into pieces of it but not all of it.

But, do you buy into it? It doesn't sound like you do yourself so it has not been an issue.

I see a pattern here, my friend, where you avoid conflict by being vague and unclear with your wife so she never really understands what you mean. This is especially damaging when dealing with an addict because addictions are much more powerful than ones feelings about the marriage. You can see this is the case.

Please note I didn't say "alcoholic" because I don't want to go down that rabbit chase with you again. Let's just agree that she is obviously addicted and can't quit.

Sorry Mel, I see I skipped over this response, probably along with some others. Thanks for the continuing guidance.

You asked if I buy into it. I do. I envision how this program will make my M be the happy, romantic marriage I so desire. I do things like spend time on this forum to help others as well as continue to learn or keep my MB knowledge fresh. I listen to the radio show in spurts. Good weeks at least 2 or 3 programs a week. I reread articles especially ones that are linked in forum threads that feel relevant or are of interest to me.

It does come down to my habit of avoiding conflict. I've always been this way. Having confrontations is very stressful for me. The adrenaline floods into my system and I get very nervous, shaky and it's all I can do to keep the lid on any emotion (which is usually anger) that pops up. I typically email her to have these difficult conversations to avoid the confrontational situations.

And yes I do tend to try to feather in what I intend to say to her. Which then comes off, most likely, vague and unclear as you've said. My guess, I do things this way to avoid the confrontational feeling and also because I have empathy for my W and feel, to some extent, that I'm forcing my will onto her (which if I word it correctly (which I suck at) I know I'm not). She certainly communicates to me that she feels forced to change. My lack of wording the request correctly and the fact we really don't have a habit of focusing on providing extraordinary care to each other is the reason she feels forced. We aren't as integrated as we need to be.

I would love it if she was 100% on board. She's told me flat out she's not. Doesn't believe it is important that we spend tons of time together. Agrees we should spend time together having fun but there's no way she's giving up going back to see her sister and to take care of the horses she boards there.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/22/16 02:07 PM
Quote
Take a look at Melody's wording again:

"Dear wife, your drinking hurts me terribly and has for years..."
"I am asking that you stop drinking forever."
"If you can't stop drinking on your own, I would be willing to help you by seeking out treatment centers."
"I want to have a happy, fulfilling marriage and that can only happen if you stop drinking."


Thanks AnyWife and thanks again Melody.

I feel as if I need to carry these around on index cards and pull them out every time the drinking conversation (and her negotiating) begins.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/22/16 02:13 PM
No response from her. She worked late and when she did arrive she was pretty cold. Which was expected.

She was communicative with the kids but pretty short with me. I chose not to talk about the elephant again. She has told me when faced with tough decisions she does need time to absorb and respond.

We were supposed to go grocery shopping together. We have our Xmas menu ready to go, just need the stuff. I asked if we were going to go last night. She said no she'd do it on her way home tonight. I said I'd love to do it together and that I could just meet her there. She declined, said she would take care of it.

Pretty upset, I'm sure , and needs to avoid me. This will probably go on for quite a few days, maybe weeks. I'll do what I can to stay positive and be pleasant to be around, but I don't think this is going to be a wonderful Holiday.
Posted By: SusieQ Re: anti-Celebration - 12/22/16 04:30 PM
Didn't Dr Harley suggest an intervention but you held off on that since you had an agreement from her? Maybe it is time for that to happen now...
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/22/16 05:34 PM
He said if she drank then that was the next step. So far she hasn't had a drink. She has insinuated that she was going to drink. I've since explained that I'm asking her to stop entirely forever.

Maybe I should email him the latest.
Posted By: SusieQ Re: anti-Celebration - 12/22/16 06:32 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
He said if she drank then that was the next step. So far she hasn't had a drink. She has insinuated that she was going to drink. I've since explained that I'm asking her to stop entirely forever.

Maybe I should email him the latest.
I think that would be good because my understanding of his advice was based on the premise that your wife agreed to quit when she hasn't done that at all. She's bring home alcohol and still trying to negotiate with you and being cold when you won't give in. She hasn't really agreed to quit at all.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/22/16 07:18 PM
Thx Suzie. I did send Dr Harley another email.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/27/16 01:41 PM
We made it through the In-Laws without a hitch. Others were drinking while MrsAlias did not. She was obviously not happy with me as she spent most of the night cold and avoiding me to some extent. The car ride home afterwards was very quiet.

We had a nice Xmas. Hunkered down at home all weekend and for the most part yesterday. Things are a little more normal between her and I. Less frigid. We spent some time alone, doing a puzzle, watching a movie.

Still no physical affection yet, no touching, hugging, etc. I'll be looking to move in that direction this week. Doing my part to find plenty of UA time together. We have nothing on the calendar unless she still plans on going out with that coworker later this week. Last night, when I asked if she had any plans this week she said she couldn't think of anything. It's possible she has decided to give up on that idea knowing I don't want her to drink.

She was in a great mood yesterday. I was so tempted to ask why.

Here is what Dr Harley provided in response to me last week.
Quote
Your wife's letter is very sincere, and I hope that she is able to stick to her agreement not to drink. The idea of curling up by the fire or doing a puzzle together with a glass of wine sounds great except for the glass of wine part. Your reaction to her bringing home a bottle of wine was great. As long as you stick to your guns and don't let up on your commitment to have an alcohol-free home with no one in the family drinking, even at social events, you will eventually have victory over it. The problem you will have in your relationship is that up until two weeks ago, your wife enjoyed being with you if she was drinking at the time. She will have a very difficult time enjoying your company without alcohol, and that goal should be something that you both work to achieve: How can she be happy with you if alcohol is not part of it?
Dr. Harley
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/27/16 01:57 PM
A little off topic and yet it is not off topic.

Our eldest son was picked up for OWI Sunday before last. The night before he and a couple of hometown girls that go to his college went back to his college town to be with their friends. It is less than an hour away. He was drinking, obviously, said he slept some, woke up late as he had to work near home and was speeding to make up his lost time. Was pulled over and taken in where he blew under the legal limit for an adult but in WI there is a zero tolerance rule for underage drinking and driving. He was charged with OWI which carries the same penalties as an over-the-age over the legal limit driver.

I took this opportunity to discuss one on one with him the dangers of drinking. He's in college so I'm not na�ve to the things he's exposed to. I told him if he thinks he's adult enough to drink then he needs to make better decisions. Use wiser judgment. There was no need to go to this party when he knew he had to work early the next morning. "Someone could have been hurt or killed with your recklessness. What do you think your employer was going to do when he smelled alcohol? He would have fired you."

He will learn his lesson through inconvenience and be hit financially. He'll lose his license for 6 to 9 months and he will be responsible for any fees, fines, etc and the additional cost of insurance. His days of having extra money to go play are over for quite some time.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/27/16 02:41 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
He will learn his lesson through inconvenience and be hit financially. He'll lose his license for 6 to 9 months and he will be responsible for any fees, fines, etc and the additional cost of insurance. His days of having extra money to go play are over for quite some time.

MrA, he will learn much more than that!! Is he being charged with a felony?
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/27/16 02:42 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
We made it through the In-Laws without a hitch. Others were drinking while MrsAlias did not. She was obviously not happy with me as she spent most of the night cold and avoiding me to some extent. The car ride home afterwards was very quiet.

We had a nice Xmas. Hunkered down at home all weekend and for the most part yesterday. Things are a little more normal between her and I. Less frigid. We spent some time alone, doing a puzzle, watching a movie.

Still no physical affection yet, no touching, hugging, etc. I'll be looking to move in that direction this week. Doing my part to find plenty of UA time together. We have nothing on the calendar unless she still plans on going out with that coworker later this week. Last night, when I asked if she had any plans this week she said she couldn't think of anything. It's possible she has decided to give up on that idea knowing I don't want her to drink.

She was in a great mood yesterday. I was so tempted to ask why.

Here is what Dr Harley provided in response to me last week.
Quote
Your wife's letter is very sincere, and I hope that she is able to stick to her agreement not to drink. The idea of curling up by the fire or doing a puzzle together with a glass of wine sounds great except for the glass of wine part. Your reaction to her bringing home a bottle of wine was great. As long as you stick to your guns and don't let up on your commitment to have an alcohol-free home with no one in the family drinking, even at social events, you will eventually have victory over it. The problem you will have in your relationship is that up until two weeks ago, your wife enjoyed being with you if she was drinking at the time. She will have a very difficult time enjoying your company without alcohol, and that goal should be something that you both work to achieve: How can she be happy with you if alcohol is not part of it?
Dr. Harley

SO HAPPY that you are receiving support from Dr. Harley!! I know this is very hard for you but you are doing just great. Hang in there, because your reward will be great if you tough this out.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/27/16 04:12 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
MrA, he will learn much more than that!! Is he being charged with a felony?

In WI a first offense OWI isn't even considered a misdemeanor let alone considered a felony. A first offense is considered a civil offense. However it is only considered that in WI and if he ever plans on moving this "ticket" will be on his record forever and it will have consequences for a very long time.

He'll be paying high-risk insurance for anywhere from 3 to 7 years and at 19 years of age the costs will be extremely pricey.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/27/16 04:19 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
In WI a first offense OWI isn't even considered a misdemeanor let alone considered a felony. A first offense is considered a civil offense. However it is only considered that in WI and if he ever plans on moving this "ticket" will be on his record forever and it will have consequences for a very long time.

Is there a way he can get this expunged from his record entirely? Alcohol related offenses can be the kiss of death at most companies. My son had a very hard time getting a job at my company because of a possession of alcohol charge when he was 19. [class c misdemeanor] We couldn't even hire him until the full 7 years had passed because we go back 7 years.

Before that, he couldn't even get a job selling furniture at a furniture store or qualify to rent an apartment!
Posted By: SusieQ Re: anti-Celebration - 12/27/16 04:32 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
We made it through the In-Laws without a hitch. Others were drinking while MrsAlias did not. She was obviously not happy with me as she spent most of the night cold and avoiding me to some extent. The car ride home afterwards was very quiet.

We had a nice Xmas. Hunkered down at home all weekend and for the most part yesterday. Things are a little more normal between her and I. Less frigid. We spent some time alone, doing a puzzle, watching a movie.

Still no physical affection yet, no touching, hugging, etc. I'll be looking to move in that direction this week. Doing my part to find plenty of UA time together. We have nothing on the calendar unless she still plans on going out with that coworker later this week. Last night, when I asked if she had any plans this week she said she couldn't think of anything. It's possible she has decided to give up on that idea knowing I don't want her to drink.

She was in a great mood yesterday. I was so tempted to ask why.

Here is what Dr Harley provided in response to me last week.
Quote
Your wife's letter is very sincere, and I hope that she is able to stick to her agreement not to drink. The idea of curling up by the fire or doing a puzzle together with a glass of wine sounds great except for the glass of wine part. Your reaction to her bringing home a bottle of wine was great. As long as you stick to your guns and don't let up on your commitment to have an alcohol-free home with no one in the family drinking, even at social events, you will eventually have victory over it. The problem you will have in your relationship is that up until two weeks ago, your wife enjoyed being with you if she was drinking at the time. She will have a very difficult time enjoying your company without alcohol, and that goal should be something that you both work to achieve: How can she be happy with you if alcohol is not part of it?
Dr. Harley

SO HAPPY that you are receiving support from Dr. Harley!! I know this is very hard for you but you are doing just great. Hang in there, because your reward will be great if you tough this out.

x2!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/27/16 06:16 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
In WI a first offense OWI isn't even considered a misdemeanor let alone considered a felony. A first offense is considered a civil offense. However it is only considered that in WI and if he ever plans on moving this "ticket" will be on his record forever and it will have consequences for a very long time.

Is there a way he can get this expunged from his record entirely? Alcohol related offenses can be the kiss of death at most companies. My son had a very hard time getting a job at my company because of a possession of alcohol charge when he was 19. [class c misdemeanor] We couldn't even hire him until the full 7 years had passed because we go back 7 years.

Before that, he couldn't even get a job selling furniture at a furniture store or qualify to rent an apartment!

We are lining up a consult with a DUI Lawyer. Seeing he passed the field sobriety test we have a little bit of hope we can get the charges reduced. At this point in time we are not too familiar with the laws and what his options are. We have a couple of referrals from friends on good lawyers.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 12/27/16 07:22 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[

We are lining up a consult with a DUI Lawyer. Seeing he passed the field sobriety test we have a little bit of hope we can get the charges reduced. At this point in time we are not too familiar with the laws and what his options are. We have a couple of referrals from friends on good lawyers.

I am relieved you are doing this. When my son was 19, little did we ever understand how devastating a little minor in possession would be to his future. He wasn't even driving or drinking but there was a beer in the car. He has a great job now, only because my company only checks back 7 years, but there are many companies that go back 10 years. And I discovered that most apartment complexes go back FOREVER.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/03/17 03:09 PM
We meet this afternoon with the lawyer to discuss the drinking and driving offense. The assistant and the law office made it sound like there may be an opportunity to get the number of penalty points on his license reduced. I'm hopeful there's more than just that.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/03/17 03:13 PM
Here's the latest email I just sent to Dr Harley.

Quote
Dr Harley,

I thought I�d provide an update. It�s not the best news.

We had some terrible drama with our daughter this weekend and that has put a lot of our talks on hold. We busted her for lying about an upcoming set of plans that would never be approved by us and as such she had a bit of a fit and ended up running away from home. We had no choice but to involve the police. She spent a couple of days away at a close friend of the family. She is back home now, we sat down and discussed everything and we have a plan in place where we will discuss things rationally instead of what took place Friday. We told her we�re willing to negotiate her options for having fun but in the end we still have veto power over those things we feel could be unsafe for her.

My wife continues to avoid alcohol. She still communicates that I�m wrong in my assessment and I continue to tell her I�m not assessing anything other than her drinking hurts me and I cannot live with it. That I don�t want to live with the triggers and feelings it brings when I see her drink. She has the backing of all her enabler family and friends. Mother In Law who lived with a now passed away alcoholic, her sister who is her best friend who now lives with an alcoholic (they don�t have much of a relationship) and a couple of her coworkers who are her drinking companions. None of these people agree with what I�m doing. These are people my wife will not distance herself from. So that�s working against me here.

Meanwhile I have your support, the support of the forum and the support of my kids, my sister and brother in law and a couple of good buddies.

My wife doesn�t believe in some of your concepts. Despite having counseled with your daughter Jennifer and having read several of your books she simply just doesn�t agree with all of the concepts. For instance, she isn�t a believer in your POUA concept. She feels time apart is good so long as that time apart is doing something that makes that person feel happy and fulfills their life. In other words I don�t think my wife agrees in what you would call an integrated marriage where the most enjoyment one receives necessarily has to come from their spouse. That to some extent we�re too separate people having lives and activities together but also apart. I know if a couple can find that balance that�s fine but we do not have that balance. If I had to give you a number of our UA hours it would be a single digit number and probably a very low single digit number. Nowhere near what you would suggest in your teachings.

I continue to discuss with her the idea of finding things we like to do together so that our time has more quality to it. Today she does her thing like crochet while I�ll work on the computer, work out or play video games. We�re in the same house, we talk, mostly about necessary stuff like the kids our finances, etc and she feels that connection is enough.

She has told me she is going to seek her own form of marriage counseling and for some reason I am not allowed to attend. I�m at a loss there. She tells me there is more than one way for us to get help and that many of the teachings of MB just don�t work for her.

So I�m at a loss on what to do. I am not ready to separate although I�m sure that is mainly because I am scared of starting over and am a master at capitulating/procrastinating. I would love to spend the rest of my days with my wife. I just don�t know if we will ever have what I would consider to be a happy, romantic relationship.

I feel like my back is against the wall here. That I either do one of two things, follow the MB concepts which I�m thinking is going to lead to a separation or I allow her to lead us to some other form of help. I know all the statistics about failed marriage counseling. It�s my hope she finds someone that would agree with your concepts. I�m in wait and see mode there.

I am growing weary having to deal with this. Feeling like on the one hand I�m fighting for my marriage and on the other hand having my wife make me feel that all our problems are of my own doing. That I�m suddenly way to over the top trying to apply the MB concepts.

Any advice for me?

You must all think I'm a terrible father seeing all these things are happening. They're coming in bunches right now that's for sure.

I know we have a loving household. We express our love for each other on a daily basis. Our kids are good kids but are certainly making some horrible choices. Some days I feel things are spinning out of control. I'm doing what I can to keep our family unit functional.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 01/03/17 03:31 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
You must all think I'm a terrible father seeing all these things are happening. They're coming in bunches right now that's for sure.

I know we have a loving household. We express our love for each other on a daily basis. Our kids are good kids but are certainly making some horrible choices. Some days I feel things are spinning out of control. I'm doing what I can to keep our family unit functional.
Thanks for updating us, MrA. The letter to Dr H is really clear, so he should be able to give you advice.

I think it highly unlikely that anyone will think you are a bad parent. Almost all of us will have had similar episodes with our kids. I know that with my own two, the older child, our daughter, has been...basically...perfect, excelling academically and doing well in her employment, with no teen drama to speak of, while the younger child, our son..well, where to start. I won't thread jack except to say that it is hard for me to see how two kids, brought up in the same family, given similar opportunities and stimuli (music lessons, constant trips all over the UK, and to museums etc, holidays abroad, hugely loving and supportive extended family) could be so different. If my son hadn't been born at home, I'd swear he'd been swapped at birth!

I do know, from my readings on the private forum, that Dr Harley advises that we do not "tell teenagers what do". This surprised me greatly when I first read it, but I've seen in consistently from him, and I think that he will tell you the same thing.

He is very much against being a disciplinarian with teenagers, or forbidding them to do things, as this often leads to running away, as you have seen, or self-harming. His advice with daughters tends to be to hold your breath until her teen years are over, and pray. With sons, if they are difficult, encourage them to leave home in their late teens.

Anyway, I hope you print his reply here.

The friends and family enablers that you speak of lead me baffled. Who thinks it is a good idea to drink? Everyone I know is cutting down, and many of my friends and colleagues are giving up alcohol for January ("Dry January"). I'm going to keep dry for as long as I can, after January is over.

Who the heck (over the age of 25) encourages people to drink????
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/03/17 04:22 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
I think it highly unlikely that anyone will think you are a bad parent. Almost all of us will have had similar episodes with our kids.

I do know, from my readings on the private forum, that Dr Harley advises that we do not "tell teenagers what do".

He is very much against being a disciplinarian with teenagers, or forbidding them to do things, as this often leads to running away, as you have seen, or self-harming. His advice with daughters tends to be to hold your breath until her teen years are over, and pray. With sons, if they are difficult, encourage them to leave home in their late teens.

SC thanks for sharing the personal comparison. I do agree with what you said and what Dr Harley states as being the best answer. Our discussion with her evolved around us working together as a team to find a solution we could all be happy with (POJA). We told her we don't like to demand things but we do have requirements in an effort to keep her safe. So if she can find ways to ensure she's safe (within our comfort levels) then she could have more freedom than she believes she has.

The whole episode was a temper tantrum on her part and she admits she just got mad and lost it.

Originally Posted by SugarCane
The friends and family enablers that you speak of lead me baffled. Who thinks it is a good idea to drink? Everyone I know is cutting down, and many of my friends and colleagues are giving up alcohol for January ("Dry January"). I'm going to keep dry for as long as I can, after January is over.

Who the heck (over the age of 25) encourages people to drink????

I wouldn't say they are necessarily encouraging her to drink (well the coworkers do, as they're drinking buddies (infrequently)) but they are certainly disagreeing that is has to be an all or nothing thing. I guess that means they're telling her it's OK to drink but not necessarily saying she should go ahead and do it. If that makes sense.

Other than her sister none of these folks have heard my reasons why I'm asking her to quit. So I suspect the conversation with them was more along the lines of "My H thinks I'm an alcoholic and that I can't control my drinking. So he says I should stop entirely". Instead of saying "When I drink it hurts my H and thus he's asking me to not drink.".
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/03/17 04:56 PM
Originally Posted by DrHarley
Hi MrAlias,
It's common for the spouse of an alcoholic to think that most if not all of their marital problems are due to the spouse's drinking. And many of them are. But once the drinking stops, the rest of the problems of the marriage come through in living color. It becomes very clear that without alcohol, they have very little in common. You formed your relationship with her through a common habit of drinking together. When that was taken away by your decision to stop (which is very wise), what kept you together was removed. Now you are faced with the reality that you have very little in common, and must create a relationship from scratch. Your constant effort to reach her will probably pay off eventually, but it will be a very frustrating process.

I advise you to continue on the path you are following. Continue to ask her to join you in life, to become equal partners, meeting each other's needs, avoid hurting each other, and making decisions together. The MB plan is a plan of extraordinary care which is clearly to her advantage once she shakes herself loose from the long-term effects of being an alcoholic. You are her rescuer, even though she does not see that right now. Some day, however, she will. I hope you will still be married when that day arrives.
Dr. Harley
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 01/03/17 05:01 PM
Thanks for posting this. Some of us like to have access to Dr H's advice, so that we can use it in the future.

I'll see if I can find anything from the private forum on the teenager issue.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 01/03/17 09:06 PM
It's hard, because his advice on teenagers is buried in threads that often do not have teenagers in the title. However, I found these. They are replies to three different posters:

Originally Posted by Dr. Harley
The less you tell your son (or wife) what to do, the easier they will both be to get along with. Your son's disrespect toward your wife is partly a function of his age (most teenagers are disrespectful) and partly a function of what he sees at home. Your best bet at this time in his life is to let him know that his disrespect hurts his mother, and pray that the time that it takes for him to develop an adult mind goes by quickly. I would not punish him at his age if I were you, and instead, try to treat him with the respect that you expect of him.

Originally Posted by Dr. Harley
Another rule of thumb is that teenagers should not be punished. I know that may sound ridiculous to some, but my experience helping countless parents raise their children is that teens respond very negatively to punishment. While it may be difficult to find effective alternatives, punishment does more harm than good in helping a teen adjust to adult life.


Originally Posted by Dr. Harley
Privileges such as cell phones, computers, driver's licence, etc. are at the discretion of parents and can be given as rewards for good behavior or taken away when that good behavior stops. When I talk about punishing, I refer more to physical punishment or grounding. I know of many cases where grounding has led to running from home or even attempted suicide.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/04/17 01:27 PM
Quote
Privileges such as cell phones, computers, driver's licence, etc. are at the discretion of parents and can be given as rewards for good behavior or taken away when that good behavior stops. When I talk about punishing, I refer more to physical punishment or grounding. I know of many cases where grounding has led to running from home or even attempted suicide.


That's an interesting set of statements.

I guarantee you my daughter would much rather be grounded to the home than have her phone taken away. These kids nowadays live on their phones. My DD is the queen of Snapchat. I think she's going for a world record or something.

On our first go around with her back in early November we grounded her for a month, took her phone for a month and took away her DL for 3 months. To receive such a large punishment was due to her doing the following: Driving with more than one person in the car (illegal), not going where she said she was included driving miles and miles out of our hometown into Minnesota (we live in WI) and then not sleeping at her friend's house but rather sleeping in an apartment with a girlfriend (not her best friend) and 5 males AND ZERO parents. I say males because the one boy she is involved with is 18 and no longer in high school.

We were totally blown away by her behavior. And at that point we hadn't ever had to ground her. So out of character for her.

WHO THEY HANG WITH IS VERY IMPORTANT!!!!

We experienced that again this weekend when she strayed from her normal set of softball buddies to another friend who we thought was an angel. Well she's no angel that's for sure.

This time around we told her we want to negotiate situations and treat this like adults would. We did ground her for 2 week, didn't take her phone nor extend her DL suspension. She was quite happy that that is all we handed down to her.

So what we did kind of goes against what DR Harley mentions ... but then times are changing some and what kids value is changing as well.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/04/17 01:35 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
We meet this afternoon with the lawyer to discuss the drinking and driving offense. The assistant and the law office made it sound like there may be an opportunity to get the number of penalty points on his license reduced. I'm hopeful there's more than just that.

My son decided to hire the lawyer. There's a good chance that my son could have plead not guilty on his own and then tried to negotiate to a lesser charge outside of court. However after talking with the attorney we were more comfortable having a professional handle the negotiation process. It will cost my son some money, maybe $1000 or so but for a comfort level this felt like money well spent.

The lesser charge will still require he lose his license but for a shorter time, it will still show on his record as a drinking offense but it will not appear as a OWI (also called DWI or DUI) and his auto insurance will still be impacted but possibly to a lesser degree (that may all depend on whether or not they drop the speeding charge during negotiations).
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 01/04/17 02:34 PM
MrA, the biggest concern would be how this will show on his background checks when applying for jobs. My company is pretty typical and he would not be able to work here with that on his record. WE go back 7 years and some companies go back 10. I hope your son's atty will fight this more aggressively so its not on his record.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/04/17 02:56 PM
Originally Posted by MelodyLane
MrA, the biggest concern would be how this will show on his background checks when applying for jobs. My company is pretty typical and he would not be able to work here with that on his record. WE go back 7 years and some companies go back 10. I hope your son's atty will fight this more aggressively so its not on his record.

According to the attorney there is no way to remove this from his record. It will go down on record with the courts and so any company that does background checks may find it. They, however, will need to go looking for it.

In Wisconsin a first offense like the one we hope he's able to plead down to is not considered a crime and so he will not be required to list it on any application in the future.

According to the attorney this is the best we can hope for. To be honest, he committed some serious violations. He was excessively speeding and we was, in all honesty, over the legal limit of .08 when he was pulled over. He blew a .07 at the police department around 1 hr and 45 minutes later.

I think if we're able to get this reduced in anyway will be a blessing.

If the prosecution wants to be pricks they could sell a jury on him being over the legal limit. My son was very polite and cooperative so hopefully that makes a difference when the attorney discusses this with the DA's office.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/04/17 05:44 PM
I don't really have a question for the forum but I did want to share something that's weighing on my mind in the near future.

Saturday is the wife's company Xmas party. They take us to a restaurant and yes there will be alcohol there. The wife has committed to going so I'm committing to go with her. I could have pushed more for not going but I didn't. that's the downside.

The upside is there may be an opportunity for me to talk with her coworkers who enable her drinking and don't agree with my all or nothing philosophy.

They obviously don't understand what this drinking has done to our relationship.

I won't initiate it but if I'm put on the defensive I will explain the reasons why and ask them for their support in helping our marriage to heal.

They're nice ladies and I cannot see them taking a stance that abuse in a relationship is good in any way. As a matter of fact the one person is divorced from a very physically abusive man and she also lost a daughter to a heroine overdose. So I would think she would fully understand my position and would support the decision.

Edited to add: My wife has already brought our troubles to these 2 ladies. I'd rather not air our dirty laundry to them but I also won't be beat down by a bunch of enablers.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/04/17 07:39 PM
Wait I actually do have a question.

Quote
I won't initiate it but if I'm put on the defensive I will explain the reasons why and ask them for their support in helping our marriage to heal.


Is this a bad idea? Should I be sure not to air our dirty laundry to these folks? My wife has asked for their opinion and they don't agree with the request I've made.

They're also just outside observers and have no idea the kind of ordeal this has created for MrAlias and I. So do I even bother or just suck up any heat they send my way? I can take the heat but I'd prefer not to. Do I ask my wife to leave if they do or do I take the time to explain what this means for me?

Posted By: BrainHurts Re: anti-Celebration - 01/04/17 08:59 PM
Are you enthusiastic about going to this Christmas party?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/04/17 09:12 PM
Originally Posted by BrainHurts
Are you enthusiastic about going to this Christmas party?

Yes. There are a lot of nice people that my wife works with and I enjoy their company. They provide a nice meal at a nice restaurant and while there is drinking there it isn't a party where it excessive.
Posted By: unwritten Re: anti-Celebration - 01/04/17 09:50 PM
I personally would suggest you not go to this party MrAlias.

At this very pivotal point in your situation, where your wife has agreed to not drink and is seemingly sticking to that for now, I would not risk putting her in a social environment with alcohol and friends that are supportive of her drinking. This is just setting her up for failure IMO.

I would also not feel the need to defend yourself and your boundaries in your marriage to coworkers. It is not fair for YOU to be put in that position.

Avoid this mess all together. Your time would be better spent on a nice date doing something fun together.
Posted By: Prisca Re: anti-Celebration - 01/05/17 04:45 AM
Quote
This is just setting her up for failure IMO.
I agree.
A couple can enthusiastically agree to do something that is destructive to their marriage. This is one of those things. She doesn't need the temptation, and she doesn't need the reminder of what she can't have.

You don't seem to really understand triggers, and just how dangerous they are ...
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/05/17 01:36 PM
Thanks folks but my wife will never agree to NOT go to this party.

I'm in the position of trying to implement the principles I have learned here with a partner that isn't on board. So I'm having to make the best of any situation.

I agree this isn't the best situation for anyone and I'll most likely get a bunch of the Mrs' cold shoulder during the party. However this is an opportunity to show her that I, at least, can be pleasant and make life's moments enjoyable without having to drink to get there.

I may be taking Dr Harley's advice in the wrong context in this situation but I see it as the best alternative I have given she isn't onboard with his advice AT ALL. If I state we shouldn't go, which I did once and she chose to ignore, she will say she'll go without me "I already committed, the company has spent the money for our plates, etc, etc. Feel free to stay home if you want but I'm going.".

Our oldest son works part-time for my wife so he will be there as well and he is definitely on board with my request that she stop drinking. He's hesitant to say too much to her given his recent drinking violations, doesn't want to come off sounding hypocritical.

I fully understand triggers. The world is full of them when it comes to alcohol. Like it or not she is going to have to learn how to deal with those situations. My hope would be that she avoid them entirely but me mandating that we avoid them isn't going to make her work with me.

Given she isn't on board with the principles and workings of the POJA I have literally zero ability to negotiate this with her and demands just make her retreat from me even more.

You can tell me all you want about how we should avoid these situations, I agree. That doesn't help me get there without further alienating my wife.

Sorry for all of the defensive talk. I get it and I agree with what you're saying. I'm walking a fine line here, trying to implement the strategies, following the advice Dr H provided without having to ask him my every move, yet working with a spouse who tells me Dr H isn't right for her and that there is more than one way to cross the road. She is exploring another way supposedly.

I say that knowing full well I may be tossed from this place. That if I'm not going to follow MB that there is nothing this place can do for me and I'll only be distracting posters from helping those who are willing to implement its strategies.

My hope is that whomever she finds to counsel her/us that that person is onboard with the concepts here or has very similar philosophies and they become a part of what her and I work towards in the future. I am educated on the failures and successes of marriage counseling having been here for a very long time and hearing all of the great posts that make this so clear for me. So I'll be sure to bail out of any counseling that sends us down a bad path.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 01/05/17 02:16 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
Thanks folks but my wife will never agree to NOT go to this party.

I'm in the position of trying to implement the principles I have learned here with a partner that isn't on board. So I'm having to make the best of any situation.

What principle are you implementing here? You are violating every MB concept by making a sacrifice and by doing something you know is marriage wrecking. All of your justifications are served up to avoid the conflict. At the end of the day, your wife shouldn't be in a drinking environment and you shouldn't be going with her. Even if she refuses to not go, you shouldn't be going, which only shows you condone her actions.

Quote
I agree this isn't the best situation for anyone and I'll most likely get a bunch of the Mrs' cold shoulder during the party. However this is an opportunity to show her that I, at least, can be pleasant and make life's moments enjoyable without having to drink to get there.

I may be taking Dr Harley's advice in the wrong context in this situation but I see it as the best alternative I have given she isn't onboard with his advice AT ALL. If I state we shouldn't go, which I did once and she chose to ignore, she will say she'll go without me "I already committed, the company has spent the money for our plates, etc, etc. Feel free to stay home if you want but I'm going.".

This is the worst thing you could do. It just shows her you aren't really serious about the drinking. It makes no sense whatsoever to take her to a drinking environment. You should take a strong stand against this and refuse to go.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 01/05/17 02:19 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
My hope is that whomever she finds to counsel her/us that that person is onboard with the concepts here or has very similar philosophies and they become a part of what her and I work towards in the future. I am educated on the failures and successes of marriage counseling having been here for a very long time and hearing all of the great posts that make this so clear for me. So I'll be sure to bail out of any counseling that sends us down a bad path.

She is just trying to find someone who won't ask her to do things that are good for her marriage. She doesn't like that MB has rules that put the marriage first. But, you wont have a marriage if she doesn't do that, regardless of who tells her.

Your posts are very irrational, MrA. You are back in conflict avoidance mode, spinning as fast as you can.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/06/17 03:13 PM
Quote
Dr Harley
I need some quick advice.

I posted on the forum about a company Xmas party my wife committed us to which takes place tomorrow evening. It's a dinner and if people want drinks they can purchase them.

In a perfect world my wife would admit to her drinking being a problem and agreeing not to go to this party. I myself enjoy visiting with these folks and it's a nice gesture the company puts forward. It's a very small company very family like and friendly.

My wife will go without me if I tell her that I think we should skip it. The forum says I shouldn't go. I thought I'd make the best of it and try to make it a fun but no alcohol night.

MrsAlias continues to not drink but also continues to be a bit cold to me. I figured this as an opportunity to show her that we can have fun but don't need to drink to do it.

Making a demand that we don't go will make her extremely angry and I feel will make matters worse. Me staying home doesn't provide the opportunity for us to be together having an enjoyable time. I'm trying to move us back together by continuing to look for ways for us to connect.

Can you please provide your thoughts?


Originally Posted by DrHarley
My general reaction is that your wife should not go at all, but if she goes, you should go with her. It will not be fun for her if you expect her to avoid alcohol. And she may deliberately do some of the things that bothered you even though she isn't drinking. It's a lose-lose situation for you. The fact that your son got a DUI should reinforce your position that your family should all be alcohol free. There should be no alcohol in the house, and when you have guests over, you should not serve alcohol.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/06/17 07:01 PM
Quote
The purpose of the Marriage Builders web site is to help you to create and implement a plan to resolve your conflicts in a way that will restore and sustain your love for each other. While many of my suggestions run counter to intuition, hundreds of thousands of couples have found that they work if they are willing to create a plan using my Basic Concepts. My Basic Concepts introduce you to my perspective on marriage, and how I go about creating plans that help make marriages successful.


What I wouldn't give to, once again, create and implement a plan. I've made attempts over the years to put the good doctor's plan into effect in our M. Only to find out, after making a joint concerted effort to use MB, that she still isn't on board, isn't a believer.

It is very disheartening to go home every day to a life where there is no mutual plan and a wife who provides a fairly cold shoulder. I'm spending my energy trying to create a MB type R best I can but there is little desire on her part to use the POJA, POUA or PORH. I'm left wondering what, if anything, is going to give that moves us in a direction of being romantically in love again.

She has acquiesced to my request of not drinking while being resentful and openly displaying her emotions to that effect. There has been no communication that indicates how long she'll remain a non-drinker and certainly no sign of how long she'll remain resentful.

I'm taking her out on a date tonight. A movie and then maybe a coffee, hot cocoa afterwards. Date night so no R talk.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/06/17 07:07 PM
The point being is if I were able to have this plan there would less need for me to ask for advice on how to resolve these conflicts that arise.

The answers would work themselves out using PORH and POJA.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 01/06/17 07:34 PM
Hi MrA, I am glad you are communicating with Dr Harley; hopefully he can help you work this out. Getting your wife to stop drinking is a monumental step.

What is your plan if nothing ever changes?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/06/17 08:02 PM
It breaks my heart to say it but I don't think I can live with her if she decides drinking has to be a part of it. While there may be opportunities to negotiate other parts of our marriage and improve on them the drinking has really become a trigger for me and creates all kinds of negative thoughts for me. It makes it hard to look at her in a favorable light.

I've seen enough of her over the years have trouble letting go of habits, especially the bad ones.

I haven't really explored how I would make that step of separation. Doing so will put our entire family in a tailspin of change (financially and emotionally). I don't know where I'd go, what I could afford to do, etc.

I've heard many people being told they should make those plans. I haven't done so yet. I'm clinging to the fact she isn't drinking and hopeful she won't ever again. I'd love for her to decide she doesn't want to drink instead of not drinking just because I asked. I know it's not my fault we are in this predicament yet I feel I'm on the receiving end of the all the bad sentiment, etc. I do have my supporters but I wish my biggest one was my wife.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/06/17 08:04 PM
As far as her and I not being able to create a romantic marriage ... separation may be our only option. If she cannot put this little issue behind us and work towards something fantastic I wouldn't want to settle for what we have right now.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 01/06/17 08:56 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
As far as her and I not being able to create a romantic marriage ... separation may be our only option. If she cannot put this little issue behind us and work towards something fantastic I wouldn't want to settle for what we have right now.

Gotcha.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/09/17 05:59 PM
Update:

Friday I took the Mrs out for a bit. We went to see a movie. She was quiet still chilly. After the movie I asked if we could go do something else, like find some hot cocoa and something to nibble on. She said no. She just wanted to go home. Got home and she headed straight downstairs to watch TV shows with our daughter. Obviously didn't want to be around me.

We went to bed around the same time and I asked if I could ask her a few questions.

I started with a statement. "It appears you are very upset with me still and don't want to really do much with me. I'm feeling a little lost as I don't know if we have anything for a plan to work this out."

"I am still angry.".
"That I've asked you not to drink?"
"That and because you spoke to our kids about the drinking and told them you were thinking of separating."
"I see. And you think I shouldn't have told them".
"No. That's just wrong. You've just added more anxiety for them. Now they're worried about us splitting up."
"I see. Well I figured our relationship greatly impacts them and that they should have as much information they need so they can respond accordingly. Also I was looking for support as your drinking is a problem for me. I feel they have a right to know that too and they can respond how they see fit."
"What you and I do is no business of theirs."
"I don't understand? We're their parents. Are you saying we should shelter them from the truth in an effort to protect their current feelings? How do you think they'll feel if and when we approach them to say we're splitting up? There would have been a lot of shock for them."
"There is nothing they can do to change what happens between you and I."
"Hmm. I guess I see it differently. I think now that they're aware they can talk openly to you about how your drinking affects them and they can also persuade us to work on our M."
"I still think it is wrong and I am still very upset that you did it."
"I'm sorry. I am trying to save this marriage. That is why I did it. You have been cold to me since I asked you to stop drinking. You're civil but cold and practically ignoring me most days. I have been trying to interact with you but it doesn't seem to help. We don't have a plan and I feel lost and not sure where we're going. What are we going to do, if anything, to fix this?"
<silence>
"Last we spoke you said you were going to seek your own counseling. Do you still plan to do that?"
"I have set up an appt but can't get in until February."
"Oh, OK. I had no idea. Is this something we're doing together?"
"No. I'm going alone. ... at least initially".
"Alright. And what is this person?"
"She is a family and marriage counselor."
"Ok. I hope she has a good plan for helping couples fix their marriage. What do we do in the meantime?"
"I don't know. I'm resenting you right now and although it comes out that way I am not trying to punish you. I don't go home thinking I'm going to be mean to you."
"Gotcha. I hear what you're saying but it is hurtful. It's hard for me to continue to push for some positives. I'm hurting from the whole drinking thing and now I'm having to live with your resentment and the behaviors exhibited from that. It's hard for me to see a light at the end of the tunnel."
"What would be your plan?"
"My plan would be for you and I to work the program we learned about. We didn't follow through the first time we tried. Your statements to me in the recent past tell me you don't believe it works."
<more silence>
"Anyways that's about all I wanted for now. I just wanted to know something was going to happen. I'm hoping we can make this work. I know we can be happy and have a romantic marriage. I love you. I hope you have a good night."
"I love you too. Good night."

The next day we went our separate ways for a while. She needed to find an outfit for her Xmas party. Yes we went. Her, my son and I went to the party (he works there part time). We had a very nice time. My wife was in a good mood. We had some nice conversation even with each other.

She's been a little less cold since we spoke Friday night.

I continue to treat her with respect and kindness and look for fun things to do together. I don't know what the future holds. Not sure what's going to come out of this counseling that won't happen for weeks upon weeks.

I started a conversation with her sister a couple weeks back and this weekend she provided some insight. Seems my wife wants what she has.

Her and her alcoholic H don't do much together. He tries to control his drinking. He does stuff for her. They cohabitate but also have fun together teasing each other etc. Seems that's enough for them to be in love with each other. She does the best she can knowing he admits to be an alcoholic and continues to drink.


My sister says if the positives of her don't outweigh the negatives then maybe I'm asking her to change too much and that maybe we just aren't right for each other and should call it quits. My wife has told her she just doesn't think whatever she does it will ever be good enough for me.

I don't know. All I ask is that she try to maintain a healthier lifestyle (eating and booze related), we rid our home of what looks like hoarding, we align our schedules so I'm not the only cook in the house and we spend more time together having fun and we build a romantic marriage together where my needs are met regularly.

I guess for my wife that's asking too much.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: anti-Celebration - 01/09/17 09:44 PM
Did she drink at the Christmas party?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/10/17 01:23 PM
No. She won't drink because she knows I don't want her to.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/10/17 01:33 PM
The counselor she made an appt. with had a cancellation and my wife will be going in today to see her. Not that I think anything will come of it. I will ask her questions about it when we're home tonight.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 01/10/17 02:10 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
My sister says if the positives of her don't outweigh the negatives then maybe I'm asking her to change too much

I know your sister means well, but this is the kind of destructive advice that most "marriage counselors" aka divorce facilitators give. Dr. Harley warns about it here:

Originally Posted by Dr Bill Harley
Since most marital therapists fail to address the romantic love issue when they try to help couples, their approach to conflict resolution usually fails to build love, and as a result, the couples divorce, even after "resolving" some of their conflicts.

An example of this current effort to "resolve" marital conflicts is found in a book by Jacobson and Christensen, Integrative Couples Therapy (Norton, 1996). In this training manual for marital therapists, couples are to be encouraged by their therapists to lower their marital expectations by becoming more understanding of each other's dysfunctional background. Irreparable wounds inflicted during childhood should inspire empathy toward a thoughtless spouse, not disappointment. Awareness of each other's limitations should lead to acceptance of each other's behavior and a willingness to meet one's own needs, instead of expecting each other to meet those needs. The suggested goal of therapy is to teach each spouse to make themselves happy, and not look to each other for their happiness. While this approach to therapy may resolve a couple's conflict, it most certainly will not lead to love. When couples follow this advice, few love units are deposited and many are withdrawn. In the end, the couple is likely to divorce.

The same sort of advice is given in Getting the Love You Want by Hendrix (Holt Rinehart, & Winston, 1988). While the book title seems to address the issue of romantic love in marriage, the author's strategy for couples is to learn to accept each other's marital failures, rather than doing anything to overcome them. I guarantee you, if you follow this strategy, you will NOT get the love you want.

My experience, and the experience of a few others who are carefully studying what it takes for a couple to be satisfied with their marriage, proves the opposite of what is currently being popularly recommended. Instead of spouses trying to lower their expectations, I believe that they should raise them. Instead of spouses learning to meet their own emotional needs, I believe that they should expect to have them met by each other, and met in a professional manner. Why? Because that's what it takes for a couple to be in love and stay in love. Furthermore, couples should not waste their time trying to "understand" each other's failures, but rather, they should try to overcome them as quickly as possible so the issue does not have time to drain their Love Banks.
here

I hope you aren't giving into the pressure to relent on your request for her to stop drinking. I realize its very hard for you to deal with conflict and hope you realize that conflict avoidance only leads to more conflict down the road.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/10/17 02:48 PM
Thanks for the feedback Melody.

I misspoke, it's my sister in law not my sister. I am fully aware of what she does with her life is very different than what I know to work.

The world needs a plan. Dr Harley is the only one that I know of that has a fool proof plan for making a marriage great IF BOTH PARTIES are engaged in following the plan.

She hasn't been pressuring me to release my request for her to drink. I'm not positive but I'm thinking I may be seeing a light at end of the tunnel on this subject. But then again that may just be wishful thinking.

I did encourage her recently to considering seeing a professional about the drinking. Alcohol counseling is an eligible HSA expense. Marriage counseling is not. Her claim was she didn't want to see a professional and we can't afford it. So now she knows it's just that she doesn't want to that is the obstacle.

Time to end this stupid debate her and I have had in the past about the level of her drinking problem. The other day I said this to her when the subject of alcoholism came up. "Your drinking hurts me and I'm asking you to not drink. If you have an addiction you should get yourself some help and get that resolved. I'll be here to support you in any way I can. I want us to get past this and move on to the great marriage I know we're going to have.".
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 01/10/17 03:55 PM
Just keep standing strong!! You are doing great...
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/10/17 03:59 PM
She gave me the name of her counselor. Another EFT, EMDR therapist. Drumming up trauma from the past. Man I hope not. We all know that that really doesn't help.

This lady counselor does have experience with chemical abuse patients so maybe there is some good that could come out of her counseling.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 01/10/17 07:11 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
This lady counselor does have experience with chemical abuse patients so maybe there is some good that could come out of her counseling.
There won't be, though, unless your wife says that she is addicted.

If your wife tells her that she is a perfectly reasonable drinker, who likes the occasional glass of wine at home, and likes going out with her friends for one or two, and that you are trying to control her and ruin her fun by stopping her from drinking altogether, just because you've stopped, and that you ruined Christmas and New Year by letting her know that you'd be miserable if she drank, the counsellor will not act as a "chemical abuse" counsellor. She will act as an individual counsellor who tells your wife that she needs to take back control of her own life.

The counsellor will only know what your wife tells her.

I know it isn't your fault your wife is using her. I just don't want you to hold out any hope for a good outcome.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/10/17 07:38 PM
Understood. Thanks SC.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/11/17 01:42 PM
MrsAlias said the counseling session went well. First visit was more debriefing than anything of course. However she did say her and the counselor talked about ways to help MrsAlias with her anxieties.

I am invited by the counselor to come to her next session if MrsAlias is up for it. I told her to let me know if and when she decided that it was OK for me to attend. Sometime in early February.

Meanwhile she continues to be in good spirits and is very pleasant around me. So at least that stressor is gone for now.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/11/17 02:02 PM
I forgot to mention that I will be bringing my MB knowledge with me to every session with this counselor. I'm going to encourage this lady to help us use this program to its fullest so her and I can move forward. I'll just have to be careful how I bring it to her attention. Basically I will spout the MB principles as if they are my principles (I am a firm believer).

If she's not on board and provides us with harmful advice and strategy I will have to have a discussion with her about her not being able to help us solve our marital issues.
Posted By: Prisca Re: anti-Celebration - 01/11/17 03:52 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I forgot to mention that I will be bringing my MB knowledge with me to every session with this counselor. I'm going to encourage this lady to help us use this program to its fullest so her and I can move forward. I'll just have to be careful how I bring it to her attention. Basically I will spout the MB principles as if they are my principles (I am a firm believer).

If she's not on board and provides us with harmful advice and strategy I will have to have a discussion with her about her not being able to help us solve our marital issues.

I've never seen this work, with other people who've tried it, and in my own experience with counselors. They'll agree to "help" you with MB, but they've got their own training and beliefs and are considered the "expert" when you hire them, so they're just going to do their own thing. Even if they say they agree with MB.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/11/17 05:03 PM
Then it's my hope the counselor helps my wife with her personal junk. I won't be committing to trying something that will only propel us towards divorce.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/25/17 01:55 PM
Quick update.

Not a lot to report. Things are moving in a more positive direction between MrsAlias and I. I'm putting in the effort to get in the UA time we need. Right now UA time consists of conversation, rec time and small amounts of affection. We kissed yesterday for the first time in months.

She has had 2 counseling sessions. Not much revealed by her about these sessions. She keeps a lot of stuff in and lately I've been really concerned that one of our biggest obstacles is a lack of PORH. Moreso it feels like I have to draw information and her feelings from her. Those conversations are always ... awkward ... and so they don't happen often.

Her and her counselor have asked me to join them for a joint session next Wed Feb 1st. I'm a bit anxious concerning this meeting. I am prepared to tell the counselor I don't think her plan is going to work for me if it, in fact, deviates from Dr Harley's plan.

On a good note I have been having private conversations with MrsAlias's sister who is best friend and confidant. Her S said she seemed much happier that last time they spoke. She said whatever I was doing to keep it up as it seems to have given MrsAlias some hope for the future. I'm puzzled by this as all I've done is stuck to my MB principles best I can. I think her biggest concern was that MB was going to tell her she couldn't have any relationships, hobbies outside of me. She asked if she could go back to spend time with her S and her horses. I said I have no issues with her doing things outside of us so long as her and I were getting and adequate amount of time meeting each other's needs. Maybe she misunderstood what the intention of the program was. Not sure as she hasn't said anything other than she was happy to hear she could still spend time with her S.

I'm hopeful MrsAlias is getting over her resentment about having to stop drinking and her resentment thinking I was wrong to discuss her drinking and our M to our kids.

I also told my W that I was very encouraged that she had quit drinking and that I was now excited to explore many of the things we did together or talked about doing as couples that I used to dread because it meant alcohol was going to be involved.

So maybe those 2 things are making a difference for her. I will be discussing these topics with her and her counselor next week.

Meanwhile I've got some nice plans for us to get out and get in some quality UA time. Things are limited here in the Great White North as I hate, hate the cold. lol. But there are plenty of indoor things we can do until the big thaw.

So that's my quick update. Things feel better. At least I feel a bit better. Not so gloom and doom anymore.

I'll be ecstatic if the counselor gets us both on the MB page again. That may be a pipe dream.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: anti-Celebration - 01/26/17 02:09 AM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
We kissed yesterday for the first time in months.
So your UA time isn't including SF?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 01/26/17 01:43 PM
Originally Posted by BrainHurts
Originally Posted by MrAlias
We kissed yesterday for the first time in months.
So your UA time isn't including SF?

Nope. I can't force myself or her into it. I'm sure I'll be ready sooner rather than later. I can't speak for when she'll be ready.

Also my health hasn't allowed it to be an option for quite some time. I've been dealing with some kind of sinus, bronchial infection for a very long time. Had pneumonia around Thanksgiving and by the time that cleared I caught a nasty cold around Xmas. I'm almost back to normal today. 2 rounds of antibiotics in the last 2 months haven't been able to heal me to 100%. I have an ear( inner ear - Eustachian tube) that has been plugged for over 3 weeks. Hearing impaired. Everything sounds like I'm underwater. Feels pretty good today. First day in a long time. She won't come near me if I'm sick.

SF has always been an issue in our M. I hold myself accountable assuming that I haven't done the things needed to create enough romantic love to make SF appealing. I say that knowing that my W believes there are different ways (other than Dr Harley's methods) to create that feeling of love.

I have a bunch of ideas I've been planning to do for date nights that I'm sure she will like. I hoped to start last weekend but the inner ear stuff caused a nasty 3 day case of positional vertigo. Incapacitated.

I am going to keep pushing to implement all of the principles without making it feel like I'm shoving MB down her throat. Best way for me to do that is to avoid saying anything like "MB says" or "Dr Harley says" but instead use statements that let her know what I would like in our M. "I would love it if ... ".



Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 02/03/17 01:58 PM
For any of you that are still following ....

The Mrs and I had our counseling session this past Wednesday. There was some interesting dialogue.

First off the counselor did give me an opportunity to provide any information I wished and ask any questions. So I gave her background on my long history of trying to implement Dr Harley's concepts. She admitted she wasn't familiar with Dr Harley's principles but had heard of him. I'm thinking best selling author in your field and you haven't researched his work? She did say MrsAlias had discussed some of the MB concepts with her. So I gave her the highlights of MB and told her these were very important principles as far as I was concerned. I told her my goal was to create an environment of extraordinary care and to create a very happy, passionate marriage and that I see MB as the right plan to do that. People who are romantically in love do not get divorced.

The counselor appears to follow a concept about the highs and lows in marriage where people fall in and out of a connection. Uhm yeah it's called not meeting needs and committing LBs thereby emptying the bank. (I didn't say this to her, just thought it). She also recommended some part of Co-Dependent No More. I told her I read it already. Told her I believe in an integrated M and that was my focus.

We had no takeaways after our first session and while my W continues individual counseling her and I will have at least a couple more couples sessions with her.

I am not completely discouraged after meeting her. Didn't get any impression that she was going to ask me/us to do something that wouldn't be in line with the MB concepts. Time will tell.

She did state to my W that a professional assessment regarding the drinking might be a good idea. During our conversation about her drinking (W still has resentment about my ask and for talking with our kids about it) the counselor did ask what exactly is my concern about the drinking.

"I don't like what it does for her. It changes her. She makes bad decisions and many times struggles to control it. She did a better job this last year but still managed to drink outside the boundaries we agreed she would adhere to.

To top it off they only time I get my most important need met is when she's had enough to drink to get her in the mood. I'd rather those moments be with her without the effects of alcohol.

It's always been such a huge part of our lives but in the last few years it has lead to some very painful moments for me. Her drinking hurts me now that those events have happened and I am triggered every time she drinks. The simplest answer is for me is to have her avoid drinking so I don't have to stress about it.

Dr Harley recommends that couples focus on the things that they did together that made them fall in love. Sadly enough the one thing we did more than anything was to party/drink. I would love to find a new way for her and I to be in love. One that doesn't rely on drinking to have fun, relax and be intimate."
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 02/03/17 02:00 PM
Meanwhile the Mrs and I are getting along well, having more moments of physical affection, some hugging and a peck or two now and then.

So that's a bit of relief.

However not knowing what this Dr's plan is is a bit concerning. I'm not signing up for a bunch of sessions where all we do is navel gaze and dredge up the past.
Posted By: unwritten Re: anti-Celebration - 02/03/17 03:21 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She did state to my W that a professional assessment regarding the drinking might be a good idea. During our conversation about her drinking (W still has resentment about my ask and for talking with our kids about it) the counselor did ask what exactly is my concern about the drinking.

What if a professional were to tell your W after assessing her that she does not have a problem? Could she then continue to drink?

The problem with encouraging her to get a professional assessment, is that regardless of the outcome, if it bothers YOU she should STOP. Encouraging her to get a second opinion is IMO encouraging her to disregard your feelings.

Doesn't sound very marriage building to me.

As with many counselors, there is an attempt to figure out who is right or wrong here, vs negotiating a win win solution and being respectful to the other person's perspective.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: anti-Celebration - 02/03/17 03:41 PM
Originally Posted by unwritten
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She did state to my W that a professional assessment regarding the drinking might be a good idea. During our conversation about her drinking (W still has resentment about my ask and for talking with our kids about it) the counselor did ask what exactly is my concern about the drinking.

What if a professional were to tell your W after assessing her that she does not have a problem? Could she then continue to drink?

The problem with encouraging her to get a professional assessment, is that regardless of the outcome, if it bothers YOU she should STOP. Encouraging her to get a second opinion is IMO encouraging her to disregard your feelings.

Doesn't sound very marriage building to me.

As with many counselors, there is an attempt to figure out who is right or wrong here, vs negotiating a win win solution and being respectful to the other person's perspective.
I totally agree with unwritten. She explained it elegantly!!
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 02/03/17 06:08 PM
Thanks for the input.

I plan to continue a simple message.

"I am triggered every time she drinks. The best option for me is to have her avoid drinking."
Posted By: SugarCane Re: anti-Celebration - 02/03/17 07:26 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
while my W continues individual counseling her and I will have at least a couple more couples sessions with her.

I am not completely discouraged after meeting her. Didn't get any impression that she was going to ask me/us to do something that wouldn't be in line with the MB concepts. Time will tell.

She did state to my W that a professional assessment regarding the drinking might be a good idea. During our conversation about her drinking (W still has resentment about my ask and for talking with our kids about it) the counselor did ask what exactly is my concern about the drinking.

"I don't like what it does for her. It changes her. She makes bad decisions and many times struggles to control it. She did a better job this last year but still managed to drink outside the boundaries we agreed she would adhere to.

To top it off they only time I get my most important need met is when she's had enough to drink to get her in the mood. I'd rather those moments be with her without the effects of alcohol.

It's always been such a huge part of our lives but in the last few years it has lead to some very painful moments for me. Her drinking hurts me now that those events have happened and I am triggered every time she drinks."
You might not have been completely discouraged after meeting this counsellor, but there are many red flags here. It's obvious that she takes the standard IC and MC counsellor line that she is there to help her client achieve the best for her. She isn't going to try and persuade her to rebuild her marriage against her will - and and she isn't too impressed with you, by the way. She has an inkling that you are controlling and unreasonable. She already has a description of how much your wife drank - from your wife. She told the counsellor that she liked to drink with friends, and at weekends, and perhaps one on a few weekday evenings. She would have had a few over Christmas and New Year. She likes to get merry from time to time - but who doesn't? She never gets drunk, and she is in control of her drinking - evidenced by her being able to give it up all these weeks. There is probably nothing about the amount your wife drank that would be seen as problematic. Yes - she should be encouraged to cut back to the 14 units per week for women (that's the UK recommendation, anyway). But as long as she keeps it low, a few drinks across the course of the week is not "problem drinking". That is her line.

YOU are the problem in this scenario, and as unwritten has so eloquently told you, the counsellor will use this independent assessment to validate your wife's drinking and confirm to her that you are unreasonable.

When you were asked what is exactly is your concern about the drinking, that wasn't a question from a counsellor that knows that even small amounts of drinking can change someone into an unpleasant person, and it certainly did not come from the position of "if it bothers the spouse, it should be stopped".

When you were asked that question you should have been much more specific about the flirting, and whatever else has taken place (I can't remember it all now). Why did you keep it so vague, talking about "she makes bad decisions"? What the heck does that mean? It sounds as if you can't put your finger on anything, and you just want to control your wife.

You need to be very careful with this counsellor. It might be in your interest to go, since your wife refuses to stop seeing her, but she is not a friend of the marriage, and she is not your friend. She is already validating your wife's independent behaviour. For her to talk about Co-Dependent No More is a screaming red flag.

You were invited to go to these meetings just so that the counsellor can she how big a n insecure tyrant you are, and now she's seen it. Be warned.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 02/06/17 01:46 PM
Thanks for the response SugarCane.

I'll heed everyone's warnings.

I can only control what I can control. So while this counselor appears to be heading down a bad path it doesn't mean I need to agree to any of her suggestions. I will not agree to any type of agreement that says she should be able to once again try to control her drinking. I will continue to emphasize my need to build a happy, romantic R without the need for alcohol.

My W did tell the counselor there were some bad incidents regarding her drinking and that she didn't want to go back there. To me that's a good sign and a bad sign all in one. She agrees she didn't do well controlling her drinking and did some inappropriate things. However she still appears to want to have the freedom to drink some. She hasn't asked me if it's OK yet so I am going to move forward assuming she never will.

I've made it clear my desire is to rebuild this absent of any drinking.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 02/06/17 01:53 PM
Originally Posted by unwritten
Originally Posted by MrAlias
She did state to my W that a professional assessment regarding the drinking might be a good idea. During our conversation about her drinking (W still has resentment about my ask and for talking with our kids about it) the counselor did ask what exactly is my concern about the drinking.

What if a professional were to tell your W after assessing her that she does not have a problem? Could she then continue to drink?

The problem with encouraging her to get a professional assessment, is that regardless of the outcome, if it bothers YOU she should STOP. Encouraging her to get a second opinion is IMO encouraging her to disregard your feelings.

Doesn't sound very marriage building to me.

As with many counselors, there is an attempt to figure out who is right or wrong here, vs negotiating a win win solution and being respectful to the other person's perspective.

Sorry for the delay in responding unwritten. Thanks for the insight.

I did tell the counselor that I wasn't sure or not if my W has an addiction. That I'm not a professional and am not qualified to make that call. I then immediately said, it doesn't matter, to be quite honest, whether she is or not. I don't like what it does to her (we didn't get into specifics what it does to her yet). I'd rather not be around her when she's drinking. It is my goal to build a happy, romantic without a need for alcohol.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 03/02/17 02:37 PM
Update:

Not a lot to report here. We have been talking a lot more the last few weeks. My W and I continue to avoid alcohol. Still struggling to find a lot that we do together. In our defense I'm pretty immobile right now as my plantar fasciitis has flared up again (seeing a physical therapist again trying to eliminate it).

The counseling hasn't done a lot for us IMHO up to this point. We've mostly talked about our current behaviors and where those create issues in our feelings of being connected.

So I have a question. The counselor does not use Dr Harley's principles but rather has her own sources.

I questioned the counseling to MrsAlias, stating I wasn't sure where the counselor was taking us as there have been zero exercises she's having us commit to. So yesterday after her IC session she said the counselor suggested we participate in a workbook that is not an MB worksheet.

Can I discuss who this other professional is and their philosophies here? I feel a little lost thinking I may lose this place as a resource for helping to improve my marriage. Meeting with this counselor once every other week is a slow process that, so far, isn't making much a dent in our love banks. Well ... at least hardly a dent in my bank.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: anti-Celebration - 03/02/17 10:00 PM
yes, can you tell us who it is? We know about most popular counselors.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 03/03/17 01:14 PM
The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work John Gottman

It sounds similar in some respects to the concepts of Dr Harley. Although the phrasing is odd ...

��Enhance your love maps.� ... Sounds like a rephrase of the Love Bank.
��Nurture your fondness and admiration.� ... Meet each other needs ... fill the love bank
��Turn toward each other instead of away.� ... avoid independent behavior
��Let your partner influence you.� ... POJA (this one may be in conflict with Dr Harley's concepts unless it really does mean negotiate).
��Solve your solvable problems.� ... POJA
��Overcome gridlock.� ... POJA
��Create shared meaning.� POJA

Posted By: Prisca Re: anti-Celebration - 03/05/17 04:08 AM
Quote
��Nurture your fondness and admiration.� ... Meet each other needs ... fill the love bank
This doesn't sound like Dr. Harley's concept of meeting each other's emotional needs. The way I'm seeing it described is:

"To nurture your fondness and admiration, Gottman stresses that appreciation is essential. Write down 3 or more of your partner's positive characteristics along with an incident that illustrates the characteristic, then read the list to each other. For example, if your partner did something as simple as doing the dishes instead of you, thank him for that kindness."

That's not Dr. Harley's lovebank model. It might meet the emotional need of admiration. Maybe.

Quote
��Turn toward each other instead of away.� ... avoid independent behavior
This is described as "the little things that count." Turn towards each other by shopping for groceries, playing a board game, or calling each other during the day. And when stressful situations come along, you'll have more "positivity" in your "emotional bank accounts."

Shopping for groceries or calling each other during the day is not going to make your marriage withstand the stress of life. You need more than that -- which is why Dr. Harley has the POUA (which I'm not seeing anything like that in these principles).

Quote
��Solve your solvable problems.� ... POJA
��Overcome gridlock.� ... POJA
Big problems with this one. Gottman identifies two types of problems: solvable and perpetual.
The solvable being things such as: husband forgetting to take out the trash.

The perpetual being such as: The wife would like to spend less time with the husband and more time with her friends. This is perpetual because they have two different types of personalities, and it will never be solved in a way that makes them both happy. The solution he gives is: "Accept and Adapt."

This is NOT POJA. The "unsolvable, perpetual" problems ARE solvable using the POJA. "Accept and Adapt" will just set up resentment.
"Overcoming Gridlock" is just his strategy for dealing with these perpetual problems.

Quote
��Create shared meaning.� POJA
These are rituals such as a morning routine, family holidays, shared meals ... Not really POJA, other than you agree to do them.


Posted By: BrainHurts Re: anti-Celebration - 12/16/17 11:19 PM
Haven�t heard from you in a long while. I hope all is well.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: anti-Celebration - 12/29/19 12:10 PM
Hello MB friends,

I am back looking for some help. I apologize for not staying in contact but mostly apologize for failing to stick with MBs.

I find myself in another terrible spot. I've spent the last 2 years living with my wife as roommates. Much has changed and much stays the same. While my wife no longer consumes a lot of alcohol she does have a drink once a week or so. It doesn't feel like a problem anymore.

However what we were left with after the problem was a loveless marriage. We just existed and did the minimum. I have fallen so far away from the mb concepts I am quite ashamed. I should not have done that even though I would have been doing them alone.

For the last few months my wife has been up to something and as I figured she started smoking behind my back. Always finding reasons to have to go to town. A few days ago i confronted her without definitive proof but enough that she had to confess.

As part of that confession I also confessed I was seriously considering a divorce. I let her know I was hurt and felt betrayed. She says she knows how that feels . She feels betrayed that i,as suggested here, told our kids I was contemplating divorce...this was over 2 years ago.

Neither of us wants a divorce but I am quite certain she doesn't want to "officially " use mb concepts. However we both discussed what we need and are working at it again.

All that said albeit super condensed here is where I'm struggling.

She said she'd quit smoking although no timeline was given. I told her I don't want to be married to a smoker and although she states she was stupid to start I'm petty sure she doesn't want to quit. She definitely doesn't want to stop her diet Pepsi despite it being a reason she had to have teeth pulled. I've told her how that bothers me both from a P A perspective and a financial perspective. It cost us over 10k to have this dental work done.

It's only been a couple of days but she's been actively working on some of the things I have asked for and we're acting more like spouses. I'm still waiting for her requests but am actively been affectionate and providing admiration whenever I can. We're hugging and having a peck now and then. We stopped doing that a long time ago.

I don't want to divorce her. She is for the most part a very nice person. However she doesn't like being "told" what to do and views my refusal to stay married to a smoker as a form of control. She likes her dependence and doesn't buy into the mb interdependence concepts.

I feel trapped. I have my doubts that she'll quit and I worry she'll just keep hiding it. This is giving me many sleepless nights. Has for months now. If she does quit she may do her thing of being passive aggressive, upset at me, treating me like a roommate. Same thing happened with the drinking.

The only alternative is divorce and that is very upsetting to me.

I am not sure where to go from here.

I'd love it if we had a great interdependent mb marriage but we don't and probably never will.



Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 12/29/19 02:48 PM
Hi MrAlias, welcome back! Thanks for the update. By smoking, she is controlling you, not the other way around. Asking a spouse to stop doing something that annoys you is not "control;" but forcing you to accept it, IS. Asking you to suffer on her behalf. The bottom line is that if one spouse refuses to use the policy of joint agreement, marital success is impossible. She has told you hundred million ways that she will never use the POJA. You have been here for years with the same problem so you know it won't change. Welcome to your future. You can't force someone to change against her will. I realize that no one wants a divorce, but do you want to spend the rest of your life in an unhappy marriage where your spouse doesn't care about your feelings? I found these 2 Harley quotes that address your situation:

Originally Posted by Dr Harley
“Isn't it interesting how someone can miss the point that mutual care in marriage is the only kind of care that makes sense? When your husband tells you that he wants you to care for him by suffering so he can have what he wants, he doesn't understand that this expectation means that he doesn't care about you. And that's the point.”

Quote
When a spouse refuses to meet the other spouse's important emotional needs, whether it's affection, financial support, or any of the others, from my perspective they have violated the terms of their marital agreement. A marital relationship is not unconditional. There are many conditions that must be kept to keep spouses feeling love toward each other, and to be safe and healthy. When those conditions are violated, the spouses suffer. Affairs are the worst way to compensate for a spouse's failure to meet an emotional need. And trying to force a spouse to meet those needs is also very unethical. But separation, and even divorce, is a logical and ethical way for for spouse to communicate the fact that unmet emotional needs will not be tolerated.

I know that your care for your wife is unconditional. And that's part of your problem. As long as you provide care for her without care being given in return, you will continue to be disappointed. My recommendation for a separation would make it clear that you expect her to do her part in this marriage. She would have a choice. The alternative is to feel the way you do today, which is not good for either of you. I'll ask Kim if she can help mediate, but a separation might be a necessary first step.
here
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 12/29/19 04:38 PM
Hello Melody, Thank you for the feedback.

It's good to hear from you and to get a clear perspective.

I do realize my wife has her ways of control in our marriage. I definitely want and feel I deserve to be happy. Seems there was so much dysfunctional behavior we grew up with and continue to see these days that we both assume there will always be a certain level of it within our own marriage ... after all it's not as bad as our siblings. blah blah blah ... blech. I don't accept that. I know it not to be true and so wish it to be different with her and I.

I was of the mindset just a few weeks ago that once she admitted to the sneaking around I was going to file. The Holidays came and I had a bit of a change of heart. I don't feel today that I am in a position to say I can walk away knowing I was doing what was right for the marriage. I haven't been doing it. I gave up and probably should have split before I started to give up. I want to walk away knowing I was still doing whatever was possible to make this a great marriage.

I have been fighting the depression and anger for far too long.

She has definitely been active since I confronted her doing what I need to have a happy marriage including stating she will quit smoking. She just hasn't offered a timeframe (which I'd hoped would be immediately). I am in a bit of a wait and see mode to see how serious she is about us, about me. I, tentatively, am giving this a couple of months to turn itself around. However I won't wait that long for her to quit smoking. She isn't smoking a ton today so it shouldn't be as hard for her to quit this time. I will probably ask her what her plan is today.

I am scared for the future. I'm at a point in my life that retirement is just over the horizon and I was so looking forward to spending those years with her doing a lot of fun things. I hate to think about doing them alone.

Thanks again Melody. I will be trying to come here for support and advice as much as possible.

Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 12/29/19 04:52 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
I don't feel today that I am in a position to say I can walk away knowing I was doing what was right for the marriage. I haven't been doing it. I gave up and probably should have split before I started to give up. I want to walk away knowing I was still doing whatever was possible to make this a great marriage.

The issue isn't what you have or haven't done, [you have done everything] but that she refuses to follow the policy of joint agreement. I look at your register date of April 2003 and see that you have had the same problems in your marriage all this time, almost 17 years. Nothing has changed. The daily conflicts might change but the dynamics never do. The fact that you have been dealing with an unhappy marriage all this time tells me you aren't really looking for solutions. Would you agree with that assessment?

In the time you have been here, you could have been divorced and happily remarried like many, many other people here. But you have wasted years of your life on a situation you obviously can't change because it takes 2 people to make a marriage work. Your wife doesn't care about you.


Quote
I am scared for the future. I'm at a point in my life that retirement is just over the horizon and I was so looking forward to spending those years with her doing a lot of fun things. I hate to think about doing them alone.

I think it is unrealistic to think she will make you happy in the future when she has refused to do so for most of your marriage. Your retirement will be just as miserable as your marriage has been all these years. I think you will be alone in retirement if you stay married. But it doesn't have to be that way.
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 12/29/19 07:58 PM
Hi MrA. I'm sorry that you had to come back here.

How old are your kids now? Is your signature accurate?
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 12/30/19 03:04 PM
Quote
The fact that you have been dealing with an unhappy marriage all this time tells me you aren't really looking for solutions. Would you agree with that assessment?

Actually I think quite the opposite. My actions may not show that of course but best I can I have been trying to work the MB concepts into my marriage. I know IT IS the solution that will work for me. She just isn't on-board. I simply haven't gotten up the nerve or what have you to end the relationship which is, I guess, the next step this plan suggests. Each time I run into another conflict with her I continue to think that maybe this time we'll work through it and be better for it.

I love my wife but I despise the things she has put me through. I suspect in her eyes she loves me too. But it's that unconditional kind of love she grew up watching her parents.

Update: During a talk yesterday she broke down and admitted she doesn't understand what is wrong with her. She doesn't know why she continues to make these bad decisions. She admitted that she has been hiding the smoking for nearly 2 years. I am very upset at this. 2 years! I am so hurt by this. She replaced the drinking with smoking. She says she is terribly ashamed. And now she's walking around feeling down and depressed. This despite me telling her she can make things better. She just needs to stop doing the things that hurt me and us and start doing the things that make me and us happy. I told her I'd give her a little while to be upset but that I can't wait around very long for her to take action to be a happy partner, quit doing the hurtful things and meet my needs.

I am lost. I don't know if I am a glutton for punishment or truly know there are good qualities in her that are worth seeing this through. I am much, much closer now to calling it quits. I feel the trust is gone. What else has she done that I don't know about. She says there is nothing else. I told her I wish I could believe that.

I think I will insist we follow MB to the letter or I'm out. I deserve that much if I plan to stick it out.



Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 12/30/19 03:08 PM
Originally Posted by SugarCane
Hi MrA. I'm sorry that you had to come back here.

How old are your kids now? Is your signature accurate?

Hello SC, nice to see you are still around.

Yes, my signature has been updated. 2 of the kids are college students living out of town both within an hour of home. DS1 a senior in college, DD a freshman in college and DS2 a junior in HS.
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 12/30/19 04:00 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
[
I think I will insist we follow MB to the letter or I'm out. I deserve that much if I plan to stick it out.

If I were you, I would sign up for the course this time. Do it yourself has not worked in these past 17 years. Sign up for program #3: https://www.marriagebuilders.com/the-online-program-accountability.htm
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 12/30/19 04:53 PM
I can always ask. Doing phone counseling with Jennifer Chalmers didn't make a difference for us albeit it should have. We came out of those sessions with my wife saying there are too many parts of the program that she doesn't agree with. I told her it doesn't work half-a$$. We can't pick bits and pieces and still make the marriage great. FYI we struggle finding things to do together. I poo-poo'd many of her ideas as I knew I wasn't going to enjoy them.

I have spent the last 2 years not talking to and doing anything with my wife that a married couple would do. Roommates at best. Both very independent outside of finances. I had come to the conclusion I was just going to bid my time until all 3 kids were out of the house and then make a decision on what to do next. The last will be in college in 1.5 years.

In the last 4 days we have talked more about us, hung out together doing things like making dinner, watching a movie, working on a puzzle ,etc.

Given my desire to make it work I will need to get back on the horse. Initiate the conversations to see where we go from here. Question 1 being "Are you ready now to give our marriage a chance by following the simple guidelines provided by MB?". I think I'll start there.

We still have all 3 of Dr Harley's books and all of our notes from those sessions with Jennifer.

Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 12/30/19 07:43 PM
I had completely forgot you counseled with Jennifer Harley!
Posted By: MelodyLane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 12/30/19 07:45 PM
You might want to still consider getting into the coaching program. It is more hands on in that they assign you a coach and you would have weekly lessons. Dr Harley supervises your progress and you would have daily access to him over on the private forum. It might take a more micromanaged approach with you and your wife.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 12/31/19 12:56 PM
Thanks Melody. I will definitely take that into consideration.

I'm going to ramble on for a bit just to provide some context. I guess maybe I'm just looking for validation that I'm doing the right thing here.

My wife is really struggling. I am beside myself just as she is with herself as to why she makes these poor decisions. She suffers from mild OCD, anxiety, depression and appears to have some type of function that draws her into addictive behaviors. Drinking way too much soda, drinking too much alcohol and now for the 2nd time in her life cigarettes. The last time she quit she was still smoking when she was with our first child and a blessing of a kidney stone came along that put her in the hospital for 4 days on morphine. She hadn't had another cigarette in almost 20 years after that.

It would be my hope that, along with great marriage counseling, she could get some help understanding this dynamic and putting in tools to stop it. One would think a person could just say STOP IT (like the Harley's say) but I'm of the mindset that this is deeper and stronger than that.

The other dynamic to deal with is her need to blame me for "making" her stop doing these things instead of holding herself accountable. She admitted part of the reason she started smoking was a "screw him" type attitude. I, of course, said I'm not to blame and the only thing you did with your actions is hurt me, hurt you and definitely hurt us. I'm trying not to lecture her too much as she is plenty upset with herself and remorseful. However I did the right thing and still informed her how her behaviors hurt me.

"If you tell me what to do I'll dig my heels in and do the complete opposite".
"Why does it matter so much that I drink pop?"

I would love for a counselor to help her get rid of these weird dysfunctional thoughts she has to life.

I have told her repeatedly I am not telling her what to do. I am only telling her what bothers me and what I am willing to live with. "These aren't threats (she calls them that). It hurts me to have to deal with these on a daily basis and they simply make me very unhappy. Why would I want to stay with someone that is making me unhappy?"

"Honey I cannot live with your drinking". She still has a beer now and then. I gave up trying to push the issue of no alcohol as I was simply bidding my time until the kids were out of the house. I do miss the days when her and I would sit together, have good talks and have a drink, maybe two. I realize alcohol doesn't need to be involved. I do enjoy my little indulgences and feel they aren't an issue for me. For now her drinking doesn't bother me so I'm leaving that topic alone.

"Honey it bothers me that you continue to do the things that create issues. Your soda drinking has proven to be a bad thing as you had to have major dental work done. Having to spend so much money to fix the damage causes me great anxiety. Not to mention it impacts how I view you from a personal attractiveness perspective." She had to have 2 teeth pulled recently.

"Honey smoking is a disgusting, unhealthy habit and I don't care for the smell, the cost and what it does to your body. I cannot and will not be married to a smoker. It's a deal breaker for me."


Posted By: SugarCane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/02/20 03:28 PM
Have you spoken to your wife about the online coaching since this post, MrA? If not, what is stopping you? Are you worried about her reaction? I can understand that, if so.

I think that even if you cannot ask her right now, or if she drags her heels or refuses, you should write to Dr Harley at the radio show for some general advice. I think that, if you want this marriage to flourish, YOU need to find some major motivation to carry on and lead your wife out of her depression.

I've been thinking about markos and Prisca; they attended a weekend seminar in person, and then did the online follow-up. For a long time after that, when they were posting here, Prisca was obviously unhappy and markos was desperate. I could see from the online forum that Dr Harley encouraged him not to give up, and to work on the assumption that Prisca really did want to save her marriage, despite her baffling rejections of all that he tried to do. markos read and implemented every piece of advice Dr Harley gave him about their problems. He studied Prisca in order to really understand what made her happy and unhappy, and he adjusted his behaviour accordingly. He had to take anti-depressants in order to face up to this task, having tried for so long already.

Only when he eliminated the major love buster of violent outbursts, and when he finally learned how Prisca liked to spend UA time and how to meet her other ENs, did he begin to see results - and this was after years of failure. And the results, when they came, were spectacular.

When I used to read their separate posts about their marriage, I could not understand Prisca's unhappiness and I felt sorry for markos for having to deal with such a no-win, permanently unhappy wife; after all, he was here, trying, and she was only reluctantly here, and obviously not trying. But once she came out of that stage as a result of his efforts and she was then able to explain her side of things, the difference between the person that she had been presenting on the board, and the real person struggling in that marriage, were unbelievable.

I'm not saying that you do anything at all to make you wife unhappy - that's not the analogy I am drawing. I'm not suggesting that you have a hidden love buster that you haven't told us about that is the root of this problem. I'm not suggesting in any way that this is your fault.

The analogy I am drawing with markos is with your having to actually do marriage builders, instead of asking her to do it. The problem is (I think) that she believe that she has already done it, and she doesn't like it. She doesn't like micro-managing every interaction with you in order to avoid DJs and all the rest of it. She doesn't like filling in forms and keeping records about her marriage. She doesn't like being presented with a list of love busters she committed in the last week, and she doesn't want to give you a list, either. She wants the marriage to be more natural and spontaneous.

If I understand correctly, though, you are disheartened when she won't "do' something she's been told you wish she would do (like affection), and you resent her for not doing it. So, you've told her what you want her to do, and you wait for her to do it. But this doesn't seem natural to her, and she wants spontaneity, not spreadsheets, and thus you are at a standoff.

You don't want to get a divorce, and indeed, that seems like a high price to pay. I can fully understand your reluctance. And yet, as Melody says, you've been here for 17 years and you are unhappy. This cannot go on.

I think Dr Harley would advise you on steps you can take to turn around a marriage with a reluctant, withdrawn wife. I don't think ultimatums are the answer. I sympathise highly with your frustration over her smoking; if my husband took up again, I might well walk out! But I think the reason she took it up and won't stop is because she doesn't care about you enough; not today. However, get her to care for you and she will care about how you feel, and be motivated to give up - and also to seek treatment for her depression. You can tell her that you would like her to stop, but don't issue ultimatums.

In sum: not being Dr Harley, I suspect that you need to stop having expectations of her for now, and work the programme by yourself (if she doesn't agree to join you yet). Rigorously eliminate love busters, including showing quiet fury at her for her behaviour. This fury, and despair, shines through in your posts, and it won't help your marriage. Be devoted to UA time out of the house. Turn her feelings around, and once she is in love with you, she will be motivated to eliminate her own love busters.

This is what I suspect, but I think you need to hear from Dr Harley directly, and you don't need to get her agreement for that. Write him an email now, describing how things have changed since she gave up binge drinking but replaced it with secret smoking, and how estranged you have been for a long time.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/02/20 09:00 PM
SugarCane, Thank you for the post. You have hit on some very key points and I'd like to respond appropriately. I am at work right now and can't so I will try to respond later on tonight.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/03/20 01:53 PM
SC,

I haven't talked MB with my W at all. She isn't a fan of many parts of the program and actually dislikes this place based on events of the past.

The reason she started smoking was because she was upset with me. She felt betrayed that I, due to advice provided here, spoke to the kids about her, her drinking and how close I was to filing for divorce. She didn't see it as necessary and only as a betrayal, away to gang up on her. Her words. I know that not to be true, that she was merely upset because everyone was looking at her in a less than glamorous light. Don't mess with her children is her mantra. Doesn't change the fact that her and I don't see eye to eye on my decision to talk with them. She's also asked me now to not tell the kids about her smoking.

Now, despite the fact she doesn't agree with the program doesn't mean I can't follow it. She has benefited greatly by me participating here and getting coaching and advice from Dr Harley directly. She may not see it that way but if it's filling her bank hopefully it won't matter. The end game is what is important.

Up until the moment I spoke to the kids about divorce I had been working MB to the best of my abilities. She went cold and dark and spent most of her time away from me. I too then withdrew. I am so tired of being punished when asking her to not hurt me. I had had enough and simply gave up. I spent the last 2 years just making due the best I could without an intimate relationship with her. Sad to say she had already started smoking behind my back. Seems she wasted no time replacing one bad behavior with another.

Her one complaint has been that she doesn't like riding in the car with me and that was one lovebuster I was fixing when all of this went down. In the last 2 years I didn't do MB at all. I wasn't mean simply civil. We were roommates. When we talked a few days ago when I confronted her during the conversation she again mentioned the driving thing. I told her then that I didn't want a divorce. That I wanted to give this thing another shot. We hugged, she said she was sorry and I said the same. I promised I would eliminate the driving behaviors that cause her anxiety. She may have forgotten I had already done this 2 years ago. I asked her to provide me with a list of things she needs and things I need to stop. I am still waiting for the list. To your point SC I don't think she wants to work a program. She wants our relationship to be more organic. For now I will continue to work my side of the program. I agree writing Dr Harley again is a good idea. I haven't had a conversation with him since we discussed talking to my children about her drinking and divorce.

To provide a little more context her and I have had no issues in the last week being close to each other. We are hugging and kissing and saying I love you. We are trying to find things to do together and have had some success. I am filling the needs I believe she needs filled which are affection, admiration, conversation and domestic support ( DS was the ONLY thing I have been doing the last 2 years).

Taking inventory I believe my needs have shifted a bit. SF may no longer be #1. It's no fun getting older. Recreational Companionship is moving up the ladder as is affection and admiration. I have discussed RC with her but I probably need to provide some information on what I need from a SF, affection and admiration perspective.

I really, really, really want her to quit smoking. It's not only a bad habit but it's now a reminder of the betrayal. I told her the smoking was a deal breaker. I have to decide how long I am willing to wait for her to stop. She's cutting back first she says.

Posted By: happyheart Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/04/20 01:13 AM
Mr Alias,

Is it possible you are being gaslighted here?
She started smoking, because she felt let down because you were complaining about her drinking?
Really?

Is she willing to work on the marriage, or just giving you enough hope to keep you haning around?

I hope you will get some good advice from Dr. H
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/04/20 12:45 PM
HH, I'm quite certain it's not that.

She started smoking because she doesn't like feeling like she's being told what to do and also says she felt betrayed because I discussed our situation with the kids. Everyone then knew i was contemplating D if she didn't quit drinking. She felt it was wrong to stress them out.

If I had to summarize her it's that she doesn't want to follow a plan as it is something that is telling her what to do. She wants a good marriage, appreciates much of what I do but struggles meeting my most important needs for one reason or another.

One thing I forget to mention is she tends to withhold information so having a PORH would certainly help. I fear I've done enough in the past when she has that she now no longer feels safe revealing everything she's thinking.

Last night I did explain what I need to be happy. She said she knows.

I am struggling to keep my focus forward at times. To not dwell. It's hard as the hurt from her deceit is so fresh. Knowing it's been 2 years...ugh. However I feel I'm doing exactly what I need to give this one last shot.

I will write to Dr Harley today.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/07/20 02:10 PM
I haven't had time to write Dr Harley yet.

I have tragic news. Over the weekend my father was killed in a bicycling accident. He couldn't see too well and peddled through a stop sign where he was struck by a car.

My wife and I have been doing well taking care of each other. I need to let this dust settle before I move back to our relationship.
I'm so very sorry to hear about the loss of your father, especially in such a sudden and unexpected tragedy. My prayers are with you and your family during this time.

Do you still plan to write Dr. Harley with your concerns?
Posted By: SugarCane Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/07/20 08:04 PM
I'm so sorry to hear such devastating news. My prayers for your family.
Posted By: BrainHurts Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/07/20 09:13 PM
I'm so very sorry for your loss. My prayers are with you and your family. pray
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/21/20 02:05 PM
Thank you for all of the kind words. It has been a rough couple of weeks. Even though I didn't get to see my father often I thought he'd live forever and that once retired him and I would have some great father and son times together. No regrets but I feel bad I didn't make the effort to go visit him in AZ more.

My wife and I are acting in a loving way towards each other. We're both wanting to keep the marriage and make it be a good marriage. We've had some pretty serious talks and in those talks I explain how the MB concepts, I believe, are the way for me to have a great marriage. She continues to dispute many of the concepts and it appears isn't willing to put them into practice. I, on the other hand, have done it since the day I made the commitment to give this one last shot.

Meanwhile she is addicted to cigarettes once again. I don't have a lot of faith that she'll be able to kick it. It took a kidney stone while pregnant last time to quit.

I believe that is what I need to talk to Dr Harley about. The fact that I need my Bank filled and want her to eliminate LBs yet she states those concepts don't work for her. She continually asks me why her smoking and drinking diet soda impacts how I feel about her. That I should love her for the person she is, not for what she does to her own body.

What's worse is that our conversations always lead to "Yeah well I may do that but you do this." kind of talk. And I've repeatedly have told her please please please if there is something I need to do or stop to make me a better husband then tell me. I am willing to change anything.

I hope to write to Dr Harley in the next day or two.
Posted By: goody2shoes Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/21/20 08:25 PM
Originally Posted by MrAlias
We've had some pretty serious talks and in those talks I explain how the MB concepts,
For many women, lecturing is a LB. Don't try to educate her, sell her on the program. Paint a happy romantic relationship between tne two of you.
Quote
What's worse is that our conversations always lead to "Yeah well I may do that but you do this." kind of talk.
Great! She tells you what bothers her, so you can change that. (right?)
Quote
I hope to write to Dr Harley in the next day or two.
He will help you how to sell the programm to your wife. You have the advantage you are a man, you can win over your wife. The other way around it is more difficult.
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/21/20 09:39 PM
MrA I’m so sorry for your loss. I hope you and your DW can be a comfort to one another. Do you listen to the radio show? It’s helped my parenting a lot too and will help you make a lot of deposits where it will get easier to schedule fun light UA time together and that’s what has the best chance of motivating you DW to eliminate her LBs
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/21 02:14 PM
Moderators, please move this thread to the Divorced/Divorcing Forum Section. Thank you.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/22/21 02:37 PM
Hello MBers,

I am sorry to report that I have decided to divorce my wife of 31 years.

Despite my efforts to follow Dr Harley's plan, follow his direct advice, receive joint counseling from Dr. Chalmers, continually listen to MB Radio and post on this forum MrsAlias and I have drifted further and further apart. I, so withdrawn, can hardly look at her anymore. I have decided it is time to move on. The feelings of dislike are growing and I don't want to become so angry that her and I cannot be civil with each other down the road.

We've lived as roommates for several years now and enough time has passed that all of my kids are now 18 years or older. The youngest is in his last year of high school.

I've spent the last year avoiding my wife. Me, firmly planted at home due to COVID (I work from home now) she would still go in to work every day and then every day after work come home only to come up with some non-essential reason to leave the house again. She finds it necessary to give me some reason why she needs to go out when she and I both know it's because she wants to smoke.

I've done an inventory of where we are at and where I'd like to go. MrsAlias simply doesn't fit into my plans for the future. We are simply have very different ideas on what makes a good M and want very different things for our future. It may have been different if she did agree with the MB principles but seeing she didn't agree with quite a few of the basic principles we'll never know.

I thought it a good idea to post again seeing I have this new and terrible news. I could use some support through this process and, at least, in the near future. I am feeling a huge sense of loss now that I've made the decision to move on. I have regrets about breaking up our family and the turmoil it will create for all 3 kids as well as myself and even for MrsAlias. The kids are all still, somewhat, dependent on us. Her and I will have a lot to work out regarding their ongoing support. I am deeply saddened that so much of what I have worked so hard for these many years is now all going to be for not. I'll be living on my own in some little shack or whatever I can afford once everything is final.

Right now everything is so up in the air. MrsAlias has agreed to complete the D using a mediator. I've already spoken to a reputable family law attorney in our home town and as of right now believe she is the lawyer we will use to complete the process.

It's my hope that MrsAlias can find a way to stay in our home but that is a huge long shot. For selfish reasons I don't want to deal with all of the "stuff" we've accumulated over the years and the home is optimal for our 3 kids for at least the next few years. I see a huge dumpster in our future, although I'm sure she doesn't see it that way.

Thank you in advance for you assistance and support.


Posted By: BrainHurts Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/25/21 10:02 PM
Thanks for the update MrAlias, Sorry it is such a sad update.

What do your kids say about the divorce?
Posted By: NewEveryDay Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/26/21 04:05 AM
MrA I’m so sorry to hear this. I know you’ve tried so hard for so long. You’re in the right place.
Posted By: MrAlias Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/26/21 07:58 PM
Thanks for the replies BH and NED.

BH, the kids are all very supportive for both of us. I'm quite certain they knew this day was coming. It's been way too obvious that Mom and Dad have been living like roommates. They are great kids and I am extremely proud of them. Which makes this decision all that much harder. The whole image/concept of losing our family, such a great family, is definitely providing plenty of pain for myself. I go from depression to anger. Sitting alone every night in our basement until bedtime, trapped due to COVID and winter. I am definitely looking forward to something more pleasant than that once this is done. Not sure where I'll go once it's over.

So far we have been very civil to each other and tonight she said we could talk about proceeding. Hopefully via a mediator. Otherwise it's just throwing money into a fire. Nothing good will come of us having lawyers trying to help us through this.

So glad to see you two still here.

I see Melody has life situations that have taken her away. Such good people here. So grateful for all the help all these many years.
Posted By: happyheart Re: Well ... I'm back ... unfortunately. - 01/27/21 12:15 AM
You have fought and tried every avenue to restore your marriage. I am sure your kids will appreciate that some day!
© Marriage Builders® Forums